# 202: Stefanie Rengel

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 1 May 2023, 1 h 01 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53376542/morbidology_202_ad_free.mp3

Temperatures were dipping below freezing with the wind chill in Toronto, Canada, on the 1st of January, 2008. People all across the globe had just rung in the new year, but at around 6PM that evening, the first murder of the year in Toronto would be unfolding, a murder that would send shockwaves across the nation and truly highlight the dangers of teenage obsession and rivalry. SPONSORS - Zocdoc: Thank you to Zocdoc for sponsoring this episode! Zocdoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient reviewed, take your insurance & are available when you need them. To find a & book a top rated doctor today, visit: https://zocdoc.com/morbidology SHOW NOTES - https://www.morbidology-the-podcast-202-stefanie-rengel PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] Okay, this is what I need to know. How did you know in
[0:37] general? How did you know in general that he was going to kill her?
[0:56] Temperatures were dipping well below freezing with the wind chill in Toronto, Canada
[1:00] on the first of July two thousand and eight. People all across the globe
[1:06] had just rung in the new year, but around six pm that evening,
[1:10] the first murder of the year in Toronto would be unfolding, a murder that
[1:15] would send shock waves across the nation and truly highlight the dangers of teenage obsession
[1:21] and rivalry. Stephanie Wrangel was born in nineteen ninety four to parents Patricia and
[1:38] Adolpho Wrangel Gonzalez judor father's Venezuelan heritage. Stephanie grew up speaking both English and
[1:47] Spanish. The relationship wasn't a last between Stephanie's parents, but Patricia and Adolpho
[1:53] found love again, with Patricia marrying a man named James Hung and Adolpho marrying
[1:59] a woman named Maureen. Both Patricia and James worked as Toronto police officers,
[2:05] and Stephanie lived at home with them in the park Hillview area. In two
[2:09] eight, fourteen year old Stephanie was a Grade nine student at Rosedale Heights High
[2:15] School of the Arts. Her friends at the school said that she was always
[2:19] there for them during their time of need, always there with the shoulder to
[2:23] cry on if needed. Patricia said that her daughter always saw the good in
[2:29] everything and everyone. She was extremely caring, particularly towards children and the elderly.
[2:38] She absolutely doted on her little brother, Ian, who was two years
[2:42] her junior. The closest in age made the siblings extremely close. Ian recollected,
[2:50] we got in a lot of fights, but in the end we always
[2:53] resolved to get along and be friends again. I could tell her things I
[2:58] didn't want to tell my parents, and she told me things she couldn't tell
[3:00] my mom. The siblings had a weekly ritual of watching Prison Break together,
[3:07] and Stephanie had even taught her younger brother how to swim. He fondly recalled
[3:12] her. On one occasion he forgot to get her a birthday present. He
[3:16] presented her with a snail from the garden, which caused her to burst into
[3:21] laughter and threw her arms around him. Then, when Stephanie's father, Adolfo
[3:28] and Maureen had two more children, she was ecstatic she adored babysitting her siblings
[3:34] and other children in the neighborhood. Stephanie was self assured and she had a
[3:39] deep faith. On Sunday, she helped out at Sunday School. She also
[3:45] volunteered at the local church and had just recently joined a Bible study group and
[3:51] was attending service at the Meeting House, which is a Toronto based church that
[3:55] was geared towards youth. But she said of her daughter, I couldn't have
[4:01] asked for a better daughter. She was responsible beyond her years, and yet
[4:06] I worried about her every day because she was so trusting. Stephanie was also
[4:13] a very strong willed girl, and she had an uncanny musical ability. Her
[4:17] grandmother, Mary Fraser, said she was one of the godsiest kids I've ever
[4:23] known, but at the same time, she had a soft spot at the
[4:27] center of her heart. When Stephanie wasn't busy with the church, she enjoyed
[4:31] filling her time by writing songs and poetry. On New Year's Day of two
[4:38] thousand and eight, Stephanie was at home babysitting her little brother Ian when she
[4:43] received a phone call from somebody asking to meet her outside a lad. He
[4:48] recalled, she wasn't exactly sure who it was, and she kept on repeating
[4:54] the name three times in a kind of unsure voice. The name of Stephanie
[5:00] was repeating with Steve, and Ian knew Steve as Stephanie's former boyfriend. They'd
[5:08] broken up in the fall, and Stephanie told people that he had cheated on
[5:12] her. Stephanie pulled on her boots and coat and told Ian that she would
[5:16] be back in two seconds. Shortly after six pm that evening, Gavin Shoebottom
[5:43] was driving along Northdale Boulevard near Saint Clair Avenue East and O'Connor Drive when he
[5:49] saw a girl stumbling down the sidewalk. He recalled, she looked like something
[5:57] was wrong. He could see that she had her cell phone in her hand
[6:01] and appeared to be trying to call or text somebody. It was Stephanie.
[6:08] Gavin pulled up alongside Stephanie and asked whether she was okay. She replied no,
[6:15] I need help. Gavin asked what had happened, and Stephanie responded,
[6:23] I've been stabbed. Gavin jumped out of his car and called nine one one.
[6:30] As he called nine one one, Stephanie tumbled into the snow bank alongside
[6:33] the road. Blood was seeping through her clothing. When the nine one one
[6:41] operator picked up, Gavin said that somebody had been stabbed. He was transferred
[6:46] to the ambulance service and he could be heard telling Stephanie in the background to
[6:51] hold her stomach. Gavin was unsure of the exact location where they were.
[6:58] He said to the operator, someone's been stabbed on north Ridge Crescent, next
[7:04] to Bermoncy. I think it's north Ridge. It was actually Northdale Boulevard.
