# 199: Kelsie Schelling

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 10 Apr 2023, 49 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53132736/morbidology_199_kelsie_schelling_ad_free.mp3

It was a cold and dark night in Denver, Colorado, on the 4th of February, 2013. A young woman had just finished up her shift at a local clothing store, when she climbed into her car and headed south to the city of Pueblo. She pulled into the Walmart and sat waiting for her boyfriend to show up. The next day, she failed to appear at work… SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-199-kelsie-schelling PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] That's just his pattern. He finds girls to take advantage of, and unfortunately
[0:39] for Kelsey, it just went way farther than that. It was a dark
[0:54] and cold night in Denver, Colorado, on the fourth of February two thousand
[0:58] and thirteen, a young woman who had just finished up her shift at a
[1:02] local clothing store when she climbed into her car and headed south to the city
[1:07] of Pueblo. She pulled into the walmart and sat waiting for her boyfriend to
[1:11] show up. The next day, she failed to appear at work. Kelsey
[1:27] Shelling was born in the small town of Holyoake, just a couple of hours
[1:32] east of Denver, Colorado, to parents Laura and Doug. When Kelsey was
[1:37] eleven years old, Laura and Doug called the quits on their marriage, and
[1:41] Laura took on life as a single parent. Over the years, Kelsey and
[1:46] her mother developed a type bond and they were practically inseparable, but Kelsey remained
[1:52] close to her father as well. Kelsey was a young woman of deep faith,
[1:57] and she was very spiritual as well. She maintained a running list of
[2:02] her favorite Bible verses. Her close friend Ali Sandovale described her as fun to
[2:09] be around. She said that Kelsey was always laughing and they were always out
[2:15] to have a good time together, sometimes even getting into trouble. After graduating
[2:20] from high school, Kelsey enrolled at Northeastern Junior College in two thousand and ten.
[2:27] Here she was taking general courses in preparation for majoring in psychology, she
[2:34] met a young man named Dante Lucas. He was from the central Colorado town
[2:38] of Pueblo. Lucas was a standout basketball player from Central High School. He
[2:46] played forward for the Plainsman, and he had ambitions to one day go to
[2:51] the NBA. As his former coach recalled it, just had a mad passion
[2:57] for basketball. He loved everything about the game and hoping that he can,
[3:01] you know, go into a Division in basketball school and then maybe make it
[3:06] to the NBA. Despite the differences in their backgrounds and their ambitions, Kelsey
[3:13] and Lucas began dating. After studying for two years, Kelsey went to Vanguard
[3:19] University, which is a Christian school in Costa Mesa, California, while Lucas
[3:24] moved to Emporia State University in Kansas, where he hoped to play basketball for
[3:29] the Division one school. At the end of the semester, Kelsey took her
[3:34] first steps on the road to independence and moved into an apartment in Laramouth Square,
[3:39] Denver, Colorado. She found a job of Lauren Decor, which was
[3:45] a Highland ranch store. Despite the distance, the couple stayed together, and
[3:50] over Christmas break of two thousand and twelve, Lucas drove from Kansas to Denver
[3:55] and stayed with Kelsey. At the time, they were both twenty one years
[4:00] old and working hard at making their aspirations come true. After the Christmas break,
[4:09] Lucas returned to Pueblo and Kelsey continued working at the store. Kelsey was
[4:24] at work on the fourth of February two thousand and thirteen when her phone picked
[4:29] It was a text message from Lucas. He asked her to drive the two
[4:33] hours from Denver to Pueblo. When she finished her shift that night, Lucas
[4:41] told Kelsey that he had something he needed to give her. She queried what
[4:46] it was, but he responded, you need to come and see for yourself.
[4:51] That night, Kelsey finished her shift at around ten pm. She climbed
[4:58] into her black Chevy Cruise and began and driving in the direction of Pueblo.
[5:02] To see Lucas Mydway through the drive, Lucas texted Kelsey and asked her to
[5:10] meet him at the walmart. Kelsey was scheduled for work the following day,
[5:16] but she never showed up. Her coworker, Savannah Heggie, called her repeatedly
[5:23] throughout the day, wondering if she was potentially ill, but the phone just
[5:29] rang and rang. That seem afternoon, Kelsey's father, Doug tried to get
[5:34] in contact with her, but once again, Kelsey never picked up. Dog
[5:40] simply believed that Kelsey was busy with work and decided that he would try her
[5:44] again later. The ours continued to trickle past, but nobody could get in
[5:49] contact with Kelsey. Her mother, Laura recollected all of her friends started contacting
[5:58] us, saying we've been trying to reach Kelsey and we can't reach her.
[6:02] When that happened, that was like when I got really really scared, because
[6:09] I just thought that, you know, there has to be a logical explanation.
