# 229: Elaine Doyle

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 6 Nov 2023, 54 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/57392302/morbidology_229_elaine_doyle.mp3

During the 1980s, forensic science was still in its early stages, lacking the advanced techniques we have today. However, over the subsequent couple of decades, remarkable strides were made in the field. DNA testing, fingerprint analysis, and fibre testing emerged, ushering in a new era of forensic capabilities. With these breakthroughs, cold cases that had long remained unsolved began to be revisited, utilizing the power of modern investigative techniques. Among these cases was the tragic 1986 murder of a teenage girl, whose lifeless body was discovered just a short distance from her own front door in Greenock, Scotland. SPONSORS - Zocdoc: Thank you to Zocdoc for sponsoring this episode! Zocdoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient reviewed, take your insurance & are available when you need them. To find a & book a top rated doctor today, visit: https://zocdoc.com/morbidology 4Patriots: Thank you to 4Patriots for sponsoring this episode! In times of uncertainty, it's crucial to be prepared. Many people worry about the possibility of enduring prolonged periods without essential resources like electricity or even food. Get all of their deals at: https://4patriots.com/morbidology SmartLabels: Thank you to SmartLabels for sponsoring this episode! Say goodbye to countless minutes rummaging through storage bins for your Halloween decorations with SmartLabels. Download their app on the app store and buy their QR labels at: https://www.qrsmartlabels.com/collections/frontpage SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-229-elaine-doyle PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] What do you even look at them up to have a lean ding? Nothing?
[0:38] Nothing? I love them well aid. During the nineteen eighties, forensic
[0:55] science was still in its early stages, lacking the advanced techniques we have today.
[1:00] However, over the subsequent couple of decades, remarkable strides were made in
[1:03] the field. DNA testing, fingerprint analysis, and fiber testing emerged, ushering
[1:11] in a new era of forensic capabilities. With these breakthroughs, cold cases that
[1:15] had long remained unsolved began to be revisited, utilizing the power of modern investigative
[1:22] techniques. Elaine Doyle was born in nineteen seventy, the only daughter of Jack
[1:40] and Maureene Doyle. The Doyle family made their home at twenty eight art Gawan
[1:44] Street in Greenwick, residing in a three story terrace house converted into flats.
[1:51] Their home was conveniently situated not far from the local amenities and a short distance
[1:55] away from the bustling docks. Jack worked as a postman, diligently delivering mail,
[2:00] while Maureen was employed at a nearby betting shop. Eliene was the apple
[2:05] of their eyes, and she took her initial steps towards independence. After completing
[2:09] her schooling. She began working as a shop assistant at a local jewelry store.
[2:15] During her school years, Eliene had effortlessly formed friendships that endured. One
[2:21] of her closest friends, Claire mcgarrity, fondly remembered her, saying she was
[2:25] such a happy girl. Eliene was very trusting. Others in her circle referred
[2:30] to her as a guardian angel, given her propensity for prioritying her friend's needs
[2:36] over her own. These friendships held a man significance for Elene, as demonstrated
[2:42] by her snoopy notebook, where she penned heartfelt sentiments. One of them read,
[2:47] one of the best things in the whole world is a friend, while
[2:52] another read friends are made for hugging. Like many girls in the area,
[2:57] Elaine enjoyed spending time with her friends in the town. Jud their proximity to
[3:02] the town centre, she frequently walked home alone. Jack and Maureen, while
[3:08] uneasy about their daughter walking home so lou especially at night, recognized the importance
[3:15] of granting her some freedom. Jack remembered his daughter as sensible, having warned
[3:21] her about the dangers of late night walks and the importance of avoiding interactions with
[3:24] strangers. He described her as a girl who was burning with life, a
[3:30] girl who never broke a promise. Elaine herself was cautious about stranger danger.
[3:37] She had confided in her friends that she had been followed by a man in
[3:39] a car on a few occasions. These unsettling incidents had left her on edge,
[3:46] prompting her to always have a male friend accompany her on her journey home
[3:51] went out with friends. Alien shared a close bond with her parents, and
[3:55] she also had an older brother, John. While e Layne and John cherished
[4:00] their sibling connection, he couldn't help but see her as his occasionally annoying little
[4:05] sister, but he described her as annoying in acute way. Maureen emphasized the
[4:12] love and affection that surrounded Elane throughout her life, and this love and affection
[4:16] was always reciprocated. She recollected she was an ice wee girl who needed a
[4:23] lot of love and cuddles, even at sixteen. Maureen also characterized her daughter
[4:30] as sweet and considerate, noting she was never a tomboy, always a girly
[4:34] girl. On the evening of the first of June nineteen eighty six in Granich,
[4:44] there was an excitement in the air. A local late night disco was
[4:47] in full swing at the Celtic Supporters Club, and sixteen year old Elaine had
[4:53] eagerly planned to attend with three of her girlfriends. It marked her first venture
[4:58] into the world of grown up discos and she was thrilled for this special night.
[5:03] Elaine dawned a stylish black and white floral dress paired with a blue leather
[5:09] jacket. Before leaving her home, she made a promise to her father Jack.
[5:15] She assured him that she would call him to let him know that she
[5:18] was safe. At about eight thirty PM, Elayne fulfilled her promise and she
[5:25] gave her father a call from the disco. She told him that she was
[5:29] having a great time and she would be home no later than twelve thirty a
[5:33] m Jack later recollected. I told her to be careful and watch herself.
[5:41] Just past midnight, Elaine and her three friends left the club and made their
[5:45] way to a nearby Hamburger stall in Cathcart Street. The area was bustling with
[5:50] young people taking advantage of the upcoming public holiday by enjoying the night out.
[5:57] They struck up a conversation with a group of other teenage by the Hamburgers Stall
[6:01] and were offered a ride home by a friend's brother. However, the lift
[6:06] wouldn't be available until one a m. Elayne had made a promise to her
[6:12] father that she couldn't break, so the decision was made for Elaine to walk
[6:15] home alone. She bid her friends farewell and embarked on the three quarters of
[6:20] a mile journey back to her family's home. Lynn Ryan, her friend,
[6:26] chased after her, desperately trying to persuade her to wait until one a m.
