# What will it take for people to pay more for locally produced vegetables?

An episode of [Deep Dive](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1491441787), 6 Jun 2024, 29 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/7740012e-e1bd-4f85-81c4-a7f50047134a/053184de-200a-4a53-a80c-ab6e006ab608/c7199162-68d2-407d-a2da-b187008e9953/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=22e00ef9-7730-4062-8cd4-ab6e006ab624

Food security is a critical issue for Singapore because it imports more than 90 per cent of its produce. The 30 by 30 goal - to grow 30 per cent of food locally by 2030 - aims to mitigate this but local farming is still struggling to create a viable ecosystem. Is it cost, consumers or commitment? Steven Chia and Crispina Robert speak to Kenny Eng, a fourth-generation farmer and founder of The Local Farm, and Professor William Chen, director of the NTU Food Science and Technology Programme. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:03] Speaker 1: You're listening to AC N A podcast.
[0:08] Speaker 1: So, hey, everyone, welcome to Deep Dive. I'm back here
[0:11] Speaker 1: with Christina my co-host. And this time I believe you
[0:14] Speaker 1: have a quiz lined up for me.
[0:16] Speaker 2: Yes. Are you ready?
[0:17] Speaker 1: Yeah, sure. Bring it on.
[0:18] Speaker 2: Ok. I'm gonna start with an easy one. I hope,
[0:21] Speaker 2: I hope what percentage of our food is imported?
[0:25] Speaker 1: Wow, that's called an easy one.
[0:28] Speaker 1: 77%.
[0:30] Speaker 2: Ok.
[0:34] Speaker 1: What's the answer? 90%? 90%. Ok.
[0:38] Speaker 2: Yes. Correct. More than that. More than that,
[0:40] Speaker 1: more than that.
[0:42] Speaker 2: Ok. Next one, pick a number. How many countries do
[0:45] Speaker 2: we import our food from? 157 120
[0:50] Speaker 2: seven or 187?
[0:53] Speaker 1: 187. Correct.
[0:55] Speaker 2: You
[0:55] Speaker 2: just went with the highest.
[0:56] Speaker 1: That's right. Because I go to the supermarket and there's
[0:58] Speaker 1: so many different things I'm like. Right.
[1:01] Speaker 2: Ok. Last one. True or false. Turkey is a sauce
[1:04] Speaker 2: for eggs in Singapore.
[1:07] Speaker 1: Wow, false,
[1:09] Speaker 1: true.
[1:09] Speaker 2: Oh, yes.
[1:11] Speaker 1: That's kind of exciting
[1:13] Speaker 2: indeed.
[1:14] Speaker 1: So, to get it from so far away, I never
[1:17] Speaker 1: knew that. Ok. So that was a bit of an
[1:18] Speaker 1: eye opener. So it's quite clear that today our topic
[1:21] Speaker 1: is all food related in the sense, but we're talking
[1:23] Speaker 1: more about local sustainable food that we can grow literally
[1:26] Speaker 1: in our own backyard to keep our own country running. Right. Correct.
[1:30] Speaker 2: That's right. The reason why we're doing this is because
[1:32] Speaker 2: there was some local farming companies that were in the news.
[1:36] Speaker 2: Have you heard of V veggies?
[1:39] Speaker 2: No. Ok. They scrapped plans to build one of Singapore's
[1:43] Speaker 2: largest indoor farms in Lim Chu. Ok. Ok. Have you
[1:47] Speaker 2: heard of if,
[1:50] Speaker 1: if he
[1:54] Speaker 2: indoor farm factory innovation? Ok. They too have shut down.
[1:58] Speaker 2: They were supposed to be a mega indoor vegetable.
[2:01] Speaker 1: Ok. Right.
[2:02] Speaker 2: And sky greens is also skating back. Even the fish
[2:06] Speaker 2: folks are running into trouble. This one sounds fishy. Ok.
[2:10] Speaker 2: It's a company called Barramundi Group which farms Asian sea bass.
[2:14] Speaker 2: They had stopped production
[2:15] Speaker 2: in our southern waters, but they have a Brunei operation
[2:18] Speaker 2: that's still actually going strong.
[2:21] Speaker 1: But the question I guess we want to ask is
[2:22] Speaker 1: what's going on? Why are all these guys coming opening
[2:24] Speaker 1: up supposed to do big things? But end up closing. Right.
[2:27] Speaker 1: And after all, we do have a goal, the 3030 goal,
[2:30] Speaker 1: but that seems a bit hard to reach now.
[2:32] Speaker 2: So it's only six years away. So we want to
[2:35] Speaker 2: talk about whether that's going to be a reachable goal
[2:40] Speaker 2: with us in the studio are Kenny, founder and principal
[2:43] Speaker 2: consultant of Garden Asia and the local farm Welcome, Kenny.
[2:46] Speaker 2: Hi there everyone. I'm Kenny from the local farm. Thank you.
[2:49] Speaker 2: And Professor William Chen, director of the NTU Food Science
[2:53] Speaker 2: and Technology Program. He is also with the Singapore Agri
[2:58] Speaker 2: Food Innovation Lab or Sale.
[3:00] Speaker 1: Hello, everyone. Ok, gentlemen, thanks for coming. Let's get cracking. Now.
