# Acciones Populares: una mirada desde la silla del juez

An episode of [Ciudadanos en acción](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1500968300), 2 May 2024, 30 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/59774350/ciudadanos_en_accion_acciones_populares.mp3

En compañía del Dr. Roberto Augusto Serrato, exmagistrado del Consejo de Estado, abordamos desde la perspectiva del juez por qué la acción popular resulta el mecanismo idóneo para la defensa de los derechos colectivos. En una guía esencial para comprender y actuar en pro de la justicia socioambiental, exploramos la naturaleza preventiva y correctiva de esta acción destacando su importancia en la protección del interés público. La discusión lograda busca generar conciencia sobre la relevancia de este mecanismo para la sociedad, en un mundo cambiante donde la protección de los derechos medioambientales y la resolución de problemas colectivos se hacen cada vez más necesarios. ¡Conoce con nosotros esta herramienta procesal y su vital papel de cara a las problemáticas actuales!

## Transcript

[0:01] Hey. That is, citizens in action. In this podcast we propose and
[0:06] now the right to words that everyone can understand from anywhere At your own pace
[0:12] you will be able to know your rights and approach current issues from a legal
[0:17] perspective. Make yourself comfortable and listen to us on a Rosario Radio. Good
[0:31] morning, everyone. My name is Esteban Rato and there today we greet him
[0:34] from the international Book Fair in Bogotá, nothing more and nothing less than of
[0:38] film from the están I must Rosario Radio and we are in company today of
[0:42] my cabin companions, Donna María Muñoz, María Camila Saldaña and Angel López.
[0:47] Today I love to say today' s edition because we bring you a very
[0:52] special episode that, as we tell you, we are in the framework of
[0:54] the International Book Fair, and for this we bring a very special guest to
[0:58] address a very important topic for us as a legal cenica, and it is
[1:00] the theme of popular actions or follow us on our social networks, such as
[1:15] GAP, a rosary and a radio rosary. To enrich this discussion we will
[1:26] have the participation of a very prominent guest, Dr Roberto Serrat. He is
[1:33] a former magistrate of the first section of the Star Council, as we welcome
[1:40] our guest. I don' t even know if he wants to give us
[1:42] a few opening words soon. Nothing, very good morning to everyone and everyone.
[1:48] It is an honor for me to be able to accompany the GAPP,
[1:53] a group that has been consolidating itself in the defense of collective rights with a
[1:59] very high recognition in the Jewish forum and all my applause and appreciation for the
[2:04] important work that they have been doing in defense of the interests of the collectivity
[2:07] and nothing. The pleasure is all ours. I think I speak for everyone
[2:10] when I say that really for us, as a legal clinic, it is
[2:15] very important precisely the popular sections and it is very interesting to have someone who,
[2:19] from the perspective of a judge of Unix judge of the Council of State,
[2:22] can bring us some light on this issue. Let' s say to
[2:23] explain to our listeners. Something interesting is what the popular sections are and precisely
[2:28] we talk about actions that, let' s say, touch on issues that
[2:34] reach us all. They are those issues that are precisely related to the public
[2:38] interest and that, therefore, within the framework of our legal clinic, what
[2:39] we do is to carry out processes that are related to various issues that affect
[2:45] us all as a collective. Indeed, they go to you and for our
[2:49] hibers you try to be wondering what the public interest is. Well, let
[2:53] ' s refer to this, by its nature, as an issue that involves
[2:57] us all. And that' s where it comes to the end of collective
[3:00] rights, which is what we all possess. As is the case with the
[3:04] environment, healthy to the optimal infrastructure of public services and protect the national cultural
[3:08] heritage, among others. And having made this introduction, we would like to
[3:14] start this space with our guest asking him what is the scope of popular action
[3:19] for the defense of collective rights and, in that sense, how he addresses
[3:23] cases of violations of these rights. All right, I' d like to
[3:29] start by going back to the way the political constitution deals with the subject Look.