[6:30] To get the lift back home. Lynne even offered Elene a place to
[6:33] stay overnight, as it was becoming much too late to be walking home alone.
[6:40] However, Elaine didn't want to cause any unnecessary worry for her parents.
[6:45] Lynn later lamented, I always wish I had persuaded her. Elayne's journey home
[6:51] would have taken her approximately twenty minutes. A few hundred yards into her walk,
[6:57] she encountered two friends on Hamilton Way. She paused to engage in a
[7:01] brief conversation with them before resuming her journey, her path illuminated by the gentle
[7:08] glow of street lights. In the early hours of the next morning, Jack
[7:13] prepared for his early morning shift as a postman. To your surprise, when
[7:18] he checked Olne's bedroom, she was nowhere to be found. Her bed remained
[7:25] untouched, leading him to conclude that she likely spent the night at a friend's
[7:29] house, most likely Line's. Jack reached out to Lynne, inquiring whether a
[7:34] Line had stayed over. The moment he learned that she had walked home alone,
[7:40] an overwhelming sense of dread washed over him. Around the same time,
[7:46] a man strolled along a leafy lane situated about twenty five yards away from Elne's
[7:51] front door. His intention was to unlock one of his garages located down the
[7:57] lane, when he noticed something in the near distance. As he drew closer,
[8:03] he was horrified to discover the lifeless body of a teenage girl. It
[8:09] was Elene Doyle. She was partially nude and had been sexually assaulted and then
[8:16] strangled to death with the ligature nearby. Her clothes were lying in a neat
[8:22] pile. Detective swiftly arrived at the sine, coordinating it off with crime scene
[8:28] tape. As they launched an investigation nearby, Jack and Marine became aware of
[8:33] the commotion unfolding outside of their home. With growing concern. And frantic worry.
[8:39] They ventured outside and approached one of the detectives seeking answers. Upon hearing
[8:46] that a girl's lifeless body had been discovered, an instinctual dread washed over them,
[8:52] apparent's intuition. In those times, d NA analysis had yet to be
[8:58] developed, but the detectives at the scene meticulously searched for any fibers that might
[9:03] have clung to Elaine. They employed wide adhesive tape to recover any potential traces
[9:09] from Elaine's body, carefully affixing them to transparent sheets for preservation. Signs of
[9:16] a struggle in the form of hair were found near Laine's body. The investigation
[9:20] was headed by Detective Chief Superintendent John Fleming, who commented in the media,
[9:26] Obviously we would be foolish to disregard any link between this killing and the Blue
[9:31] Bell Woods murder, but we are not connecting the two at the moment.
[9:35] He was referring to the murder of twenty year old Alison Murray, who had
[9:39] been found dead ten days earlier in blue Bell Woods near her home in Drumchapel,
[9:45] Glasgow. Detective scanned the neighborhood searching for Alien's missing handbag a blue clutch
[9:52] bag that she was known to have been carrying when she parted ways with her
[9:54] friends. In times uncertainty, it's crucial to be prepared. Many people worry
[10:03] about the possibility of enduring prolonged periods without essential resources such as electricity or even
[10:09] food. That's why I'm excited to introduce you to four patriots dot com,
[10:13] your one stop destination for reliable preparedness products that not only serve your immediate needs,
[10:18] but also have the potential to safeguard your life in the face of adversity.
[10:24] One product that stands out is four Patriots' latest solar generator, the Patriot
[10:28] par Generator two thousand X. Harnessing the bondless free energy of the Sun,
[10:35] this generator can pour various essentials from lights and television to crucial medical equipment and
[10:41] even refrigeration. What's more, it's expandable and comes with a complementary solar panel.
[10:46] You can also explore four patriots best selling survival foodkits, crafted for a
[10:50] shelf life of twenty five years, ensuring both sustenance and peace of mind.
[10:56] These delicious tasting males can be easily prepared even in the apps sense of electricity.
[11:01] Simply boil water over an open fire, let it simmer and serve.
[11:05] To ensure you don't miss out on this week's exclusive discounts and deals, I've
[11:09] arranged for a special page dedicated to listeners of Morbidology at four patriots dot com
[11:13] slash morbidology. Head over now to take advantage of these offers before they disappear.
[11:20] Go to four patriots dot com slash morbidology. But hurry, these deals
[11:24] won't last long. Save money and get peace of mind now by going to
[11:28] four patriots dot com slash morbidology. News of Eleane's murders spread rapidly throughout the
[11:37] area, leaving residents deeply unsettled. The specter of an opportunistic killer lurked in
[11:43] their midst, weighing heavily on the community, causing women and girls to fear
[11:48] venturing out alone. One local father remarked this place was reckoned to be safe
[11:54] by everyone until NOU detectives began to conduct to door to door inquiries with Elayne's
[12:01] neighbors. They wanted to establish whether anybody had seen or heard anything suspicious that
[12:07] night. The care d in the investigation, a couple of neighbors reported seeing
[12:13] a group of five youths in Elayne Street at about one a m Meanwhile,
[12:18] John and Marine were distraught beyond reconciliation. They went to stay with family and
[12:24] received support from the community. George and Ann Porter had some words of wisdom
[12:28] for them, telling them keep hoping and praying your daughter's killer will be caught.
[12:33] Their daughter, Lorna, had been found dead with her throat slashed on
[12:37] Waste Grand in Bellshill, Lanarkshire in nineteen eighty four. She had been on
[12:43] her way home to nearby Hollytown from her boyfriend's home when the killer struck.
[12:48] Lorna's killer was still on the loose at the time, and Anne commented,
[12:52] we know what the parents of Elaine are feeling right now. It's hell.
[12:58] On June sixth, detectives reached to the public for assistance in their ongoing investigation.
