# Desplazamiento por violencia: un estado de cosas inconstitucional.

An episode of [Ciudadanos en acción](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1500968300), 7 Mar 2024, 31 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/58957629/podcast_5_estado_de_cosas_inconstitucional.mp3

La población más vulnerable dentro de la vulnerable”, así describe la Corte Constitucional a las víctimas de desplazamiento forzado por el conflicto armado en Colombia. Niños(as), madres, comunidades étnicas y campesinas hacen parte de los cuatro millones de personas afectadas por este tipo de desplazamiento. Lastimosamente la política pública de atención a esta población también ha sido un factor de vulneración de derechos, lo que llevó a la Sentencia T-025 de 2004 de la Corte Constitucional que declaró el estado de cosas inconstitucional en la materia. ¿Qué implica esto? ¿Cómo solucionar esta problemática que afecta a cerca del 10% de la población colombiana? ¡Escúchanos en Ciudadanos en Acción para conocer más sobre este importante fallo judicial!

## Transcript

[0:01] Hey. That is, citizens in action. In this podcast we propose to
[0:06] take the right to words that everyone can understand from anywhere At your own pace
[0:13] you will be able to know your rights and approach current issues from a legal
[0:17] perspective. Make yourself comfortable and listen to us on a radio rosary. All
[0:27] of the stones are looking at him breaking bones of the earth that complains,
[0:36] leaving hope invalid hello. I' m Mariana Ponte and, next to Maria
[0:46] Camila Saldaña and Esteban earlier. Today we have a mission to remind you that
[0:50] the right is from and for all, welcome and welcome from an uncontrollable cry
[0:58] of visceral pains. No line I don' t know hello. We start
[1:04] a new season of citizens in action. Let' s hear them witness so
[1:14] many goodbyes they saw those of the sea. There' s the sea Hello.
[1:17] As well, Mari, the truth excited to be here with you in
[1:22] the booth today talking about such an important issue for our cyber- obeyers for
[1:26] Colombia. I' d say, Maca, how are you, well,
[1:29] well, Mary, excited to deal with this subject that I find very interesting
[1:32] and that I feel it' s important that we all know. Well,
[1:34] today, as Maca said, we have a very interesting topic and it is
[1:38] that the Gap this month of March is going to be accompanying an initiative of
[1:44] remembrance of the sentence zero twenty- five of two thousand four, that this
[1:49] month turns twenty years old. It has been since the Court issued a super
[1:57] - important lecture to him, and that is why we want to initiate this
[2:00] initiative of remembrance. Talking a little bit about what the state of things is
[2:04] unconstitutional and a little bit focused on the state that was specifically stated in that
[2:07] sentence. To this end we will have the accompaniment of the assistant teacher of
[2:15] the Constitutional Court, Juan Jacobo Calderón, who even when he could not accompany
[2:19] us in the cabin, helped us with a little knowledge about the ey because
[2:25] it is important, because it is important specifically the one that was declared in
[2:30] the third twenty- five, et cetera. So, to start with the
[2:34] podcast, let' s talk a little bit about what is the state of
[2:37] things in constitutional? Well Mari So, the unconstitutional state of affairs is a
[2:42] figure that takes place when there have been four situations. The first is a
[2:46] massive and recurring violation of the fundamental rights of a certain population. The other
[2:51] is, when there are general problems, usually linked to the lack of compliance
[2:55] of certain authorities with their legal and constitutional obligations. Individual guardianships are often not
[3:01] useful, because it gives the seriousness and the magnitude and the violation of human
[3:06] rights, it is impossible to protect them in large sections of the population through
[3:10] individual sentences and already the perfect general malca measures. I feel like this gives
[3:15] us a foothold Let' s say it sounds pretty technical, all of a
[3:17] sudden. Listeners have not yet been able to understand what this figure means,
[3:22] which is precisely why we bring our expert' s words to suddenly give us
[3:25] more light around this. How to define the figure of the unconstitutional state of
[3:32] things. This is a complex figure that is generally related to so- called
[3:45] structural judgements. These are judgements through which the courts, I mean the structural
[3:55] ones, intend to adopt or attempt to adopt corrective measures in order to deal
[4:04] with serious and structural violations of fundamental rights in particular, but one could also
[4:18] say to address violations of constitutional rights. Well, and those were the words
[4:30] of our expert and also to complement what he has already said for the rapporteur
[4:36] of the judgment we are commemorating today. This is a figure that allows the
[4:42] Court to go beyond law, that is, to act in situations of reality,
[4:45] that is, it would not be judged to be a legal act,
[4:48] but as a reality and is designed as an evolution of the tutelage action that
[4:55] we already know because of the gravity of these massive violations of human rights.