[7:14] Gavin was told to keep pressure on the wound, and he ran back to
[7:16] his car and got a blanket, which he wrapped her on. Stephanie and
[7:20] applied pressure to her stomach. Stephanie could be heard in the back of the
[7:27] nine one one call crying in pain and faintly repeating it hurts. Gavin told
[7:34] the nine one one operator, she's completely awake. She's crying. She's in
[7:40] a lot of pain. Gavin attempted to reassure Stephanie that everything was going to
[7:45] be okay. He said to her, You'll be okay, don't worry,
[7:49] honey. The nine one one operator then asked Gavin to ask Stephanie where her
[7:56] attacker went, She pointed up the road and said that he was white.
[8:03] Midway through the conversation, the ambulance sirens could be heard in the distance,
[8:07] but Gavin wasn't exactly sure where they were, and he had given them the
[8:11] wrong straight name. The NME one one operator informed Gavin that the ambulance couldn't
[8:16] find them. As the ambulance struggled to locate Stephanie and Gavin, Stephanie was
[8:22] becoming more and more faint. She managed to provide Gavin with a name that
[8:30] sounded to him like David Beggs before she fell unconscious. Paramedics finally located Stephanie
[8:37] and Gavin. Desmond Fan was the first on the scene with his partner.
[8:43] They crouched down beside Stephanie, but there were no vital signs. She was
[8:48] pronounced dead. In the medical examiner's office, it was discovered that Stephanie had
[8:54] been stabbed a total of six times. One of them was fatal. It
[9:01] had plunged into her left lower chest and went through her liver, diaphragm,
[9:05] lung, and m paris the inner lining on the back of her chest.
[9:09] The other stab wounds were to her left breast, her abdomen, her armpit,
[9:15] her shoulder, and upper arms. There were also defensive wounds. Detectives
[9:20] envelope the crime scene in luminous yellow tape and began their investigation. They combed
[9:26] the entire area, finding out across O'Connor Drive and Saint Clair Avenue in search
[9:33] of any kind of evidence that could lead them to the killer. As the
[9:37] crime scene was being thoroughly analyzed, other detectives began conducting door to door inquiries.
[9:45] They were hoping to find somebody who had saw or heard something suspicious.
[9:52] While searching around the vicinity, detectives came across a blood stained knife in a
[9:56] nearby back yard. It was a serrated knife, and DNA from clumps of
[10:01] fiber came back as a match to Stephanie. It was evidently the murder weapon.
[10:09] Meanwhile, Detective Sergeant Steve Ryan embarked on the family home to give Patricia
[10:15] and James the terrible news that their daughter was the victim of a homicide.
[10:20] After leaving their home, he stated, they're distraught. They've just had a
[10:26] child murdered. As soon as Patricia heard that her daughter had said the name
[10:31] David Beggs, it sounded somewhat familiar to her. A couple of months earlier,
[10:39] Stephanie had told her mother about a strange encounter with the seventeen year old
[10:43] boy that she knew and to David back in two thousand and five. However,
[10:50] this boy was named David Bagshaw, not David Beggs. Stephanie was home
[10:56] alone when this strange encounter occurred. On the twentieth of October, she received
[11:03] the phone call from Bagshaw, who asked her to come outside. Stephanie did,
[11:09] and Bagshaw told her Melissa wants me to stab you. He was referring
[11:16] to his fifteen year old girlfriend, Melissa Tadarovic. Backshaw then threw his phone
[11:22] down on the ground and said, when she calls, tell her I tried,
[11:26] so she'll stop pestering me to kill you. He then turned and left,
[11:31] leaving his cell phone on Stephanie's porch. As soon as Stephanie told Patricia
[11:37] about this peculiar incident, she drove right over to Bagshaw's home to return his
[11:41] cell phone. She also read him and his mother the Riot Act and asked
[11:48] what exactly was going on. Backshaw told Patricia that his girlfriend Toddarova had been
[11:54] honting him to kill Stephanie. He commented, I like Stephanie, I don't
[12:01] want to do it. If I wanted her dead, she'd be dead.
[12:05] Patricia left Bagshaw's home after she and his mother agreed that there would be no
[12:09] further contact between him and Stephanie. Patricia then called up Toddarovic and told her
[12:16] to never send Bagshaw to her home ever again. Toddarovic responded, well,
[12:24] she just has to stop spreading rumors about me. Stephanie told her mother that
[12:28] she hadn't been spreading rumors at all, but instead was trying to warn Bagshaw
[12:35] that Toddarovic may have been cheating on him. Patricia thought that this was the
[12:39] end of it, but now her daughter was dead and the name David had
[12:45] come out of her mouth. Patricia thought that possibly Gavin, who called nine
[12:50] one one, had misheard the surname, and she immediately went to the police
[12:54] station with this information. So detectives working on the MoMA's side now had a
[13:01] person of interest, seventeen year old David Bagshaw. That she had seen Bagshaw
[13:13] lurking aboard outside in the hours that preceded the murder, only further solidifying the
[13:18] detective's belief that he had learned Stephanie outside and then attacked her. Detectives immediately
[13:26] picked up and arrasted Bagshaw at his home. They also wanted to speak to
[13:31] Toadarovic. As Bagshaw was arrested, detectives called Todarovic's home and asked her and
[13:39] her mother to come down for a routine interview. As they sat down in
[13:45] the interview, Toddarovic made a chilling confession. She stated, I wanted her
[13:54] dad and I'm glad she is. Everybody in the room was, including Todarovic's
[14:01] mother, who attempted to shut her up with those comments. Toddarovik had just
[14:07] propelled herself to a suspect in the murder case as well as big Shaw.
