# AI Dividend Proposal Roils Korean Market

An episode of [Bloomberg Tech](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1611767434), 12 May 2026, 43 min.

Audio: https://podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/e73c998e-6e60-432f-8610-ae210140c5b1/41764a4f-fc64-4e11-89ba-ae7c0030ab5e/0c6089bf-ea1f-4b15-9f6b-b448011b9f52/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=9caafc41-289c-4115-995d-ae7c0030ab75

Bloomberg’s Caroline Hyde and Ed Ludlow discuss comments by a South Korean policymaker that the country should pay citizens a “dividend” using taxes on AI profits. Plus, the largest US derivatives exchange, CME, is planning to create a futures market for computing power, one of the key drivers of the AI boom. And the CEO of SAP talks about the company’s push into AI agents across business operations. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:02] Speaker 1: Bloomberg Audio Studios, podcasts, radio news. Bloomberg Tech is alive
[0:12] Speaker 1: from coast to coast with Caroline Hide in New York
[0:17] Speaker 1: and Eva Low in San Francisco.
[0:22] Speaker 2: This is Bloomberg Tech coming up. Big swings in Korean
[0:25] Speaker 2: stocks after a South Korean policy maker suggests paying citizens
[0:29] Speaker 2: at dividend using taxes on AI profits.
[0:32] Speaker 3: Past The largest US derivatives exchange CME is planning to
[0:36] Speaker 3: create a futures market for computing power, one of the
[0:39] Speaker 3: key drivers of the AI.
[0:40] Speaker 2: Boom, and SAP pushes further into AI agents across business
[0:45] Speaker 2: operations with its new Autonomous Enterprise platform.
[0:48] Speaker 4: We'll discussed with the CEO.
[0:50] Speaker 3: First we check in on these markets, which well, maybe
[0:52] Speaker 3: for once we get a shakeout of what has been
[0:55] Speaker 3: a relentless grind hire in the tech industry and most
[0:58] Speaker 3: notably some of the chip stocks which today are the
[1:00] Speaker 3: biggest foolers having been of course the crescendo effect in
[1:03] Speaker 3: the NASDAK we're not by one point four percent. It's
[1:05] Speaker 3: the biggest drop we've seen since late March ed and
[1:07] Speaker 3: all of this is as we still have anxiety about
[1:09] Speaker 3: to your politics and that is feeding through to inflationary trashures.
[1:13] Speaker 4: More broadly, take a look at this chart.
[1:17] Speaker 2: Korean stocks took a dive on Tuesday following a Facebook
[1:20] Speaker 2: post by a South Korean policy maker saying the nation
[1:24] Speaker 2: should pay citizens a quote dividend using taxes on AI profits.
[1:28] Speaker 2: The benchmark hosspy sank as much as five percent, then
[1:32] Speaker 2: paired losses when the Korean government later said that was
[1:35] Speaker 2: his personal opinion.
[1:37] Speaker 4: South Korean shares of.
[1:38] Speaker 2: Samsung's and s k heinez recoup some of their losses,
[1:41] Speaker 2: but still closed down around five percent. Let's get more
[1:44] Speaker 2: with Bloomberg's executive editor for Global Tech, Peter Elstrove. It's
[1:47] Speaker 2: the kind of story you wake up, you see at
[1:49] Speaker 2: number one on the Bloomberg terminal, and you're not really surprised,
[1:51] Speaker 2: but you do a double take and you go a
[1:54] Speaker 2: Facebook post that sank an entire market.
[1:57] Speaker 4: Who is this policy maker and what do we need
[1:59] Speaker 4: to know? Yeah, it is a.
[2:02] Speaker 5: Bit of a surprise, and there are surprising dynamics behind
[2:05] Speaker 5: this post. So, as you mentioned, this advisor Kim Engbung
[2:09] Speaker 5: posted on Facebook about this idea of an AI dividend
[2:13] Speaker 5: really a citizen's dividend because of the AI profits. Again,
[2:17] Speaker 5: it was posted on Facebook. It's not official policy. The
[2:20] Speaker 5: President's office was quick to come out and say that
[2:22] Speaker 5: it's his personal opinion. But it's a twenty five hundred
[2:25] Speaker 5: word post. It's very in depth. It's actually quite philosophical.
[2:29] Speaker 5: He talks about the evolution of the Korean economy, what
[2:32] Speaker 5: it means for the people, what it means for citizens,
[2:34] Speaker 5: how they're going to be challenges, but they're going to
[2:36] Speaker 5: be opportunities too, and then he homes in out in
[2:38] Speaker 5: this idea that perhaps there should be a dividend to
[2:41] Speaker 5: rebuild the social foundation of the country as they go
[2:44] Speaker 5: into this new era. So he's not talking about new
[2:47] Speaker 5: taxes on these companies, just to be clear, on the
[2:50] Speaker 5: key companies like Samsung and sk Heinix, he's just talking
[2:52] Speaker 5: about how the country is going to benefit from their
[2:55] Speaker 5: profits and what the country should do with those profits.
[2:58] Speaker 5: And the profits are pretty staff just to be clear,
[3:01] Speaker 5: Samsung is on track to make something like two hundred
[3:03] Speaker 5: and twenty billion dollars this year. Sk Heinix won't be
[3:06] Speaker 5: far behind. So you're talking about four hundred billion dollars
[3:09] Speaker 5: in profits from just two companies. Of course, it's not
[3:11] Speaker 5: as much as you would get in the US, but
[3:13] Speaker 5: it's much more concentrated in Korea, so the contribution to
[3:17] Speaker 5: the Korean budget is going to be much more substantial.
[3:20] Speaker 5: They're going to have this windfall, and so he's talking
[3:22] Speaker 5: about what they should do with it.
[3:23] Speaker 3: He's clicking in on a hot button topic, whether it
[3:26] Speaker 3: be here in the United States, where Open Ai has
[3:28] Speaker 3: been essentially suggesting ways in which there could be some
[3:31] Speaker 3: sort of wealth fund created to distribute the wealth created
[3:34] Speaker 3: by AI more broadly. But also there's potential labor issues,
[3:39] Speaker 3: particularly for Samsung.
[3:40] Speaker 6: Sk heinis has.
[3:41] Speaker 3: Been promising profits towards its engineers and workers, but Samsung
[3:45] Speaker 3: is facing a potential strike.
[3:47] Speaker 5: Yeah, it's a really important point. This is not just
[3:49] Speaker 5: a Korea issue. This is really a global issue. Governments
[3:52] Speaker 5: around the world. They're trying to figure out, what are
[3:54] Speaker 5: we going to do if there is this big, big
[3:56] Speaker 5: AI boom as we've seen so far, what are you
[3:58] Speaker 5: going to do with all those profits? What are you
[4:00] Speaker 5: going to do with that new wealthy You've had the
[4:01] Speaker 5: billionaire's tax proposed of course in California too. Now Samsung
[4:06] Speaker 5: and eske Heinix have been wrestling with this issue. As
[4:09] Speaker 5: you mentioned, Samsung right now is in negotiations with its
[4:12] Speaker 5: labor union, which is threatened to strike because they want
[4:15] Speaker 5: to bigger share those profits too. Again, this is not
[4:17] Speaker 5: a new tax on these companies though, if they proceed
[4:20] Speaker 5: with this dividend. As we've talked about, it's more a
[4:23] Speaker 5: sense of what the Korean government can do to prepare.
[4:26] Speaker 5: And the big message from Kim in this whole discussion
[4:29] Speaker 5: is that his government in Korea and then governments around
[4:32] Speaker 5: the world, need to be more proactive and thinking about
[4:35] Speaker 5: how they're going to navigate this much more complex world
[4:38] Speaker 5: with AI as it begins to change the economy, begins
[4:41] Speaker 5: to change the workplace and employment too.
