# 210: Samantha & Tessara Crespi

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 26 Jun 2023, 49 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53983103/morbidology_210_samantha_and_tessara_crespi.mp3

Creek Pine Drive is an upmarket residential neighbourhood located in Charlotte, North Carolina. It boasts of large single-family homes dotted along a tree-lined avenue. It’s the kind of place that most families can only ever dream of living, but for the Crespi family, it was a reality. However, a darkness was lurking within the family that would rear its ugly head after an episode of psychosis. The ensuing events cast a spotlight on the effectiveness of mental health services, raising crucial questions about the accurate diagnosis and the challenges faced by individuals seeking proper treatment. SPONSORS - 4Patriots: Thank you to 4Patriots for sponsoring this episode! With hurricane season fast approaching, it's time to prepare with 4Patriot's emergency food packages. Use the code "MORBIDOLOGY" for 10% off: https://4patriots.com/ HealthyCell: Thank you to HealthyCell for sponsoring this episode! Healtycell's REM Sleep gel to ensure a deep and REM sleep. They offer various other products designed with our wellbeing in mind. Get 20% off with code "MORBIDOLOGY" at: https://healthycell.com/morbidology SHOW NOTES - https://www.morbidology-the-podcast-110-samantha-tessara-crespi PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] Um, I was getting my haircut, and when I came back into the
[0:37] neighborhood, I was stopped. There was a lot of commotion going on,
[0:41] and they let the van ahead of me go to our street and they stopped
[0:46] me. Creek Pine Drive is an up market residential neighborhood located in Charlotte,
[1:04] North Carolina. A boasts of large single family home started along a tree lined
[1:10] avenue. It's the kind of place that most families can only ever dream of
[1:14] living, but for the Crasby family, it was reality. However, a
[1:19] darkness was lurking within the family that would rear its ugly head after an episode
[1:25] of psychosis. The ensuing events cast a spotlight on the effectiveness of mental health
[1:30] services, raising crucial questions about accurate diagnosis and the challenges faced by individuals seeking
[1:38] proper treatment. David Crasby came from a family of high achievers. He his
[1:55] brother, and father all held degrees from California State University, Sacramento, where
[2:00] David graduated in nineteen eighty three with a degree in accounting. David aspired to
[2:07] make his mark in the world of finance. He was a straight A student
[2:10] in college and passed the Certified Public Accountants exam as a senior. According to
[2:16] his friend Paul Nethercutt, who shared a dorm with David, he wasn't always
[2:22] a top student, but grew into the role of a perfectionist. He set
[2:27] that along the way. David always managed to impress his teachers and amuse his
[2:30] colleagues. He stated he was always the one who would get the most out
[2:36] of his talent. He was not one of the most athletic ones or one
[2:39] of the most smooth ones, but he was coordinated enough and knew how to
[2:45] get the most out of his abilities. Residing in the Pocket area of Sacramento,
[2:51] California, David embarked on a career at Sacramento Savings Bank, where he
[2:55] showcased his dedication and affable nature. His colleague, Richard's sleigh Maker, recalled
[3:01] of him, he was dedicated, but he had the ability to make every
[3:06] one like him. He was such an outstanding person. No matter what kind
[3:09] of problems would come up, he could always deal with them. In the
[3:14] nineteen eighties, David married a woman named Kimberly. In nineteen eighty nine,
[3:20] they welcomed their first child together, the daughter named Jessica, four years later,
[3:25] their family grew with the arrival of their son, Dylan. However,
[3:30] tragedy struck in nineteen ninety three when Kimberly succumbed to a year long battle with
[3:36] a brain tumor, leaving David and the children devastated. In the aftermath of
[3:43] Kimberly's passing, David felt compelled to re enter the world of dating. He
[3:47] rekindled a friendship with a fellow Sacramento State University alumna named Kim, and their
[3:53] connection quickly blossomed. Kim recalled how David called her up and suggests they go
[4:00] on a date. She said, within two weeks, I knew for me
[4:06] this was a whole world I could care for. Their relationship flourished, leading
[4:12] to an engagement and subsequent marriage in nineteen ninety four. However, the couple
[4:17] encountered a rough patch when David learned of the impending sale of the bank he
[4:21] worked for. Undeterred, he swiftly secured a new position as an administrator at
[4:29] the Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency, before eventually transitioning to the Money Store,
[4:35] which is a prominent home equity lender based in Sacramento. Following several years of
[4:42] marriage, Kim made the heartfelt decision to legally adopt Jessica and Dylan, solidifying
[4:46] their bond as a family. In nineteen ninety six, their joy multiplied when
[4:51] they welcomed their son, Joshua. Then, on the sixteenth of October two
[4:57] thousand, the Crespy family experienced the arrival of twin girls, Samantha and Tessa,
[5:03] completing their household. Prompted by David's new role as a director of internal
[5:09] audits for which Ovia Foundation, the family relocated to the outskirts of Charlotte in
[5:15] North Carolina. Settling into their new chapter, they purchased an expansive two story
[5:20] brick house in the Deerfield Creek subdivision on Creek Point Drive, a home which
[5:27] was valued at half a million dollars, spanning fourth thoys in nine hundred square
[5:31] feet. The residents offered each family member their own bedroom, while Samantha and
[5:36] Tessa shared a bedroom, which they decorated with Winnie the Pooh, their favorite
[5:42] character. The girls were known for their close bond and infectious happiness, and
[5:46] they had a profound affection for their parents. Their grandfather Lauren recalled they were
[5:53] the twins, happy little girls. They loved their dad and everything. As
[5:59] identical twins, Samantha and Tassarah shared a special connection. They delighted in dressing
[6:04] up his princesses and embrace their individual preferences. Samantha loved lambs, swimming,
[6:12] pink poodles, and the color blue, while Tasseah loved to dance and she
[6:16] loved the color purple. The Grasby family fostered a deep sense of faith,
[6:23] actively participating in the religious education programs at their local Saint Matthew Catholic Church.
