# Workers' safety on lorries: A system of many moving parts

An episode of [Deep Dive](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1491441787), 10 Aug 2023, 27 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/7740012e-e1bd-4f85-81c4-a7f50047134a/053184de-200a-4a53-a80c-ab6e006ab608/c58baf6a-0764-4a38-9a01-b05a017fbe8a/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=22e00ef9-7730-4062-8cd4-ab6e006ab624

It has been described as an “intractable” problem: The transportation of migrant workers to and from their worksites. Why is this issue so complex? How can safety and business realities find common ground? Steven Chia breaks it down with Debbie Fordyce president of migrant rights group Transient Workers Count Too (TWC2) and Associate Professor Walter Theseira from the Singapore University of Social Sciences. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: You're listening to a CNA podcast.
[0:05] Speaker 1: Hey, everyone. It's Stephen again and welcome back to another
[0:08] Speaker 1: episode of Heart of the Matter. Now, today's topic is
[0:11] Speaker 1: what has been described as an intractable problem, the transportation
[0:15] Speaker 1: of migrant workers to and from their works sites for
[0:19] Speaker 1: those unfamiliar. Let me get you up to speed on Wednesday.
[0:22] Speaker 1: 2nd August, several government agencies put out a joint statement
[0:25] Speaker 1: to say that a ban on ferrying workers on lorries
[0:28] Speaker 1: was not ideal.
[0:30] Speaker 1: Citing business realities has said that if companies are not
[0:33] Speaker 1: able to operate their businesses, there will be and I quote,
[0:37] Speaker 1: knock on effects on society which includes delayed projects and
[0:40] Speaker 1: higher costs borne by consumers. This was in response to
[0:44] Speaker 1: renewed calls among worker rights groups to ban the practice
[0:48] Speaker 1: petitions for a ban included 100 groups and individuals. Over
[0:51] Speaker 1: 20
[0:52] Speaker 1: business groups also urged the government to be careful of
[0:55] Speaker 1: regulatory changes saying there are real practical and operational complexities.
[1:00] Speaker 1: The issue is not new mps have raised it several
[1:03] Speaker 1: times over the last 14 years. At the heart of
[1:07] Speaker 1: the matter is the issue of competing goals. On the
[1:10] Speaker 1: one hand, we want to protect the migrant community who
[1:12] Speaker 1: build our roads,
[1:13] Speaker 1: schools or hospitals. On the other hand, is the question
[1:17] Speaker 1: of how to do it in a way that is
[1:19] Speaker 1: sustainable from a business point of view. So, is there
[1:22] Speaker 1: a common ground today, we're going to try to cut
[1:24] Speaker 1: through the noise and unpack some of the key factors
[1:27] Speaker 1: around this issue. What are the complexities? Can they be
[1:31] Speaker 1: innovatively solved? Who should be the one to do it?
[1:34] Speaker 1: And how
[1:36] Speaker 1: with me to discuss this issue? Debbie Fordyce, she is
[1:40] Speaker 1: the president of the migrant workers rights group TWC two. Hello,
[1:44] Speaker 1: it's wonderful to be here. Associate professor Walter Tara who
[1:47] Speaker 1: heads up an Urban Transport Masters program at the Singapore
[1:51] Speaker 1: University of Social Sciences. Hi, good to be here. And
[1:54] Speaker 1: just a quick note to add
[1:55] Speaker 1: that we did reach out to several business groups including
[1:58] Speaker 1: the Association for small and medium enterprises and the Singapore
[2:01] Speaker 1: Contractors Association. We invited them to come on the show
[2:05] Speaker 1: but they declined. Ok, Walter, I'm going to start with
[2:07] Speaker 1: you now, the the business community statement which you know,
[2:10] Speaker 1: it highlights how costs will go up. That's been met
[2:12] Speaker 1: with some criticism including from ambassador at large, Tommy. But
[2:16] Speaker 1: I can see how if you're not, you know, running
[2:18] Speaker 1: the business yourself, it's easy to dismiss the real concerns.
[2:21] Speaker 1: So we spoke to several people who, who are involved
[2:24] Speaker 1: in transporting workers. One of them runs a construction company,
[2:28] Speaker 1: they build highways and bridges he told us that a
[2:30] Speaker 1: job requiring about 3 to 400 workers will need at
[2:33] Speaker 1: least 10 buses. And he estimates that could cost him
[2:37] Speaker 1: at least half a million dollars a year beyond money.
[2:39] Speaker 1: There's also the
[2:40] Speaker 1: shortage of drivers and buses. So costs and logistics cannot
[2:43] Speaker 1: be waived away. As an economist break down the issue
[2:46] Speaker 1: of cost and how that will trickle down the chain.
[2:50] Speaker 1: I think we have to realize that safety is essentially expensive, right?
[2:55] Speaker 1: Or rather that safety involves tradeoff in the entire system.
[2:58] Speaker 1: What we do in the transport system is we try
[3:01] Speaker 1: to balance safety among other competing objectives that we might have.