[4:43] Speaker 3: Philosophical indeed, blom bags Peter Alstrom, thanks for running us
[4:47] Speaker 3: through it. Look Staying in Asia, President Trump is poised
[4:50] Speaker 3: to travel to China to meet with President Shijinping later
[4:53] Speaker 3: this week now, a number of top tech executives are
[4:55] Speaker 3: expected to join the trip.
[4:56] Speaker 6: As we told you yesterday, the.
[4:58] Speaker 3: Likes of Tim Kok, the likes of tests Evil Musk
[5:00] Speaker 3: notably absent in Vidio CEO Jensen Wang, who was reportedly
[5:05] Speaker 3: not even invited here with Moris Bloomberg's Chip and AI
[5:08] Speaker 3: reporter Maggi Easton say is that the case that the
[5:11] Speaker 3: invite wasn't extended to Jensen who seems so close to
[5:13] Speaker 3: the president.
[5:16] Speaker 7: Yes, exactly, that's what we're reporting here. In Vidia's chief
[5:19] Speaker 7: executive officer, the leader of America's most valuable company, did
[5:24] Speaker 7: not get the invite to come to China, even though
[5:27] Speaker 7: he has a lot at stake in China, and Jiwang
[5:30] Speaker 7: is continuing to push for some sort of AI chip
[5:32] Speaker 7: sale there, though. This seems to be a signal that
[5:35] Speaker 7: he's not going to get Blackwell sales in China anytime soon,
[5:40] Speaker 7: at least from the US permission side.
[5:43] Speaker 2: It's interesting you're writing about this in your Tech in
[5:45] Speaker 2: Depth today right that the President's priorities and Jensen Wang's
[5:50] Speaker 2: priorities right now they might not be as aligned as
[5:53] Speaker 2: they have been in recent months. Just take us into
[5:56] Speaker 2: your Tech in Debt.
[5:59] Speaker 7: Absolutely, so, there's really a stark contrast here. If you
[6:02] Speaker 7: look at the last time President Trump met with President
[6:05] Speaker 7: she in Korea last October, Blackwells were top of mind.
[6:09] Speaker 7: You know, President Trump was telling reporters that he was
[6:11] Speaker 7: going to talk.
[6:12] Speaker 6: To She about those chips.
[6:14] Speaker 7: At the same time, in video was lobbying for potentially
[6:17] Speaker 7: selling those high powered processors to China. So now we're
[6:21] Speaker 7: seeing sort of a reversal in Trump's priorities.
[6:24] Speaker 6: The issue of AI chips has.
[6:26] Speaker 7: Been deliberated, and it was decided that, you know, the
[6:29] Speaker 7: US would allow in Video to sell its H two
[6:31] Speaker 7: hundred processor, which is less powerful than the Blackwell. And
[6:35] Speaker 7: it seems to be that that's sort of where the
[6:37] Speaker 7: line stands, and the latest signal of that is, of
[6:39] Speaker 7: course Jensen not joining for this China trip.
[6:42] Speaker 3: It's interesting that maybe more on the focus from the
[6:45] Speaker 3: Chinese leadership perspective is Taiwan, and there in line is
[6:48] Speaker 3: the whole issue of supply chain and a desire to
[6:51] Speaker 3: make America stand alone a little bit more in its
[6:54] Speaker 3: own ability to fabricate these chips. Margie, who do you
[6:57] Speaker 3: think is going to be centered around conversation?
[7:00] Speaker 6: And when it comes to.
[7:01] Speaker 3: Jensen, is it a big loss because the market is
[7:04] Speaker 3: down what eight ten percent on his name today?
[7:08] Speaker 7: Well, look, it's certainly not the boost that the idea
[7:11] Speaker 7: that AI chips could be on the table and Blackwells
[7:14] Speaker 7: could be on the table was last October. I mean
[7:16] Speaker 7: that's sent in Video's you know market cap above five
[7:19] Speaker 7: trillion dollars. So we're not seeing that same enthusiasm, and
[7:22] Speaker 7: even for something like the H two hundreds, it's unclear
[7:25] Speaker 7: if in video will ever be able to you know,
[7:27] Speaker 7: tally up sales from selling those to China. China could
[7:30] Speaker 7: still reject those. You know, it's possible that comes up
[7:33] Speaker 7: in this meeting, though the focus is probably going to
[7:35] Speaker 7: be bigger geopolitical issues, especially the warn Iran, and so
[7:39] Speaker 7: it seems since AI chips are just not a focus
[7:41] Speaker 7: in videos, definitely not going to get a boost from
[7:45] Speaker 7: this meeting, and you know, they might even see some declines.
[7:48] Speaker 6: As you're pointing.
[7:48] Speaker 2: Out Lin Beg's Maggie Eastland, thank you very much. The
[7:52] Speaker 2: melt up in chip SUNDAYI infrastructure stocks is hitting a
[7:56] Speaker 2: pause today. I'm looking at the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index. It's
[7:59] Speaker 2: up behind forty percent over the last twelve months through
[8:02] Speaker 2: yesterday's close, up seventy percent year to date, but today,
[8:06] Speaker 2: in the moment, we're on track for our biggest drop
[8:08] Speaker 2: since that last week of March. Is probably worth pointing
[8:11] Speaker 2: out as well that CPI inflation accelerating in April, coming
[8:15] Speaker 2: in three point eight percent year on year. That has
[8:18] Speaker 2: had big impact on the markets of the moment. Let's
[8:21] Speaker 2: get more with Kim Forrest, CEO Boca Capital Partners. I
[8:24] Speaker 2: was talking with the equities desk this morning at Bloomberg
[8:26] Speaker 2: News about a lot of these names that are really
[8:29] Speaker 2: lower today, taking a pause, Intel, Micron, Intel particular, they
[8:34] Speaker 2: were kind of primed for a bit of a pullback, right.
[8:37] Speaker 4: Is that it is that.
[8:38] Speaker 2: Just timing in the moment, or is it this CPI
[8:41] Speaker 2: print we got this morning.
[8:43] Speaker 8: I think the CPI print is completely disregarded by the
[8:48] Speaker 8: Chip Nation and AI because they don't care. They just
[8:52] Speaker 8: simply don't care what cast things are, or I guess
[8:57] Speaker 8: overall they don't care. God knows that. You know, AMD
[9:01] Speaker 8: is probably making some gains because they have a somewhat
[9:05] Speaker 8: lower price GPU than in Nvidia, and it's capable, so
[9:10] Speaker 8: you know, cost is relative. But yes, I don't think
[9:13] Speaker 8: CPI has anything to do with today's tech selloff. I
[9:17] Speaker 8: think it has more to do with just look at
[9:21] Speaker 8: the gains for the year, and sometimes you just run
[9:24] Speaker 8: out of buyers, even momentum buyers can't continue. So it's
[9:29] Speaker 8: probably that as well as what happened in South Korea. Again,
[9:36] Speaker 8: buyers want to buy companies that are going up and
[9:39] Speaker 8: perhaps yesterday's sell off of those memory names was enough
[9:44] Speaker 8: to cool the temperature of buying chip stocks today.
[9:49] Speaker 3: It's interesting to talk about momentum, and we've been hearing
[9:53] Speaker 3: from some of the biggest leaders on Wall Street just
[9:56] Speaker 3: today about whether AI is real, what the investment opportunities are,
[9:59] Speaker 3: who wins, who lose?
[10:00] Speaker 6: Just take a listen to Jamie Diamond a little bit earlier.
