# S Iswaran case: Twists, turns, jail time and a media scrum

An episode of [Deep Dive](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1491441787), 4 Oct 2024, 14 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/7740012e-e1bd-4f85-81c4-a7f50047134a/053184de-200a-4a53-a80c-ab6e006ab608/a72ba867-8986-4815-a933-b1ff002a0389/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=22e00ef9-7730-4062-8cd4-ab6e006ab624

Former transport minister S Iswaran was handed a one year sentence by Judge Vincent Hoong on five charges, including obtaining gifts as a public servant. Why did he get more than what the prosecution asked for? Head of criminal law at Quahe Woo and Palmer, Sunil Sudheesan, explains the rare move. Plus, Crispina Robert gets a firsthand account from senior journalist Koh Wan Ting who covered the court proceedings. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:03] Speaker 1: You're listening to AC N A podcast?
[0:08] Speaker 2: Hi, everyone. This is Christina Flying Solo for this episode,
[0:12] Speaker 2: Steven is on a filming trip so he's not here
[0:14] Speaker 2: when the biggest news of the week broke, which is
[0:18] Speaker 2: the sentencing of former transport minister is Swan. Judge Vincent
[0:22] Speaker 2: Hong handed down a 12 month sentence. Today. The East
[0:26] Speaker 2: Warn case dominated headlines for more than a year after
[0:30] Speaker 2: it was announced that he was going
[0:32] Speaker 2: going to be investigated for corruption. Now the last time
[0:36] Speaker 2: a minister was tainted with the specter of corruption was
[0:39] Speaker 2: back in 1986 when National Development Minister Tai Cheng Wan
[0:44] Speaker 2: was investigated for accepting bribes in that incident. He took
[0:48] Speaker 2: his own life before he was charged. Now this time
[0:52] Speaker 2: at the time of his charging is Warren was a
[0:54] Speaker 2: P A veteran. He
[0:56] Speaker 2: important portfolios like trade and transport. So to talk to
[1:01] Speaker 2: me about this very big story in the studio is
[1:04] Speaker 2: my colleague from the digital desk, senior journalist Koh Wan Ting,
[1:09] Speaker 2: together with two other reporters wing has been covering the
[1:12] Speaker 2: East Warn case and I'm keen to get a bit
[1:15] Speaker 2: of the behind the scenes details on what it's like
[1:17] Speaker 2: to cover the biggest case in a while.
[1:23] Speaker 2: Welcome to the podcast Wing. Hi, Christina. OK. W I
[1:26] Speaker 2: was watching your updates like it was a nail biting
[1:29] Speaker 2: saga when you were posting for our live blog. Now
[1:32] Speaker 2: safe to say everyone was surprised when the sentence landed.
[1:37] Speaker 2: I remember you were saying, oh my. So tell me
[1:39] Speaker 2: a little bit more to the lead up of that sentencing,
[1:42] Speaker 2: which of course everyone was there for the key things
[1:45] Speaker 2: that
[1:45] Speaker 2: judge said before he handed out the sentence. So Justice
[1:50] Speaker 2: Vincent Hong said that he had considered the submissions by
[1:53] Speaker 2: both the prosecution and the defense. And he also laid
[1:55] Speaker 2: out the aggravating factors and the motivating factors that were
[1:59] Speaker 2: put out by the prosecution. And the defense in the
[2:01] Speaker 2: previous hearing, when Israel pleaded guilty, the prosecution asked for
[2:05] Speaker 2: about 6 to 7 months and the
[2:07] Speaker 2: defense asked for no more than eight weeks. And then
[2:09] Speaker 2: in the end, justice Hong said that he couldn't agree
[2:11] Speaker 2: on both positions and he said he would impose a
[2:13] Speaker 2: sentence that was higher than both. And that was when
[2:16] Speaker 2: we were really surprised because it doesn't usually happen in
[2:19] Speaker 2: the cases that I've covered, go into a little bit
[2:21] Speaker 2: of the reasons that he laid out why he couldn't
[2:25] Speaker 2: stick with either the upper end of what the prosecution wanted,
[2:29] Speaker 2: know what the defense asked for. Right. So he said
[2:31] Speaker 2: that it would have been manifestly inadequate. Yes, he said
[2:35] Speaker 2: that it would be manifestly inadequate. Also, considering the aggravating
[2:38] Speaker 2: factors of the case, such as the total duration of
[2:41] Speaker 2: is war's offending in the high office that he occupied
[2:44] Speaker 2: because he was a minister and he was the chairman
[2:46] Speaker 2: of the F one steering committee at the time as well.
