# Are Schools Relevant? (podcast)

An episode of [Stream of Subconsciousness](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1498345708), 17 Jun 2024, 1 h 30 min.

Audio: https://api.substack.com/feed/podcast/145683938/59c06fbd911e768c9aeedcafd2d7b549.mp3

“The illiterate of the 21st century will not be those who cannot read and write, but those who cannot learn, unlearn and relearn.”— Alvin Toffler * What learning is, and schools are. * What’s personally meaningful, socially useful, and institutionally enforced. * Today's priorities are creativity, communication, and insight. * Are kids less courageous than before? * How does one learn to be creative? The old public school model is a zombie. It's dangerous and should be dismantled. We don't need to know what comes next, just make room for it! This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit mindstrengthbalance.substack.com/subscribe

## Transcript

[0:00] SPEAKER_00: Today, we're talking with Dr. Lincoln Stoller.
[0:04] SPEAKER_00: Now, Dr. Stoller has a PhD in quantum physics.
[0:09] SPEAKER_00: He has taught.
[0:10] SPEAKER_00: He's worked as an educator.
[0:11] SPEAKER_00: He's also been a mountaineer, a hypnotherapist, and an EEG neurofeedback therapist.
[0:18] SPEAKER_00: He grew up on the East Coast and is now in private practice as a clinical counselor
[0:23] SPEAKER_00: in Victoria,
[0:24] SPEAKER_00: B.C.,
[0:25] SPEAKER_00: Canada.
[0:26] SPEAKER_00: This is a man who loves learning.
[0:29] SPEAKER_00: He loves talking about education.
[0:31] SPEAKER_00: He hates teachers, but he works on hard problems and he works hard on problems.
[0:37] SPEAKER_00: So let's see what he has to say today.
[0:40] SPEAKER_00: Let's go on in.
[0:42] SPEAKER_00: This is the Educational Triage Podcast.
[0:48] SPEAKER_00: Welcome.
[0:50] SPEAKER_00: Thank you so much.
[1:09] SPEAKER_00: Well,
[1:10] SPEAKER_00: join us every week and listen in as Philip Summers and I,
[1:15] SPEAKER_00: Tony Hunt,
[1:16] SPEAKER_00: jump in feet first to discuss issues that may affect our classes,
[1:21] SPEAKER_00: students,
[1:22] SPEAKER_00: communities,
[1:23] SPEAKER_00: as well as our teaching.
[1:26] SPEAKER_00: Please subscribe if you enjoy and find relevance in what you experience here.
[1:31] SPEAKER_00: And if you haven't left a quick review, please do.
[1:34] SPEAKER_00: We appreciate your candor and insights so we can improve as we move forward.
[1:39] SPEAKER_00: Now, let's see what's on board today.
[1:42] SPEAKER_00: Hey, everybody.
[1:44] SPEAKER_00: Welcome back to the Educational Triage Podcast.
[1:47] SPEAKER_00: This week, alongside the philanthropic Philip, we have special guest Lincoln Stoller.
[1:57] SPEAKER_00: Education.
[1:58] SPEAKER_00: You have some very strong opinions on education.
[2:00] SPEAKER_00: You've written about education.
[2:03] SPEAKER_00: You have different things in different books about your theories of education.
[2:10] SPEAKER_00: You were mentored by John Taylor Gatto.
[2:14] SPEAKER_00: So why don't you tell us a little bit about where you're coming from and your view.
[2:22] SPEAKER_00: What's your primary view and philosophy of education?
[2:24] SPEAKER_00: And we'll just kind of springboard from there.
[2:28] SPEAKER_03: Well, it changes day by day, but today I'd say there are three views.
[2:33] SPEAKER_03: One is personal meaning,
[2:40] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[2:40] SPEAKER_03: what's useful,
[2:42] SPEAKER_03: meaningful,
[2:44] SPEAKER_03: and how to learn things that are personally useful.
[2:49] SPEAKER_03: And then there's being creative in a field usually, which involves a different kind of learning.
[2:57] SPEAKER_03: Some sort of connection to some other standard, you know, scientific, artistic, musical or something.
[3:07] SPEAKER_03: And then I'd say there's cultural, which is relative to another standard again.
[3:15] SPEAKER_03: So, you know, I have a 13-year-old now.
[3:19] SPEAKER_03: I have a 25-year-old son too.
[3:20] SPEAKER_03: Different learning standards.
[3:27] SPEAKER_03: different learning environments, what they learn, how they learn, what they think is important.
[3:35] SPEAKER_03: I get to watch them.
[3:36] SPEAKER_03: And then I have my own experience.
[3:38] SPEAKER_03: School is pretty much a social learning environment, I would say.
[3:44] SPEAKER_03: It doesn't, it sort of pretends to teach you to be creative, but I don't think it succeeds.
[3:51] SPEAKER_03: And it also doesn't succeed in teaching you personal meaning.
[3:56] SPEAKER_03: meaningful stuff so i should say that so i'm both a physicist and a psychotherapist
[4:03] SPEAKER_03: and that's kind of two sides to the learning triangle the psychotherapy side lets
[4:09] SPEAKER_03: me see people's personal meaning and their adventures toward you know becoming
[4:18] SPEAKER_03: larger and more clear in their personal values
[4:23] SPEAKER_03: And the physics side lets me see the creative within the context of a structure.
[4:32] SPEAKER_03: And there's a certain social element too,
[4:34] SPEAKER_03: because there's what's historically true or presumed to be historically true and
[4:39] SPEAKER_03: the people you're supposed to listen to.
[4:41] SPEAKER_03: And the nice thing I like about science is the only thing you can be sure of is that everybody is wrong.
[4:48] SPEAKER_03: Eventually, every theory is contingent on its fundamental assumptions.
[4:54] SPEAKER_03: And nobody's found any unassailable fundamental assumptions.
[4:59] SPEAKER_03: So there's a social element to what are you supposed to believe and so forth.
[5:03] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[5:04] SPEAKER_00: Well, with science, aren't you supposed to go about science with the notion that it's wrong?
[5:11] SPEAKER_00: That's what you're trying to prove.
[5:14] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[5:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[5:15] SPEAKER_03: there are different ways,
[5:15] SPEAKER_03: different methodologies,
[5:17] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[5:18] SPEAKER_03: a theoretical versus an experimental.
[5:21] SPEAKER_03: I mean, there's a nice,
[5:23] SPEAKER_03: Einstein quote that says that a theory is something that nobody believes except for
[5:27] SPEAKER_03: the theorists who proposed it.
[5:29] SPEAKER_03: And an experiment is something that everybody believes except for the experimentalists who observed it.
[5:35] SPEAKER_03: So it depends, you know, and there's truth.
[5:38] SPEAKER_03: That was definitely true.
[5:40] SPEAKER_03: That's true.
[5:40] SPEAKER_03: It's absolutely true.
[5:42] SPEAKER_03: So, you know, it's a very interesting alternative area and learning.
[5:49] SPEAKER_03: So you go to school to learn these technical fields and,
[5:53] SPEAKER_03: And you either come out believing it and then you become a professor or you reject
[6:01] SPEAKER_03: it and then you become a researcher or you go into some other field because of how
[6:07] SPEAKER_03: you're awarded or not.
[6:09] SPEAKER_02: In your book,
[6:10] SPEAKER_02: Becoming Super Genius,
[6:11] SPEAKER_02: I was reading along and you had alluded to the fact,
[6:15] SPEAKER_02: well,
[6:15] SPEAKER_02: actually,
[6:15] SPEAKER_02: you were specifically saying that creativity is in every endeavor that you do.
[6:24] SPEAKER_02: it's almost like art in a lot of ways.
[6:26] SPEAKER_02: You're creating art.
[6:28] SPEAKER_02: You're creating something regardless of what it is.
[6:32] SPEAKER_02: It may be a note to somebody I was getting or a piece of sculpture or a painting.
[6:40] SPEAKER_02: You also were talking about how schools generally don't really address the individuals.
[6:48] SPEAKER_02: They just sort of teach us how to
[6:51] SPEAKER_02: behave in our society so i guess my point is this is we all know that schools dump
[6:58] SPEAKER_02: on creativity they start dismantling it around fourth and fifth grade just to get
[7:04] SPEAKER_02: us all regimented well yeah i mean i'm giving it the benefit of the doubt but yeah
[7:13] SPEAKER_02: by the time fourth fifth grade hit she's supposed to be serious adult again
[7:18] SPEAKER_02: And so it stops appealing to your sense of creativity and starts appealing to your
[7:22] SPEAKER_02: sense of just getting stuff done,
[7:24] SPEAKER_02: I guess.
[7:26] SPEAKER_02: What kind of structure could there be, like, say, after the age of 10 that would encourage creativity?
[7:34] SPEAKER_02: Can you think of how that could be done at all?
[7:37] SPEAKER_02: I don't know, structure, that's a funny word.
[7:40] SPEAKER_02: What kind of structure could we use to open up everything?
[7:43] SPEAKER_02: That's sort of an oxymoron.
[7:47] SPEAKER_03: I started mountaineering because I like the openness of it.
[7:51] SPEAKER_03: It has elements of creativity and exploration and learning and social interaction and reality.
[8:00] SPEAKER_03: And you could do the same with a lot of other endeavors.
[8:04] SPEAKER_03: I just happen to like sort of solo endeavors.
[8:08] SPEAKER_03: But some people like team endeavors or group endeavors or even business.
[8:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I should say even business.
[8:16] SPEAKER_03: I should say certainly business because it's got sort of the three things that I mentioned.
[8:22] SPEAKER_03: You have to be creative to some degree.
[8:25] SPEAKER_03: You have to be social to some degree.
[8:27] SPEAKER_03: And you have to adhere to the body of accepted knowledge to some degree.
[8:35] SPEAKER_03: And so getting involved in those things provides some sort of three-part harmony in
[8:44] SPEAKER_03: the learning universe.
[8:47] SPEAKER_03: And that's quite a bit different than a school,
[8:49] SPEAKER_03: which is generally one side,
[8:52] SPEAKER_03: which is the established knowledge.
[8:54] SPEAKER_03: Because I don't even think...
[8:56] SPEAKER_03: Although schools are given the job of socializing you,
[9:01] SPEAKER_03: I don't think they do a very good job of it.
[9:02] SPEAKER_03: They just sort of normalize you.
[9:04] SPEAKER_03: It's not the same as socializing you.
[9:07] SPEAKER_00: I think where you were coming from,
[9:08] SPEAKER_03: Philip...
[9:10] SPEAKER_00: But I think where Philip was coming from is in the early years...
[9:15] SPEAKER_00: from kindergarten up to third or fourth grade, they start squelching the creativity.
[9:21] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, but what after 10, he said.
[9:23] SPEAKER_03: So I was looking about after 10.
[9:25] SPEAKER_02: How about 10-ish, you know?
[9:27] SPEAKER_03: Well, I started doing it at 13, which is early, but still.
[9:31] SPEAKER_03: And then I also tried to do other things like slot car racing,
[9:36] SPEAKER_03: which was probably good for that age because,
[9:38] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[9:38] SPEAKER_03: you build these little models and you do a little electrical motor work and controls.
[9:42] SPEAKER_03: And now they're,
[9:45] SPEAKER_03: know um radio controlled planes and gyrocopters and drones and so there and another
[9:53] SPEAKER_03: thing that's available for you know teenagers is like i mean these are just things
[9:58] SPEAKER_03: i did like scuba diving uh right where you have to be responsible and there's some
[10:03] SPEAKER_03: real feedback so this is what i'm saying you know
[10:07] SPEAKER_03: Kids do paper routes, right?
[10:09] SPEAKER_03: I mean, that's a traditional sort of reality touchstone.
[10:15] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[10:16] SPEAKER_03: even if you get younger,
[10:17] SPEAKER_03: it's like the lemonade stand that people tell their kids to go out and sit on.
[10:21] SPEAKER_03: I don't really, you know.
[10:24] SPEAKER_03: Well, what else did I do?
[10:26] SPEAKER_03: You know, going out to explore.
[10:27] SPEAKER_03: Kids go into the woods.
[10:28] SPEAKER_03: There's a big nature education effort.
[10:32] SPEAKER_03: And that's, I think, you know, the what's his name, the
[10:40] SPEAKER_03: What is it?
[10:40] SPEAKER_03: The Eightfold Way?
[10:41] SPEAKER_03: No, that's something else.
[10:43] SPEAKER_03: You know, John, what's his name?
[10:46] SPEAKER_03: Not Fox.
[10:47] SPEAKER_03: Is it Fox?
[10:48] SPEAKER_03: No, John.
[10:48] SPEAKER_03: Really?
[10:49] SPEAKER_03: No, the current guy who's writing these books about the coyote.
[10:54] SPEAKER_03: Remember that book?
[10:55] SPEAKER_03: Oh, I don't know.
[10:57] SPEAKER_03: John Holtz, all that whole sort of unschooling stuff out, nature schooling.
[11:03] SPEAKER_03: Oh, okay.
[11:04] SPEAKER_02: Oh, got it.
[11:05] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[11:06] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, okay.
[11:07] SPEAKER_02: I don't know.
[11:07] SPEAKER_02: I'm not familiar if I am.
[11:09] SPEAKER_02: Not by name.
[11:11] SPEAKER_02: You know,
[11:12] SPEAKER_02: it's interesting you're speaking about this because Tony and I both had worked in
[11:16] SPEAKER_02: similar programs where the kids had an outside adjunct.
[11:21] SPEAKER_02: Tony worked with a career education sort of program that had school on-site days and then at-work days.
[11:29] SPEAKER_02: Okay.
[11:29] SPEAKER_02: And they coordinated the two.
[11:31] SPEAKER_02: I had a program where I was incorporating all kinds of stuff.
[11:35] SPEAKER_02: I had a climbing wall.
[11:37] SPEAKER_02: And,
[11:37] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[11:38] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[11:39] SPEAKER_02: I taught the kids all kinds of stuff,
[11:41] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[11:41] SPEAKER_02: using the climbing wall and having a mentor of the elementary school kids.
[11:45] SPEAKER_02: So I guess I always liked my model.
[11:50] SPEAKER_02: And you're sort of describing it.
[11:52] SPEAKER_02: It's sort of more guided mentorship.
[11:56] SPEAKER_02: It's like, Tony, especially with CE2,
[11:59] SPEAKER_02: when you'd send those kids out in the world, you know, it's like, did you go to your job site?
[12:03] SPEAKER_02: You know, you got to do what they ask you to do.
[12:06] SPEAKER_02: And you kind of had to have a stiffer hand on them so they knew the P's and Q's so they could watch them.
[12:14] SPEAKER_02: You know, not just being a teacher, but yeah, it's important you do this.
[12:17] SPEAKER_02: It's a social kind of way of dealing with things.
[12:19] SPEAKER_02: And so it was a really good program and it was very beneficial and very successful.
[12:26] SPEAKER_00: Well, it puts them into that realm where they have to
[12:29] SPEAKER_00: understand that they now have mentorships and they're going to be learning
[12:33] SPEAKER_00: different kinds of skills in order to function as an adult in the work world.
[12:40] SPEAKER_00: But there were some students who couldn't deal with that, which was interesting.
[12:45] SPEAKER_00: They did not like having to have that responsibility.
[12:50] SPEAKER_00: And so they wanted to do something that was more akin to what they were really
[12:55] SPEAKER_00: interested in,
[12:56] SPEAKER_00: which we tried to do.