[6:14] Kelsey's concern family contacted Lucas. They'd been unaware that she had traveled down
[6:20] to Pueblo to speak with him just the night before, but Lucas confirmed this
[6:26] to them He said that they had spoken, but that Kelsey was upset with
[6:30] him, so he turned around and walked back to his grandmother's home. Laura
[6:36] recalled and I just said, if you hear from her, you need to
[6:42] tell her that we're taking this very seriously and that we're calling the police.
[6:46] And he was like, okay, I will. It wasn't until the thirteenth
[6:53] of February that a statewide alert went out for Kelsey, with Denver Police spokesman
[6:58] Sonny Jackson referring to her disappearance as out of character. Investigators were keen to
[7:04] trace Kelsey's last known movements. They appealed to the public for information and provided
[7:12] a photograph and description of Kelsey and her two thousand and eleven black Chevrolet Crews,
[7:16] which was still missing. Kelsey stood around five feet four inches tall and
[7:24] wed approximately one hundred and twenty ponds. As for identifying features, she had
[7:30] three tattoos, including a Chinese symbol on her neck, a cursive scrawl on
[7:35] the side of her left arm, and a Fleur de lays on her ribcage.
[7:41] Investigator stated that foile play was not suspected in Kelsey's disappearance. She was
[7:46] simply categorized as a missing person, but each day that passed, concerns were
[7:51] rising further and further. As his common knowledge, the first forty eight to
[7:57] seventy two hours of a disappearance are the most idol when it comes to finding
[8:01] clues and ensuring that the missing person is found safe and well. However,
[8:09] Kelsey had already been missing for nine days by the time the statewide alert went
[8:13] out. Naturally, the first person that investigators wanted to speak to was Kelsey's
[8:18] boyfriend, Dante Lucas. He confirmed that Kelsey had arrived in Pueblo to speak
[8:24] with him. Text messages confirmed that Kelsey had arrived at the Walmart. However,
[8:31] she appeared to be waiting for Lucas to show up for almost an r
[8:35] She texted Lucas to say that she was tired of waiting and that she would
[8:41] come to him. Lucas responded and asked Kelsey to meet him on a specific
[8:46] street. It was a street near his grandmother's home where he had been staying.
[8:54] Text messages indicated that Kelsey arrived at the street like asked, but once
[8:58] again she was left waiting for Lucas. She texted him, where are you
[9:05] I've been here over and are just waiting. According to Lucas, he met
[9:09] Kelsey there and the two chatted, but an argument broke out and he returned
[9:15] to his grandmother's home. He stated, she came down to Pueblo and we
[9:20] were talking and then we ended up. She ended up, you know,
[9:24] getting mad at me. So I went back home that night, and I
[9:28] thought she was going back home, but she ended up staying until the next
[9:33] morning. As the search for Kelsey continued, her family set up a Facebook
[9:39] page in the hopes of spreading her disappearance far and wide. Kelseie's car was
[9:46] finally discovered abandoned on the fourteenth of February in an open employee parking lot at
[9:52] Saint Mary's Corwin Hospital in Pueblo. The find was a very ominous turn of
[9:58] events in the case. It indicated that Kelsey had in fact arrived in Pueblau
[10:03] but never left, at least not in her own car. It also gave
[10:09] way to the possibility that Kelsey was more than just missing. As soon as
[10:13] the discovery was reported in the media, one of Kelsey's friends came forward with
[10:20] a tidbit of information that was not yet known to many people in Kelsey's life
[10:24] answered the public as well. When Kelsey vanished she was pregnant. An email
[10:33] had come into various news publications with this revelation. It was an own fact
[10:39] that Kelsey was going to visit Dante Lucas when she vanished, and as the
[10:43] case with any missing person case, Lucas fell under a cloud of suspicion.
[10:50] Many people were questioning what kind of relationship the couple had, whether there was
[10:54] any trouble, and whether he was somehow involved with her disappearance. Well,
[11:01] that same friend that disclosed that Kelsey was pregnant in an email to the media
[11:07] also said that Kelsey and Lucas had been having trouble in their relationship. The
[11:13] friend even mentioned accusations of physical abuse at the hands of Lucas. As soon
[11:20] as this friend came forward, more came out of the woodwork. On the
[11:24] Facebook group, somebody else posted she always complained about them fighting. Investigators began
[11:33] looking into the relationship of the couple to see if there were any issues.