[2:49] Speaker 2: And Justice Hong said that it wouldn't be remedied by
[2:51] Speaker 2: his disgorgement,
[2:53] Speaker 2: that means him paying back the money doesn't take away
[2:57] Speaker 2: the fact that he did all of these things and
[3:00] Speaker 2: he harmed public interest because he had brought some reputational
[3:04] Speaker 2: damage to the government in general. What was the mood
[3:09] Speaker 2: like in the courtroom when this was announced when the
[3:12] Speaker 2: judge gave his sentence? I wasn't in the courtroom per se.
[3:15] Speaker 2: So I was in a separate
[3:16] Speaker 2: media room where we had a live stream of the proceedings,
[3:19] Speaker 2: but even in the media room, we could feel it
[3:22] Speaker 2: was very tense. So we would just hang on to
[3:24] Speaker 2: every word the judge was saying. And when he said
[3:27] Speaker 2: that the sentence would be in excess of what the
[3:29] Speaker 2: prosecution and the defense asked what we were like who?
[3:33] Speaker 2: So it was a surprising kind of events for us
[3:35] Speaker 2: when you spoke to lawyers after this, what are some
[3:38] Speaker 2: of the common reactions?
[3:40] Speaker 2: We've been getting one of the lawyers I spoke to
[3:43] Speaker 2: actually said that he wasn't surprised by the severity of
[3:46] Speaker 2: the sentence per se, but he was more surprised by
[3:49] Speaker 2: how much in excess the judge imposed, you know, compared
[3:52] Speaker 2: to what the prosecution asked for the judge imposed five
[3:54] Speaker 2: more months of jail. That's right. But this lawyer that
[3:57] Speaker 2: I spoke to said that the judge was definitely justified
[4:00] Speaker 2: what he did because of all the aggravating factors that
[4:02] Speaker 2: he laid out. Ok. This is actually not the only
[4:08] Speaker 2: twist in this tale.
[4:10] Speaker 2: So let's go back to the case when it first
[4:12] Speaker 2: went to court, you guys were expecting a trial and
[4:15] Speaker 2: then you were told e it's going to be done
[4:17] Speaker 2: and dusted in one day. Tell me a little bit
[4:19] Speaker 2: about that one. That was definitely a shocker for all
[4:22] Speaker 2: of us journalists in the media room. So I remember
[4:24] Speaker 2: that we all turned up quite early to report voices
[4:28] Speaker 2: on the ground. You know, a number of people who
[4:29] Speaker 2: queued up from as early as I think 6 a.m.
[4:31] Speaker 2: we waited for the case to start at 10 a.m.
[4:33] Speaker 2: We were all prepped. So for myself, I even brought
[4:35] Speaker 2: an extension
[4:36] Speaker 2: to the media room anticipating a long day of trial
[4:39] Speaker 2: and maybe three more days of trial because it was
[4:41] Speaker 2: slated from September 24th to September 27th. So we were
[4:45] Speaker 2: all prepared to stay in court the whole day. We
[4:47] Speaker 2: even prepare our own lunches and then suddenly the wining goes,
[4:51] Speaker 2: is my client is prepared to take a certain course
[4:52] Speaker 2: of action and the reporters just looked at each other
[4:55] Speaker 2: and like he's going to plead guilty OK, tell me
[4:57] Speaker 2: a little bit more about being able to communicate quickly
[5:01] Speaker 2: what's happening
[5:02] Speaker 2: in court and then sending back the information to base
[5:06] Speaker 2: and then your editors going through your stuff. What are
[5:09] Speaker 2: the key things that you guys need to be careful about?