[10:02] Speaker 9: Kim, The way I look at it is that AI
[10:05] Speaker 9: is re all. A lot of money's going to go
[10:07] Speaker 9: into it. It doesn't mean everyone does it is going
[10:09] Speaker 9: to be a winner. Like go back to the Internet.
[10:12] Speaker 9: A lot of people lost, a lot of people won.
[10:14] Speaker 9: And so you know in the hyper skills those data centers.
[10:18] Speaker 4: Not find use.
[10:18] Speaker 9: They probably will, But is it possible some do it badly,
[10:21] Speaker 9: design it badly, didn't get the right Yes, of course
[10:24] Speaker 9: it's possible, Kim.
[10:25] Speaker 3: You've that on invested in the right names, some that
[10:29] Speaker 3: have done incredibly well through momentum otherwise recently, But are
[10:33] Speaker 3: too many ramping higher at this moment?
[10:35] Speaker 6: Will we start to see more discernment?
[10:38] Speaker 8: I hope so it Actually we've seen some discernment with
[10:42] Speaker 8: Intel coming back from you know, it was not only
[10:46] Speaker 8: dead and buried, but it had the.
[10:48] Speaker 4: Grass grew over.
[10:49] Speaker 8: It's great, right, I mean, it was gone, and yet
[10:53] Speaker 8: here we are, and why are we here? I think
[10:55] Speaker 8: it's the forward movement of AI development. And whenever AI
[11:01] Speaker 8: came on the scene and chat GPT captured everyone's imagination
[11:06] Speaker 8: both in Nvidia and open AI seemed to be like
[11:10] Speaker 8: the winners, and everybody else was just going to languish. Well,
[11:13] Speaker 8: technology rollouts don't really work that way. And I think
[11:16] Speaker 8: we're probably in I've been watching a lot of baseball
[11:20] Speaker 8: because the Pittsburgh Pirates are actually tolerable to watch this
[11:23] Speaker 8: year so far, and we're probably in the bottom of
[11:27] Speaker 8: the second inning in AIM, so we have a lot
[11:31] Speaker 8: of road to go ahead of us.
[11:34] Speaker 2: The big calendar item this week probably is President Trump's
[11:39] Speaker 2: visit to China meeting with President President g and also
[11:43] Speaker 2: the delegation of top CEOs, all relevant to to the
[11:47] Speaker 2: fields that you've outlined. What's at stake here for the
[11:51] Speaker 2: technology investor and for markets this week.
[11:55] Speaker 8: Well, the US and China are walking a really really
[11:59] Speaker 8: narrow line between each other. Where AI is considered is
[12:05] Speaker 8: you know, the topic for a long time America has
[12:10] Speaker 8: been winning. But I think it feels like decades ago
[12:14] Speaker 8: whenever Deep Seek came out. Maybe it was the beginning
[12:17] Speaker 8: of twenty twenty five. You know, the shiver went through
[12:21] Speaker 8: the AI community going, oh my gosh, China might have
[12:24] Speaker 8: something here. And while we want competition, it's the military
[12:30] Speaker 8: uses of AI and the military uses of the chips
[12:33] Speaker 8: that were very cognizant of. And I think that's why,
[12:37] Speaker 8: you know, Jensen Wong didn't get the invite. They don't
[12:40] Speaker 8: really want to discuss that at this point, so don't
[12:43] Speaker 8: invite them, don't have the conversation about it. But yes,
[12:46] Speaker 8: AI is very much a contention between the US and China,
[12:51] Speaker 8: and I know that the US is you know, US
[12:54] Speaker 8: first would like to develop it and sell it to
[12:57] Speaker 8: the rest of the world, but so would China. So
[12:59] Speaker 8: there's going to be tension over the world of AI.
[13:02] Speaker 3: Kim Forest Cio of Boca Capital Partners, it's always great
[13:05] Speaker 3: to check in with you. Thanks the expertise. Now coming
[13:08] Speaker 3: up the largest US de riveters exchange. That's the CME.
[13:11] Speaker 3: It's planning to create a futures market for computing power details.
[13:15] Speaker 6: Next, this is Bloomberg Tech.
[13:23] Speaker 10: The United States is short power for short compute we're
[13:28] Speaker 10: short chipped. Is there going to be shortages at all?
[13:31] Speaker 10: Three and memory for things. I actually believe a new
[13:37] Speaker 10: acid class will be buying futures of compute. We just
[13:41] Speaker 10: don't have enough compute power right now.
[13:44] Speaker 3: That was black Rock CEO Larry Fink a week ago
[13:47] Speaker 3: at Milken.
[13:48] Speaker 6: For telling what is big news out today.
[13:50] Speaker 3: CME and Silicon Data are teaming up to create a
[13:53] Speaker 3: futures market for computing power, one of the pillars of
[13:55] Speaker 3: the AI boom.
[13:56] Speaker 6: Bloomberg's finance for portech. Adam Doherty has actually.
[13:58] Speaker 3: Been following what's the condage has been doing around this
[14:01] Speaker 3: for a while, and now the CME brings it because,
[14:03] Speaker 3: according to Terry Duffy at the CME computes the new oil.
[14:07] Speaker 11: That's right, it's just another commodity that is going to
[14:09] Speaker 11: be able to not just be traded, tracked versus That's
[14:13] Speaker 11: really what was the first pillar was the index that
[14:16] Speaker 11: was created Silicon Data bringing that too investors so they
[14:20] Speaker 11: could at least start to have more transparency around putting
[14:24] Speaker 11: a number to what people were valuing as the price
[14:29] Speaker 11: of compute technology. And now we have the ability to hedge,
[14:33] Speaker 11: to hedge against price moves and some of the risks
[14:37] Speaker 11: that are out there, as it would you tracking oil
[14:41] Speaker 11: or other commodity prices. This is really bringing this into
[14:44] Speaker 11: the institutional space, and you're going to have both the
[14:47] Speaker 11: tech firms and investors that are going to jump into
[14:51] Speaker 11: this and build the market and grow it so that
[14:53] Speaker 11: it has the actual liquidity to back it.
[14:56] Speaker 2: Kata and I go even more basic than that. You know,
[14:58] Speaker 2: futures contracts an agreement to buy or sell something at
[15:02] Speaker 2: a later date at a fixed price, So you're either
[15:05] Speaker 2: locking in that cost or you're betting in a price
[15:08] Speaker 2: change in either direction. But like with compute, like I
[15:12] Speaker 2: think we're talking about GPUs or GPU hours something like that.
[15:16] Speaker 2: You know, have they worked out how this would work
[15:18] Speaker 2: in the real world, that's.
[15:20] Speaker 11: Right, So the index is where you're getting into that
[15:23] Speaker 11: detail about GPUs and the processing power. That was kind
[15:28] Speaker 11: of the first step. Now with the futures contracts, as
[15:32] Speaker 11: you are pointing out, this is the ability to hedge
[15:35] Speaker 11: for future moves, putting a price to or really the
[15:41] Speaker 11: bet of where these contracts are going to be traded
[15:45] Speaker 11: in the future.
[15:46] Speaker 6: So it's both looking at.
[15:47] Speaker 11: Where is the price of these GPU processing power trading
[15:53] Speaker 11: today and where do we see it in a few weeks,
[15:56] Speaker 11: months and as it builds out it's really going to be.
[16:00] Speaker 11: It has to develop, and I think that it's something
[16:03] Speaker 11: that also needs the blessing of regulators. But the intent
[16:08] Speaker 11: is to be able to put a price on not
[16:11] Speaker 11: just where this power is trading at the very moment,
[16:15] Speaker 11: but in the future.