[5:00] What we really realize is that the State of Things and the Constitution is a
[5:02] term used by the Constitutional Court to define and declare situations of very large human
[5:10] rights violations that come to affect a large population or a specific population. So
[5:15] what we see is that precisely the declaration of such a State gives rise to
[5:19] a fairly broad set of orders that are intended to link multiple entities or actors
[5:26] that are suddenly involved with the issue in order to achieve a structural solution.
[5:32] It is understood, as my cabinmate, María Camila, well says, that
[5:35] what happens is that if only one specific case was isolated, this problem could
[5:40] not be solved. That' s why it looks like a structural issue.
[5:45] Of course and that' s precisely why the actions of your cloth are already
[5:48] serving us. And that is why the court, even when this sentence is
[5:50] entered into the tea that is generally known as the ones before your cloth,
[5:55] these are given in places where the tutelaries no longer if they see, because,
[6:00] given the gravity and magnitude of the violation of human rights and in addition
[6:04] to the constitutional facts and in addition to the number of people affected by the
[6:09] problem, they have to go into taking structural measures. And now I believe
[6:13] that an important clarity, that is, if we do not talk about guardianship
[6:15] that, for our service listeners who suddenly do not know much about these issues,
[6:20] protection of fundamental rights. We understand fundamental rights as those most important to
[6:25] the individual. We talk about the right to participation, the right to life,
[6:29] the right to health. But not only can a state of unconstitutional things
[6:32] be declared around these issues. It can also be declared against other rights called
[6:38] economic, social and cultural rights. These rights have a special characteristic, which
[6:44] is that, as such, they are not achieved by mere action, but
[6:47] are rights that, over time, the State is going to allocate resources for
[6:50] the realization and improvement of its guarantee for the population. An example of this,
[6:58] so that it is not as ethereal, let' s say the prison
[7:01] population, as we talked about in a previous podcast, Let' s say
[7:05] a state of things and constitutional around this population was declared by virtue of two
[7:08] things. On the one hand, some fundamental rights were being violated, such
[7:12] as access to health, to decent treatment, but other economic, social and
[7:15] cultural rights were also being violated. So, in that sense, we see
[7:21] that the constitutional state of affairs, especially in the subject that brings us here
[7:25] today in the booth, because it can be given by the violation of these
[7:28] two types of rights and I feel that this gives them the skin to speak
[7:33] precisely about another subject and is the origin precisely of the constitutional state of affairs.
[7:36] This originates in the 1990s, when for the first time it is declared
[7:41] and so, what happens here is that we basically begin to understand that when
[7:46] there is an accumulation of processes that are taking place for the same cause,
[7:49] because the Court pronounces itself on this matter by declaring in certain cases a State
[7:55] of things and constitutional. That is to say, you will realize that there
[7:58] are many wards, for example, that they pronounce themselves on the same subject,
[8:01] as happened at the time, for example, with the state of affairs
[8:07] and constitutional, with the prison population, and what was decided was to declare
[8:11] this state to take structural measures, which is to solve the problem in a
[8:16] systematic way. Well, they go there to complement you, because the most
[8:20] impressive thing that figure is that it was developed jurisprudentially by our Constitutional Court It
[8:26] is creation in Colombian power, so to speak, and to the extent that
[8:28] it does not have a point of reference either in the Constitution or in the
[8:31] Law. And what it does is that it takes the reality of the facts
[8:33] and from there it is effectively determined, as the Court is understood as the
[8:41] guardian of the Constitution, it is she who orders a series of immediate actions
[8:46] and, as this one was saying, they will do a structural time to
[8:50] deal with this situation. And these orders can only be resolved within the framework
[8:54] of a public policy. Why, because it is such a serious issue that
[8:58] it embraces the action of many entities. It is not a single entity issue,
[9:01] but many have to articulate all their actions and competences in order to cope
[9:05] with the situation and even overcome it. We must also, therefore, before
[9:13] introducing them, because it is important this state of inconstitutional thing that, moreover,
[9:18] as María Camila said, was a Colombian creation. Let' s tell
[9:24] them what our expert gave us about their importance. The unconstitutional state of affairs
[9:33] finds that the violation of rights has been the result of the failure of the
[9:39] State authorities to perform their functions in budgetary matters, in organizational matters, in
[9:48] the adoption of specific measures, in the area of monitoring. Finally and then,