[11:39] As a relationship was being analyzed, investigators discovered that Kelsey had an online talent
[11:45] profile which included a strangely vague photograph of herself to accompany it. The website
[11:54] was named Explore Talent. Coincidentally, there were two other women from the Denver
[11:58] area that were missing who had an online talent profile as well, Kara Nichols
[12:05] and Raven Furlong. The rumor mill began running rampant that the cases were somehow
[12:11] connected, that all three women may have met up with the same person,
[12:16] possibly for a modeling gig. As the last Vegas Examiner queried, is it
[12:22] at all possible, even remotely the Kelsey Shelling fell for the same kind of
[12:28] meeting? Could she have been doing some kind of modeling online that led her
[12:33] into the trap of a predator. As rumors were circulating across social media,
[12:39] Explore Talent announced that they were assisting investigators, but said that Kelsey hadn't logged
[12:46] onto the account since two thousand and six. According to Kelsey's friends, the
[12:56] relationship between Kelsey and Loo Becas was toxic from the very beginning. Her friend
[13:03] Ali recalled how Lucas often put Kelsey down, calling her names and telling her
[13:09] that she was fat and ugly and that nobody else would ever want her.
[13:16] Throughout the relationship, Kelsey had gone from a bubbly young woman to more standoffish
[13:22] and reserved. Her friend, Bobby commented of the relationship, she adored him
[13:28] and was obsessed with him, and I don't feel like he felt the same
[13:31] way as her. Towards the end of January twenty thirteen, she was more
[13:37] defeated and exhausted by their relationship. Investigators were still searching for information and trying
[13:46] to figure out exactly where Kelsey had vanished from. They were able to establish
[13:50] that the battery on her cell phone had died on the seventh of February,
[13:56] and that when it died, it was in Pueblu Veastigators continued searching for Kelsey
[14:01] in this area, and they sought out surveillance footage from Pueblu. A surveillance
[14:07] camera outside Pueblu Walmart captured Kelsey parking her car at around eleven thirty pm on
[14:15] the fourth of February. She was then observed leaving some time later. Then
[14:22] the following day, Kelsey's car appeared at the Walmart parking lot again. This
[14:26] time, a meal was observed climbing out of the vehicle, walking through the
[14:31] parking lot, where somebody pulled up in another vehicle. This man is then
[14:37] seen climbing into this vehicle. Kelsey's car sat in the parking lot for the
[14:43] next eighteen hours. Then, on the sixth of February, around seven thirty
[14:48] am, a mom was spotted on the surveillance entering the car and then driving
[14:54] it away. On the sixteenth of February, Lucas was arrested on charges of
[15:00] identity theft. Investigators had learned that on the sixth of February, Lucas had
[15:05] used Kelsey's bank card to lift out four hundred dollars. With Lucas behind bars
[15:11] but cooperating with investigators, the search for Kelsey continued, but there was absolutely
[15:18] no trace of her. In March, her family made an emotional play for
[15:24] information. Her brother Colby stated, Kelsey was always quick to lend a helping
[15:31] hand, and we're asking everyone to continue lending a hand to help her too.
[15:37] At the brass conference, the family stood alongside Pueblo Police Detective Neil Robinson,
[15:43] who stayed it we're working this as a missing person case. That's why
[15:50] the family is here, and it's pleading with the public to help find Kelsey.
[15:54] The weeks continued to trickle past with no new developments in the case.
[15:58] Then At the end of April, the charges against Lucas were dismissed after it
[16:03] was discovered that Kelsey had allowed him to use her bank card previously. That's
[16:08] same month, sniffer dogs were brought in to search the wooded areas throughout Weblue.
[16:14] Around the same time, Kelsey's family confirmed that Kelsey was in fact pregnant
[16:18] when she vanished, she had just reached the eight week mark. In confirming
[16:25] the poignant detail, Laura Saxton, her mother, stated, we all love
[16:30] and miss Kelsey so much and are more deeply saddened to know that whatever happened
[16:34] to her that night also involved her onborn child, my first grandchild as well.
[16:44] Kelsey's father, Doug, announced during a press conference that there was a
[16:47] ten thousand dollar reward for any information that led to an arrest and conviction of
[16:52] the person responsible. Kelsey had learned she was pregnant after Lucas came to stay
[16:59] with her for the Christmas period. She had taken a home pregnancy test just
[17:04] the day before Kelsey drove to Pueblau. She had seen photographs of her ultrasound
[17:10] confirming that she was eight weeks pregnant to Lucas as well as to other family
[17:15] members and Lucas's mother. That same evening, she had texted Lucas, I
[17:22] know now how you truly do feel. You have no obligation to me and
[17:26] you don't want to have anything to do with me. Kelsey's family said that
[17:32] Kelsey was extremely excited about the pregnancy, but Lucas wasn't. Her mother Laura
[17:38] commented, he was upset. He said they were so young. She made
[17:44] excuses for him. She wasn't sure he would be involved in their lives.
[17:49] Furthermore, Laura said that Lucas gave Kelsey mixed signals. One day he would
[17:56] say that he didn't want to be a father, the next he said he
[18:00] would take the baby away from Kelsey when it was born. Laura stated she
[18:06] was bound and determined to have the baby. She was really excited to be
[18:11] a mom. By early February, however, Lucas reportedly had a change of
[18:15] heart. He seemed to be coming around to the idea of being a father.
