# INS Brahmaputra accident puts spotlight on Indian Navy's safety standards | In Our Defence, S02, Ep 32

An episode of [In Our Defence](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1617244439), 25 Jul 2024, 1 h 01 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/60801959/25_jul_24_iod_25_july_128.mp3

The Indian Navy’s INS Brahmaputra warship, docked at the Mumbai Dockyard for refitting, was overturned earlier this week under mysterious circumstances. What started with a fire on Sunday has led to significant damage and the disappearance of a sailor. With a Rear Admiral now probing the incident, what are the implications for the ship's future usability and the broader safety and maintenance of Indian naval vessels? Salvaging the Brahmaputra is a challenging and costly endeavour. But such incidents aren't entirely new to the Indian Navy. Host Dev Goswami and defence expert Shiv Aroor outline a history of significant accidents in the past two decades, especially between 2013 and 2014, when a series of mishaps led to the resignation of then-Navy Chief Admiral DK Joshi. What challenges does the Navy face in maintaining assets in congested dockyard environments like Mumbai? The duo also discuss other naval mishaps involving the INS Chakra and INS Arihant, highlighting the difficulties of maintaining and operating complex naval machinery, especially nuclear submarines. Tune in as we review the Navy's safety record and the warship's future! Please tune in and share your thoughts at pods@indiatoday.com or text us at 8588966996! Produced by Anna Priydarshini Sound mix by Nitin Rawat

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: This is India today podcasts.
[0:06] Speaker 2: Fires on ships are not uncommon at all. There's a
[0:09] Speaker 2: thing called the fire triangle on ships because ships contain
[0:12] Speaker 2: the three things you need most for a fire to breakout,
[0:15] Speaker 2: which is fuel, heat, and oxygen. I remember getting into
[0:19] Speaker 2: a lot of trouble at that time reporting on it
[0:21] Speaker 2: for the Indian Express, because I had accessed to know
[0:23] Speaker 2: some of the early reports about what had happened. Regarding
[0:27] Speaker 2: the possibility that there was nobody on the bridge of
[0:29] Speaker 2: the ship when the collision took place. We don't know
[0:31] Speaker 2: if that's true or not, but that was something a
[0:33] Speaker 2: source had told me at that time. And the ship
[0:35] Speaker 2: just sank right there again, miraculously everyone survived. But a
[0:39] Speaker 2: national asset, a warship colliding right off your coast with
[0:43] Speaker 2: your own merchant vessel and sinking right there, you know,
[0:47] Speaker 2: makes you look foolish.
[0:49] Speaker 3: It makes you look inept.
[0:51] Speaker 2: One would imagine that the purpose of spending a large
[0:53] Speaker 2: amount of money over one hundred core or more to
[0:56] Speaker 2: salvage a ship would be to use it again. Now,
[0:59] Speaker 2: in the brahmapo Us case, if it is salvagable, I hope,
[1:02] Speaker 2: and I hope it is, she can be put back
[1:04] Speaker 2: to work. Once she's salvaged, you know, will be to
[1:07] Speaker 2: completely repair her. It will happen at huge cost because
[1:10] Speaker 2: she's sunk and put her back to service like the beitwa.
[1:13] Speaker 4: Hello and welcome to Another Defense, a weekly podcast on
[1:17] Speaker 4: all things well defense, where i They've Goswami, your host,
[1:21] Speaker 4: along with senior journalist Svarur, break down the world of
[1:25] Speaker 4: conflicts that range from the subtle to the brute. We
[1:28] Speaker 4: bring you nuances and perspectives that will inform and at
[1:31] Speaker 4: times provoke.
[1:35] Speaker 5: This is In Our Defense.
[1:38] Speaker 4: Hello and welcome to the very second episode of In
[1:41] Speaker 4: Our Defense High Shift. I imagine it must be quite
[1:44] Speaker 4: the busy time for the Ministry of Defense the past
[1:47] Speaker 4: couple of weeks. We mentioned this in our previous episode.
[1:50] Speaker 4: In the previous episode actually that the army is having
[1:53] Speaker 4: quite the tough time in German Kashmira with a gang
[1:56] Speaker 4: of militants kind of running loose, and it's become sort
[1:59] Speaker 4: of the knob for the last three weeks that you
[2:00] Speaker 4: have some sighting or the other. Every couple of days
[2:03] Speaker 4: some gunfight breaks out and then they managed to slip
[2:05] Speaker 4: away things.
[2:06] Speaker 5: That we've covered in a previous podcast.
[2:08] Speaker 4: In a previous episode, sorry on Custmane and why it's
[2:11] Speaker 4: becoming so difficult really for the secrety forces to kind
[2:14] Speaker 4: of pin these new terrists downs. So again, refer to
[2:17] Speaker 4: that if you want to get an update on that.
[2:20] Speaker 4: We'll talk about the other service on this episode of
[2:22] Speaker 4: the Indian Navy, which faced a major accident earlier this
[2:26] Speaker 4: week on Monday, we record as usual on a Wednesday
[2:29] Speaker 4: with Iron, there was a fire on board and then
[2:33] Speaker 4: because of the firefighting operations, the ship kind of listed. Basically,
[2:37] Speaker 4: it kind of fell on its side. If you say that,
[2:41] Speaker 4: and we've seen images and even though the Navy will
[2:45] Speaker 4: not yet come out and say it, but if you
[2:47] Speaker 4: were to go by information posted by journalists let shive,
[2:52] Speaker 4: you can get a sense that there's no coming back
[2:54] Speaker 4: really for this ship, or even if it does, it's
[2:56] Speaker 4: going to be like an uphill task to kind of
[2:58] Speaker 4: bring the ship back and you know, kind of break
[2:59] Speaker 4: it back to war fighting abilities. One sailor, as we
[3:03] Speaker 4: record right now, remains missing. It's been two days now,
[3:06] Speaker 4: so I think we can assume that the chances of
[3:08] Speaker 4: his survival are fairly slim, though you never know what happens.
[3:12] Speaker 5: Regions will go on.
[3:13] Speaker 4: That's what I know sitting in the newsroom and DELI
[3:16] Speaker 4: covering this from far away, you obviously would know a
[3:20] Speaker 4: bit more. So on this episode for our listeners and viewers,
[3:22] Speaker 4: we will talk about in maybe we will talk about
[3:25] Speaker 4: not a string that's a very wrong adjective to use,
[3:28] Speaker 4: but we will talk about some recent accidents that have
[3:30] Speaker 4: happened in the last two decades and just generally the
[3:34] Speaker 4: safety of Indian Navy ships when they are not fighting
[3:38] Speaker 4: a war, when they're not in conflict.
[3:39] Speaker 5: When they're not in operations. But before we do that,
[3:42] Speaker 5: like I said, this is what we know for a
[3:44] Speaker 5: sitting away and our office. What do you know and
[3:48] Speaker 5: what can you tell us about the situation right now?
[3:50] Speaker 2: So you know they first of all, this was a
[3:54] Speaker 2: very bad thing to happen, very very tragic accident. And
[3:58] Speaker 2: right off the start I echo what you said. You know,
[4:01] Speaker 2: we hope for the best. As far as that missing
[4:03] Speaker 2: sailor is concerned. It's been two days. Hope is fading,
[4:06] Speaker 2: but uh, you know, let's hope for a miracle. He's
[4:10] Speaker 2: a young sailor who was in one of the compartments
[4:13] Speaker 2: when the ship listed so and he may have been
[4:16] Speaker 2: trying to escape when the ship collapsed, So hope, hoping
[4:20] Speaker 2: for the best as far as he's concerned.
[4:21] Speaker 3: Now the ship.
[4:25] Speaker 2: The Navy has been typically circumspect about information because that's
[4:29] Speaker 2: that's natural, because this is, after all, you know, war
[4:32] Speaker 2: fighting asset. So they've provided some you know, one statement
[4:36] Speaker 2: on the on the day that the accident took place,
[4:38] Speaker 2: where they said that a fire had had broken out
[4:41] Speaker 2: on the ship and that you know, the fire had
[4:43] Speaker 2: been brought under control. And then they updated that statement
[4:47] Speaker 2: a few hours later because the media had obviously got
[4:50] Speaker 2: around to what had actually happened. And uh, and you're
[4:52] Speaker 2: a you're a Bombay boy, Dave, So you know that
[4:55] Speaker 2: the Naval dockyard in Mumbai, uh is not exactly a
[5:00] Speaker 2: secret location, right, it's uh, you know, what's happening inside
[5:04] Speaker 2: is visible from from you know, high rise buildings all
[5:07] Speaker 2: around it. You know, that's been a kind of concern
[5:10] Speaker 2: for a very very long time. It's actually one of
[5:11] Speaker 2: the reasons also why the Navy wants to move most
[5:14] Speaker 2: of its assets to Karva.
[5:16] Speaker 3: And other places.
[5:17] Speaker 2: But the naval dockyard is you know, you can pretty
[5:20] Speaker 2: much see what's happening inside the Naval dockyard.
[5:22] Speaker 4: Uh.
[5:22] Speaker 2: And uh, And it became pretty much public knowledge that
[5:26] Speaker 2: this wasn't just a fire, there was much more to it,
[5:29] Speaker 2: and the Navy then updated statement and said that the
[5:34] Speaker 2: due to during the firefighting operations, the ship had began
[5:37] Speaker 2: to list. List is basically to lean to one side
[5:40] Speaker 2: its center of gravity ships. It leans to one side
[5:42] Speaker 2: and it completely collapsed, uh, you know, onto the onto
[5:46] Speaker 2: the the dock itself.
[5:49] Speaker 3: Uh.
[5:50] Speaker 2: And if you look at the pictures very closely, it's
[5:52] Speaker 2: it's uh, it's not a small thing, you know. The
[5:55] Speaker 2: the the military is often often often criticized for using
[5:59] Speaker 2: you femisms in its statements like the like the Navy
[6:02] Speaker 2: statement very very gently says, the ship is resting on
[6:06] Speaker 2: its side, you know, which makes it sound like a
[6:09] Speaker 2: you know, a princess on a bed or something. If
[6:12] Speaker 2: you look at the picture, it's anything but that, right.
[6:14] Speaker 2: The ship is half sunk. The the you know, the
[6:17] Speaker 2: the tower and the superstructure of the ship has smashed
[6:21] Speaker 2: into the dock, the concrete dock. There is extensive damage
[6:25] Speaker 2: if you look at it from the back, you know,
[6:27] Speaker 2: one propellers in the air. And this is like a
[6:32] Speaker 2: nearly a four thousand ton ship. So any kind of
[6:35] Speaker 2: collapse of this kind means you can bet that there's
[6:37] Speaker 2: a lot of internal damage in addition to the external damage.
