# Best of: When flights run into trouble, how much money should you get?

An episode of [Deep Dive](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1491441787), 5 Dec 2024, 25 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/7740012e-e1bd-4f85-81c4-a7f50047134a/053184de-200a-4a53-a80c-ab6e006ab608/b30c7391-5aa8-49df-969c-b23700227883/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=22e00ef9-7730-4062-8cd4-ab6e006ab624

Some passengers of SQ321 were given cash advances in light of injuries when the aircraft experienced severe turbulence. Are all airlines obliged to compensate? How are amounts decided and could you later sue for more? Lawyers Paul Ng, head of aviation at Rajah and Tann Singapore LLP, and Chooi Jing Yen from Eugene Thuraisingam LLP are guests. See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:03] Speaker 1: You're listening to AC N A podcast, Steve ask me
[0:07] Speaker 1: what's my favorite month of the year? Alright. What is
[0:10] Speaker 1: your favorite month in the year? December? It's my birthday
[0:15] Speaker 1: and the podcast team takes a much needed break in December. Ah, ok,
[0:21] Speaker 1: that sounds nice. I should have known that was coming.
[0:25] Speaker 1: So I'm telling you now. So what happens in December
[0:28] Speaker 1: is that we clear our leave and we think of
[0:32] Speaker 1: new material that we can come back with a bang
[0:34] Speaker 1: in January 2025. But if you're listening in, don't worry,
[0:38] Speaker 1: we will still fill the air time with some of
[0:40] Speaker 1: the great stuff that we've done before and we'll just
[0:43] Speaker 1: replay it for you so that you can
[0:45] Speaker 1: hear it and maybe feel it's even greater than it
[0:47] Speaker 1: was before. Yeah, so we picked what we call our
[0:50] Speaker 1: best of and these are our top performing episodes for
[0:54] Speaker 1: 2024 all December. You get to hear our voices still,
[0:58] Speaker 1: so tune in and we'll be back with a blast
[1:01] Speaker 1: in the brand new year in January 2025. Yeah. Don't
[1:04] Speaker 1: miss us too much.
[1:07] Speaker 1: Hello, everyone and welcome back to this episode of deep guy.
[1:11] Speaker 1: My name is Christina Robert and I'm here with my
[1:13] Speaker 1: co-host Steven Chen. Hello. Hello, everyone. Hi, Steve. Ok. So
[1:17] Speaker 1: you travel quite a bit for work too, right. Tell
[1:21] Speaker 1: me what's your biggest fear about traveling? I have to
[1:24] Speaker 1: fly budget. No, I'm kidding.
[1:27] Speaker 1: The comforts of life because we always fly budget so
[1:30] Speaker 1: privileged when you're on a plane that doesn't feel very safe.
[1:33] Speaker 1: What do you mean? Sometimes for whatever reason you hear
[1:36] Speaker 1: things in the plane which are a bit clinky and
[1:38] Speaker 1: you start thinking, well, this seatbelt doesn't really click so well,
[1:41] Speaker 1: it makes me a bit fearful of that journey that
[1:44] Speaker 1: I'm taking. Ok. And of course, turbulence is one of
[1:46] Speaker 1: those two when the plane is rocking. I mean, you know,
[1:48] Speaker 1: nobody feels safe in that kind of environment. Yeah, exactly.
[1:52] Speaker 1: So I'm not really good with flying. I have anxiety
[1:54] Speaker 1: and it flares.
[1:55] Speaker 1: So for me, right, if I were on that flight
[1:58] Speaker 1: sq 321, which is the reason why we're talking about
[2:01] Speaker 1: this today, I would have literally just, yeah, died of
[2:05] Speaker 1: anxiety first before any injuries. I think everyone knows about
[2:10] Speaker 1: this story now and they will probably have seen some
[2:12] Speaker 1: rather horrific images and videos of what happened on that
[2:15] Speaker 1: flight from London to Singapore that happened on the 21st
[2:18] Speaker 1: of May. It hit severe turbulence made an emergency landing
[2:22] Speaker 1: in Bangkok. One passenger died and dozens others were badly.
[2:27] Speaker 1: So today we're going to discuss the rather complicated issue
[2:31] Speaker 1: of airline compensation. Who decides how much to pay out
[2:34] Speaker 1: when something bad happens? Why do people hire lawyers, for example?