[5:11] Speaker 2: So it always helps to be prepared for the cases.
[5:14] Speaker 2: So to be well versed with the charges what they
[5:17] Speaker 2: are and the timeline of the events and when they
[5:19] Speaker 2: happen before you go into the case so that you
[5:21] Speaker 2: have all this background knowledge, they can pull out when
[5:24] Speaker 2: you are dealing with a court case that's proceeding really fast.
[5:26] Speaker 2: But it also helps that I have a whole team
[5:28] Speaker 2: backing me up.
[5:29] Speaker 2: So I had a colleague who was in court transcribing,
[5:31] Speaker 2: what actually happened. Word for word verbatim. I was the
[5:34] Speaker 2: one who was taking all that and summarizing it into
[5:36] Speaker 2: digestible pieces for our life blog. I think a lot
[5:40] Speaker 2: of people don't realize actually it's quite stressful to be
[5:43] Speaker 2: in a media scrum. Tell me a bit more about
[5:45] Speaker 2: that apart from getting up really early to speak to
[5:47] Speaker 2: the first person of the queue, which is what my
[5:50] Speaker 2: colleague did. You have to be prepared that you be
[5:52] Speaker 2: jostled a lot on the ground where you're taking photos
[5:54] Speaker 2: or where you're trying to ask questions
[5:56] Speaker 2: or when you're trying to just get a video or
[5:58] Speaker 2: proper shoot of the people walking in. And we also
[6:01] Speaker 2: have to look out for, you know, not just this one,
[6:03] Speaker 2: we wanted to look out for his lawyers, we want
[6:05] Speaker 2: to look out for his wife as well and they
[6:08] Speaker 2: could be entering the court from different places as well
[6:10] Speaker 2: because there are two entrances, there's the main entrance and
[6:13] Speaker 2: there's the basement entrance, which is quite a walk away.
[6:15] Speaker 2: So if he decides to go to one and not
[6:17] Speaker 2: the other, you will have missed him.
[6:19] Speaker 2: So you have to be prepared for all these scenarios
[6:21] Speaker 2: as well. It's a definitely a different day in the office, right? Yeah,
[6:25] Speaker 2: I mean, it's not every day. You see a high
[6:27] Speaker 2: profile case involving a minister who is at the wrong
[6:30] Speaker 2: side of the law. Adrenaline is one thing but just
[6:33] Speaker 2: knowing how to report life is a whole new experience. Ok?
[6:36] Speaker 2: Thank you. One thing for coming. Thank you Chris.
[6:42] Speaker 2: It was a surprise like much of this case from
[6:45] Speaker 2: the start from amended charges to se Warren pleading guilty
[6:49] Speaker 2: to a one year sentence. We want to get the
[6:52] Speaker 2: help of lawyer Sunil Sadan to break down a bit
[6:55] Speaker 2: of what happened in court this morning. We are recording
[6:58] Speaker 2: in the afternoon. Welcome to deep dive, Sunil, quick reaction
[7:01] Speaker 2: on the sentencing. This is the thing that was interesting
[7:04] Speaker 2: to us. The prosecution had asked for between 6 to
[7:07] Speaker 2: 7 months in jail defense asked for a maximum of
[7:10] Speaker 2: eight weeks and Justice Hong landed on one year which
[7:15] Speaker 2: was quite surprising, I have to admit, I was a
[7:17] Speaker 2: bit surprised
[7:18] Speaker 2: Justice Hong set out his reasons for it. Now, first,
[7:21] Speaker 2: is it normal for sentences to be higher than what
[7:25] Speaker 2: both defense and prosecution asked for bearing in mind? By
[7:29] Speaker 2: the way, that section 165 the maximum is two years.
[7:32] Speaker 2: The answer is no. Usually when it comes to plea
[7:35] Speaker 2: arguments and sentencing arguments and all that judges usually take
[7:40] Speaker 2: what the prosecution say as probably the upper limit.