[12:57] SPEAKER_00: Some of them really wanted to go into veterinary medicine,
[13:00] SPEAKER_00: but we couldn't get any vets because they can't be back in the rooms with the
[13:07] SPEAKER_00: doctors or anything.
[13:09] SPEAKER_00: They have to work up to the front desk if they had any room there.
[13:13] SPEAKER_00: And there was a lot of confidential information.
[13:15] SPEAKER_00: So, yeah.
[13:17] SPEAKER_02: Pretty formal stuff, business-wise.
[13:18] SPEAKER_02: But we also had... A lot of learning to be done in the arts or in mountaineering.
[13:23] SPEAKER_00: I was into theater, so... When we did the... When you and I both did the residential... Yeah.
[13:30] SPEAKER_00: We both taught residential for juvenile offenders, but at different times.
[13:35] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[13:36] SPEAKER_00: And there was a ton of creativity that we allowed the students to have there.
[13:41] SPEAKER_00: And to go with it was managed.
[13:43] SPEAKER_00: But if the kids came up with a great idea that they wanted to follow or they wanted
[13:47] SPEAKER_00: to attempt,
[13:48] SPEAKER_00: then,
[13:48] SPEAKER_00: yeah,
[13:49] SPEAKER_00: that was allowed.
[13:51] SPEAKER_00: And so for some of them, it was a release for others.
[13:54] SPEAKER_00: It was a real hell because there was nothing that they needed to have those confines,
[14:02] SPEAKER_00: which is really interesting.
[14:04] SPEAKER_02: I was teaching things like flow state.
[14:06] SPEAKER_02: Chicks ain't me.
[14:07] SPEAKER_02: Hi to them.
[14:08] SPEAKER_02: How to learn how to learn.
[14:10] SPEAKER_02: Things like that.
[14:11] SPEAKER_02: And we'd start off the afternoons basically meditating.
[14:15] SPEAKER_02: I'd have them focus on something,
[14:17] SPEAKER_02: a small shell,
[14:19] SPEAKER_02: and just study it for five minutes,
[14:22] SPEAKER_02: which went,
[14:23] SPEAKER_02: after a while,
[14:24] SPEAKER_02: that went on really quickly for them.
[14:26] SPEAKER_02: They're going, oh, ready?
[14:27] SPEAKER_02: So, yeah, we had a lot of freedom.
[14:32] SPEAKER_00: Let me jump back up on the rock.
[14:34] SPEAKER_00: And let's take a look at what is education.
[14:38] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[14:39] SPEAKER_00: would you say that the primary goal of schools is to teach the fundamentals from
[14:44] SPEAKER_00: which other things happen?
[14:47] SPEAKER_03: No.
[14:50] SPEAKER_03: No.
[14:51] SPEAKER_00: Where do you think that those should come from?
[14:53] SPEAKER_03: I think a person defines their own fundamentals.
[14:56] SPEAKER_03: If somebody is trying to teach you something that's meaningless to you, then it's meaningless.
[15:01] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[15:03] SPEAKER_03: Until something's meaningful to you, it's not going to have a place in your world.
[15:07] SPEAKER_03: It's not going to be relevant.
[15:09] SPEAKER_03: You're not going to remember it.
[15:11] SPEAKER_03: You're not going to work with it.
[15:15] SPEAKER_03: So I think the idea of fundamentals to a point is relative.
[15:21] SPEAKER_03: So you could say that if you never learned to read, then it would become a problem.
[15:28] SPEAKER_03: But if you were engaged with the world...
[15:32] SPEAKER_03: you would find reading to be useful and you wouldn't have to follow a program in
[15:38] SPEAKER_03: order to understand its use.
[15:41] SPEAKER_03: And it doesn't take a lot of work to learn to read.
[15:44] SPEAKER_03: It just takes some work and a lot of reason.
[15:48] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[15:49] SPEAKER_03: this is the interesting thing that if you're motivated,
[15:52] SPEAKER_03: you can basically do high school in a year,
[15:53] SPEAKER_03: all 12 years of it,
[15:55] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[15:55] SPEAKER_03: or maybe two years.
[15:56] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[15:58] SPEAKER_03: And also there's a certain amount of learning that comes without anyone teaching you anything.
[16:02] SPEAKER_03: You learn how to speak.
[16:03] SPEAKER_03: You learn how to understand people and express yourself.
[16:07] SPEAKER_03: The screwdriver you use to build the concept you have in your mind.
[16:12] SPEAKER_03: But if you don't have a concept in your mind,
[16:14] SPEAKER_03: then no amount of skill in reading or writing is going to be put to any use.
[16:19] SPEAKER_00: It's just going to be... But that learning doesn't happen in a vacuum either.
[16:23] SPEAKER_00: I mean, you need to have the right environment around you that's going to propel you forward.
[16:27] SPEAKER_00: to want to be able to talk.
[16:29] SPEAKER_00: If you're growing up in silence, then you're not going to be able to do that so well.
[16:34] SPEAKER_03: Well, it's interesting.
[16:35] SPEAKER_03: I was just reading about Paul Dirac,
[16:37] SPEAKER_03: who was a famous physicist and who basically grew up in silence because his father
[16:41] SPEAKER_03: constantly disciplined him for speaking.
[16:45] SPEAKER_03: And so it seems to me, well, he may have been slightly autistic anyway, or Asperger's.
[16:51] SPEAKER_03: But anyway, he had a different attitude towards speaking.
[16:54] SPEAKER_03: So there was this joke,
[16:56] SPEAKER_03: there was a unit of speech and his circle was one word per month that was built on
[17:01] SPEAKER_03: what he would speak.
[17:03] SPEAKER_03: So it depends.
[17:05] SPEAKER_03: If you deal with an autistic kid,
[17:08] SPEAKER_03: a severely autistic kid,
[17:09] SPEAKER_03: then your notions of speech are going to be different from theirs.
[17:15] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[17:15] SPEAKER_03: I should just say that in the school,
[17:18] SPEAKER_03: my earlier son went to a Sudbury school,
[17:20] SPEAKER_03: which is based on the Summerhill model of
[17:22] SPEAKER_03: Democratic education, no courses, no requirements, no teachers.
[17:28] SPEAKER_03: And in that school, they had autistic kids.
[17:30] SPEAKER_03: And their problems remediated fairly quickly when their social group could
[17:37] SPEAKER_03: accommodate them rather than their social group insisted that they conform,
[17:43] SPEAKER_03: which they couldn't do as autistic kids.
[17:45] SPEAKER_00: Can you give an example of that?
[17:46] SPEAKER_03: A lot of these problems, like also ADHD and stuff, disappeared when the environment became flexible.
[17:53] SPEAKER_00: Well, it became focused on what they wanted and what they felt that they needed, correct?
[17:59] SPEAKER_03: And people around them allowed that.
[18:01] SPEAKER_03: Right.
[18:02] SPEAKER_02: Right.
[18:04] SPEAKER_02: You know, this whole premise reminds me of Chesterton's fence.
[18:09] SPEAKER_02: You know, we're not going to go blasting through these fences unless we know why they're there.
[18:14] SPEAKER_02: But at the same time, I know why they're there and they need to be blasted through.
[18:18] SPEAKER_02: And when you said, when you kind of advocated for not a formal...
[18:23] SPEAKER_02: environment in which to learn to read and write,
[18:26] SPEAKER_02: for example,
[18:26] SPEAKER_02: I started to kind of go,
[18:27] SPEAKER_02: wait a minute,
[18:28] SPEAKER_02: that sort of messed me up.
[18:31] SPEAKER_02: But at the same time, you're absolutely right.
[18:33] SPEAKER_02: For example,
[18:34] SPEAKER_02: math and I don't get along,
[18:36] SPEAKER_02: but I can do the math that I need to do really well and really easily because I'm
[18:42] SPEAKER_02: motivated to do it.
[18:44] SPEAKER_02: I'm not a mathematician per se.
[18:45] SPEAKER_02: I have real trouble with equations and numbers,
[18:49] SPEAKER_02: but when I need to know it,
[18:50] SPEAKER_02: like I was a paramedic and I could
[18:51] SPEAKER_02: titrate doses right down to the drops per minute, you know?
[18:56] SPEAKER_02: And so I learned the math and I think you're right on that.
[19:00] SPEAKER_02: You'll learn to read and write because you want to learn to read and write,
[19:03] SPEAKER_02: not because it's due by Wednesday.
[19:07] SPEAKER_00: So do you think schools should be there to help us not only socialize,
[19:13] SPEAKER_00: but also give us a mode that fits our learning structures best?
[19:18] SPEAKER_00: In other words, schools are there to teach us how we learn rather than what to learn?
[19:24] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[19:25] SPEAKER_03: that would be,
[19:26] SPEAKER_03: I'm not sure you can teach anybody how to learn,
[19:30] SPEAKER_03: but you can give them the opportunity to use resources to learn.
[19:37] SPEAKER_03: I have to go back to what I said before,
[19:41] SPEAKER_03: which is there's social learning and there's creative learning,
[19:45] SPEAKER_03: and then there's a formal or historical or structured,
[19:51] SPEAKER_03: whatever it is,
[19:52] SPEAKER_03: the body of knowledge learning.
[19:55] SPEAKER_03: And then I don't think anything goes very far unless you have a reason to do it.
[20:03] SPEAKER_03: So like I deal as a therapist with people who come to me at later,
[20:07] SPEAKER_03: mostly in their life,
[20:09] SPEAKER_03: middle age adults who are having trouble finding meaning in their pursuit.
[20:16] SPEAKER_03: You know, they've been they've worked their way into a successful career.
[20:19] SPEAKER_03: And now they're thinking, what am I doing with my life?
[20:22] SPEAKER_03: I'm starting to get annoyed with all the bullshit and the structure and the limitations of
[20:29] SPEAKER_03: And I'm increasingly less satisfied with just taking a paycheck.
[20:34] SPEAKER_03: And what's going on?
[20:36] SPEAKER_03: So you could say that these people need more something.
[20:41] SPEAKER_03: Insight, spirit, creativity, opportunity.
[20:45] SPEAKER_03: And they learned.
[20:46] SPEAKER_03: These were high-performance learners who did everything right and got good grades and high evaluations.
[20:55] SPEAKER_03: And they're searching for meaning.
[20:59] SPEAKER_03: And then you could say, well, there are other people who didn't even learn that.
[21:02] SPEAKER_03: And maybe they found meaning in some other place.
[21:05] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[21:05] SPEAKER_03: there's like a story from,
[21:07] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[21:07] SPEAKER_03: Sudbury schools of,
[21:08] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[21:09] SPEAKER_03: these may be apocryphal stories,
[21:10] SPEAKER_03: but it doesn't matter.
[21:11] SPEAKER_03: Some kid who didn't learn anything except to play the saxophone.
[21:14] SPEAKER_03: It's all he did ever.
[21:17] SPEAKER_03: And then he made a profession of being a saxophone player,
[21:19] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[21:22] SPEAKER_03: and Ken Robinson has the most viewed TED talk by far on,
[21:27] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[21:27] SPEAKER_03: the TED site.
[21:29] SPEAKER_03: And it's basically just a talk about finding yourself through learning.
[21:35] SPEAKER_03: Of course, he's a great speaker.
[21:37] SPEAKER_03: He was a great speaker.
[21:39] SPEAKER_03: But he's basically saying, oh, he has a story.
[21:43] SPEAKER_03: You know, a girl who was accused of having learning disabilities turned out to be a dancer.
[21:48] SPEAKER_03: And everything she learned in her life came through dancing.
[21:51] SPEAKER_03: This was her story as an adult saying this is what happened to her.
[21:55] SPEAKER_03: Right, right.
[21:56] SPEAKER_03: through that mode everything became meaningful and other people around her were in
[22:00] SPEAKER_03: a similar mode and they shared information and there's a different social and body
[22:05] SPEAKER_03: of knowledge and mode of learning that was appropriate for her and her other
[22:11] SPEAKER_03: kinesthetic compatriots which the normal school couldn't understand and was going
[22:18] SPEAKER_03: to assign her the designation of retarded and you know probably if they had done
[22:25] SPEAKER_03: that she would
[22:26] SPEAKER_03: then be retarded.
[22:27] SPEAKER_03: She would act retarded and fulfill their expectations for a retarded person.
[22:32] SPEAKER_03: And probably at some point believe she was retarded.
[22:37] SPEAKER_03: So you could say the same thing of many people and their styles of learning.
[22:42] SPEAKER_03: But you could also say, well, I have another interesting story I'm dealing with right now.
[22:46] SPEAKER_03: A mother came to me saying her teenage son is a lazy, good for nothing, irresponsible, you know,
[22:56] SPEAKER_03: wastrel and that I should fix him.
[23:00] SPEAKER_03: I should fix him.
[23:02] SPEAKER_03: So, you know, so, so I get on, you know, a call with him and I say, you know, what's your problem?
[23:08] SPEAKER_03: And he says, you know, my mother.
[23:10] SPEAKER_03: And so, yeah, it's clear.
[23:11] SPEAKER_03: His mother is the problem.
[23:13] SPEAKER_03: And like, what's the story?
[23:14] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[23:14] SPEAKER_03: his mother is the one with the whole history of abuse and struggle and,
[23:18] SPEAKER_03: and,
[23:18] SPEAKER_03: uh,
[23:19] SPEAKER_03: violation and,
[23:20] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[23:21] SPEAKER_03: And she's living vicariously through him.
[23:24] SPEAKER_03: She wants him to do all the things she never could do,
[23:26] SPEAKER_03: thinking that somehow that will redeem her or something.
[23:31] SPEAKER_03: And the message I had for him was that it's really not about you at all.
[23:36] SPEAKER_03: It's about your family.
[23:37] SPEAKER_03: And how much can you stand to bear of her need for help?
[23:44] SPEAKER_03: Because she needs help, but she can't take the responsibility of doing it herself.
[23:49] SPEAKER_03: So here's another learning environment.
[23:51] SPEAKER_03: where the kid who's perfectly capable to do anything he wants is almost being
[23:56] SPEAKER_03: obstructed by his mother,
[23:57] SPEAKER_03: who's put herself in front of him.
[24:00] SPEAKER_03: So she'll actually sit in his room until he finishes his assignments.
[24:04] SPEAKER_03: Well, that'll ruin any assignment.
[24:06] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[24:06] SPEAKER_03: So the problem is kind of at right angles to every expectation.
[24:11] SPEAKER_03: It's not his problem.
[24:13] SPEAKER_03: It's not a school problem.
[24:15] SPEAKER_03: It's not a psychotherapy problem.
[24:18] SPEAKER_03: The lesson he's learning is much greater than the assignment he's being forced to do.
[24:22] SPEAKER_03: Well, the point is he may not want to learn that lesson.
[24:24] SPEAKER_03: He may say, hell with it.
[24:26] SPEAKER_03: I didn't sign up for this.
[24:27] SPEAKER_03: I don't want to be my mother's therapist.
[24:29] SPEAKER_03: And then the sad thing I'm telling is you can't avoid it.
[24:32] SPEAKER_03: She's your mother.
[24:33] SPEAKER_03: You're going to be living with her for the rest of your life if she lives so long.
[24:37] SPEAKER_03: And so you're going to have to find some way to, you know, keep this boat afloat.
[24:43] SPEAKER_03: Otherwise you'll have no family.