[14:13] Detective Ryan immediately stopped the interview, handcuffed Toddarovic, and took her to a
[14:18] holding cell in the police station. Toddarovik had originally come to the police station
[14:24] as nothing more than a potential witness, but now she was going to be
[14:30] questioned as a suspect. The detectives in charge of the investigation regrouped before bringing
[14:37] Todarovic back to be interviewed, and originally you came in with your mother a
[14:45] few hours ago, and we were interviewing you as a what we thought was
[14:50] a witness. Some of the answers that you gave and in your manners too,
[15:00] made us think that we should stop that interview as a witness. And
[15:07] at that time we were actually arrested for what we felt was participating in that
[15:13] homicide. And you were paraded in front of the stop. Sorry, you
[15:18] were put in a room and I got a duty council lawyer for you to
[15:22] speak with. Is this all correct? Okay? Mom left the station shortly
[15:28] after that, and then you requested to have your mother brought back, and
[15:33] so she came back in and has spoken to you. And now here we
[15:37] sit and we want to further investigate this homicide. They were working on the
[15:43] theory that, for some reason, told Rovik had encouraged Bagshaw to kill Stephanie,
[15:50] but they needed to understand why David Bradshaw or Bagshaw Rahala ten months?
[16:04] For some reason, I thought it was long. And Stephanie, the girl
[16:11] who's killed, you've known her for home? Um, yeah, let maybe
[16:19] I ask it this way. You've you've known of her for how long?
[16:26] Nine months? And you've only seen her once and I'm Coxwall, I'm about
[16:33] home five months David. There was some talk David. Why don't you tell
[16:51] me how how David felt about stuff because of the past than to date?
[17:03] Okay? Anything else? And I won't call everyone. I won't call every
[17:12] anything. Okay, I'm me keep calling me? Do you know why step
[17:22] you to speak up? I'm sorry, I'll say I can keep here.
[17:27] Umast question? Why didn't he like her only because she always chose to call
[17:37] my Okay? Anything else? And how did you feel out stuff? I
[17:48] don't want to call you, and that's because why I just don't want his
[18:00] act talking to him? Okay? And so he's your boyfriend? Is he
[18:06] still your boyfriend? To me? I don't think I go to see you.
[18:11] Sorry, what I meant to say it was before he was arrested.
[18:15] Were you too still dating? The conversation then switched to the murder. All
[18:26] right, let's let's move right to what happened last night? Then you tell
[18:32] me what what you know? What happened? I called me and he said
[18:38] he was going to her house and I said okay, And then he called
[18:44] me or I called him and he said I think I called him and then
[18:47] he's like, oh wait, I see her and he hung up the phone.
[18:51] And then I called him and I said, did you kill her?
[18:56] And then he said yeah, And they were talking about him going to Stevens.
[19:00] Ok okay. I called her Stephen's house and he said he was going
[19:04] to say Stevens okay. And then he came over to me and he came
[19:11] over to your house. All right, let's let's go right back that he
[19:15] called you and said, I'm going over to Stephanie's house and you said okay.
[19:22] But why would you say okay? Well, you didn't like him even
[19:27] talking with stuff. So why was it okay that he was going over there?
[19:33] What was he going over there for? All right? Did he tell
[19:41] you anything? Why I know in general who was going to Okay? This
[19:52] is what I need to know. How did you know in general? How
[19:56] did you know in general that he was going to kill her? When did
[20:00] he first tell you that? And I asked you that today? No,
[20:06] when did he first tell you that? Was it nine months ago, six
[20:08] months ago, a week ago, a day ago? When when did he
[20:12] first tell you that? Three months ago? Now? How did that come
[20:18] up? Okay? And why did you want her? Dad? I think
[20:29] her like dead. I was joking, okay, trying to explain about does
[20:37] something debt? Literally? Okay? So I just told Rovic appeared to be
[20:48] cool, calm and collected as she said to the detectives that she told Babshaw
[20:55] she wanted staff and eat debt. They queried us to why. Okay,
[21:00] So, going back three months ago when when you said to him I want
[21:04] her dead? What what did she do to cause you to be displeased with
[21:12] her and make that comment whether you whether you're sort of serious, half serious
[21:17] or joking? What did she do to make you say that? She would
[21:22] call David and say she's pregnant, and then on before the day that happened,
[21:30] and um, why she was couldn't call him for that? Like she
[21:36] had a boyfriend Stephen, right, and only that she was spreading rumors about
[21:41] here at that time, she's spreading rumors about me? And what was she
[21:47] saying? She said, to be honest, I know it's awful that you
[21:52] need to be honest. Please, Also she starts giving to the guys,
[22:03] she started okay, and that that was upsetting, Like, well, I
[22:11] can tell you're upsettable, all right? And when did she start spreading most
[22:22] rumors. I guess I want to go. And did you don't say anything
[22:30] to haven't talked to her two months ago? Okay, she said, she's
[22:36] good, don't talk to stuff again. But when a couple of months ago,
[22:45] when she started saying these things that you were going and doing these things
[22:48] to the boys, did you say anything last week or last week? Okay,
[22:53] sorry last week? Did you say anything to David about that? Yeah?
[22:59] What did you tell her? Daughter? Rov claimed that Stephanie had been
[23:04] spreading rumors about her. She said that she never liked Stephanie because she knew
[23:10] that she and Barkshaw had dated, but this was back when Stephanie was twelve
[23:15] and he was fifteen. She then somehow reached the conclusion that Stephanie was spreading
[23:21] rumors about her, and she said that this was ruining her relationship with Barkshaw.
[23:26] Dadtor Rovac admitted that she had told Barkshaw to kill Stephanie countless times.
[23:33] She said that on the night before the staving, she had a bad dream
[23:36] in which Barkshaw and Stephanie were fooling around. She said, he knows I
[23:42] have dreams like that. She also said that the detectives that she just had
[23:47] a general dislike of Stephanie. Was there any more talk about her being killed?
[24:00] Is the general feeling that I don't like her? Okay? And so
[24:07] then when he said to you, I'm going over last night, I'm going
[24:11] over to Stephanie's house. What's he specific about where he was going? Thank
[24:23] you? And what makes you think that thank you? Do you remember exactly
[24:30] what he told you? Did he say how he was going to do it?
[24:41] He still he phones you and he says, I have a knight of
[24:44] the night each play, and I'm going to Steffanie sus What was your response
[24:48] to that? Thank okay, whatever you want? And what did that mean?
