# 227: Ethan Stacy

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 23 Oct 2023, 53 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56957312/morbidology_227_ethan_stacy.mp3

Nestled within Davis County, Utah, Layton stands as a vibrant city, intimately connected to the bustling heart of Salt Lake City. This commuter’s haven, with its approximately 80,000 residents, has carved its place on the map. However, in spring of 2010, citizens of Layton awoke to find police officers scouring throughout the neighborhoods. They were searching for a little boy who had inexplicably vanished in the middle of the night. SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-224-ethan-stacy PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] M if he has. I mean, if you have to guess why he's
[0:36] why he walked out, it's leverage. He only wants the boy for leverage
[0:41] because when his why did Ethan walk? What would you say? Ethan's confused,
[0:47] he doesn't know where he is. It's nela nestled within Davis County,
[1:03] Utah. Layton stands as a vibrant city intimately connected to the bustling heart of
[1:08] Salt Lake City. This commuter's haven, with its approximately eighty thousand residents,
[1:15] has carved its place on the map. However, in spring of twenty and
[1:19] ten, citizens of Leyton awoke to find police officers scoring throughout the neighborhoods They
[1:26] were searching for a little boyhood inexplicably vanished in the middle of the night.
[1:42] Ethan Stacey was born on the twenty second of September two thousand and five to
[1:47] Stephanie and Joe Stacy. He was born at the Fort Stuart Army Base in
[1:52] Georgia, and shortly thereafter the Stacey family relocated from Georgia to Florida, where
[1:57] they established their new home. Ethan was an ordinary young boy, brimming with
[2:01] a zest for life and a deep love for the Transformers. His father,
[2:07] Joe fondly recollected he was the best little boy that you'd ever meet. He
[2:12] really was. He was a very lovable child, and that's all he wanted
[2:16] was to love on people all the time. His grandmother, AFREDA. Stacey,
[2:21] characterized him as an affectionate child with bondless determination, a young soul capable
[2:27] of achieving whatever he said his mind to. In addition to his warm hearted
[2:31] nature, Ethan possessed a talent for bringing joy to others through his amusing facial
[2:37] expressions. Amber Lluellen, a close friend of the family, remembered Ethan was
[2:43] very loving. He loved hugs, and he was a funny kid. He
[2:46] would make you laugh just by being himself. He was always happy, and
[2:51] he loved his daddy. Despite his tender age of just four, Ethan was
[2:54] already displaying signs of remarkable intelligence. Joe said that he could teach Ethan something
[3:00] and the young boy would grasp it almost instantly. Joe recalled, He's just
[3:07] a very intelligent boy. The union between Stephanie and Joe eventually crumbled, culminating
[3:14] in their separation towards the end of two thousand and nine, Joe returned to
[3:19] Richland's, Virginia, his hometown, while Stephanie relocated to Leyton in Utah.
[3:25] Following their divorce, custody of Ethan was granted to his father, according to
[3:30] the divorce documents. Joe expressed his concern the mother has always abandoned the child,
[3:37] and I'm afraid the mother will come and take him and I'll never see
[3:39] him again. On the twenty eighth of April twenty and ten, the divorce
[3:44] was finalized and four year old Ethan was sent to live with Stephanie at her
[3:49] Leyton Meadow apartment in Leyton, Utah, albeit only for the summer. Ethan
[3:54] had developed a deep attachment to living with his father in Richland's Virginia. However,
[4:00] the contentious custody battle led to a court order requiring Ethan to spend the
[4:04] summer with his mother in Leyton and the remainder of his time with his father
[4:09] in Richland's. For Joe, who had dedicated his life to his son,
[4:14] the decision for Ethan to spend the summer with Stephanie was heartbreaking. He expressed,
[4:19] I just wanted him to grow up where his daddy grew up in a
[4:23] small town in the mountains where it was safe. Joe had worked tirelessly to
[4:28] provide a life of pride and happiness for his son, with their cherished moments
[4:32] often spent at the nearby park and engaging in PlayStation three adventures with Spider Man.
[4:39] Ethan undeniably held a special bond with his father, As his grandmother,
[4:44] Freda attested, Ethan did not want to even talk to his mother on the
[4:47] phone. She'd call and he'd say, I don't want to talk to her.