[2:39] Speaker 1: And when do they decide that they want to go
[2:41] Speaker 1: to court? Can you negotiate for more money without actually
[2:45] Speaker 1: going to court? These are some of the things we
[2:47] Speaker 1: want to discuss today. We got some legal folks with
[2:50] Speaker 1: us to help
[2:50] Speaker 1: for to answer those questions. This recording is also happening
[2:54] Speaker 1: online because since we're in the aviation sector, these guys
[2:57] Speaker 1: don't stay put in one country. So both our guests
[2:59] Speaker 1: are overseas at the moment. Mr Paul NG is the
[3:02] Speaker 1: head of Aviation at Raja and Tan. He's calling in
[3:05] Speaker 1: from New York. He's also an adjunct professor at NUS
[3:08] Speaker 2: Law. Thank you. Happy to be here,
[3:10] Speaker 1: Mr Chui Jing Yan, a disputes lawyer from Eugene Tuai
[3:13] Speaker 1: Singham L LP is in Bangkok. Hello everyone. My pleasure
[3:17] Speaker 1: to be here as well
[3:22] Speaker 1: on a recent flight out of KL we had already
[3:25] Speaker 1: boarded and then the pilot basically said, oh Changi is
[3:28] Speaker 1: not accepting any more flights in because there's a severe thunderstorm.
[3:32] Speaker 1: So the flight took off something like two hours later.
[3:35] Speaker 1: So it wasn't very long actually, but delays happen all
[3:39] Speaker 1: the time and we can't, you know, expect airlines to
[3:41] Speaker 1: be compensating for every little thing, right?
[3:44] Speaker 1: So my first question is what is compensation territory and
[3:48] Speaker 1: what gets you a food voucher in a hotel room Paul,
[3:51] Speaker 1: you want to start
[3:52] Speaker 2: sure. In terms of compensation territory at the high end, obviously,
[3:56] Speaker 2: bodily harm and property damage. And here we are talking
[4:00] Speaker 2: about people who are on board or within an area
[4:03] Speaker 2: that's within the control of the airline or the air operator.
[4:06] Speaker 2: In terms of what can you get compensated when you
[4:09] Speaker 2: are within this location. There are international conventions that deal
[4:13] Speaker 2: with it because aircraft obviously flies around the world.
[4:16] Speaker 2: The laws in each country is quite different. The most
[4:19] Speaker 2: widely ratified conventions, the Montreal Convention and we will come
[4:22] Speaker 2: back to that in just a while. And then if
[4:24] Speaker 2: you come down the scale from bodily harm, death and
[4:27] Speaker 2: property damage, there's delays and baggage loss. Now, that's more interesting.
[4:33] Speaker 2: I don't know whether you've read the back of your ticket.
[4:35] Speaker 2: There are terms and conditions so contractually you have certain rights,
[4:39] Speaker 2: that's one,
[4:40] Speaker 2: but rights are also imposed on the airline in your favor.
[4:45] Speaker 2: So for instance, if you flew in the US or Europe,
[4:48] Speaker 2: there are quite favorable rules in terms of compensation as
[4:52] Speaker 2: to how many hours beyond which you should get a
[4:55] Speaker 2: meal ticket, you should get money, you should get accommodation.
[4:58] Speaker 2: Let me
[4:58] Speaker 1: jump in there because there is the eu air passenger rights.
[5:01] Speaker 1: Is that what you're talking about? Can you give an
[5:02] Speaker 1: example of one or two things that would come under
[5:04] Speaker 1: these rights
[5:05] Speaker 2: delays
[5:05] Speaker 2: beyond a certain number of hours will entitle you from
[5:09] Speaker 2: a whole range of things
[5:10] Speaker 2: from food vouchers to accommodation to money. Those are strict,
[5:15] Speaker 2: meaning that even if the airline was to show that
[5:18] Speaker 2: there is unfavorable weather conditions, the legislation protects very favorably
[5:24] Speaker 2: the passenger.
[5:26] Speaker 1: So even if it wasn't the airline's fault, so to speak,
[5:29] Speaker 1: they would still have to compensate the passenger according to
[5:32] Speaker 1: that legislation. Right. That's what you're saying
[5:34] Speaker 2: in both the Montreal Convention and these other eu and
[5:38] Speaker 2: US legislation,
[5:39] Speaker 2: there are strict portions and there are portions that you
[5:42] Speaker 2: need to prove. And yes, there are strict portions which
[5:44] Speaker 2: doesn't matter what the conditions were. You are entitled to
[5:47] Speaker 2: a certain amount of recovery or remedy, which is good
[5:50] Speaker 2: news for people
[5:51] Speaker 2: flying.
[5:51] Speaker 1: Right. For example, if I took, let's say Air France
[5:54] Speaker 1: and I was flying to London, it comes under that
[5:58] Speaker 1: eu umbrella and something happens on that flight. It doesn't
[6:01] Speaker 1: matter what nationality, it doesn't matter where your original departure was.