[18:22] He'd grown up without a father and said that it was important that his
[18:25] child would have a father. Kelseye's family, much like the majority of the
[18:30] community and people all across social media, believed that Lucas was somehow involved in
[18:37] Kelsey's disappearance. He denied any involvement and told investigators that after he went back
[18:44] inside his grandmother's home, he thought that Kelsey had driven home. However,
[18:49] he said he learned the next morning that she had slept in her car.
[18:56] He said that at around seven am, Gelsey had asked him to take her
[19:00] to the hospital because she wasn't feeling well. He said that they drove to
[19:04] Parkview Hospital and she went inside for a round two hours hours for an hour
[19:17] and are you saying the hospital? He said that when Kelsey came out,
[19:30] she told him that she wasn't pregnant anymore. It was a peculiar thing for
[19:33] him to say, because Kelsey had visited the doctor just the day before she
[19:37] traveled to Pueblau and was informed that her baby was healthy. He said that
[19:45] at around nine am, they drove from the hospital to the walmart and parted
[19:48] ways. He stated she went to get some snacks something to eat because she
[19:56] was hungry, and then came back and we ended up talking. She ended
[20:02] up telling me get out of the car at Walmart because she didn't want to
[20:06] take me home, so I just left the Walmart and started walking home.
[20:11] The detective asked whether Kelsey could have harmed herself because of the potential miscarriage,
[20:17] and Lucas replied that Kelsey was a troubled and erratic young woman who had bad
[20:21] anxiety. I'm telling me about that, but she's totally imported, she said
[20:30] at the hospital Time for life. Um just one time time about the hospital
[20:40] of wool Time. In regard to the four hundred dollars that Lucas had taken
[20:45] from Kelsey's bank account, surveillance footage had captured him alone in the car taking
[20:49] the money, even though he first of all claimed that Kelsey lifted the money.
[20:56] Why it's not the car. There were a number of inconsistencies with Lucas's
[21:11] claims. For one, there was no record of Kelsey ever being a park
[21:17] Few medical center. Furthermore, surveillance footage from the Walmart on the fifth and
[21:22] sixth of February didn't capture Kelsey at all. It only captured a man driving
[21:29] her vehicle alone. The search for Kelsey continued in May. However, this
[21:36] search was organized by her family. They began at the Old Pueblo Greyhound Park,
[21:41] Awf Lake Avenue and from here, they found out further afield conducting an
[21:47] inch by inch search. The focus of the search was on the south side
[21:52] because that was where Kelsey was last seen at the Walmart parking lot. Investigators
[21:59] had already searched this area, but Kelsey's family just wanted to make sure that
[22:03] nothing was missed. As Sergeant Eric Gonzalez commented in the media, it can't
[22:10] hurt who knows they might come across, maybe a personal item of hers,
[22:15] anything can help. More than one hundred and fifty people showed up to partake
[22:19] in the search, many of whom didn't even know Kelsey but were moved by
[22:25] her disappearance and her family's resilience. They trudged through woodland scarred underneath foliage and
[22:32] bushes, and scanned through ditches and debris in the prairie that ran alongside the
[22:37] eighteen hundred block of West Pueblo Boulevard. Unfortunately, nothing of merit was found.
[22:45] The family also had two large billboards erected. One was a Northern Avenue
[22:52] heading towards the State Fairground, and the other was off Santa Fe Avenue,
[22:56] heading towards Pueblo County. The billboards had Kelsey's face emblazoned on the front,
[23:03] along with the phone number to call if anybody had any information about her whereabouts.
[23:11] The family were upset with how investigators were handling the case, and her
[23:15] father, Doug commented in the media the lack of communication between investigators and the
[23:22] Shelling family is certainly another negative element in this case that is already negative as
[23:29] it is. Kelsie was reportedly pregnant when she vanished while presumably visiting her boyfriend.
[23:36] Dante Lucas has since been jailed, but on charges related to using her
[23:41] credit card without permission. However, the fact that he used her card after
[23:45] her disappearance indicates that he knows more about what happened to her than he's admitting.
[23:52] Another search was organized for the thirty first of August, but once again
[23:56] the search was unfruitful, and Kelsey's family returned home still know the wiser to
[24:02] what had happened to her. The months continued to pass achingly slow for Kelsey's
[24:07] loved ones. Lucas certainly was considered a person of interest in her disappearance,
[24:14] but seemingly investigators didn't have enough evidence for an arrest. On the two year
[24:21] anniversary of her disappearance, her family organized a march to raise awareness and encourage
[24:26] investigators to continue working on the case. Kelsey's family still strongly believed that Lucas
[24:33] had done something to Kelsey, with her mother Laura commenting, we are not
[24:40] satisfied with Lucas's original account of the events leading up to Kelsey's disappearance. We
[24:47] are informed that he has since refused to speak with the Pueblu Police Department.