[6:40] Speaker 2: So so this is what happened very quickly. What happened
[6:45] Speaker 2: was a fire broke out. The nature of that fire
[6:47] Speaker 2: is not known just yet, but fires on ships are
[6:52] Speaker 2: are not uncommon at all. You know that there's a
[6:54] Speaker 2: there's a thing called the fire triangle on ships because
[6:58] Speaker 2: ships contain the three things you know you need most
[7:02] Speaker 2: for a fire to breakout, which is which is basically fuel, heat,
[7:06] Speaker 2: and oxygen, and all of these things are in highly
[7:09] Speaker 2: confined spaces and ships I'm sure you've been on a
[7:12] Speaker 2: naval ship theyve and you've seen what they like. They're
[7:15] Speaker 2: basically full of tightly you know, wound corridors filled with
[7:20] Speaker 2: equipment and pipes and you know, hardware and things like that,
[7:24] Speaker 2: you know, leaving very very there are no large open
[7:27] Speaker 2: spaces on a ship apart from the deck a military ship,
[7:30] Speaker 2: I mean a warship like the Irons Bramaputra, And therefore,
[7:33] Speaker 2: when a fire breaks out in any area of the ship,
[7:36] Speaker 2: it becomes quite difficult to get to the location of
[7:40] Speaker 2: the of the fire. Of course, you know there are
[7:43] Speaker 2: fire suppressant equipment on all ships in various places. But
[7:48] Speaker 2: we don't know yet what the nature of the fire
[7:50] Speaker 2: is and where it was, so we can't speculate on that.
[7:53] Speaker 2: But obviously it to the fire that was big enough
[7:56] Speaker 2: to cause quite a great deal of damage. Now, the
[8:00] Speaker 2: few open source pictures and videos that are out there
[8:02] Speaker 2: show the ship a blaze at nighttime somewhere in the
[8:06] Speaker 2: you know, central part of the ship, on the upper
[8:08] Speaker 2: decks is where this fire broke out. Now, the standard
[8:11] Speaker 2: operating procedure when something like this happens, obviously, is a
[8:14] Speaker 2: firefighting protocol kicks in. You try and douse the fire
[8:18] Speaker 2: as quickly as possible. Now, this particular ship, the natural
[8:21] Speaker 2: question that most people ask is, you know, a ship
[8:24] Speaker 2: is usually full of fuel. It's a warship, so it
[8:26] Speaker 2: would have weapons and ammunition on board. Mercifully, this ship
[8:31] Speaker 2: was in refit, which means it was going to be
[8:33] Speaker 2: docked for an extended period of time, and therefore it
[8:37] Speaker 2: had a little bit of fuel but not too much,
[8:39] Speaker 2: you know, not enough to cause an inferno, and all
[8:42] Speaker 2: weapons and equipment had been removed.
[8:44] Speaker 3: For the refit.
[8:45] Speaker 2: That's a standard safety protocol when you're a dock for
[8:48] Speaker 2: an extended period, weapons are removed and so once the
[8:52] Speaker 2: firefighting actually started.
[8:54] Speaker 3: You know, most people think of a ship as, oh,
[8:57] Speaker 3: it's in the water.
[8:57] Speaker 2: So you know what can go wrong if you you
[9:00] Speaker 2: start fire fighting a fire on it?
[9:03] Speaker 3: The problem? The problem is a ship is actually a
[9:05] Speaker 3: pretty delicate thing. Uh.
[9:07] Speaker 2: It's it's it's very finally balanced in the water. You know,
[9:11] Speaker 2: there's a there's a center of buoyancy, there is a
[9:13] Speaker 2: center of gravity.
[9:14] Speaker 3: Uh.
[9:15] Speaker 2: And without going into the you know aquatic physics of
[9:19] Speaker 2: how a ship balances in water. Uh. The point is
[9:22] Speaker 2: when you're firefighting a large blaze on a ship and
[9:25] Speaker 2: it's basically in its dock, uh, you're filling you're filling
[9:29] Speaker 2: a part of that ship with a lot of water.
[9:31] Speaker 3: Uh.
[9:31] Speaker 2: And if that water isn't getting brained out or doesn't
[9:35] Speaker 2: have a way to get itself out, which is frequently
[9:38] Speaker 2: the case, because the whole point of a ship is
[9:40] Speaker 2: that you know, water can can't get out or in right.
[9:42] Speaker 3: It's it's it's enclosed. It's an enclosed shell.
[9:46] Speaker 5: Uh.
[9:46] Speaker 2: That water begins to build up in levels and even
[9:50] Speaker 2: the smallest uh imbalance in in that kind of buoyancy
[9:54] Speaker 2: will make the ship start to list.
[9:56] Speaker 5: Uh.
[9:57] Speaker 2: You know, in most people's mind, they'll probably think a
[9:59] Speaker 2: four thousand ton ship is probably like a sturdy beast.
[10:02] Speaker 3: It is, but this is water.
[10:05] Speaker 2: And most people you know also think, you know, water
[10:07] Speaker 2: can't do this. I mean, the ship, after all, is
[10:10] Speaker 2: in water. But this is water that's not outside, but
[10:12] Speaker 2: it's inside the ship. And water on the inside of
[10:15] Speaker 2: a ship acts in a vastly different manner from water
[10:18] Speaker 2: on the outside. Inside it is completely uh, you know,
[10:23] Speaker 2: altering buoyancy dynamics, the physics, the center of gravity of
[10:27] Speaker 2: a ship, and therefore it starts to list. And when
[10:29] Speaker 2: a huge, massive ship starts to list a little bit,
[10:32] Speaker 2: it's like a building leaning. If it leans a little
[10:35] Speaker 2: bit under its own weight, it's going to lean a
[10:37] Speaker 2: whole lot more and then finally collapse. And that's what
[10:39] Speaker 2: happened to. The ship started leaning a little bit. You know,
[10:42] Speaker 2: attempts were made, possibly to pump out the water, you know,
[10:45] Speaker 2: to make sure the ship didn't completely collapse, but it
[10:49] Speaker 2: wasn't possible. The blaze was too big water. The priority
[10:52] Speaker 2: was on putting out the fire, and you know, at
[10:56] Speaker 2: some point that that point of no return was reached
[10:59] Speaker 2: where the weather ship completely collapsed into the harbor and
[11:03] Speaker 2: most of it as you can see in those pictures
[11:05] Speaker 2: as well.
[11:06] Speaker 4: It's I'm glad you mentioned Mumbai and in your answer there,
[11:09] Speaker 4: because you're going to divet a special section about Mumbai
[11:12] Speaker 4: on this episode, especially to do with the fact the
[11:15] Speaker 4: dockyard there.
[11:15] Speaker 5: And the repairs that happened there.
[11:17] Speaker 4: But before we do that, and before we actually get
[11:20] Speaker 4: to the larger question of the Indian Navy's accidents in
[11:24] Speaker 4: the last twenty odd years, I want to actually focus
[11:27] Speaker 4: on a period of one single year, from twenty to
[11:30] Speaker 4: thirteen to twenty fourteen, there were ten accidents, beginning with
[11:34] Speaker 4: an explosion on ins in Rukshak, the submarine that killed
[11:37] Speaker 4: eighteen eighteen sailors.
[11:40] Speaker 5: There was a.
[11:40] Speaker 4: Small fire on board irons where Art. There was a
[11:42] Speaker 4: fire on board ironis Kunkin. There was a scraping incident
[11:45] Speaker 4: involving IROs Turkash. There was a collision of the fishing
[11:49] Speaker 4: board that did not have its lights on. There was
[11:51] Speaker 4: a crack on the sonar dom of Ius Betwa. There
[11:55] Speaker 4: was the irons Indhu Goosh, the lead class of the
[11:57] Speaker 4: submarine that s sunkhalir Is kind of you know, hitting
[12:00] Speaker 4: something on my livertool was trying to secure alongside a berth.
[12:04] Speaker 4: There was some water ingress into some part of a
[12:06] Speaker 4: ship called Linus W pull. There was a damage to
[12:09] Speaker 4: a port propeller of Arawat. And finally there was the
[12:14] Speaker 4: incident of a fire or in a compartment of irons
[12:16] Speaker 4: in Durata, also a submarine, also in the Ghost class.
[12:20] Speaker 3: This incident led to the.
[12:21] Speaker 5: Resignation of then Navy Chief Admiral d Kjoshi. One of
[12:25] Speaker 5: the rare instances.
[12:25] Speaker 4: If I'm not wrong of a service chief resigning, you
[12:29] Speaker 4: would think why, But if you see ten accidents in
[12:31] Speaker 4: you know, a span of seven eight months, moral responsibility
[12:34] Speaker 4: atter that that's why he resigned. We'll get into accidents,
[12:38] Speaker 4: we'll get into the possible reasons, and we'll get into
[12:40] Speaker 4: whether or not the situation is alarming in the first place.
[12:43] Speaker 4: But that one year, if like you must have been
[12:45] Speaker 4: a reporter back then, can you tell us what happened?
[12:48] Speaker 4: Because this is a long list of incidents to happen
[12:50] Speaker 4: within a span of seven eight months.
[12:51] Speaker 2: So I have a bit of a you know, a
[12:53] Speaker 2: bit of a complicated take on that period because I
[12:56] Speaker 2: was I was someone who was reporting on those incidents
[12:59] Speaker 2: as well. And uh, forgive me for being brutally honest,
[13:03] Speaker 2: but uh, many of the accidents that you've just read out,
[13:07] Speaker 2: uh they've those.
[13:09] Speaker 3: Are routine accidents.
[13:10] Speaker 2: Now, look, you know, when I started my first answer,
[13:13] Speaker 2: I told you about the fire triangle on a ship,
[13:15] Speaker 2: which is basically that you know, a warship at sea. Uh,
[13:19] Speaker 2: it's it's basically begging to catch fire. Okay, it's got
[13:24] Speaker 2: it's got inflammable paint, it's got fuel, it's got weapons,
[13:29] Speaker 2: it's got no shortage of oxygen, it's got hot chambers.
[13:33] Speaker 3: Uh, you know, and it's got and it's got fuel.
[13:36] Speaker 2: So a fire breaking on in a ship by itself
[13:40] Speaker 2: is not a big deal. It's a big deal if
[13:43] Speaker 2: that fire destroys the ship or if that if that
[13:45] Speaker 2: fire sinks the ship. Now, in many of the cases
[13:48] Speaker 2: that you've just listed, those were fires which we brought
[13:50] Speaker 2: under control. In some cases there was a tragic loss
[13:53] Speaker 2: of one or two lives, unacceptable, no doubt about it.
[13:55] Speaker 2: But the ship was saved. The ships in most in
[13:58] Speaker 2: most of those cases were saved. Now, at that particular time,
[14:01] Speaker 2: I think there were more forces at play than just
[14:04] Speaker 2: a focus on naval accidents.
[14:06] Speaker 3: I think there was some there.