[3:32] Our Constitution is identified as a constitution that is responsible for protecting the rights
[3:38] of individuals and for that purpose, the great novelty that it brings is to
[3:45] create a series of mechanisms for the protection of those rights. Almost always in
[3:49] citizenship, it identifies guardianship as the reference point for achieving this goal. However,
[3:55] what one finds from the magistracy of that of the one administration of justice
[4:00] is that through popular actions a very important dynamic is also achieved in the guarantee
[4:05] and effectiveness of human rights, in this case, not of the individual,
[4:11] but of the large collectivities. And that is the great plus that these protection
[4:17] mechanisms have, as you noted in detail, they serve to protect collective rights
[4:24] and interests. They are not even required to be threatened until there is contingent
[4:30] damage. This is what is known as even if injury has not materialized.
[4:36] In any case, the mechanism of popular action can proceed. In other words,
[4:42] we find ourselves, as I have referred to it so many times before
[4:46] the jewel of the crown along with the tutelage. Popular action is a tremendously
[4:49] effective mechanism for the citizenry to use it to demonstrate it and try to generate
[4:58] the protection not of an individual right, but of the collective. And that
[5:04] ' s its great value. Attachment ready. Thank you very much, because
[5:11] we rescued very much that I did of how to protect the collectivity and that,
[5:16] therefore, helps us as well as having the tutelage to know as these
[5:20] mechanisms that also help us as to understand that we are all part of a
[5:24] society and that, therefore, we can defend the rights of all. And
[5:26] with this we wanted to ask you why popular action is considered to be a
[5:30] judicial mechanism of a preventive and corrective nature and how this feature can be included
[5:35] in the protection and guarantee of collective rights that I am going to ask.
[5:40] Little is known about the fact that a mechanism for the protection of rights such
[5:45] as that of popular action serves for eventualities that have not even caused harm,
[5:51] that is, that in the mere expectation of injury the constituent in this figure
[5:57] and then what it means and translates is that there does not need to be
[6:02] a consolidated damage in the face of the mere expectation that such an affectation will
[6:10] occur in the future. We already have a preventive scenario where this special and
[6:15] valuable mechanism is validated. It will also make it clear that the other eventuality
[6:21] has caused damage to a collective right and what makes popular action clear. The
[6:27] sentencing judge is trying to correct and try to bring things back to their original
[6:31] state if that is possible. Therefore, what is known in the judicial world,
[6:36] such as restitution, or seeing things to their original state, is produced.
[6:41] If this is not possible, then it generates the possibility of opening up,
[6:46] the alternative possibility, to compensate economically the damages caused to the entity that
[6:53] is in charge of the protection of the right. As you see, it
[6:57] is a very wide range that offers this figure of popular actions to anyone who
[7:02] wants to present the demands. I want to highlight something that sometimes goes unnoticed,
[7:08] but it is the backbone of this figure and it has no expiry date.
[7:15] I must tell you that when the popular action takes place, what happens
[7:18] through the l four hundred and seventy- two of the ninety- eight,
[7:23] the first regulation pointed out that it should be attempted five years after the occurrence
[7:28] of the action or the omission generating the damage that affected the collectivity, the
[7:33] Constitutional Court, in a historical judgment, in the c two hundred and fifteen
[7:39] of a thousand nine hundred ninety- nine was precise in indicating that this norm
[7:44] was unconstitutional and what then enabled the use of this mechanism at any time,
[7:48] and that is very important for the collectivity to know, know and use it.
[7:53] And let' s say I feel that there are just a few interesting
[7:58] elements that I' d like to explain soon. In other words, this
[8:00] civir listeners. An interesting one is the subject of expiration. What we say
[8:03] our guest explains is precisely that it is that possibility that a person has to
[8:07] go to the judge and, at any time of time, to file an
[8:11] application. And this is precisely what we do in the legal clinic, and
[8:16] that is that we are face- to- face. Let us say to
[8:20] vulnerable communities that do not know their rights and often say in the face of
[8:24] a scenario of affectation to their environment, to their public health service or so
[8:28] on, let us say possible variables of collective rights are faced with a lack
[8:33] of knowledge in which they are precisely entitled to certain minimum conditions of those services,
[8:39] but that, if we do not know, they do not know when
[8:39] or how to go to the judge. What implies that they do not have
[8:41] any lapses is that at any moment of time they can do so by bringing
[8:46] before the judge all the facts and evidence that they can carry to say that
[8:50] the matter of substance is decided, and it is a very, very interesting
[8:56] matter that, precisely taking into account the guaranteeing aim pursued by this action and
[9:01] the protection of rights, the law prevents a special procedural procedure that is extremely
[9:09] important for the community, but in practice we can say that all judges give
[9:15] this good treatment. It is important to note that the process of popular action
[9:18] for a judicial official must have the impression that it is preferred, that is,
[9:26] that any management society to a demand for popular action obliges the judicial authority
[9:31] to process it more accurately than the other demands it has in its office.