[3:03] Speaker 1: According to the Singapore, food authorities numbers local vegetable production
[3:07] Speaker 1: accounted for just 3.2% of total food consumption in 2023.
[3:12] Speaker 1: That's down from 3.9% in 2022. Seafood production also fell.
[3:17] Speaker 1: So
[3:18] Speaker 1: is this linked to the big closures? I mean, what's
[3:21] Speaker 1: what's been happening since 2022 that has resulted in this Kenny?
[3:25] Speaker 2: Yes, it contributes to farms that has closed geopolitical scenarios
[3:29] Speaker 2: have happened, you know, energy cost has gone up, kind
[3:33] Speaker 2: of disrupted a lot of high tech farmers in terms
[3:35] Speaker 2: of their costing. All this plays a part in terms
[3:38] Speaker 2: of their decision to whether to continue producing or they
[3:41] Speaker 2: are continue to just bite the bullet and just keep
[3:43] Speaker 2: burning down.
[3:44] Speaker 2: So I guess this affects the the total quantity of
[3:48] Speaker 2: uh vegetables and fish being produced in Singapore.
[3:51] Speaker 1: Well, in addition to what Kenny just said, I I
[3:53] Speaker 1: also think that maybe this also
[3:56] Speaker 1: uh has something to do with the establish, establishing the
[4:00] Speaker 1: p value chain proper ecosystem so that the local local
[4:04] Speaker 1: produce can actually reach out to the to the end
[4:08] Speaker 1: point that is not just consumer but other buyers as well.
[4:12] Speaker 1: So you're saying in a way, the ecosystem has not
[4:14] Speaker 1: been fully established. Well, it takes
[4:16] Speaker 2: time totally agree. I mean,
[4:18] Speaker 2: ecosystem itself needs both sides of the coin which is
[4:21] Speaker 2: demand and supply, ramping up. The supply is only one
[4:24] Speaker 2: part of the ingredient in terms of technology digitization, high
[4:28] Speaker 2: tech is just one ingredient in productivity. There is actually
[4:31] Speaker 2: a lot of other parts that is part of the
[4:33] Speaker 2: ecosystem that we need to build. So I think other
[4:36] Speaker 2: than supply that we saw that is trying to ramp
[4:38] Speaker 2: up over the years, demand matters as well. Farmers at
[4:41] Speaker 2: the end of the day are entrepreneurs,
[4:43] Speaker 2: they are not just farmers, right? They are just business
[4:45] Speaker 2: people who wants to survive. Let's unpack that a little bit, right?
[4:49] Speaker 2: Because infrastructural costs have been named as one of the
[4:53] Speaker 2: key problems for high tech farms.
[4:56] Speaker 2: Explain to our listeners what goes into a high tech
[5:00] Speaker 2: farm in the first place compared to, you know, a
[5:03] Speaker 2: regular farm, but the kind of farm that, you know,
[5:06] Speaker 2: we grew up,
[5:07] Speaker 1: the kind of the tractor the guys going around. Yeah.
[5:10] Speaker 2: Yeah, exactly that we see on TV, we didn't grow
[5:12] Speaker 2: up on the farm but you know what I mean? Right.
[5:15] Speaker 2: So the high tech farm cost is prohibitive is what
[5:18] Speaker 2: we understand. But why
[5:20] Speaker 2: I guess it's really very subjective, it doesn't mean that
[5:24] Speaker 2: the traditional farmers have it easy as well. Ok. Right.
[5:27] Speaker 2: Because they have been around for many years. So we
[5:30] Speaker 2: are comparing with farmers that have invested lots of money
[5:32] Speaker 2: years ago at that time is quite a huge investment
[5:35] Speaker 2: versus now when cost has gone up and then when
[5:38] Speaker 2: you compare to the investment, they have to go into tech,
[5:40] Speaker 2: what goes into technology or what goes into high tech
[5:43] Speaker 2: farms varies from different, whether it's a fish farmer, whether
[5:48] Speaker 2: it's a farmer or whether it's a vegetable farmer.
[5:51] Speaker 2: So three of the different farms have different technology that
[5:54] Speaker 2: they use and it depends on what technology that they
[5:57] Speaker 2: use and where they actually built it on to actually
[6:00] Speaker 2: put into place. So most of the investment comes in
[6:03] Speaker 2: is really the technology parts that they have to build.
[6:06] Speaker 2: For example, if we are building a hydroponic system, I
[6:09] Speaker 2: need to build the system, right? So that takes money. So,
[6:14] Speaker 2: but if you prepare a land,
[6:16] Speaker 2: what needs to be prepared that takes longer time that
[6:18] Speaker 2: a lot of people may not appreciate is the soil, right?
[6:22] Speaker 2: So if a farmer is new and they want to
[6:25] Speaker 2: just keep doing it, the soil is, takes time for
[6:28] Speaker 2: them to be as good as what it is,
[6:30] Speaker 1: I guess what we're saying is that basically the start
[6:31] Speaker 1: up is difficult and we don't talk about the traditional
[6:34] Speaker 1: methods because we know Singapore is land scarce. So we've
[6:37] Speaker 1: been going towards a more high tech version
[6:40] Speaker 1: Agri farming or Agritech farming, right? So with that in
[6:43] Speaker 1: mind the initial cost is high to get all this technology.