[6:07] Speaker 2: There are
[6:07] Speaker 2: actually quite complicated
[6:08] Speaker 2: rules on that. The people who used to complain when
[6:11] Speaker 2: these rules were set up were low cost carriers because
[6:13] Speaker 2: their chance of having to compensate was the highest. But
[6:17] Speaker 2: in fact, the eu legislation was set up to punish
[6:21] Speaker 2: low cost carriers if they didn't make their timing because
[6:24] Speaker 2: they charge low fares and passengers should have at least
[6:28] Speaker 2: a minimum expectation as now as to Singapore Airlines flying
[6:32] Speaker 2: into us space or say Air Asia starts to fly
[6:36] Speaker 2: and they used to fly to London.
[6:38] Speaker 2: There are parameters that have to apply. How large is
[6:41] Speaker 2: the portion of the flight in the eu before it
[6:44] Speaker 2: qualifies for the legislation.
[6:47] Speaker 1: So it does sound a bit complicated, but essentially there
[6:49] Speaker 1: is some legislation to try and protect passengers a bit
[6:53] Speaker 1: more as you've mentioned. So when we look at this
[6:56] Speaker 1: case with SQ, is it then fair to say that
[6:58] Speaker 1: from what Paul's explained? Any,
[7:00] Speaker 1: anything that happens within the airline's control or within the
[7:04] Speaker 1: airline's premises, so to speak, they should be held responsible for. Absolutely.
[7:08] Speaker 1: The Montreal convention provides for a limit right now. It's
[7:13] Speaker 1: about us 170,000 where the airline has to pay if
[7:17] Speaker 1: you prove that you suffered that amount of damages regardless
[7:20] Speaker 1: of whether the airline was at fault.
[7:22] Speaker 1: And I think that makes a lot of sense because
[7:24] Speaker 1: when you're sitting on the airplane as a passenger, your
[7:27] Speaker 1: life is literally in the hands of the pilot and
[7:30] Speaker 1: his crew. And there's nothing you can do about anything
[7:32] Speaker 1: one of the rationales behind the Montreal convention. And before
[7:37] Speaker 1: the Montreal Convention existed, there was a Warsaw or Hague
[7:39] Speaker 1: convention where the limits were a bit different. But basically,
[7:43] Speaker 1: we have been seeing a trend where the compensation amounts
[7:46] Speaker 1: have been going up and up in terms of the
[7:49] Speaker 1: limit where you don't actually have to prove liability
[7:51] Speaker 1: on the part of the airline. It makes it a
[7:52] Speaker 1: lot simpler for the passengers. Of course, this doesn't mean
[7:56] Speaker 1: that you automatically get 100 and $70,000. The moment something
[8:00] Speaker 1: happens to you on the plane, you still have to
[8:02] Speaker 1: prove damage. You still have to prove what injury you suffered.
[8:05] Speaker 1: I think we should talk specifically about su 321 because
[8:08] Speaker 1: that's the one that everyone knows about. Now, they paid
[8:10] Speaker 1: out quite a handful of money from full refund of
[8:12] Speaker 1: tickets to cash up to $25,000 depending on their injuries.
[8:17] Speaker 1: The larger cash payments were called advance payments.
[8:20] Speaker 1: Now, we know these are actually goodwill payments and how
[8:22] Speaker 1: do airlines typically decide on the amount? That's what we're
[8:25] Speaker 1: curious to find out. Why did some people get 25?
[8:28] Speaker 1: Some people get less? Some people get way more even
[8:31] Speaker 1: before there's investigation or anything, right? Tell us why did
[8:34] Speaker 1: they decide to give up this money? Just like that
[8:36] Speaker 2: quite a lot has been said and speculated as to
[8:39] Speaker 2: the reasons Singapore Airlines is a premier carrier and its
[8:43] Speaker 2: reputation has to be protected. It is valuable.
[8:47] Speaker 2: So a gratitude payment where people are not asking for it.
[8:51] Speaker 2: My understanding is 10,000 for minor injuries and then 25,000.
[8:55] Speaker 2: But that's just the initial advance payment. As you say,
[8:58] Speaker 2: it could be more for the person who was deceased.
[9:01] Speaker 2: They are discussing what is an appropriate level of competition.
[9:05] Speaker 2: It shows actually to the public that they are concerned
[9:09] Speaker 2: about their passenger
[9:10] Speaker 2: and that they are prepared to put the money where
[9:13] Speaker 2: their mouth is and compensate them where injury that's on
[9:17] Speaker 2: their
[9:17] Speaker 2: airplanes.
[9:18] Speaker 1: But in a way they had no obligation to do so.