[24:45] SPEAKER_03: So it's,
[24:46] SPEAKER_03: I mean, these are people who are actually better off.
[24:49] SPEAKER_03: I get people who have real histories of violence and abuse, and they're even more difficult.
[24:54] SPEAKER_03: And when you talk about what's education for these people,
[24:57] SPEAKER_03: the whole idea goes out the window because we're just talking about survival.
[25:01] SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
[25:02] SPEAKER_03: That's very true as well.
[25:04] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[25:05] SPEAKER_00: So there's also,
[25:06] SPEAKER_00: in a sense,
[25:07] SPEAKER_00: maybe an evolutionary approach to education as far as where on the spectrum people
[25:14] SPEAKER_00: are finding it.
[25:15] SPEAKER_00: And what they use it for.
[25:17] SPEAKER_00: So Peter Gray from Boston College talks about how play is actually where children
[25:25] SPEAKER_00: learn the social mores and they learn what the precepts are of society,
[25:30] SPEAKER_00: etc.,
[25:31] SPEAKER_00: etc.,
[25:31] SPEAKER_00: etc.,
[25:32] SPEAKER_00: because they're mimicking,
[25:33] SPEAKER_00: they're playing what they see at home,
[25:34] SPEAKER_00: etc.,
[25:36] SPEAKER_00: And they teach that to what's acceptable and what's not to each other from their peers.
[25:42] SPEAKER_00: And then they go into school and that whole thing is just flipped around because
[25:46] SPEAKER_00: now they're told to conform.
[25:48] SPEAKER_00: They're told to stay right there.
[25:50] SPEAKER_00: But is that sort of, that would play into the socialization, maybe some of the cultural, would you say?
[26:01] SPEAKER_00: And that it's all evolutionary is what he also says.
[26:06] SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
[26:06] SPEAKER_03: You have to repeat.
[26:07] SPEAKER_03: You have to rephrase that.
[26:10] SPEAKER_00: He says that learning is evolutionary and it evolves from children playing with each other.
[26:20] SPEAKER_00: And when they're playing, let's say they're playing mom and dad.
[26:25] SPEAKER_00: Maybe they're playing, you know, neighbors or whatever.
[26:29] SPEAKER_00: And they're the Flintstones, whatever, whatever we did when we were kids.
[26:34] SPEAKER_00: And that's where they start learning the social mores.
[26:37] SPEAKER_00: And they bring that.
[26:38] SPEAKER_00: And so they're using their imagination.
[26:40] SPEAKER_00: They're using a lot of kinesthetic energy.
[26:43] SPEAKER_00: They're using their observations about the world around them.
[26:47] SPEAKER_01: Mm hmm.
[26:47] SPEAKER_00: So would that entail the personal as well as the cultural of the three that you
[26:55] SPEAKER_00: gave us and possibly part of the being creative?
[26:58] SPEAKER_03: That's right, I think.
[27:00] SPEAKER_03: To me,
[27:01] SPEAKER_03: the whole idea behind nature schooling,
[27:04] SPEAKER_03: and it was John Young I was trying to think of,
[27:06] SPEAKER_03: Coyote's Guide to Connecting with Nature,
[27:08] SPEAKER_03: and what does the Robin teach us?
[27:11] SPEAKER_03: And actually, he says it's built on
[27:17] SPEAKER_03: some native American or indigenous teaching.
[27:22] SPEAKER_03: So yeah,
[27:22] SPEAKER_03: you get into an environment that is rich,
[27:26] SPEAKER_03: that is fractal in the sense that it's detailed even on the small scale and on the
[27:32] SPEAKER_03: large scale.
[27:32] SPEAKER_03: This is why I think nature is so useful.
[27:35] SPEAKER_03: You can look under a leaf or you can look into clouds and there'll be lessons at every scale.
[27:42] SPEAKER_03: And to some extent there's an interaction between every scale.
[27:46] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[27:46] SPEAKER_03: clouds make rain and rain makes weather and weather makes soil and soil make plants
[27:51] SPEAKER_03: and we eat plants.
[27:52] SPEAKER_03: And there's no end to the string that you can follow as opposed to a library or a
[27:59] SPEAKER_03: school or a class,
[28:00] SPEAKER_03: which has an assignment that finishes and chapter six ends,
[28:03] SPEAKER_03: usually in a kind of wrapped up way that doesn't either inspire you or tell you
[28:09] SPEAKER_03: where to go.
[28:10] SPEAKER_03: And it chops everything up into subjects as if the world.
[28:13] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[28:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[28:15] SPEAKER_03: we all know that that's really for the benefit of administrators,
[28:18] SPEAKER_03: graders,
[28:19] SPEAKER_03: and basically the whole Prussian model of teaching people how to work.
[28:26] SPEAKER_03: And one of the answers, or if it hasn't been asked yet, questions is whether the system can be fixed.
[28:32] SPEAKER_03: And my feeling is that there isn't one system.
[28:36] SPEAKER_03: There's a social system, socializing school, police public school is mostly a socializing effort.
[28:42] SPEAKER_03: And then there's a skill effort.
[28:44] SPEAKER_03: You have to know how to drive or you have to know how to read.
[28:49] SPEAKER_03: The basics are really work ethics.
[28:53] SPEAKER_03: And then there's the creative aspect,
[28:56] SPEAKER_03: which is both material and creative,
[28:58] SPEAKER_03: constructing new things and ideas,
[29:01] SPEAKER_03: and personally creative,
[29:02] SPEAKER_03: finding insight into your family and yourself and your world.
[29:07] SPEAKER_03: And none of that is really taught.
[29:08] SPEAKER_03: That's pretty much it.
[29:10] SPEAKER_03: I would say it's more than not taught.
[29:12] SPEAKER_03: It's discouraged because you're supposed to take the answers, not question the answers or in other ways.
[29:19] SPEAKER_03: In graduate school,
[29:21] SPEAKER_03: I was advised to this cute little phrase,
[29:25] SPEAKER_03: get your passport and then you can travel,
[29:27] SPEAKER_03: which is to say,
[29:28] SPEAKER_03: do your homework,
[29:29] SPEAKER_03: get a grade,
[29:31] SPEAKER_03: satisfactory grade,
[29:32] SPEAKER_03: get certified and then travel,
[29:35] SPEAKER_03: which I don't believe is true.
[29:37] SPEAKER_03: I believe once you've locked in,
[29:40] SPEAKER_03: your horizons you're in the box and in fact you don't travel unless you break out
[29:46] SPEAKER_02: of the box well yeah which is what we were talking about was it's a very limited
[29:52] SPEAKER_02: approach to everything considering the human experience is so vastly wide open and
[29:59] SPEAKER_02: we're telling people here's what you're gonna learn and here's why it is important
[30:05] SPEAKER_03: so i think it's relative
[30:07] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[30:08] SPEAKER_03: in the early 20th century,
[30:11] SPEAKER_03: the US and its Western allies were great ascending powers and industry was booming
[30:19] SPEAKER_03: and trade was forming and there were customers everywhere.
[30:23] SPEAKER_03: And there was a lot of need for jobs to do these things.
[30:29] SPEAKER_03: And there was a limited need for innovation to solve technical problems like how to
[30:35] SPEAKER_03: make the intermittent windshield wiper work.
[30:37] SPEAKER_03: There's a whole movie made about that.
[30:39] SPEAKER_03: Or all kinds of interesting technical problems,
[30:43] SPEAKER_03: how to make a better airplane,
[30:45] SPEAKER_03: how to figure out traffic flow.
[30:49] SPEAKER_03: An interesting aside is that a lot of subtle things really affect our world.
[30:58] SPEAKER_03: And one of them is zoning.
[31:01] SPEAKER_03: One of those boring things in the world has a huge effect on
[31:05] SPEAKER_03: how the demographics, where we live, how we live, how new buildings and commerce is constructed.
[31:13] SPEAKER_03: And one of the reasons I moved to Canada was because they have very open zoning laws.
[31:17] SPEAKER_03: You can build a commune in Canada and you can't do that in the U.S.
[31:24] SPEAKER_03: Zoning laws in the U.S.
[31:26] SPEAKER_03: are local and very few localities are open to communes.
[31:31] SPEAKER_03: but in Canada, either it's provincial or federal and you're allowed to have communes.
[31:37] SPEAKER_03: And so obviously you're gonna have a different culture after a few generations,
[31:41] SPEAKER_03: if you can live in an extended community versus what we see in the US where
[31:45] SPEAKER_03: everybody's got a little quarter acre plot of land with a fence between themselves
[31:50] SPEAKER_03: and their neighbor and never speak to them.
[31:52] SPEAKER_03: It just doesn't take too many generations before you have psychological problems
[31:59] SPEAKER_03: that are related to that.
[32:00] SPEAKER_03: But where am I going?
[32:03] SPEAKER_03: Somehow it's like knowing this stuff is important.
[32:07] SPEAKER_03: And also not letting people know this stuff is important.
[32:11] SPEAKER_03: Not to be too unwashed in my radicalism.
[32:15] SPEAKER_03: It's true that you do have to get along and you have to sort of know how to game
[32:22] SPEAKER_03: the system and how to advance the system and how to work in the system to some extent,
[32:27] SPEAKER_03: if you think the system is remediable,
[32:30] SPEAKER_03: is fixable.
[32:32] SPEAKER_03: legitimate so i mean like look at you it's politics now and well it's world
[32:36] SPEAKER_03: politics becoming very um sort of tending toward fascism and populism and you know
[32:44] SPEAKER_03: it doesn't seem like any one election is going to solve that and where did it come
[32:48] SPEAKER_03: from oh i knew where i was going i was going to say in the early 20th century when
[32:53] SPEAKER_03: the
[32:54] SPEAKER_03: economies of the West were growing and strengthening.
[32:58] SPEAKER_03: There was a lot of need for people with a certain both mindset and skill set.
[33:02] SPEAKER_03: And those are the kind of people that were taught and that kind of legislation that
[33:06] SPEAKER_03: was passed,
[33:08] SPEAKER_03: the kind of social programs that were enacted.
[33:10] SPEAKER_03: And that's sort of maybe that arc has passed its peak where, you know, China is not any more
[33:20] SPEAKER_03: 4 billion or whatever it was, 2 billion poor people.
[33:23] SPEAKER_03: Now it's like 2 billion middle class people.
[33:26] SPEAKER_03: And we're really in a lot of chaos.
[33:28] SPEAKER_03: Products that cost $200 to make in the US cost $10 to make in China.
[33:35] SPEAKER_03: And now the question is,
[33:36] SPEAKER_03: are you going to vote with your wallet or are you going to vote with your morality?
[33:41] SPEAKER_03: Support slave labor because it's cheap and it makes your family more comfortable.
[33:46] SPEAKER_03: Or are you going to buy locally?
[33:48] SPEAKER_03: You know, that cult kind of mantra.
[33:51] SPEAKER_03: I think we're facing that now.
[33:53] SPEAKER_03: And so now you've got a school system that teaches you on an early 20th century model,
[33:59] SPEAKER_03: and we're in the 21st century,
[34:02] SPEAKER_03: so that if you learn what they teach in school,
[34:06] SPEAKER_03: you'll basically be behind the curve.
[34:08] SPEAKER_03: I'm not even talking about artificial intelligence and all the other things that are on the horizon.
[34:14] SPEAKER_03: Just basically...
[34:15] SPEAKER_03: So there's no point in learning a lot of the stuff that's considered basic.
[34:20] SPEAKER_03: I went to college and graduate school and I would never have learned to write if I
[34:24] SPEAKER_03: went through the standard program,
[34:26] SPEAKER_03: liberal arts,
[34:27] SPEAKER_03: graduate school.
[34:28] SPEAKER_03: They never taught me how to write.
[34:30] SPEAKER_03: And at one point I discovered I didn't know how to write because I failed a writing test,
[34:34] SPEAKER_03: which I wasn't actually supposed to even take.
[34:36] SPEAKER_03: But I took by accident and failed.
[34:39] SPEAKER_03: And then I got upset because I thought I wasn't an idiot.
[34:42] SPEAKER_03: And it turned out I was an idiot.
[34:44] SPEAKER_03: And I had to sort of get remedial help on how to write.
[34:48] SPEAKER_03: And it was interesting.
[34:50] SPEAKER_03: You know, I learned a lot.
[34:51] SPEAKER_03: And now I've been writing for a decade so I can write better.
[34:54] SPEAKER_03: But it's definitely a skill.
[34:56] SPEAKER_03: I learned you don't say what you mean.
[34:58] SPEAKER_03: You say what is effective in communicating, which is rarely what you mean.
[35:04] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[35:05] SPEAKER_03: So.
[35:05] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[35:06] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[35:08] SPEAKER_00: Let me ask you this.
[35:09] SPEAKER_00: Do you think that those are the reasons why people seem to be,
[35:13] SPEAKER_00: or maybe I'm wrong on this,
[35:15] SPEAKER_00: I feel as though more and more we've become averse to risk.
[35:20] SPEAKER_00: And students are just terrified of putting themselves out there as far as taking risks.
[35:28] SPEAKER_00: And then the people who do take risks, there's a lot of, I just hear people mock them.
[35:36] SPEAKER_03: for seems to failing well so what's that all about i can't say exactly because it's
[35:43] SPEAKER_03: generational and i'm not in that situation and i don't want to be in that situation
[35:49] SPEAKER_03: i mean if you put me back in high school i wouldn't last a day i'd start breaking
[35:53] SPEAKER_03: windows and uh so in some sense i can't really tell you what it's like to be normal
[36:01] SPEAKER_03: as a student today because i would refuse to be i was a
[36:06] SPEAKER_03: sort of normal student in my own day,
[36:08] SPEAKER_03: which was in the 70s and the 60s,
[36:10] SPEAKER_03: depending which school you talk about.
[36:13] SPEAKER_03: But I wasn't a very good student because I didn't like it.
[36:15] SPEAKER_03: And I knew something was something was not right here.
[36:19] SPEAKER_03: You know, it's like being in a family where nobody cares.
[36:22] SPEAKER_03: That's what school is.
[36:24] SPEAKER_02: Same here.
[36:25] SPEAKER_02: Same experience.
[36:26] SPEAKER_02: Same time.
[36:26] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[36:27] SPEAKER_03: And so after a while, you say something's not right here.
[36:29] SPEAKER_03: Nobody's really doing what I need.
[36:32] SPEAKER_03: I don't really see them doing what anyone needs.
[36:35] SPEAKER_03: And no one's even coming to answer the question of why they're doing anything at all.
[36:39] SPEAKER_03: So I have to say this is my current experience.
[36:45] SPEAKER_03: So we talked about this before.
[36:47] SPEAKER_03: So we talked about the N word, the N word.
[36:50] SPEAKER_03: And it seems to be a real charged word today.
[36:55] SPEAKER_03: And it makes me laugh because there's so many other words that could be charged, you know.
[36:59] SPEAKER_03: But, you know, it's it's the it's the flag.
[37:01] SPEAKER_03: It's the skull on the crossbones flag of socially inappropriate behavior.
[37:07] SPEAKER_03: The ultimate.
[37:09] SPEAKER_03: And it really bugs me because I grew up looking.
[37:12] SPEAKER_03: I wasn't supposed to,
[37:13] SPEAKER_03: but I secretly looked or not secretly just happened to be available to look at the
[37:18] SPEAKER_03: history of 19th century America and racism in the early 20th century.