[13:03] They were still in search of Elaine's missing handbag and requested the community's cooperation
[13:09] and keeping an eye out for it. Their efforts remained focused on reconstructing Elaine's
[13:15] last known movements. They knew she had left her friends at the Hamburger stall
[13:20] around midnight to begin her journey back home. Tragically, Elayne was intercepted by
[13:26] her killer not far from her front door. The very next day, a
[13:31] tip from the public emerged. According to the tipster, they had witnessed a
[13:35] girl who resembled Lane boarding a taxi shortly after midnight on Cathcart Street. Detectives
[13:43] appealed to the public for additional information on this siding, urging anybody else who
[13:48] may have witnessed this incident to come forward. They emphasized that the person getting
[13:52] into the taxi may not have been a Laine, underlining the need to establish
[13:58] further details. By now, the five teenagers seen in the neighborhood around one
[14:03] a m still hadn't come forward, and detectives once more appealed for information about
[14:07] the youths. While still trying to track down these teenagers and Aliene's handbag,
[14:13] a woman placed a phone call to a citizen's advice bureau in Greenwick. She
[14:18] said that she had vital information about Elaine's murder, but hung up without providing
[14:24] her name or that information. On June tenth, detectives placed an advertisement in
[14:28] the Daily Record requesting the woman to call back, but unfortunately she never did.
[14:35] Undetered detectives continued to press forward with their investigation. On June fourteenth,
[14:41] Elene's father, Jack, joined forces with Ian Murray, the father of Alison
[14:46] Murray, to make it heart felt plea for information. They came together and
[14:52] pleaded, please help find our daughter's killers. Jack said that meeting Ian had
[14:58] helped him make the pain of losing his that little bit more bearable. He
[15:03] stated, We've been able to talk over our herd and remember our girls the
[15:07] way they should be remembered, as happy, loving daughters. The following month,
[15:13] Jack and Marine were home when their phone began to ring. Jack answered,
[15:18] and on the other end of the line they heard the voice of an
[15:20] unfamiliar woman. Amidst sobs, she revealed that she had information regarding their daughter's
[15:26] killer, before abruptly disconnecting the phone call. Just a couple of days later,
[15:33] this same woman composed a letter addressed to Jack, offering details a boid
[15:37] Elaine's murder. However, Jack never received any further communication from her. Consequently,
[15:45] detectives issued a public appeal for the unknown woman to come forward. Detective
[15:50] John Fleming described her as frightened and emphasized the importance of speaking to her.
[15:56] Detectives continued their relentless efforts on the investigation. By the end of July,
[16:03] they had interviewed more than two thousand individuals and taken over one thousand statements.
[16:08] However, Elaine's killers still remained elusive. Despite a few incoming tips, The
[16:14] lack of information provided by the public left detectives and Elaine's loved ones disheartened.
[16:19] The five teenagers still hadn't come forward to identify themselves to detectives, nor had
[16:26] anybody else who may have been able to identify them. Detective Fleming commented,
[16:32] there were five youths seen walking near Orlean's home shortly after midnight on the night
[16:36] she died. No one has come forward despite repeated appeals they could have vital
[16:41] information. There was also a young couple who had been seen walking in the
[16:45] area around the same time, but despite pleas for them to come forward,
[16:51] they still hadn't. That same month, detectives learned of three other results on
[16:56] women. These women didn't initially come forward to detectives, but when they did,
[17:00] they said they didn't think that their attacks were of any significance. The
[17:06] first woman had been attacked just a few hundred yards away from where Lane was
[17:08] attacked and just twelve days later. The year beforehand, two other young women
[17:14] had been attacked in the vicinity, and detectives began to wonder whether the attacks
[17:18] were connected. Detective Fleming announced, we urgently need the cooperation of the public
[17:26] to track down this man before he has given the opportunity to strike again.
[17:30] What interested detectives were the similarities between the four attacks. All four women had
[17:37] been attacked in the same area at the weekend and at about one a m
[17:42] other than the lane. However, all other women survived the attacks, although
[17:48] with psychological scars that would last a lifetime. While investigating these potentially linked cases,
[17:55] detectives received a fresh lead. According to the informant, they had witnessed
[17:59] the ends visual responsible for Elaine's murder fleeing from the crime scene. The suspect
[18:04] was estimated to be somewhere between twenty to thirty years old, with a height
[18:10] ranging from approximately five feet six inches tall to five feet seven inches tall.
[18:15] He was observed running down Art Gawin Street towards West Shaw Street, ultimately vanishing
[18:22] from view. The individual was dressed in dark outer wear, complimented by a
[18:26] light or white shirt protruding from his trousers. The tips are noted that the
[18:32] suspect appeared to be disheveled and agitated. Subsequently, two more tips reached the
[18:37] detectives. These callers reported encountering a young man displaying signs of agitation roughly five
[18:45] hundred yards away from where Leane's body was discovered around one a m. That
[18:48] night. These witnesses described the individual as approximately nineteen to twenty two years old,
[18:56] with short red or auburn hair. He stood at a height rainwing from
[19:00] about five feet five inches tall to seven inches, sporting a medium build.
[19:06] His complexion was pale, and his facial features possibly included freckles. The mountains
[19:11] dressed in a dark colored jumper, dark trousers, and a light colored shirt.
[19:17] Detectives now had a good description of the man they believed to have killed
[19:19] a Lane. In early August, they turned to the public and asked for
[19:23] more assistance in helping to identify him. It provided a description and asked people
[19:30] to name anybody that sounded similar to the description. Then, on the nineteenth
[19:34] of August, they released a composite sketch of the suspecting question. Detective Fleming
[19:40] announced it is absolutely imperative that we trace this man. By the next day,
[19:45] detectives had received almost one hundred names of men who looked like the composite
[19:49] sketch. However, the glimmer of hope that the case could be cracked began
[19:53] to fade when detectives couldn't tie any of the men to the murder of a
[19:57] Lane. The investigation plotted on, but the tips began to dwindle. By
[20:04] November, more than twenty weeks had passed, the detectives were no closer to
[20:08] finding the killer than they were on day one. Have you ever found yourself
[20:17] tirelessly searching for a new doctor, reaching out to every single person you know
[20:19] for their trusted recommendation. You know, the kind of doctor who not only
[20:23] listens attentively to your concerns, but also puts you at ease and truly comprehends
[20:29] your needs. After what feels like endless weeks of searching, just when you
[20:33] think you found the perfect match, you realize that they don't accept your insurance.