[3:05] Speaker 1: So just to give a simple example that I think
[3:07] Speaker 1: everybody is familiar with, you just have to look at
[3:09] Speaker 1: the speed limit, the speed limit that we set on
[3:12] Speaker 1: the road, tries to trade off the safety of people
[3:15] Speaker 1: on the road versus getting to where you want to
[3:17] Speaker 1: go on time.
[3:18] Speaker 1: And so you could actually increase safety by reducing the
[3:22] Speaker 1: speed limit. But that would mean that for a lot
[3:25] Speaker 1: of people, you would take a huge amount of time
[3:27] Speaker 1: to get to where you want to go and people
[3:28] Speaker 1: aren't willing to make the trade off. I think when
[3:31] Speaker 1: it comes to thinking about safety for migrant workers, we
[3:34] Speaker 1: have to admit we're making a tradeoff here. We're basically
[3:38] Speaker 1: saying with the current system we have today that we're
[3:40] Speaker 1: willing to accept some compromises and safety in return for
[3:44] Speaker 1: a lower cost of the system.
[3:45] Speaker 1: The real issue there is that this is a choice
[3:48] Speaker 1: or a situation that we're forcing on migrant workers in
[3:52] Speaker 1: a way. And that's a very different situation from maybe
[3:56] Speaker 1: the safety trade off that you and I might make
[3:58] Speaker 1: if we're driving our own vehicle and we choose to
[4:00] Speaker 1: drive a bit faster or something like that. I mean,
[4:02] Speaker 1: that's a risk that we're taking on ourselves. But in
[4:04] Speaker 1: this case, it is a risk, I suppose
[4:07] Speaker 1: in a way we're imposing on people and they don't
[4:10] Speaker 1: have a lot to say in the matter. And I
[4:11] Speaker 1: think that's the difficult issue here. Really, Debbie. Have you
[4:14] Speaker 1: heard what Walter has said? Yes, of course, I agree
[4:17] Speaker 1: with all of those complexities that have been brought up.
[4:19] Speaker 1: It should be remembered that a lot of these workers
[4:22] Speaker 1: are making a very low salary. They don't enjoy a
[4:24] Speaker 1: minimum salary like most Singaporeans do with the progressive wage scheme.
[4:28] Speaker 1: But the people that we talk to usually are making
[4:31] Speaker 1: around $500 as their basic salary. If costs go up
[4:35] Speaker 1: for employers that usually will be borne by the workers
[4:38] Speaker 1: in some way or another.
[4:39] Speaker 1: So the employers already have a lot of costs to
[4:42] Speaker 1: deal with, you know, the levies and the costs of
[4:45] Speaker 1: housing and maintaining workers and the security bond and things
[4:48] Speaker 1: like that. We understand that especially these small subcontractors will
[4:51] Speaker 1: be feeling a lot of pressure with this, but I
[4:54] Speaker 1: don't think that I can come up with any sort
[4:56] Speaker 1: of solution. But sometimes we have seen some really fast
[5:00] Speaker 1: action on things. Remember in 2013, the so called riots
[5:04] Speaker 1: when that
[5:04] Speaker 1: Indian worker Kumara when he died, the problem was in
[5:09] Speaker 1: the issue of buses and transport. At that time when
[5:12] Speaker 1: that happened, there was a very haphazard system of small
[5:16] Speaker 1: transport vehicles including small lorries, jostling around the side streets
[5:21] Speaker 1: trying to pick people up. He got caught in the
[5:23] Speaker 1: middle of it. He was run over very quickly afterwards.
[5:27] Speaker 1: There was a system set up for buses to
[5:30] Speaker 1: transport workers in large numbers back to their dormitories and
[5:33] Speaker 1: there's a huge space there for them to line up
[5:36] Speaker 1: nicely and they're assured they'll get on the right bus
[5:39] Speaker 1: and the bus will bring them there and take them
[5:41] Speaker 1: back because of COVID. That system was scrapped because people
[5:45] Speaker 1: weren't allowed out of the dormitories when they were finally
[5:48] Speaker 1: allowed out, they started to come back to that area
[5:50] Speaker 1: in large numbers. And I've noticed that that area is
[5:53] Speaker 1: not fully operation
[5:55] Speaker 1: now that we're back to small lorries, ferrying people from
[5:59] Speaker 1: little India on Sunday evenings back to dorms. But these
[6:02] Speaker 1: are again these small open lorries. But my point is
[6:06] Speaker 1: action was taken immediately. Ok. So you're saying change can
[6:09] Speaker 1: be affected. It almost sounds like you're talking more about
[6:11] Speaker 1: the infrastructure to support these workers in this area of transportation,
[6:15] Speaker 1: we can't deny that cost is an issue. As Walter mentioned,
[6:18] Speaker 1: safety is expensive, ironically,
[6:20] Speaker 1: and that's one of the main arguments given by the
[6:22] Speaker 1: business community, including a project today. So I want to
[6:25] Speaker 1: just play you a clip. We have the vice president
[6:27] Speaker 1: of the Association of Small and medium Enterprises A Y
[6:31] Speaker 1: and this is what he said on TV. Imagine a
[6:34] Speaker 1: guy that can be Ferried together with a lorry now
[6:37] Speaker 1: has to take a separate transport, maybe two transport if
[6:39] Speaker 1: you have more workers, right? And you're going to add
[6:42] Speaker 1: up to road congestion.