[37:24] SPEAKER_03: And what was going on in the South and what was what blacks and other colored
[37:29] SPEAKER_03: peoples were subjected to indigenous immigrants,
[37:34] SPEAKER_03: mostly blacks and slavery.
[37:36] SPEAKER_03: And it's so heinous and so awful.
[37:39] SPEAKER_03: And so,
[37:40] SPEAKER_03: so far beyond the pale that for me to feel that everything could be made right by a
[37:46] SPEAKER_03: small newspeak language,
[37:48] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[37:49] SPEAKER_03: gets me all upset.
[37:51] SPEAKER_03: it's similar to the,
[37:51] SPEAKER_03: in Canada,
[37:52] SPEAKER_03: there's a whole sort of reconciliation issue about treating Native Americans with deference,
[37:58] SPEAKER_03: which is also bullshit because it's basically for making white people feel good.
[38:04] SPEAKER_03: And so I think that the prescription against the word nigger is also another one of
[38:07] SPEAKER_03: those things to make white people feel good because you're not actually doing
[38:11] SPEAKER_03: anything and you're not learning what the real crimes were.
[38:15] SPEAKER_03: And it's not about a word.
[38:16] SPEAKER_03: It's how the word was used.
[38:19] SPEAKER_03: And, you know,
[38:21] SPEAKER_03: knife is not bad it's when you stick it in people that it becomes a problem so the
[38:27] SPEAKER_03: word is not bad but it's when you stick that word in people and so by forbidding
[38:31] SPEAKER_03: people to say the word you're then pretending the whole thing never happened and i
[38:35] SPEAKER_03: think it's like saying the holocaust never happened very much like the same thing
[38:39] SPEAKER_02: yeah the absurdity comes when it's stated that the person's reclaiming the word
[38:46] SPEAKER_02: when they're the person that it's come from for example when i was traveling in
[38:51] SPEAKER_02: Europe in 78, right out of high school.
[38:53] SPEAKER_02: And I met a guy and he was in Germany.
[38:55] SPEAKER_02: He was very excited about going to the protest and the, um, pride parade for schools in Germany.
[39:03] SPEAKER_02: Now school is German for like gay boy or sissy or something.
[39:07] SPEAKER_02: I don't know exactly, but they used to call gay folks school.
[39:11] SPEAKER_02: And so he said, we claim the word proudly like Americans did the word gay and
[39:18] SPEAKER_02: And I thought, yeah, just take the word and go, okay, great.
[39:20] SPEAKER_02: I'll be that, whatever.
[39:22] SPEAKER_02: I'm not that, but I'll be that.
[39:24] SPEAKER_02: And it really took the power out of it.
[39:27] SPEAKER_02: But you can't, black folks can't even say that you're on TV.
[39:31] SPEAKER_03: I mean, for a while it was the term of endearment, you know, kind of the boys in the hood kind of thing.
[39:39] SPEAKER_00: Well, it still is.
[39:41] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[39:41] SPEAKER_03: So, but it's actually, you know, so.
[39:45] SPEAKER_02: Not something I couldn't use, but then again, I'm okay with it.
[39:48] SPEAKER_00: I'm totally okay with it.
[39:49] SPEAKER_00: Well, we were talking about risk aversity and where everybody is today, et cetera.
[39:53] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[39:53] SPEAKER_03: so I think the answer is that you'd have to ask that question in the context of a
[39:58] SPEAKER_03: person's environment.
[39:59] SPEAKER_03: So if my son goes to public school next year,
[40:03] SPEAKER_03: he will be in an environment where he's,
[40:05] SPEAKER_03: what,
[40:06] SPEAKER_03: I don't know,
[40:06] SPEAKER_03: not allowed to say the word,
[40:08] SPEAKER_03: punished if he does say the word,
[40:09] SPEAKER_03: made fun of if he,
[40:11] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[40:12] SPEAKER_03: whatever.
[40:13] SPEAKER_03: And the question of is he to be afraid?
[40:16] SPEAKER_03: Should he be afraid?
[40:17] SPEAKER_03: Should he be more cautious?
[40:20] SPEAKER_03: Would have to be answered in terms of, well, what's the reward and what's the punishment?
[40:26] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[40:26] SPEAKER_03: like John Cage had his piece of three and a half minutes of silence where he got
[40:32] SPEAKER_03: out on the stage and sat in front of a piano for three and a half minutes and did nothing.
[40:36] SPEAKER_03: And this was considered dramatic and unfortunate.
[40:39] SPEAKER_03: creative and disruptive when he first did it but if he went out there and like
[40:45] SPEAKER_03: pulled his pants down took a shit on stage or spent three minutes saying it would
[40:50] SPEAKER_03: all have a different effect depending on the time and the audience and it is very
[40:55] SPEAKER_03: much in other words it's not even the act or the word or the performance it's how
[41:00] SPEAKER_03: it's received and the context very much so yeah it's like
[41:05] SPEAKER_03: If you did it in an alley versus a Carnegie Hall, it would be a completely different effect.
[41:10] SPEAKER_03: Oh, yeah.
[41:11] SPEAKER_00: Exactly.
[41:13] SPEAKER_03: Should kids be cautious and fearful?
[41:15] SPEAKER_03: Well, I guess it depends on what they're ready for.
[41:20] SPEAKER_03: Are they being taught how to be courageous?
[41:23] SPEAKER_03: Which is an interesting question.
[41:25] SPEAKER_00: The social media sort of bootstrap them.
[41:27] SPEAKER_00: I mean, you know, just kind of stomp them down into the ground in a way.
[41:31] SPEAKER_03: I don't follow social media enough, but one thing I notice about social media is it mixes ages.
[41:37] SPEAKER_03: I noticed this at least.
[41:39] SPEAKER_03: So my younger son watches older kids presentations on social media.
[41:44] SPEAKER_03: I'm talking about YouTube videos, not just conversations.
[41:48] SPEAKER_03: And he's learning because another thing about conventional schooling is it did not support age mixing.
[41:56] SPEAKER_03: So now we're seeing apparently more age mixing.
[42:00] SPEAKER_03: And then why didn't it support age missing?
[42:02] SPEAKER_03: Was it just bureaucratically convenient?
[42:05] SPEAKER_03: Or was there really some intention not to let people learn from the lessons of the older kids?
[42:11] SPEAKER_00: Which, you know... They used to in the one-room schoolhouse.
[42:15] SPEAKER_03: Well, they kind of did away with that.
[42:17] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[42:18] SPEAKER_00: Well, the thing is that Philip and I...
[42:24] SPEAKER_02: All kinds of things from YouTube that teachers and adults aren't even aware of.
[42:30] SPEAKER_02: And it's forming the culture for sure.
[42:32] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[42:33] SPEAKER_02: Gen alpha is definitely in screen.
[42:38] SPEAKER_03: It's actually funny.
[42:39] SPEAKER_03: I don't listen in on my son's stuff because I don't care and because he's actually
[42:47] SPEAKER_03: relatively trustworthy or very trustworthy.
[42:50] SPEAKER_03: But I hear in conversation with him what he learns.
[42:53] SPEAKER_03: So, for example, he knows the word jizz means – well, it means sperm.
[43:01] SPEAKER_03: He knows ejaculate means to ejaculate sexually.
[43:05] SPEAKER_03: But he doesn't know the word ejaculate also means other things like – Assigned outburst.
[43:10] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[43:11] SPEAKER_03: He didn't know that.
[43:12] SPEAKER_03: So I just find it very funny.
[43:14] SPEAKER_03: I mean, it's kind of like learning sex through Playboy magazines.
[43:17] SPEAKER_03: He knows a few things, but they're kind of twisted and they're kind of wrong.
[43:21] SPEAKER_03: And I don't even want to correct him.
[43:24] SPEAKER_02: Hey, what's wrong about learning sex from Playboy magazines?
[43:31] SPEAKER_02: Come on.
[43:32] SPEAKER_02: My brother was older.
[43:34] SPEAKER_03: And I told my son, what did I ask him?
[43:38] SPEAKER_03: I said,
[43:39] SPEAKER_03: have you been playing doctor at all?
[43:41] SPEAKER_03: He said, what's playing doctor?
[43:42] SPEAKER_03: And I thought everybody plays doctor.
[43:44] SPEAKER_03: Oh,
[43:44] SPEAKER_03: you get the neighborhood girl in the bushes when you're four and you hurt each
[43:49] SPEAKER_03: other or six or eight,
[43:50] SPEAKER_03: or I don't know.
[43:51] SPEAKER_03: It's like everybody I know played doctor.
[43:53] SPEAKER_02: I'll show you mine.
[43:54] SPEAKER_02: You show me yours thing.
[43:56] SPEAKER_00: Pretty much because it's cute.
[43:57] SPEAKER_00: I mean, you're curious.
[43:59] SPEAKER_03: And I think one of the reasons they don't seem to be doing it is because it's not a prohibited thing.
[44:06] SPEAKER_03: Now there's a lot of age mixing.
[44:08] SPEAKER_03: And so everybody knows that they're going to hear from somebody else.
[44:11] SPEAKER_03: They don't have the same level of secrecy.
[44:14] SPEAKER_03: Everybody's talking about whatever he's doing.
[44:15] SPEAKER_03: There's social media.
[44:17] SPEAKER_03: They're seeing it on YouTube.
[44:18] SPEAKER_03: The older girls and the younger girls and boys.
[44:21] SPEAKER_03: And nobody's keeping them apart so that there's the secret mystery that they have
[44:24] SPEAKER_03: to explore in the bushes.
[44:27] SPEAKER_00: But kids aren't playing together as much as they did when we were younger either.
[44:32] SPEAKER_03: Well, mine are.
[44:33] SPEAKER_03: See, that's the difference.
[44:35] SPEAKER_03: Mine are because they're homeschooled.
[44:36] SPEAKER_03: Because they're homeschooled.
[44:38] SPEAKER_00: Oh, okay.
[44:39] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, yeah.
[44:40] SPEAKER_00: But see, I know a lot of – I mean, there are no other kids on our street aside from the kid next door.
[44:47] SPEAKER_00: So they have to arrange play dates.
[44:50] SPEAKER_03: And they do in my case.
[44:51] SPEAKER_00: And then the parents are there during the whole thing observing everything that's going on.
[44:56] SPEAKER_03: Well, not in my case.
[44:57] SPEAKER_03: That may be relative to the situation.
[45:00] SPEAKER_03: In my case, they're off just doing whatever they're doing.
[45:03] SPEAKER_03: Nobody – because –
[45:05] SPEAKER_03: The homeschool group that I'm part of is all a bunch of parents who are homeschooled themselves.
[45:10] SPEAKER_03: They trust their kids to a higher degree, perhaps, than others.
[45:14] SPEAKER_03: And they're off doing what they're doing.
[45:16] SPEAKER_03: They sit on the trampoline for hours and hours, beating each other up, telling dirty jokes.
[45:21] SPEAKER_03: Who knows what they're doing?
[45:23] SPEAKER_02: Right.
[45:23] SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
[45:24] SPEAKER_02: I remember doing that.
[45:25] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[45:26] SPEAKER_02: We did such hazardous things, but it didn't kill any of us.
[45:30] SPEAKER_00: We built dams.
[45:31] SPEAKER_00: We went off into the woods.
[45:34] SPEAKER_00: We hunted.
[45:35] SPEAKER_02: Jumped.
[45:36] SPEAKER_02: We tracked.
[45:37] SPEAKER_02: The jumps were a great thing.
[45:39] SPEAKER_00: We played cops and robbers.
[45:41] SPEAKER_00: We did everything.
[45:42] SPEAKER_00: I mean, we were shooting each other.
[45:45] SPEAKER_00: It was just stuff that we saw.
[45:47] SPEAKER_03: And there is a limit.
[45:49] SPEAKER_03: And there are dangers.
[45:49] SPEAKER_03: There's no doubt.
[45:50] SPEAKER_03: Right.
[45:51] SPEAKER_03: I finally had the BB gun taken away when I shot out most of the windows in my house.
[45:56] SPEAKER_03: Not because I was aiming for them,
[45:57] SPEAKER_03: but because I didn't know that behind the leaves,
[46:00] SPEAKER_03: that the BBs went through the leaves and that there were houses behind the leaves.
[46:03] SPEAKER_03: So, you know, it's just ignorance, right?
[46:06] SPEAKER_03: Well, that was a learning experience.
[46:07] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, but I could have taken somebody's eye out because we were shooting at each other.
[46:10] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[46:11] SPEAKER_02: Oh, we did that.
[46:12] SPEAKER_03: But we wore goggles.
[46:13] SPEAKER_03: Well, you learned about that.
[46:16] SPEAKER_03: But some lessons are bad,
[46:18] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[46:18] SPEAKER_03: like we stopped mountaineering or you should not shoot bullets at each other.
[46:22] SPEAKER_03: That's why there's paint guns and paint armor.
[46:25] SPEAKER_03: There are safe ways to do these things.
[46:27] SPEAKER_03: And so the idea is that you give a person enough latitude to learn.
[46:32] SPEAKER_03: And I think it should be said,
[46:34] SPEAKER_03: so we don't actually fail to say it,
[46:36] SPEAKER_03: that you learn the most by making mistakes.
[46:39] SPEAKER_03: You don't learn by following the rules.
[46:41] SPEAKER_03: All that does is keep you on the path,
[46:44] SPEAKER_03: which life,
[46:45] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[46:45] SPEAKER_03: as soon as the course ends,
[46:47] SPEAKER_03: you're off the path.
[46:48] SPEAKER_03: You know, real life gives you new problems.
[46:51] SPEAKER_03: In my book,
[46:52] SPEAKER_03: I have this story of a kid who joined the army because he wanted to meet girls and
[46:59] SPEAKER_03: became a medic.
[47:01] SPEAKER_03: And his story is that one man,
[47:03] SPEAKER_03: what they teach you as a medic when you're in the battlefield,
[47:05] SPEAKER_03: it's completely different.
[47:06] SPEAKER_03: You know, you don't like suture up a cut or tie off an artery.
[47:10] SPEAKER_03: You have somebody with their arm blown off.
[47:12] SPEAKER_01: Right.
[47:13] SPEAKER_03: You know, like that.
[47:14] SPEAKER_03: And the lesson he said was whatever it is you're going to do,
[47:17] SPEAKER_03: you've got to do something in his case because you've got eight minutes before the
[47:21] SPEAKER_03: person dies and no idea what to do next.
[47:25] SPEAKER_03: And it was a very interesting story because he said it's interesting because as the medic,
[47:31] SPEAKER_03: everybody thought he was God because it was him that was going to determine the
[47:36] SPEAKER_03: life or death of their friends.
[47:38] SPEAKER_03: And that became very traumatic for him because he couldn't do it.
[47:42] SPEAKER_03: all he could do was the best he could do.
[47:44] SPEAKER_03: And he didn't know whether they were going to survive or not.
[47:47] SPEAKER_03: And they would, you know, in the battlefield, he'd be given dead people and be told to fix them.
[47:52] SPEAKER_03: And he'd have to like say,
[47:53] SPEAKER_03: okay,
[47:54] SPEAKER_03: I'll make them better because nothing else was as acceptable in terms of response.
[47:59] SPEAKER_03: And then he got all kind of fucked up personally feeling, you know, an imposter of some kind.
[48:05] SPEAKER_03: So, I mean, this is like heavy stuff and you don't really want to go that far.
[48:11] SPEAKER_03: That's like too far.