[20:37] Fret not, for I have found the perfect solution for you, sockdoc.
[20:41] With thousands of highly rated doctors, each accompanied by verified patient reviews,
[20:47] SOCTOC is the answer to your predicamentzoctoc is a free app where you can find
[20:52] amazing doctors and book appointments online. We're talking about booking appointments with thousands of
[20:56] top rated, patient reviewed doctors and spacialists. You can filter specifically for ones
[21:02] who take your insurance, are located near you, and treat almost any condition
[21:06] you're searching for. If I was searching for a doctor, ZocDoc would have
[21:10] been absolutely perfect for me. Go to z ocdoc dot com, slash morbidology
[21:15] and download the ZocDoc app for free. Then find and book at to operated
[21:18] doctor today. That's zerocedoc dot com, slash more biology, zockdoc dot com,
[21:25] slash more Biology. On the fifth of that month, the reward was
[21:30] put forward by a group of anonymous businessmen from the same area. It was
[21:37] a four figure reward that the exact amount wasn't disclosed. Detective Fleming was surprised
[21:42] by the reward fund but pleased. He stated, it is uncommon in Scotland
[21:48] to offer rewards of this nature, but it is one we welcome. He
[21:55] said that he had little doubt that somebody in the area was withholding vital information,
[21:59] but hope the reward would lure them out. The investigation was hampered by
[22:03] a lack of leads. After Elayne left her girlfriends at the Hamburger stall,
[22:08] there hadn't been any other reported sightings of her, at least not yet anyway.
[22:15] However, it was believed that somebody somewhere must have seen her as she
[22:18] treked back home alone. One more important tip came into detectives around the same
[22:23] time. According to a man, he had seen Elaine walking on art Gown
[22:29] Street. He observed a man following her and at one stage she appeared to
[22:34] argue with him. According to the eye witness, he said something to the
[22:41] man and asked the girl whether she was okay, but he was told by
[22:45] the man to mind his own business. He told detectives that he put it
[22:48] down to a lover's tiff and left that but he was sure that the girl
[22:53] was Lane. It was a decision that he would come to regret for the
[22:57] rest of his life. Christmas came and went, but it was a somber
[23:03] event for the Doyle family. Elainne's mother, Maureen, spent the entire Christmas
[23:07] week in bed crying. She solemnly commented, I couldn't bring myself to enjoy
[23:15] Christmas without my little Girl. In February, Detective Fleming spoke with the Daily
[23:19] Record. He shared his belief that Elayne's killer was a local man and that
[23:25] somebody within the community was shielding him. During the Mammoth murder inquiry, detectives
[23:32] had interviewed around five thousand people and had taken an additional three thousand, five
[23:37] hundred statements. However, nobody could offer any further insight into Elane's murder.
[23:44] Jack commented that he wasn't bitter over the lack of public response, commenting,
[23:49] if someone has information about Elayne's killer and hasn't come forward, I can only
[23:55] assume it's through fear. He said that he and Maureen had been inundated by
[24:00] letters and phone calls of condolences from people throughout the area. He didn't feel
[24:06] as though people weren't necessarily coming forward because they didn't want to, but because
[24:10] they had no information or were scared. In March, Jack Amorine went to
[24:15] their daughter's grave and found ten carnations, two of them were crossed in the
[24:21] shape of a kiss. Perhaps by this fine. They reached out to Alan's
[24:26] close friends and family, but nobody could provide any explanation for the presence of
[24:30] the flowers. Concerned and curious, they promptly reported the matter to detectives,
[24:37] who showed a keen interest. The possibility that Alian's killer might have left these
[24:41] carnations intrigued the detectives, prompting them to reach out to the public for any
[24:47] potential leads. They also conducted inquiries at local florists and garden centers in the
[24:52] vicinity, hoping to gather some information about the origin of the flowers. Into
[25:00] this another disturbing incident took place less than a mile away from where Elaine was
[25:04] killed. Two teenage girls were on their way back home from a disco class
[25:10] when a man attacked them in Larkfield Road. One girl managed to struggle free
[25:15] and staggered to a nearby home, where police were called to the scene.
[25:19] The second girl was discovered dazed in a nearby cemetery. Detectives considered the possibility
[25:26] that Elaine's killer was the same man who had attacked the two teenage girls,
[25:30] putting a dark cloud over the coastal town. Then in June, Jack and
[25:36] Moureene spoke with the Daily Record about the immense loss of their daughter, Moraine
[25:41] poignantly stated, time isn't such a great healer. Everybody keeps telling me this,
[25:48] but I feel as lost and confused today as I did the night Elaine
[25:52] didn't come home. They were both deeply religious and said that they didn't want
[25:57] vengeance against their daughter's killed. Instead, they just wanted the see him arrested
[26:03] to prevent any other parents from going through the same horrific ordeal as them.
[26:08] Jack commented, why would anyone want to harm a girl like that? Knowing
[26:14] the answer wouldn't lessen our grief, but it might help us to understand.