[6:47] Speaker 1: And you're saying, because it's so different. Every type of
[6:49] Speaker 1: farm
[6:49] Speaker 2: needs
[6:50] Speaker 2: more things to it than the traditional farm right from
[6:53] Speaker 2: the census to your parts. And most of them are imported.
[6:57] Speaker 2: So it depends on where you bring it from. So
[6:59] Speaker 2: the capital expenditure is very high. When the government s
[7:02] Speaker 2: fa started this itself, there is a lot of grants
[7:05] Speaker 2: available from all these high tech farmers to tap on.
[7:08] Speaker 2: And I believe majority of them,
[7:09] Speaker 2: we have tapped onto the funds to minimize what they
[7:13] Speaker 2: have to invest in, into respective funds. So
[7:15] Speaker 1: is it
[7:15] Speaker 1: fair to say that the start up costs wasn't as
[7:19] Speaker 1: exponential because they had grants to help them with the
[7:22] Speaker 1: provider
[7:23] Speaker 2: to take the grants, right? Provided they literally, so assuming
[7:26] Speaker 2: that they take the grants,
[7:27] Speaker 2: the initial capital is definitely high depends on where you
[7:30] Speaker 2: bring the technology from, right? But at the end of
[7:33] Speaker 2: the day itself, there are grants available that the statistics
[7:37] Speaker 2: you can find them that they have actually spent tons
[7:39] Speaker 2: of money all to
[7:41] Speaker 2: help this farmers to have a good kick start. But
[7:45] Speaker 2: that's what happens. They have the initial kickstart, right? But
[7:48] Speaker 2: there's only one part of the equation. OK. So starting
[7:51] Speaker 2: may not be the biggest problem that they had because
[7:54] Speaker 2: they had money to tap into, they have the technology
[7:57] Speaker 2: to tap into, right? Because of the likes of scientists
[8:00] Speaker 2: and people who have these technologies to share. So then
[8:04] Speaker 2: what's the problem? Why couldn't they last?
[8:08] Speaker 1: Well, I mean, at the beginning of any high tech farm, they,
[8:13] Speaker 1: they look, they, they need to, you know, make a
[8:16] Speaker 1: profit out of this farming practice. So a lot of
[8:20] Speaker 1: them are going into something that local consumer may not,
[8:23] Speaker 1: may not be so fancy about. Like for example, Michael
[8:26] Speaker 1: Green
[8:27] Speaker 1: kale. This, I mean, how much kale we eat, right?
[8:31] Speaker 1: So instead of kale, it should have been like maybe
[8:33] Speaker 1: I don't know your buck choi or something that more
[8:35] Speaker 1: locals eat, right? But those are low profit,
[8:39] Speaker 1: profit.
[8:39] Speaker 2: And also how do you how do you compete with
[8:42] Speaker 2: the cheaper options in the?
[8:45] Speaker 2: So that's what I have been sharing with many people, right?
[8:48] Speaker 2: Why are we saying that overseas import are cheaper? OK.
[8:52] Speaker 2: So let's put it from another perspective, agriculture state around
[8:56] Speaker 2: Asia or around the world, majority of the farms are
[9:00] Speaker 2: part of their GDP, right? Means it contributes to them, right?
[9:03] Speaker 2: So what do the government usually do is that they
[9:05] Speaker 2: will subsidize the agriculture sector to make it competitive so
[9:08] Speaker 2: that they can export.
[9:10] Speaker 2: So in a layman terms, for example, if you eat
[9:14] Speaker 2: a Australian beef in Singapore, maybe you have to thank
[9:17] Speaker 2: the Australians who pay tax to the government to subsidize
[9:20] Speaker 2: their cattle farmer to make it competitive for them to
[9:23] Speaker 2: come to Singapore. But nobody will look at the import
[9:26] Speaker 2: food that come to Singapore has been subsidized versus what
[9:30] Speaker 2: we have to pay
[9:31] Speaker 2: to produce one maybe pack of vegetables in. So then
[9:35] Speaker 2: my question has always been, has it been apple to
[9:38] Speaker 2: apple comparison or we just generalizing things that just because
[9:42] Speaker 2: of the dollar value? And we say that Singapore is expensive? Yes,
[9:45] Speaker 2: it's for, for
[9:46] Speaker 1: so in that sense, then Singapore government could if they
[9:50] Speaker 1: wanted to subsidize the local produce so that it is
[9:53] Speaker 1: competitive in pricing, but
[9:54] Speaker 2: they
[9:54] Speaker 2: already give these grants, is that not a kind of
[9:58] Speaker 2: a subsidy.
[9:59] Speaker 2: So the grant itself is just like a Kickstarter grant.
[10:02] Speaker 2: All right, for them to kickstart the K pe, right?
[10:05] Speaker 2: All right. What we are saying is the end part
[10:08] Speaker 2: of the chain, right? So Singapore itself, one of the
[10:11] Speaker 2: policies that we do is that we import more than 90%.
[10:15] Speaker 2: All right. And we know that we have to diversify
[10:17] Speaker 2: the basket as well
[10:18] Speaker 2: means we have put all the eggs in different baskets, right?