[9:20] Speaker 1: Are they trying to front load? What could be a
[9:23] Speaker 1: possible crisis down the
[9:25] Speaker 1: line
[9:25] Speaker 2: under the Montreal convention is there is a strict liability
[9:29] Speaker 2: up to a certain amount of 100 special drawing rights
[9:33] Speaker 2: is about 100 and $70,000. But you have to prove
[9:36] Speaker 2: that loss, it's not free. So
[9:39] Speaker 1: this is really goodwill in a way in. You got
[9:42] Speaker 1: something to add to this one. I don't think it
[9:44] Speaker 1: has been very clear as I position on whether let's
[9:47] Speaker 1: say for the 10,000 amount they've been offering for minor injuries.
[9:50] Speaker 1: I'm not sure whether if you accept this, you're not
[9:52] Speaker 1: allowed to come back anymore. Is it in full and
[9:54] Speaker 1: final settlement of the entire thing?
[9:56] Speaker 1: The 25,000 has been referred to as an advance which
[9:59] Speaker 1: doesn't stop you from going to court if you later
[10:01] Speaker 1: realize that you did suffer more than that. But if
[10:04] Speaker 1: it's the case that the 10,000 is in full and
[10:07] Speaker 1: final settlement, then it could be the case where SI
[10:09] Speaker 1: A is trying to, let's say reduce the pool of
[10:12] Speaker 1: potential claimants that they would have to
[10:13] Speaker 1: deal with. Are they allowed to do that? Can they
[10:15] Speaker 1: say I'm going to give you X amount of money?
[10:17] Speaker 1: But in return, you have to agree to ABC and
[10:20] Speaker 1: it happens all the time in litigation and even you're
[10:22] Speaker 1: talking about minor injuries, you still have a full spectrum.
[10:25] Speaker 1: Some people may have just suffered bruises, let's say if
[10:28] Speaker 1: they were wearing a seatbelt, you get $10,000 for that.
[10:31] Speaker 1: You know, we probably will take it, but of course,
[10:34] Speaker 1: whoever's in doubt if you suffered something more serious than that.
[10:37] Speaker 1: And as I say, that's a minor injury or if
[10:39] Speaker 1: you want to take legal advice before agreeing to anything,
[10:42] Speaker 1: it will always come with some sort of document or
[10:44] Speaker 1: agreement to sign. And you should consult a lawyer to
[10:46] Speaker 1: look through those clauses if anyone's concerned about it,
[10:49] Speaker 2: just to add that even the strict portion, which is
[10:52] Speaker 2: a limit rather than something that's paid
[10:55] Speaker 2: automatically of the proof loss. Just remember that when you're
[10:58] Speaker 2: proving loss, that amount can be reduced due to contributory
[11:02] Speaker 2: actions that you took or didn't take on the plane.
[11:05] Speaker 2: For
[11:06] Speaker 1: example, if you did not wear your seat belt,
[11:08] Speaker 2: well,
[11:08] Speaker 2: if the sign came out and it sounded that the
[11:10] Speaker 2: seat belt side came up, but people didn't have much
[11:12] Speaker 2: time to react to it and you did not put
[11:15] Speaker 2: on your seat belt and other people did. And other
[11:17] Speaker 2: people didn't get injured that there's still a case to
[11:20] Speaker 2: be made that
[11:21] Speaker 2: the full amount of your loss may not be compensated.
[11:25] Speaker 2: So you do take a risk going into a claim
[11:27] Speaker 2: situation rather than taking money up front.
[11:30] Speaker 1: Yeah.
[11:30] Speaker 1: No, I wanted to ask about physical injuries. I can
[11:33] Speaker 1: understand it. And I think that's how airlines kind of
[11:36] Speaker 1: decide how much and how much to give out and
[11:38] Speaker 1: all that.
[11:39] Speaker 1: But what about mental trauma? Because, you know, when we
[11:42] Speaker 1: were reading some of the comments on social media, there
[11:45] Speaker 1: was a recent incident of a Qatar Airways plane that
[11:48] Speaker 1: was stuck on the tarmac for hours and hours and,
[11:51] Speaker 1: and it was in the heat wave and people were
[11:54] Speaker 1: feeling very distressed, et cetera and some of them were
[11:56] Speaker 1: saying that they weren't physically affected, but
[11:59] Speaker 1: you know, they were quite traumatized by the whole incident.
[12:02] Speaker 1: So that's a good option for me to claim. It's
[12:04] Speaker 1: never been easy to launch such a claim in the
[12:07] Speaker 1: Singapore courts. That's for one. And generally speaking, you do
[12:11] Speaker 1: need to show some sort of fairly serious psychiatric disorder
[12:16] Speaker 1: or harm that has arisen out of the incident, which
[12:18] Speaker 1: means going to actually see a psychiatrist and being assessed
[12:23] Speaker 1: and then having a report and then going through cross
[12:25] Speaker 1: examination in court that that's challenged. So again, it's not
[12:28] Speaker 1: all that simple, which is why the current offers by
[12:31] Speaker 1: si might make sense to some passengers, right? I think
[12:34] Speaker 1: we're saying sometimes you're stuck on the tarmac for whatever reason,
[12:37] Speaker 1: it may take two, sometimes three hours, four hours. And
[12:41] Speaker 1: if the air conditioning isn't working, it's extremely uncomfortable. Is
[12:45] Speaker 1: there any recourse for
[12:46] Speaker 1: passengers didn't say I'm not happy
[12:48] Speaker 1: with this.