[26:18] Over time, the months gradually transformed into years, and the case grew colder
[26:23] with each passing day. Detectives diligently pursued every tip they received, but none
[26:30] proved to be fruitful. Potential lead emerged in March of nineteen ninety five,
[26:36] coinciding with the conviction of James Morrow from Greenwick, who had perpetrated a brutal
[26:41] assault on a young mother, resulting in a fourteen year prison sentence. Morrow
[26:45] had faced accusations of assaulting two girls in Greenwick back in nineteen eighty seven,
[26:51] but he had been acquitted of those charges. Upon Morrow's conviction, detectives announced
[26:56] their intention to question him regarding Elaine's murder. He had been residing in the
[27:00] area at the time of her death, and the similarities between his crimes and
[27:04] her murder were striking. Nevertheless, detective swiftly eliminated him as a suspect.
[27:11] In two thousand and five, a significant breakthrough occurred when it was announced that
[27:15] Elene's handbag had been discovered. Detectives chose not to disclose the exact date of
[27:22] the discovery, but confirmed that it was now undergoing examination. Since nineteen eighty
[27:27] six, forensic testing had advanced significantly, incorporating DNA profiling, fiber analysis,
[27:34] and more modern finger printing technology. A senior officer acknowledged this development, remarking
[27:42] it is an extremely significant breakthrough, perhaps the single most important development in this
[27:47] tragic case for many many years. Additionally, detectives now had access to modern
[27:52] computer software, enabling them to input all evidence, including statements, into the
[27:57] computer system, which would then them with valuable investigative leads. In June two
[28:03] thousand and six, Jack and Moureene made an emotional play to help catch their
[28:07] daughter's killer. It was the first time that they had spoken on Elaine's murder
[28:11] in years that the passage of time had done very little to alleviate their grief.
[28:18] It had now been twenty years since Elaine was killed, but Jack and
[28:22] Maureene said it seemed like just yesterday that she was taken from them. They
[28:27] stated, Elaine has always spoken about with great affection, and people still say
[28:33] to us, the town has never been the same since. Our family knows
[28:37] how important it is to help the police in every way possible. We appeal
[28:41] to everyone in the town to provide the police with information they need to solve
[28:45] the crime. When this happens, we will be able to grief peacefully,
[28:49] and then the time will also be able to move on, knowing that justice
[28:53] has been done. In that same year, it was revealed the DNA testing
[29:00] on Alien's handbag had yielded meal DNA. Further revelations disclose that the handbag had
[29:07] been found just a week after Eliane's murder, intentionally placed on the steps of
[29:15] the Wit Memorial Library Museum in Greenwick and partially subjected to burning. Whoever had
[29:22] left it there seemed to have a clear intention of ensuring its discovery. Detectives
[29:27] entertained two possibilities either the killer had left it there to taunt the detectives,
[29:34] or somebody else had been tasked with destroying it. Detective Inspector Ross McKay commented,
[29:41] this is the first time we have revealed that someone attempted to burn alien's
[29:45] bag, and we are hoping that will jog someone's memory somewhere. Perhaps it
[29:49] was the killer or someone he had asked to get rid of the bag,
[29:52] but we are hoping that a member of the public will remember the attempts to
[29:56] burn a blue bag. It's the type of incident that just might stick out
[30:03] in someone's mind. Remarkably, nothing had been stolen from the handbag, leading
[30:07] detectives to speculate that it might have been taken as a grim keepsake by a
[30:11] Layene's killer. In addition to this DNA profile, male DNA had also been
[30:17] recovered from Elaine's body, from her face and back. This male DNA profile
[30:22] was subsequently run through a national database, but no matches were found, implying
[30:27] that the killer hadn't been apprehended for any other crime. Since the database is
[30:32] inception, detectives embarked on the artist task of revisiting the three thousand individuals who
[30:37] had originally been questioned during the investigation collecting their DNA samples for analysis. Detective
[30:45] Mackay acknowledged the painstaking nature of this process, stating, we are one hundred
[30:51] percent confident we will solve this crime. It is there to be solved.
[30:56] DNA is a fantastic investigative tool for us. I'm sure we're going to have
[31:00] a success with it. As detectives commenced this rigorous undertaking, Elaine's friend Lynn,
[31:06] who had accompanied her to the disco that night, decided to break her
[31:10] long standing silence. She shared the immense difficulty she had experienced since Elne's murder,
[31:17] stating that night, whoever killed Elaine took part of my heart too,
[31:22] and my life as well. Lynn revealed that she had developed agrophobia and continued
[31:27] to feel helpless even two decades later. While detectives now possessed the killer's DNA
[31:33] sample, they grappled with the challenge of matching it to a suspect. The
[31:40] years dragged on. By twenty eleven, detectives turned to a modern tactic,
[31:45] familial DNA testing. This meant that they could search through DNA databases for any
[31:51] matches that were similar to the killer's DNA, whether that be from a child
[31:56] or some other kind of relative. They had set up a newts aim to
[32:00] investigate the case, Operation Evergreen, and they began a mass screening exercise,
[32:06] collecting DNA samples from thousands of people in tandem with familial DNA analysis. They
[32:14] appealed to the public an afthet if anybody had harbored any kind of suspicions about
[32:17] anybody in the past to reach out. In June of twenty eleven, the
[32:23] twenty fifth anniversary of Elaine's murder arrived, prompting her father Jack to speak publicly.
[32:30] On the occasion, He voiced his heartfelt hope that the renewed investigation could
[32:37] at long last deliver justice for his daughter. The waight of twenty five years
[32:42] of grief was evident on Jack's face as he emphasized that both the family and
[32:46] heir Layne herself deserved justice. Jack convayed his failings, staring time has not
[32:52] hailed the wounds. The passage of time teaches you to cope with the heartbreak.
[32:58] But as any parent who is life lost a child will know, the
[33:00] Payne Maureene and I fail on a daily basis is as real as when we
[33:06] first received that awful news. Later in the same month, the televisedoryconstruction of
[33:12] Elaine's murder was featured on Crime Watch. Detectives reported that the response to the
[33:16] program was encouraging, resulting in numerous tips and the identification of persons of interest.