[6:44] Speaker 1: And if you think about that, you know, if they
[6:47] Speaker 1: don't take a a grab because it's too expensive and
[6:49] Speaker 1: costly because it's gonna drive up cost, right?
[6:52] Speaker 1: They paid public transport, public transport may, may end up
[6:55] Speaker 1: taking longer. Your project ends up being delayed. So he's
[6:58] Speaker 1: really highlighting a certain level of inconvenience. Many of the
[7:01] Speaker 1: companies already have these lorries and these are their workers.
[7:04] Speaker 1: So it makes sense a fair concern, especially based on
[7:08] Speaker 1: the delays we've been having for many BT O projects,
[7:10] Speaker 1: especially
[7:11] Speaker 1: your, your views on that walter. If we want to
[7:14] Speaker 1: change the system, it's not something that I think is
[7:16] Speaker 1: going to happen overnight. But at the same time, if
[7:19] Speaker 1: we don't say that we have any intent to change
[7:21] Speaker 1: the system, I don't think any change will actually meaningfully result.
[7:24] Speaker 1: And that's really the problem here. So what I mean
[7:26] Speaker 1: by this is that,
[7:28] Speaker 1: I don't think that the situation if we have a
[7:30] Speaker 1: ban on transporting a migrant workers in, I don't think
[7:33] Speaker 1: the situation will be one where we convert immediately to
[7:37] Speaker 1: something else and I don't think it will be one
[7:39] Speaker 1: either where, for example, all the workers start taking public
[7:42] Speaker 1: transport or they start taking private buses or whatever. I
[7:45] Speaker 1: think it will be a mix of things. The real
[7:47] Speaker 1: response will be the following. First, I think we'll see
[7:50] Speaker 1: a movement of where migrant workers are staying compared to
[7:54] Speaker 1: their work site. So I think this current
[7:56] Speaker 1: situation where migrant workers especially in construction. So on almost
[8:01] Speaker 1: university living in dormitories, I don't think that situation will
[8:04] Speaker 1: be fully tenable. If we have a ban on migrant
[8:08] Speaker 1: workers in lorry, you'll have to look much more seriously
[8:10] Speaker 1: at citing workers much closer to their work sites or
[8:14] Speaker 1: closer to public transport. Then if you look at public transport,
[8:17] Speaker 1: I think you have to look at things like operating
[8:19] Speaker 1: hours to public transport, the operating hours, especially in the morning.
[8:23] Speaker 1: Don't make a lot of sense for a lot of
[8:24] Speaker 1: work sites which have
[8:25] Speaker 1: to really start at the crack of dawn. So you
[8:27] Speaker 1: might have to look at extending operating hours on some services.
[8:31] Speaker 1: And then finally, when you look at the transport infrastructure,
[8:34] Speaker 1: it's a reality that there are not enough private or
[8:37] Speaker 1: commercial bus services right now to accommodate their needs. And
[8:40] Speaker 1: that means that from the policy point of view, you
[8:43] Speaker 1: got to look at things like whether you need to
[8:45] Speaker 1: have more life and things, special life and coe categories
[8:48] Speaker 1: for these buses that it's not to say that this
[8:51] Speaker 1: is impossible. But what I'm saying is that
[8:54] Speaker 1: we're not talking about the situation, I think where you
[8:56] Speaker 1: banned this overnight and then everybody has to scramble. I
[8:59] Speaker 1: think it's more about if you want to be realistic
[9:02] Speaker 1: about phasing this out, you have to start putting in
[9:05] Speaker 1: some steps so that the entire ecosystem can adjust over
[9:08] Speaker 1: the next however many years to actually get to your goal.
[9:11] Speaker 1: I think that's a good point. I mean, you mentioned
[9:12] Speaker 1: it's pretty much a change in the ecosystem. There is
[9:14] Speaker 1: a change in the way we operate, which would be
[9:17] Speaker 1: entirely different from now. The statement from the business community
[9:20] Speaker 1: including a sme also released to the media, they said
[9:23] Speaker 1: in the process of transitioning to safer transportation modes for workers,
[9:27] Speaker 1: it is essential to acknowledge that society must be ready
[9:30] Speaker 1: to accept a change in the social compact.
[9:33] Speaker 1: It sounds a bit similar to what Walter has said.
[9:36] Speaker 1: But what do you take to mean by this change
[9:38] Speaker 1: in social compact? We really do have to look at
[9:40] Speaker 1: migrant workers from a more people centered point of view
[9:43] Speaker 1: rather than economic centered point of view. So Singapore is
[9:46] Speaker 1: always happy to pat itself on the back for creating
[9:49] Speaker 1: this economic miracle, but we just have to face up
[9:51] Speaker 1: to that economic miracle being built on the backs of
[9:54] Speaker 1: workers who are here in huge numbers. We're not asking
[9:58] Speaker 1: for an immediate ban to this kind of thing, but
[10:00] Speaker 1: it will have to happen in stages.