[6:30] David, demonstrating his commitment, lent his financial expertise to assist the church with
[6:34] its finances. Not only were the Crassbies known for their strong faith, but
[6:40] they were also cherished members of the community, welcoming new neighbors with warmth and
[6:45] kindness. David and Kim greeted Marla Carrera, a fellow resident, with the
[6:50] thoughtful gesture of a bunt cake. The children, who were eager to engage
[6:56] with their peers, could often be found playing alongside their neighborhood friends. As
[7:00] one neighbor recalled, the majority of us don't have family nearby, so we
[7:06] become each other's family Weekends held great significance for the Craspy family. Irrelished quality
[7:13] time spent together, whether it was biking through the scenic neighborhood, preparing meals
[7:17] as a collective effort, or simply enjoying shared movements in front of the television.
[7:23] However, in two thousand and four, an unexpected blow befell the family
[7:28] when David received a testicular cancer diagnosis. On deterred, he underwent surgery and
[7:33] radiation treatments, ultimately triumphing over the disease as it went into remission by lay
[7:40] at two thousand and five. Friday, the twentieth of January twenty and six
[8:11] began like any regular day for the Craspy family. The older children went to
[8:16] school, while David took the day off work and stayed at home to take
[8:18] care of Samantha and Tessa, who were both suffering from a cold. At
[8:24] around eleven and thirty am, David chatted with his mother on the phone for
[8:28] fifteen minutes. Kim was at home that morning as well, and at twelve
[8:33] fifteen pm she left to go and get a hair cut. Before she left,
[8:39] she planted a kiss on Samantha and Tessa. I say ate lunch of
[8:43] marsh, potatoes and gravy. Around twenty minutes later, however, a phone
[8:48] call came in to local police, Pa Fama, Yeah, I just sild
[8:54] my two daughter. I just sold my two daughters. Smacky that hour,
[9:00] sir, kemmy, What's what happened? Okay? How? I mean,
[9:03] what's going on right now? Are you on medication? Are they breathing or
[9:09] anything? Now? What did you do to him? You stabbed him?
[9:13] What's your name? Okay? What happened? Let's kill them? Okay?
[9:24] Who are these girls? Two daughters? Okay? How old are they by?
[9:30] They're twins? Yeah? How how did you kill them? What can
[9:33] I medic? Answer? Come on? Okay, keep talking to me because
[9:39] you sound like you're a little bit tired and stepping. We're wondering if you
[9:41] maybe took too much medication. I know, I know what's real, sir.
[9:46] We're all everybody's on the way. Okay, all right, how many
[9:50] times do you think he's stabbing? Sir? Where did you cut him?
[9:54] Bottom? Okay? Realizing the bodies we're at, we're at I'm sorry,
[10:01] However, where did you say that that the girls are at? And sat
[10:07] Sir? In the kitchens, form one's in the bathrooms that we could be
[10:15] to try to help the girl. It was from David. He told the
[10:18] operator that he had stabbed Samantha and Tessa to death and that he was going
[10:24] to take his own life. With sirens blazing, officers responded to the family
[10:31] home. They pulled up outside and found David pacing back and forth on the
[10:35] driveway. He was unharmed as he was handcuffed by one of the officers.
[10:41] The others scanned the home from room to room. There was a trail of
[10:45] blood leading into the kitchen. On the floor, they found the lifeless body
[10:50] of Samantha. She was wearing a fuzzy light blue shirt and blue pants.
[10:56] She had been stabbed more than a dozen times, mostly in a chest and
[11:00] back. The officers continued in their search of the home. They followed another
[11:05] trail of blood into the bathroom, where they found Tessera. She was wearing
[11:11] a purple shirt, skirt and tights, and much like her twin sister,
[11:15] she had been stabbed a dozen times, mostly in the chest and back.
[11:20] Officer Andrew Mulach crunched on beside her and thought that he felt a pulse.