[16:17] Speaker 3: Silicon Data commonly who's the founder of all this previously
[16:20] Speaker 3: a trader, was her idea to bring transparency to those
[16:24] Speaker 3: who were going and trying to buy compute and just
[16:26] Speaker 3: understand what one offering was like to another. Or she
[16:29] Speaker 3: really thinking that this could become a fully fledged asset
[16:31] Speaker 3: class that the retail investors want to get in it,
[16:33] Speaker 3: and more broadly, we want to sort of build up
[16:35] Speaker 3: an ecosystem.
[16:36] Speaker 11: Around I do think it was all about the ecosystem.
[16:38] Speaker 11: What Silicon Data and what Carmen was building from the
[16:42] Speaker 11: very start was again one pillar to something that was
[16:45] Speaker 11: much larger. And when we talk about transparency, before today,
[16:50] Speaker 11: there really wasn't a big player like CME that was
[16:53] Speaker 11: able to bring compute as an asset class to the
[16:58] Speaker 11: market in this way. As a derivatives exchange, they already
[17:03] Speaker 11: have the traders and so You might not have just
[17:06] Speaker 11: the tech firms and the AI providers, the superscalers that
[17:12] Speaker 11: are going to be using this to hedge their own costs,
[17:15] Speaker 11: but you're bringing an entire new institutional base that is
[17:19] Speaker 11: going to look at this asset class in the same
[17:21] Speaker 11: way that they would oil, metals and other things that
[17:24] Speaker 11: they trade. So it's going to be kind of a
[17:26] Speaker 11: mix of many different worlds that is going to build
[17:30] Speaker 11: this ecosystem, this new market.
[17:32] Speaker 2: That was my next question really is like put CME
[17:35] Speaker 2: in the context of the broader derivatives markets. A next
[17:37] Speaker 2: step would be, I guess other players would make similar
[17:40] Speaker 2: proposals for futures contracts on computes in other jurisdictions.
[17:44] Speaker 11: Yes, you already have seen some exchanges, some upstarts, but
[17:49] Speaker 11: no one to the size of CME, which is the
[17:52] Speaker 11: largest US derivatives exchange, come into this space. It's very
[17:56] Speaker 11: likely that we'll see other large exchange operators will jump
[18:01] Speaker 11: into this and build their own marketplace, because it's all
[18:04] Speaker 11: about the more liquidity, the more trading, and the more
[18:07] Speaker 11: interest that you can build, the better it is for
[18:09] Speaker 11: the market as a whole. It doesn't need to be
[18:11] Speaker 11: just one exchange.
[18:13] Speaker 2: Bloombo's Karen Doherty on a big breaking news story this morning,
[18:16] Speaker 2: Thank you very much. Sam Altman is expected to take
[18:19] Speaker 2: the stand today in the closely watched trial over the
[18:22] Speaker 2: charitable status of open Ai. Elon Musk has accused the
[18:26] Speaker 2: startup and his fellow co founders and Microsoft of betraying
[18:29] Speaker 2: open AI's founding mission for their own benefit. Yesterday, we
[18:33] Speaker 2: learn more about the financial gains during testimony from Microsoft
[18:37] Speaker 2: CEO Sati and Nadella and open AI's former chief scientist
[18:40] Speaker 2: Ilia Sutzkiva. Bloomberg's Madeline Meckelberg is covering the case and
[18:44] Speaker 2: has been there every single day. Let's start with the
[18:48] Speaker 2: what's to come, Sam Altman. You know this is the
[18:51] Speaker 2: testimony probably that the world's waiting for.
[18:54] Speaker 4: What do we know at this stage?
[18:57] Speaker 10: That's right.
[18:58] Speaker 12: This is definitely the high profile witness that we've been
[19:01] Speaker 12: waiting to hear from. We've heard from at this point
[19:03] Speaker 12: all of the other major players in this open Ai
[19:07] Speaker 12: battle with Elon Musk, that includes Elon Musk, Greg Brockman,
[19:11] Speaker 12: Ilias Setskov, Sati, Nadella. As you said, and so we
[19:15] Speaker 12: don't know much about Altman. We don't even know what
[19:18] Speaker 12: time we're expecting him to take the stand today, but
[19:21] Speaker 12: there's just a few days left at trial, and he
[19:23] Speaker 12: really has a lot of questions that he's going to
[19:25] Speaker 12: have to answer for before the jury. I think we're
[19:28] Speaker 12: going to hear him grilled on a lot of the
[19:30] Speaker 12: subjects that we've covered already at trial, mainly about his
[19:34] Speaker 12: relationship with Elon Musk, but also chiefly about his ouster.
[19:38] Speaker 12: That's something that Musk's legal team has been making a
[19:41] Speaker 12: really big issue of. This is back in the twenty
[19:43] Speaker 12: twenty two twenty twenty three time period, and they're going
[19:47] Speaker 12: through a lot of concerns that employees voiced at that time,
[19:50] Speaker 12: or members of the board rather voiced at that time
[19:52] Speaker 12: about his leadership style. So I think this is going
[19:55] Speaker 12: to be an opportunity for him to kind of respond
[19:57] Speaker 12: to a lot of the allegations and the description that we've
[20:00] Speaker 12: heard so far and tell his side of the story,
[20:03] Speaker 12: which is an essential one in this case.
[20:05] Speaker 3: And the essential element of the story is well to
[20:08] Speaker 3: convince that it wasn't just out of greed that they were.
[20:12] Speaker 6: Turning into a for profit business.
[20:13] Speaker 3: What is it that through Sam's leadership style that they're
[20:17] Speaker 3: looking to prove one way or other.
[20:20] Speaker 4: That's right.
[20:20] Speaker 12: So that's the central argument from Musk here, is that
[20:23] Speaker 12: they've betrayed the founding mission in an effort to try
[20:26] Speaker 12: to enrich themselves. That's why we've heard so much about
[20:30] Speaker 12: how much stake some of these leaders have in open AI,
[20:33] Speaker 12: how much money was being thrown around and made here
[20:36] Speaker 12: since they've made this conversion to a for profit. I
[20:38] Speaker 12: know your viewers know that the value of open ai
[20:41] Speaker 12: has skyrocketed, especially in recent years, and so all these
[20:45] Speaker 12: folks who had equity in the very early days of
[20:47] Speaker 12: making it a for profit have made significant return since then.
[20:51] Speaker 12: Their steak has grown so much. And so I think
[20:54] Speaker 12: what we've seen from Musk lawyers is an attempt to
[20:56] Speaker 12: show that all men has maybe not been truthful to
[20:59] Speaker 12: the board and the past asked, his motives have not
[21:01] Speaker 12: always been clear. So while he may be saying one
[21:04] Speaker 12: thing about his commitment to the mission, I think they're
[21:07] Speaker 12: trying to have the jury ask some questions about whether
[21:10] Speaker 12: he's telling the truth there and whether that's really where
[21:13] Speaker 12: his motivation is.
[21:14] Speaker 3: Megs, Madlin and Macabeg will let you get back to
[21:17] Speaker 3: that courtroom.
[21:17] Speaker 6: We appreciate you.
[21:19] Speaker 3: Checking in on eBay and GameStop shares well. Apparently the
[21:23] Speaker 3: fifty six billion dollar takeover offer from GameStop is.
[21:28] Speaker 6: Deeply non credible nor attractive.
[21:31] Speaker 3: According to eBay itself, ed, we have clearly something that
[21:35] Speaker 3: now could become some sort of proxy battle. It could
[21:37] Speaker 3: become hostile takeover where Ryan Cohen goes directly to shareholders
[21:41] Speaker 3: of eBay. But thus far a company that is worth
[21:44] Speaker 3: a quarter of the company it's trying to book bid
[21:46] Speaker 3: four hasn't managed to convince the board.