[33:23] Among these leads were six individuals who now lived in Australia, prompting Scottish
[33:29] detectives to seek assistance from Interpol. That same year, a man who identified
[33:34] himself as Alexander Cannon appeared at Greenwick police station. He appeared to be agitated
[33:40] and bluntly stated I want to confess to the murder of Elaine Doyle. He
[33:46] said that he had met her at a health center near her home in Ardgowne
[33:50] Street. However, this health center wasn't built until years after Elaine was killed.
[33:57] Detectives rolled him out of the investigation. In January two thousand and twelve,
[34:01] the Doyle family endured yet another devastating tragedy when a Layne's seventeen year old
[34:07] nephew, Jack Doyle, was fatally stabbed in Greenwick, born years after Elaine's
[34:13] murderer. This was a heart wrenching coincidence for the family. A family member
[34:19] expressed their shock, stating, my family are deeply shocked by what has happened
[34:24] and we're trying to come to terms with it. Ultimately, a nineteen year
[34:28] old named Stephen MacIntyre was convicted of Jack's murder, but Elaine's killer continued to
[34:34] elude justice. However, time was slowly catching up on him. Among the
[34:43] names of persons of interest in the case was a man named John Doherty.
[34:47] He had been a resident of the area during the time Elaine was killed,
[34:52] and he had been out with friends on that night. At the time,
[34:57] he was far from being a suspect. Rather, he was merely one among
[35:00] many meals in the area who piqued the detective's curiosity. In March of twentyd
[35:07] and twelve detectives paid a visit to Doherty's flat in the heart of Tetrafalgas Square
[35:12] in Greenwick, located less than a mile away from where Leanne had resided all
[35:15] those decades earlier. Doherty was cooperative, willingly providing a DNA sample, his
[35:22] finger prints, and even consenting to being photograph These collected samples were despatched to
[35:28] the crime lab in Dundee for analysis. Detectives were left stunned when the results
[35:34] returned, revealing that Dogherty's DNA was a perfect match to the genetic material discovered
[35:40] at the crime scene. On the twenty second of March, forty eight year
[35:45] old John Dogherty was taken into custody in connection with Elean's murder. Tragically,
[35:52] Eline's father, Jack was no longer alive to witness the groundbreaking development. He
[35:57] had died from cancer the year beforehand. He had persevered with unwavering hope that
[36:02] one day his daughter's killer would be found. Martin Brown, the witness who
[36:07] had spotted someone shadowing Lane on the night she was killed, unequivocally identified Dogherty
[36:14] from a lineup as the man he had seen. However, despite the damning
[36:19] DNA evidence against him, Doherty professed ignorance about Elaine's murder when he was arrested,
[36:24] asserting that his knowledge was limited to what he had read in the newspapers.
[36:29] What do you know look with them or that of Elene d Nothing?
[36:32] Not, nothing other than well faid, tell me what your bad hey look
[36:38] on newspapers? Young girl? Not up my way home. During his interview
[36:45] with detectives, first of all, claimed he couldn't remember where he was the
[36:51] night Elaine was killed. However, he then admitted that he was at the
[36:54] same disco as her. He said that he had danced with a couple of
[36:59] girls, one of whom could have been a Laine, but he wasn't sure.
[37:04] When told he was identified as the man seen following Lane near her home,
[37:08] he replied, I wasn't in that neck of the woods. While Dogherty
[37:14] was booked into jail on a murder charge, detectives returned to his flat.
[37:20] Here they came across two copies of a newspaper story about Elaine's murder. At
[37:25] the time of Elaine's murderer, John Dogherty was a twenty two year old residing
[37:30] with his parents on Anne Street in Greenwick. He had left skill at sixteen,
[37:35] worked as a laborer in the yards for a period, experienced bouts of
[37:38] unemployment, and participated in government work programs. Back in nineteen eighty six,
[37:45] he was engaged to a woman named Linda Hargy. When news of Elaine's murder
[37:50] began circulating throughout the area, Linda couldn't help but wonder why Dogherty hadn't responded
[37:55] to the police appeal. Detectives had called on everybody had been at the club
[38:00] that night to come forward, and it struck Linda as peculiar that Doherty had
[38:06] refrained from doing so. Linda knew for certain that he had been at the
[38:09] club that night, and her inquiry about his silence triggered an alarming reaction.
[38:15] Dougherty erupted into a furious rage, shoving Linda against a wall and vehemently instructing
[38:22] her to never bring up the matter again. Their relationship was characterized by volatility
[38:28] and experienced numerous on and off phases. In the following year, nineteen eighty
[38:35] seven, Doherty embarked on an unexpected six year journey with the Army, a
[38:39] decision that perplexed his friends and family. Joining the armed forces had never been
[38:45] on his radar before. After Eleane's murder, Doherty had withdrawn from socializing with
[38:51] friends, and he eventually vanished from the scene to join the Army. Upon
[38:57] his return to civilian life, its relationship with Linda had soured, leading to
[39:01] their separation. Doherty secured a position with the local authority, a job he
[39:07] continued to hold at the time of his eventual arrest. The day after Dougherty
[39:12] was arrested, he faced charges of both murder and theft. Despite these serious
[39:16] accusations, Dockerty was granted bail and released from jail. In January. The
[39:22] next year, he was formally indicted on the murder charge and he was ordered
[39:27] to stand trial. In the subsequent month, Doherty appeared in court and entered
[39:31] a play if not guilty to the murder charge. Halloween has always been my
[39:39] favorite time of the year. I take pride in decking out my home with
[39:44] spooky decorations, from light up pumpkins and skeletons to candles, omitting those quintessential
[39:49] false scents. Yet one thing I can't stand is the struggle to locate my
[39:52] stash of Halloween decorations. If you can relate it, here's the ideal solution
[39:58] Smart Labels. Smart Labels you can effortlessly catalog your storage bins using their user
[40:02] friendly app and QR code stickers. This means you'll always know which bin contains
[40:08] what, from the label's color to the unique code. Just search for Halloween
[40:13] on their app and hey, presto, it will tell you exactly what storage
[40:16] bin your decorations are in. Alternatively, you can scan the QR code on
[40:21] your storage bin to instantly access a detailed inventory of its contents. Say goodbye
[40:27] to spending endless minutes rummaging through bins. Get straight to decorating this holiday season.