[11:26] He scooped her up into his arms and rohnoid's side to where paramedics had just
[11:30] arrived. The paramedic could find no pulse and suggested that the officer's heart was
[11:35] pounding so fast in his own chest that it was probably his pulse he felt,
[11:41] not Tessera's. Tragically, both girls were pronounced dead at the scene.
[11:46] As David was arrested, detectives intercepted Kim as she was returning home from the
[11:52] hairdresser. I was getting my haircut and when I came back into the neighborhood,
[11:56] I was stopped. There was a lot of commotion going on, and
[12:01] they let the van ahead of me go to our street and they stopped me,
[12:05] and then they asked me to get out of the van. It was
[12:09] already getting those waves that should get when something terrible has happened. And the
[12:13] police officer told me, your daughters have been murdered and your husband has confessed,
[12:18] and that's and I couldn't believe it. They stopped her in her car
[12:22] a boy two blocks away from the family home to Grinda neighbor's home and broke
[12:26] the terrible news that her daughters were deceased and that her husband had been arrested
[12:31] for their murders. Meanwhile, Samantha and Tessa we are transported to the medical
[12:37] Examiner's office. Before they arrived, it was evident what their cause of death
[12:41] was. Samantha, who weighed forty pounds, was stopped eighteen times in the
[12:46] chest, back and head. Tessa, who weighed forty two points, was
[12:52] stopped fourteen times, with one that went all the way through her chest.
[12:58] The autopsies underscored the totality of the double murder. The scene inside the home
[13:03] was horrific, even to the most seasoned detectives, and all were left shaken
[13:07] by what they had seen. In an effort to help them in their healing,
[13:13] counselors were brought in to speak to the responding officers, as well as
[13:16] the crime scene technicians who examined the home. That night, David was charged
[13:22] with two counts of murder. Ours later, around one hundred people gathered at
[13:26] Saint Matthew Catholic Church, where the family were members, to pray for them.
[13:31] The church remained open throughout the night for anybody who needed some company or
[13:35] somebody to pray. With the shocking and gruesome nature of the murders left the
[14:05] community in a state of horror and shock. David was known as a loving
[14:11] and devoted father, and this seemingly sudden act of violence shattered the image of
[14:15] a model family that friends and neighbors had Michael Crowley, a longtime friend of
[14:22] David, expressed his disbelief in the media, starting, if you had to
[14:26] interview the modeled family, they would be who I would think of. I
[14:31] can't tell you how inconceivable this is. The community had regarded the Cresby family
[14:37] as familiar faces in their upmarket neighborhood. Julie Sheehannah, neighbor, shared her
[14:41] thoughts, starting, it's tragic. All we can do is pray. We're
[14:46] family, neighborhood. They are a part of this neighborhood. We have to
[14:52] pray for them. Detectives investigating the case revealed that there were no previous calls
[14:56] for assistance from the Cresby household. Police spokesman Keith Bridges added, as far
[15:03] as I know, that was an intact family. This revelation further deepened the
[15:09] mystery surrounding David's actions. The public weren't yet aware of what David had said
[15:16] on the nine one one call regarding medication and depression. Amid the community struggle
[15:24] to comprehend the tragedy, David's father, Lauren, disclosed some issues with his
[15:28] son's mental health. Lauren explained that David had battled depression for a number of
[15:35] years, and more recently had been experiencing insomnia, prompting him to start taking
[15:39] medication just a week before the incident. David had always been open about his
[15:46] struggle with depression, Lauren recounted, in no way did he ever show this.
[15:52] There were no eruptions from him or anything. He told us he had
[15:56] problems depression, but he had the best doctors he could find in North Carolina.
[16:02] David's battle with depression had first emerged in nineteen ninety five, marked by
[16:06] suicidal thoughts and attempts, including contemplating jumping from a bridge and planning an overdose
[16:12] with over the counter pills. In nineteen ninety seven, he sat in a
[16:17] running car in a garage, further highlighting the severity of his mental health challenges.
[16:22] In the aftermath of the double murder, Kim, David's wife, reflected
[16:27] on their seemingly perfect life, which was overshadowed by the undercurrent of mental illness.
[16:33] When they moved to Charlotte. David experienced a two month episode of depression,
[16:38] and they faced difficulties in finding prompt psychiatric help. Eventually, they found
[16:45] a doctor who prescribed David the antidepressant Paxil, but he had disliked the medication
[16:51] due to its side effects and its impact on his mental state. Kim recalled
[16:56] his goal was to get off the medication. For someone who likes to think
[17:00] on their own, it's not fun to be medicated. David didn't like the
[17:03] medication, and he told Kim that it made him gain weight and that he
[17:07] hated the way it altered his mind. As time went on, David's struggles
[17:12] with his mental health persisted. There were periods when he would vanish from the
[17:18] family home for days without prior notice. After one such episode, he said
[17:22] to Kim, I was going to look for a place to die. Despite
[17:27] these episodes, David could also experience extended periods of apparent stability. Kim described
[17:34] him as alternating between elevated moods filled with happiness, humor, and profound connection,
[17:41] and bouts of deep depression triggered by various stimuli. David had sought mental
[17:47] health services both in California and North Carolina, expressing frustration with his search for
[17:53] effective treatment. Although he claimed to have the best doctors in North Carolina to
[17:59] his father, the road to finding appropriate care proved challenging for him. The
[18:04] onset of testicular cancer in two thousand and four only exacerbated David's already severe depression.