[9:39] And this obviously makes a significant difference. Anyway, I have to say this
[9:46] all of a sudden. It' s a bit technical, but it'
[9:48] s very important that you know it' s an autonomous action. Therefore,
[9:50] I could present a popular action. So there is a contractual dispute which the
[9:58] two parties to the dispute have formulated, or I can bring a popular action.
[10:03] Thus it has been sued in nullity of the administrative act against which I
[10:09] manifest a nonconformity as an individual subject. That then generates an amplitude of tremendously
[10:15] important coverage for citizenship. Look at Law fourteen thirty- seven, which is
[10:22] the code of procedure and administrative litigation, because in its article one hundred and
[10:26] forty- four it is very expensive to point out this novelty and it seems
[10:31] to me that it is very valuable for the citizenry to know it. In
[10:35] other words, in the form of a synthesis, it is only above the
[10:41] process of a popular action, the guardianship mechanism, which must be resolved within
[10:46] ten days. Everything else has to wait until the pronouncement of the sentence of
[10:50] popular action is seen you look at the value. I have a practical question
[10:56] and that is to say in our litigation experience, then we find that a
[11:01] surplus of yours can last for years without resolution and what we end up doing
[11:05] is that we present procedural taxes and so on, what is the message that
[11:09] could leave us this and face a legality that is sometimes on paper, but
[11:13] that is not seen in practice. Well, really, what happens when in
[11:18] the legislation it is so precise to point out a preferential procedure to this type
[11:22] of mechanism. The judicial authority is being given an early warning, a bell,
[11:28] a bell in the sense of either you fulfill these terms, or it
[11:33] has a problem of what kind of disciplinary nature. Often the person does not
[11:39] like to report to the judicial authority because he or she is omitting the performance
[11:43] of his or her duties. However, the message that I want to convey
[11:46] is that the next one does not need to denounce it. Remember that in
[11:50] all administrative litigation proceedings the Public Prosecutor' s Office is always present through a
[11:58] specialist prosecutor. It is on the subject that, in the terms of an
[12:01] article, he knows. Let me mention it. Article three hundred and three
[12:05] must be notified of any self- admittance of popular action. One can ask
[12:11] that attorney to generate an impulse of action through his requests as an agent of
[12:15] the Public Prosecutor' s Office. There is an alternative figure that also let
[12:20] me tell you can be useful and it is the request for a special surveillance
[12:26] by the Higher Council of the Judiciary, which dynamizes that judge or that magistrate
[12:31] who is making omissive in the performance of his duties and through this request,
[12:37] believe me that the mechanism of impulse of these prostitutional actions has been very effective.
[12:45] OK and taking into account this that you mention, then we want to
[12:48] address a little bit the particular procedural features of the People' s Action and
[12:54] with that we wanted to ask the question of what instruments the People' s
[12:58] Action has to ensure an effective fulfillment of its purpose to repair and avoid harm
[13:03] to collective rights and interests? And with this we can soon mention some of
[13:07] these particularities, such as the precautionary means, the tests of physics. That
[13:11] ' s a good question, that' s a good question for me.