[24:52] Over the past two years, Kelsey's family had staged numerous events and organized searches
[24:56] in Pueblu. They desperately wanted to keep the case at the forefront of everyone's
[25:02] minds and to keep it on the police radar. As the march went ahead,
[25:07] investigators in Pueblo made a fresh appeal for information the asset of anybody knew
[25:15] anything at all about Kelsey's disappearance to get in contact right away. In support
[25:21] of Kelsey's family, the police department put purple ribbons on each of their vehicles
[25:26] and asked the community to join in by doing the same thing. They also
[25:30] went to the Walmart and handed out purple ribbons to each shopper. Just days
[25:36] after the two year anniversary, Kelsey's family filed a lawsuit against Pueblo Police.
[25:42] They accused them of obstructing the investigation into your disappearance and lying to them about
[25:48] evidence. They also filed a lawsuit against Dante Lucas, claiming that he had
[25:55] caused the death of Kelsey. They also accused his family of somehow being involved.
[26:03] The lawsuit read in part, evidence has been overlooked, disposed of,
[26:07] and leads have not been followed up on, and detectives have intentionally lied and
[26:12] falsified information about evidence recovered and withheld it. According to the lawsuit, the
[26:21] person captured on surveillance removing Kelsey's car from the Walmart on the sixth of February
[26:26] was Lucas. It also accused his mother of being the person who picked him
[26:32] up from the walmart the day before. Has mentioned Kelsey's car was found abandoned
[26:37] in the parking lot of Saint Mary's Corwin Hospital. According to the lawsuit,
[26:44] Pueblo Police refused to send the surveillance to the FBI for enhancement. It also
[26:51] accused Detective Neil Robinson of not responding to the family since March of two thousand
[26:56] and fourteen, despite their repeated inquiries. The lawsuit also revealed that Kelsey had
[27:03] arrived at the Pueblo Walmart at eleven twenty pm. At three fifty four am,
[27:08] Lucas called Kelsey's cell phone, even though cellular pins indicated that the phones
[27:15] were in very close proximity. Kelsey's family had learned these details by hiring a
[27:21] private detective. They suggested that this was after Kelsey was killed by Lucas,
[27:27] and he was attempting to distance himself from the murder by phoning Kelsey so that
[27:33] he could then tell investigators that he was calling her to try and find out
[27:38] where she was. Moreover, when Kelsey's car was examined, Detective Robinson told
[27:45] the family that it was wiped cling. However, he later admitted that he
[27:49] had lied to the family and the dried bodily fluids and two large palm prints
[27:55] on the front seat headrest had been found. Detective later said that the evidence
[28:00] didn't return anything, but the family maintained he had lied once before, who
[28:07] was to say that he wasn't going to lie again. The private detectives working
[28:11] for Kelsey's family had searched the car as well, and had found three fingerprints
[28:15] from the driver's side mirror that detectives in Pueblau had failed to find. Furthermore,
[28:23] they identified undercarriage damage on the passenger's side and found what appeared to be
[28:30] human hair in the damaged area. The private detectives requested the surveillance footage of
[28:37] Kelsey's car being parked by the unknown person and they sent it. However,
[28:41] it was missing crucial sections that could identify the driver. Even more disturbing,
[28:48] on the thirty first of May two thousand and fourteen, a fisherman on Lake
[28:52] Minnikoa in Pueblau snacked his line on an object that he maintained was a human
[29:00] head and torso. Detective Robinson said that he would send a dive team out,
[29:07] but he never did. The media were desperate to get a response to
[29:11] the lawsuit, but the Chief of Police, Lewis Valez, said that they
[29:15] were advised against commenting on the lawsuit. Then commented, we are, however,
[29:22] looking into what we feel is prudent to say about this investigation that will
[29:27] not have anything to do with the lawsuit. Once we determine the extent of
[29:32] these comments, we may put them out through social media. Around the same
[29:36] time, Deputy police Chief Andrew McLaughlin stated to the media that there were no
[29:41] persons of interest in the case, but then in September of that same year,
[29:47] court documents completely contradicted what he had said. In the court documents,
[29:53] Dante Lucas was identified as a person of interest in Kelsey's disappearance. Chef McLaughlin
[30:00] responded and said he was unaware that his lawyer had listed Lucas as a person
[30:06] of interest in the motion and contended that Lucas wasn't a person of interest and
[30:12] that he didn't understand why he was named as such in the court documents.
[30:18] It was abundantly clear that the Pueblo investigation into Kelsey's disappearance was rife with problems
[30:25] and contradictions. Towards the end of the year, Lucas and his family denied
[30:30] that they were responsible for Kelsey's death. In court filings, the lawsuit had
[30:37] named Lucas, his mother Sarah, his sister Dawn Shay, and his grandmother
[30:42] Vivian and accused them of conspiring with Lucas or acting as an accomplice. On
[30:51] the fourth of February two sixteen, it had been three years since Kelsey vanished.