[9:56] it allows the authorities to find that they are not aware of the powers
[10:03] or that they are in breach of their obligations to protect rights. Judicial control
[10:07] powers are activated in a corresponding manner, with the aim of demanding the fulfilment
[10:18] of those powers in order to guarantee rights. And this is done in a
[10:24] structural way, that is, by linking different branches of power. It can
[10:30] be linked to the executive branch, the executive branch and the legislative branch,
[10:33] including by taking measures related to control bodies. And this has the consequence that
[10:46] its use has allowed to transform the approach to some social problems. Precisely as
[10:56] our expert said, the state of cousincussional is super important because, in one
[11:01] way or another, it brings to the public eye and draws attention to a
[11:05] subject that requires urgent attention. Then, on the one hand, it sows
[11:11] the national political debate on this issue and, in one way or another,
[11:16] it fosters dialogue between the Court of Authorities, academia and social organizations. This
[11:20] is in order to develop public policies that can deal with the problem and that
[11:24] can solve this problem, which, as we have already mentioned, is structural.
[11:33] Well, and here we also bring some examples of this declaratory. In
[11:37] Colombia, we have cases such as social security for officials, prison overcrowding,
[11:43] inadequate protection of defenders, human rights and the right to health. Let us
[11:50] say precisely this gives us the opportunity to introduce the sentence that we have come
[11:54] to speak today, which is that it deals precisely with the state of constitutional
[12:00] affairs in matters of forced displacement due to the armed conflict. I really feel
[12:03] that this is a theme that resonates for many of the cyber listeners, for
[12:07] us to can booths in one way or another, and it is that really
[12:11] a large percentage of the Colombian population has been affected by this type of displacement
[12:16] And it is interesting to see that the Court has pronounced itself around a declaration
[12:20] of state of affairs and constitutional regarding the public policy that has been managed to
[12:24] care precisely for this population that, as we are going to see today is
[12:28] a highly vulnerable population and that the State, let us say, has not
[12:33] attended to it with open hands, as it should have happened, but that
[12:39] precisely this population has been found with the series of obstacles that led to the
[12:41] Court having to pronounce itself on it. Yes, before we begin with the
[12:48] subject of the sentence itself, it is necessary to bear in mind that,
[12:50] when the Court declares a state of affairs in constitutional, it follows up on
[12:54] the subject to say whether to lift it or not. And, for example,
[12:58] in this specific case that brings us here today to the third twenty-
[13:01] five, where they declared the state of affairs institutional with regard to internal forced
[13:05] displacement, the Court has not been able to lift the state of affairs to
[13:09] this day. This means that the Court continues to follow up on these issues
[13:13] through public hearings to this day. And, moreover, this implies that,
[13:18] considering that the hundredth was two thousand four, we are already in two thousand
[13:20] twenty, twenty years. In twenty years, the State has not been able
[13:24] to articulate its public policy in such a way that the Court can say so.
[13:30] We rise because the structural violation of the rights of displaced persons has already
[13:35] ceased well. And so now let us understand a little bit the context of
[13:41] the sentence and that is what were the facts that led to this good sentence.
[13:45] This ruling arises from the accumulation of one hundred and eight cloths basically,
[13:48] that is, about one hundred and fifty families who argued the lack of protection
[13:54] of the State on various issues. Many of these fabrics have already been rejected
[14:00] many times arguing many things, but one of the most impressive arguments is that
[14:03] even entities should be expected to be sufficiently resourced to provide subsidies to these populations.
[14:11] So let' s say that' s what the court is went into
[14:15] studying during these sentences and you said it. Me. I think one of
[14:18] the most interesting issues in this ruling is to talk about the issue of resources,
[14:22] because it seems that in the country the excuse of the authorities often ends
[14:26] up being a lack of resources. What we are going to see here is
[14:30] that there are precisely a number of principles that guide these issues because of their
[14:35] importance for the rights of individuals and groups as particularly vulnerable as is the case
[14:39] of forcibly and forcibly displaced persons. So, excuse me, E, let
[14:46] ' s say we have to assume that remedy. One cannot, let us
[14:48] say, excuse authority by saying that there is no one, but that it
[14:52] is precisely the availability of the national budget that has to be generated. Let
[14:56] us say in this sense, it is important to understand what kind of population
[15:01] we are talking about who we understand are sheltered by the term forced displaced persons.