[13:16] I must begin by pointing out that normally the person filing a lawsuit collects that
[13:24] he estimates that his protection of the law will be achieved only when a sentence
[13:28] is handed down. However, what lawmakers have been doing lately is to strengthen
[13:33] the mechanism of precautionary measures. The precautionary measures are constructed to guarantee the object
[13:43] of the proceedings and the effectiveness of the sentence on a provisional basis, in
[13:48] such a way that in those contexts where there appears to be a good right,
[13:52] where the process we know is going to take a long time, what
[13:56] the person can do is ask the judge to order a precautionary measure through protection
[14:01] through which that right of that guarantee is protected. It has a truly significant
[14:07] novelty of this issue, of the measures that hoteliers in popular actions and that
[14:11] can be decreed even before the demand is admitted. As you almost feel,
[14:18] I do not need to inform the plaintiff that there is a lawsuit against him
[14:24] if he sees that this right or that collective guarantee is being affected. He
[14:28] himself makes the determination. For example, it sees a waste water spill in
[14:35] a water source and there is the evidence provided in the demand. That judicial
[14:41] authority does not have to inform the party or entity complained of that there is
[14:46] a proceeding against one of them It directly enters before the control mechanism is admitted
[14:52] and decides to suspend any futu affectation of that water source. Imagine the advantage
[15:03] that that offers in the modern world, where a judicial process can take a
[15:07] long time to be resolved and those precautionary measures are now being extended. Of
[15:15] course this is when the lawsuit has already been filed. I must note here
[15:18] a very technical topic, try to make it as simple as possible, but
[15:24] believe me that it is relevant look at the regulation of precautionary measures was in
[15:31] principle in law four hundred and seventy- two, but then it comes into
[15:33] force. The seca enters into force from July 2nd two thousand twelve and in
[15:39] an article, in article two hundred twenty- nine, in its paragraph it
[15:43] says that the precautionary measures will be regulated by the rules of Zepaca in dealing
[15:46] with popular actions, in such a way that here there is a very particular
[15:50] figure, and is that two laws must be integrated for the purposes of understanding
[15:56] how the precautionary measures are handled in these actions, as the point has been
[16:00] understood and resolved, means that there is an integral ambition, but amplified,
[16:08] of the mechanisms of use of these precautionary measures. For Endo, if I
[16:14] want to present a precautionary measure today in a popular action, I can do
[16:18] it from four scenarios. I can make a request for preventive measures, I
[16:23] can make a request for anticipatory measures, I can make a request for precautionary
[16:30] measures and I can make a request for precautionary measures, for suspension And listen
[16:36] to me well, not only of administrative acts, not only of state contracts,
[16:41] but of administrative actions. What a broad and valuable spectrum. I hope
[16:45] I have been clear and if not, please ask me I feel that,
[16:53] because this is a perfect point. Let' s say, it' s
[16:56] salt to characterize what popular action is. Let' s say the tools that
[17:00] the legislation has to precisely provide the judge with a series of instruments and also
[17:06] the same community to precisely invoke the violation or threat to collective rights let'
[17:11] s say in this case. I feel that an important question arises and is
[17:14] related to a very very particular phase of the procedure of popular action, exactly
[17:18] as you were saying. A stage is presented as part of this procedure,
[17:23] which is the special hearing in progress. This hearing allows the process to end
[17:29] in a scenario similar to conciliation. But the question does not arise how this
[17:33] space can be a useful tool that serves to solve these problems that arise for
[17:40] the public interest. Oh, what a good question to Madria Mira. What
[17:45] I would like to highlight is that the last thing that can least happen to
[17:49] a lawyer is to carry out a long trial that ends with a sentence that
[17:56] extends in time one, two or five years, sometimes ten years and looking
[17:59] at both instances, what the legislator conceived with popular actions was to create a
[18:04] figure. I couldn' t call it conciliation, because there are no identifiable
[18:11] subjects in the controversy. Not here is the whole collectivity, the whole community
[18:15] linked in the resolution of this case. Then the legislator proceeded to call him
[18:22] and the special hearing of compliance pact, because it cannot be reconciled and the
[18:26] maximum that can happen is that the authority refuses to fulfill its obligations agree to
[18:33] the fulfillment of those duties in time with a very rigorous judicial control. Hence,
[18:38] the name of this audience. What we have always been pointing out by
[18:45] the judicial authorities is that this opportunity. It is a golden opportunity whenever there
[18:51] is enough evidence to understand that this collective right is already clearly affected. Do
[18:59] not let me go forward with this judicial process until the judgment because it will
[19:03] also make a mistake, first, because it will maintain the violation of that
[19:08] collective right and, secondly, because it can be stated in the judgment that
[19:12] they condemn it in costs. Like that sentence on the coast, an additional
[19:17] sum of money is generated against the public entity. There may be a patrimonial
[19:22] liability that even generates repetition actions for those responsible for that delay in the process.