[10:02] Speaker 1: So for instance, a lot of workers do live on
[10:04] Speaker 1: construction sites and even though the dormitories don't have the
[10:08] Speaker 1: same sort of amenities and facilities, most workers prefer that
[10:12] Speaker 1: because it means that they can roll out of bed,
[10:14] Speaker 1: get themselves ready and be straight at work already.
[10:16] Speaker 1: The other problem about the way the lorry system works
[10:20] Speaker 1: now is not only the exposure to the elements of sun,
[10:23] Speaker 1: heat and rain, but the fact that they might have
[10:26] Speaker 1: to be transported to the work site hours before they
[10:29] Speaker 1: start work because there are too few lorries for so
[10:32] Speaker 1: many workers and they might have to wait a couple
[10:34] Speaker 1: of hours before they go back to the dormitory.
[10:37] Speaker 1: So the dormitories, they're situated far from any bus or
[10:40] Speaker 1: M RT stations. So how do people get anywhere before COVID?
[10:46] Speaker 1: It was a lot easier for workers to be living
[10:48] Speaker 1: outside of dormitories. They were living in residential areas and
[10:53] Speaker 1: they could make use of public transport. There are a
[10:55] Speaker 1: lot of buildings that are close to public transport that
[10:58] Speaker 1: are not being used that could be converted to workers
[11:00] Speaker 1: storms as is happening to a limited extent now.
[11:03] Speaker 1: But I think that the Singapore population would find that
[11:07] Speaker 1: a dis amenity to have to share all of this
[11:09] Speaker 1: public space on transport with so many migrant workers. But again,
[11:14] Speaker 1: why should that be, why shouldn't it be that they
[11:16] Speaker 1: have public transport made available to them? Do you feel
[11:20] Speaker 1: that this is also a sort of a mindset that
[11:22] Speaker 1: perhaps those of us in Singapore? But I think it's
[11:25] Speaker 1: also many other parts of the world, this whole not
[11:27] Speaker 1: in my backyard kind of mentality.
[11:30] Speaker 1: We know they're working for us. We know they're here,
[11:32] Speaker 1: but we don't want to fully embrace them in our society.
[11:36] Speaker 1: And that's very true. And that's a system that Singapore
[11:39] Speaker 1: has created to its credit, the system of temporary. So
[11:44] Speaker 1: the permanent temporariness of migrant workers who are never part
[11:47] Speaker 1: of the community. But would it be fair to say
[11:49] Speaker 1: that for the workers themselves, they might find that uncomfortable
[11:52] Speaker 1: too to have to be on the public transport system.
[11:56] Speaker 1: Everybody else doing peak hour to be living in an
[11:58] Speaker 1: H DB flat with them. I'm just trying to, you know,
[12:01] Speaker 1: throw a flip side. Is it possible that they would
[12:03] Speaker 1: also feel some discomfort not being among their own. If
[12:06] Speaker 1: they were living close to those areas, they would be
[12:08] Speaker 1: there in large numbers. So they probably would not be
[12:11] Speaker 1: as individuals. We're talking about 400,000 workers just about male
[12:15] Speaker 1: workers in the C MP sectors. So I don't think
[12:18] Speaker 1: they would be isolated among Singaporeans and I don't think
[12:21] Speaker 1: they would mind
[12:22] Speaker 1: the convenience at all. I think a lot of workers
[12:24] Speaker 1: feel that the dormitories have a prison, like quality to
[12:28] Speaker 1: them because of the kind of safety measures that are
[12:31] Speaker 1: in place, the difficulty of coming and going, the monitoring
[12:34] Speaker 1: of where they can go, but also the difficulty of
[12:37] Speaker 1: going any place, it involves a lot of time and money.
[12:41] Speaker 1: The workers themselves don't feel out of place if they're
[12:43] Speaker 1: mingling with Singaporeans. I think it's the Singapore residents that
[12:46] Speaker 1: have a problem with that.
[12:48] Speaker 1: So that is a much larger issue that I think
[12:51] Speaker 1: we are probably unable to tackle entirely in this discussion.
[12:55] Speaker 1: And it sounds like transport is just one of the
[12:57] Speaker 1: things in the cog. But with regards to transport, authorities
[13:01] Speaker 1: have come up with some interim measures. They are asking
[13:03] Speaker 1: for drivers to ensure that they are arrested. There's cover
[13:06] Speaker 1: for them in the lorries isn't overloaded. There are speed
[13:09] Speaker 1: limits
[13:10] Speaker 1: and we have seen a reduction in accidents involving lorries,
[13:14] Speaker 1: faring workers. In fact, uh I just want to play
[13:16] Speaker 1: you a clip from Amy, the minister of state who
[13:19] Speaker 1: shared a bit about this as well as
[13:21] Speaker 2: stated in our previous response, the government shares the objective
[13:25] Speaker 2: of enhancing safety for every worker regardless of nationality.