[15:05] In this sense, there is a law, the law three hundred and
[15:07] eighty- seven and one thousand nine hundred and ninety- seven, which in
[15:11] its first article defines us is displaced. Any person who has been forced to
[15:15] migrate within the national territory by leaving his habitual place of residence or economic activities,
[15:22] because his life, physical integrity, security or personal freedoms have been violated
[15:26] or are directly threatened. And here' s what happens is that they stand
[15:33] out. Let' s say a few examples. Among them is the issue
[15:35] of internal armed conflict. So let' s say all this gives us the
[15:41] opportunity for the vulnerability situation faced by these groups. Let' s say highlight
[15:48] and it' s very interesting to see that in these forced displaced groups we
[15:54] don' t just find people in abstract. Not only do we have groups
[15:58] of people who are displaced, but there are a number of particular situations at
[16:00] the heart of these groups that are living and generating a situation of vulnerability.
[16:06] Let' s say more latent. Of course, this subject that Esteban is
[16:11] talking about is called an intersectional approach. Intersectionality occurs when in the same person,
[16:18] to put it another way, a number of characteristics converge that make it
[16:25] more vulnerable. So, for example, a person who is in a condition
[16:30] of displacement is a person who is vulnerable. This intersectionality goes active at the
[16:33] moment when suddenly it is displaced. In addition, she is a woman who,
[16:38] because she is a woman, already has certain characteristics that make her more
[16:42] vulnerable than now. Suddenly she' s also a mother, head of the
[16:45] family, who, etcetera. So what Esteban was telling us is precisely that.
[16:52] The displaced population, besides being vulnerable as such inside it has a number
[16:56] of subjects and people who are through other situations, which make them even more
[17:03] vulnerable and, in addition, allow the violation of their rights to be even
[17:11] more serious. Precisely because of all the characteristics that went through them. And
[17:17] you said so, say, in the forced displaced group there are many examples,
[17:21] women, sometimes from families, children and adolescents, including ethnic populations that
[17:26] have been affected and even the peasants themselves are considered by some court rulings to
[17:30] be of special protection. So we understand that not only do we say by
[17:37] virtue of their status, whether economic or of age or gender of ethnicity,
[17:41] they already have in themselves a factor that makes them vulnerable, but, moreover,
[17:45] by being displaced, they increase to vulnerability and are subjected, as Mari
[17:48] says, to situations that can be mainly affected in the enjoyment and enjoyment of
[17:52] their rights. In this regard, it is also important to bear in mind
[17:59] that, while displaced persons are treated as a group as such, they are
[18:04] treated equally with respect to the displacement they suffered, not all of them are
[18:10] the same, because they are not all affected by the same circumstances of vulnerability.
[18:15] And that is precisely why the Court often takes care in such tutelage to
[18:18] look at such circumstances, which make them even more vulnerable in addition to being
[18:22] displaced. So, what we were saying, children and adolescents, women,
[18:27] mothers, heads of households, people who belong to ethnic peasants and adopt a
[18:33] series of so to speak, corrective measures to confront this displacement and those other
[18:41] characteristics that are more vulnerable to them. Well, and then, already coming
[18:45] in as a little bit more on the subject, what are these violated rights
[18:48] that lead to declaring a state of things unconstitutional. Among these rights we find
[18:55] several: dignified life, personal integrity, equality, petition, work under health,
[19:00] social security, education and special protections for vulnerable groups, as our cabin
[19:06] mates had already been told, for let us say that if we say here
[19:11] it is very important and personally I steal the word. It is important to
[19:17] realize that they are almost a fairly broad list of rights, which shows us
[19:21] precisely that sometimes one would think that these populations are being subjected. Let'
[19:26] s just say a certain kind of circumstance that affects your rights, but that
[19:30] really goes way beyond what one could calculate. This was precisely what one hundred
[19:34] and fifteen families presented to the Court at the time and that, at the
[19:37] time of analysis, let us say the judges at the time all these files,
[19:42] since they saw that there was a plurality of rights that generated a massive
[19:45] violation. Let' s say the constitutional guarantees these people had. Exactly,
[19:51] as we specifically told you at the start of the podcasts, we talked very
[19:56] generally about what results in the state of things being declared and if we say
[19:59] that it was massive rape, that this violation is due to problems of a
[20:03] general type, that the utelas already serve us because of the severity of the
[20:08] impact on rights and because AMAS is affecting many people and because general measures are
[20:11] needed. But then, now it' s time to tell you what happened
[20:17] in the third twenty- five and why the Court considered that it resulted in
[20:22] declaring the state of things unconstitutional and it was because a number of criteria were
[20:27] met and let' s say there I would like to, because it'
[20:30] s a pretty technical issue. There are six criteria that were addressed by the
[20:33] judgement. Let' s say, we want to get you listeners in the
[20:37] most digestible way, so that you understand the complexity of the matter then.