[7:43] Speaker 2: There have been occasions obviously, when judges have gone beyond
[7:47] Speaker 2: the limit, if they think the case calls for that
[7:51] Speaker 2: kind of messaging to be sent to the public. So
[7:54] Speaker 2: the recent case I can think about is DJ Sharmila
[7:58] Speaker 2: who in the M fa watch the diplomacy. That's right.
[8:03] Speaker 2: So in that case, she gave one week in jail,
[8:07] Speaker 2: prosecution and defense both asked for fines. So lawyers were
[8:12] Speaker 2: changed in the arguments are going on on appeal now
[8:15] Speaker 2: before justice did sing. So it does happen, but it's
[8:19] Speaker 2: not normal, it's not normal. We seldom see it. And
[8:22] Speaker 2: when we do, usually as defense lawyers were quite heartbroken.
[8:25] Speaker 2: So Mr David Singh would have been quite heartbroken. He's
[8:28] Speaker 2: the top lawyer and he's a tough cookie.
[8:31] Speaker 2: Second justice H mentioned that sticking to this range, what
[8:35] Speaker 2: they both suggested would have been quote unquote, manifestly inadequate. Now,
[8:40] Speaker 2: he laid out the key reasons. There are two main
[8:43] Speaker 2: parts to this, right. Basically, he said that the mitigating factors,
[8:48] Speaker 2: the amounts were small, there was no victim in this
[8:51] Speaker 2: et cetera were not strong, but the culpability factor was
[8:56] Speaker 2: much stronger. The fact that he was such a senior
[8:58] Speaker 2: member of government,
[9:00] Speaker 2: the higher the office, the higher the culpability in this
[9:03] Speaker 2: particular case. Ultimately, there was no evidence of corruption. That
[9:10] Speaker 2: means there was no overt favor shown by Mr Iswaran
[9:15] Speaker 2: to any of the persons involved. It came down to
[9:18] Speaker 2: section 165 which guards against the creation of the conflict
[9:23] Speaker 2: of interest a little bit. So
[9:26] Speaker 2: if you have a business relationship with the public servant,
[9:29] Speaker 2: the public servant cannot receive gifts because once the public
[9:33] Speaker 2: servant receives gifts, he may feel obliged. So is that
[9:39] Speaker 2: creation of that perhaps obligation that creates the conflict of interest?
[9:43] Speaker 2: So 165 was meant to if you would guide the
[9:47] Speaker 2: behavior of civil servants, which is why it's broad. That's right.
[9:51] Speaker 2: So this 165 essentially
[9:53] Speaker 2: captures that idea that it's about integrity. It's about incorruptibility,
[9:58] Speaker 2: it's about the position you inhabit. Right. Totally right. And
[10:02] Speaker 2: it deals with persons who have existing business relationships. The
[10:07] Speaker 2: case was supposed to go to trial. And then on
[10:10] Speaker 2: that day, that was a kind of a twist as
[10:12] Speaker 2: well when the charges were amended and he pleaded guilty.
[10:17] Speaker 2: So there's a big difference between corruption
[10:21] Speaker 2: and accepting gifts under section 165. So let me deal
[10:26] Speaker 2: with two things first, number one, it was a twist
[10:29] Speaker 2: only to those who didn't know, what do you mean
[10:31] Speaker 2: by that? That means in the negotiation process, they were
[10:34] Speaker 2: going to court to fight for statements and all that
[10:36] Speaker 2: kind of stuff. But the parallel route was being run
[10:39] Speaker 2: as well, which is can we do a deal in
[10:42] Speaker 2: terms of sentence or in terms of the deal is normal,
[10:45] Speaker 2: perfectly normal. We do it all the time.
[10:47] Speaker 2: You will be surprised in a number of cases that
[10:49] Speaker 2: crack on the first day, that means it gets resolved
[10:53] Speaker 2: on the first day, which is what happened here. That's right.
[10:55] Speaker 2: People on the inside would know already and clearly they
[10:57] Speaker 2: knew because they were preparing with all the mitigation arguments
[11:00] Speaker 2: really right and sentencing arguments. So this was something known
[11:04] Speaker 2: to everybody with the parties like your defense and your prosecution.