[10:21] Speaker 2: So we may have signed several FTA S to make
[10:24] Speaker 2: sure that we are neutral. We cannot be positioned that
[10:27] Speaker 2: we are actually subsidizing, right? So
[10:29] Speaker 1: then we should argue that economic point because again, these
[10:32] Speaker 1: farmers overseas, they are being subsidized because they actually make
[10:35] Speaker 1: more money from selling outside of their own country than
[10:39] Speaker 1: in their own country. But
[10:40] Speaker 2: they
[10:40] Speaker 2: already have a very large, large market in their country.
[10:44] Speaker 2: So they don't even have to worry about the bottom
[10:46] Speaker 2: line there.
[10:47] Speaker 2: Ok. Let's go to consumers. We ran a poll on
[10:50] Speaker 2: CN A telegram, whatsapp and Instagram channels on how willing
[10:53] Speaker 2: people were to support local produce. Ok. So we received
[10:57] Speaker 2: more than 18,000 votes and here's what we found. So
[11:00] Speaker 2: I'm gonna get you to guess, ok, one in four
[11:03] Speaker 2: are willing or not willing to pay more
[11:06] Speaker 2: to support local produce. One out of four not willing
[11:11] Speaker 2: to pay. Yes. Not willing to pay more. That's
[11:15] Speaker 1: a, I'm surprised that means every out of every four people,
[11:17] Speaker 1: three of them say, ok, I don't mind paying more.
[11:19] Speaker 2: Yes. But the question is how much more, how much?
[11:24] Speaker 1: Ok. So that's our next part. How much
[11:25] Speaker 2: more? Anything from 50 cents more to $2 more.
[11:30] Speaker 1: So, a packet of vegetables costs $2. I'm willing to
[11:33] Speaker 1: pay up to
[11:35] Speaker 2: 20% maybe 50 cents,
[11:37] Speaker 1: maybe two
[11:38] Speaker 1: dollars, 50 cents. So the vegetables are $3 then. Nope,
[11:42] Speaker 1: I'm not buying it.
[11:43] Speaker 1: So,
[11:43] Speaker 2: correct, 50 cents more was what they were willing to do.
[11:46] Speaker 2: But what's really interesting is that if you look at
[11:49] Speaker 2: one hour four,
[11:50] Speaker 2: they say that they are willing. Wheeling is just like,
[11:53] Speaker 2: do you support local? Yes, I do. Yeah. But do
[11:55] Speaker 2: you pay to buy local? Then that's where, how much
[11:59] Speaker 2: money only if it's 50 cents more. So that's going
[12:01] Speaker 2: to be a big challenge as well. So 50 cents
[12:04] Speaker 2: can be pretty subjective. Right? If you have a sale
[12:07] Speaker 2: going on and there is a huge group of vegetables
[12:10] Speaker 2: that are super cheap, then we will never hit our baseline.
[12:13] Speaker 1: But then the question is why does local produce have
[12:17] Speaker 1: to cost more?
[12:19] Speaker 1: Why can't it be as competitive as the other guys
[12:21] Speaker 1: that we bring in? Well, I think we also have
[12:24] Speaker 1: this currency issue, you know, sing dollar is so strong.
[12:28] Speaker 1: When
[12:28] Speaker 2: I go to the supermarket, sometimes at giant or NTUC,
[12:33] Speaker 2: these big packets from China, for example, leafy vegetables, they
[12:37] Speaker 2: are three for $2. Have you seen those? So how
[12:42] Speaker 2: do we compete with the local hydroponics, high tech farm,
[12:47] Speaker 2: the vegetables are better. It's cleaner, it's maybe even prewashed.
[12:52] Speaker 2: But I mean, I might pay more, but I don't
[12:54] Speaker 2: think my mom would pay double
[12:57] Speaker 1: for the average person. We assume all vegetables are kind
[13:00] Speaker 1: of the same. You know, the nutritional value is pretty
[13:02] Speaker 1: much the same. So I don't imagine it being,
[13:05] Speaker 1: you know, like 50% less protein or less nutrition that
[13:08] Speaker 1: vegetable versus the local vegetable. You know what?
[13:11] Speaker 2: We already have a problem with the consumer part of
[13:14] Speaker 2: the equation. Now, I think the thing is consumer are
[13:17] Speaker 2: very visual people. All right. So when they go to
[13:20] Speaker 2: buy certain things, either the price are talking to them, right?
[13:24] Speaker 2: Or whether they look at the vegetables, some of them
[13:26] Speaker 2: have that touch and say, oh this is fresher or not,
[13:28] Speaker 2: but just think about it, right. How long do you
[13:30] Speaker 2: think it will take for the vegetables to arrive in Singapore?
[13:33] Speaker 2: And how long can the freshness and nutritional f of
[13:38] Speaker 2: the vegetables? Actually, it depletes every day. Yeah. So imagine
[13:42] Speaker 2: if you buy a local vegetables, right? They are in
[13:45] Speaker 2: the shelf for seven days. They are still fresh because
[13:48] Speaker 2: it will slowly deplete until the seven day. By the
[13:51] Speaker 2: time you import some of the vegetables from other countries,
[13:55] Speaker 2: they may be three day old, two day old.