[48:13] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[48:13] SPEAKER_00: But in the same moment,
[48:15] SPEAKER_00: though,
[48:15] SPEAKER_00: probably just realizing and being slightly creative with what he had learned,
[48:22] SPEAKER_00: he could apply that to whatever it was.
[48:24] SPEAKER_00: I mean, depending.
[48:25] SPEAKER_00: He did.
[48:26] SPEAKER_00: But it also depends on his mindset at the time and how frozen that is with the trauma.
[48:31] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[48:31] SPEAKER_03: Well, it's an interesting story.
[48:32] SPEAKER_03: You should read it.
[48:33] SPEAKER_03: And you tell your readers to go look at that book.
[48:35] SPEAKER_03: Everybody's story is different.
[48:37] SPEAKER_00: I'm halfway through that book right now.
[48:39] SPEAKER_00: You're talking about the learning project.
[48:42] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[48:43] SPEAKER_03: Story of Dave Williamson learning to be a doctor.
[48:46] SPEAKER_02: We're kicking around this subject and we started with,
[48:50] SPEAKER_02: maybe we started with the thesis of,
[48:52] SPEAKER_02: okay,
[48:53] SPEAKER_02: what do we do with the structure of school today?
[48:56] SPEAKER_02: If we do anything at all, you know, what's the future of learning in the world?
[49:03] SPEAKER_02: And we've kicked around all these subjects and it keeps coming back to that.
[49:06] SPEAKER_02: We learned our best lessons from our life experience.
[49:10] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it sounds like almost all of us had to, it wasn't within the school day per se.
[49:17] SPEAKER_02: It was like the monumental things that happened to us.
[49:21] SPEAKER_02: At least we thought they were, you know, like Dave, things like that.
[49:24] SPEAKER_02: That was a huge learning experience and very valuable, relevant,
[49:29] SPEAKER_02: And so we're kind of kicking around.
[49:31] SPEAKER_02: The more we kick it around, the more I realized that I think the structure itself of schools is gone.
[49:39] SPEAKER_02: It's out-served its usefulness.
[49:41] SPEAKER_02: It's no longer needed.
[49:44] SPEAKER_02: I don't know what's next,
[49:45] SPEAKER_02: but I would love to kick it around with very intelligent people for a while and
[49:50] SPEAKER_02: come up with a plan because I think the way schools are now is
[49:54] SPEAKER_02: I keep coming back to the same conclusion.
[49:56] SPEAKER_02: They're inefficient.
[49:58] SPEAKER_02: They're unnecessary.
[49:59] SPEAKER_02: They're irrelevant.
[50:00] SPEAKER_00: That's why we have that burgeoning absenteeism.
[50:05] SPEAKER_00: I think maybe almost 50% now.
[50:08] SPEAKER_03: I would also say the whole argument creates these factions with their own attitudes and arguments.
[50:17] SPEAKER_03: And,
[50:17] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[50:17] SPEAKER_03: if you had a teacher,
[50:19] SPEAKER_03: somebody who was trained as a teacher and earned their profession as a teacher,
[50:24] SPEAKER_03: defending what they did.
[50:26] SPEAKER_03: They tell you how useful it was and how relevant it was and how well, you know, various things.
[50:35] SPEAKER_03: And it can't be denied that there is some relevance and usefulness utility.
[50:40] SPEAKER_03: The question is, is it efficient?
[50:42] SPEAKER_03: Are they efficient?
[50:43] SPEAKER_03: Are they adaptive?
[50:45] SPEAKER_03: Are they making use?
[50:47] SPEAKER_03: Are they valuing other people's time?
[50:50] SPEAKER_03: And are they unbiased?
[50:51] SPEAKER_03: Well, they're clearly biased.
[50:53] SPEAKER_03: Another girl in my book who said when she went home from school,
[50:59] SPEAKER_03: she'd be interested in all kinds of things,
[51:01] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[51:01] SPEAKER_03: cooking,
[51:02] SPEAKER_03: animals,
[51:03] SPEAKER_03: ecology,
[51:03] SPEAKER_03: the weather.
[51:05] SPEAKER_03: But then she went to school and she had no interest in doing anything.
[51:08] SPEAKER_03: She would just sit there and, you know, become a zombie.
[51:13] SPEAKER_03: And then it was irrelevant.
[51:14] SPEAKER_03: And at some point she said, you know, I can teach myself.
[51:18] SPEAKER_03: You know, I don't have to.
[51:20] SPEAKER_03: I mean, it's kind of a mysterious thing.
[51:22] SPEAKER_03: I think we'll never figure out what triggers learning.
[51:24] SPEAKER_03: But something triggered her, and she said, I have an open mind.
[51:27] SPEAKER_03: I can actually go somewhere with these resources.
[51:32] SPEAKER_03: And then it became a personal mission for her.
[51:35] SPEAKER_00: Is this the one that went to South America?
[51:38] SPEAKER_03: No,
[51:38] SPEAKER_03: this was the one who went to a Sudbury school,
[51:40] SPEAKER_03: which didn't teach her anything,
[51:41] SPEAKER_03: and she didn't learn anything until she got to this point where she decided she
[51:44] SPEAKER_03: wanted to learn everything.
[51:46] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[51:47] SPEAKER_03: She was off and running.
[51:48] SPEAKER_03: There it is, yeah.
[51:50] SPEAKER_03: And I think that's what well, I have to go back to where I started.
[51:55] SPEAKER_03: There is social learning.
[51:56] SPEAKER_03: There is book learning.
[51:58] SPEAKER_03: And then there's creative learning or learning to take risks.
[52:01] SPEAKER_03: And so, yeah, there's a dwindling place for yesterday's book learning.
[52:08] SPEAKER_03: There's still a place,
[52:09] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[52:09] SPEAKER_03: there's still things you can do,
[52:10] SPEAKER_03: learning to read,
[52:11] SPEAKER_03: write and do mathematics.
[52:13] SPEAKER_03: But, you know, it's a tremendous waste of time.
[52:17] SPEAKER_03: Ten years when you're only 20 years old is half your life.
[52:21] SPEAKER_03: And to spend it eight hours a day, 90% wasted, is not efficient.
[52:28] SPEAKER_03: It's not good for you.
[52:28] SPEAKER_03: It's not good for the culture.
[52:30] SPEAKER_03: And it's not good for whatever profession or pursuit you're going to focus on later is.
[52:36] SPEAKER_00: And as I told Philip,
[52:38] SPEAKER_00: there's the statistic that the educational outcomes,
[52:43] SPEAKER_00: or whatever you want to call them,
[52:45] SPEAKER_00: are only affected by schools 1% to 14%.
[52:49] SPEAKER_02: I have a hard time believing that.
[52:50] SPEAKER_02: I go 14 is the max, but there it is.
[52:53] SPEAKER_00: 14 is the max because most of the learning is done outside of school.
[52:58] SPEAKER_03: So that's what we should do.
[53:00] SPEAKER_03: We being the royal, no, not the royal, the collective we.
[53:06] SPEAKER_03: We should take less time.
[53:09] SPEAKER_03: You know, this is what I would say.
[53:10] SPEAKER_03: Schooling should be reduced to like four hours,
[53:13] SPEAKER_03: four days a week instead of eight hours,
[53:15] SPEAKER_03: five days a week.
[53:16] SPEAKER_03: That would be an improvement.
[53:18] SPEAKER_03: I'd agree.
[53:19] SPEAKER_03: And that would scale it down.
[53:21] SPEAKER_03: And then the question would be, okay, now you have some extra time.
[53:24] SPEAKER_03: You don't want the kids turning into like gang warfare or whatever wastes of time
[53:31] SPEAKER_03: or antisocial behavior could develop.
[53:34] SPEAKER_03: So then you've got to provide something else and the structure isn't there.
[53:38] SPEAKER_03: It's just not there.
[53:40] SPEAKER_03: So people,
[53:42] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[53:42] SPEAKER_03: it'd be nice if you can afford to send your kid to wilderness school and maybe that
[53:47] SPEAKER_03: would be the
[53:48] SPEAKER_03: aim but now most parents probably have jobs that mean they're not home during the
[53:56] SPEAKER_03: day and they can't provide which is sort of the whole purpose of school or
[54:00] SPEAKER_03: conventional school to be daycare um so you so then you know the one faction says
[54:06] SPEAKER_03: well we take what is school now and we improve it and the other faction says we
[54:11] SPEAKER_03: just we just throw it out and create something new
[54:14] SPEAKER_03: My personal feeling is that you get further by throwing it out and creating
[54:17] SPEAKER_03: something new because there's so much momentum and so much rigidity in the system.
[54:22] SPEAKER_03: What are you going to do?
[54:23] SPEAKER_03: Go to the principal of your high school and get them to wear flower and go play in the sandbox?
[54:29] SPEAKER_03: It's never going to happen.
[54:32] SPEAKER_03: This is what I've learned from therapy is that once you're an adult,
[54:35] SPEAKER_03: you're kind of locked into your mindset.
[54:37] SPEAKER_03: You're invested in many ways, psychologically, economically and culturally.
[54:42] SPEAKER_03: So I don't think that,
[54:44] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[54:44] SPEAKER_03: and this is what Gatto says,
[54:46] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[54:46] SPEAKER_03: just somewhere between just leave it and burn it down.
[54:49] SPEAKER_03: I mean, burning it down is not very nice because, you know, there are people inside.
[54:54] SPEAKER_03: But leaving it means that you have to have somewhere else to go or not.
[54:59] SPEAKER_03: I mean, there is also truth in that.
[55:01] SPEAKER_03: And I tell my clients this.
[55:03] SPEAKER_03: It's not bad to not know.
[55:05] SPEAKER_03: Not knowing is the beginning of learning.
[55:08] SPEAKER_03: So before you have an answer to anything, you're going to not know.
[55:12] SPEAKER_03: And that's going to maybe a long, a big place of not knowing.
[55:16] SPEAKER_03: As big as whatever it is you're going to need to fill it with.
[55:19] SPEAKER_02: I've also found that by knowing some things doesn't improve the situation anyway.
[55:24] SPEAKER_02: It is what it is.
[55:26] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it's nice to know the why, but it's happening.
[55:30] SPEAKER_00: Well, I think you need to start with the why.
[55:32] SPEAKER_02: Hmm.
[55:34] SPEAKER_02: But,
[55:34] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[55:34] SPEAKER_02: if you're getting your butt kicked,
[55:36] SPEAKER_02: you're thinking more about getting butt kicked,
[55:37] SPEAKER_02: working on it,
[55:38] SPEAKER_02: instead of why.
[55:39] SPEAKER_02: And if you do know why, it's like, eh, still butt kicking.
[55:42] SPEAKER_03: Well, the rule in therapy is, you know, stop the injury.
[55:48] SPEAKER_03: You know, when there's an injury, the first thing to do is stop the crime.
[55:54] SPEAKER_03: So if you would think that you sort of transform that to education, you would say stop the miseducation.
[56:02] SPEAKER_02: Right.
[56:03] SPEAKER_02: The structure itself is what's causing the harm and impeding the progress completely.
[56:09] SPEAKER_03: So I would consider going to most compulsory education an abuse,
[56:14] SPEAKER_03: an abuse of another person's personal value.
[56:17] SPEAKER_03: So I would say stop that.
[56:19] SPEAKER_03: And you would say, well, what are we going to do?
[56:21] SPEAKER_03: And I don't know what you're going to do,
[56:22] SPEAKER_03: but you're going to have to stop it first and have to go into that we don't know space.
[56:27] SPEAKER_03: It's like when the Iron Curtain went down.
[56:32] SPEAKER_03: In the Eastern countries, they didn't know what to do.
[56:34] SPEAKER_03: Nobody had ever been even allowed to talk in public.
[56:38] SPEAKER_03: And they were supposed to now figure something out.
[56:40] SPEAKER_03: And I had a friend who was part of the solidarity movement in Poland when the place became democratic.
[56:47] SPEAKER_03: And he said, you just have to let people talk.
[56:49] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, he's one of those people.
[56:52] SPEAKER_03: And he said, you just have to let people vent.
[56:53] SPEAKER_03: They would say the craziest things and you couldn't stop them.
[56:56] SPEAKER_03: They just had to get it out of their system.
[56:58] SPEAKER_03: For a long time, just a whole period of chaos.
[57:02] SPEAKER_03: before you could even settle down to say,
[57:04] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[57:05] SPEAKER_03: we see this,
[57:05] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[57:05] SPEAKER_03: when you have an emotional conflict,
[57:08] SPEAKER_03: you just have to,
[57:09] SPEAKER_03: to some extent,
[57:10] SPEAKER_03: let it burn out.
[57:11] SPEAKER_03: You can't like stick your foot in it and wrench it to the ground and think you've solved anything.
[57:16] SPEAKER_03: It's not even,
[57:17] SPEAKER_03: well,
[57:18] SPEAKER_03: like Tony says,
[57:19] SPEAKER_03: it's not even,
[57:20] SPEAKER_03: you haven't even asked the question of why yet,
[57:23] SPEAKER_03: or whatever the question was,
[57:24] SPEAKER_03: what,
[57:25] SPEAKER_03: why,
[57:25] SPEAKER_03: how,
[57:26] SPEAKER_03: all those questions have to be asked.
[57:28] SPEAKER_00: I think fundamentally, if you want to change the system, you're going to have to answer, why change it?
[57:35] SPEAKER_00: And then you can say the what, which is to what?
[57:41] SPEAKER_00: What do you want it to be?
[57:44] SPEAKER_00: But if you know why you want to change it,
[57:47] SPEAKER_00: then that would be almost a natural transformation to the what.
[57:53] SPEAKER_03: I don't think you'll have agreement.
[57:55] SPEAKER_03: on one just when you get agreement on the other, right?
[57:57] SPEAKER_03: So you're going to work the separate questions, right?
[58:00] SPEAKER_03: Separate questions.
[58:01] SPEAKER_00: Well,
[58:01] SPEAKER_00: you never will because look at how many people have opinions on what education is
[58:07] SPEAKER_00: and what it should be.
[58:09] SPEAKER_00: Everybody, I mean, opinions are like assholes.
[58:12] SPEAKER_00: Everybody has one, right?
[58:14] SPEAKER_00: So how are you going to figure this out?
[58:18] SPEAKER_00: Now, if we say we need the policymakers to do it, that's what got us here in the first place.
[58:24] SPEAKER_00: Because we know that fewer than 40%,
[58:27] SPEAKER_00: actually fewer than 20% of policymakers have any idea of what goes on in education
[58:34] SPEAKER_00: or what education is.
[58:35] SPEAKER_00: And maybe that's not such a bad thing when you're trying to form something.
[58:40] SPEAKER_00: So you need to have a decent melange of people who are looking at this.
[58:47] SPEAKER_00: And most likely you want to have the kids tell you what it is that they want as well,
[58:52] SPEAKER_00: because they're the ones who are being impacted.
[58:55] SPEAKER_03: They're also the ones who know they're on the front lines, as it were.
[58:58] SPEAKER_03: They know what the real challenge is and the real social milieu is.
[59:05] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[59:05] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[59:06] SPEAKER_00: I was thinking today because I was thinking about transformation, right?
[59:12] SPEAKER_00: while I was reading your books.
[59:14] SPEAKER_00: And I was thinking about a survey that I used to give the kids at the beginning of
[59:20] SPEAKER_00: the year,
[59:21] SPEAKER_00: which is,
[59:22] SPEAKER_00: what is it that you want from school this year?