[21:49] Speaker 2: Yeah, the offer was one hundred and twenty five dollars
[21:51] Speaker 2: a share, fifty percent cash, fifty percent game Stop stock.
[21:54] Speaker 2: eBay's at one oh seven, and there were concerns about
[21:57] Speaker 2: actually how game Stop would come up with the financing
[22:00] Speaker 2: of that offer.
[22:01] Speaker 4: What happens next?
[22:02] Speaker 3: Yeah, and question of course all about whether or not
[22:04] Speaker 3: this can remain an investment grade company if combined, and
[22:07] Speaker 3: that seems to be a key issue that our reporting
[22:10] Speaker 3: shows that resources showing that that TV offering not enough
[22:13] Speaker 3: if it's not investment graded.
[22:16] Speaker 2: Not the end of that story. Welcome back to Bloomberg Tech.
[22:25] Speaker 2: Generally speaking, we're seeing technology stocks down and quite significantly then,
[22:29] Speaker 2: as that one hundred off by almost two percent now,
[22:32] Speaker 2: and actually semiconductors and chips are the mainstay of that decline.
[22:36] Speaker 2: There's two parts to it. We saw an astonishing rally,
[22:39] Speaker 2: in particular in chip stocks that as of yesterday's close
[22:42] Speaker 2: we're up seventy percent year to date, so we're taking
[22:44] Speaker 2: a time out a breather, but the Philadelphia Semiconductor Index
[22:48] Speaker 2: down almost six percent and on track for its biggest
[22:50] Speaker 2: drop since the last week of March.
[22:52] Speaker 4: We did get a pretty hot.
[22:53] Speaker 2: Inflation print this morning, and our equities desk is saying
[22:57] Speaker 2: in the Global markets wrap that that's part of it,
[22:59] Speaker 2: the whole in rally. In the rally we see in
[23:01] Speaker 2: stocks carry now. Intel is an interesting case study one
[23:06] Speaker 2: of those taking a breather. It's been driven by reports
[23:08] Speaker 2: for a potential deal with Apple and a strategic pivot
[23:11] Speaker 2: into AI. Intel was staging a comeback and in a
[23:14] Speaker 2: blazing rally, added over four hundred billion dollars in market
[23:17] Speaker 2: value in just six weeks, but short interest is near
[23:20] Speaker 2: a fifty two week high, suggesting that for some today
[23:24] Speaker 2: might be the day to bet against some momentum rhyme.
[23:27] Speaker 2: Vastellica joins us with for once some good timing on
[23:31] Speaker 2: the piece you put out this morning. I joke, I joke,
[23:34] Speaker 2: explain the short interest piece to me. How does that work?
[23:37] Speaker 2: Why would it drive the stock like this?
[23:39] Speaker 13: Sure, so, as you mentioned, Intel has seen some really
[23:43] Speaker 13: tremendous momentum in the Star price over the past few weeks.
[23:47] Speaker 13: I think it's up more than two hundred percent since
[23:50] Speaker 13: late March. So that's a very attractive opportunity for a
[23:53] Speaker 13: lot of short sellers who are expecting that this momentum
[23:56] Speaker 13: will not only reverse, but reverse in a pretty dramatic fashion.
[23:59] Speaker 13: Because in addition to how much the stock is moved up,
[24:02] Speaker 13: the multiple is at an all time high over one
[24:05] Speaker 13: hundred times estimated earnings. So you have a high valuation
[24:09] Speaker 13: stock that's already seen some pretty significant games. It's not
[24:12] Speaker 13: really a surprise that people are betting on a reversal,
[24:15] Speaker 13: even though a lot of short sellers are saying, when
[24:18] Speaker 13: you have a company like this with so much positive momentum,
[24:22] Speaker 13: so much fundamental momentum, it's very difficult to pick a
[24:26] Speaker 13: top and really write the move down. So a lot
[24:29] Speaker 13: of confusion here, but certainly some people are betting on
[24:32] Speaker 13: a reversal.
[24:33] Speaker 3: And they're looking pretty clever today at least as we're
[24:36] Speaker 3: currently trading off by more than ten percent. What's interesting, though,
[24:39] Speaker 3: is that the analyst community still think one should be
[24:42] Speaker 3: buying the stock. What is it seventeen buys only three cells,
[24:44] Speaker 3: even though the price.
[24:45] Speaker 6: Target is a little out of whack who it currently
[24:47] Speaker 6: is run.
[24:48] Speaker 13: I would say that consensus is a little bit more
[24:50] Speaker 13: muted on Intel relative to some other big tech names.
[24:54] Speaker 13: I think there's far more hold ratings than there are buys.
[24:57] Speaker 13: But I do think people are warming up to this story.
[25:00] Speaker 13: A lot of skepticism for years about will they be
[25:03] Speaker 13: able to get their foundry business back at the top
[25:07] Speaker 13: of the line the industry standard, and there's been a
[25:09] Speaker 13: lot of optimism that they are showing some progress on
[25:12] Speaker 13: This turnaround was a very ambitious move. It's cost them
[25:14] Speaker 13: a lot of money. There's been a lot of skepticism,
[25:17] Speaker 13: but lately we are seeing very strong results. We had
[25:20] Speaker 13: this report about potentially working with Apple on chip making,
[25:24] Speaker 13: which would be a huge validation for the chip making business.
[25:27] Speaker 13: So there are some very positive signs here. Like I said,
[25:30] Speaker 13: the multiple is very high, there's a lot of questions
[25:32] Speaker 13: out there, and the stock has already seen a pretty
[25:35] Speaker 13: significant move.
[25:36] Speaker 3: And that's benefit of the US government for one play
[25:38] Speaker 3: bags Ron Plastelica, thanks so much.
[25:40] Speaker 6: Always great reporting.
[25:41] Speaker 3: Now let's talk about a growing number of bench firms
[25:44] Speaker 3: who are pumping ever larger sums into leading startups, open
[25:47] Speaker 3: AI and topic.
[25:48] Speaker 6: But our next guest is taking a different approach.
[25:50] Speaker 3: Bennett Segeil is a co founder of a style which
[25:52] Speaker 3: targets seed stage startups. Checks three five million dollars, it's
[25:56] Speaker 3: just closed. It's third fund four hundred and fifty million
[25:59] Speaker 3: dollars in total. That's a large seed round and fund,
[26:02] Speaker 3: but perhaps small versus multi stage VC fundraises that we've
[26:05] Speaker 3: seen of late. So Bennett and I'm pleased to welcome
[26:07] Speaker 3: you here into the New York studio. Seeds rounds have
[26:12] Speaker 3: become astronomically large in many ways.
[26:14] Speaker 6: So are you doing what you've always done? Are you
[26:17] Speaker 6: having to change with the times? How is your VC
[26:19] Speaker 6: model looking?
[26:19] Speaker 1: Well?
[26:19] Speaker 14: First off, thank you for having me. I think we
[26:22] Speaker 14: right now live in a world of giants, both on
[26:24] Speaker 14: the venture capital side and the company side, and we've
[26:26] Speaker 14: really stuck to our craft, which is early stage investing,
[26:30] Speaker 14: backing founders with an idea of raising a few million
[26:33] Speaker 14: dollars and looking to build a giant of tomorrow, and
[26:36] Speaker 14: we wanted a fund size that allowed us to execute
[26:38] Speaker 14: on this strategy where we could be a close partner
[26:41] Speaker 14: to these founders. As funds get larger, incentive shift and
[26:44] Speaker 14: they increasingly put larger amounts of capital on the later
[26:46] Speaker 14: stage rounds, and you see that with Anthropic and Open
[26:49] Speaker 14: AI raising many billions of dollars. We tend to start
[26:53] Speaker 14: more at the ground floor and have crafted our fund
[26:56] Speaker 14: in our team to be a partner to founders when
[26:59] Speaker 14: it's not obvious and before the technology is clear, before
[27:02] Speaker 14: the market opportunity is present.