[14:08] Speaker 2: Were some wheels within wheels, uh politically speaking, in terms
[14:13] Speaker 2: of what was happening with the naval leadership, I think there,
[14:16] Speaker 2: you know, there may have been some strings being pulled
[14:20] Speaker 2: against the Navy chief of that time. And boy am
[14:22] Speaker 2: I going to get it on social media for saying
[14:24] Speaker 2: this out loud, because this is something that most people
[14:26] Speaker 2: only say in whispers and they don't like saying it
[14:28] Speaker 2: out loud. But I think that I think there was
[14:30] Speaker 2: a bit of a campaign there. But having said that,
[14:34] Speaker 2: none of these incidents was small. They were all real incidents,
[14:39] Speaker 2: uh and uh. And you know, there were there were
[14:41] Speaker 2: many credible reporters, you know, Manupabi Rahul saying, many others
[14:45] Speaker 2: who reported diligently on many of these accidents, and uh
[14:49] Speaker 2: uh and uh and uh. They brought a spotlight on
[14:53] Speaker 2: what seemed to the country to be a kind of uh,
[14:56] Speaker 2: you know, a kind of culture of uh carelessness, of
[15:02] Speaker 2: a culture of uh you know, ineptitude or incompetence leading
[15:06] Speaker 2: to these accidents. And their reports were bang on because,
[15:09] Speaker 2: after all, these are war fighting assets.
[15:12] Speaker 3: It's peace time.
[15:13] Speaker 2: These are hugely expensive, taxpayer funded, you know, pieces of
[15:18] Speaker 2: military hardware. How is it that you know, every single week,
[15:22] Speaker 2: there's a fire here, there's a collision there, someone's falling
[15:24] Speaker 2: off a ship here.
[15:25] Speaker 3: I mean, what's going on? Isn't this like a trained service? Uh?
[15:28] Speaker 3: You know?
[15:29] Speaker 2: So, I think the Navy got caught in a kind
[15:31] Speaker 2: of whirl of of of of national and media attention
[15:35] Speaker 2: where every small thing was you know, was amplified in
[15:39] Speaker 2: a big way. It's very much like crime reporting in
[15:43] Speaker 2: our country. If we see a gang rape happening somewhere,
[15:46] Speaker 2: suddenly gang grapes will start getting reported from all over
[15:50] Speaker 2: the country and be given even bigger media focus. Then
[15:55] Speaker 2: they usually would take the example of this, this I
[15:58] Speaker 2: s Lady Puja Kaiker right now. Because of her, the
[16:03] Speaker 2: ups has become a spotlight. I mean, do we even
[16:05] Speaker 2: care about the ups on a daily news wheel? You
[16:08] Speaker 2: you know, you run a desk as well. Nobody really
[16:10] Speaker 2: cares that much about the upsc But now because of her,
[16:14] Speaker 2: it's become an emotive issue. So I think that became
[16:17] Speaker 2: part of it, and many of those accidents got amplified
[16:20] Speaker 2: in a bigger way than they normally would have. I'm
[16:22] Speaker 2: not saying they were wrongly amplified. They were absolutely rightly amplified.
[16:26] Speaker 2: But the point is there was really a problem with
[16:30] Speaker 2: the Navy. There was genuinely a problem with the navy,
[16:32] Speaker 2: and the Navy being the Navy, the buck stops with
[16:34] Speaker 2: the chief and he, you know, he resigned, and whatever
[16:37] Speaker 2: his reasons were, he you know, he took the moral
[16:39] Speaker 2: responsibility for what was being increasingly perceived as you know,
[16:44] Speaker 2: a navy not able to pull its flock together and
[16:48] Speaker 2: you know, get a fix on these accidents and these things.
[16:51] Speaker 1: Uh.
[16:51] Speaker 2: And that's that, That's what happened. Obviously, Admiral dk Joshi
[16:55] Speaker 2: landed on his feet, became the left governor of uh
[16:58] Speaker 2: and the ender Man and Nicobar Islands.
[16:59] Speaker 3: Which I think he still is.
[17:00] Speaker 2: Yes, so he's uh, you know, he's his tail is
[17:04] Speaker 2: not overs as they say. But the Sindur Rakshak accident
[17:08] Speaker 2: that happened, and I'll never forget that night because I
[17:11] Speaker 2: was in the office when that happened, and I remember
[17:13] Speaker 2: our Bombay Bureau calling us up and giving us the story. Uh,
[17:18] Speaker 2: that was a that was a catastrophic accident.
[17:23] Speaker 3: Uh.
[17:24] Speaker 2: It eighteen sailors died in that accident. It was it
[17:28] Speaker 2: was because of the explosion of torpedoes while they were
[17:31] Speaker 2: being loaded into the submarine for a mission. Uh and
[17:34] Speaker 2: uh uh nobody has seen the final uh you know,
[17:38] Speaker 2: bord of inquiry report into what happened. But what we
[17:41] Speaker 2: do know is that some standard operating procedures and safety
[17:44] Speaker 2: protocols were obviously overlooked, uh, you know, during that very
[17:48] Speaker 2: very careful and sensitive procedure. And we'll get into this
[17:50] Speaker 2: a little bit more because it actually has a lot
[17:53] Speaker 2: to do with what we're going to talk about in
[17:55] Speaker 2: the BRA, which is that you know, the same boring
[17:58] Speaker 2: protocols that your train and trained and trained to do.
[18:01] Speaker 3: In peacetime over and over again.
[18:03] Speaker 2: Sometimes crews and teams can start taking them for granted,
[18:07] Speaker 2: saying and you know sometimes and believe me, the Indian
[18:12] Speaker 2: Navy is one of the most professional, one of the
[18:15] Speaker 2: most you know, meticulous about detailed services I have ever seen,
[18:19] Speaker 2: believe me. And I'm not just saying this, but I
[18:22] Speaker 2: think there have been occasions when you know, standard operating procedures,
[18:28] Speaker 2: there have been slip ups in them, you know, plus
[18:30] Speaker 2: maybe a little bit of complacency because you're an experienced crew.
[18:34] Speaker 2: These things can happen. And like I, you know, like
[18:36] Speaker 2: I keep repeating, you're handling deadly equipment. You're handling, you know,
[18:42] Speaker 2: a torpedo. A torpedo is a bomb, right ye and
[18:46] Speaker 2: uh uh, And therefore the smallest errors can lead to
[18:49] Speaker 2: something like this. So the the the Sindu Rukshak accident
[18:54] Speaker 2: was materially different from the other accidents because in the
[18:58] Speaker 2: Sindro Dukshak there was ordnance explosion which led to its
[19:02] Speaker 2: sinking and finally it's decommissioning. Many of the others were,
[19:07] Speaker 2: you know, were acts of incompetency, you know, uh, breakdowns
[19:14] Speaker 2: in command, breakdowns in uh, you know, command and control,
[19:19] Speaker 2: navigational errors, the lack of you know, situational awareness, which
[19:24] Speaker 2: you are trained for when your ownership. You know, someone
[19:27] Speaker 2: dropping an anchor on a sonar dome, uh, you know,
[19:30] Speaker 2: colliding with a fishing boat. All those things are unacceptable.
[19:33] Speaker 2: I mean, there's no excuse for any of those things.
[19:35] Speaker 2: It's easy for us to say them. But yeah, that
[19:37] Speaker 2: particular year was a was truly a you know, a
[19:42] Speaker 2: year that the Navy wanted to move past.
[19:44] Speaker 3: Very very fast.
[19:45] Speaker 5: I can imagine.
[19:46] Speaker 4: I'm glad you began by by qualifying that fires and
[19:51] Speaker 4: you know, small collisions are kind of parf of the
[19:54] Speaker 4: course when it comes to the Indian Navy. Because when
[19:56] Speaker 4: you suggested that we discussed that any yes, exactly U
[20:00] Speaker 4: when you sayest that we discussed this on this episode,
[20:03] Speaker 4: I was a bit conflicted because of this very reason,
[20:05] Speaker 4: because I I've always thought that such minor accidents, you know, Hoda,
[20:09] Speaker 4: because it's not like driving a car on the road
[20:12] Speaker 4: where you have so much friction that you press on
[20:13] Speaker 4: the brakes and suddenly you'll stop right.
[20:15] Speaker 5: It's like you said, it's water.
[20:17] Speaker 4: It's not like you see a board in front of you, like,
[20:19] Speaker 4: oh breaks bar on your ship will come to standing
[20:21] Speaker 4: still within like two minutes.
[20:22] Speaker 5: That that does not happen.
[20:23] Speaker 4: The water will still, you know, kind of push you through,
[20:25] Speaker 4: and like you described fire on board and then fighting
[20:28] Speaker 4: the fire actually can imperil the ship because of the
[20:29] Speaker 4: water that using to kind of fight the fire on board.
[20:33] Speaker 4: But still, so I did the research, and you know,
[20:35] Speaker 4: this is motive what I came up with. And that's
[20:37] Speaker 4: when I want now you to give us that sort
[20:39] Speaker 4: of this overall overarching picture of you know, where and
[20:44] Speaker 4: why some of the accidents that shouldn't have happened are happening.
[20:48] Speaker 4: We've lost two ships we've almost lost one ship and
[20:51] Speaker 4: you've lost one submarine. You lost one ship in twenty
[20:55] Speaker 4: eleven Iron.
[20:56] Speaker 5: It's in the Cagarine.
[20:57] Speaker 4: It collided with the with the commercial commercial ship.
[21:01] Speaker 5: It kind of sang.
[21:02] Speaker 4: It was salvaged, but then it was the Navy thought
[21:05] Speaker 4: it best to decommission it a year before it was
[21:07] Speaker 4: anyway supposed to be decommissioned officially. Then you lost iranis
[21:11] Speaker 4: Indurakshak in that explosion that we just spoke about.
[21:14] Speaker 5: You has Irons.
[21:14] Speaker 4: Beta Ba that you know kind of almost listed. It
[21:17] Speaker 4: was also salvaged back in operations, but back then it
[21:20] Speaker 4: was assumed the huge at huge cost. The same ship,
[21:24] Speaker 4: by the way, was involved in an accident a couple
[21:26] Speaker 4: of years earlier before it actually had this accident which
[21:29] Speaker 4: we were talking about, which happened in Iron twenty sixteen. Yeah,
[21:33] Speaker 4: the listing happened to the sixteen twenty fourteen it kind
[21:36] Speaker 4: of scraped.
[21:36] Speaker 5: So something had.
[21:37] Speaker 4: Happened post the accidents I've listed above that those that
[21:41] Speaker 4: kind of fened in twenty fourteen. You've also had, according
[21:44] Speaker 4: to a report by the Control Auditor General, you have
[21:46] Speaker 4: had five accidents in the period of twenty fourteen and
[21:49] Speaker 4: fifteen and after that, what I could find was that
[21:52] Speaker 4: you've had a minor fire on board ironis Victumdke back
[21:55] Speaker 4: then it was the only aircraft carriacter of India in service.
[22:00] Speaker 5: You and very decently.
[22:01] Speaker 4: You've also had a fire on i S run Weir
[22:03] Speaker 4: where three people were three people died, like you described
[22:06] Speaker 4: where you said that some most of these major accidents
[22:10] Speaker 4: have involved operational failures feelings at at the human level. Essentially,
[22:14] Speaker 4: the report that I was talking about, the CAG report
[22:16] Speaker 4: by the auditor in twenty seventeen, it set seventeen one
[22:20] Speaker 4: percent seven one percent of the accidents of the Indian
[22:23] Speaker 4: Navy that it kind of surveyed in the last one
[22:25] Speaker 4: decade were because of human errors.