[4:53] Meanwhile, over in Leyton, Stephanie had a new boyfriend named Nathan Sloop.
[4:59] Even before Ethan's moved to Leyton, Nathan had been sending Joe threatening text
[5:03] messages. Joe recalled the ordeal steering I've been threatened over the past six months
[5:10] by him. The Stacy family believed that Stephanie's motives extended beyond wanting custody of
[5:16] Ethan. They suspected she only wanted Ethan with her for the summer to hurt
[5:23] Joe. Freda noted it was like Ethan was just a pawn. Since there
[5:30] was a court order for Ethan to spend the summer with Stephanie, there was
[5:33] nothing that could be done. It was a quiet night for Layton Police.
[5:40] On the tenth of May twenty ten, Shortly after midnight, a call came
[5:45] into police from Stephanie, who reported that Ethan had disappeared from their Layton Meadow
[5:50] apartment. According to Stephanie, she had tucked Ethan into bed at around eleven
[5:56] pm that night. Approximately an hour later, she went to check on him,
[6:00] only to discover an empty bed. Frantically, she scarred the entire apartment,
[6:08] but Ethan had seemingly vanished. Stephanie informed detectives that this wasn't the first
[6:14] time that Ethan had wandered off during the night. Upon the arrival of detectives
[6:18] at their home, Stephanie disclosed that despite Ethan's brief ten day stay, he
[6:24] had already strayed from home five times. When he's walked out the five times,
[6:31] he hasn't made it ant of the courtyard, that's correct. What what
[6:35] have you guys talked to him about? I mean to see, I've tried
[6:38] to sit in the bed and explain to him that he can't do that,
[6:41] that if he wakes up, he needs to squee leave our back door.
[6:44] Ben he needs anything in and get me or get Nathan. When pressed for
[6:51] the reason behind Ethan's disappearances, Stephanie immediately pointed fingers at Joe. If you
[6:59] other guess why he why he walked out? It's leverage. He only wants
[7:03] the boy for leverage because when his fo why did Ethan walk? What would
[7:08] you say? Ethan's confused. He doesn't know where he is because his daddy
[7:15] told him that I was dead, that I wasn't ever coming back, and
[7:18] then nothing. He's here with me. He's confused, so his father's kind
[7:24] of mentally uh, abusive. He has no idea? No, Okay,
[7:30] I just had to ask that question. Okay, thanks, detectives not inquired
[7:33] aboid the activity Stephanie had engaged him with Athan since his arrival. What kind
[7:39] of things have you done with me Ethan since he got here? Is there
[7:42] anything around? But I don't ever spake him. I've never spoked him.
[7:46] No, I'm talking where have you taken him? We're trying to figure ot
[7:48] where he might have gone? If to give him to the park, actually
[7:51] give the store to Walmart. He's god of work. I worked fifth for
[8:00] Bloakfaster and Roy Italy flows next week. Okay, everything for their wait,
[8:07] I love him that much. Whereas most women with them like no, I
[8:13] want to listen to this. All I wanted was him. It's just one
[8:18] of my baby. Time was of the essence in this urgent situation. It's
[8:24] widely recognized that the initial forty eight hours of a disappearance, especially involving a
[8:28] child or critical, As time passes, the chances of locating the missing individual
[8:35] alive dwindle. Despite a third search of the immediate vicinity, Ethan remained elusive.