[13:58] Speaker 2: So by the time, then so many people will start
[14:01] Speaker 2: to say that, hey, my vegetable don't last. Yeah, why
[14:04] Speaker 2: is that? So, so this is because of the logistics
[14:07] Speaker 2: that comes in the whole chain logistics that how you
[14:10] Speaker 2: bring them through, right? And of course, different countries that
[14:13] Speaker 2: produce different, produce itself. Sometimes they have oversupply. So guess
[14:17] Speaker 2: where they will go if there's oversupply
[14:19] Speaker 2: when they oversupply from one country, they put it to
[14:22] Speaker 2: the next country causes the next country to have oversupply
[14:25] Speaker 2: and then it filters to us. Ok.
[14:27] Speaker 1: We have a lack of supply. So we just take
[14:30] Speaker 1: it in, right? So is that sort of where we
[14:33] Speaker 1: want to work towards where one day we have so
[14:35] Speaker 1: much produce that we are selling it to other countries.
[14:38] Speaker 1: But I think we also perhaps need to bear in
[14:40] Speaker 1: mind that the supply chain disruption are getting more and
[14:43] Speaker 1: more frequent. So we should not take it as a
[14:46] Speaker 1: given that the waste will continue flowing to Singapore
[14:49] Speaker 2: when I was reading about how much farming costs in Singapore?
[14:53] Speaker 2: I understand that because manpower costs and then there's energy costs,
[14:57] Speaker 2: there's water cost, there's land costs. So as you say,
[15:01] Speaker 2: at the end of the day, it's a business. Right.
[15:04] Speaker 2: And
[15:05] Speaker 2: do you think that farming in Singapore is costly to
[15:09] Speaker 2: begin with? I think there is no doubt because everything
[15:12] Speaker 2: is expensive in Singapore because we are a city. We
[15:14] Speaker 2: are just a little dot Right. It's not just about farming,
[15:18] Speaker 2: it's everything else, right? I mean, just, yeah, so that's
[15:20] Speaker 2: a given, right? Every city itself face this challenge, right?
[15:24] Speaker 2: But I think rather is the threat real like what
[15:26] Speaker 2: prof have shared. Yeah. Is the threat that one day
[15:29] Speaker 2: we have money, we can't eat money. Will it come true?
[15:32] Speaker 2: I did the test. So exactly. So during circuit breaker,
[15:37] Speaker 2: as you remember? Right. So I decided to do a Kickstarter.
[15:41] Speaker 2: I thought everybody is snatching away their toilet rolls. It's
[15:45] Speaker 2: about time for me to put some vegetables into the
[15:48] Speaker 2: front and hoping that they will subscribe.
[15:50] Speaker 2: Right? And so so I did a Kickstarter. I told,
[15:53] Speaker 2: I asked the farmers, the farmers all come in and
[15:55] Speaker 2: they say, ok, let's try five, I say 500 say, ok,
[15:58] Speaker 2: let's try 225 actually agrees to subscribe. So I went
[16:03] Speaker 2: to the farmers, farmers say, if you can get 20
[16:05] Speaker 2: that's awesome. You have 200. Why don't you go ahead.
[16:08] Speaker 2: So I say, ok, let's go ahead. But when we
[16:10] Speaker 2: ask people to pay, guess how many? Now it's my
[16:13] Speaker 2: turn to ask you 225. Ok. How many? Right? That
[16:17] Speaker 2: says that they will support, right? How many actually paid
[16:20] Speaker 2: 20
[16:22] Speaker 2: a little bit more? 75? All right. So that was
[16:26] Speaker 2: 75 of packs for six months. All right, every week
[16:30] Speaker 2: we will deliver to it in 2021. We did another one, right?
[16:35] Speaker 2: We say we go for three months. All right. And
[16:37] Speaker 2: we change every week for you so that you won't
[16:39] Speaker 2: have the same thing for you, right? Ok. So we
[16:41] Speaker 2: thought 75 work a little bit harder. We should get
[16:44] Speaker 2: 100 families that willing to pay
[16:47] Speaker 2: and we say let's do it then. Now that's the
[16:50] Speaker 2: next number out of 75. How many stayed on with us?
[16:53] Speaker 2: 40
[16:55] Speaker 2: 1515. So what does it mean? You know what happens
[16:59] Speaker 2: during that period? Right. During the period itself when we
[17:02] Speaker 2: are panicking. Guess what happens to the media
[17:06] Speaker 2: we're sharing with you Singaporeans don't panic. There is lots
[17:10] Speaker 2: of food behind. We have enough, don't snatch, don't, we
[17:14] Speaker 2: will replenish. We have enough. We have stockpiles. We have this,
[17:17] Speaker 2: we have that. This is exactly what Steve told me
[17:20] Speaker 2: before we started this recording. He says, I'm not worried
[17:24] Speaker 2: about food security. Like the government is very good. So
[17:27] Speaker 2: the trust is there, right? So we were really jaded
[17:30] Speaker 2: at that point in time. All right. But thankfully something happened,
[17:33] Speaker 2: a business friend contacted me
[17:35] Speaker 2: and say that can I like your three months back?
[17:37] Speaker 2: But don't send to my home, send to the poor.
[17:42] Speaker 2: That was the moment where we started to realize that
[17:46] Speaker 2: where we send, who we send doesn't matter as long
[17:49] Speaker 2: as the person appreciate local produce, right? How somebody is
[17:52] Speaker 2: paying for it. So the local farm started. Yeah. So
[17:55] Speaker 2: pros you were telling us this, right? Don't just depend
[17:58] Speaker 2: on consumers, think bigger, think broader, go to businesses, go
[18:03] Speaker 2: to hotels.