[20:41] First of all, we are talking about a massive and widespread violation of constitutional
[20:45] rights, as we now present to you a list of almost ten rights that
[20:49] were addressed in the judgment. In addition, we find that a prolonged omission
[20:53] by the authorities of their obligations. In other words, there are not only
[20:59] rights, but the authorities have duties in respect of these rights. And what
[21:03] is happening is that precisely they omit to fulfill them, they omit precisely to
[21:07] bring them to reality. And this is what leads the situation to endure time.
[21:11] And finally, a lack of legislative, administrative or even budgetary measures,
[21:15] that is to say, on economic issues, to effectively protect these rights exactly
[21:22] the other three criteria, because, as this one mentioned at the beginning,
[21:26] there are six that led to this state of affairs being clarified. It'
[21:33] s just good. For example, in these cases, the adoption of a
[21:37] thing that the Court calls unconstitutional practices was taking place. So, in the
[21:41] judgment, the Court says that they found that many of the entities that had
[21:45] to care for the displaced were incorporating the guardianship action as part of the procedure
[21:49] to be able to access that. What does it mean that the displaced person,
[21:55] in order to have access to the service he provided to the entity regarding
[21:59] his situation of displaced person, told them how first you put a tutelage on
[22:06] me and then I, if I am going to do what I am entitled
[22:08] to, then here was the adoption of institutional practices. In addition, other
[22:11] criteria were that, as we mentioned initially, there are many people who were
[22:18] affected by displacement, which implies that if all the people affected by displacement came
[22:22] to take action, that would be the only thing that was going to cause
[22:26] was greater judicial oversight and, therefore, no solution was going to be found.
[22:30] And the last criterion was that, just as it was a social and
[22:33] structural problem, it implies the intervention of several entities in order to articulate a
[22:38] national public policy that could finally address this very complex and so serious situation.
[22:45] What does that mean? It means that many entities needed to adopt a complex
[22:49] and coordinated set of actions, which also implies not only the coordination of the
[22:55] entities, but also that the Government or the Nation as such allocates a number
[23:00] of resources to be able to cope with this situation and create public policy.
[23:06] Well and there I very much rescue what you say and highlighted the importance of
[23:11] this principle of coordination among all the entities that make up the state. This
[23:15] must be what it would be like to seek, as if these realities were
[23:22] to be changed, the realities that are contradicted by the Constitution and that is
[23:26] a structural strategy that will lead to the real change of these realities so that
[23:32] they will stop violating human rights. And so let' s say I feel
[23:34] that this whole theoretical framework leads us to understand what was the scope of the
[23:38] solutions presented by the Constitutional Court at the time, as our compañera Mariana said
[23:42] at the beginning. One of the most interesting features of this judgment was that
[23:48] jurisdiction was assumed once the sentence was pronounced to follow up on it. That
[23:55] is, the Court ordered such entities a series of orders and what it began
[24:00] to do over time and during these twenty years has continued to happen is to
[24:03] analyze how these orders have been executed by each of the entities involved, precisely
[24:07] connecting also with the principle of coordination. It is understood that each of the
[24:12] orders could not be understood as isolated, but had to be integrated in order,
[24:18] in fact, to establish a structural solution that would elaborate this policy,
[24:26] let us say Macro, that would address this problem in the most comprehensive way
[24:30] possible and that would allow us to say all the actors, such as civil
[24:34] society, international organizations, the same academy, with the universities, but especially
[24:40] the public entities, to assume the challenge of effectively ending this future problem.