[24:59] What did you take that to me when you said that okay? What
[25:07] did you mean when you said, okay, do whatever you want and if
[25:11] you want to kill or killer? Did you say that those words? I
[25:15] said, do whatever you want? Well, that's not if you want to
[25:18] kill her a killer? You said, what did I mean? So?
[25:23] He fumed June, He says, I have an eight inch blade night not
[25:27] good and set myselfs and your response is do whatever you want? What did
[25:34] he say to that? I don't remember. Did you think of calling nine
[25:41] one? One reporting that there was a guy I don't delivered to a young
[25:45] girl's seals with a knife to killer. Okay, I don't know. She
[25:59] revealed it. As Bargshaw had walked to Stephanie's home, he called her,
[26:03] but she claimed that they didn't talk about Stephanie or the murder. She said
[26:07] that they were talking about their upcoming birthdays. After the murder was carried out,
[26:12] Bargshaw at taxed Toddarovic, I love you, honey, I can't wait
[26:17] to see you. He then got a taxi to her home. She told
[26:22] detectives that she had asked him how the murder was carried out, and he
[26:26] mimed stabbing her in the stomach. She stated, I wasn't happy about it.
[26:33] During the interviewed, Todarovic claimed that she had told Bargshaw to kill Stephanie,
[26:38] but she then claimed that she was only joking. She even admitted that
[26:42] after the stabbing was carried out, she had called Bagshaw up and asked if
[26:48] Stephanie was dead. Detective Ryan said Barkshaw was doing what you wanted him to
[26:53] do. That's why you didn't call anybody. She responded a little bit,
[27:00] there was no point in calling because if somebody stabbed, they're pretty much dead.
[27:06] Daughterovic's behavior during the interview was disturbing. She was upset when she spoke
[27:11] about the alleged rumors, but when she described Stephanie being killed, she was
[27:15] emotionless. Detective Ryan later said that Tottarovic's demeanor was so cold that it made
[27:22] the hair on the back of its next stand up in a way that it
[27:25] had never done so during his twenty one year career. It was apparent to
[27:30] detectives that this case was going to be an extremely complex one, one rife
[27:36] with teenage emotions, including obsession and jealousy. Tatarovic and Bagshaw were students at
[27:55] the same high school and had begun dating in March of two thousand and seven.
[28:02] Their relationship quickly became sexual, and after just a few days they were
[28:06] professing their love to one another. The relationship was marred by jealousy on both
[28:12] sides. In the space of just four months, Bagshaw had texted or called
[28:18] Toddarovic more than three thousand, three hundred times. Toddarovic monitored his emails to
[28:25] determine if he was speaking to other girls and demanded his Facebook in MSM passwords
[28:32] Toddarovic was very jealous of Bagshaw's earlier relationships, in particular Stephanie. Even though
[28:38] they dated briefly back in two thousand and five when she was just twelve years
[28:44] old, the relationship was nothing serious whatsoever. The couple went on group outings
[28:51] to the park, they had pizza at a restaurant near their school. They
[28:55] never once even had a single one on one date, but Stephanie was twelve
[29:00] years old. Then one afternoon, Bagshaw had left a vulgar massage on Stephanie's
[29:06] family's home phone, a message that referred to oral sex, and her mother,
[29:11] Patricia immediately put a stop to the relationship. It may have two thousand
[29:18] and seven, Toddarovic expressed jealousy over Stephanie during an MSN conversation between herself and
[29:26] Bagshaw. Her thoughts then turned to violence, as she wrote, I'm going
[29:32] to fucking stab her if I want to. During the same conversation, Bagshaw
[29:37] told Toddarovic that Stephanie had recently told him that she was pregnant, and for
[29:44] reasons unknown, Toddarovic erronestly took this to mean that Stephanie was telling Bagshaw that
[29:51] he was the father. I'd like to note that there was no evidence that
[29:55] Stephanie was ever pregnant. The hatred and jealousy that Toddarovic felt only continued to
[30:02] grow, and by the next month she in Bagshaw began discussing a wild plot
[30:08] to kidnap and kill Stephanie. During the conversation, Toddarovic wrote, no sex
[30:15] until then, loll. The conversations were rife with sexual references, and Tatarovic
[30:23] became obsessed with the idea of Bagshaw killing Stephanie. Then, in October of
[30:30] two thousand and seven, Toddarovic became convinced that Stephanie was spreading rumors about her.
[30:36] Shortly before this, Stephanie had broken up with her new boyfriend, Steve,
[30:41] and she confided in Bagshaw that he was cheating on her. Stephanie then
[30:47] told Bagshaw to be careful of Toddarovic in case she was doing the same thing.
[30:53] Stephanie and Todarovic had never met in person, but Todarovic took this as
[30:57] a threat to our relationship. Then, on the twentieth of October, Toddarovic
[31:03] wrote, I want her dead. We've been through this. She then said,
[31:10] bang bang Bagshaw responded, I need a bang first. I want to
[31:15] bang you. Toddarovik replied, I want her dead. Lall, we've been
[31:21] through this. If it takes more than a week, then we're just going
[31:23] to be friends. Later that afternoon, Bagshaw showed up at Stephanie's home and
[31:30] told her that Todarovic wanted him to kill her. It was that incident that
[31:34] I referred to earlier. Todarov continually summoned Bagshaw to kill Stephanie, and over
[31:41] MSN conversations, she told him that she was going to be withholding sex until
[31:47] he carried out the murder. She stoked his jealousy by saying that she would
[31:52] sleep with another boy if her wishes were denied. In fact, Todarovic had
[31:57] already been exchanging flirty messages with another teenage boy, and she let Bagshaw no.
[32:06] She didn't like the idea of Bagshaw interacting with Stephanie, but she had
[32:10] another boy messaging her about sex. In one conversation, Bagshaw wrote, do
[32:17] you love me? Do you want me? Ddtorovic responded, not if you
[32:22] don't do it, because I hate you and it's the only thing that would
[32:27] make me want you again. Then on the seventeenth of December, Toddarovic wrote
[32:31] to Bagshaw on MSN that she was going to block him until he killed Stephanie.