[18:11] He found himself confined to his bed for days, crippled by fear,
[18:15] and unable to venture outside. In an effort to alleviate his distress, a
[18:21] psychiatrist prescribed him additional medication. After undergoing three weeks of outpatient therapy, David
[18:27] regained some strength and resumed his work routine once again. He gradually weaned off
[18:33] his medication, only to find himself consumed by a resurgence of depression by December
[18:40] of two thousand and five. Initially, David's decline manifested as insomnia and anxiety,
[18:48] a state Kim likened to his inability to quiet his restless mind. Seeking
[18:52] relief, a psychiatrists prescribed prozac, a medication that required three weeks to take
[18:59] effect. Trazodone was also prescribed to address his anxiety, and ambien was recommended
[19:06] as a sleep aid However, these medications provided a little solace to David,
[19:11] who continued to wrestle with his inner turmoil. During sleepless nights, David would
[19:17] pace incessantly, obtaining only brief periods of rest lasting an hour or two.
[19:25] While the rest of the family slept, he would occupy himself with work on
[19:30] his computer. A day prior to the tragic events that claimed Samantha and tasseras
[19:36] lives, David's medication regime underwent a change. Ambian and trazodone were discontinued,
[19:44] and he was prescribed Linesta, another sleep medication in its place. On the
[19:49] morning of the double murder, David said he was too exhausted and unable to
[19:53] focus to go to work. Kim thought that he was capable of looking after
[19:57] Samantha and Tassea for just over an hour while she went to get her hair
[20:02] cut. After she left, David and the girls had been home alone for
[20:07] about twenty minutes when the girls asked whether they could play hide and seek.
[20:12] As they played, David grabbed two large kitchen knives and placed them on the
[20:17] counter. He planned on stabbing both of them in the kitchen. When they
[20:22] entered, he grabbed one of the knives and began stabbing Samantha. Tessa began
[20:29] to scream and ran away and hit upstairs on Samantha with stead. David ran
[20:34] after Tessa, calling out her name. He found her hiding in the walking
[20:40] closet in the master bedroom's bathroom. He pulled her out of the closet,
[20:45] held her down, and stabbed her. After David was arrested, he gave
[20:51] a full and detailed confession to the murders, as well as divulge his struggles
[20:56] with mental illness. He said that his battle with the prayer had triggered thoughts
[21:00] of killing not just Samantha and Tassah, but the rest of his children,
[21:06] Kim and his parents. He also said that he had thoughts about running down
[21:11] strangers in his car Dvatol detectives. He was worried about losing his job as
[21:17] a senior vice president and believed that he was in financial trouble. He also
[21:22] said he thought that he had failed to adequately care for his family, and
[21:26] said that by killing the twins he somehow believed that this would end his worries.
[21:33] He stated, I can't function, I can't take care of things.
[21:37] I'm like a zombie. It's always been kind of when I'm struggling at work
[21:41] and I can't concentrate, I can't see out of it, I can't see
[21:45] out of the darkness. David said that in the weeks before the murders,
[21:51] his depression had reared its ugly head once more. He couldn't sleep and he
[21:56] was struggling to make sense of emails from work. He said that he had
[22:00] been harboring dark thoughts for some time, and said that when the twins were
[22:03] three or four, he often carried a butcher knife in his pocket. On
[22:08] one occasion, he thought about stabbing Kim as she slept, and on another
[22:14] occasion, he thought about killing two of his other children. He said the
[22:18] bouts of his depression had ended after he got help, before adding, but
[22:23] this time I didn't see a way out of my depression and a way out
[22:26] of my situation. I wanted to stop our life the way it was.
[22:33] David further commented that he knew what he had done was wrong. He stated,
[22:37] I did this horrible thing. I know this was wrong to do.
[22:41] It confirms that I'm bad. David's comments only highlighted his delusional beliefs He was
[22:48] not in any way in financial trouble and wasn't in jeopardy of losing his job.
[22:56] He was on a six figure salary and provided very well for his family.
[23:00] David also said the detectives that he had a forty five thousand dollars bonus
[23:04] a year beforehand and feared he wasn't going to get another. According to his
[23:10] employers, however, he was actually on track to receive the biggest bonus of
[23:15] his career just weeks after the murders. David's mind then went back to the
[23:21] morning of the murder. He said that he had been harboring dark thoughts for
[23:25] some time, but had managed to put them to the back of his mind
[23:27] until that day. He stayed it they wanted to play the game, and
[23:34] then I said, I just I've got to do this because I don't want
[23:38] things to go on and that would stop the thoughts. David revealed that both
[23:44] of his daughters had begged him to stop, and when he was asked why
[23:48] he had stabbed them both so many times, he responded, I wanted it
[23:52] to be over. I wanted it to be over for both of them.