[30:56] That same week, the General Assembly named the fourth of February Missing Persons
[31:02] Day to remind Colorado that Kelsey and three hundred more people just like her still
[31:07] remained missing. The day was commemorated with Senator Jerry Sonenberg reading a laud the
[31:14] names of each person who was missing. He stated, for these families and
[31:19] friends, the pain that goes with this is an everyday occurrence. It's important
[31:26] that we do remember. It's important that we continue to find ways to help
[31:30] those who are missing, and to not forget that we need to do something
[31:34] to help the missing. Many who attended the Senate's morning session held up pictures
[31:41] of their loved ones. He further said that he was pushing for a bill
[31:45] designed to give law enforcement one more tool in their efforts to find the missing
[31:49] who are presumed dead. Senate Bill sixteen oh three four would make it a
[31:55] felony to tamper with a dead body. At the time, Steale law not
[32:00] distinguish a tampering charge that applies to physical evidence, such as fingerprints on an
[32:06] item, or tampering with or destroying a body in order to obstruct an investigation.
[32:13] In April, that new bill was signed into law. Beforehand, it
[32:17] was only a class six felony to tamper with a dead body, which was
[32:22] more like a misdemeanor. The bill had been spearheaded by none other than Kelsey's
[32:27] mother, Laura, who said, I've had so many defeats and disappointments over
[32:32] the last three years that this victory is hard fought, especially as it was.
[32:39] The following month, it was announced that the Pueblo Police were going to
[32:43] be assisted by the Colorado Bureau of Investigations going forward. Pueblo Police had reached
[32:50] out to the CBI asking if they could review the investigation into Kelsey's disappearance thus
[32:55] far. She philestated, would review the case, have a whole new set
[33:01] of eyes to look at the case and give us any ideas that they might
[33:06] have regarding things that either we did not do or that they fail should be
[33:09] followed up. In February of the following year, it was the four year
[33:15] anniversary of Kelsey's disappearance. The Pueblo Police Department put on a united front with
[33:21] Kelsey's family for a vigil in her honor and remembrance. The vigil took place
[33:27] at the walmart where Kelsey was last seen. The reward fund was boosted up
[33:32] to one hundred thousand dollars around the same time, and Kelsey's family announced it
[33:37] on the Help Find Kelsey Facebook page. Unfortunately, the reward fund did not
[33:43] learn anybody in and in April, a search warrant was executed on the former
[33:49] Lucas family home on Manor Ridge Drive in the city south Side. Investigators embarked
[33:55] on the home and excavated parts of the backyard. Their search then found out
[34:00] further afield, and they began scouring an undeveloped plot of land not too far
[34:07] from the family's home. Unfortunately, the search turned up no clues. Just
[34:14] a month after the search, a small fire broke out at the former Lucas
[34:17] home. Investigator speculated that the fire was arson. The new residents were home
[34:24] at the time and spranging to action, attempting to extinguish the blaze before it
[34:30] spread. The search for Kelsey only continued. In November of two thousand and
[34:49] seventeen, Lucas was arrested in Denver in connection to a robbery. In September,
[34:55] he and his brother had robbed a man while he was sitting in a
[34:59] vehicle in West Mesa Avenue. Following the Arras Lucas was once again asked a
[35:05] boy Kelsie's disappearance. This time, its version of events had changed drastically.
[35:14] He now claimed that after Kelsey drove to the street to meet him, they
[35:17] partied. He said that he used cocaine and drank alcohol while Kelsey took percosett.
[35:24] In his words, they got twisted before heaving to his grandmother's home,
[35:29] where Kelsey went into a room to sleep while he went into another room to
[35:34] relax. He said that he eventually fell asleep and was awakened by his mother,
[35:39] who was unhappy that he had Kelsey in the home. He said that
[35:45] his mother had told him it was disrespectful to have women in his grandmother's home.
[35:50] Lucas now claimed that the last time he saw Kelsey was at his grandmother's
[35:54] home. He said that he went to sleep and never saw her again.