[32:38] Less than two weeks later, Stephanie was bleeding to death in the snow
[32:43] near her home. After this conversation, Toddarovic didn't block Bagshaw, and the
[32:49] pastoring to kill Stephanie only continued. She even told another friend on MSN that
[32:54] she was quote unquote getting somebody killed. On New Year's Day, Toddarovic demanded
[33:01] the Bagshaw kill Stephanie. He replied, can't you just forget about it?
[33:07] She responded no. Later in the evening, Bagshaw told Toddarovic that he was
[33:14] on his way to Stephanie's home and he was armed with a knife. At
[33:19] six ten pm, Bagshaw called up Todarovic and said, I see her.
[33:23] He then hung up the phone. After Stephanie had been fatally stabbed, Toddarovic
[33:30] and Bagshaw called one another thirteen more times. Toddarovic placed one phone called to
[33:37] Stephanie, but obviously she didn't answer. It appeared as though she was wanting
[33:42] to make sure that Bagshaw had made good on his claims. News of Stephanie's
[33:49] murder had spread and many teenagers knew that Todarovic had wanted her dead. That
[33:54] night, a friended message Todarovic before her arrest, saying that she might be
[34:00] in big trouble if police ever find out that she wanted Stephanie dead. In
[34:06] a staggering display of a lack of empathy, the friend then said, oh
[34:10] my god, what if you get arrested before your birthday? Todorovic responded,
[34:17] who knows I wanted her dead? Because I only told you and David,
[34:22] so unless you told someone. Todarovic knew the Bagshaw had killed Stephanie, but
[34:28] she tried to seek the blame away from him. She said that he couldn't
[34:31] have committed murder because he was with her all night. The friend then queried,
[34:37] why don't you even care? What if she was your friend? What
[34:42] did she ever do to you? The next day, Toddarovic and Bagshaw appeared
[35:06] in court. They shuffled into the courtroom with their hands handcuffed and blank expressions
[35:12] on their faces. Toddarovic sat beside the prisoner's box donning of zip up swearer
[35:19] underneath a black jacket. Bagshaw was in the prisoners box wearing a long sleeved
[35:23] button up shirt. While typically the defendant's families would be in attendance for court
[35:30] hearings, nobody was there for either Toddarovik or Bagshaw. Details of the shocking
[35:36] murder dominated the headlines in Toronto. It was terrible enough for the victim to
[35:42] only be fourteen years old, but for the two defendants to only be teenagers
[35:45] as well. It shook the entire city to the very core. Meanwhile,
[35:52] and makeshift Maria began to appear on the street where Stephanie had taken her last
[35:57] breath. People left flowers, trinkets, and cards of condolences, including one
[36:04] which read make your young soul rest in peace. Tributes for Stephanie came in
[36:09] floods. There was an outpouring of love and grief dominated social media. Her
[36:15] former boyfriend Steve Lopez posted, Stephanie, I don't think you're gone like everyone
[36:21] says you are. I believe you'll always be here right beside me, watching
[36:24] my every move and keeping me safe. I know this may sound like a
[36:29] tragic love story, but I hope you're standing right beside me as I write
[36:32] this note to you. As the community struggled to make sense of the gruesome
[36:37] murderer. Toddarovik and Bagshaw were charged with first degree murder and romanded into custody.
[36:45] During the brief court hearing, defense attorney Marshall Sack, who was representing
[36:50] Toddarovic, described his client as an a student who came from a good family.
[36:57] He said that her parents were devastated and sent their condolences to Stephanie's family.
[37:02] However, he then added that the allegations against Toddarovic did not add up
[37:07] to a murder charge. He stated, the snopsis makes no reference at all
[37:12] to my client's involvement in the actual crimes, except to say that my client
[37:16] is alleged to have indicated that she wanted the deceased not to be alive.
[37:22] Beyond that, I see nothing, and that's not first degree murder. He
[37:28] contended that Bagshaw had committed the murderer and that Toddarovic had abetted it, which
[37:32] meant that she should not have been charged with the murder. Even suggested that
[37:37] she wasn't present when the murder occurred, stating, I believe she was home.
[37:43] I do not see her as a party did the matter. She was
[37:45] not present during the court hearing Bagshaw's obsession with Toddarovic was on full display as
[37:53] he continually tried to get her attention and mouth the words I love you.
[38:00] Rovic was doing everything in her power to ignore him, only glancing towards him
[38:04] once and then looking away. As the case was meandering through the justice system,
[38:09] Stephanie's stepmother, Maureen, announced that she wanted Toddarovic and Bagshaw tried as
[38:15] adults. She said that she wanted calls for a tougher Youth Criminal Justice Act
[38:22] and referred to the two defendants as monsters. She wasn't the only one to
[38:28] call for harsh treatment. A Facebook page was set up in Stephanie's honor,
[38:32] and many on there called for Toddarovic and Bagshaw to be tried as adults.
[38:38] People from all across Canada and the United States flocked to the Facebook page to
[38:43] share their condolences. News of the murders spread quickly across social media, and
[38:50] people who didn't even know Stephanie, as well as people who lived overseas,
[38:54] were horrified by the violence perpetrated against her. On the fifth of January,
[39:00] around four hundred people gathered at United Church for a candlelight vigil in Stephanie's memory.
[39:06] Reverend Scott Patton told the mourners that the candle they held represented a wish
[39:10] in their hearts for better times in the future. He stated, there was
[39:15] a presence of hope with a presence of light. The lights are a sign
[39:20] of hope among the tragedy. From the church, the group walked silently and
[39:24] solemnly through the east and neighborhood that Stephanie had called home. They stopped outside
[39:30] the family home, where Patricia and James thanked them for their outpouring of support.