[23:56] The detective then asked David whether he thought he could stopped himself. He replied,
[24:03] probably, no, it had to happen today. The detective responded,
[24:08] it had to happen today. David said it had to happen today because the
[24:14] thoughts weren't stopping. I didn't want to go to the doctors this afternoon.
[24:18] David was then asked why he couldn't just have killed one of them. He
[24:22] responded, because they're twins, they go together. David told detectives that he
[24:30] loved all of his children and that they were all good children. He also
[24:33] said that the twins hadn't done anything that morning to set him off, and
[24:37] that it was all in his head. As for Kim, he said that
[24:41] she felt fine at leaving him alone with the girls while she went for her
[24:45] haircut. He stated she had no reason to know that they wouldn't be safe.
[24:52] She didn't think I'd ever hurt them. While David had seen numerous doctors,
[24:57] he said the detectives that he ever told them about the dark thoughts he
[25:02] had about harming his family. He said he didn't want Kim to think badly
[25:07] of him and worried that doctors would report it and his children would be taken
[25:11] from him. He stated, I never talked to anybody about them, not
[25:17] even the therapist I saw yesterday. David said that the plan after killing the
[25:22] twins was to take his own life. He said he considered getting in his
[25:26] car and causing an accident or jumping off a highway divider. He said that
[25:32] after washing his hands and changing his clothing, however, he had a change
[25:36] of heart. He said, I wanted to be stopped from hurting myself.
[25:42] He said that if he could speak with Kim, he would tell her that
[25:45] he was sorry. Around five hours into the interrogation, detectives left David alone
[25:52] in the interrogation room. The camera was still rolling and it captured him rocking
[25:56] back and forth, rubbing his palms on the table. He talked to himself
[26:02] or around an r and kept repeating the words pride in Mecklenburg County over and
[26:08] over again. He also kept repeating you got in jail. In a solemn
[26:34] court appearance on Monday morning, David was formerly charged with two counts of first
[26:38] degree murder. He appeared to be dazed, but he nodded to his brother,
[26:42] who was sitting in the public gallery, and then answered the judge's questions.
[26:48] Following the brief hearing, David was returned to jail, specifically the medical
[26:53] unit, where he was placed under continuous observation. In this union, in
[27:00] are housed individually in cells with glass windows to ensure constant monitoring, as there
[27:06] were concerns about David's potential for self harm. Outside the courtroom, David's brother
[27:11] John said through tears, Obviously it's a sad and horrible time for us.
[27:15] All. I want to express our thanks to the people of Charlotte for their
[27:19] support and prayers. We fail them. District Attorney Peter Gilchrist also made some
[27:26] comments and told reporters that it was too early for them to decide whether they
[27:30] were going to be seeking the death penalty against David. Just one day later,
[27:36] District Judge Phil Howerton ordered David's transfer from the jail's medical unit to Central
[27:41] Prison for his own safety. David had undergone evaluations of both the jail and
[27:48] the Carolina's Medical Center's behavioral health center, which confirmed his suicidal tendencies. At
[27:56] Central Prison, inmates received care in an eighty bed acute care hospital or an
[28:00] impatient mental health center in mid steamed at risk of suicide, undergo immediate screening
[28:07] and are placed under the supervision of a psychiatrist and a mental health team.
[28:12] As David was being transported to Central Prison, a heart wrenching funeral took place
[28:18] for Samantha and Tessera. Hundreds of mourners packed into Saint Matthew Catholic Church to
[28:23] bid their final farewells to the young girls. The girl's single white casket occupied
[28:29] the center of the sanctuary. Inside, the twins lay side by side along
[28:33] with their favorite dolls. During the service, Kim, who stood beside her
[28:38] daughter's coffin, delivered a heartfelt eulogy. Reading from a handwritten note. She
[28:45] alluded to the challenges of mental illness and described a dark impulse that had entered
[28:49] their home. With tears streaming down her face, she stayed it demons had
[28:56] their moment, but Goddess faithful. Placing her hand on the coffin, she
[29:00] whispered through her grief, our sweet angels, Tessa and Sammy forever five.
[29:07] After the service, the family made their way to Sacramento, where Samantha and
[29:11] Tessa were laid to rest at their birthplace. Before the burial, another ceremony
[29:17] was held at Saint Anthony's Parish, where the girls had been baptized. Reverend
[29:22] Brandon O'Sullivan presided over the service and pondered the question where is God in all
[29:27] of this tragedy, though we had no definitive answer. He spoke about finding
[29:33] a glimmer of light through the path of the cross, knowing that the two
[29:37] girls who had barely graced this earth were now free from suffering. Reflecting on
[29:42] mandel illness, he acknowledged the challenges of recognizing its ravages within a person living
[29:48] amidst love and life. However, he urged everyone to persevere. Kim stood
[29:55] before the grieving crowd, emanating strength and composure, encouraging them to find solace
[30:00] in laughter. She expressed gratitude for her unwavering faith and the support she received,
[30:07] providing her with the strength to endure. She once again referenced David's dark
[30:14] impulse and depressed state of mind, sharing her fear of what could have transpired
[30:18] with their other children if he didn't call name one one when he did.