[27:04] Speaker 3: But the size of the seed rounds, even when a
[27:07] Speaker 3: product hasn't developed. I mean, you're thinking, what was it
[27:10] Speaker 3: reporting around two billion being raised by Thinking Machines Lab.
[27:13] Speaker 3: You're thinking about safer superintelligence again, a two billion seed round.
[27:18] Speaker 6: I know Ed's going to come in with the avocados
[27:19] Speaker 6: and the mangoes, But how do you stick to your knitting? Oh,
[27:23] Speaker 6: you just you ignore those sorts of coming.
[27:25] Speaker 14: No, it's a great question. I think there's a bifurcation
[27:27] Speaker 14: in the market. I think there's traditional seed rounds, which
[27:29] Speaker 14: increasingly companies started by younger founders, graduates from Harvard MIT Stanford.
[27:34] Speaker 14: They're raising what we call more traditional seed round of
[27:36] Speaker 14: between three to five million dollars. In many cases, they're
[27:38] Speaker 14: building on top of foundational model companies, so they're leveraging
[27:42] Speaker 14: the technology and the capital invested in open Ianthropic and
[27:46] Speaker 14: we've backed a number of those companies and they build them.
[27:48] Speaker 14: What we call the application layer on the flip side
[27:51] Speaker 14: is exactly the types of rounds you're talking about. It's
[27:53] Speaker 14: typically researchers that are spinning out of established model companies.
[27:57] Speaker 14: They're raising in many cases could be hundreds of millions,
[28:00] Speaker 14: could be billions of dollars out of the gate to
[28:01] Speaker 14: go and do research and perhaps commercialize the future technology.
[28:05] Speaker 14: We've largely avoided those rounds. In those rounds have been
[28:08] Speaker 14: led by companies like Indries and Horrowitz and others. We
[28:11] Speaker 14: will pick our spots, but many cases founders don't really
[28:14] Speaker 14: need five hundred million dollars out of the gate, though
[28:16] Speaker 14: in this capital markets environment, they're able to get it,
[28:18] Speaker 14: and there are funds that will back them to do so.
[28:21] Speaker 2: Before co founding a Star, you did four years at
[28:25] Speaker 2: CO two and I imagine focused on slightly different scale
[28:30] Speaker 2: and domains, but would you just reflect a little bit
[28:32] Speaker 2: on the difference in your experience what that was like
[28:35] Speaker 2: out investing out of CO two versus the seed stage
[28:39] Speaker 2: at these check sizes and round sizes.
[28:42] Speaker 14: Yeah, it's a great question. I think incentives do matter,
[28:45] Speaker 14: and there's a reason that funds increasingly raise larger amounts
[28:48] Speaker 14: of money over time, and when they raise larger quantuments
[28:51] Speaker 14: of capital, they tend to invest in the later stages
[28:53] Speaker 14: and they tend to focus on large dollar deployment. You know,
[28:55] Speaker 14: CO two is a multi stage fund. They invest venturing
[28:58] Speaker 14: through public markets. Most of the focus tends to be
[29:00] Speaker 14: on the growth stages when there's already clear winners and
[29:03] Speaker 14: you could invest hundreds and millions of dollars in a company.
[29:06] Speaker 4: And look to earn a multiple on that.
[29:08] Speaker 14: You know where we play at the seed stage, we're
[29:10] Speaker 14: investing typically it starts out at a couple of million dollars.
[29:13] Speaker 14: We're backing on a founder before there's an idea, before
[29:16] Speaker 14: there's consensus around a market, and we're working with them
[29:19] Speaker 14: to build their business.
[29:20] Speaker 4: The beauty of our model is.
[29:22] Speaker 14: We can actually make venture type returns, and we can
[29:24] Speaker 14: make one hundred, two hundred and three hundred times our
[29:26] Speaker 14: money but we have to go and find these, you know,
[29:29] Speaker 14: incredible opportunities early, and it takes many years for the
[29:32] Speaker 14: companies to sort of grow and mature. The other aspect
[29:35] Speaker 14: of our model, which is different from coaches, will continue
[29:37] Speaker 14: to invest, which we've done in our best companies over time,
[29:40] Speaker 14: and be one of the largest shareholders in the cap table,
[29:43] Speaker 14: so be much more concentrated with a handful of companies
[29:46] Speaker 14: that we hope will go from inception stage to the
[29:48] Speaker 14: public markets over a decade or longer.
[29:51] Speaker 2: Well, Caroline was referring to about coconut rounds, avocado rounds,
[29:54] Speaker 2: mango seed rounds. Is I wrote a column a few
[29:57] Speaker 2: months ago that it's pointless saying seed because inside cases
[30:01] Speaker 2: the entry level is so high. But you're committed to
[30:04] Speaker 2: this two to five million dollar level, you know, that
[30:08] Speaker 2: would counter that that the seed market is alive and
[30:12] Speaker 2: well and true to its definition.
[30:14] Speaker 14: Look, we're going to play the game in the field.
[30:16] Speaker 14: We've modestly grown fun size. We started out with a
[30:19] Speaker 14: three hundred million dollar fund. We're now in fun three
[30:21] Speaker 14: or four hundred and fifty million, So we see inflation
[30:23] Speaker 14: in round size, and you know, our goals to partner
[30:26] Speaker 14: with the best founders in Silicon Valley, so we will
[30:28] Speaker 14: do what we need to do to accomplish that. That said,
[30:32] Speaker 14: it's still rare for founders to raise one hundred million
[30:35] Speaker 14: dollars out of the gate with no product or prior
[30:39] Speaker 14: track record. That is a rare, I would say circumstance
[30:42] Speaker 14: of particularly researchers coming out of labs what we see
[30:45] Speaker 14: in other cases. For instance, with a company called Decagon,
[30:48] Speaker 14: which is one of the leaders in AI customer support.
[30:50] Speaker 14: It's one of the killer use cases that AI where
[30:52] Speaker 14: you could replace a lot of folks in the call
[30:54] Speaker 14: center functions. You know, we co let a seed round
[30:57] Speaker 14: at a twenty two point five million dollar valuation. In
[31:00] Speaker 14: less than three years, the company has valued at nearly
[31:02] Speaker 14: five billion dollars, and we've invested in every single round
[31:05] Speaker 14: and worked with them to build the business. I think
[31:07] Speaker 14: there are a number of examples like that where you
[31:10] Speaker 14: can do a lot with less capital and in fact
[31:12] Speaker 14: enforces discipline on the teams and the companies.
[31:15] Speaker 2: Decagoon founded by Jesse Jang and Ashri and Stream of Us.
[31:19] Speaker 2: I think I've been on this program Bennett's eeg or
[31:22] Speaker 2: Astar co founder, not enough time, but really interesting look
[31:25] Speaker 2: at that earlier stage of investing. Thank you very much.
[31:27] Speaker 2: Now coming up, we're going to speak with SAPCO Christian Klein.
[31:31] Speaker 2: There's the company debuts, it's autonomous enterprise platform, it's conversations.
[31:36] Speaker 4: Next, this is Doonberg Tech.