[59:25] SPEAKER_00: What can we do in order to get you to where you need to be?
[59:30] SPEAKER_00: And how would you like to get there?
[59:32] SPEAKER_00: And what else do you want to learn?
[59:36] SPEAKER_00: And my last year, everybody looked at me and said,
[59:41] SPEAKER_00: Why would you give them something like that?
[59:43] SPEAKER_00: Well, what age are you addressing?
[59:44] SPEAKER_00: These are juniors and seniors in high school.
[59:47] SPEAKER_03: Yeah,
[59:47] SPEAKER_03: well,
[59:47] SPEAKER_03: I think that's pretty precocious,
[59:49] SPEAKER_03: expecting them to have answers when they never even asked that question before.
[59:54] SPEAKER_00: And I said, because it tells us where they're coming from.
[59:58] SPEAKER_00: It tells us what they want.
[59:59] SPEAKER_00: It puts expectations on us on how we're going to serve them,
[1:00:02] SPEAKER_00: because I never saw teachers as being like the dictators of a classroom.
[1:00:08] SPEAKER_00: I saw us as being,
[1:00:10] SPEAKER_00: as you would say,
[1:00:10] SPEAKER_00: a mentor or somebody who's there to help guide them in the direction that they want
[1:00:16] SPEAKER_00: to go.
[1:00:17] SPEAKER_00: And so this gave us more information for that.
[1:00:21] SPEAKER_00: And yet I had these people who were against that.
[1:00:23] SPEAKER_00: And I thought, wow, when I leave this year, that's going to be the end of this.
[1:00:30] SPEAKER_00: And I was right.
[1:00:32] SPEAKER_00: It's really interesting.
[1:00:34] SPEAKER_00: Because they've taken,
[1:00:36] SPEAKER_00: and this is alternative education,
[1:00:38] SPEAKER_00: they've tried to transform it back into a mainstream classroom kind of role or environment.
[1:00:47] SPEAKER_02: Well, that's what I was going to say, too, because the structure is the way it is.
[1:00:51] SPEAKER_02: Whether or not you want to be a semi-dictator, you have to be.
[1:00:56] SPEAKER_02: It's set up that way.
[1:00:57] SPEAKER_02: Yes.
[1:00:59] SPEAKER_02: If you come into class late, where's your tardy note?
[1:01:03] SPEAKER_02: I did attendance.
[1:01:04] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, it's just, yeah.
[1:01:09] SPEAKER_03: I was given a tour in the local high school, and you're walking down the hall with a group of
[1:01:16] SPEAKER_03: kids and parents who are going to be entering in ninth grade next year.
[1:01:21] SPEAKER_03: And each classroom has a teacher standing at the door and there's some work,
[1:01:29] SPEAKER_03: artwork or otherwise work on the bulletin board in the hall.
[1:01:34] SPEAKER_03: You can see what they're doing.
[1:01:35] SPEAKER_03: They're saying,
[1:01:36] SPEAKER_03: oh,
[1:01:36] SPEAKER_03: and then we went into a room where the math teacher and they had a little game they
[1:01:39] SPEAKER_03: did on the board for everybody.
[1:01:41] SPEAKER_03: And it's going through my head as, oh, they're showing us
[1:01:46] SPEAKER_03: how much fun we're going to have, how interesting the material is going to be.
[1:01:51] SPEAKER_03: And I'm just thinking this to myself, this just looks like a prison.
[1:01:55] SPEAKER_03: These are the bar doors and these are the small windows that you can see out.
[1:02:00] SPEAKER_03: And this is going to be your life run by bells and halls and the,
[1:02:05] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:02:05] SPEAKER_03: 90% required courses and some small amount of latitude and a little time during the
[1:02:11] SPEAKER_03: day when you can go eat.
[1:02:13] SPEAKER_03: or play outside.
[1:02:13] SPEAKER_03: This is just a prison.
[1:02:14] SPEAKER_03: It's just a prison with a different kind of clothing on.
[1:02:17] SPEAKER_03: Instead of orange jumpsuits, you get to wear something else.
[1:02:21] SPEAKER_03: I would have liked to have stopped and said to each teacher that that's what I felt they were doing.
[1:02:25] SPEAKER_03: And they couldn't receive that.
[1:02:27] SPEAKER_03: It would be against everything.
[1:02:29] SPEAKER_03: And it would be a violation of what they think they're doing.
[1:02:32] SPEAKER_03: It's like to admit that you were just imprisoning people when your whole sort of
[1:02:36] SPEAKER_03: sense of validity was the idea of your power.
[1:02:40] SPEAKER_03: So,
[1:02:40] SPEAKER_03: I would say,
[1:02:41] SPEAKER_03: though,
[1:02:42] SPEAKER_03: to muddy the waters again,
[1:02:44] SPEAKER_03: that I know kids who went to Waldorf schools who in their last years refused to go
[1:02:49] SPEAKER_03: to the Waldorf schools anymore and insisted that they go to the public high school
[1:02:53] SPEAKER_03: because they wanted to see what life was to other people,
[1:02:57] SPEAKER_03: not just the select enlightened few.
[1:02:59] SPEAKER_00: Oh, an exchange program.
[1:03:02] SPEAKER_03: They were going to really matriculate it into high school.
[1:03:05] SPEAKER_03: And they were going to get lockers and they were going to, you know, the whole thing.
[1:03:09] SPEAKER_03: And they were willing to do it because they wanted to.
[1:03:11] SPEAKER_03: I mean, this is the cut.
[1:03:13] SPEAKER_03: They were fearless kids.
[1:03:14] SPEAKER_03: They weren't entirely foolish.
[1:03:16] SPEAKER_03: They wanted to meet girls and meet boys and have opportunities and see what made
[1:03:21] SPEAKER_03: the rest of the world tick.
[1:03:23] SPEAKER_03: Because all of our schools are a little, you know, Germanic.
[1:03:27] SPEAKER_00: Different.
[1:03:27] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:03:28] SPEAKER_00: So you said that you wrote that your son went to a non-manipulative school?
[1:03:34] SPEAKER_03: Well, he went to a Summerhill-like school.
[1:03:36] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[1:03:37] SPEAKER_03: Okay.
[1:03:38] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:03:39] SPEAKER_00: What does that mean, non-manipulative?
[1:03:42] SPEAKER_03: Well, in his case, it meant that there were no classes, no teachers, no grades.
[1:03:47] SPEAKER_03: The only thing there was was a schedule.
[1:03:49] SPEAKER_03: They wanted you to come in the morning and stay till the end of the afternoon.
[1:03:54] SPEAKER_03: But most kids rebelled against that.
[1:03:56] SPEAKER_03: They wanted to come as soon as they woke up in the morning and they wanted to stay
[1:04:01] SPEAKER_03: all day into the night.
[1:04:03] SPEAKER_03: You know, they wanted it to be their whole world rather than be requiring you to be.
[1:04:07] SPEAKER_03: It turned out to be a limitation.
[1:04:09] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[1:04:09] SPEAKER_03: we just can't stand you here too much because we actually have to clean up this
[1:04:12] SPEAKER_03: place and get some work done.
[1:04:16] SPEAKER_03: And that was his school.
[1:04:18] SPEAKER_03: And then, you know, when he got he graduated, they have a graduation thing.
[1:04:22] SPEAKER_03: He basically turned to me and said, what the fuck did you do to me?
[1:04:24] SPEAKER_03: I don't know anything.
[1:04:25] SPEAKER_03: I can't get into college.
[1:04:27] SPEAKER_03: I have no credentials.
[1:04:29] SPEAKER_03: You know, what did you do to me?
[1:04:32] SPEAKER_03: And,
[1:04:32] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:04:32] SPEAKER_03: I kind of had to laugh because he,
[1:04:37] SPEAKER_03: you never appreciate what's done to you unless you see it have an effect.
[1:04:41] SPEAKER_03: And it wasn't until he went to college and now he's like been the star college
[1:04:45] SPEAKER_03: student for the last six years and now sort of runs the whole program.
[1:04:51] SPEAKER_03: And the joke that the college professors would say is that kids from these programs
[1:04:55] SPEAKER_03: are so obnoxious because they actually know what they want to do.
[1:05:00] SPEAKER_03: And they ask questions.
[1:05:02] SPEAKER_03: And they ask questions.
[1:05:04] SPEAKER_03: So annoying.
[1:05:05] SPEAKER_03: Good ones.
[1:05:07] SPEAKER_03: So, I mean, and this sort of answers your question of are kids afraid to do things?
[1:05:13] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[1:05:13] SPEAKER_03: yeah,
[1:05:14] SPEAKER_03: if you're going to get all your adults all the way up,
[1:05:16] SPEAKER_03: as far as you can see,
[1:05:18] SPEAKER_03: telling you that you're not supposed to be asking questions,
[1:05:20] SPEAKER_03: you're not supposed to know what you're doing.
[1:05:23] SPEAKER_03: If they all tell you that, at some point, most kids will start to believe it.
[1:05:27] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I'm 67 and I'm still finally waking up to the fact that all these people were full of shit.
[1:05:35] SPEAKER_03: They were all constricted in their view by some something, some legacy knowledge systems.
[1:05:43] SPEAKER_03: And that, I mean, so maybe this is the final thing.
[1:05:46] SPEAKER_03: How do you get creative?
[1:05:48] SPEAKER_03: And being creative is like the fundamental skill of awareness.
[1:05:55] SPEAKER_03: And in any field, there's a boundary.
[1:05:58] SPEAKER_03: And on the other side of the boundary is this world of dangerous ignorance,
[1:06:03] SPEAKER_03: which you have to go into if you want to learn something new.
[1:06:07] SPEAKER_03: And it is ignorant and it is dangerous and you'll feel unprepared.
[1:06:13] SPEAKER_03: And that's where all new knowledge comes from.
[1:06:19] SPEAKER_03: Sometimes it's organic growth, and other times it's revolutionary destruction.
[1:06:24] SPEAKER_03: And you may not even know.
[1:06:25] SPEAKER_03: It's like this kid with his mother.
[1:06:27] SPEAKER_03: Is he going to be received well when he tells her his problems are actually her problems?
[1:06:34] SPEAKER_03: I can't tell him, except that I know that that's where the answer is going to have to come.
[1:06:39] SPEAKER_01: Mm-hmm.
[1:06:40] SPEAKER_00: Wow.
[1:06:42] SPEAKER_00: So I'm trying to think.
[1:06:45] SPEAKER_03: And nothing happened.
[1:06:45] SPEAKER_00: Well, yeah, exactly.
[1:06:47] SPEAKER_00: Yeah.
[1:06:47] SPEAKER_02: And then that's good moments where you go, that's a good thing.
[1:06:51] SPEAKER_00: That's not a bad thing.
[1:06:53] SPEAKER_02: I mean, yeah.
[1:06:54] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[1:06:55] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[1:06:55] SPEAKER_02: the failure I was working with kids today,
[1:06:58] SPEAKER_02: they were making a roller coasters out of the foam pipe wrap cut in half and then marbles.
[1:07:06] SPEAKER_02: And this one kid was getting frustrated.
[1:07:08] SPEAKER_02: It's failure in this course.
[1:07:09] SPEAKER_02: And I said,
[1:07:10] SPEAKER_02: Okay, let's say it's perfect and it runs great.
[1:07:14] SPEAKER_02: Then what?
[1:07:15] SPEAKER_02: And he goes, oh, I want to keep tinkering with it.
[1:07:18] SPEAKER_02: And I go, uh-huh.
[1:07:20] SPEAKER_02: So the failure is just part of your fun, isn't it?
[1:07:22] SPEAKER_02: And he goes, oh, yeah.
[1:07:25] SPEAKER_02: I go, yeah, it's part of the process, dude.
[1:07:27] SPEAKER_02: It's the most of it.
[1:07:29] SPEAKER_00: Well, if you don't fail, you don't learn.
[1:07:32] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[1:07:32] SPEAKER_02: I mean, you got to see if it works and it's not working.
[1:07:34] SPEAKER_03: Well, the downside is that it can be very frustrating to fail over and over again.
[1:07:39] SPEAKER_03: It takes a special kind of spine to endure.
[1:07:44] SPEAKER_02: And just to go, you have to kind of enjoy the failure and go, no, it's part of it.
[1:07:51] SPEAKER_02: But you need to be resilient in order to do that.
[1:07:54] SPEAKER_00: And do we really teach resilience?
[1:07:56] SPEAKER_00: No.
[1:07:58] SPEAKER_03: And I'm not even sure.
[1:08:00] SPEAKER_03: Well, I mean, like the,
[1:08:01] SPEAKER_03: the kid I was talking to the other day,
[1:08:03] SPEAKER_03: he said,
[1:08:04] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:08:04] SPEAKER_03: I'm kind of procrastinate and I don't get things done and I don't really know how
[1:08:08] SPEAKER_03: to organize.
[1:08:09] SPEAKER_03: I said, well, look, there are structures to organize.
[1:08:12] SPEAKER_03: You do an outline and then you do a schedule and then you work according to the
[1:08:16] SPEAKER_03: schedule and you see if anything's productive.
[1:08:18] SPEAKER_03: And then you look at it and see whether you're left with anything.
[1:08:21] SPEAKER_03: And then you fix it.
[1:08:21] SPEAKER_03: You know, you iterate, you go back and say, Oh, a new schedule, maybe a new outline.
[1:08:26] SPEAKER_03: And then hopefully, uh,
[1:08:28] SPEAKER_03: In this process, you have some discernment and discretion and you try to polish things up.
[1:08:33] SPEAKER_03: You see some ideas, you get new ones, you throw out old ones.
[1:08:36] SPEAKER_03: And it's an incremental process, sort of iterative and hopefully progressive.
[1:08:42] SPEAKER_03: And time management is a big thing because you do set a limit to how much you're going to put up with.
[1:08:50] SPEAKER_03: And I told him, don't take the...
[1:08:54] SPEAKER_03: structure that you're given as the right structure if you're told to produce a
[1:08:57] SPEAKER_03: four-page paper by thursday and you don't think you can but you could produce an
[1:09:02] SPEAKER_03: eight-page paper in a month then you should just put your foot down and say i have
[1:09:08] SPEAKER_03: an insight and this is where it takes me and i'll give you an eight-page paper in a
[1:09:12] SPEAKER_03: month and if you don't like it too bad and a good teacher would say wonderful i'll
[1:09:18] SPEAKER_03: do everything i can support you but then most teachers won't because they won't get
[1:09:22] SPEAKER_03: it and
[1:09:23] SPEAKER_03: And then you have to live with the result, the consequences.
[1:09:29] SPEAKER_03: And that's perhaps the most important thing,
[1:09:31] SPEAKER_03: to learn how to stand up for yourself and believe in your own insight.
[1:09:38] SPEAKER_00: Well, just to have the agency.
[1:09:40] SPEAKER_00: But you also have to understand the consequences.
[1:09:42] SPEAKER_00: And if you can't live with the consequences,
[1:09:44] SPEAKER_00: if you haven't figured those out,
[1:09:46] SPEAKER_00: I mean,
[1:09:46] SPEAKER_00: how do we teach consequential factoring?
[1:09:50] SPEAKER_00: If I, you know, cause and effect.
[1:09:52] SPEAKER_00: That used to be something that they wanted us to teach.
[1:09:57] SPEAKER_00: They also wanted us to hold people accountable.