[13:31] Speaker 2: We have worked closely with stakeholders and introduce a suite
[13:36] Speaker 2: of additional measures, additional safety measures. For example, we have
[13:42] Speaker 2: mandated that the front passenger cabin be fully occupied before
[13:46] Speaker 2: the rear deck can be used to carry workers
[13:50] Speaker 2: required lorries, transporting workers to be fitted with canopies and
[13:55] Speaker 2: higher site railings.
[13:58] Speaker 2: Raise requirements for SPS and work permit holders to obtain
[14:02] Speaker 2: a Singapore class three license that will allow them to
[14:06] Speaker 2: drive light goods vehicles
[14:09] Speaker 2: and impose higher penalties for noncompliance.
[14:14] Speaker 2: These measures have helped to enhance safety and reduce the
[14:17] Speaker 2: risk for workers.
[14:19] Speaker 2: The average number of fatalities from road traffic accidents involving
[14:23] Speaker 2: persons on board lorries has halved from around six per year,
[14:28] Speaker 2: from 2013 to 2017 to around three per year from
[14:32] Speaker 2: 2018 to 2022.
[14:35] Speaker 2: The average number of injured persons on board lorries has
[14:39] Speaker 2: also reduced by about a third.
[14:43] Speaker 2: Our efforts will focus on improving safety for all road users.
[14:48] Speaker 2: We will also continue to roll out measures that address
[14:52] Speaker 2: a multitude of factors behind accidents such as driving behaviors
[14:57] Speaker 2: and vehicle speed.
[15:00] Speaker 2: The government recognizes that it is not ideal for workers
[15:03] Speaker 2: to be transported on lorries. But we also understand the
[15:07] Speaker 2: genuine concerns from employers,
[15:10] Speaker 1: Debbie are these measures enough? There has a reduction in accidents.
[15:13] Speaker 1: So could this be the in between having more interim measures?
[15:17] Speaker 1: So we're not banning it entirely but we're saying let's
[15:19] Speaker 1: make it safer. Yeah, I think so. But I think
[15:22] Speaker 1: that if the costs were to fall back on the
[15:24] Speaker 1: worker that would be troubling. So I think that if
[15:27] Speaker 1: you were to ask a lot of workers,
[15:28] Speaker 1: would you rather have a higher salary and higher risk
[15:31] Speaker 1: or would you prefer a lower salary with increased safety?
[15:35] Speaker 1: They would go for the higher salary. This is something
[15:38] Speaker 1: that has become a very public issue because it's visible
[15:41] Speaker 1: to the public. Whereas many other, the things that workers
[15:45] Speaker 1: have to endure are not made public. And I do
[15:48] Speaker 1: think that a lot of these small companies that hire
[15:51] Speaker 1: them
[15:51] Speaker 1: would probably not be able to exist without the deductions
[15:56] Speaker 1: from salary and other cost cutting measures that they take
[15:59] Speaker 1: that impact migrant workers. There's the problem, it will come
[16:03] Speaker 1: with costs. And I think that perhaps some of these
[16:06] Speaker 1: smaller subcontractors would be better off perhaps going out of
[16:10] Speaker 1: business and a different kind of system set up. Instead
[16:14] Speaker 1: the issue here is the workers just don't have a
[16:16] Speaker 1: lot of bargaining power, right?
[16:18] Speaker 1: Because they know that there are a bunch more workers
[16:20] Speaker 1: completely willing to replace them at the same wages and
[16:23] Speaker 1: lower wages. And so that's why I think, you know,
[16:25] Speaker 1: this whole situation, unfortunate problem is a lot of the
[16:29] Speaker 1: costs get passed down to them simply because the employers
[16:32] Speaker 1: know they can replace these guys. That that's really the
[16:34] Speaker 1: issue here. Nobody wants to be the first to raise
[16:36] Speaker 1: their costs and then pitch that project because you always
[16:39] Speaker 1: have to find the lowest cost and the lowest cost
[16:42] Speaker 1: means generally, you know, the lowest wage workers.
[16:48] Speaker 1: Hello, my name is Steve Lei and I'm Theresa Tang
[16:50] Speaker 1: and we are the hosts of CNN correspondent, a podcast
[16:54] Speaker 1: that takes you to the heart of the work our
[16:56] Speaker 1: correspondents do across the globe from China's COVID response to
[17:00] Speaker 1: the Child Care Center massacre in Thailand from the fall
[17:03] Speaker 1: of
[17:04] Speaker 1: to the rise of Anwar Ibrahim as Malaysia's Prime Minister,
[17:08] Speaker 1: we speak to the people at the reporting frontlines. So
[17:11] Speaker 1: if you want to know how the biggest global stories unfold,
[17:15] Speaker 1: make sure you follow or subscribe to us wherever you
[17:18] Speaker 1: get your podcasts.