[18:04] Speaker 2: You were saying, yeah,
[18:05] Speaker 1: I
[18:05] Speaker 1: mean you just need one of these huge companies, the
[18:08] Speaker 1: airport catering services, they need tons and tons of vegetables
[18:11] Speaker 1: every day. Yeah, I think if we take these really
[18:13] Speaker 1: like national security level, then we can mobilize, mobilize, you know,
[18:19] Speaker 1: more stakeholders like the S A schools, hospital F and
[18:23] Speaker 1: B sectors.
[18:25] Speaker 1: They were just, you know, in fact, they will also
[18:28] Speaker 1: help us achieve this, establish a better value chain because
[18:32] Speaker 1: then you have this demand for people and then supply.
[18:37] Speaker 1: So in a way you're saying we force it, make
[18:39] Speaker 1: it work by saying, ok, all the military units need
[18:42] Speaker 1: to buy vegetables from ABC company and it becomes so
[18:46] Speaker 1: you force the demand and therefore the supply has to
[18:48] Speaker 1: ramp up to service.
[18:49] Speaker 2: You come
[18:50] Speaker 2: up with the product and
[18:50] Speaker 2: then you go out to market and then you see
[18:53] Speaker 2: whether people like it, but in this case, because there's
[18:55] Speaker 2: so many challenges. Do you think that that could be
[18:59] Speaker 2: a way to really meet our goal? The 3030 goal?
[19:03] Speaker 2: I think it's a food security problem. Ok. All right.
[19:06] Speaker 2: So we have to understand that this is a food
[19:07] Speaker 2: security issue that we're locking. It's not just a business deal.
[19:11] Speaker 2: All right. So we have to take that what we
[19:13] Speaker 2: just shared earlier with some caution, right? Why? Because
[19:17] Speaker 2: when we say let's get someone big to offtake, they
[19:21] Speaker 2: are big, they can off take a lot, then they
[19:24] Speaker 2: will ask back the farmers, can you produce, do you
[19:26] Speaker 2: have enough? Right? I have large volume. Can you do it?
[19:30] Speaker 2: Imagine that our vegetables is at three point something percent
[19:32] Speaker 2: right now. Can we even produce the 30 for them? So,
[19:37] Speaker 2: but then to me itself is that one is a wish,
[19:40] Speaker 2: one is a need. So what I'm saying here is
[19:43] Speaker 2: that it takes time.
[19:45] Speaker 2: So we are not asking the big players to say
[19:48] Speaker 2: that take all. Why don't you start with just one type?
[19:52] Speaker 2: Take 1% right? And then let the farmers sustain, right?
[19:56] Speaker 2: Let them grow more, get the ecosystem in place. Then
[19:59] Speaker 2: you from 1% you go to two and then you
[20:01] Speaker 2: slowly increase.
[20:02] Speaker 1: But you know, Singapore, we don't like to do things
[20:04] Speaker 1: too slowly.
[20:04] Speaker 2: That's
[20:05] Speaker 2: exactly the problem that I think
[20:06] Speaker 2: is a huge problem that we are not patient enough
[20:08] Speaker 2: ecosystem takes time to build.
[20:10] Speaker 1: We talk about 30 by 30. I think we are
[20:12] Speaker 1: also being a little bit impatient. We need to bear
[20:15] Speaker 1: in mind that the 30 by D was pushed out
[20:18] Speaker 1: in 2019. So everybody is now is asking a question.
[20:22] Speaker 1: If we look at the history of the ev, then
[20:26] Speaker 1: we should be more. Yeah. Yeah.
[20:30] Speaker 1: I don't see a technology driven.
[20:32] Speaker 2: I
[20:32] Speaker 2: totally agree with him is that we are too eager
[20:35] Speaker 2: to see results, but we have set ourselves a target,
[20:38] Speaker 2: a goal that we are trying to work towards. And
[20:41] Speaker 2: the ecosystem takes time. For example, I would
[20:42] Speaker 1: challenge you because with all the technology out there, everybody
[20:45] Speaker 1: else in some part of the world, somebody is already
[20:48] Speaker 1: doing something similar, not exactly the same but similar. Can't
[20:51] Speaker 1: we just leap frog.
[20:54] Speaker 1: Singapore is quite unique in the sense that we tropical country,
[20:57] Speaker 1: humidity is different and the temperature is different. The climate
[21:00] Speaker 1: condition is very different from the rest of the world.
[21:03] Speaker 1: So whether the technology is suitable for local condition, that
[21:07] Speaker 1: is some,
[21:08] Speaker 2: there's a lot of creating that needs to be done.
[21:10] Speaker 2: A lot of technology that many of them have brought
[21:14] Speaker 2: in from Europe.
[21:15] Speaker 2: All right. They have Israel, they have many different technology
[21:18] Speaker 2: that has in place. But are they really suitable for Singapore?
[21:22] Speaker 2: And what are the changes that you need to do?
[21:24] Speaker 2: What are the lessons that you may have to learn
[21:26] Speaker 2: before you really get a sustainable production.
[21:30] Speaker 2: That takes time, that takes time. I think it takes
[21:33] Speaker 2: people like prof you were telling us that you have
[21:35] Speaker 2: the grant from the National Research Foundation, right to work
[21:39] Speaker 2: on an efficient indoor farm system for Singapore.