[22:28] Speaker 5: This is what I found.
[22:29] Speaker 4: I don't know how to make sense of this because
[22:32] Speaker 4: this is actually quite quite complicated, because you don't really
[22:35] Speaker 4: if you want, for our listeners and viewers, if you
[22:37] Speaker 4: go on to the internet research, you will actually not
[22:39] Speaker 4: find a coherent picture emerging like you normally would with
[22:42] Speaker 4: many things. You don't have one authoritative source tanding with this.
[22:45] Speaker 4: For this data, I had to look at different different
[22:47] Speaker 4: websites and different different sources.
[22:49] Speaker 5: So this is what I've found.
[22:51] Speaker 4: I don't know, I don't quite know what to make
[22:53] Speaker 4: how to make sense of this because again, like I said,
[22:55] Speaker 4: some of them could be like you said, natural power
[22:57] Speaker 4: of the core. Some of them are actually very very
[23:00] Speaker 4: you know that they should not have happened in the
[23:01] Speaker 4: first it's at all what do you make of all
[23:04] Speaker 4: of this?
[23:05] Speaker 2: So you know, the Vindhia gery, the Irons Vindia Gary
[23:08] Speaker 2: accident that you mentioned, they've you know, it was a
[23:11] Speaker 2: very crucial, crucial, uh mishap that took place, and that
[23:16] Speaker 2: was an accident that was pure human error.
[23:20] Speaker 4: Uh.
[23:21] Speaker 2: You have a warship, you have a merchant vessel. You know,
[23:24] Speaker 2: there are certain rules of navigation and rules of passage
[23:28] Speaker 2: as far as the ships are concerned.
[23:29] Speaker 3: Uh.
[23:30] Speaker 2: And the Vindya Gary simply went and rammed was rammed
[23:33] Speaker 2: by that ship. Now, Vindea Giri is a is a frigate.
[23:36] Speaker 2: It's a it's a it's a it's a it's a warship,
[23:38] Speaker 2: which is big, but it's nothing compared to a giant
[23:40] Speaker 2: merchant vessel or a container vessel or whatever it was
[23:43] Speaker 2: that collided with it.
[23:44] Speaker 3: So it was it was.
[23:47] Speaker 2: It was smashed and dragged like a little toy for
[23:50] Speaker 2: for and I remember reporting about that story at that time.
[23:54] Speaker 2: There were actually videos from the ship, you know, showing
[23:57] Speaker 2: the damage while it was happening, and those videos are
[23:59] Speaker 2: still there on YouTube. They're terrifying, rearly terrifying. The silver
[24:04] Speaker 2: lining is nobody died mercifully and miraculously. Everyone was rescued
[24:08] Speaker 2: by the merchant vessel itself, and this crippled ship was
[24:11] Speaker 2: dragged back to the harbor where it promptly sank because
[24:14] Speaker 2: it had a huge gash in its side, so it
[24:17] Speaker 2: just it just went and hit the sea bottom the
[24:19] Speaker 2: naval dockyard. Most people think that the naval dockyard is
[24:21] Speaker 2: very deep.
[24:22] Speaker 3: It's not that deep.
[24:23] Speaker 2: It's I think I think it's about ten meters deep.
[24:26] Speaker 3: That's it.
[24:27] Speaker 2: So, you know, a ship actually hitting the seabed is
[24:30] Speaker 2: not such a big deal. But either way, Vindiaghery went down.
[24:35] Speaker 2: A lot of song and dance was made about salvaging
[24:38] Speaker 2: her and you know, bringing it up and repairing it
[24:41] Speaker 2: and souping it up for operations.
[24:44] Speaker 3: Huge cost.
[24:44] Speaker 2: I can't even remember the number, but like many many
[24:48] Speaker 2: tens of crows, over one hundred and fifty crows was
[24:51] Speaker 2: spent on salvaging and repairing the Vindia Ghury, only to
[24:55] Speaker 2: arrive at the decision that no, she's got nothing left
[24:58] Speaker 2: in her, we're supposed to retire her anyway, which shouldn't
[25:02] Speaker 2: have been a factor.
[25:04] Speaker 3: The factor. The fact is, you.
[25:05] Speaker 2: Know, as as a country, you should be squeezing every
[25:08] Speaker 2: last drop out of your public assets, right But anyway,
[25:11] Speaker 2: she was too far gone to be to be retrieved
[25:14] Speaker 2: in any meaningful sense, So she was decommissioned and she
[25:17] Speaker 2: was used as a target ship and things like that.
[25:20] Speaker 2: But before the Windia Giri there was another accident, and
[25:23] Speaker 2: that was in two thousand and six. This was off
[25:26] Speaker 2: the course of Goa where the Irons Prahar, which was
[25:30] Speaker 2: a corvette. You know, and we're using these names which
[25:33] Speaker 2: which may be alien to some of our listeners and viewers,
[25:36] Speaker 2: but basically warships.
[25:40] Speaker 3: The simple thumb.
[25:41] Speaker 2: Rulers think of it in terms of size, not so
[25:43] Speaker 2: much in terms of capability because those capability is of
[25:45] Speaker 2: all blurred. So the corvettes are the are the smallest warships.
[25:49] Speaker 2: Then you've got the frigates, Then you've got the destroyers.
[25:53] Speaker 2: Then you've got cruisers, which.
[25:55] Speaker 3: We don't have.
[25:55] Speaker 2: The Americans and some of the other forces have them,
[25:58] Speaker 2: and then you've got larger, larger ships, and then you've
[26:02] Speaker 2: got your aircraft carriers. So the COVID are the smallest warships,
[26:05] Speaker 2: bigger than your fastest aircraft and offshore patrol vessels irons.
[26:09] Speaker 2: Prahar was off the coast of Goa and it just
[26:13] Speaker 2: went careening into a shipping corperation of India merchant vessel
[26:18] Speaker 2: off the coast of go I think it was called
[26:19] Speaker 2: the mly Rajiv Gandhi if I'm not mistaken. And I
[26:23] Speaker 2: remember getting into a lot of trouble at that time
[26:25] Speaker 2: reporting on it for the Indian Express because I had
[26:28] Speaker 2: accessed to, you know, some of the early reports about
[26:31] Speaker 2: what had happened, regarding the possibility that there was nobody
[26:34] Speaker 2: on the bridge of the ship when the collision took place.
[26:38] Speaker 2: We don't know if that's true or not, but that
[26:39] Speaker 2: was something a source that told me at that time.
[26:41] Speaker 2: And the ship just sank right there again. Miraculously everyone survived.
[26:46] Speaker 2: But a national asset, a warship colliding right off your
[26:50] Speaker 2: coast with your own merchant vessel and sinking right there,
[26:55] Speaker 2: you know, makes you look foolish, makes you look incompetent,
[27:00] Speaker 2: makes you look very far from the maritime military force
[27:04] Speaker 2: that you're supposed to be, and it just makes you
[27:06] Speaker 2: look it makes you look inept. You know, the word
[27:10] Speaker 2: inept is not used often enough, but it's a word
[27:12] Speaker 2: that the military shudders when it hears because they don't
[27:15] Speaker 2: want to ever be seen as inept. Inept means you
[27:18] Speaker 2: can't do what you're trained to do, you can't be
[27:20] Speaker 2: depended on to do what your task is, And the
[27:24] Speaker 2: Navy started to look inept. And and five years after
[27:29] Speaker 2: the Praher sinking, which which which caused a huge psychological
[27:33] Speaker 2: scar for the Navy, when the Windagiary accident happened, there
[27:36] Speaker 2: were alarm bells in the system. There were there were
[27:39] Speaker 2: genuine alarm bells in the system, which is that, you know,
[27:42] Speaker 2: what the hell.
[27:43] Speaker 3: Is going on?
[27:44] Speaker 2: Why are our guys taking their warships and ramming them
[27:46] Speaker 2: into merchant vessels and sinking them? You know, is there
[27:50] Speaker 2: a training issue? Is there a culture issue? God forbid,
[27:53] Speaker 2: it's a culture issue, then, you know, then we've got
[27:56] Speaker 2: to go back to the drawing board. But thankfully, in
[27:58] Speaker 2: both cases there were reasons why they happen. There were
[28:00] Speaker 2: navigational letrors, There was a lack of situational awareness. There
[28:03] Speaker 2: was a breakdown of command. And you know, the Navy,
[28:07] Speaker 2: the Navy, which has reminded me after my recent tweets
[28:10] Speaker 2: also I said, you know, heads always rolled. They said,
[28:13] Speaker 2: you know, in the Navy, nobody's ever spared, And that
[28:15] Speaker 2: is true. I have to give that to the navy.
[28:17] Speaker 2: Heads have always ruled. Commanding officers of these ships have
[28:20] Speaker 2: been court martialed.
[28:21] Speaker 3: They've been sacked.
[28:24] Speaker 2: Even ships where you know, sinking hasn't happened, like the
[28:27] Speaker 2: ironis Thrishoole or the irois Talvar. You've had commanding officers
[28:30] Speaker 2: who've been thrown out of the navy, bought, marshalled and
[28:33] Speaker 2: sent home. So the Navy doesn't spare anyone. But the
[28:37] Speaker 2: problem is, how do you stop this from happening? Why
[28:42] Speaker 2: is this thing, this kind of thing actually happening. You know,
[28:46] Speaker 2: fires and you know minor collisions are okay, but when
[28:50] Speaker 2: you think of think of the psychological damage that happens
[28:53] Speaker 2: to a force when it.
[28:54] Speaker 3: Loses a ship.
[28:56] Speaker 2: You know, a ship is like a a ship is
[28:59] Speaker 2: like a place of worship. It's it's the everything that
[29:04] Speaker 2: is real about the Indian Navy is all enshrined in
[29:08] Speaker 2: its warships. You know, more than just symbolically symbolically, physically metaphorically.
[29:14] Speaker 2: In reality, a ship loaded with bombs and weapons capable of,
[29:18] Speaker 2: you know, conveying your country's message that damn thing sinks
[29:23] Speaker 2: in your harbor is a terrible psychological scar and an embarrassment.
[29:27] Speaker 2: And it's happened way too often. Of course, it's happened
[29:30] Speaker 2: in other countries as well, but for it to happen
[29:33] Speaker 2: periodically in India suggests that there's an issue. Whether it
[29:36] Speaker 2: is standard operating procedure, whether it is complacency, whether it
[29:39] Speaker 2: is a breakdown of the chain of command, whether it
[29:42] Speaker 2: is a blurring of lines as far as responsibility is concerned.
[29:45] Speaker 3: You know, the.