[17:22] Speaker 1: Walter, there are many businesses, there are contractors that have
[17:25] Speaker 1: hundreds of workers and those that have 20 workers. I mean,
[17:29] Speaker 1: will it hit them differently
[17:30] Speaker 1: in the current ecosystem that we have? The contractors are
[17:34] Speaker 1: largely responsible for figuring out the role and how they're
[17:37] Speaker 1: going to get their workers to the site of making
[17:39] Speaker 1: those arrangements. And I think what you're pointing at is
[17:42] Speaker 1: that there's this fundamental problem of scale in a lot
[17:45] Speaker 1: of the sector in Singapore, which is that? Yeah, true.
[17:47] Speaker 1: We've got hundreds of thousands of migrant workers, but we
[17:50] Speaker 1: also have got dozens or hundreds of companies, many of
[17:53] Speaker 1: whom hire a very small number of workers from some respects.
[17:56] Speaker 1: It's actually a mystery as to why
[17:58] Speaker 1: we've got so many companies when actually many of them
[18:00] Speaker 1: probably suffer from very poor economies of scale. What I'm
[18:03] Speaker 1: pointing to here is that if we have some consolidation
[18:07] Speaker 1: in the sector, right? Or if we have, for example,
[18:10] Speaker 1: service providers in the sector who take up the role
[18:13] Speaker 1: of providing transport services. Right, then these are ways for
[18:17] Speaker 1: actually companies to outsource out contract some of these requirements
[18:21] Speaker 1: and then you don't have to worry about fulfilling it
[18:23] Speaker 1: themselves anymore. The other thing
[18:25] Speaker 1: talked about earlier is also the fact that for some
[18:27] Speaker 1: workers and some projects, there's going to be the option,
[18:31] Speaker 1: the realistic option of having those workers sighted on site
[18:34] Speaker 1: or much closer or the realistic option of them taking
[18:37] Speaker 1: public transport. The point here is that it will not
[18:40] Speaker 1: be a situation where overnight every single small company is
[18:45] Speaker 1: going to have to go and buy a bus or
[18:47] Speaker 1: something like that for their workers. It will be a
[18:49] Speaker 1: situation where some will have workers move closer,
[18:52] Speaker 1: some will have workers take public transport, some will contract
[18:55] Speaker 1: out the service. There are going to be a variety
[18:57] Speaker 1: of options. So we shouldn't imagine that all of a
[19:00] Speaker 1: sudden all these guys become transport companies overnight. That will
[19:03] Speaker 1: not be the case and it sounds like an outright
[19:05] Speaker 1: ban is really not the solution because it will hurt
[19:08] Speaker 1: both sides. But this idea of having workers live on
[19:12] Speaker 1: site because that's happened in the past. But imagine if
[19:14] Speaker 1: it were to be regulated that, you know, at least 30%
[19:17] Speaker 1: of your workers have to live on site.
[19:19] Speaker 1: Debbie, is that something you mentioned earlier that that could
[19:22] Speaker 1: be preferred by the workers too.
[19:25] Speaker 1: Well, it still does happen and I think it depends
[19:27] Speaker 1: on the project. Of course, you know, if it's a
[19:29] Speaker 1: very large project, look at Marina Bay Sands, everyone was
[19:32] Speaker 1: living on site. So there are a lot of large
[19:34] Speaker 1: projects like that where it has happened and it does
[19:37] Speaker 1: continue to happen. But those are generally very large ones.
[19:41] Speaker 1: There are a lot of these small subcontractors, as Walter said,
[19:44] Speaker 1: they hire 10 or 20 people. These are the ones
[19:47] Speaker 1: that I think tend to have the most problems with
[19:50] Speaker 1: their jobs, with their companies and they might
[19:52] Speaker 1: be hired out as supply workers to different places all
[19:55] Speaker 1: the time for them. It doesn't make sense for them
[19:58] Speaker 1: to live on site. They do have to have some
[19:59] Speaker 1: place to live. So, yeah, I remember a few years
[20:02] Speaker 1: back when I did some renovations at home, the guys,
[20:04] Speaker 1: I would see them walking in from the bus stop
[20:06] Speaker 1: and they'd have a shower after the end of the
[20:07] Speaker 1: day and jump back on the bus just like everybody else.
[20:10] Speaker 1: But I guess it was because there were like maybe
[20:12] Speaker 1: five of them, you know, at most, what other solutions
[20:15] Speaker 1: can we have. So if we look at other ways
[20:17] Speaker 1: to innovate this, if we put aside the ban,
[20:19] Speaker 1: what are the other strategies we might employ to deal
[20:23] Speaker 1: with the current situation and what can we do? That
[20:25] Speaker 1: would be fairly immediate from my side? It's very hard
[20:28] Speaker 1: for me to think about that because there are too
[20:30] Speaker 1: many entities that are involved and we're really not looking
[20:33] Speaker 1: for an immediate ban. We're looking for an improvement on
[20:36] Speaker 1: the situation and maybe eventually a ban on these small lorries.