[31:40] Speaker 2: SAP has unveiled a new autonomous enterprise platform at this
[31:44] Speaker 2: year's SAP Sapphire Conference, expanding its push into AI agents
[31:49] Speaker 2: across business operations. Joining us now is SAP CEO Christian Client.
[31:54] Speaker 2: Let's start by stripping away the jargon. What is an
[31:57] Speaker 2: autonomous enterprise platform and what is it that your customers
[32:01] Speaker 2: can now do, Christian that they couldn't do before.
[32:05] Speaker 4: Yeah, thanks a lot. First of all, ed for having
[32:07] Speaker 4: me yesterday.
[32:08] Speaker 15: We launch the Autonomous Enterprise and we have record attendency
[32:12] Speaker 15: at Sapphire and I see only thousands of customers very
[32:15] Speaker 15: excited about the Autonomous Enterprise because we showed our customers
[32:19] Speaker 15: today that while the large language models are getting better
[32:22] Speaker 15: and better, they don't know anything about your business data
[32:26] Speaker 15: and your business processes. And as part of the autonomous
[32:29] Speaker 15: Enterprise is our new AI platform. And here we are
[32:32] Speaker 15: infusing the brain of every company, which is the EERP,
[32:35] Speaker 15: into the platform, so that the agents also not only
[32:38] Speaker 15: have the large language models, but also that they have
[32:41] Speaker 15: the context of how a company wants. And then on
[32:44] Speaker 15: top we had customers like eight and AM, JP Mong
[32:47] Speaker 15: Chase who have brewn that you know, with these agents
[32:50] Speaker 15: you can really deliver accurate, compland and reliable results.
[32:54] Speaker 6: Christian, how are you showing that productivity?
[32:58] Speaker 3: What sort of data, what sort of statistics you're able
[33:00] Speaker 3: to show your clients?
[33:02] Speaker 15: Actually we shottle together with JP Mong Chase that they
[33:05] Speaker 15: can close the books faster now by thirty percent.
[33:08] Speaker 4: We have shown with H and M that the turno.
[33:11] Speaker 15: In their commerce shop is now better because of our
[33:14] Speaker 15: personalized agent. We have shown that inventory god reduced by
[33:18] Speaker 15: ten percent because actually our agents work with each other
[33:21] Speaker 15: and the demand agent actually signaled the inventory agent, hey,
[33:25] Speaker 15: how to optimize and to how to optimize procurement. So
[33:29] Speaker 15: we really could also connect the story very well from
[33:32] Speaker 15: the front office into the fulfillment functions, which is the
[33:35] Speaker 15: power of SAP.
[33:38] Speaker 2: Very recently spoke to AWS CEO Matt Garman, an AWS
[33:42] Speaker 2: partner of SAPs, but they are also moving into this
[33:46] Speaker 2: exact domain. How much pressure you feel, in Christian to
[33:50] Speaker 2: offer this sort of encompassing agentic platform because if you don't,
[33:55] Speaker 2: someone else will.
[33:57] Speaker 4: Yeah, for sure.
[33:58] Speaker 15: But look, take AWS actually a great partner. I mean,
[34:01] Speaker 15: Matta and I talk regularly, and because you know, as
[34:04] Speaker 15: a matter of fact, not all data of the world
[34:07] Speaker 15: sits in SEP systems. And with AWS, we are now
[34:09] Speaker 15: partnering to also build a harmony data layer because of
[34:12] Speaker 15: course still agents they can't compensate for problem data modules.
[34:16] Speaker 15: And as part of our new SEP business aiplatform, we
[34:19] Speaker 15: also now harmonized data SAP non SEP data, and then
[34:23] Speaker 15: we've infused it into the agents, so we see AWS
[34:27] Speaker 15: Microsoft we had in Vitair. Here on stage we have
[34:29] Speaker 15: data break Snowflakes. They are all now joining our platform
[34:33] Speaker 15: to harmonize business data and these are the partnerships we
[34:36] Speaker 15: need to deliver highly ecoate AI.
[34:39] Speaker 3: Is it the accuracy that you think wins people over
[34:41] Speaker 3: from worrying that you're going to lose out competition? That's
[34:44] Speaker 3: the heart of where it's going, Like everyone's a frenemi,
[34:47] Speaker 3: but also the labs serious competition.
[34:49] Speaker 6: How do you fend off the software anxiety?
[34:52] Speaker 4: Caroline Exactly.
[34:53] Speaker 15: I guess the heart of the new platform is clearly
[34:55] Speaker 15: our contact layer, because the brain of every company is
[34:58] Speaker 15: the EERP. I mean, we have over seven point five
[35:01] Speaker 15: million data fields in there, we have thousands of business processes,
[35:04] Speaker 15: and that knowledge sits in our platform. And this is
[35:07] Speaker 15: clearly how the platform also can differentiate. You can use
[35:10] Speaker 15: any commodity LLM you want. People can bring their own
[35:13] Speaker 15: modules what they would like to use. But then on
[35:16] Speaker 15: the blootform, these agents immediately get the context what only
[35:20] Speaker 15: SEP has and that's our why to win, and that's
[35:23] Speaker 15: how SEP will differentiate.
[35:26] Speaker 2: Christian in Nvidia CEO Jens Munk's formula or equation is
[35:30] Speaker 2: very simple. More compute, more tokens, more revenues. Do you
[35:35] Speaker 2: have any case studies with customers where you can say
[35:38] Speaker 2: there's actual real revenues through the agentic work they've done
[35:42] Speaker 2: with SAP.
[35:43] Speaker 4: Yeah.
[35:43] Speaker 15: I had Chensen actually with me on the keynote today
[35:46] Speaker 15: and he clearly said he, of course, which is our
[35:49] Speaker 15: best luck first of all as a customer to SVP,
[35:51] Speaker 15: but the second obviously in order to get higher consumption
[35:54] Speaker 15: of compute and chips. I mean, you need consumption at
[35:57] Speaker 15: the top where the real value creation happens. And that's
[36:00] Speaker 15: why when we actually now can build an autonomous supply
[36:04] Speaker 15: chain for in Vitia. I mean they see this immediately
[36:06] Speaker 15: also in the hardware consumption. And this is where also
[36:08] Speaker 15: in Vita and SAP are partnering up to build the
[36:11] Speaker 15: autonomous enterprise.
[36:13] Speaker 3: Christian Klein of SAP Sapphire event, we very much appreciate
[36:17] Speaker 3: you joining from Florida.
[36:18] Speaker 6: Thank you.
[36:24] Speaker 3: Ford, and it's set to open a nearly three billion
[36:26] Speaker 3: dollar battery plant in Marshall, Michigan, bringing new manufacturing jobs.
[36:30] Speaker 6: An investment to the United States.
[36:31] Speaker 3: The facility will use technology though license from China's COATL
[36:35] Speaker 3: supplying LITHIUMAH and phosphate battery chemistry, an arrangement drawing some
[36:39] Speaker 3: scrutiny amid the US China attentions. This comes across as
[36:42] Speaker 3: President Trump heads to China this week for talks of
[36:44] Speaker 3: President using ping so joining us. We've got a roundtable
[36:46] Speaker 3: Niberg's Auto Report at Keith Norton and Senior Tech editor
[36:49] Speaker 3: Mike Shephard And Keith, I start with you, because what
[36:53] Speaker 3: is the relationship like between Ford and CAATL. Has it
[36:56] Speaker 3: been rosy throughout the ability to build out this manufacturing site.
[37:00] Speaker 10: Yeah.
[37:00] Speaker 16: CTL is in Marshall, Michigan right now, training workers, helping
[37:05] Speaker 16: get this plant off the ground. It's due to open
[37:08] Speaker 16: this year. Ford takes great pains to say it's fully
[37:12] Speaker 16: owned by Ford and the workers are employed by Ford.