[39:37] Adolpho and Moraine were in attendance, as well as Stephanie's younger brother Ian.
[39:43] They joined the others on the porch of the home and shared an embrace.
[39:47] After standing outside the home in silence for around five minutes, the crowd
[39:52] then walked to the spot where Stephanie was attacked. Here they planned their candles
[40:00] into the snow covered ground. The following morning, it was Stephanie's visitation at
[40:05] the Heritage Funeral Center in East York. It was an open casket and Stephanie
[40:10] was laying peacefully with a rose inside her hands. Photographs depicting her life were
[40:16] displayed alongside bouquets of flowers. The funeral followed, and during the service,
[40:22] Patricia said that her daughter had the kind of watchful and caring eye that would
[40:29] have made her a fantastic mother. She then added and very disappointed that all
[40:35] miss seeing her in action. Following the service, Stephanie's family clutched tightly to
[40:40] one another and stood in silence as her casket was led from the church and
[40:45] into the awaiting hoarse On the seventh of January, it was the first day
[40:51] back at school after the winter break for students at Rosedale Heights School of the
[40:55] Arts. All of Stephanie's friends were shaken up by the horrific murder that morning.
[41:01] There was a moment of silence in her memory, and afterwards Principal Barrie
[41:07] sketchly told students that their feelings of grief were normal. He encouraged them to
[41:12] speak with brievement counselors that were going to be on hand all week. He
[41:17] stated, this is a difficult way to start a new school year, but
[41:22] hopefully out of sadness we can build again a message of hope. He further
[41:28] told the students that they were planning a memorial service for Stephanie in the upcoming
[41:31] weeks, and we'd be working with her family in organizing it. The atmosphere
[41:37] at school was tense. The students chatted amongst themselves about what had happened.
[41:44] One girl commented, it's stupid, it was all about a boy. A
[41:50] couple of days later, Stephanie's family released a statement to thank everybody for the
[41:54] immeasurable support that they had shown them. Our gratitude goes out to the public
[42:01] officials and our family at the Toronto Police Service for their continued support and dedication.
[42:08] We also appreciate the news media respecting our privacy during the most difficult and
[42:14] profoundly sad time in our lives. To the residents of park View Hills,
[42:19] surrounding neighborhoods and all the witnesses who've come forward, you have shown us what
[42:24] it means to be part of a real community, and for all your support,
[42:29] we truly thank you, along with other countless Canadians. Towards the end
[42:34] of the month, Tatarovic had a bail hearing. It was denied and Justice
[42:38] David McCombs gave his reasoning behind the denial. He stated, it is apparent
[42:45] that the motive for this murder was senseless jealousy on the part of Melissa Tadarovik.
[42:51] It engendered a hadred so vile that she wanted the subject of her jealousy,
[42:55] an innocent girl dead, and she used David Bagshaw as an instrument of
[43:00] her hatred. As more details of the murder case were made public, Adolpho
[43:07] in Moraine began selling purple bracelets in Stephanie's memory that since learned that there were
[43:13] a handful of teenagers who knew that Tadarovic and Bagshaw post dangers, but felt
[43:17] as though there was nowhere to turn. With the bracelets, they were donating
[43:22] part of the proceeds to Kids Help Phone, which is a confidential counseling service.
[43:28] But Alfo poignantly said, if anybody would have said what they knew about
[43:31] those two young offenders, my daughter would probably be alive. I'm sure a
[43:37] lot of people fail, not guilt, but regret for not saying anything before
[43:42] this happened. I strongly believe if they knew about a line like this where
[43:46] they can sell their information without being scared of getting into trouble, maybe somebody
[43:52] else can get lucky and be saved. The rest of The proceeds would benefit
[43:57] the art program at United Church, where Stephanie loved performing in plays, as
[44:01] well as the Hospital for six Children and Roasteel Heights School of the Arts.
[44:07] They shared their wishes that they could establish an annual reward in Stephanie's name at
[44:12] the school, but also in Maureene. Both worked as court officers, but
[44:16] Maureene was currently on maternity leave and they were over the moon when the first
[44:21] order of two thousand wrist bands sold practically instantly. Maureene stated, it amazes
[44:29] me this outpouring of support. She was an awesome girl, She was an
[44:32] awesome teenager. You see all these people, some who didn't even know Stephanie,
[44:37] and they're willing to buy bracelets. It means a lot to us.
[44:43] In January, it was the one year anniversary of Stephanie's murder. People gathered
[44:46] outside United Church, where a newly planted tree stood proudly in her memory.
[44:53] The group held candles and marched in line around the residential area. The following
[45:00] month, Toddarovic appeared in court where she pleaded not guilty to the murder of
[45:04] Stephanie. Melissa Tadarovik was ordered to stand trial on the murder charge first,
[45:28] and that trial began on the third of March two thousand and nine. During
[45:32] the opening statements, Prosecutor Robin flummer Felt put forward their theory that Toddarovic had
[45:37] ordered Bagshaw to kill Stephanie in a jealousy driven obsession. He spoke about the
[45:45] earlier incident wherein Bagshaw showed up at Stephanie's home and asked her to tell Todarovik
[45:51] he had attempted to kill her. He stated this bizarre incident frightened Stephanie and
[45:58] her parents. Prosecutor Flummerfelt went on to reveal that Toatarovich had denied Bagshaw sex
[46:05] until he carried out the murder, as discovered via the couple's conversations. Prosecutor
[46:12] flummer Fell then described the stabbing, pausing a couple of moments to allow the
[46:15] gravity to sink into the jury. He held up the murder weapon, a
[46:22] knife that was encased in a plastic tube. He continued, stating she didn't
[46:28] just counsel or encourage, She pressured Bagshaw into killing Stephanie. Why because of
[46:35] a jealousy that grew inside of her, that had become so bitter and so
[46:39] vile that she slowly formed an idea that became an obsession. As he delivered
[46:45] his opening statement, Datorovic showed not one shred of emotion. Patricia was among
[46:52] the first witnesses to testify, and she detailed the relationship between Stephanie and Bagshaw
[46:59] from back into two thousand and five. She said that there was never any
[47:01] suggestion that she or Bagshaw were ever sexually involved with one another. Ian Stephanie's
[47:09] younger brother also testified. He told the courthouse Stephany received a phone call and
[47:15] he heard somebody on the other end of the line say meet me. He
[47:20] said that she kept repeating the name Steve it was her former boyfriend, as
[47:25] if she were unsure whether it was him or not. Doctor Michael Pollanin,
[47:30] the pathologist, then described the series of injuries to Stephanie. He spoke about
[47:37] the fatal stab wounds and said that during autopsy he found that a leader of
[47:42] blood had seeped into Stephanie's chest cavity. He stated that is in fact lethal.