[1:09:59] SPEAKER_00: And as soon as they said start holding people accountable, they stopped holding people accountable.
[1:10:06] SPEAKER_02: But is the criteria and the consequence relevant?
[1:10:09] SPEAKER_02: For example,
[1:10:11] SPEAKER_02: when you were speaking about this,
[1:10:12] SPEAKER_02: Lincoln,
[1:10:12] SPEAKER_02: you were saying how,
[1:10:13] SPEAKER_02: okay,
[1:10:14] SPEAKER_02: I can't do that paper,
[1:10:15] SPEAKER_02: but I want to do more and give you this.
[1:10:18] SPEAKER_02: And I thought while you were speaking, what the heck's with due dates?
[1:10:22] SPEAKER_02: I mean, honestly, they're there for the convenience of the teacher and the system only.
[1:10:27] SPEAKER_02: There's no due date in life per se.
[1:10:30] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[1:10:30] SPEAKER_03: the more courageous answer would be this whole assignment is bullshit and this
[1:10:34] SPEAKER_03: subject is useless and I'm going to spend my time somewhere else.
[1:10:38] SPEAKER_03: That would be the most courageous.
[1:10:40] SPEAKER_03: See, I'll give you my example.
[1:10:42] SPEAKER_03: I said in high school, gym class is a waste of my time.
[1:10:46] SPEAKER_03: I want to go do bike racing.
[1:10:48] SPEAKER_03: I'm going to cut gym class, and I'm going to race my bike around the neighborhood.
[1:10:52] SPEAKER_03: And I did that until I was finally caught and sent to the principal.
[1:10:57] SPEAKER_03: And I said, I was very forward.
[1:10:59] SPEAKER_03: I said, this is a waste of my time.
[1:11:01] SPEAKER_03: This is what I'm doing.
[1:11:02] SPEAKER_03: And I actually got the otherwise, you know,
[1:11:05] SPEAKER_03: semi-retarded gym teacher to support me.
[1:11:08] SPEAKER_03: He said, yeah, it's a good idea.
[1:11:10] SPEAKER_03: He should do it,
[1:11:11] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:11:12] SPEAKER_03: because he appreciated building physical strength and he could see that I was going
[1:11:17] SPEAKER_03: to do it.
[1:11:18] SPEAKER_03: But the principal couldn't support me.
[1:11:20] SPEAKER_03: And so I ended up,
[1:11:21] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:11:22] SPEAKER_03: getting punished or something,
[1:11:24] SPEAKER_03: some bullshit,
[1:11:24] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:11:25] SPEAKER_03: didn't really mean much.
[1:11:27] SPEAKER_03: But,
[1:11:28] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:11:29] SPEAKER_03: the alternative to writing a four page,
[1:11:31] SPEAKER_03: eight page paper when you're asked to write a four page paper is to say,
[1:11:35] SPEAKER_03: you know, I'm not going to write any paper at all.
[1:11:38] SPEAKER_03: I'm going to sit in my house and paint a picture because that's what I like to do.
[1:11:42] SPEAKER_02: Well, I was assuming that he was, or she were into that subject so much.
[1:11:46] SPEAKER_02: They go, you know what?
[1:11:47] SPEAKER_02: A four page paper is just make work.
[1:11:49] SPEAKER_02: I'm into this.
[1:11:50] SPEAKER_02: I want to give it more.
[1:11:52] SPEAKER_03: Well, that would be nice.
[1:11:53] SPEAKER_03: Then you'll get rewarded.
[1:11:54] SPEAKER_03: But what you want to do is I want to go out.
[1:11:57] SPEAKER_03: I want to hang out in the neighborhood and listen to what people are saying for the
[1:12:01] SPEAKER_03: rest of the semester,
[1:12:02] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:12:03] SPEAKER_03: or,
[1:12:03] SPEAKER_03: or,
[1:12:05] SPEAKER_02: I mean, you know, whatever.
[1:12:07] SPEAKER_02: What do you plan on gaining from that?
[1:12:09] SPEAKER_02: Let's come up with a preliminary idea and find out it probably isn't even relevant anymore.
[1:12:16] SPEAKER_02: But have an idea of what you're looking at.
[1:12:18] SPEAKER_02: I think that's good.
[1:12:19] SPEAKER_02: What you want to do.
[1:12:20] SPEAKER_03: I think that's a reasonable thing.
[1:12:21] SPEAKER_03: You could say, look, this is another story in my book.
[1:12:24] SPEAKER_03: As a teacher or as whatever my role is, supervisory role, I'm here to help you do something.
[1:12:30] SPEAKER_03: So let's figure out something.
[1:12:32] SPEAKER_03: That's meaningful.
[1:12:33] SPEAKER_03: That's beyond what you already see.
[1:12:35] SPEAKER_03: So maybe you see, this is what you want to do or want a place you want to be.
[1:12:39] SPEAKER_03: Maybe you like horses.
[1:12:40] SPEAKER_03: I became a volunteer at a veterinary hospital.
[1:12:44] SPEAKER_03: That was actually pretty awful, but nevertheless, uh, okay.
[1:12:48] SPEAKER_03: You learned that,
[1:12:50] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:12:50] SPEAKER_03: cleaning up dog shit and watching how badly they treated the animals was very disheartening,
[1:12:55] SPEAKER_03: but,
[1:12:56] SPEAKER_03: um,
[1:12:57] SPEAKER_03: certainly turned me off to any desire to be a veterinarian,
[1:13:00] SPEAKER_03: but,
[1:13:01] SPEAKER_03: uh,
[1:13:02] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:13:02] SPEAKER_03: I mean, like, OK, take it to the next level.
[1:13:04] SPEAKER_03: Take it.
[1:13:05] SPEAKER_03: Teaching a kid.
[1:13:06] SPEAKER_03: I don't know if teaching is the word.
[1:13:07] SPEAKER_03: Empowering a kid to go beyond their first insight to their next insight.
[1:13:11] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:13:12] SPEAKER_03: Right.
[1:13:13] SPEAKER_03: I don't think that's so hard if you're sensitive.
[1:13:16] SPEAKER_00: No, no.
[1:13:19] SPEAKER_00: I was just going to say sometimes just having a conversation with them and probing.
[1:13:23] SPEAKER_00: and getting them to delve further.
[1:13:25] SPEAKER_00: And that sort of ignites something in them that makes them want to figure something out.
[1:13:30] SPEAKER_00: And then, you know, you just keep going with them, but that's part of the mentoring process, isn't it?
[1:13:35] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:13:36] SPEAKER_03: Well, you know, the mentoring is not that well defined either apprenticeship kind of mentoring.
[1:13:42] SPEAKER_03: But I would say,
[1:13:43] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:13:43] SPEAKER_03: my best,
[1:13:44] SPEAKER_03: my best mentors,
[1:13:45] SPEAKER_03: and this would differ for other people would be the people who gave me the most
[1:13:50] SPEAKER_03: resources with the least constraints.
[1:13:52] SPEAKER_03: And they gave me a goal so that I had the resources and a goal.
[1:13:57] SPEAKER_03: And they gave me the greatest amount of responsibility.
[1:13:59] SPEAKER_03: I like responsibility.
[1:14:01] SPEAKER_03: Maybe other people don't like that so much.
[1:14:03] SPEAKER_03: Maybe that makes them afraid or confused and they're not as patient or they're not as stubborn as I am.
[1:14:09] SPEAKER_03: And I could understand that maybe they need more help and more attention.
[1:14:12] SPEAKER_03: And some of my mentors might not have been good for them because they didn't have that time.
[1:14:17] SPEAKER_03: And I didn't ask them that.
[1:14:18] SPEAKER_03: That's accurate.
[1:14:19] SPEAKER_03: So I felt that I got like from Gato.
[1:14:21] SPEAKER_03: I didn't see Gato more than a handful of times, but we made the most of the time.
[1:14:26] SPEAKER_03: He's the one who told me to go see Phyllis Schlafly.
[1:14:29] SPEAKER_03: And I never would have otherwise because I thought she was a terrible person.
[1:14:36] SPEAKER_03: And he said, no, no, you'll find she's very interesting.
[1:14:40] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[1:14:41] SPEAKER_03: other people who've done similar things that have motivated me with very little
[1:14:46] SPEAKER_03: input on their part.
[1:14:48] SPEAKER_03: That to me, I'm not even sure if I call those mentors or inspiring people.
[1:14:52] SPEAKER_03: Sometimes they haven't even taught me anything at all.
[1:14:54] SPEAKER_03: Just being around them has left to the, you know, just watching them has been inspirational.
[1:15:01] SPEAKER_02: I can name a few people in my life of exactly that's what you speak.
[1:15:06] SPEAKER_02: I don't know if they're mentors, but yeah, they're very significant.
[1:15:11] SPEAKER_00: Well, there's also that term coach.
[1:15:15] SPEAKER_00: That's another good term.
[1:15:15] SPEAKER_00: The sports analogy.
[1:15:16] SPEAKER_00: Right.
[1:15:17] SPEAKER_00: The sports analogy because they help you figure out what you're good at and then
[1:15:22] SPEAKER_00: how to exploit that and move it forward.
[1:15:24] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, a coach is more involved in my view.
[1:15:29] SPEAKER_03: Well,
[1:15:29] SPEAKER_03: a mentor too will be involved,
[1:15:31] SPEAKER_03: but a coach is – so in my view,
[1:15:34] SPEAKER_03: a mentor is somebody who works alongside you and a coach is somebody who sort of
[1:15:37] SPEAKER_03: works behind you,
[1:15:39] SPEAKER_03: supporting you and criticizing and suggesting things.
[1:15:43] SPEAKER_03: They're the one with a stopwatch.
[1:15:44] SPEAKER_03: The mentor doesn't have a stopwatch.
[1:15:46] SPEAKER_03: The coach has a stopwatch.
[1:15:48] SPEAKER_02: Right, yeah.
[1:15:49] SPEAKER_02: There's a specific role for the coach.
[1:15:51] SPEAKER_02: If you're a sport coach versus a minor, I don't know, verbal coach, voice coach, yeah.
[1:15:59] SPEAKER_02: They're there to cheer you on as well, to provide that support.
[1:16:04] SPEAKER_03: I like the movie The King's Speech.
[1:16:06] SPEAKER_03: What's his name?
[1:16:07] SPEAKER_03: Colin Firth.
[1:16:08] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:16:09] SPEAKER_03: Colin Firth was the king and Jeffrey Rush was the speech therapist.
[1:16:14] SPEAKER_03: And that was a mentoring.
[1:16:15] SPEAKER_03: That was a mentoring coaching thing.
[1:16:19] SPEAKER_03: Right.
[1:16:20] SPEAKER_03: And of course it was very sweet because of the,
[1:16:23] SPEAKER_03: the,
[1:16:24] SPEAKER_03: the structure,
[1:16:25] SPEAKER_03: the social structure was all,
[1:16:27] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:16:28] SPEAKER_03: mixed up in contradictory and humorous.
[1:16:29] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:16:32] SPEAKER_03: And so, you know, I would say, I think this hasn't been said and it should be said that,
[1:16:38] SPEAKER_03: And if you read the Phantom Street Artist interview in my book, he says it.
[1:16:45] SPEAKER_03: Here was a kid who learned on the street and didn't really have any education at
[1:16:51] SPEAKER_03: all and didn't really have any family either and became a graffiti artist.
[1:16:56] SPEAKER_03: And he says, you have to find the mentors.
[1:17:01] SPEAKER_03: It's not for us to give them.
[1:17:03] SPEAKER_03: A lot of the responsibility has to be the individual.
[1:17:07] SPEAKER_03: who's learning, the learner.
[1:17:09] SPEAKER_03: So it's not really, I think it's truth to this.
[1:17:12] SPEAKER_03: It's not really about us creating the learning environment.
[1:17:16] SPEAKER_03: It's more, I can't really defend this, but I feel this.
[1:17:20] SPEAKER_03: It's more about us creating resources and encouraging learners to find them.
[1:17:26] SPEAKER_03: You knock on the doors,
[1:17:28] SPEAKER_03: you go to the library,
[1:17:29] SPEAKER_03: you get bored or you get fucked up or you make all the mistakes you need until you
[1:17:34] SPEAKER_03: realize that you probably get further using our resources than you would by just
[1:17:41] SPEAKER_03: playing chicken on the railroad tracks or whatever stupid shit you might be doing
[1:17:45] SPEAKER_03: with your time.
[1:17:47] SPEAKER_02: I was thinking about that.
[1:17:48] SPEAKER_02: Strangely enough, these mentors of mine, I never asked to be my mentors.
[1:17:53] SPEAKER_02: I never said, would you be my mentor in this role of mentor?
[1:17:57] SPEAKER_02: They just became what I see as a mentor, a person who guides me through life and gives me that.
[1:18:05] SPEAKER_02: They didn't have the name.
[1:18:07] SPEAKER_03: Well, one guy gave me a job, so that was pretty clear.
[1:18:12] SPEAKER_02: I had a job where I had a mentor and I was working under this person,
[1:18:15] SPEAKER_02: but then I had developed a relationship with another person.
[1:18:19] SPEAKER_02: mentor in the program and he became more or less the primary for me so I see
[1:18:27] SPEAKER_03: there's like a teacher there's a employer there's a coach there's a mentor and then
[1:18:33] SPEAKER_03: I think at the highest level there's a person who inspires you who actually doesn't
[1:18:39] SPEAKER_03: actually know that they're doing anything for you you just see them watch them
[1:18:43] SPEAKER_02: maybe sit around next to them for a while you're just being them yeah I mean you
[1:18:47] SPEAKER_02: just soak it up yeah
[1:18:50] SPEAKER_02: And hopefully you have a judgment.
[1:18:51] SPEAKER_03: I felt I was really lucky when I, I guess this guy was important to me.
[1:18:56] SPEAKER_03: I wanted to know about physics and I didn't know what even physics really was or
[1:19:01] SPEAKER_03: what it involved or what it would require or who I'd have to be with or what I
[1:19:06] SPEAKER_03: could expect from it.
[1:19:08] SPEAKER_03: And I don't think anybody really knows.
[1:19:10] SPEAKER_03: Change with time.
[1:19:12] SPEAKER_03: So I looked up some professor at Princeton and went to visit him.
[1:19:15] SPEAKER_03: And I was just very lucky that he was a brilliant, sensitive
[1:19:20] SPEAKER_03: helpful guy who kind of knew exactly where I was coming from and had no other
[1:19:25] SPEAKER_03: responsibilities for several days and just spent several days with me.
[1:19:29] SPEAKER_03: I mean, I didn't hardly know who he was.
[1:19:32] SPEAKER_03: Wow.
[1:19:33] SPEAKER_03: And,
[1:19:34] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:19:34] SPEAKER_03: I only learned later that,
[1:19:35] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:19:36] SPEAKER_03: he was like superhero still is considered,
[1:19:40] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:19:40] SPEAKER_03: seminal field of physics,
[1:19:42] SPEAKER_03: but he never,
[1:19:43] SPEAKER_03: he just,
[1:19:43] SPEAKER_03: you know,
[1:19:44] SPEAKER_03: we just talked like brothers basically.
[1:19:48] SPEAKER_03: And it,
[1:19:49] SPEAKER_03: I don't know what it did for me.
[1:19:51] SPEAKER_03: It set a higher standard.
[1:19:53] SPEAKER_03: In fact, no one ever met that standard, right?