[40:32] To begin, just visit Qrsmartlabels dot com or check out Amazon or Walmart
[40:38] for their convenient QR labels. Then download the smart Labels app from the Apple
[40:44] App Store or Google Play to simplify your storage management. Say hello to hassle
[40:50] free decorating with smart Labels. The murder trial commenced on March twenty eighth,
[40:59] with dockertys to Nann's attorney, Donald Finley, asserting that his client was not
[41:02] responsible for the murder, but instead blamed someone else. They presented a special
[41:09] defense of incrimination, suggesting that the actual killer could be among a list of
[41:15] names derived from the investigation. Defense Attorney Finley read aloud forty one separate names
[41:22] of other persons of interest who had been looked into during the investigation. In
[41:28] contrast, the prosecution maintained that John Doherty was indeed Elaine's killer. They alleged
[41:34] that he had forcibly grabbed Elaine by the hair while she was walking home,
[41:37] struck her on the head, and either removed or compelled her to remove her
[41:40] clothing. Subsequently, he forced her to the ground, pressed her face into
[41:46] the earth, sat or knelt on her, and used a ligature to strangle
[41:52] her. During the trial, the jury was presented with details about the discovery
[41:55] of Elaine's body and the findings from her autopsy. Detective William Kennedy testified about
[42:01] his presence at the crime scene and his role in placing a blanket over Elaine's
[42:07] body. When defense attorney Finley inquired about his knowledge of crime scene contamination at
[42:14] the time, Kennedy responded next to nothing. To be honest, it became
[42:20] evident that the defensed him were trying to lay the groundwork to argue that the
[42:23] crime scene may have been contaminated. In response to these allegations, former Chief
[42:30] Superintendent George Nettlee denied mishandling the crime scene. Retired Detective Inspector James Goldeye also
[42:37] refuted claims that the blanket had ever been placed over Elaine's body. He clarified
[42:44] the blankets had been hung on the fence to obscure the view, but he
[42:47] maintained that no blanket had covered her. Defense Attorney Finley countered this calling it
[42:53] a potentially catastrophic blunder by the police at the scene and insinuating that evidence would
[43:00] support the presence of a blanket over a lane. Subsequently, retired detective John
[43:06] Wilson provided a testimony regarding the blanket. He maintained that he had never witnessed
[43:12] a blanket covering Elaine's body. However, the defense team then presented a statement
[43:17] he had made back in two thousand and twelve where he had said I definitely
[43:22] saw the body covered with a prisoner's blanket. In response, John Wilson expressed
[43:28] doubt, steering. I don't think I would have said that to be honest.
[43:32] He accused Strathkey police of manipulating his words. Defense Attorney Finly accused police
[43:38] of conducting a cover up over the inquiry into Lane's murder. Ex Detective John
[43:44] O'Neill said he wasn't sure whether a layne had been covered with a blanket.
[43:49] However, in twenty twelve, he had told officers he remembered the idea being
[43:52] discussed that a lane should be covered up. He accused those officers of sewing
[43:58] doubts in his mind. Defense Attorney Finley responded, when you mentioned the blanket
[44:04] on the body, Amnesia flows through the veins like a disease. According to
[44:09] former detective Chief Inspector William Clark, the crime scene had in fact being contaminated.
[44:15] He said that he was awestruck when he saw the body of Elaine was
[44:20] covered by a blanket. He testified the body had been contaminated to a certain
[44:24] extent by the blanket. Former Chief Inspector William Clarke agreed. He testified that
[44:31] Elaine's body was covered by a blanket, but back in twenty twelve he said
[44:37] there was no blanket. Keith Enyan, a former head of forensic support with
[44:43] Strathkei Police, testified next. He explained how he had used adhesive tape to
[44:47] collect any potential hair or fibers from Aline's body. When Prosecutor John Scullion inquired,
[44:55] Enyon acknowledged that the sticky tape could also pick up microscopic elements such as
[45:00] dried blood, skin cells, or other cellular material that might not be visible
[45:06] to the naked eye. The defense team then introduced Alexander Cannon, the individual
[45:12] who had falsely confessed to Helene's murder in twenty eleven. According to a psychiatrist,
[45:19] he was suffering from severe mental health problems at the time. Following this,
[45:24] Elayne's friend Lynn, who had been with her at the disco, took
[45:28] the stand. She discussed the man in the car that had followed Elaine on
[45:32] multiple occasions. The testimony then shifted to Lynde's husband, Francis McCurdy. Surprisingly,
[45:42] it was revealed that he was on the list of potential suspects in the
[45:45] case. Lynn and her sister Debbie had informed detectives that the composite sketch of
[45:51] the suspect bore a resemblance to Francis. Nevertheless, Lynne testified that during their
[45:59] twenty two years to get other, he had never exhibited behavior or made statements
[46:05] that would lead her to suspect him in Elaine's murder. By now, Francis
[46:09] was deceased. Among the list of potential suspects was also Bernard Bradley, a
[46:15] teenager at the time who had been seen dancing with Elne at the disco.
[46:20] Bernard testified and said that suggestions he killed Elene were ridiculous. He said that
[46:27] after the disco, one of his friends drove him home and he went straight
[46:30] to bed. Elayne's own brother, John took to the witness stand to deny
[46:35] that he was the killer as well. Much like Bernard, he said that
[46:38] suggestions he was involved were ridiculous. A number of other persons of interest that
[46:45] the defense had named testified during the trial as well. Each of them denied
[46:50] any involvement in Alain's murder. Among them was Colin MacIntyre, who had confessed
[46:55] to the murder more than twenty seven years ago. He testified that he had
[47:00] made the confession after detectives threatened him with violence. He maintained that he was
[47:06] at home at the time of Elaine's murder watching television with his family. He
[47:10] testified, the more I was denying it, the more angry they were getting,
[47:15] The more angry they were getting, the more scared I was getting.