[19:27] That is why, in a statement by the first section of the Council
[19:32] of States, it generates a precision that I would like to see documented later,
[19:37] if possible, by this GAP group, which is a wonder to indicate
[19:41] to the public that there is a decision under which it is said that whenever
[19:48] there is a summons to a de facto hearing of compliance, the subject is
[19:52] not resolved by the lawyer who is responsible for representing the interests of the public
[19:56] entity, but is an ace of the spring of the Conciliation Committee. The
[20:03] Conciliation Committee is an instance of the most holy level where is the Chief Director,
[20:07] the supreme leader of the entity, as well as four other officials who
[20:11] accompany him. Imagine, I have to tell you that normally one thinks that
[20:18] decisions in the State are of one monolithic person. No. No. No.
[20:22] No. In dealing with this mechanism, the actions are made the decisions
[20:26] of matter of whether or not it is agreed. Enforcement of a judgment in
[20:30] the event of a violation of collective law. It depends on five people and
[20:33] that' s good, because there are five who answer, five who decide.
[20:37] It generates greater transparency, greater rigour in the analysis and, obviously,
[20:41] we are facing a more weighted decision. See if you want to draw a
[20:48] conclusion at this point. I would say the worst thing that can happen to
[20:52] a popular action plaintiff is to expect the issue to be resolved with a sentence.
[20:56] The law gives you the possibility to use the compliance agreement. After you
[21:00] go through that mechanism, go that way and avoid a long process that will
[21:04] surely end up very bad. Okay. Thank you, and so also to
[21:11] explain how to perceive listeners, for it is probably the first time that you
[21:15] hear the terminar hearing especially of covenant of fulfillment, truth or conciliation, probably
[21:21] if it is a little more familiar to you. Well, the special hearing
[21:22] of the compliance pact is important for popular actions, which allows the parties to
[21:26] be those who are really close to the facts involved and are the ones who
[21:33] propose settlement formulas to reach an agreement and be able to solve, as well
[21:38] as their requests or interests, as with those who are violating these collective rights.
[21:42] And finally, to close, because we wanted to address the issue of
[21:52] the protection of augmentational average rights. But first we wanted to ask you a
[21:56] question, and that is the scope of the popular session for the defense of
[22:00] collective rights and how it deals with cases of violations of these rights. Well,
[22:06] really, what I found in my years as a magistrate is that it
[22:12] ' s a tremendously effective mechanism for the protection of rights. And I'
[22:17] m going to say even why. When a demand for popular action is filed,
[22:22] the citizen who formulates it is not required to be a lawyer. So,
[22:27] when he does the approach, he usually tries to generate a problem that,
[22:33] although it is collective, he places it from his perspective of not knowing
[22:37] the right deeply. That happens in a good number of cases, and the
[22:41] good thing about popular action is that it allows for extra bugs and another petite.
[22:45] Imagine yourself, and that then forces the judicial officer to believe that if
[22:52] the facts of the lawsuit, the evidence collected in the course of the proceedings,
[22:59] allow him to deduce that this collective right must be extended in its protection
[23:03] coverage, because he can do so, and I can do so because the
[23:08] procedural system enables him to do so. I am going to give you a
[23:12] simple example, but it seems to me to be valuable because it also happened
[23:17] to us in a lawsuit that was filed in the first section, a complaint
[23:25] for pollution is presented precisely to a water round by a citizen. At the
[23:30] time of making the complaint, it was precisely alleged that the person was himself
[23:34] and the inhabitants of the building, thus affecting the environment. When the site
[23:41] is inspected, it is found that not only he was generating this pollution without
[23:45] the neighbors. Neighbors were also generating spills, as the facts of demand related
[23:52] to water source pollution. The protection provided by the first section was that of
[24:00] preventing all other polluters from the water source from being condemned in the sense that
[24:07] it could no longer discharge. Look at that in the other actions is not
[24:12] possible with the popular. If we have this coverage. Therefore, when you
[24:18] told me what is the scope of this bird Mary mechanism, there we will
[24:22] see it very clearly exposed, and that is that the judge has very wide
[24:26] powers and powers. We told him colloquially that when the Juves presents his intervention
[24:36] in these actions, he changes the clothes and wears a red robe, which
[24:41] is the tunic of the defender of the rights of the collectivity. I hope
[24:45] that I have responded to your concerns and, given that I am filming it
[24:51] on your subject this year about the care of the environment and nature, it
[24:55] is also important to establish that in that which we have mentioned of the conciliation
[25:00] of reaching an agreement of the care of the environment, because the human being
[25:03] achieved, because in this a method with his fellows that is now necessary to
[25:07] find a way to cohabit in harmony, since with the other beings of the
[25:10] earth and with the protection of the environment. So, by way of closure,
[25:12] we wanted to come to a reflection on what we can expect from popular
[25:17] actions in the face of the new challenges posed by the twenty- first century.