[20:40] Speaker 1: But we can certainly understand why they're used and why these,
[20:45] Speaker 1: especially the smallest contractors
[20:47] Speaker 1: use of this. We noticed that with all of these
[20:49] Speaker 1: voices about banning lorries, we see very few workers who
[20:53] Speaker 1: are standing up to say the same thing. And it's
[20:55] Speaker 1: because they fear for losing their jobs. Sounds like it's
[20:58] Speaker 1: really the economics, I mean, would money in a way
[21:00] Speaker 1: solve this problem? So if the government were to give
[21:03] Speaker 1: more subsidies for the implementation of this, if we as
[21:07] Speaker 1: users were willing to pay more at the end of
[21:09] Speaker 1: the day, for the work that is being done, could
[21:11] Speaker 1: that also to help resolve this issue?
[21:14] Speaker 1: Yeah, I I think money actually does make a huge
[21:17] Speaker 1: difference because I think for a lot of the contractors
[21:20] Speaker 1: who are in the business today and again, to be
[21:22] Speaker 1: very fair to them, they have accepted a project on
[21:25] Speaker 1: certain terms and conditions with a certain price assuming that
[21:29] Speaker 1: the current cost structure is going to be what it is.
[21:31] Speaker 1: So all those
[21:32] Speaker 1: guys who have accepted projects over the next couple of years,
[21:34] Speaker 1: it's obviously going to be impossible for them to actually
[21:38] Speaker 1: do those projects on time and within budget and make
[21:40] Speaker 1: money for themselves if they had to contemplate a huge
[21:43] Speaker 1: change in regulations overnight, that forced them to basically change
[21:46] Speaker 1: the entire operating model. So I think to be fair
[21:49] Speaker 1: to them
[21:49] Speaker 1: uh with the current projects and pricing in mind, they
[21:52] Speaker 1: can't do this. But that's why if we're talking about
[21:54] Speaker 1: changing the system, uh it has to be something which
[21:57] Speaker 1: is not done overnight, but it has to be something
[22:00] Speaker 1: which is done with a sufficient timeline with sufficient plans
[22:03] Speaker 1: so that any changes in costs get priced into the system.
[22:06] Speaker 1: I think that's the important thing here.
[22:08] Speaker 1: The problem with the companies is that if somebody is
[22:10] Speaker 1: going to be the first guy to try to implement
[22:13] Speaker 1: better standards for transport of migrant workers, they'll suffer a
[22:16] Speaker 1: huge disadvantage in the market. And so I think one
[22:19] Speaker 1: possible way of getting around this is for the market
[22:22] Speaker 1: for the people who are buying construction services to actually
[22:24] Speaker 1: move first. And what we've done in the past I
[22:27] Speaker 1: think is that uh when we have a problem with
[22:29] Speaker 1: the ecosystem and we want it to get moving in
[22:32] Speaker 1: the correct direction,
[22:33] Speaker 1: sometimes it might be the public sector which needs to
[22:36] Speaker 1: take the lead. So that means that for public sector
[22:39] Speaker 1: construction projects could be heb projects or if you're more
[22:42] Speaker 1: cost worried, it could be, for example, other government infrastructure,
[22:46] Speaker 1: you could say that you want to see perhaps a
[22:49] Speaker 1: higher minimum standard for worker protection in terms of transport.
[22:52] Speaker 1: And so you would say that part of the conditions
[22:55] Speaker 1: of tendering for those projects is that you stipulate, you
[22:58] Speaker 1: guarantee that you provide a certain transport
[23:01] Speaker 1: standard, which is better than the current situation of migrant
[23:03] Speaker 1: workers and lorries and so on, right? So, so that
[23:05] Speaker 1: could be one way of moving it forward. The idea
[23:07] Speaker 1: there is that if you start with certain public sector
[23:10] Speaker 1: projects where you're willing to absorb, perhaps the increased cost, right,
[23:14] Speaker 1: then you could actually lay the groundwork for the ecosystem
[23:17] Speaker 1: to start moving gradually in the correct direction. So that's
[23:20] Speaker 1: one way of looking at it. But again, here, we're
[23:22] Speaker 1: talking about public money, we're talking about the burden of taxpayers.
[23:25] Speaker 1: So this would have to be, you know, something
[23:28] Speaker 1: that has public support. It can't be a situation of,
[23:31] Speaker 1: you know, the government saying we want to do this.
[23:33] Speaker 1: And then the next day, the public says, what are
[23:35] Speaker 1: you doing about taxpayer dollars? We at least have to
[23:38] Speaker 1: have probably more broad consensus on this from the public
[23:42] Speaker 1: that we want to see things moving in that direction. OK.
[23:45] Speaker 1: Last question, moving forward, we obviously can't find a solution today.
[23:47] Speaker 1: Do you think the next step needs to be sort
[23:50] Speaker 1: of a task force to set up a committee to
[23:52] Speaker 1: look at this? And what are some of the areas
[23:53] Speaker 1: that you feel should be addressed in the
[23:55] Speaker 1: future? Walter from a social perspective, we decide that it's
[24:00] Speaker 1: untenable that we subject migrant workers to essentially a different
[24:04] Speaker 1: safety standard from what we want to accept for Singaporeans.