[29:45] Speaker 2: Public doesn't care about all those reasons. The fact is
[29:49] Speaker 2: these ships are entrusted to the military that you know,
[29:53] Speaker 2: all care will be taken off them, and when something
[29:56] Speaker 2: like this happens, that public faith gets eroded. Now, remember
[30:01] Speaker 2: that the Navy is a highly professional force. They know
[30:04] Speaker 2: what they're doing. They're not a bunch of guys just
[30:06] Speaker 2: sailing ships not knowing what to do. And accidents, and
[30:09] Speaker 2: this bears constant repeating. They've accidents can and will happen
[30:14] Speaker 2: as someone said, an accident is basically, you know, the
[30:18] Speaker 2: three days of a week. The other five days you're fine.
[30:21] Speaker 2: Those three days account for some kind of accident happening.
[30:25] Speaker 2: You know, go prepared for that kind of thing happening.
[30:27] Speaker 2: So I'm not surprised at all that these things have happened,
[30:31] Speaker 2: but it's still it's alarming that it's still happening even now.
[30:36] Speaker 3: That's the problem.
[30:37] Speaker 2: In twenty twenty four, after that black phase of accidents,
[30:41] Speaker 2: especially after the Baitwa, the beatwall also shouldn't have listed
[30:44] Speaker 2: there was a fire there.
[30:46] Speaker 3: There was no fire in the Ironer's Baitwi. If I'm
[30:48] Speaker 3: not missing, it.
[30:49] Speaker 2: Slipped off to its looks yeah again, but again that
[30:53] Speaker 2: was an error. That was the three I think three
[30:55] Speaker 2: sailors even died in that mishappened. Then it collapsed on
[30:58] Speaker 2: its side. Thankfully, the baitwise in service. It was salvaged
[31:01] Speaker 2: again at great cost cost. But but the I don't
[31:05] Speaker 2: know if can be salvaged, right, I don't know, because
[31:09] Speaker 2: it's it's twenty five years old, it's it's not near
[31:11] Speaker 2: its end. It's got a few years left of service.
[31:15] Speaker 2: But again we are presented with the same dilemmas spending
[31:19] Speaker 2: you know, upwards of one hundred crow to pull her
[31:22] Speaker 2: up salvage her. She was already in Refit is that
[31:25] Speaker 2: going to happen?
[31:26] Speaker 3: We don't know.
[31:26] Speaker 4: Yeah, And you know, to extend your thought about heads
[31:29] Speaker 4: always rolling in the Indian Navy, and you briefly mentioned.
[31:32] Speaker 5: It, but i'll kind of talk more about it.
[31:34] Speaker 4: The commanding officer of ionis being acted against because the
[31:37] Speaker 4: ship hit a fishing fishing vehica fishing boat. What struck
[31:41] Speaker 4: me was when I read about it was that the
[31:43] Speaker 4: boat was unlit, the fishing boat its lights were off.
[31:45] Speaker 4: So when I was reading about about it, I was like,
[31:47] Speaker 4: this is unfair on the commanding office. I mean, I
[31:50] Speaker 4: don't know the exact deedals of what happened, but to
[31:52] Speaker 4: me it felt like, Okay, the probably the fishing boat
[31:54] Speaker 4: was at fault because it did not have lights on,
[31:56] Speaker 4: so that's probably why the huge ass military ship must
[32:00] Speaker 4: have missed it.
[32:01] Speaker 5: But then, like you said that, that's.
[32:02] Speaker 4: The culture and in the navy to kind of, you know,
[32:04] Speaker 4: make sure that you know someone's always held accountable. All Right,
[32:07] Speaker 4: we'll talk more about this topic, especially the location.
[32:11] Speaker 5: Of some of these uh these accidents. But after a
[32:13] Speaker 5: quick black.
[32:19] Speaker 1: Pany pany pany, so beautiful, so elegant, just looking.
[32:26] Speaker 6: Like a wow eh bang?
[32:30] Speaker 1: Was that enough crunch for you? Because this cringe fest
[32:33] Speaker 1: doesn't stop here.
[32:35] Speaker 6: Yes, And if by watching such reals and viral videos
[32:38] Speaker 6: you think your life is becoming moem, then I cost
[32:41] Speaker 6: them and me.
[32:42] Speaker 1: Anna will bring the most puke worthy, nauseating and repulsive
[32:47] Speaker 1: trends on social media and.
[32:49] Speaker 6: Well maybe enact some of them, but most of all
[32:53] Speaker 6: discuss and seriously dissect these trends.
[32:56] Speaker 1: So get ready to laugh, cringe and question you man.
[33:00] Speaker 6: Dropping soon on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and wherever you get
[33:04] Speaker 6: your cringe, I mean audio entertainment from.
[33:07] Speaker 1: So let's talk cringe.
[33:15] Speaker 5: Hello and welcome back.
[33:16] Speaker 4: Shive and I are discussing the recent accident mishappen on
[33:19] Speaker 4: nine as Brahmaputra in Mi in Mumbai at the dockyard.
[33:23] Speaker 5: It caught fire.
[33:25] Speaker 4: Firefighting operations led to it kind of tilting on its side,
[33:28] Speaker 4: and like she said just before the break, that salvaging
[33:30] Speaker 4: it is going to be quite difficult and would probably
[33:33] Speaker 4: happen at a great cost if even the Navy goes
[33:36] Speaker 4: and price salvage, which I think they'll try, but you
[33:38] Speaker 4: never know at what condition the ship will kind of
[33:40] Speaker 4: they will definitely try. Yeah, and we'll also talk we'll
[33:43] Speaker 4: talk about what salvaging is all about and what really
[33:45] Speaker 4: happens to ships when they suffer such accidents. But before that,
[33:48] Speaker 4: I want to focus a bit briefly on the location
[33:51] Speaker 4: of some of the accidents that we've talked about.
[33:53] Speaker 5: In the first of this episode. Mumbai. The list I've had.
[33:57] Speaker 4: I am not going to read everything out once again,
[33:59] Speaker 4: but just stand to reason, a lot number of accidents
[34:03] Speaker 4: have happened at the moon By dockyard or near or
[34:06] Speaker 4: off the coast of Mumbai. Very simple question. You know,
[34:10] Speaker 4: when I take my card to servicing. I mean, I'm
[34:11] Speaker 4: a fillicky guy, so I don't know if everyone does it,
[34:13] Speaker 4: but when I take my card to servicing, the one
[34:14] Speaker 4: thing I look for a service center is key. There
[34:16] Speaker 4: should be enough space because I know I'm not the
[34:18] Speaker 4: one who will be handling the vehicle. There will be
[34:21] Speaker 4: service center guys will be driving the vehicle around, so
[34:23] Speaker 4: I want to ensure it's not like jam packed with
[34:25] Speaker 4: vehicles so they don't end up making it nicking the
[34:27] Speaker 4: corner you're in there. Very crude analogy, if I may,
[34:30] Speaker 4: but I've been to the moon by dockyard. I was
[34:33] Speaker 4: on a Coast Guard ship over that. I've seen it
[34:35] Speaker 4: like I was on the ship. And I also also
[34:36] Speaker 4: seen the dockyard. It is quite cramped, like she've also
[34:41] Speaker 4: said before in the before the break, it's also quite
[34:43] Speaker 4: visible to everybody over there. Uh, a lot of number
[34:47] Speaker 4: of these accidents have happened in the dockyard because a
[34:50] Speaker 4: lot number of these ships have been in refit or
[34:52] Speaker 4: have were being repaired or kind of we're you know,
[34:55] Speaker 4: coming to some sort of you know, coming towards the
[34:57] Speaker 4: dockyard when when staccidents happened. And also, like said the
[35:00] Speaker 4: it's not very deep the movement of care, it's around
[35:02] Speaker 4: ten meters.
[35:04] Speaker 5: Don't you think it's just the wrong.
[35:05] Speaker 2: Place to have a dockyard then, so one hundred percent
[35:09] Speaker 2: the look, the fact that the Navy has such a
[35:13] Speaker 2: legacy presence in Mumbai is not difficult to understand because
[35:17] Speaker 2: the Navy, you know, a naval combat presence in Mumbai
[35:21] Speaker 2: dates back to you know, to the British era, right
[35:25] Speaker 2: because Mumbai is an actual harbor deep sea. The arabiency
[35:29] Speaker 2: is important, you know, trade routes, et cetera, et cetera.
[35:32] Speaker 2: So Mumbai being a important naval hub has always been understandable.
[35:38] Speaker 2: The problem is, Mumbai is not the Mumbai that it
[35:42] Speaker 2: once was, and it hasn't been for at least a
[35:44] Speaker 2: half century. Now it's not like nowaays seeing these problems
[35:49] Speaker 2: happen and we've decided that things need to change. The
[35:53] Speaker 2: the the very reason why the Karva Naval Base in
[35:58] Speaker 2: Kalamba came up in such it's the biggest naval base
[36:02] Speaker 2: in Asia. By the way, Karvar is just south of Goa.
[36:05] Speaker 2: It's in North Karnatica is uh is the place where
[36:10] Speaker 2: the Indian Navy has its largest largest base right now.
[36:14] Speaker 3: It has a ship lift facility. Uh.
[36:16] Speaker 2: The irons Vikrant is based there.
[36:18] Speaker 3: Uh and uh I think as well. So it's it's
[36:22] Speaker 3: a huge base.
[36:23] Speaker 2: And the one of the one of the specific reasons
[36:27] Speaker 2: why the Karvar base was being built in such a
[36:30] Speaker 2: big way across two phases was to decongest home by
[36:34] Speaker 2: was to uh, you know, if not entirely move the
[36:38] Speaker 2: navy out of uh uh Mumbai into Karvar, at least
[36:43] Speaker 2: to you know, decongested in a really big way. I
[36:46] Speaker 2: remember at one point of time they've where the thought
[36:49] Speaker 2: process with within the government and the Navy was to
[36:52] Speaker 2: actually shift the Western Naval Command Headquarters, lock Stock and
[36:56] Speaker 2: Barrel to Karvar because because the the the the rationale
[37:01] Speaker 2: and the idea was that you can't have so many
[37:04] Speaker 2: warships and you know, dangerous equipment and bombs and ammunition
[37:09] Speaker 2: and missiles and torpedoes, you know, in a city in Kollaba,
[37:13] Speaker 2: for God's sake, right there, you know, Bombay. So you know,
[37:16] Speaker 2: there had always been this this this impulse to get
[37:21] Speaker 2: everything out of Mumbai to a place like Carva. And
[37:23] Speaker 2: I've been to Carver. It's actually my father's native place.
[37:26] Speaker 2: And it's a huge, sprawling base. You know, you're saying,
[37:29] Speaker 2: you're talking about cramped, and you know when you go
[37:31] Speaker 2: to a car servicing center, you would love Carava. There's
[37:34] Speaker 2: no shortage of space. It's the Navy's playground. It's like
[37:37] Speaker 2: a completely beautiful, huge, expansive harbor with you know, with
[37:43] Speaker 2: no shortage of birthing facilities for ships, submarines, aircraft carriers,
[37:47] Speaker 2: what have you. It's paradise as far as the Navy's concerned. Now,
[37:51] Speaker 2: the question is do you still want to maintain a
[37:53] Speaker 2: presence in Mumbai. You know, a kind of token presence,
[37:57] Speaker 2: you know, helicopters, small ships, maybe a two because you
[38:01] Speaker 2: need them because Mumbai is a strategic location, or do
[38:04] Speaker 2: you want to you know, still continue to suffer the
[38:07] Speaker 2: you know, the cramped nature of the Mumbai Naval Dockyard.