[47:51] His testimony was followed by testimony from a sixteen year old friend of Bagshaw.
[47:55] He told the courthoy he'd spoken to Bagshaw after the murderer and that he
[48:00] readily confessed to what he had done. He said that Bagshaw told him that
[48:05] Totarovic threatened to kill herself if he did not kill Stephanie. He stated,
[48:12] he told me he had stabbed Stephanie around five times, and he showed me
[48:15] where, pointing to his left breast and down to his stomach. This friend
[48:22] lived near Stephanie, and he said that Bagshaw had appeared at his home after
[48:25] the murder. While here, Totarovich had called Bagshaw and asked if he had
[48:30] killed Stephanie. He responded that he had. She called back some time later
[48:37] and asked Bagshaw how he was planning on covering it up. The trial rested
[48:43] without the defense ever calling any witnesses. During closing arguments, prosecutor flummer Felt
[48:49] said that the jury needed to look no further than Tatarovic when looking for why
[48:53] Bagshaw killed Stephanie. He said, without her, there is no crime without
[49:00] her, there is no murder without her. We are not here without her.
[49:05] Stephanie Wrangell goes on living the life she has destined to live. He
[49:09] outlined all of the messages between Todtarovich and Bagshaw and stated she held sax out
[49:16] as the carrot for her to fulfill her evil intentions. In this case,
[49:22] she was not just a counselor, she was a driving force. Defense attorney
[49:27] Marshal Sack said during his closing arguments that the overall meaning between the messages was
[49:31] beyond diluted. He said that the Internet makes it difficult to convey subtle nuances
[49:37] and emotions. He stated not everything everyone sends is an expression of their intentions.
[49:46] He claimed that the countless times Totarovich told Bagshawe that she wanted Stephanie dead,
[49:52] she didn't actually mean it. When she told him she wanted him to
[49:55] kill her, she didn't actually mean it. The jury were then sent off
[50:00] to deliberate, and they returned with a verdict the following day. They found
[50:06] Melissa Tadarovik guilty of the first degree murderer of Stephanie Wrangel. As the verdict
[50:12] was rad aloud, Ddarovic broke down into tears. It was the first time
[50:17] she had shown any emotion other than when she cried during the interview as she
[50:22] spoke about rumors. The prosecutor read aloud a statement from Stephanie's family outside of
[50:29] court which read as a family, we were relieved to hear the verdict,
[50:35] but admit it is very difficult to be happy when so many people's lives have
[50:38] been ruined, not only ours, but surely the accused families as well.
[50:45] The prosecution were seeking an adult sentence for Todarovik, and before the judge made
[50:50] the decision, she underwent two psychiatric assessments. Before then, Bagshaw appeared in
[50:55] court where he pleaded guilty to the first degree of Stephanie. An agreed upon
[51:02] statement of fax was read aloud to the court and contained the details of the
[51:07] numerous messages between him and Todarovik. He read in part. Once inside Tadarovic's
[51:15] home, he told her what he had done and they had sex, which
[51:19] was his reward for killing Stephanie. Outside of court, his devince attorney,
[51:23] Heather MacArthur, said Barshaw decided to plead guilty to spare the family the pain
[51:29] of the trial. She stated, my client is incredibly remorseful for what he's
[51:35] done. He knows that there's nothing he can do to change it, but
[51:38] by taking this step at least he hopes to see if the Wrangel family further
[51:43] pain. In July, Toddarovic was back in court to be sentenced. Doctor
[51:50] Philip Lassen likened her to Glen Close his character in Fatal Attraction. He said
[51:57] she could evolve into a high functioning adult whoh out violently in intimate relationships,
[52:02] and said she showed trades of borderline personality disorder. He stated her persistent tearfulness
[52:09] flowed from self pity and a sense of personal victimization rather than the death of
[52:15] Miss Wrangel. Stephanie's family presented heartfelt victim impact statements. Her grandmother Mary clutched
[52:23] tightly to a tissue as she said there was no trial for Stephanie, no
[52:29] jury, no judge, no concessions because of her youth, no pity,
[52:35] just a brutal, calculated, cold blooded execution and afterwards a bizarre reenactment and
[52:42] a sexual reward freely given for a job well done. God help us all.
[52:49] Patricia said to the courtroom, if I let myself remember her, the
[52:52] way I should be able to her smile, or the way she played with
[52:57] her brothers and her natural infectious laugh, or her ability to banter back and
[53:02] forth with the wittiest of people, and told her ground it breaks my heart.