[30:23] Elton John's circle of life emanated through the church speakers. It was the same
[30:30] song that played when the girls were baptized, serving as a poignant tribute to
[30:34] their brief lives. As hurricane season approaches, it's vital to prepare for potential
[30:44] disasters. Hurricane Ida's devastating impact on the Gulf Coast serves as a stark reminder
[30:51] Qauntless homes were destroyed, leaving many without access to food and water. Power
[30:55] outages lasted for weeks, and floods washed out roads, preventing grocery stores from
[31:00] restocking. Families faced hunger and desperate waits for slow arriving aid. Four Patriots
[31:07] offers a solution emergency food kits that provide long lasting and delicious sustenance and packed
[31:12] in the USA, These kids last up to twenty five years and come in
[31:17] covert storage totes then include a wide variety of tasty breakfasts, lunches, and
[31:22] dinners. With thousands of five star customer reviews, for Patriots has earned trust.
[31:27] These survival food kits aren't limited to natural disasters. In today's uncertain world,
[31:33] having a backup plan is crucial. Prepare now with four Patriots ensure your
[31:38] families well being during emergencies, and right now you can go to four patriots
[31:44] dot com and use the code more bidology to get ten percent off your first
[31:47] purchase on anything in this store, including their emergency food supplied kids designed to
[31:52] last up to twenty five years. Just go to four Patriots dot com and
[31:56] use the code more biology to get to percent of your first purchase of four
[32:01] Patriots survival food. That's for Patriots dot com and use the code morbidology.
[32:12] Just two days after the funeral, Kim called up the Charlotte Observer. She
[32:15] told them that she wanted to assure people that God was helping her family and
[32:20] that she wanted people to seek help from mental illness. She also wanted to
[32:24] take a moment to let the world know how fantastic her two daughters were.
[32:29] She commented, it's my moment to talk about Tessie and sam Everybody's not going
[32:35] to care tomorrow, but today they do. Kim said that when she was
[32:39] returning home from the hairdresser appointment and was stopped by police near her home,
[32:45] her initial thought was that David had taken his own life. She said that
[32:50] he had never once threatened the children or her and had given no warning that
[32:53] morning. That's Samantha and Tessa were anything other than safe in his company.
[33:00] She said. He was their father. He loved them, they loved him.
[33:06] She thought back to one instance when David was depressed and said, I
[33:09] am sad that this world is so dark sometimes and they would be a part
[33:14] of it. Kim said to her husband, you would never do anything,
[33:19] would you. David replied no, No. Kim went on to speak about
[33:24] the struggles getting David help before commenting, we're getting the best help right now,
[33:30] and two little people have died. Now we know all of these people
[33:34] that are available to help us. But when we were really in the throes
[33:37] of it, I was opening the phone book, you know. Towards the
[33:42] end of January, it was announced that David was being defended by attorney Jim
[33:45] Cooney, who was a devoid Catholic and death penalty opponent. He was also
[33:52] considered a death penalty expert. He helped to get Alan gel off death row
[33:55] in two thousand and two and then won him a retrial in which he was
[34:00] acquitted. In the aftermath of the funeral, Kim expressed her frustration, revealing
[34:07] that despite David's years of seeking help from various healthcare professionals, he was never
[34:12] thoroughly assessed or provided with proper treatment. Kim strongly believed that he may have
[34:17] been misdiagnosed. All along adding another layer of complexity to the case. After
[34:24] her comments, details emerged regarding a doctor from PHS Correctional Care, a provider
[34:30] of healthcare in jails, who stated that David likely suffered from bipolar disorder and
[34:37] psychotic depression. David had disclosed his mental health struggles to the doctors, expressing
[34:44] constant thoughts of suicide during the interview. Bipolar disorder as a condition categorized by
[34:51] extreme mood swings ranging from heightened emotions to profound sadness and hopelessness, often accompanied
[34:58] by periods of normal mood. It can lead to changes in energy levels and
[35:02] behavior. The double murder had actually occurred during a time when there was a
[35:07] heated debate regarding the use of antidepressants in the United States, with some people
[35:13] attributing violent acts to these medications. In response, the U s Food and
[35:19] Drug Administration mandated the Prozac and similar prescription antidepressants carry warnings but an increased risk
[35:27] of suicidal thoughts and behaviors in children with depression and other psychiatric disorders, while
[35:34] the FDA required a less stringent warning for adults, mentioning that antidepressants can cause
[35:38] anxiety, irritability, hostility, aggressiveness and impulsiveness. The organization was currently reviewing
[35:46] the possibility of issuing a stronger warning regarding suicidal behavior in adults using antidepressants.