[38:10] Speaker 3: It's it's ridiculous.
[38:11] Speaker 2: It is that I have seen satellite pictures of shipping
[38:15] Speaker 2: movements in the Javahal Hiruport Trust and the Naval dockyard.
[38:19] Speaker 3: It is crazy.
[38:20] Speaker 2: It's one of the most cramped shipping areas in the world,
[38:24] Speaker 2: and it is it is rapidly becoming unmanageable because of
[38:27] Speaker 2: the fishing aboat traffic in the area as well. It's
[38:30] Speaker 2: become it's become very very difficult. So which is why
[38:33] Speaker 2: Indian navigators and mariners and worship commanders some of the
[38:36] Speaker 2: best in the world, because this is a difficult place
[38:39] Speaker 2: to operate. But is that something we should just accept
[38:42] Speaker 2: nine Asia or should we you know, take advantage.
[38:45] Speaker 3: Of some of the other things that we have.
[38:46] Speaker 2: Karva is not very far from Mumbai, you know, relatively speaking,
[38:51] Speaker 2: So these cramped congestions in the naval dockyard in Mumbai
[38:56] Speaker 2: have been on for a very long time. But these
[38:59] Speaker 2: particular acts that are happening, not all of them are
[39:04] Speaker 2: specifically related to the congestion that's happening there. They're happening
[39:08] Speaker 2: despite those congestions. And it must be said in the
[39:12] Speaker 2: to the Navy's credit that they've they've taken this congestion
[39:16] Speaker 2: as a as a reality, that this is something we've
[39:19] Speaker 2: got to live with you until we get our new
[39:21] Speaker 2: home somewhere else. Yipea. So so I think I think
[39:27] Speaker 2: ultimately the accidents that we've been talking about as far
[39:31] Speaker 2: as Mumbai is concerned, the reason why they're happening there
[39:34] Speaker 2: is also because of the of the the sheer amount
[39:37] Speaker 2: of missions that are launched from Mumbai. We also have
[39:40] Speaker 2: to look at it like that, you know, the same
[39:42] Speaker 2: principle that we apply to the MAKE twenty one and
[39:44] Speaker 2: the number of crashes. It's because of the sure quantum
[39:48] Speaker 2: of ships based in Mumbai, quantum of ships going out,
[39:52] Speaker 2: quantum of ships coming back. The accident rate you know,
[39:56] Speaker 2: of ships from Mumbai seems to be higher, but it's
[39:59] Speaker 2: actually not like that. If you actually, I'm sure if
[40:01] Speaker 2: we go down into the actual numbers, you know, it
[40:04] Speaker 2: will tell a different story. But yeah, there is a
[40:06] Speaker 2: real problem with having to decongest Mumbai and give the
[40:10] Speaker 2: Navy more.
[40:11] Speaker 3: Space to work.
[40:12] Speaker 4: Right, let's uh, you know, go to sort of the
[40:15] Speaker 4: nerdy territory we we end up going to on some
[40:17] Speaker 4: some episodes. When I was reading about what all of this,
[40:21] Speaker 4: I came there is terms some.
[40:22] Speaker 5: Of which you also you know, mentioned on on this
[40:24] Speaker 5: on this episode.
[40:25] Speaker 4: Or there's there's repair, there's overhaul, there's refit, there's you know,
[40:30] Speaker 4: mirror of routine maintenance. Tell us in like you know
[40:33] Speaker 4: Indian navy terms or any navy terms. What are all
[40:35] Speaker 4: these terms all about? Because you know, you had ships
[40:38] Speaker 4: being in the dog for months on end, going undergoing,
[40:41] Speaker 4: like you know, an overhaul, and then suddenly it's like,
[40:43] Speaker 4: you know, supposed to be brand new. What exactly goes
[40:45] Speaker 4: on when these ships go back to harbor for these
[40:48] Speaker 4: months long maintenance or whatever whatever happens?
[40:51] Speaker 6: What?
[40:51] Speaker 5: What? What?
[40:52] Speaker 4: So?
[40:52] Speaker 2: You know, a warship is a is A is a
[40:56] Speaker 2: is a bit of a floating city. Okay, even a
[40:59] Speaker 2: ship like the Iron you know, has founded people on it. Okay,
[41:04] Speaker 2: four hundred people, three hundred sailors, one hundred officers if
[41:08] Speaker 2: I'm not mistaken, or the ratio is a little different,
[41:10] Speaker 2: but for hunted people on a ship means it's like
[41:13] Speaker 2: a not a small number now ship. A warship, even uh,
[41:17] Speaker 2: you know, even a warship like the which is not
[41:19] Speaker 2: particularly large, is hugely complicated, multiple decks, endless tunneling corridors,
[41:28] Speaker 2: super easy to get lost. I've gotten lost on all
[41:31] Speaker 2: the warships that I've been on. It takes you days
[41:34] Speaker 2: until you find your feet as to which deck is this,
[41:38] Speaker 2: which corridor is? Where am I being able to read signs?
[41:41] Speaker 2: And you know, find your way back to where you
[41:42] Speaker 2: want to be.
[41:43] Speaker 3: So these are hugely.
[41:45] Speaker 2: Complicated pieces of equipment, you know, built for war. Now,
[41:49] Speaker 2: warships are very sturdy. They're built for you know, unlike
[41:54] Speaker 2: fighter aircraft, which need maintenance frequently, ships are fairly sturdy because, uh,
[42:00] Speaker 2: because the the you know, the the domain in which
[42:03] Speaker 2: they operate is is hostile anyway. Salt water it's going
[42:07] Speaker 2: to make you rust. The salt water is gonna make
[42:09] Speaker 2: your paint peel, it's going to be it's going to
[42:12] Speaker 2: be hostile on your systems. The air is salty and
[42:15] Speaker 2: it's there's a lot of humidity, so moisture is going
[42:18] Speaker 2: to get into everything. So ships are built to resist
[42:20] Speaker 2: all that. Warships are especially built to resist all of
[42:24] Speaker 2: those things. But when they require maintenance, that maintenance is
[42:27] Speaker 2: not you know, tello arge maintenance. It's not like that
[42:32] Speaker 2: maintenance takes a bloody long time. Weeks sometimes, okay, because
[42:37] Speaker 2: the turnaround in an aircraft can be a few hours.
[42:40] Speaker 2: A fighter aircraft can be maintained in a few hours
[42:43] Speaker 2: and turned around.
[42:44] Speaker 3: For its next flight. A ship. And it's a good
[42:47] Speaker 3: thing that you you mentioned the different things.
[42:49] Speaker 2: There's repair, there is maintenance, there is overhaul, there is refit,
[42:54] Speaker 2: there is upgrade, all those things, and if you want
[42:59] Speaker 2: me to give you a very quick definition of each,
[43:00] Speaker 2: just to differentiate. Repair is self explanatory. That's you know,
[43:04] Speaker 2: if something is damaged or broken, then you repair it.
[43:06] Speaker 6: Uh.
[43:07] Speaker 2: This can be small repair or big repair. Maintenance is
[43:11] Speaker 2: exactly like a car servicing. You're checking your checking the
[43:14] Speaker 2: levels of different pieces of critical equipment just to make
[43:18] Speaker 2: sure that everything's working fine. Importantly, in maintenance, nothing may
[43:22] Speaker 2: actually be done to the ship.
[43:23] Speaker 5: It's just a check to.
[43:24] Speaker 2: See some good oil levels here, lubricant levels here, coolant
[43:28] Speaker 2: levels there, you know, whatever, what gas levels, hydraulics, all
[43:33] Speaker 2: that stuff just to make sure everything is shipshape, and
[43:35] Speaker 2: that's where the word hip shape actually comes from.
[43:37] Speaker 3: Third is overhaul.
[43:40] Speaker 2: Now, overhaul is a slightly deeper level of maintenance. It
[43:45] Speaker 2: is it doesn't only involve maintaining all available equipment, but
[43:51] Speaker 2: also changing certain systems where required, possibly adding some new
[43:56] Speaker 2: systems where required. I'm not talking about advanced systems, but
[44:00] Speaker 2: small small pieces of equipment being added and giving the
[44:05] Speaker 2: critical systems on the ship, mechanical systems in the ship
[44:09] Speaker 2: a longer sort of life. Then you've wet refit. Now,
[44:13] Speaker 2: a refit is basically almost like an upgrade. You are
[44:18] Speaker 2: taking all the most crucial pieces of equipment on the
[44:22] Speaker 2: ship and you're either replacing them or you're completely refurbishing
[44:25] Speaker 2: them and giving them.
[44:29] Speaker 3: Much more longevity.
[44:31] Speaker 2: The reason for a refit is to extend the life
[44:34] Speaker 2: of a ship and keep it in that kind of
[44:37] Speaker 2: shape for a longer period, because obviously there's a lot
[44:39] Speaker 2: of wear and tear that happens on a ship. So
[44:41] Speaker 2: a refit is a much more advanced kind of exercise,
[44:44] Speaker 2: which takes weeks, if not months, Sometimes it can take
[44:47] Speaker 2: a year. Also, if you're talking about something like an
[44:50] Speaker 2: aircraft carrier, and then there are even something beyond the refit.
[44:53] Speaker 2: There's a life extension, upgrade, an upgrade or a life
[44:57] Speaker 2: extension which can involve changing the engines. Uh, you know,
[45:03] Speaker 2: refurbishing parts of the hull. Uh you know, new radars,
[45:07] Speaker 2: new combat systems, software upgrades, additional weapons systems, that kind
[45:12] Speaker 2: of thing. All those things can happen as part of
[45:14] Speaker 2: a an upgrade of a ship. It can happen in
[45:16] Speaker 2: a refit as well.
[45:17] Speaker 3: Some of these things have a.
[45:18] Speaker 2: Bit of an overlap, but that's basically how they happen. So, yeah,
[45:22] Speaker 2: maintaining a ship is is one complicated, multi dimensional, multi
[45:28] Speaker 2: team effort that takes a very very long time.
[45:31] Speaker 5: Thanks for that answer. I mean that's quite quite the
[45:34] Speaker 5: interesting answer. Nay, especially for people who are interested in
[45:37] Speaker 5: and stuff like this.
[45:39] Speaker 4: So talking about salvage operations, talking about and let's talk.
[45:43] Speaker 5: About the ship that we have at hand.
[45:46] Speaker 4: Like you said, the name will most definitely want to
[45:48] Speaker 4: salvage it and then you'll see what to do with
[45:51] Speaker 4: the ship.
[45:52] Speaker 5: What does a saluage operation look like?