[12:49] Speaker 2: Maybe I can just interject actually the Montreal convention and
[12:52] Speaker 2: the case law that has taken place excludes non physical injury.
[12:58] Speaker 2: So mental injury, there are cases and of course, it
[13:01] Speaker 2: depends on whether the court that you litigate in recognizes
[13:04] Speaker 2: those cases. But there are cases that confirm that mental
[13:07] Speaker 2: injury alone is insufficient. But if you have a physical
[13:11] Speaker 2: injury
[13:12] Speaker 2: that then manifests itself as a mental deficiency or injury afterwards,
[13:17] Speaker 2: then that it can be claimed under the Montreal Convention.
[13:21] Speaker 2: So in a way indirectly you could but you still
[13:24] Speaker 2: need to show a physical injury.
[13:26] Speaker 1: Yeah, basically find yourself a good lawyer who can help
[13:29] Speaker 1: you argue in that gray area and a good psychiatrist
[13:33] Speaker 1: who write you a note while the Montreal Convention, as
[13:36] Speaker 1: you mentioned, does protect us to some extent, it doesn't
[13:38] Speaker 1: seem to really cover a lot of the day to
[13:40] Speaker 1: day issues that passengers may encounter delays last minute flight cancellation,
[13:44] Speaker 1: especially with the budget airlines, I mean lost baggage and
[13:47] Speaker 1: all that. I think we can look towards insurance to
[13:49] Speaker 1: claim
[13:50] Speaker 1: but things which often really disrupt your logistical travel. You know,
[13:54] Speaker 2: Montreal Convention is mostly death injury and damage to property.
[14:00] Speaker 2: It does cover damage to baggage. You have some compensation
[14:03] Speaker 2: under the Montreal Convention, then you look to your carriage
[14:06] Speaker 2: contract under the ticket and also the rules in the
[14:10] Speaker 2: location that you're flying and buy insurance.
[14:16] Speaker 1: Yeah. No, definitely. But I want to pick up that
[14:18] Speaker 1: you say and then it depends on the location you're
[14:20] Speaker 1: traveling to. So how does it work if I'm flying
[14:23] Speaker 1: out of Paris? But into Singapore, which law applies? Then
[14:27] Speaker 2: very
[14:27] Speaker 2: good question. And people hire lawyers to figure that out.
[14:32] Speaker 1: We got you guys online. That's what
[14:35] Speaker 2: it sounds like a very easy question to answer. But
[14:38] Speaker 2: just remember how many laws are involved. So the aircraft
[14:42] Speaker 2: itself has a state of registration, the citizenship of the
[14:45] Speaker 2: passenger is one where they flew out of is one
[14:48] Speaker 2: where the land is another. And then the countries that
[14:50] Speaker 2: they fly over so very often it depends on what
[14:53] Speaker 2: is the injury. And when it happened, one thing that
[14:56] Speaker 2: people have been focusing on is
[14:58] Speaker 2: the passenger in the airline. But frankly, in a litigation
[15:01] Speaker 2: case where we've seen elsewhere where there's death and damage,
[15:05] Speaker 2: the injured families will try to take action against everybody
[15:08] Speaker 2: around it, including the manufacturers. You would have noticed that
[15:12] Speaker 2: Boeing was straight in there to investigate the case because
[15:17] Speaker 2: it's their incentivized to protect themselves. It's always deep pockets.
[15:21] Speaker 2: You look around for who can compensate you
[15:25] Speaker 2: and then you look for the cause of
[15:26] Speaker 2: action.
[15:27] Speaker 1: Is it possible for the aviation companies, the industry in
[15:30] Speaker 1: a way, the airline, the manufacturer to come together and
[15:34] Speaker 1: share the burden, share the load. No, everybody's out for
[15:37] Speaker 1: himself to try and limit damages, right? That's the whole
[15:41] Speaker 1: point because if they volunteer, there's nothing to stop them.