[53:07] I just can't go there. She said that memories of how Stephanie died
[53:13] would haunt her for the rest of her life. Ian, who was now
[53:15] thirteen years old, question why he didn't look out the window and see his
[53:21] sister dying. He broke into a sob as he said, I could have
[53:25] told her I love her and everything was going to be fine if she could
[53:30] just hold on a little longer. Todarovic was given the opportunity to make a
[53:35] statement. She stated, I want to say that I'm very sorry for everything
[53:39] I've said and done to contribute to Stephanie's death. Every day I wish I
[53:45] could go back in time and change everything I said and have Stephanie be alive
[53:50] and with her family again. I want you to know that I take full
[53:53] responsibility for my part, and I know it's hard for you to believe me
[53:58] when I say that I never meant for this to occur. I know there
[54:02] are no words I can ever say to take away the pain in suffering your
[54:06] family has felt. Melissa Dadorovich was then sentenced to life in prison without the
[54:12] possibility of parole for seven years. In handing down the sentence, the judge
[54:16] stated, a person who plans and orchestrates and directs another person to take the
[54:23] life of a human being is at least as morally culpable as the person who
[54:29] does the actual act. Put simply, the puppet master is not less blame
[54:34] worthy than the puppet. Indeed, I would suggest that the master is more
[54:37] culpable, since he or she puts the whales in motion and then stands back
[54:43] under the facade of disassociation while the scheme that they have created on folds.
[54:51] David Bagshaw was sentenced next. Patricia read laud a victim impact statement where she
[54:57] said that her daughter once had a puppy love crush on Bagshaw. She said
[55:01] that the murder was an act of betrayal against her daughter, who navely hoped
[55:06] to help the troubled bully. Bagshaw spoke before the courtroom as well. He
[55:12] was in floods of tears as he said, I killed an innocent girl who
[55:16] deserved to live. I want to ask for forgiveness, but realize that I
[55:21] can't even forgive myself. I will bear the heavy burden for what I did
[55:25] forever. Not one day will go by where I don't regret what I did
[55:31] to Stephanie's family. I'm so sorry Stephanie. I'm so sorry. David Bagshaw
[55:38] was then handed a sentence of life in prison with a minimum of ten years.
[55:44] In handing down the sentence, the judge stated, pretending to be another
[55:49] of her friends, he lured this young girl out of the safety of her
[55:52] home and then proceeded to stab her multiple times. He left this young girl,
[55:58] who was still alive, defend for herself, no doubt, terrified and
[56:04] certainly gravely wounded. The following year, Bagshaw appealed his sentence. His attorney
[56:28] argued the maximum youth sentence of ten years was more appropriate. His appeal was
[56:32] denied. Then, in two thousand and eleven, Tatarovic, who was turning
[56:37] twenty, tried to convince the judge to a lawyer to stay in the youth
[56:42] facility. She argued that you wanted to finish a science course. Her request
[56:47] was denied and she was sent to Grand Valley Institution for Women. In two
[56:52] and fourteen, Tatarovic appealed her conviction. She claimed that she was only joking
[56:58] when she ordered Bagshaw to kill Stephanie. Her request for a new trial was
[57:04] denied. Then, in two thousand and seventeen, Toddarovik had her first parole
[57:07] hearing, she was questioned about the motivation behind the murderer and she said it
[57:15] was a game we'd play continuously. I like to see how much he would
[57:19] do for me. She was asked whether the power and to control was an
[57:23] aphrodisiac, and she agreed. She further admitted that she only asked Bagshaw to
[57:29] kill Stephanie because he was talking with her. She said, my thinking at
[57:35] the time was that if the girl is out of the picture, I could
[57:38] be happy with my boyfriend. The two member parole board agreed that Toddarovic could
[57:44] have on escorted absences from prison to a halfway house. In November the following
[57:51] year, she was granted Dey parole for six months. The parole board said
[57:55] that Toddarovic appeared to show genuine remorse for her actions, and they said that
[58:00] she had made progress in addressing her emotions and relationship patterns. In March of
[58:06] two thousand and nineteen, however, it was announced that Tottarovak had violated her
[58:10] parole and was sent back to prison. She had become entangled in a love
[58:15] triangle with two former inmates outside of prison. She failed to report these romantic
[58:22] relationships which was a condition of her parole. Totarova had begun a relationship with
[58:28] one of the men and then became involved with his friend. Her parole officer,
[58:34] Angela law st at it. She appeared to be manipulating them against one
[58:38] another. She told the first man that he was not satisfying her sexually,
[58:44] and then complained about it to the second. Her behavior was very similar to
[58:50] the type of behavior that led to the murder of Stephanie. In two and
[58:54] twenty Tottarovak applied for day parole once more, but it was denied. The
[59:00] tragic case of Stephanie Wrangel highlighted the tortured emotional entanglements of teenagers. They were
[59:07] evidently lacking even the most basic human empathy. For months, Melissa Tadorovic had
[59:15] been pushing and pushing David Bagshaw to commit murder. Finally, Toddterovic's powers of
[59:22] persuasion succeeded, and on the first day of two thousand and eight, Bagshaw
[59:28] agreed to carry out the grim deed. Well, Bessie's that is it for
[59:55] this episode of Morphodology. As always, thank you so so much for listening.
[1:00:00] I'd like to set a big, massive thank you to my newest Patreon
[1:00:04] supporter, Lisa. As y'all know, More Biology is a one woman teams
[1:00:07] to the support album. Patreon seriously goes such a long way and I am
[1:00:12] eternally grateful. If you'd like to support the show, the link to Padreon
[1:00:15] is in the show notes, and in exchange for you support, I upload
[1:00:20] ad free in early release episodes behind the Scenes which include bonus audio videos and
[1:00:25] case files, bonus episodes of More Biology plus, and I also send out
[1:00:30] some merch. It's just over a month now until Crime Con in London.
[1:00:37] I'm going to be there all weekend on podcast Row and it really is such
[1:00:40] a fun weekend. On the Saturday night, they even have a quiz and
[1:00:45] I'd love for some of you to be there and we can partner up on
[1:00:47] a team. If you're interested in getting a ticket, I have a ten
[1:00:52] percent discount for my listeners. Just head on over to crime Con doct code
[1:00:57] dot uk and enter the promo code more Bid for ten percent off your ticket.
[1:01:04] Remember to check us out at morebitology dot com for more information about this
[1:01:07] episode and to read our true crime articles. Until next time, take care
[1:01:12] of yourself, stay safe and have an amazing week,

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