[35:54] Doctor Irvin Thompson, the medical director of Carolina's Medical Center run Off Behavioral Health
[36:00] Services, explain that although rare, violence could occur when individuals with depression become
[36:07] psychotic, particularly if medications are prescribed inappropriately. For instance, if someone is
[36:15] suffering from bipolar disorder but misdiagnosed with depression and then given antidepressants, it could
[36:22] trigger monic episodes leading to violent actions. David Crespy's case represented an extreme example.
[36:30] Numerous studies have consistently shown that individuals with mental illness are not more prone
[36:36] to committing violent acts compared to those without mental illness. More often, they
[36:40] pose a danger to themselves and silently endure their internal struggles. However, the
[36:46] problem arises when mental illness is misdiagnosed and individuals are prescribed medications that are unsuitable
[36:53] for their specific condition. The reality is that mental illness affects cointless individual jules
[37:00] every single day, including people that we know and love. According to the
[37:05] National Mental Health Association, one in four adults will experience a significant mental disturbance
[37:10] during their lifetime. When left untreated, the consequences can be profound. The
[37:17] National Mental Health Association estimates that the annual cost of mental illness in the United
[37:23] States and compassing both the private and public sectors, amounted to two hundred and
[37:29] five billion dollars at the time, with only ninety two billion dollars allocated to
[37:35] direct treatment costs. The remaining sum represents lost work ours and indirect expenses.
[37:43] Nevertheless, effective treatment exists when appropriately utilized. Despite the widespread prevalence of mental
[37:50] illness, funding for mental health initiatives remains a low priority in legislative agendas.
[37:58] Furthermore, insurance coverage from mental illness false short compared to coverage for other medical
[38:04] conditions. In July, it was revealed that David's defense team and prosecutors were
[38:30] working on a play agreement. However, District Attorney Peter Gilchrist commented in the
[38:36] media, it's improper for me to discuss any possibility of how this case will
[38:40] be resolved. David's defense team provided a little more information other than to say
[38:46] that prosecutors had said that if he pleaded guilty, then the death penalty would
[38:52] be off the table. This revelation was a welcome relief to Kim, who
[38:57] said that despite what David had done, she didn't want to see him put
[39:00] on trial for his life. She said, I do not believe that taking
[39:06] David's life could in any way make right what went so tragically wrong on January
[39:10] twentieth. Seeking the death penalty for David would be yet another layer of injury
[39:16] upon or already deeply hurt family. Kim also said that the family was thankful
[39:22] that David didn't take his own life as well. She added, his life
[39:28] will be of value wherever he is on earth, including in prison. When
[39:32] there is life, there is hope for healing. If the case did go
[39:37] to trial, then prosecutors could have a difficult time convincing twelve jurors that David
[39:42] deserved to die. When against a death sentence would be David's history of mental
[39:46] illness, absence of previous violent behavior, and Kim's opposition, but still there
[39:53] was a chance that David could have been sentenced to death. Defense attorney Cooney
[39:58] commented, David committed these acts while in the midst of a psychotic episode.
[40:04] He will pay for them. With the rest of his life. He said
[40:07] that David and Kim had followed every single treatment plan that was given to them,
[40:12] and David took everything that he was prescribed. It was only after David
[40:15] killed his daughters that he was probably diagnosed with bipolar disorder and psychotic depression.
[40:22] Before the court hearing, David spoke from behind bars. He said that he
[40:27] often cried alone and thought about how he stabbed his two little girls to death.
[40:32] He said that he often woke up in the middle of the night and
[40:35] wondered, how could I do something like this? I robbed Tess and Sam
[40:39] of a wonderful life and from the people who loved them. On other n
[40:44] i's David saw Samantha and Tessa in his dreams. He recalled, Sam and
[40:50] Tess are playing where they're riding their bikes were together. He further added,
[40:57] Sam and tesser in heaven. Now I knew it. They were both wonderful
[41:00] little girls. They were innocent. He said that in the days after the
[41:06] murders, he feared he would never see his wife again, but then in
[41:08] April she visited him and was making weekly visits since then. He said,
[41:15] the first thing he did was apologize and tell her that it wasn't him who
[41:17] committed the murders. Kim replied, I know. Since the murders, David
[41:25] said, the dark thoughts had gone since he was properly diagnosed. He was
[41:30] on proper medication to treat his mental illness Lexiproux, an antidepressant, lithium,
[41:37] a mood stabilizer, and respired All, an antipsychotic. He was blown away
[41:43] by the support he had received from his family, as well as from friends
[41:46] and co workers. He said, I've been very fortunate to have a lot
[41:52] of people send me letters that are encouraging and very compassionate. I spend a
[41:57] great deal of my money buying postage. David then said, it's been difficult
[42:02] to be separated from my wife and children. It's been hard to have my
[42:07] routine changed, but I count my blessings. There are many things that are
[42:12] good, like when a guard gives me two apples instead of one, or
[42:15] when I get a card from my daughter I didn't expect saying she misses me.