[36:00] According to Lucas, after he woke up, he went to the bank and
[36:05] lifted out four hundred dollars, but maintained that he had Kelsey's permission and that
[36:09] she always shared money with him. He said that he had lied about going
[36:15] to Parkview Hospital and said that after withdrawing the money, he drove Kelsey's car
[36:20] to the Walmart, where he dropped it off. He also suggested that Kelsey
[36:24] had walked to somebody's home from his grandmother's home to purchase drugs. Lucas denied
[36:30] that he returned to Walmart to pick up Kelsey's car, but when he was
[36:35] interviewed the next day, he admitted that he got Kelsey's car from the Walmart
[36:39] and drove it to the hospital where it was eventually found. He said that
[36:45] he dropped it there because there was a drug dealer in the area that he
[36:49] and Kelsey knew, and that he could walk to his mother's house on Toronto
[36:53] Street from there. Just a couple of weeks later, there was a massive
[36:59] breakthrough in the case when Lucas was served an arrest warned in connection with Kelsey's
[37:05] disappearance, which investigators were now referring to as a homicide. That same day,
[37:13] his mother, Sarah Lucas, was arrested for robbery. It was for
[37:16] the same robbery committed by Lucas and his brother. Lucas was then charged with
[37:22] first degree murder. The arrest had come almost five years after Kelsey had vanished,
[37:30] and it was a bittersweet moment for her family, it meant that Kelsey
[37:35] was never coming home, at least not alive anyway, and while her family
[37:39] had long believed that she was dead, a charge of murder just completely shattered
[37:45] Annie small hope that they had held on to Her mother, Laura stated,
[37:51] getting Kelsey home is still where my drive is. I don't mean to sound
[37:54] ungrateful, because I know that there's so much work that's gone into this.
[38:00] The arrest is huge. It's absolutely huge, and it's something we wanted to
[38:05] happen a long time ago. But as far as bringing peace and healing,
[38:09] it doesn't do a whole lot for me. Without Kelsey. It's a little
[38:14] bit of an empty victory, although it's a very important one. In the
[38:19] wake of the charge, the search for Kelsey only continued, and on the
[38:22] five year anniversary to her disappearance, a vigil was held. Laura struggled to
[38:28] hold in her emotion as she said to the crowd. I don't get to
[38:31] help her plan a wedding. I don't get to go through the process of
[38:36] pregnancy and childbirth with her. I don't get to see her be a really
[38:40] great mummy. In May of twenty and eighteen, it was determined by a
[38:45] judge that there was enough evidence against Lucas for him to stand trial for the
[38:50] first degree murder of Kelsey. He subsequently pleaded not guilty as a number of
[38:55] pretrial motions were being ironed out. Lucas's Sarah, was sentenced to three years
[39:01] in prison for her role in the robbery. After she pleaded guilty. The
[39:07] murder trial was ready to begin in February of two thousand and twenty one.
[39:13] On the third of February, Kelsey's family drove down Interstate twenty five from Denver
[39:19] to Pueblau, the same route that Kelsey would have taken the night she vanished.
[39:24] They entered the courtroom and sat down in the spectator gallery, ready to
[39:30] see the man charged with their daughter's murder. There seems to be an old
[39:36] saying no body, no crime, but that's just not true. The absence
[39:42] of a body is evidence in a homicide. Certainly makes the prosecutor's job much
[39:46] more difficult, but it's far from impossible. During opening statements, prosecutor Michelle
[39:53] Chausner laid out Lucas's actions in the days before and after Kelsey dis appeared.
[40:00] She revealed that there were numerous text messages that outlined the couple's tumultuous relationship.
[40:07] She said that over the course of several days, Lucas had tried to convince
[40:10] Kelsey to drive down to Pueblu. She stated the only man she was with
[40:17] that night is seated in the courtroom at the defense table. That man lured
[40:22] her to Pueblau over the course of two days. As mentioned earlier, Lucas
[40:28] told Kelsey that he had a surprise for her. He wrote, just wait
[40:32] to see for yourself. You probably wouldn't believe me if I told you.
[40:37] After Kelsey arrived in Pueblau, at around two forty am, a call was
[40:42] made to a romantic interest of Lucas that Kelsey knew nothing about. Curiously,
[40:50] the call to the other woman was made from Kelsey's cell phone, not Lucas's.
[40:55] As Prosecutor Chaucener stated, Kelsey has never seen, heard, or talked
[41:01] to this woman. During the defense's opening statements, defense attorney Carl Tommler painted
[41:08] a picture of a broken hearted family that were desperately seeking for answers and putting
[41:14] pressure on law enforcement to make an arrest. He said that after the lawsuits
[41:20] were filed, investigators were desperate to make an arrest. He stated, there's
[41:25] a lot of pressure, a burning desire from people whose hearts have been broken
[41:30] to solve this case. During the trial, the jury would hear from a
[41:35] former inmate that was incarcerated with Lucas, Ryan Rivera, who claimed that Lucas
[41:40] had admitted to killing Kelsey. He said that Lucas told him he didn't believe
[41:45] he would be convicted because investigators would never find Kelsey's body. He also claimed
[41:52] that Lucas had told him that his mother, Sarah, had helped him dispose
[41:57] of Kelsey's body. Following his testimony, the jury then heard from Kelsey's friend
[42:01] Lucash Akinsey. She said that in December of two thousand and twelve, she
[42:07] had noticed that Kelsey was covered in bruises. She further said that Kelsey had
[42:12] once told her that she had been physically assaulted by Lucas and a member of
[42:16] his family. Other friends testified to watch the same brook. Taylor said that
[42:23] when she was out one day with Kelsey, Lucas kept harassing her over text
[42:29] messages. He called her fat and a slot, and in another text message,
[42:35] he threatened, bitch, I'll fuck you up cell phone evidence was presented
[42:39] during the trial which showed that after Kelsey's disappearance, her cell phone and Lucas's
[42:45] cell phone were hanging in the same location, which indicated that Lucas was in
[42:51] the possession of Kelsey's cell phone. Text messages were also presented revealing the tumultuous
[42:58] nature of their enship. On the third of February, Kelsey accused Lucas of
[43:04] ignoring her. She wrote, I'm really hurt the way you talk to me
[43:08] about the other people. At least I know now you have no obligation to
[43:14] me. I thought you agreed to love me, but I guess I was
[43:16] just a fool. I've never been so heartbroken. The pregnancy was a point
[43:22] of contention between Kelsey and Lucas. Kelsey had wanted to have the bab while
[43:29] Lucas didn't. Further tax messages revealed that on the night that Kelsey had vanished,
[43:36] Lucas had texted his mother, Sarah, saying that Kelsey had miscarried.