[1:19:56] SPEAKER_03: He set the highest standard of all.
[1:19:58] SPEAKER_03: And no one,
[1:19:59] SPEAKER_03: except for maybe one or two people like John Cotto and a few other people who
[1:20:04] SPEAKER_03: didn't really challenge me at all.
[1:20:05] SPEAKER_03: They just shared with me.
[1:20:07] SPEAKER_03: And this guy didn't challenge me either.
[1:20:08] SPEAKER_03: He didn't judge me.
[1:20:09] SPEAKER_03: He didn't judge anything.
[1:20:10] SPEAKER_03: He just said, well, this is what my life is to me.
[1:20:13] SPEAKER_03: And this is why you might find it.
[1:20:16] SPEAKER_03: I can relate to you.
[1:20:16] SPEAKER_03: And all he did was encourage me.
[1:20:19] SPEAKER_00: But it was more of a peer relationship, wasn't it?
[1:20:23] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:20:23] SPEAKER_03: He didn't know how the universe worked either.
[1:20:24] SPEAKER_03: I mean, we were complete equals.
[1:20:27] SPEAKER_03: We were both in the dark.
[1:20:29] SPEAKER_03: The fact that he'd had a Nobel Prize and founded quantum mechanics, he still didn't know.
[1:20:34] SPEAKER_03: And it's true.
[1:20:35] SPEAKER_03: And that's why he was great.
[1:20:38] SPEAKER_03: And he's better than some of these physicists who are depressed about the fact that they don't know.
[1:20:41] SPEAKER_03: He didn't bother him.
[1:20:43] SPEAKER_02: That's very important.
[1:20:45] SPEAKER_02: It's almost inevitable with quantum physics that
[1:20:49] SPEAKER_02: For example, string theory and everyone was all hot on that.
[1:20:52] SPEAKER_02: Now, I don't think so.
[1:20:53] SPEAKER_02: And I'm thinking,
[1:20:54] SPEAKER_02: well,
[1:20:54] SPEAKER_02: of course,
[1:20:55] SPEAKER_02: that makes total sense that that would kind of come and go and we would move on in
[1:21:00] SPEAKER_02: our knowledge base.
[1:21:03] SPEAKER_03: I'm not sure.
[1:21:03] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[1:21:04] SPEAKER_03: even if you're doing art,
[1:21:05] SPEAKER_03: I mean,
[1:21:06] SPEAKER_03: some people,
[1:21:07] SPEAKER_03: some artists,
[1:21:08] SPEAKER_03: maybe the best artists are never fully satisfied with what they do.
[1:21:11] SPEAKER_02: Never.
[1:21:12] SPEAKER_03: But at some point, you have to say enough of that.
[1:21:14] SPEAKER_03: I'm going on.
[1:21:15] SPEAKER_03: I'm going to start over.
[1:21:18] SPEAKER_03: And some people would throw it out, which I don't know who's the judge, and other people will sell it.
[1:21:25] SPEAKER_03: There are a lot of funny stories of artists doing weird things.
[1:21:29] SPEAKER_03: Jackson Pollock just dumping paint on canvases and stuff like this.
[1:21:34] SPEAKER_02: But who's to say that that is not divine art and expression?
[1:21:39] SPEAKER_02: I mean, I'm not venturing into that realm to say, no, this is, or no, it's not.
[1:21:46] SPEAKER_03: There was a girl...
[1:21:47] SPEAKER_03: when I was in college, her art was just hearts.
[1:21:50] SPEAKER_03: She just made hearts, you know, round hearts, red hearts, sharp hearts.
[1:21:55] SPEAKER_03: So all she did is like, it was really hard to see that as artistic.
[1:22:00] SPEAKER_03: But, well, there's this Japanese woman who made her whole living doing polka dots.
[1:22:05] SPEAKER_03: I mean, maybe you remember her name.
[1:22:06] SPEAKER_03: And, you know, she's like, the great art of modern art in Japan.
[1:22:11] SPEAKER_03: That's all she ever did was polka dots.
[1:22:13] SPEAKER_03: And so who's to say you're right.
[1:22:16] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, wabi-sabi.
[1:22:17] SPEAKER_02: I mean, it's the art of mending that which is broken, clearly doing it with gold paint.
[1:22:27] SPEAKER_02: Like we've been saying, I feel just so limited by the education society and structure.
[1:22:34] SPEAKER_03: Also, I go back to when I started it.
[1:22:36] SPEAKER_03: You've got the social part, you've got the information part, and you've got the creative part.
[1:22:41] SPEAKER_03: And I'm not sure the creative part is the hardest one.
[1:22:44] SPEAKER_03: It takes the most courage.
[1:22:46] SPEAKER_03: It offers the least financial reward or social support.
[1:22:52] SPEAKER_03: But it also offers the most personal meaning.
[1:22:56] SPEAKER_03: So I don't know.
[1:22:57] SPEAKER_03: It has the most effect.
[1:23:00] SPEAKER_02: Yeah,
[1:23:00] SPEAKER_02: you can only be in flow state two hours in one day at the very,
[1:23:05] SPEAKER_02: very most in that intense learning state.
[1:23:09] SPEAKER_03: I think we should encourage it.
[1:23:11] SPEAKER_03: But how many people even know what it is?
[1:23:15] SPEAKER_03: It's not common.
[1:23:16] SPEAKER_03: It's not common.
[1:23:18] SPEAKER_02: No, and they don't know the trigger.
[1:23:20] SPEAKER_02: They know when they feel good and they're in the groove,
[1:23:23] SPEAKER_02: but they don't know that that's actually a state you can get yourself in.
[1:23:27] SPEAKER_00: You can only be in the flow state for two hours?
[1:23:30] SPEAKER_02: You can only stand about two hours at the most of it.
[1:23:33] SPEAKER_02: There's only so much.
[1:23:35] SPEAKER_00: Let me ask you this then, just for clarification.
[1:23:40] SPEAKER_00: If I'm working on a project and let's say I start at 6 p.m.
[1:23:46] SPEAKER_00: and I come up for air and I look over and it's 2 a.m.
[1:23:50] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[1:23:51] SPEAKER_00: Have I not been in a flow state that whole time?
[1:23:54] SPEAKER_02: Not the whole time.
[1:23:56] SPEAKER_02: You know,
[1:23:56] SPEAKER_02: flow states aren't like intoxicating to the point where,
[1:24:01] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[1:24:01] SPEAKER_02: you may lose track of time,
[1:24:03] SPEAKER_02: but there's menial things,
[1:24:05] SPEAKER_02: you know,
[1:24:05] SPEAKER_02: ebbs and flows.
[1:24:06] SPEAKER_02: You're just in a groove.
[1:24:08] SPEAKER_02: It really intensifies if the consequences in the environment are rich and deep.
[1:24:13] SPEAKER_02: Hence, you know, Alex Honnold's four-hour ascent.
[1:24:19] SPEAKER_02: He kind of, a lot of what he didn't,
[1:24:23] SPEAKER_02: accomplish in flow he'd already accomplished because he studied the root so
[1:24:28] SPEAKER_02: intensively that you know some of it was just kind of like slogging it through he
[1:24:33] SPEAKER_02: just had high consequence the whole time yeah he's in a whole different matter but
[1:24:40] SPEAKER_00: got it yeah okay well i think it's time to wrap up for this week this is uh this is
[1:24:49] SPEAKER_03: what philip says after about an hour and a half we just like
[1:24:53] SPEAKER_03: It's time to wrap up.
[1:24:54] SPEAKER_03: It's true.
[1:24:56] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:24:58] SPEAKER_02: And then the best thing to do is go and do something totally unrelated and recover
[1:25:02] SPEAKER_02: and then come back to the problem later.
[1:25:04] SPEAKER_00: But you know, in five minutes, it's going to be, Oh crap.
[1:25:09] SPEAKER_00: I should have.
[1:25:10] SPEAKER_00: Why did you know?
[1:25:12] SPEAKER_03: It's going to be the second guessing.
[1:25:14] SPEAKER_03: It's always like that.
[1:25:16] SPEAKER_03: If you're lucky.
[1:25:16] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:25:17] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:25:17] SPEAKER_02: If you're human, that's how it happens.
[1:25:20] SPEAKER_02: Yeah.
[1:25:22] SPEAKER_00: Lincoln, I can't tell you how grateful I am and what a pleasure this has been.
[1:25:29] SPEAKER_03: Good stuff.
[1:25:30] SPEAKER_03: Yeah.
[1:25:31] SPEAKER_03: Thank you.
[1:25:33] SPEAKER_03: We're sort of different here, that you're still in some mode of making a difference on a social level.
[1:25:41] SPEAKER_03: And I'm not, right?
[1:25:42] SPEAKER_03: So I'm dealing with, as a therapist, individuals.
[1:25:47] SPEAKER_03: And when you ask the question, like, what are we going to do?
[1:25:49] SPEAKER_03: How are we going to do it?
[1:25:50] SPEAKER_03: Where are we going to go?
[1:25:52] SPEAKER_03: I have to ask a different question when I'm dealing with individuals.
[1:25:55] SPEAKER_03: I don't get that.
[1:25:56] SPEAKER_03: I don't get the answers.
[1:25:57] SPEAKER_03: I'm just part of the process.
[1:25:59] SPEAKER_03: I want to be part of the process and I have to be removed enough to know that I'm
[1:26:05] SPEAKER_03: not entitled to the answers.
[1:26:07] SPEAKER_03: You know,
[1:26:07] SPEAKER_03: it's not for me to solve the problems or even know if the problems have been solved
[1:26:11] SPEAKER_03: at all,
[1:26:12] SPEAKER_03: which is an interesting place to be,
[1:26:14] SPEAKER_03: but I feel consequential,
[1:26:16] SPEAKER_03: right?
[1:26:16] SPEAKER_03: Because although I don't know what the answer is for people's personal problems,
[1:26:20] SPEAKER_03: I do have some insight, or maybe it's a delusion, that I played a role in moving it forward.
[1:26:26] SPEAKER_02: Yeah, being satisfied being the 89th monkey.
[1:26:31] SPEAKER_02: Go into obscurity.
[1:26:33] SPEAKER_02: Unless you're the 100th, you're just 89.
[1:26:34] SPEAKER_03: Yeah, right.
[1:26:36] SPEAKER_03: That's another story, yes.
[1:26:38] SPEAKER_03: Because you know that was a false story.
[1:26:41] SPEAKER_03: It turns out not to be true, the whole hundredth monkey thing.
[1:26:43] SPEAKER_02: No, that's not true.
[1:26:44] SPEAKER_03: It sounds good, yeah.
[1:26:46] SPEAKER_02: I can't help but think that genius,
[1:26:49] SPEAKER_02: I mean,
[1:26:49] SPEAKER_02: somewhere like 10,000 years ago,
[1:26:51] SPEAKER_02: someone was easily delving into the ideas or swimming in my head.
[1:26:54] SPEAKER_02: It's just, they go, what?
[1:26:56] SPEAKER_02: When he mentioned it or she mentioned it, because it's just not the base of knowledge for the time.
[1:27:03] SPEAKER_03: Well, I was just shocked the other two facts to leave you with.
[1:27:07] SPEAKER_03: When the Europeans came to the Americas, the indigenous people did not have the wheel.
[1:27:12] SPEAKER_03: Holy shit.
[1:27:14] SPEAKER_03: And the other thing that I was amazed to learn was throughout the Dark Ages,
[1:27:18] SPEAKER_03: what we call the Dark Ages,
[1:27:19] SPEAKER_03: whether you want to call it the European Dark Ages.
[1:27:22] SPEAKER_00: The medieval period.
[1:27:24] SPEAKER_03: 500 years.
[1:27:25] SPEAKER_03: One of the few things that they invented was the horseshoe.
[1:27:29] SPEAKER_03: You know, 500 years to invent the horseshoe.
[1:27:32] SPEAKER_03: It just makes you think, you know, so we're talking about creativity and the importance of it.
[1:27:36] SPEAKER_03: There have been times, centuries, in which there's been very little creativity for whatever reason.
[1:27:42] SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
[1:27:43] SPEAKER_03: Because it was peaceful.
[1:27:45] SPEAKER_03: I don't know.
[1:27:46] SPEAKER_00: The Dark Ages?
[1:27:46] SPEAKER_00: The Dark Ages is – that was because – they call it the Dark Ages.
[1:27:52] SPEAKER_00: We know it also as the medieval period.
[1:27:55] SPEAKER_00: But that's because when the – was it the Italians who came out with the Renaissance?
[1:28:04] SPEAKER_00: When the Renaissance was developed –
[1:28:07] SPEAKER_00: At the advent of the Renaissance, they wanted to show how much better they were.
[1:28:13] SPEAKER_00: So they went and they said the previous era were the Dark Ages.
[1:28:18] SPEAKER_00: And now you're coming out of the Dark Ages into the Renaissance.
[1:28:23] SPEAKER_00: But the medieval period gave us the universities.
[1:28:25] SPEAKER_00: It gave us a great deal of what we have, especially in sciences.
[1:28:29] SPEAKER_02: A lot of change.
[1:28:31] SPEAKER_02: I believe it coincided with the split in the church.
[1:28:35] SPEAKER_02: the Orthodox and the Roman Catholic Church, too.
[1:28:39] SPEAKER_02: That's what started the Dark Ages, per se.
[1:28:41] SPEAKER_02: Oh, the Dark Ages of church splitting.
[1:28:44] SPEAKER_03: Protestantism,
[1:28:45] SPEAKER_03: started by Luther,
[1:28:46] SPEAKER_03: was really the foundation of fascism,
[1:28:49] SPEAKER_03: or at least was fundamental in the creation of fascism.
[1:28:54] SPEAKER_03: Hitler borrowed from Luther's speeches and appealed to his populace through a populism.
[1:29:01] SPEAKER_03: Of course, they also were under the thumb of
[1:29:04] SPEAKER_03: whatever world war one had left them but i mean yeah there's you know two sides to
[1:29:11] SPEAKER_03: every blade it seems uh you know it was great that they invented the printing press
[1:29:16] SPEAKER_03: but now a lot of you know what you would call today false news could spread or or
[1:29:23] SPEAKER_03: whatever you want to call it anyway misinformation misinformation yeah
[1:29:27] SPEAKER_03: Well, I mean, it's not misinformation if it's used.
[1:29:30] SPEAKER_03: It's just not.
[1:29:32] SPEAKER_00: If it's used, then it's still misinformation.
[1:29:34] SPEAKER_00: I mean, it's propaganda, basically.
[1:29:36] SPEAKER_03: Well, don't tell that to my Pentecostal friends.
[1:29:42] SPEAKER_00: Yeah, they're in the wrong way.
[1:29:44] SPEAKER_03: So we've accomplished nothing.
[1:29:45] SPEAKER_03: Very good.
[1:29:46] SPEAKER_03: Perfect.
[1:29:48] SPEAKER_00: It works.
[1:29:48] SPEAKER_03: Just as it should be.
[1:29:51] SPEAKER_00: So thank you very much.
[1:29:52] SPEAKER_00: You're welcome.
[1:29:55] SPEAKER_00: And Philip, you too.
[1:29:56] SPEAKER_00: And to all of our listeners, we'll see you next week when we talk about what we have learned.
[1:30:05] SPEAKER_00: And until then, keep your freedom on the ground while you reach for the stars.
[1:30:09] SPEAKER_00: Bye-bye.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