[45:55] Speaker 4: Like you mentioned during the course of this episode, it's
[45:57] Speaker 4: happened a couple of times in the past with and
[45:58] Speaker 4: has been Degaty and with Ana bed Pa. I think
[46:01] Speaker 4: on both those occasions, I don't remember about Vinegarty, but
[46:04] Speaker 4: for Irons, I'm pretty sure a US firm was contracted
[46:08] Speaker 4: for that because and remember I think I saw tweet
[46:11] Speaker 4: of fears from back then, if I'm not wrong, or
[46:12] Speaker 4: maybe in the thread that you posted right now that
[46:15] Speaker 4: you know you need specialized, specialized expertise for this. It's
[46:19] Speaker 4: not really available across the globe. It's only a few
[46:22] Speaker 4: firms here and there that have this sort of expertise.
[46:25] Speaker 4: So what does the salvage operation look like?
[46:27] Speaker 5: Number one? And number two?
[46:29] Speaker 4: Let's say the kind of uplifted it's back on a
[46:32] Speaker 4: A and the Navy real ki. Maybe the hull is
[46:34] Speaker 4: so badly damaged we can't keep.
[46:36] Speaker 5: This afloat forever.
[46:38] Speaker 4: But then the next thing would be that you know,
[46:40] Speaker 4: they would kind of, you know, see what parts are
[46:42] Speaker 4: kind of you know, not damaged, and then take them
[46:44] Speaker 4: out and keep them in space and then perhaps a
[46:47] Speaker 4: different ship, and then use the rest of the whole
[46:48] Speaker 4: for something else, like for example, with Negary was.
[46:50] Speaker 5: Used for target practice.
[46:52] Speaker 4: Similarly, I think Sindhu Goes for a brief file was
[46:55] Speaker 4: used for Marco's training off the coast of Mumbai before
[46:58] Speaker 4: it was purposely sunk.
[46:59] Speaker 5: Sunk can you know, lead to rest? So what happens
[47:02] Speaker 5: to the ship after it is salvaged if it is
[47:04] Speaker 5: not proven to be seaworth?
[47:06] Speaker 2: So, salvage is very very difficult, very expensive and a
[47:09] Speaker 2: very very complicated process. And it's also very expensive because
[47:14] Speaker 2: only a few countries and a few companies have the
[47:17] Speaker 2: expertise to do it now. Very simply put, a salvage
[47:22] Speaker 2: is basically taking a sunk ship and putting it back
[47:26] Speaker 2: on its feet in the water. If the in the
[47:30] Speaker 2: example of the Brahma, which is half sunk right now,
[47:33] Speaker 2: a salvage operation would basically end with the ship floating
[47:37] Speaker 2: on its own in the dock. Once that happens, the
[47:40] Speaker 2: salvage is basically done. Now, a salvage operation isn't just
[47:44] Speaker 2: pulling the ship out. That sounds very simple, but remember
[47:46] Speaker 2: this is a four thousand and done hunk of metal.
[47:50] Speaker 2: You know that that's that's sitting very very heavily on
[47:53] Speaker 2: the seabed right now. So it's there are all manner
[47:57] Speaker 2: of equipment that come into play to do this, and
[48:00] Speaker 2: it's a very complicated. Remember that each there isn't one
[48:04] Speaker 2: solution as far as salvage is concerned, you will have
[48:07] Speaker 2: salvage engineers who will spend weeks inspecting the ship. There
[48:12] Speaker 2: will be salvage divers who will be down in the
[48:16] Speaker 2: water photographing and filming every aspect of how the ship
[48:20] Speaker 2: is sitting in on the seabed. Uh, and then they
[48:22] Speaker 2: will come up with a salvage mechanism which will which
[48:27] Speaker 2: is basically a very very specific document that we'll talk
[48:30] Speaker 2: about which parts will be lifted by a crane, you know,
[48:33] Speaker 2: where there will be you know, ballast machines to provide
[48:36] Speaker 2: some lift from under underwater, whether there will be some
[48:40] Speaker 2: tugboats that will be involved, so all kinds of mechanical uh,
[48:44] Speaker 2: you know stuff.
[48:45] Speaker 6: Uh.
[48:45] Speaker 3: You know, the magic comes into play to lift that
[48:49] Speaker 3: ship out.
[48:49] Speaker 2: And it's it's extremely uh it's a very very specialized
[48:53] Speaker 2: engineering field because you're dealing with an enormous amount of
[48:58] Speaker 2: weight uh that's sitting in a not a lot of water.
[49:01] Speaker 2: So so salvage companies typically take a lot of time
[49:04] Speaker 2: and they charge top dollar for this because they know
[49:08] Speaker 2: that there are very few companies that do this, but
[49:10] Speaker 2: also because let's be fair, it's an extremely specialized and
[49:13] Speaker 2: difficult proposition to salvage a ship, and there have been
[49:16] Speaker 2: Believe me, there have been many, you know, salvage attempts
[49:20] Speaker 2: of ships that have been abandoned because the salvage companies said,
[49:23] Speaker 2: it's it's not possible.
[49:25] Speaker 3: There's there's just it's it's too heavy.
[49:28] Speaker 4: Uh.
[49:29] Speaker 2: The cost of doing doing this is not going to
[49:32] Speaker 2: be economical for the customer, and they will present them
[49:36] Speaker 2: with that scenario. So there have been occasions when ships
[49:38] Speaker 2: have been left in the seabed without being salvaged because
[49:40] Speaker 2: it's just makes no sense to salvage it.
[49:43] Speaker 4: Uh.
[49:43] Speaker 2: In the case of the islands Roma Potra, I think
[49:45] Speaker 2: it looks pretty salvageable.
[49:47] Speaker 5: Uh.
[49:49] Speaker 2: The Betwa was completely on its side and it was salvaged. Vindaguri,
[49:52] Speaker 2: which had sunk, was also salvaged. That's a different story
[49:55] Speaker 2: because it was so badly damaged. It was finally decommissioned.
[49:58] Speaker 2: But Bramaputra, my sense is that it will be salvaged.
[50:03] Speaker 2: The navy chief also visited and had a look for himself,
[50:07] Speaker 2: and I'm sure that talks already on right now into
[50:10] Speaker 2: figuring out what to do. The reason the reason why
[50:13] Speaker 2: things have to move fast they've also is because it's
[50:15] Speaker 2: sitting in the water. The water is ruining the ship
[50:19] Speaker 2: with each passing day. With each passing day, ingress of
[50:23] Speaker 2: water is going to make your equipment, make your electronics,
[50:28] Speaker 2: make other parts of the ship less and less and
[50:30] Speaker 2: less repairable, and to bring it back into ship shape.
[50:33] Speaker 2: So whatever needs to happen, it needs to happen at
[50:35] Speaker 2: a reasonably swift pace. Once it is pulled up, then
[50:40] Speaker 2: a variety of scenarios present themselves. Like you know, in
[50:43] Speaker 2: the case of the Vendagari, one would imagine that the
[50:46] Speaker 2: purpose of spending a large amount of money over one
[50:49] Speaker 2: hundred core or more to salvage a ship would be
[50:51] Speaker 2: to use it again. Now in the Brahmaputra's case, if
[50:57] Speaker 2: it is salvageable, and I hope and I hope it is,
[51:00] Speaker 2: you know, she can be put back to work. Once
[51:02] Speaker 2: she's salvaged, uh, you know, will be to completely repair her.
[51:06] Speaker 2: It will happen at huge cost because she's sunk, and
[51:09] Speaker 2: put her back to service. Like the bit one irons
[51:11] Speaker 2: Bita was an excellent example of something that had partially sunk,
[51:14] Speaker 2: was on its side, gravely damaged, repaired at enormous cost,
[51:17] Speaker 2: but now is in active service.
[51:19] Speaker 3: And has been, has been. It's the same class.
[51:22] Speaker 2: So so so there is a there is a live
[51:24] Speaker 2: example of just a few years ago of a ship
[51:26] Speaker 2: that was similarly damaged and is now in you know,
[51:29] Speaker 2: in reasonably good condition and in active service. Uh, but
[51:33] Speaker 2: we don't know about what the damage is to the Irons. So,
[51:37] Speaker 2: like you rightly said, either the best case scenario is
[51:40] Speaker 2: that she's salvaged and uh, you know, she will be repaired.
[51:44] Speaker 2: Remember she was in refit, yes, which means that she
[51:47] Speaker 2: was already undergoing a kind of upgrade and a you know,
[51:51] Speaker 2: extensive deep maintenance exercise already, so all of those costs
[51:56] Speaker 2: will have to be you know accounted for.
[51:58] Speaker 4: Uh.
[51:59] Speaker 2: And the best case scenario is that a repaired, refurbished
[52:02] Speaker 2: IRIS goes back to service.
[52:05] Speaker 3: Could take take a few years. I'm not gonna lie.
[52:08] Speaker 1: Uh.
[52:08] Speaker 2: The second second best scenario is that she's salvaged, but
[52:12] Speaker 2: you know, will she will have very limited operations because
[52:16] Speaker 2: the Navy might not want to use her as a
[52:18] Speaker 2: frontline surface combatant or ship to go on long missions,
[52:22] Speaker 2: but can have a much more limited near shore kind
[52:26] Speaker 2: of mission. The third option would be that what you mentioned,
[52:30] Speaker 2: which is that she's not gonna sail out of the
[52:32] Speaker 2: harbor again. Ever, let's cut her up and use what
[52:35] Speaker 2: we can. And like you said, you've got the bait.
[52:37] Speaker 2: Why you've got other ships that can use equipment on her.
[52:40] Speaker 2: So she sadly will have to be cut up or
[52:42] Speaker 2: scrapped and you know, cannibalized for parts that can be used.
[52:45] Speaker 2: And believe me, a warship is a gold mine of
[52:47] Speaker 2: usable parts. Even old warships are very very rich in
[52:52] Speaker 2: uh you know, in in plates, in equipment, in all
[52:55] Speaker 2: all manner of parts that are lucrative for the Navy
[52:58] Speaker 2: and that can be used or they it will just
[53:00] Speaker 2: be scrapped. The The other other possible use of a
[53:05] Speaker 2: ship like this is to use it as a target,
[53:07] Speaker 2: like the Vindha Giri Vinda Ghur was used as a
[53:10] Speaker 2: you know, as a target for missile practice.
[53:14] Speaker 3: Uh the Intra. I hope that doesn't happen.
[53:16] Speaker 2: But when it when it finally on its last legs,
[53:19] Speaker 2: that's a great way to use a ship and you know,
[53:21] Speaker 2: send it down to Davy Jones locker the seabed, uh
[53:24] Speaker 2: you know, in a in a in a graceful way.
[53:26] Speaker 2: So that could also happen, but these are early days
[53:29] Speaker 2: yet believe me, it's a long haul. It's going to
[53:32] Speaker 2: take months, maybe you know, a year, maybe even two
[53:36] Speaker 2: years before we have clarity into what's going to happen
[53:40] Speaker 2: with the ship. Let's first focus on, you know, what
[53:42] Speaker 2: the Navy is going to do about the ship, because
[53:45] Speaker 2: remember it has sunk in its birth, which means the
[53:48] Speaker 2: ship is is now permanently occupying a berth, you know,
[53:52] Speaker 2: and causing amplifying the congestion that already exists in the
[53:55] Speaker 2: naval dockyard. So that problem is also there. They've so
[53:58] Speaker 2: so the Navy now has to move fast to pull
[54:01] Speaker 2: her up.