[47:20] There was also Alan Cleary, who had gave detectives at the time of false
[47:23] alibi. On the witness stand, he said that he had simply made a
[47:28] terrible error of judgment. Defense attorney Finley said to him, what kind of
[47:34] man does this unless he had something to hide? An evil man. Another
[47:38] suspect was Brahm Buckley, who was serving a life sentence for killing a mother
[47:44] of two in Wales. In twenty ten, Docerty's defense team tried to argue
[47:49] that there were similarities between the two cases, causing Buckley to have an outburst
[47:53] on the witness stunt. All the other men who were named as persons of
[47:58] interest, there was no evidence to connect any of them to Alien's murder.
[48:04] John Doherty, on the other hand, was connected to the murder with DNA.
[48:07] Forensic scientist Terrence Randall said that over the years she ran more advanced testing
[48:13] on the samples taken from Elaine's face, body, and legs. Finally,
[48:17] she found male DNA on her face and back that had come from the same
[48:21] person. The DNA had gotten on to Elaene's back after she was strangled from
[48:27] behind. The DNA was remarkable evidence because it was found on a Layne's nude
[48:32] body as opposed to on her clothing. Fiona McMahon, head of the DNA
[48:38] database team at the police lab, testified that Doherty's DNA came back as a
[48:43] full match to that DNA profile. Fiona testified that she had collected samples from
[48:49] most of the other persons of interest that the defense had named during the trial,
[48:52] yet none of them matched the DNA at the crime scene forensic scientist Pauline
[48:58] McSorley then told the jury that it was more than a billion times more likely
[49:00] that the DNA profile found on Elayne had come from Doherty more than any other
[49:06] unrelated meal. She said that if the DNA had gotten there as Elayne danced
[49:10] in the club with somebody, then she would have expected to recover it from
[49:15] her blows, but she didn't. After the prosecution rested, the defense began
[49:20] their case. They once more mentioned the car that had followed Elayne several times
[49:24] in the lead up to her murder. They called on Samantha Nicol, who
[49:29] said she was an Ardgayn Street in the early morning ours of the second of
[49:31] June nineteen eighty six. She said that she saw a man walking up and
[49:37] down the street in the hours before Elene's body was discovered. She said that
[49:42] she didn't recognize him. After her testimony, the trial came to an end.
[49:47] Prosecutor John Scullion said during his closing arguments that they had proved beyond a
[49:52] reasonable doubt that John Dockerty was guilty. He reminded the jury of the DNA
[49:58] evidence and the eyewitnesses is including Martin, identifying him as the angry man following
[50:02] Elaine and Dougherty's ex fiancee, who described his outburst when she asked him why
[50:08] he wasn't talking to police. He said to the jury, I would invite
[50:13] you to consider that each individual piece of evidence combines to build a clear,
[50:17] powerful and compelling case. Defense attorney Donald Finley, on the other hand,
[50:23] accused detectives of not properly securing the crime scene. He said that the way
[50:29] they had acted caused evidence to become contaminated. Therefore, he said that the
[50:35] DNA evidence against Doherty was unreliable. The jury were then sent off to deliberate.
[50:40] The crux of the case was whether they believed that the DNA evidence was
[50:44] reliable or not. They deliberated for just a couple of hours before returning with
[50:50] a verdict. They found John Dougherty guilty of the murder of Elaine Doyle.
[50:55] Finally justice had been served, but it was bittersweet for Elene's family. They
[51:01] had waited so long for this moment, and Jack wasn't there to witness it.
[51:07] Elaine's brother, John commented, I kept asking why us, why this
[51:12] family? Now? I just wish my dad was alive to see this verdict.
[51:16] He wanted so much for this day to come, and he would have
[51:19] been happy with the outcome. John Doherty was subsequently sentenced to life in prison
[51:24] with the minimum of twenty one years. In twenty sixteen. However, he
[51:30] appealed to have his conviction quashed. His defense attorney Donald Finley told the Court
[51:36] of Appeal beyond a shadow of a doubt, there has been a miscarriage of
[51:39] justice. He said that the question was how a microscopically small sample of Doherty's
[51:45] DNA came to be on Lane's body. He also accused the jury of being
[51:51] overly and unreasonably influenced by the existence of the DNA. The appeal was denied
[51:59] the Wales. John just As may have turned slowly, but with the remarkable
[52:01] advancements in DNA technology and forensic science, justice was no longer an elusive dream.
[52:09] Jack and Maureene Doyle had tirelessly championed the cause of justice for their beloved
[52:14] daughter, Elaen. Despite their unwavering determination, Jack passed away without witnessing justice
[52:22] being served. Well, Bestie's that is it for this episode of Morbidology.
[52:45] As always, thank you so so much for listening, and I'd like to
[52:49] say a big massive thank you to my new supporter up on Patreon, Scott.
[52:53] If you'd like to support Morbidology up on Patreon, the link is in
[52:57] the show notes, or you can just download the app or go on desktop
[53:00] and search for Morbidology. In exchange for your support, I upload bonus episodes
[53:05] of Morbidology plus that aren't on the regular podcast feats. I'm just about to
[53:09] record the next episode, which covers the disturbing murder of four year old Sabrina
[53:14] Clement. I also upload ad free and early release episodes behind the scenes,
[53:19] which includes bonus audio, video and case files, and I send out some
[53:23] cool exclusive merch along with a handwritten thank you card. Morbidology is just a
[53:29] one woman team, so the support upon Patreon seriously goes such a long way.
[53:32] It helps to keep independent shows running and free to consume. If you'd
[53:37] like to support the show in another way, please consider leaving me a rating
[53:39] and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever else you're listening. Remember
[53:45] to Jackosoid at morbidology dot com for more information about this episode and to read
[53:50] some true crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay
[53:54] safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