[15:43] Speaker 1: But ultimately, it's a question of who can be proved
[15:46] Speaker 1: to be at fault. For example, if si was sued
[15:49] Speaker 1: or an airline was sued in a particular incident,
[15:53] Speaker 1: they have the option of bringing in the manufacturer as
[15:56] Speaker 1: a third party to contribute to anything that they may
[15:59] Speaker 1: be ordered to pay. That's a possibility. Let's talk about
[16:02] Speaker 1: taking an airline to court. What does that entail? One
[16:05] Speaker 1: interesting thing. And we were talking about this before we
[16:07] Speaker 1: started was SQ 006. Si crashes are few and far
[16:11] Speaker 1: between the touch wood. SQ 006, the one in Taiwan
[16:15] Speaker 1: was quite bad. 83 people died.
[16:17] Speaker 1: Sia's offer to the next of kin of those who
[16:20] Speaker 1: died was US $400,000. But in the end, 40 lawsuits
[16:26] Speaker 1: were filed in Singapore, more than 60 in the US.
[16:30] Speaker 1: And you're talking about different jurisdictions, right? In the end,
[16:34] Speaker 1: they settled out of court. That's another dimension to this, right?
[16:38] Speaker 1: I don't take the 400 K, I tell you, I'm
[16:41] Speaker 1: gonna sue you and then I settle out of court.
[16:44] Speaker 1: So all the settlements would have come with a confidentiality
[16:48] Speaker 1: clause which is why none of us would know what
[16:52] Speaker 1: amounts were actually paid out because none of the parties
[16:55] Speaker 1: are allowed to speak about it. Otherwise they'd have to
[16:57] Speaker 1: pay it back to S A,
[16:58] Speaker 1: a reason for this would be that for SI A,
[17:01] Speaker 1: it protects them from future speculative litigation, let's say, from
[17:05] Speaker 1: plaintiffs who are looking for a windfall. When you go
[17:08] Speaker 1: back to the question of jurisdiction, you notice that there
[17:10] Speaker 1: were lawsuits being filed in Singapore, there were lawsuits being
[17:13] Speaker 1: filed in the US. Now, when we as lawyers advise
[17:16] Speaker 1: litigants on where to file the lawsuits, there are strategic
[17:19] Speaker 1: considerations as well and there are factors which the court
[17:23] Speaker 1: consider and whether or not to take jurisdiction. So sometimes
[17:26] Speaker 1: the same case may be found in competing jurisdictions. The
[17:29] Speaker 1: plaintiff may file a claim in one jurisdiction and the
[17:32] Speaker 1: defendant may file in another. And that's because the laws
[17:35] Speaker 1: of the various jurisdictions may favor either plaintiff or defendant
[17:39] Speaker 1: in any particular case. But the question of which court
[17:42] Speaker 1: will eventually take jurisdiction is a complex one because the
[17:45] Speaker 1: courts look at a whole basket of factors.
[17:47] Speaker 1: So then when you come back to the question of settlement,
[17:50] Speaker 1: it may also be the case that the passengers who
[17:52] Speaker 1: sued in the US and passengers who sued in Singapore
[17:55] Speaker 1: for all we know they may be getting very different
[17:57] Speaker 1: amounts as well.
[17:59] Speaker 1: Yeah, you were saying the rules of how it works
[18:02] Speaker 1: in the US is a bit different, right? Yes. So,
[18:04] Speaker 1: I mean, in terms of substantive personal injury law, for example,
[18:07] Speaker 1: there may be some kinds of heads of claim that
[18:10] Speaker 1: the Singapore courts don't award as much as they would
[18:13] Speaker 1: in the US and vice versa. So depending on what
[18:16] Speaker 1: type of injury you suffer. You know, it may be
[18:18] Speaker 1: more advantageous to go to whichever jurisdiction. So it really
[18:21] Speaker 1: sounds like what you should do is first get a
[18:23] Speaker 1: good lawyer to help figure out what is your best
[18:26] Speaker 1: strategy
[18:27] Speaker 1: move forward. That's right. And in fact, you might even
[18:29] Speaker 1: need to speak to a lawyer in more than one
[18:31] Speaker 1: jurisdiction as a Singapore lawyer. I can say what Singapore
[18:34] Speaker 1: personal injury law is. You might at the same time
[18:36] Speaker 1: need to ask UK lawyer Australian lawyer, us lawyer, what
[18:40] Speaker 1: the position in their jurisdiction is. So, I guess for
[18:43] Speaker 1: the average person you're also thinking at the end of
[18:45] Speaker 1: the day, is it really worth it to go through
[18:47] Speaker 1: all this effort? One of it is, yeah, I, I
[18:49] Speaker 1: maybe you've offered me a settlement, maybe you haven't, but
[18:52] Speaker 1: for me to engage lawyers in different jurisdictions to
[18:54] Speaker 1: then fight it over a prolonged period of time against
[18:57] Speaker 1: a huge MNC I'm thinking, is it really worth it?