[21:43] Speaker 1: So this is exactly the point we are trying to
[21:45] Speaker 1: Ken
[21:45] Speaker 1: and they're trying to make. That is we need to
[21:47] Speaker 1: find the technology which are suitable for local farming conditions.
[21:51] Speaker 1: We have received this one from National Research Foundation to
[21:55] Speaker 1: work with the farm farm. No, uh uh these are
[21:59] Speaker 1: Dutch indoor farm called Rui. So they have operation, production,
[22:03] Speaker 1: operation in at the Loyang site.
[22:05] Speaker 1: What we are going to do is to create this
[22:07] Speaker 1: test based infrastructure and create building and then, and then
[22:12] Speaker 1: we would test all the innovation that we develop through
[22:16] Speaker 1: this ground and then see whether they are suitable for
[22:19] Speaker 1: the to enhance the farming yield or nutritional value. So
[22:24] Speaker 1: I think this this way then we from farming perspective,
[22:27] Speaker 1: we already have a value chain because
[22:29] Speaker 1: on technology, we tweak the condition to see whether they
[22:32] Speaker 1: are suitable to help Singapore achieve a better yield, better nutrition.
[22:37] Speaker 1: And then from there, we move on to the farm site.
[22:39] Speaker 1: So there's no disruption,
[22:41] Speaker 2: the other layer itself is that while he's taking time
[22:44] Speaker 2: that is needed for a proof of concept or whether
[22:47] Speaker 2: to make sure that it's suitable itself farmers operation cost
[22:52] Speaker 2: farmers basically burning every day. All right. So when we
[22:56] Speaker 2: have a goal,
[22:57] Speaker 2: the question itself is that whose goal is that? Is
[23:00] Speaker 2: it a farmer's dream to hit 2030? Maybe I just
[23:04] Speaker 2: want to produce enough to be sustainable. But if you
[23:07] Speaker 2: ramp up the production, then there must be an ecosystem
[23:10] Speaker 2: where the demand comes in. If you think about it,
[23:12] Speaker 2: like what profit share 2019 was all started. We are
[23:15] Speaker 2: like maybe like what, six less than six years about, right.
[23:19] Speaker 2: We are just about six years now. Right? And what
[23:22] Speaker 2: has changed since the six years, every student that goes
[23:25] Speaker 2: back home
[23:26] Speaker 2: know that food security is important because it filters to
[23:29] Speaker 2: the moe syllabus. Every kid knows that technology is the
[23:33] Speaker 2: way the aunties and uncles in the community will receive
[23:36] Speaker 2: seeds for them to grow vegetables. So all this takes time. Right. Right.
[23:40] Speaker 2: Because let's put it back
[23:42] Speaker 2: in the sixties itself. We are self efficient in food.
[23:46] Speaker 2: We are agriculture state, we export pork,
[23:50] Speaker 1: right.
[23:51] Speaker 2: So the thing is that after 50 over years to
[23:55] Speaker 2: become who we are today as a first world country,
[23:58] Speaker 2: we have sacrificed and prioritize right to something. So actually
[24:04] Speaker 2: we are just
[24:05] Speaker 2: one big route to me. Yeah. So I think agriculture
[24:08] Speaker 2: is always the cornerstone of civilization. It's just a matter
[24:11] Speaker 2: of how we rook into agriculture and see whether what
[24:15] Speaker 2: we have. And the only problem that Singapore has that
[24:17] Speaker 2: a lot of country doesn't have the same problem is
[24:19] Speaker 2: that we do not have a hinder land. So I
[24:21] Speaker 2: can't push the farmers to somewhere else. Where else can
[24:24] Speaker 2: we go? Lim Chu Kang. That's where we
[24:26] Speaker 1: multi story car
[24:27] Speaker 1: park,
[24:30] Speaker 2: the car on top of my HDB. So what we
[24:33] Speaker 2: always say is that we are limited land but we
[24:35] Speaker 2: have import space. But we are forced to think
[24:38] Speaker 1: right on one point when I see the Singapore, the
[24:42] Speaker 1: challenges we are facing is similar elsewhere. Also the food, import,
[24:48] Speaker 1: even the big country, they all import food. So we're
[24:51] Speaker 1: not the only one. So about
[24:53] Speaker 2: dependence is it's quite serious, right? I mean when when
[24:57] Speaker 2: Malaysia has a chicken ban,
[24:59] Speaker 2: that was kind of a bit of a chaos, right?
[25:01] Speaker 2: On the
[25:02] Speaker 1: what I'm trying to get at is that for example,
[25:05] Speaker 1: some big country like China France, they may think, oh,
[25:08] Speaker 1: let's not worry about it. We have plenty of land.
[25:12] Speaker 1: In fact, they just simply import
[25:14] Speaker 1: food.
[25:14] Speaker 2: I can say this because I'm 1/4 cha horticulture farmer,
[25:17] Speaker 2: every farmer, parents of farmers, their dream is to earn enough,
[25:24] Speaker 2: get the kids out of the industry
[25:26] Speaker 2: and not be a be a farmer, right? So it's
[25:29] Speaker 2: not just a Singapore thing, right? China is facing the
[25:33] Speaker 2: same challenge I have friends around the world. They are farmers, right?