[37:15] Speaker 16: It is just a licensing deal. But they've had a
[37:17] Speaker 16: good relationship to develop these lower cost LFP batteries that
[37:22] Speaker 16: are central to Ford's efforts to overhaul its EV strategy
[37:27] Speaker 16: and deploy more affordable evs in twenty twenty seven.
[37:32] Speaker 3: But Mike this relationship, though Rosie hasn't been particularly well
[37:37] Speaker 3: loved by some people in Michigan. But even and the
[37:40] Speaker 3: wholes of Congress, right, how has this been sitting The
[37:43] Speaker 3: sharing of technology between China and US giants?
[37:47] Speaker 17: Well, in general, there has been a lot of reluctance
[37:50] Speaker 17: to allow this kind of a partnership. Anything that remotely
[37:53] Speaker 17: touches on advanced technology immediately draws concerns from wawmakers here
[37:59] Speaker 17: in Washington who really fear the leakage of technology to China,
[38:03] Speaker 17: but also the potential leakage of data and other information
[38:08] Speaker 17: that could jeopardize US national security. And we have seen that,
[38:12] Speaker 17: of course in the battle over TikTok, and then more
[38:15] Speaker 17: recently we have seen this in terms of legislation at
[38:19] Speaker 17: the State level, and even introduced here at the national
[38:22] Speaker 17: level this week in Washington aimed at restricting Chinese purchases
[38:26] Speaker 17: of land and also investments in businesses here for those
[38:30] Speaker 17: verious security reasons. And it's important to know, Caro, that
[38:33] Speaker 17: COTL itself is the focus of some of those concerns.
[38:38] Speaker 17: The company in twenty twenty five was added to this
[38:40] Speaker 17: Pentagon list of companies that the US government believes support
[38:45] Speaker 17: China's military.
[38:47] Speaker 2: Keith, do you not have a great sense of deja vu?
[38:50] Speaker 2: Didn't you and I write about a COATL licensing deal
[38:53] Speaker 2: in twenty twenty three that Sections as a Republican Party
[38:57] Speaker 2: then said was a trojan horse.
[39:00] Speaker 4: Different.
[39:01] Speaker 16: Yeah, So there continues to be these concerns, as Mike
[39:04] Speaker 16: is saying about ties to the Chinese Commingist Party with CTL.
[39:09] Speaker 16: But here's the reality, Ed, you cannot pursue an EV
[39:13] Speaker 16: strategy without dealing with the Chinese. The Chinese control eighty
[39:17] Speaker 16: percent of the world's capacity for batteries, and that is
[39:21] Speaker 16: the most costly component of an electric vehicle. CATL has
[39:25] Speaker 16: half of that, So they're the battery giant that you
[39:29] Speaker 16: must deal with if you want to have an electric
[39:31] Speaker 16: vehicle strategy.
[39:33] Speaker 2: What that story at the time showed shep and became
[39:37] Speaker 2: true in the first few months of this administration was
[39:40] Speaker 2: there is a scale of China hawkishness right ranging from
[39:44] Speaker 2: we need complete access and work with China to let's
[39:48] Speaker 2: not do any business with China. And when the President
[39:50] Speaker 2: goes with that entourage with CEOs in the next twenty
[39:53] Speaker 2: four hours, that spectrum of hawkishness will also be a
[39:57] Speaker 2: part of the political story.
[40:00] Speaker 17: Well, it certainly will ed. We will see that follow
[40:03] Speaker 17: the delegation with the President. And these are the concerns
[40:07] Speaker 17: that's around the ability of China, for example, to purchase
[40:11] Speaker 17: advanced AI chips from Nvidia, and a notable absence of
[40:15] Speaker 17: courses noted early on the program is Nvidia's Jensen Wang
[40:19] Speaker 17: and also the Iran conflict itself will barge into these
[40:23] Speaker 17: talks and really perhaps restrain the ability of unfettered deal
[40:28] Speaker 17: making by some of these companies. They'll be looking for
[40:31] Speaker 17: smaller wins, perhaps in the Chinese market, and then we'll
[40:35] Speaker 17: come up the question, of course, of what can China
[40:38] Speaker 17: do for the US, which is what Donald Trump has
[40:40] Speaker 17: tried with other trading partners like Japan, South Korea, the
[40:44] Speaker 17: European Union, encouraging them to invest here in the US
[40:48] Speaker 17: as part of trade negotiations. The challenge is though reaching
[40:51] Speaker 17: some sort of a grand bargain with the US would
[40:54] Speaker 17: require much more complex talks on issues ranging from tariffs
[40:58] Speaker 17: to market access China, and then also the even more
[41:02] Speaker 17: sensitive question of rare earths and whether China would relax
[41:07] Speaker 17: its position in terms of handling the choke point that
[41:10] Speaker 17: it holds, the chokehold that it holds over those elements
[41:15] Speaker 17: that are critical to manufacturing in so many areas, including autos,
[41:19] Speaker 17: but across the economy, I mean.
[41:20] Speaker 3: Where US is where it's that when it comes to
[41:22] Speaker 3: battery technology. Keith and I go back in many ways
[41:25] Speaker 3: to market access, because with one breath you'll hear the
[41:28] Speaker 3: Ford CEO working on this relationship with the atl and
[41:32] Speaker 3: then the second best saying, but we don't want Chinese
[41:34] Speaker 3: main cars or auto's coming to the United States.
[41:36] Speaker 6: So that's something that's got to be balanced.
[41:39] Speaker 16: Exactly right, because the United States is still well behind
[41:42] Speaker 16: the Chinese and eb technology maybe a decade behind. And
[41:47] Speaker 16: of course the Chinese auto industry is supported by its government,
[41:50] Speaker 16: so they have lower costs. So Jim Farley, the CEO
[41:54] Speaker 16: of Ford, says, keep the Chinese out, but we also
[41:58] Speaker 16: value our partnerships with the Chinese.
[42:00] Speaker 5: We want to do more of them.
[42:02] Speaker 16: So yeah, it's a very fine line that they're treading here,
[42:05] Speaker 16: and they do need Chinese tech if they want to
[42:08] Speaker 16: have evs, but they also would be swamped by Chinese
[42:12] Speaker 16: competition if Chinese evs were allowed in For America.
[42:16] Speaker 2: Bloombergs Keith Norton and Bloomberg's Mike Shepherd, thank you very much. Okay,
[42:20] Speaker 2: before we go, let's take a look at today's big number.
[42:23] Speaker 2: One hundred and thirty five billion dollars. That's how much
[42:25] Speaker 2: Netflix says it has spent over the past decade making
[42:29] Speaker 2: films and TV shows in more than fifty countries. That's
[42:32] Speaker 2: a part of a new website called the Netflix Effect
[42:35] Speaker 2: that the company is using to show how it boosts
[42:38] Speaker 2: local economies. Netflix says the impact goes beyond direct employment.
[42:41] Speaker 2: For instance, highlighting how South Korea Caro sort of twenty
[42:45] Speaker 2: five percent spike in airline bookings.
[42:47] Speaker 3: I just think new film Nana and the Magician's Nephew
[42:50] Speaker 3: actually going to having a long run in theaters. How
[42:54] Speaker 3: Netflix is changing the game that does it though, for
[42:57] Speaker 3: this edition of Bloomberg Tech, a.
[42:59] Speaker 2: Big show ahead, a big remainder of the week. Don't
[43:01] Speaker 2: forget to check out the pod. That's where you can
[43:03] Speaker 2: find it. This is Bloomberg Tech.
[43:06] Speaker 7: M HM

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