[11:08] Speaker 2: That's right. The second thing you talked about was no
[11:11] Speaker 2: corruption in this case. OK. So that's significant to me,
[11:14] Speaker 2: we know that 165 is part of the suite of
[11:17] Speaker 2: offenses to deal with protection against corruption. But 165 doesn't
[11:24] Speaker 2: suggest any corruption to begin with. It suggests a conflict
[11:28] Speaker 2: of interest but conflict of interest doesn't jump straight to corruption. Ok?
[11:32] Speaker 2: But explain to my listeners what needs to be quite
[11:35] Speaker 2: clear cut corruption,
[11:37] Speaker 2: clear cut, corruption is the giving of a favor in
[11:40] Speaker 2: exchange for the gift. That's clear cut. So for example,
[11:45] Speaker 2: if I bought you a meal and you get a
[11:48] Speaker 2: contract to build a road in return. Right? That's clear cut.
[11:53] Speaker 2: That's the absurd scenario, of course. But it's this idea
[11:56] Speaker 2: of quid pro quo. Right. Precisely. There has to be
[11:59] Speaker 2: a meeting of the minds.
[12:00] Speaker 2: There has to be an exchange of favors if you
[12:03] Speaker 2: would and there has to be something done to the
[12:06] Speaker 2: detriment of your principle. So for example, let's say building
[12:13] Speaker 2: the road, right? I have five bids that come in,
[12:16] Speaker 2: your bid is actually the second lowest I should be
[12:20] Speaker 2: giving to the lowest bid, for example. But then I
[12:23] Speaker 2: remember that nice Makan you gave me. So maybe the
[12:26] Speaker 2: second lowest bid can get the deal instead.
[12:29] Speaker 2: So that means that my principal is deprived of the
[12:32] Speaker 2: ability of getting the lowest bid. This is assuming that
[12:36] Speaker 2: all five are equal quality. So in that scenario, because
[12:39] Speaker 2: of the detriment suffered by the principal because of the
[12:43] Speaker 2: favor given, right, that's clear cut corruption just to follow
[12:47] Speaker 2: up in the eyes of the ordinary man,
[12:49] Speaker 2: they may not see a real difference between section 165
[12:53] Speaker 2: and corruption because as far as they can see and
[12:57] Speaker 2: based on what the judge has said, Mr Iswaran did
[13:01] Speaker 2: damage the reputation of the government. Let's put it in
[13:03] Speaker 2: a slightly different way. Members of the public will be
[13:06] Speaker 2: angry that ministers are taking gifts and then then rightfully
[13:10] Speaker 2: so you're in such a position, you're getting paid well already. Yeah,
[13:13] Speaker 2: and you're still taking this kind of gifts from people
[13:16] Speaker 2: you have business relationships with so that incites a level
[13:20] Speaker 2: of emotion. Obviously, it runs afoul of the law. So therefore,
[13:25] Speaker 2: a custodial sentence is necessary. This is one of the
[13:28] Speaker 2: biggest cases, right? Just looking at the judgment, for example,
[13:31] Speaker 2: what's very clear to you. It's very clear that the
[13:34] Speaker 2: court will come down hard on public servants. The issue
[13:38] Speaker 2: that is up for discussion now is is very straightforward.
[13:41] Speaker 2: When you're a minister
[13:43] Speaker 2: and you are taking gifts from people, you are dealing
[13:46] Speaker 2: with business relationships.
[13:49] Speaker 2: The nuance of business relationships will be good to scope
[13:53] Speaker 2: out sometime in the future. The nuance of what is
[13:56] Speaker 2: a public servant and how lines are to be drawn
[14:00] Speaker 2: the way this whole thing has played out. It does
[14:02] Speaker 2: feel like a cautionary tale. So thank you for coming.
[14:06] Speaker 2: Thank you to the team as well. Janani Johari Tiffany,
[14:09] Speaker 2: Joan Chan Sa Wen to Yan Yan and sound mixing
[14:13] Speaker 2: is by Ken Delbridge. Thank you everyone. See you next
[14:15] Speaker 2: week when Steve and I will be back.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