[25:37] Speaker 2: Whether it's in UK, whether it's in Australia, they face
[25:40] Speaker 2: the same challenge. The biggest problem I remember I asked
[25:43] Speaker 2: South African farmer, what's the biggest challenge in your country?
[25:46] Speaker 2: Is it attracting young people to join the industry? How
[25:50] Speaker 2: different is that from Singapore? We are facing the same challenge.
[25:53] Speaker 2: This industry is not in silo,
[25:56] Speaker 2: right? Everyone across the world is facing the same challenge.
[25:59] Speaker 1: But this one is even more challenging because it's such
[26:01] Speaker 1: an old industry actually. And also
[26:03] Speaker 2: it's a very basic industry because it relates to our food,
[26:07] Speaker 2: which is something that you can't wish away. At
[26:10] Speaker 1: what point when we have, we said one out of
[26:12] Speaker 1: four are willing to pay but not pay that much.
[26:15] Speaker 1: I mean, is there sort of a goal that you
[26:18] Speaker 1: think in the next five years if we hit that
[26:19] Speaker 1: for you? It's like we're on our way.
[26:22] Speaker 2: But II I still agree what profit numbers are just numbers, right?
[26:26] Speaker 2: It takes the whole ecosystem ie for us when we
[26:31] Speaker 2: are trying to drive to be the aggregator of demand,
[26:34] Speaker 2: we simplify our produce because we realize that the persona
[26:39] Speaker 2: of people that buy local are younger female below 45.
[26:42] Speaker 2: But guess what happened to them is that they hardly
[26:45] Speaker 2: cook at home
[26:46] Speaker 2: and Singapore only have fish, eggs and vegetables, right? If
[26:49] Speaker 2: I try to sell to this group of people who
[26:51] Speaker 2: love to support local, willing to pay the 50 cents
[26:54] Speaker 2: but don't cook, but they don't cook. Where do you
[26:56] Speaker 2: think this vegetable goes to their mom? Right. So to
[26:58] Speaker 2: the salad bowl that they buy from like the salad
[27:01] Speaker 2: bowl places
[27:02] Speaker 1: they
[27:02] Speaker 2: buy,
[27:03] Speaker 1: but they got to buy kale for the salad bowl.
[27:05] Speaker 2: So that's why we realize that there must be innovation. So,
[27:08] Speaker 2: for example, we converted the vegetables to gelatos.
[27:12] Speaker 2: So the more gelatos you eat, the more vegetables you
[27:14] Speaker 2: buy and then we actually convert them. That's one way. Ok. Right.
[27:17] Speaker 2: And then we have to simplify vegetables
[27:20] Speaker 1: in a way. you are adapting what you're selling to
[27:22] Speaker 1: suit changing trends.
[27:25] Speaker 2: There is a growing number of people willing to pay
[27:28] Speaker 2: more to support local. That's why the statistics come about. Right.
[27:31] Speaker 2: But the question is that if you dig deeper, how much,
[27:34] Speaker 2: what is their lifestyle like? What do they really want? So, William,
[27:38] Speaker 1: what about you?
[27:39] Speaker 1: Well, I would say that we should look at the
[27:41] Speaker 1: food security more on from the integrated
[27:45] Speaker 1: perspective. It's not just about farmer, it's not just about consumer,
[27:49] Speaker 1: it's not just about technology, we need to, you know,
[27:52] Speaker 1: work together and find solutions that are suitable for enhance
[27:56] Speaker 1: Singapore's farm farm you and provide a proper nutrition for population.
[28:02] Speaker 1: I think with a collective effort, we should be able
[28:04] Speaker 1: to achieve that.
[28:05] Speaker 2: OK. So Steve, please buy locally produced vegetables.
[28:10] Speaker 1: Actually, I don't really like vegetables.
[28:15] Speaker 2: Do not listen to him. Thank you for coming on
[28:21] Speaker 2: and explaining to us. I do think that in this case,
[28:24] Speaker 2: the 90% is not a good score for us, right.
[28:27] Speaker 2: Usually 90% is good. But the more than 90% to
[28:30] Speaker 2: me
[28:31] Speaker 2: is quite scary. And this 3030 goal and food security
[28:35] Speaker 2: is really like an insurance. So we are actually investing
[28:39] Speaker 2: in ourselves right in our future. So that's what I
[28:42] Speaker 2: took away from
[28:43] Speaker 1: it in the back of my head. Just tell ourselves
[28:45] Speaker 1: food security. Remember, you know what if one day
[28:48] Speaker 1: this stops being imported, what will you do? I think
[28:51] Speaker 1: we will start shopping a little bit differently at the supermarket.
[28:54] Speaker 1: Thank you all so much for coming in for sharing
[28:56] Speaker 1: your thoughts with us. If you guys have any thoughts
[28:58] Speaker 1: on what you've heard or you can drop us a comment.
[29:00] Speaker 1: This will go out on youtube but also on Spotify
[29:02] Speaker 1: and wherever you get your usual good podcasts. I want
[29:07] Speaker 1: to say thanks to the team, team behind this production, Tiffany, Ianni,
[29:10] Speaker 1: Johari Jo and Chas Win and Rossley put a and
[29:13] Speaker 1: I guess that's it for now.
[29:14] Speaker 2: Till next week. Eat your vegetables.
[29:16] Speaker 1: Bye for now.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