[54:02] Speaker 4: In fact, I was just thinking that when you were
[54:03] Speaker 4: answering about salvaging that the cranes and the extra to
[54:08] Speaker 4: both that said that that might have to come into
[54:10] Speaker 4: kind of salvage this ship will actually make the situation
[54:12] Speaker 4: worse as much worse in Mumbai. Right as we end
[54:17] Speaker 4: this episode, a couple of you know, tidbits and nuggets
[54:20] Speaker 4: like we like we do, the custom one very much
[54:22] Speaker 4: on topic and kind of you know, controversial. While doing
[54:25] Speaker 4: the research, I came across very one or two vague
[54:29] Speaker 4: reports about the irons Chukra and Arihant. The second one
[54:33] Speaker 4: is even more controversial, I Chukrau, the summarine that we
[54:36] Speaker 4: had on lease from Russia, a nuclear powered submarine that
[54:40] Speaker 4: was primarily being used by the Navy to train its
[54:42] Speaker 4: sailors in nuclear operations because it knew the nuclear powered
[54:46] Speaker 4: and nuclear capable.
[54:47] Speaker 5: I Sarian was just coming up in a few years.
[54:50] Speaker 4: Apparently that suffered as craping incidents somewhere in twenty seventeen,
[54:54] Speaker 4: a few years later in Russia. I'm not sure if
[54:57] Speaker 4: the two things were linked, but again because it's a
[54:59] Speaker 4: nuclear sumbody, the government and the Navy have been traditionally
[55:02] Speaker 4: mum on that.
[55:03] Speaker 5: No official relief confirmation of that. Obviously wanted inputs on that.
[55:07] Speaker 4: Second, Sari Hant the very interesting report that said that
[55:10] Speaker 4: a hatch was left open, leading to the ingress of
[55:13] Speaker 4: sea water into a crucial component of the of the submarine,
[55:17] Speaker 4: leading to it being docked for around eight months.
[55:20] Speaker 5: I think it was just one report, no official confirmation,
[55:23] Speaker 5: no official word on it.
[55:24] Speaker 4: There were some counter write ups by I think also
[55:27] Speaker 4: a few retired Navy officers completely saying that the report
[55:32] Speaker 4: was trashed and nothing of the chart is possible. They
[55:34] Speaker 4: didn't say it never happened because they probably wouldn't know,
[55:37] Speaker 4: but they said, going by what the report was saying,
[55:40] Speaker 4: it's not possible because apparently didn't even have a hatch
[55:42] Speaker 4: where the report says the hatch was. I have you
[55:45] Speaker 4: write about this again because being a nuclear submarine in
[55:47] Speaker 4: the government and navy have been completely mum on that.
[55:50] Speaker 4: Can you confirm the second? And what if you say
[55:51] Speaker 4: about the first?
[55:52] Speaker 2: Yeah, so I'll go the first. First, the inns Chukla
[55:55] Speaker 2: incident is true. The scraping incident did happen. It was
[55:57] Speaker 2: more than scraping, I was quite there was a damage
[56:01] Speaker 2: that was serious enough to put the submarine out.
[56:04] Speaker 3: Of out of action for a while.
[56:06] Speaker 4: Uh.
[56:06] Speaker 3: And it was it was not because of.
[56:10] Speaker 2: That incident that it was returned to Russia. There was
[56:13] Speaker 2: some other issues that India decided to return it a
[56:15] Speaker 2: little early because it was it had finished. Uh, you
[56:18] Speaker 2: know that the training of those officers had been completed.
[56:22] Speaker 2: Plus the arrianth had come on board. So it was
[56:24] Speaker 2: decided that the Indian Navy wants its second, the follow
[56:28] Speaker 2: on Chakra submarine, which is currently being refurbished and created
[56:31] Speaker 2: in Russia that will join after a few years. So Uh,
[56:35] Speaker 2: that incident did definitely happen. But yeah, it was played
[56:38] Speaker 2: down majorly. No official statements. The Arihant issues a little
[56:41] Speaker 2: bit more complicated.
[56:42] Speaker 3: Uh uh, there was.
[56:45] Speaker 2: Again, none of this is official because the Navy has
[56:49] Speaker 2: never spoken about it. They're they're not allowed to speak
[56:51] Speaker 2: on spacific so you can't blame them either. There was
[56:54] Speaker 2: no major accident on the arianth the hatch, the hatch
[56:57] Speaker 2: accident or what is being called an open hatch. You know,
[57:01] Speaker 2: it was a much smaller, much smaller issue. It didn't
[57:05] Speaker 2: It had nothing to do with water ingress. There was
[57:08] Speaker 2: a there was some kind of a systemic issue that
[57:11] Speaker 2: that took place, you know, when the when the submarine
[57:14] Speaker 2: was somewhere near the Anderman Islands and it was fixed.
[57:18] Speaker 2: It was fixed very very soon. There was no problem
[57:21] Speaker 2: with the submarine. It was it had to go for
[57:25] Speaker 2: a for a routine maintenance and refit just a few
[57:29] Speaker 2: weeks later, which I think sparked the whole idea that oh,
[57:32] Speaker 2: it's gone back to aishaka Putnam now because something big
[57:35] Speaker 2: bad has happened.
[57:37] Speaker 3: But no, it was it was I am told from.
[57:39] Speaker 2: People on the team that it was a it was
[57:41] Speaker 2: a serious incident, but it was a small incident that
[57:44] Speaker 2: didn't stop operations at all, and it had nothing to
[57:46] Speaker 2: do with.
[57:47] Speaker 4: The hatch, right, So yeah, routine maintenance. And I think
[57:50] Speaker 4: to just expand on that thought and something that we've
[57:52] Speaker 4: discussed previously, the fact that naval ships require such extensive
[57:58] Speaker 4: periods of maintenance means that you know, India just urgently
[58:02] Speaker 4: needs maybe more nuclear subminians and maybe one more aircraft
[58:05] Speaker 4: carrier because that is the one part that we're still lacking.
[58:07] Speaker 4: I mean, it's something like an Anes bram Rabano. It's
[58:09] Speaker 4: a very tragic loss if that loss, you know, actually happens. Yeah,
[58:13] Speaker 4: but you do have other ship the same class, you know,
[58:16] Speaker 4: in your fleet, so they are kind of there to
[58:18] Speaker 4: kind of fill in the void left by by your
[58:21] Speaker 4: by your flagship. But with something like an Arii Hunt,
[58:24] Speaker 4: when it goes out of commission for routine men, it
[58:27] Speaker 4: gets it gets potted because that's the only one you.
[58:29] Speaker 5: Have in service.
[58:29] Speaker 4: Like, oh my god, you don't have a Nucletusmit anymore.
[58:31] Speaker 4: But anyway, that's something you discussed on the previous episode
[58:33] Speaker 4: on Nucleus subs.
[58:35] Speaker 5: Right, So final a.
[58:36] Speaker 4: Bit completely off topic, but just because it came up
[58:38] Speaker 4: during my research. So when I was doing the research.
[58:41] Speaker 4: I just came across some report of irons PETA. But
[58:43] Speaker 4: there was an event when it was being affiliated with
[58:48] Speaker 4: a regiment of the Indian Army. The horse fell not
[58:51] Speaker 4: wrong and one squadron of the Air Force.
[58:53] Speaker 5: I forgot which one it was. What is this concept
[58:56] Speaker 5: all about? So I did some googling. It was like this.
[58:58] Speaker 4: It was began in nineteen ninety to foster like some
[59:01] Speaker 4: sort of inter services whatever. Anyway you tell us what's
[59:04] Speaker 4: this affiliation is all about.
[59:05] Speaker 2: So there are quite a few of these affiliations. I
[59:08] Speaker 2: think the iron is run weir and the Rajputana Rifles.
[59:11] Speaker 2: I'm not sure, but that these ship squadron and you
[59:17] Speaker 2: know and army battalion or regiment affiliations have happened because
[59:21] Speaker 2: it was a it was it was an idea that
[59:24] Speaker 2: someone had in the nineties to foster a greater sense
[59:28] Speaker 2: of jointness, oh that bugbear jointness, which we still keep
[59:32] Speaker 2: talking about. Obviously, somewhere someone had the foresight to see
[59:35] Speaker 2: that the you know forces, uh, you know, need a
[59:39] Speaker 2: little nudge to you know, work together a little bit more,
[59:42] Speaker 2: mix a little better, you know, foster a sense of
[59:45] Speaker 2: jointness that is more than just doing joint exercises, but
[59:49] Speaker 2: you know, feel a sense of joint culture and joint belonging.
[59:52] Speaker 2: And someone thought it was nice if you have regimental
[59:55] Speaker 2: affiliations with warships and aircraft squadrons.
[59:58] Speaker 3: So that was that was how it worked.
[1:00:01] Speaker 2: I think it's a little questionable about how successful those
[1:00:04] Speaker 2: affiliations have been because, you know, apart from the usual
[1:00:08] Speaker 2: ceremonial stuff you see and the you know, actual rituals
[1:00:11] Speaker 2: that take place, one doesn't know how it sort of
[1:00:16] Speaker 2: fits into the order of battle as it were, which
[1:00:19] Speaker 2: is where all these things really matter. And as we've seen,
[1:00:22] Speaker 2: jointness continues to be a big, you know, sore thumb
[1:00:26] Speaker 2: with the military, so to speak.
[1:00:28] Speaker 3: So so yeah, it's it's a it's a harmless thing.
[1:00:32] Speaker 3: But I don't think it, you know, really.
[1:00:33] Speaker 2: Served any great purpose than ceremonials. And I'm not saying
[1:00:37] Speaker 2: ceremonials are not important. They're very, very important in the military.
[1:00:40] Speaker 2: I'm just saying from a tactical strategic perspective, I don't
[1:00:44] Speaker 2: think they meant anything else.
[1:00:45] Speaker 5: Yeah, I think that's what the moral I said.
[1:00:48] Speaker 4: Then, Yeah, thanks shift, great insights, and especially love that
[1:00:52] Speaker 4: part about where you explained how the different processes of
[1:00:54] Speaker 4: maintenance when it comes from naval ships, and I think
[1:00:57] Speaker 4: that's some sort of a fee, that sort of an
[1:00:59] Speaker 4: insight that we we look for on this on this podcast.
[1:01:03] Speaker 4: Thanks once again and thanks us always to our producer
[1:01:05] Speaker 4: and Appladition, and to also our listeners and viewers. That's
[1:01:08] Speaker 4: it for this week's defense does for more tune in
[1:01:10] Speaker 4: next week. Then stay safe and not lost any poulties
[1:01:12] Speaker 4: to the passport by

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