[25:19] This can take into account the environmental climate crisis, the epidemics and because
[25:25] all the emergence of artificial intelligence and its very extraordinary boom. It was a
[25:30] very good question that would return multiple facets. I am going to start precisely
[25:33] with the last one, and it is the use of information and communication technologies
[25:38] in this type of process look, some scenario is valid the use of instruments
[25:45] such as a drone, for example, or computers or statistical analysis or analysis
[25:51] of artificial intelligence, is precisely in these popular actions, because of the difficulty
[25:56] in obtaining a valuable test for the purposes of resolving the dispute. But the
[26:03] second one I would like to highlight is something that really worried me a lot
[26:07] in my time as a justice administrator and that' s how you have heard
[26:11] it in your law schools. The worst thing that can happen to a judge
[26:14] that his sentence remains to frame is not true, that is, that he
[26:18] dictates the protection of the law, but then it turns out that that judgment
[26:22] was never fulfilled well. What should I point out here? Fortunately for the
[26:26] first section of the Council of State, I believe that it was a pioneer
[26:30] in generating mechanisms to guarantee the actor to the community that the ruling would be
[26:37] enforced. We generate a mechanism to accompany the judicial sentence with all the drafts.
[26:45] True, if the person did not comply with the decision, copies were
[26:48] certified to the prosecutor' s office, which in fact constantly accompanied the execution
[26:55] of the sentence. If the person did not comply with the decision, if
[26:57] copies could even be certified for a prevarication by omission. And fundamentally, what
[27:03] we wanted was a permanent presence through the control bodies. And thirdly, almost
[27:10] today we could say my presence in the Council of State, the years I
[27:14] was in that ninety- five percent ninety- five percent of our decisions did
[27:18] not motivate incidents of contempt. I am going to try to be precise with
[27:26] this component, since the sentence generated figures for compliance with the decision, very
[27:33] few of them were not complied with. Therefore, then, if I know
[27:37] that when you demand the prosperity of my claims to ensure that this protection of
[27:44] the law is effective, the message that I would send answering the first question
[27:49] that I asked would be associated to the fact that the citizenry in general has
[27:55] to understand that this is a truly effective, valuable, useful, gratuitous mechanism,
[28:02] the need of proxy that can sometimes have the accompaniment of groups as important
[28:06] as the GAB of the University of Rosario and that, in fact, guarantees,
[28:11] in fact, the protection of the collectivity. That is the importance of
[28:15] this mechanism and that is why I insist on pointing it out as the jewel
[28:18] of the economy, because thank you very much for that closure. I feel
[28:22] like closing the space perfectly. I would like to make a few brief conclusions.
[28:25] Understand, Let' s say that this space allows us to effectively see
[28:30] popular action as a constitutional action that seeks to protect collective rights, especially in
[28:34] emphasis as in issues that touch us all, such as the environment, public
[28:38] health, and let' s say that cyber listeners understand that this mechanism is
[28:42] at their disposal and that it is precisely another of the points that this charity
[28:47] is about is that it lacks pedagogy in saying access to the administration of justice
[28:52] in an effective way. How vulnerable communities are to say so many violations of
[28:55] their rights they can access without even requiring a lawyer. How is the case
[28:59] of popular action, and let' s say that' s where I would
[29:03] close by saying that Gab is precisely a space that allows communities to take to
[29:07] law and to know thanks to this space that we had today, how it
[29:11] looks from the other perspective, this red robe of human rights protection, as
[29:15] our guest said today. Thank you so much, let' s say join
[29:21] us in today' s space. It really is a very rewarding space for
[29:23] everyone and in this way we close the space wanted to civir listeners. Thank
[29:26] you so much for tuning us in today. This was citizens in action in
[29:32] this podcast we set out to bring the right to the words that everyone can
[29:36] understand and see each other in a next episode? This was citizens in action
[29:52] in this podcast we set out to bring the right to the words that we
[29:56] can all understand? Don' t you? No, no? Don'
[29:57] t you? Don' t you? Yeah? Is it in an upcoming episode?

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