[42:21] I'm in poverty here, I don't have anything, but knowing that my
[42:24] wife and children love me, that feels good. His mind then turned back
[42:30] to Samantha and Tessera and said that he anguished over what he did. He
[42:37] stated, I know what I did was wrong. I wasn't well and I
[42:40] did a very bad thing. I was very sick. My God, I
[42:45] would never do that in my right mind. I'm devastated. I sob I
[42:51] blame myself. I still ache over it. I believe what I did was
[42:54] something I'd never do in my right mind. I believe God has forgiven me
[43:00] for it. I don't see any reason I won't see Sam and Tess and
[43:05] all the people I love in heaven. On the twenty ninth of July two
[43:09] thousand and six, the courtroom was packed with people, including the homicide detectives
[43:15] who had investigated the double murder. David pleaded guilty to two counts of first
[43:20] degree murder. He apologized to his family and to his late daughters three tears.
[43:27] He said, I am so sorry for my actions. My wonderful wife
[43:31] deserves to have five children on this earth. I wasn't raised to do anything
[43:37] like this. Most of all, I'm sorry to Tess and Sam, who
[43:40] were wonderful, loving and good. They were everything you could wish for as
[43:45] a father. I think about them so much, they deserved to grow up
[43:51] and continue to do whatever they did best, which was to give love and
[43:54] receive love and care for others. He also thanked the president doctors for correctly
[44:00] diagnosing him and prescribing him the correct medication. He stated, for the first
[44:07] time in my life, I've been correctly diagnosed. It made me appreciate the
[44:10] horror of what I've done. District Attorney Beth Freeman was still seeking the toughest
[44:15] sentence possible, although that couldn't be a death sentence. She described how Tessra's
[44:22] heart must have been pounding as she hidden an upstairs closet and heard her father
[44:25] calling her name and coming for her. She said to the judge, there
[44:30] is no excuse for these crimes. The emotion in the district attorney's voice was
[44:36] palpable, as was the emotion in Defense Attorney Jean Lawson's. She said to
[44:40] the judge, I think what the evidence has shown is that a very very
[44:45] fine man lost his light. Compleaded for her husband's life, telling the judge
[44:52] that she still loved David and that she believed his actions were simply because he
[44:55] was sick. Her voice quivered with emotion as she said, he's a good
[45:00] man. I believe he did this because he was sick. I love him.
[45:06] You don't stop loving someone because they're sick. I want his life to
[45:09] be spared. We love him and we want him in this world. The
[45:15] fact that he did this is unbelievable to all of us, probably even to
[45:19] himself. He would have died for his children. Ultimately, David Crespy was
[45:24] sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for each murder. After
[45:30] the sentencing phase, Kim spoke with the media once more. She said that
[45:35] she and the three other children still lived in the home where Samantha and Tasso
[45:39] were brutally murdered. She stated, my house is where my girls walked.
[45:45] She revealed the she, Jessica, Dylan, and Joshua speak through their grief
[45:50] and we're all in counseling. In November of that year, both she and
[45:54] David spoke with Oprah. Kim appeared on the show, while David appeared from
[46:00] behind bars. When he was asked why he didn't take his own life after
[46:04] killing the girls, he replied that he had promised his wife he wouldn't kill
[46:07] himself. Hope were responded, I wish you'd promised her you'd never hurt the
[46:14] kids. David's confession only highlighted another problem. He was not truthful with his
[46:21] therapist. If he hadn't been open about his dark thoughts to harm his family,
[46:27] then there's every possibility that he could have been properly diagnosed and therefore prescribed
[46:32] proper medication. It is a poignant fact that if he were truthful, and
[46:37] there's every chance that Samantha and Tessa could have been saved. For years,
[46:45] David Cresby had been harboring dark thoughts, first about himself and then about his
[46:50] family. He had suffered from depression for over two decades, but when the
[46:54] thoughts of harming himself turned into thoughts of harming his family, he wasn't open
[47:00] with his therapist. In the end, it was Samantha and Tessara Crespy who
[47:07] paid the ultimate price. Well, Bessie thought, is it for this episode
[47:40] of Morbidology. It's always thank you so so much for listening, And I'd
[47:45] like to say the biggest thank you to my new supporter up on Patreon,
[47:49] Sarah. As you all know, Morbidology as a one woman's team, so
[47:52] the support up on Patreon seriously goes such a long way, and I genuinely
[47:57] am eternally thankful. An exchange for your support, up on Patreon, you
[48:01] get add free and early release episodes, bonus episodes of more Biology plus that
[48:06] aren't on the regular podcast platforms behind the scenes, and I also send out
[48:10] some merch and a handwritten thank you care. If you don't want to join
[48:15] Patreon, but want to support the show in another way, please consider leaving
[48:19] me a rating and review up on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever else
[48:22] you're listening. Reading some reviews are a super easy way to support a show
[48:28] that you like, and I genuinely do appreciate the fact. Remember to check
[48:31] us out at morebiology dot com for more information about this episode, and to
[48:36] read or twat grime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves,
[48:40] stay safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