[19:00] Speaker 1: And I guess it depends on how severe your injury
[19:03] Speaker 1: or accident may have been. Right, Paul, what would you
[19:06] Speaker 1: tell people who in this situation, should I wait to
[19:09] Speaker 1: then ask for more? What approach should they take
[19:12] Speaker 2: any form of litigation can be long and costly? If
[19:17] Speaker 2: you are relying on the judge to make a decision,
[19:19] Speaker 2: there's some uncertainty so you could have a law
[19:22] Speaker 2: and costly litigation and then not get the result you
[19:25] Speaker 2: want because legal system is adversary a win lose situation. Now,
[19:30] Speaker 2: there's some historical basis to why there are these international
[19:33] Speaker 2: conventions which is actually to protect the resilience of the
[19:37] Speaker 2: aviation industry. You don't want airlines to not be airlines
[19:41] Speaker 2: just because they could be sued by people who get
[19:43] Speaker 2: injured and there is some risk in flying. Although obviously
[19:46] Speaker 2: we are told it's safer than driving on the road.
[19:50] Speaker 2: I think one thing that people don't talk about very
[19:52] Speaker 2: much is that, as we said before the Montreal Convention,
[19:55] Speaker 2: there is a strict liability portion, but there's also an
[19:58] Speaker 2: exclusivity provision in the article 21 which actually protects the
[20:04] Speaker 2: airline if they are able to show that they weren't
[20:07] Speaker 2: the ones at fault. I mean, there are some technical
[20:09] Speaker 2: terms but essentially they weren't the ones at fault
[20:13] Speaker 2: or it's a third party that caused the injury. So
[20:16] Speaker 2: after they pay out the strict liability portion, if they
[20:19] Speaker 2: can prove that technically, for Montreal countries, you cannot then
[20:25] Speaker 2: take a separate action, say you find some cause of action,
[20:28] Speaker 2: bring it against the airline and claim for more than
[20:32] Speaker 2: the strict
[20:33] Speaker 2: person. This is if the airline is able to show
[20:37] Speaker 2: that they are not at fault and this people don't
[20:39] Speaker 2: talk about very much. But frankly, there have been cases
[20:41] Speaker 2: in the UK and in the US which affirm the
[20:44] Speaker 2: exclusivity of the Montreal Convention to protect airlines. Now, having
[20:48] Speaker 2: said that I've been interviewed before by CN on the
[20:51] Speaker 2: Malaysian Airlines, loss of aircraft
[20:53] Speaker 2: and the suits they are brought by the Chinese in China. Obviously,
[20:58] Speaker 2: they could still bring a case in China and a
[21:01] Speaker 2: judge that is not well versed in international treaties or
[21:05] Speaker 2: not well advised could make a different decision even for
[21:09] Speaker 2: something clear is that there is still a chance that
[21:12] Speaker 2: if you litigate you could win.
[21:14] Speaker 2: But as I said, long, costly and unpredictable and
[21:17] Speaker 1: you
[21:18] Speaker 1: could lose. Basically, that's the bottom line, right. Yeah, we
[21:21] Speaker 1: know lawyers are not cheap. So you end up paying
[21:22] Speaker 1: more than what you actually even got. So at the
[21:26] Speaker 1: end of the day, there's so many other considerations that
[21:29] Speaker 1: have to be taken into account. But we have to
[21:32] Speaker 1: ask you, is there a concern that this may also
[21:34] Speaker 1: result in one day higher fares for all of us?
[21:37] Speaker 1: Because airlines are then going to say, well, I gotta
[21:38] Speaker 1: buy more insurance. You got to take more protection.
[21:41] Speaker 1: I'm going to factor in more risks. Will this then
[21:43] Speaker 1: trickle down to the ticket prices? We see, is there
[21:46] Speaker 1: a concern there too? If it really is the case
[21:49] Speaker 1: that we are going to see more instances of unpredictable
[21:53] Speaker 1: turbulence affecting aircraft, then yes, it's going to be quite
[21:57] Speaker 1: inevitable because if you look at the Montreal Convention, you
[22:00] Speaker 1: know that airlines are going to be liable for a
[22:03] Speaker 1: certain amount if we are going to see more of
[22:05] Speaker 1: these incidents. And I don't see costs not rising for passengers,
[22:09] Speaker 1: especially when it comes to turbulence, right? Because a lot
[22:12] Speaker 1: of reports are saying that climate change is something airlines
[22:15] Speaker 1: can't control, right? Aircraft flying into an air pocket. And
[22:19] Speaker 1: just in the last few days, we've heard of a
[22:21] Speaker 1: few other airlines who have hit turbulence as well while
[22:23] Speaker 1: travel is a nice luxury to many, it's essential for some.