[24:07] Speaker 1: If that's the case, then I think we do actually
[24:10] Speaker 1: need to set some steps in motion to think about
[24:12] Speaker 1: this more carefully and think about what are the steps
[24:14] Speaker 1: we need to take to actually solve the problem sustainably
[24:18] Speaker 1: if you want to talk about the task force, I
[24:19] Speaker 1: do think that if we agree that this is a problem,
[24:22] Speaker 1: a task force,
[24:23] Speaker 1: it is important because it is very clear to me
[24:26] Speaker 1: that we cannot have the responsibility for solving. The problem
[24:30] Speaker 1: lies solely on the backs of the companies involved in
[24:33] Speaker 1: hiring migrant workers. And that's because there are so many
[24:36] Speaker 1: moving parts to this. We're talking about having workers live
[24:40] Speaker 1: closer to their work site, which means that for example,
[24:43] Speaker 1: for H DB residents and Singaporeans, they have to accept
[24:45] Speaker 1: that there might be more migrant workers in the community.
[24:48] Speaker 1: So that's one important stakeholder. We're talking,
[24:50] Speaker 1: talking about possibly adapting the public transport system to accommodate
[24:54] Speaker 1: migrant worker transport more readily, which means more operating costs,
[24:57] Speaker 1: for example, perhaps extended operating hours in some areas. And
[25:01] Speaker 1: we're also talking about the rest of the transport system, right?
[25:03] Speaker 1: Private buses which are currently inadequate to meet the needs
[25:06] Speaker 1: of migrant workers, but also from the point of view
[25:09] Speaker 1: of Singaporeans or motorists accepting that yeah, there might be
[25:12] Speaker 1: certain issues of congestion and so on. But again, these
[25:15] Speaker 1: are issues that we have to live with and adapt to.
[25:18] Speaker 1: Uh and that's why I think absolutely, if we are
[25:20] Speaker 1: really going to be serious about having this change, it
[25:23] Speaker 1: can't be overnight, there has to be a look at
[25:26] Speaker 1: it from many different stakeholders and we will have to
[25:29] Speaker 1: come up with some policy adaptations and acceptance of some
[25:33] Speaker 1: changes in our way of living in order to accommodate this.
[25:35] Speaker 1: But I think that's where we we have to be
[25:37] Speaker 1: going if we are serious about this. But if we're
[25:40] Speaker 1: not serious about this, and I think we have to
[25:42] Speaker 1: admit that really what we're saying is we're accepting a
[25:44] Speaker 1: different safety standard, right?
[25:46] Speaker 1: For migrant workers compared to Singaporeans. Yeah, there would just
[25:49] Speaker 1: have to be the political will to do it. There
[25:51] Speaker 1: are a lot more voices that are speaking out about this.
[25:53] Speaker 1: And so that's a good thing. That's maybe where things
[25:55] Speaker 1: will start. And I think it may have to come
[25:57] Speaker 1: from maybe foreign companies doing business in Singapore who decide
[26:01] Speaker 1: to pull out because they see this as a human
[26:03] Speaker 1: rights issue. So the foreign companies have their shareholders to
[26:07] Speaker 1: answer to and people have been looking into this kind
[26:10] Speaker 1: of thing, the issues not only of transport by lorries,
[26:13] Speaker 1: but of
[26:14] Speaker 1: recruitment fees and low wages and lack of medical treatment,
[26:17] Speaker 1: access to medical treatment, various other things. So that may
[26:20] Speaker 1: be something that would push the government over to rethinking
[26:24] Speaker 1: a lot of these things. But with the political will,
[26:27] Speaker 1: then perhaps a task force could be put together. So
[26:30] Speaker 1: it certainly sounds like the issue of transport is just
[26:33] Speaker 1: one of the factors that many of our migrant workers
[26:35] Speaker 1: are facing. And it sounds like it's a larger discussion
[26:38] Speaker 1: that we need to be having about having them in
[26:40] Speaker 1: our society working, being among us and how we deal
[26:43] Speaker 1: with that.
[26:44] Speaker 1: Well, thank you so much for coming in, sharing your
[26:46] Speaker 1: thoughts and to all of you who have been listening in.
[26:49] Speaker 1: In fact, if you have some ideas, solutions to this
[26:53] Speaker 1: uh intractable problem, it's has been called, you know, we
[26:56] Speaker 1: do love to hear from you so you can drop
[26:57] Speaker 1: us an email at CN A podcast at dot com
[27:01] Speaker 1: dot SG. And if you have any other views to
[27:04] Speaker 1: share also, just drop us a note, you know, otherwise
[27:06] Speaker 1: you can drop us a five star review maybe four
[27:09] Speaker 1: if you really didn't like it, but on Apple podcasts
[27:12] Speaker 1: or on Spotify
[27:14] Speaker 1: till next week, I'm Steven. Keep talking. Keep connecting. Bye
[27:18] Speaker 1: for now.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