[43:40] Further tax messages were presented from after Kelsey had disappeared. In one, Lucas
[43:46] taxed her mother Laura and said that he had spoken to Kelsey on the phone
[43:52] and that she was okay, but her cell phone was broken, which was
[43:55] why she couldn't get in contact with her family. He suggested that Kelsey was
[44:00] driving to California. On the second week of the trial, prosecutors played allowed
[44:07] Lucas's interrogations with investigators bizarrely. When he was first interviewed, he denied that
[44:14] he and Kelsey were even in a relationship. He said we hung out one
[44:20] time. The next time she confessed her love to me. He said that
[44:25] they were sextually active and that she could be pregnant, but said that he
[44:30] didn't have any proof of the pregnancy. It was ironic considering the fact that
[44:36] investigators would obtain all of their tax message conversations, conversations which focused on the
[44:43] pregnancy, and even the pregnancy scan which was sent to Lucas. The evidence
[44:49] against Dante Lucas was purely circumstantial. There was no smoking gun, so to
[44:54] speak, no body, no blood evidence, no DNA. After three weeks
[45:01] of testimony, the prosecution rested their kiss. The defense also rested without calling
[45:07] any witnesses. During closing arguments, the prosecution argued that all of the evidence
[45:14] presented showed that Lucas had killed Kelsey, despite the fact her body was never
[45:20] found. As for the defense, they said that the kiss was the biggest
[45:24] stretch in Colorado history and reminded the jury that there was no DNA evidence.
[45:32] After just a few hours of deliberation, the jury returned with a verdict.
[45:38] They found Dante Lucas guilty of the murder of Kelsey Shelling. He was immediately
[45:44] handed a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole. Following the
[45:50] verdict, Laura commented to KKTV, I don't know what my life looks like
[45:55] going forward. It's going to take me a long time to figure things.
[45:59] Oh, please keep searching. If you're at hiking, she could be found
[46:04] and brought home and half the prog or burial. She then appeared outside the
[46:09] court room alongside the prosecution and spoke to the goggle of media that had assembled.
[46:16] That's this his pattern. He finds girls to take advantage of and unfortunately
[46:22] for Kelsey, had just went way farther than that. So, you know,
[46:27] I think the community should feel good, just feel safe that he's not
[46:31] going to be back out on the streets again. There were times I thought
[46:34] we would never get to trial. That's how dire things seemed, but I
[46:39] just didn't want to give up. I couldn't. I couldn't give up on
[46:43] Kelsey. I I just couldn't. Kelsey Shelling had lots of things in life
[46:50] to look forward to, her own apartment and a job that she loved,
[46:54] and she had just found out that she was expecting a little be a b
[46:58] boy. Kelcie was ready to take on the world as a single mother if
[47:04] her boyfriend Dante Lucas didn't want to be in their lives. She had the
[47:08] full support of her friends and family, but on that cold winter night,
[47:14] Kelsey set off into the darkness, driving the two hours to Pueblo and to
[47:20] her untimely death. Well, besties, that is it for this episode of
[47:46] Morbidology. As always, thank you so so much for listening, and I'd
[47:51] like to say the biggest thank you to my nurse to Patreon's supporter Hannah.
[47:55] If you'd like to support the show, please do check Morbidology out on pat
[48:00] Treon. I upload loads of bonus content and send out some merch and a
[48:05] handwritten thank you card. Because you all know Crime con in London is coming
[48:08] up on the eleventh and twelfth of June I'm going to be there hanging out
[48:14] on podcast row all weekend, and I'd really love to see some of you
[48:17] there. If you're interested, just head on over to crime Con dot code
[48:22] dot uk and enter the promo code Morbid for ten percent off your ticket.
[48:28] Remember to check us out at morbidology dot com for more information about this episode
[48:31] and to read or three crime articles. Until next time, take care of
[48:36] yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