[22:26] Speaker 1: How would you guys sort of advise people who are
[22:28] Speaker 1: now looking at the situation? Thinking, well, how should I
[22:31] Speaker 1: approach this as a passenger? My next flight, what should
[22:35] Speaker 1: I be looking to do, Paul and go first.
[22:37] Speaker 2: I just flew to New York on SQ and any turbulence,
[22:41] Speaker 2: everybody had their seat belt on the stewardesses were seated,
[22:45] Speaker 2: no food or drink. So choose an airline that has
[22:49] Speaker 2: a good safety record. Singapore Airlines until now had a
[22:52] Speaker 2: fantastic day. That's the first. Secondly, I think
[22:55] Speaker 2: you do need to buy insurance and on the point
[22:57] Speaker 2: about ticket prices going up, it will go up because
[23:00] Speaker 2: the cost of insurance will go up if insurers have
[23:03] Speaker 2: to cover the airlines for compensating the passengers for their injury,
[23:09] Speaker 2: death or damage and they will have to because you
[23:12] Speaker 2: cannot fly
[23:13] Speaker 2: an aircraft without third party liability insurance. So insurance will
[23:17] Speaker 2: go up means costs will go up, buy insurance for
[23:20] Speaker 2: yourself and choose a good airline.
[23:22] Speaker 1: One
[23:22] Speaker 1: good thing that has come out of all this is awareness,
[23:25] Speaker 1: as we always say, prevention is better than cure for
[23:28] Speaker 1: me as well. I came up to Bangkok on a
[23:30] Speaker 1: scoot flight and same as Paul. You know, the moment
[23:33] Speaker 1: the seatbelt sign comes on, everybody is seated, all the
[23:36] Speaker 1: food disappears. Nobody dares to go to the toilet
[23:39] Speaker 1: in the past. Some people used to not be so
[23:41] Speaker 1: concerned about keeping your seatbelt on even after the sign
[23:44] Speaker 1: goes off. Now I notice even after the sign goes off,
[23:46] Speaker 1: most of us still keep the seatbelt on. That was
[23:49] Speaker 1: the interesting cultural shift, right for us because we're so
[23:53] Speaker 1: scared by all the images that we saw all the
[23:55] Speaker 1: blood and all the injuries. It was quite terrible actually. Yeah,
[23:58] Speaker 1: that will change the way we travel. I guess my
[24:01] Speaker 1: next holiday will be a drive to Malaysia. Oh wait,
[24:03] Speaker 1: that's dangerous. I think, I think
[24:04] Speaker 1: ferry to but maybe that is another option. I think
[24:07] Speaker 1: statistic despite all that has happened, airline travel is still
[24:12] Speaker 1: the safest travel mode amongst everything else. At least
[24:15] Speaker 1: for now.
[24:16] Speaker 2: I don't think air travel will reduce. It's just that
[24:19] Speaker 2: people on planes will be a little bit more careful
[24:22] Speaker 2: and he the seat belt sign,
[24:24] Speaker 1: which
[24:24] Speaker 1: is a good thing overall because it so happens. I'm
[24:26] Speaker 1: working on the talking point episode now about people who
[24:28] Speaker 1: were not wearing seat belts, but
[24:30] Speaker 1: the car
[24:31] Speaker 2: when you make that claim, the airline won't be able
[24:34] Speaker 2: to say contributory negligence, you didn't put on your seatbelt.
[24:37] Speaker 2: So there's a money to
[24:39] Speaker 1: this one is full negligence. It's true. We don't have
[24:42] Speaker 1: a habit of wearing a seatbelt, especially for a back seat, drivers. Right.
[24:44] Speaker 1: Exactly in the rear seat. But did you know that
[24:47] Speaker 1: actually by law it is mandatory? Oh, my God. We
[24:49] Speaker 1: built it up in all seats in the car, breaking
[24:52] Speaker 1: the law. I know guys. Thanks so much for
[24:55] Speaker 1: dialing in and sharing your thoughts with us. I think
[24:57] Speaker 1: this is one thing we just wanted to shed a
[24:58] Speaker 1: bit more light on the issue for all of us.
[25:00] Speaker 1: And yeah, if you're listening in, you have thoughts on this. So,
[25:02] Speaker 1: you know, next time you travel, what are you doing?
[25:04] Speaker 1: More of, less of drop us a note. Let us
[25:06] Speaker 1: know we would love to have a feedback from you
[25:09] Speaker 1: as well. Thank you to both the gentlemen here and
[25:12] Speaker 1: thanks to the team behind the podcast, Tiffanie Ang Jaini, Johari,
[25:15] Speaker 1: Joan Chansa Ween and sound mixing by Ken Delbridge. Thank you. Goodbye.
[25:20] Speaker 1: Bye for now.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