[24:45] Then let us remember that at the beginning we told them that the current unconstitutional
[24:51] state of affairs regarding internal forced displacement has not been lifted. In other words,
[24:53] the Court has not considered that the situation has ceased. That is precisely
[24:56] why, in the context of the hearings which we were talking about and which
[25:00] this group was saying very well right now, the Court continued to follow up
[25:04] on the situation and has now issued more than 100 follow- up orders on
[25:10] the subject of displacement. And that is precisely why, today, twenty years
[25:14] after the Court declared the state of affairs and that it has not yet risen
[25:15] and that the situation still persists, we ask our expert what could be said
[25:23] about the progress that has been made in the face of the orders that the
[25:29] sentence handed down during these twenty years, that the main ones. Let'
[25:38] s say breakthroughs, let' s say verifiable. Thus, the problem of
[25:41] displaced persons was raised. In the first place, let' s say from
[25:49] the public agenda and that after this, a process of construction or reformulation or
[25:57] refinement of the Bulgarian policy has begun based on the idea of rights and the
[26:04] actual enjoyment indices of them and different dimensions have developed. Displacement against women,
[26:17] displacement against children, displacement against specially protected groups, to technically differentiated communities.
[26:33] And although someone might say that I have been in the state of affairs for
[26:40] a long time without stating what has been overtaken, the truth is that,
[26:45] in the face of such a complex structural problem mediated by the acute problems of
[26:55] violence in our country, let us say, progress can always be short.
[26:56] But from the point of view of the understanding of the phenomenon and the adoption
[27:03] of concrete measures to overcome it, in order to overcome it forgiveness, great
[27:11] and important progress has been made. I believe that the Court' s challenge
[27:18] is how progress should be made to further advance the overcoming of all orders given.
[27:33] And this is further reflected in other unconstitutional States where similar difficulties arise.
[27:48] Well, and then with what our expert has just told us, there we
[27:51] highlight the importance of what he was telling us to take into account these sectors
[27:56] of multi- vulnerable populations, such as children, women, people of African
[28:02] descent. And, therefore, a comprehensive public policy is needed that will covet
[28:07] various sectors and also take into account the structuring of differential programmes to address these
[28:12] populations as well not only as a programme of assistance to victims of forced displacement,
[28:19] but what our country really needs is a comprehensive humanitarian plan that addresses all
[28:25] these problems of displaced persons, of the multi- vulnerable sectors and takes into
[28:33] account the number of people involved. And so, indeed, I feel that
[28:37] this is a perfect, perfect conclusion for today' s podcast leads us to
[28:41] rethink how this issue has been addressed from the centre of the public agenda,
[28:45] how, indeed, it is already understood as a structural issue that is addressed
[28:49] from the plurality of actors, not only are public actors, but also private
[28:53] actors, and that all this is the path that will really lead us to
[28:57] materialize the commitments that they made with the Peace Agreement to bring comprehensive peace to
[29:02] the Colombian people, because a robust public policy that really takes into account all
[29:07] these variables would not be exactly possible. It is that even when the declaration
[29:11] is now twenty years old and has not yet risen, that does not mean
[29:15] that it has not progressed, as our expert said. That doesn' t
[29:21] mean we haven' t had any improvements. That does not mean that the
[29:25] state is not building public policy. What it means is that the situation persists
[29:29] and that we all somehow have the duty to keep working for this and that
[29:33] it is a subject that is not over, that even when suddenly one does
[29:37] not feel so close suddenly one feels that it is something that still exists.
[29:41] There is still, on the basis of the point that internal forced displacement is
[29:44] not only because of armed conflict, but also because it has a totally multi
[29:49] - causal phenomenon. So this is the space to remember that we still,
[29:55] as a country, have a debt to the displaced and also, to understand
[29:59] that it is not only with those who have been displaced for complicating more,
[30:03] but also with those of other causes. Thank you very much. Dear listeners
[30:06] for tuning us in today follow us on our social networks, the GAP and
[30:11] Rosario Radio, so you don' t miss any episode. I have the
[30:15] sun and the rain that bathes me an intoxicating desert with neck of a drink
[30:19] of pulque to sing with the coyotes. Everything that happened to us. I
[30:25] have my lungs breathing clear blue the hard ones that are few. This was
[30:32] citizens in action. In this podcast we set out to bring the right to
[30:38] the words that we can all understand. We hear each other in an upcoming episode.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