[8:41] Detectives commands store to door searches as a precautionary measure to jack of Ethan
[8:46] had somehow entered somebody else's home. Ethan was described as standing at approximately four
[8:52] feet four inches tall and weighing around fifty pounds. He had blonde hair and
[8:58] striking blue eyes. When last seen by his mother, he was dressed in
[9:01] Spider Man pajamas. Over forty officers were mobilized to search for Ethan, with
[9:07] the invaluable assistance of canine sniffer dogs, scouring a one mile radius around the
[9:13] apartment. The search continued relentlessly throughout the night, aided by flashlights, and
[9:20] carried on into dawn. One significant aspect of the investigation involved questioning a dozen
[9:26] registered sex offenders residing in the vicinity. There loomed a pervasive fear that Ethan
[9:33] might have wandered off at night, potentially encountering a child predator. While the
[9:39] search was under way, Stephanie and Nathan were separated and questioned. It became
[9:45] increasingly evident that their narratives were diverging and inconsistent with one another. In a
[9:52] moment of emotional breakdown, Stephanie confessed that Nathan had become consumed by jealousy towards
[9:58] Ethan. Well, then, I guess it made him beginning get frustrated with
[10:03] him because they would just spend time with him. I don't know what made
[10:07] that first. Okay, so Nate, Nathan was getting frustrated with Ethan because
[10:13] of all the time Ethan was wanting to spend with you. Is that what
[10:16] you're saying to spend time to him? Because he was just blatting his mouth
[10:18] telling everybody what his daddy dame. I don't know why he was being that
[10:24] way. I don't know why was he jealous of that way before? Never
[10:30] what did he say to made you feel he was like jealous of Ethan?
[10:33] He would say that Ethan was being disrespectful, and I couldn't. I couldn't
[10:37] bring myself to speak my kid. I've never spake my kid. I never
[10:41] hadn't spend my kid. Okay, I mean it was okay, the first
[10:46] couple ofs of his swaniers out there. Okay, I can deal with that.
[10:50] You know, maybe he was wrong for yelling at me and or since
[10:54] they were being the baby, you know something, and Tuesday night took him
[11:01] in there. Then it freaked out because I opened the door. So let's
[11:07] go to Tuesday night. She then shifted her focus to the night proceeding Ethan's
[11:11] disappearance, recoinding her he had awoken in the middle of the night to play
[11:16] PlayStation. Oh, Ethan had got up in the middle of the night.
[11:20] It was playing Flavisation in the middle of the night. Plane what PlayStation can't
[11:26] do that? Kids do that? Tuesday morning, early Tuesday walk, he
[11:33] put it once to day. Then one got into him and he just decided
[11:41] to did Ethan needed his butt? Look. Stephanie also mentioned that the following
[11:46] day, Nathan had subjected Ethan to physical harm, although she couldn't recall the
[11:50] exact reasons, I think I can't remember anything because he thought he was one
[11:56] TV. It wouldn't sup there with Molly, and he said, you don't
[12:00] need to be above you know. I think the plat doing, you know,
[12:05] and I didn't hear wrong with So he's ins in the kitchen with you
[12:11] and then he goes respect were he's been talking about. He was crying as
[12:26] these inconsistencies were brought to light. Both Stephanie and Nathan eventually admitted to horrifying
[12:33] truths. Ethan was dead. They had buried him on Powder Mountain. In
[12:41] the midst of pouring rain. Detectives descended upon Powder Mountain, concentrating their search
[12:46] efforts near the Wolf Canyon trailhead on State Road one five eight and we Were
[12:50] County. Nathan had guided them to this location. Curious bystanders gathered their mood
[12:58] somber as they observed detectives carrying shovels to canopies said of the two distinct sites
[13:05] less than a quarter mile up the trail. At around five pm, a
[13:09] collective gasp rippled through the onlookers as officers emerged from the trail with a small
[13:15] blue body bag containing Ethan's remains. He had been wrapped in eight layers of
[13:22] plastic bags, buried alongside a broken hammer, a shovel head, and a
[13:26] bottle of lighter fluid. Stephanie was arrested on suspicion of child abuse, obstruction
[13:33] of justice, and desecration of a corpse. Nathan faced charges vaggravated murder,
[13:41] child abuse, obstruction of justice, and desecration of a corpse. As the
[13:46] tragic details emerged, it became clear that Ethan had endured just over two weeks
[13:52] of unimaginable terror. Back in their teenage years, Stephanie and Nathan crossed paths,
[14:03] but their connection didn't truly form until October of two thousand and nine.
[14:09] By that point, Nathan had accumulated a significant criminal record. Between two thousand
[14:15] and two thousand and three, he had been convicted multiple times, including charges
[14:20] of criminal mischief, disorderly conduct, and drug possession. In two thousand and
[14:26] three, he served a thirty day jail sentence for one drug possession charge and
[14:31] later received a six month suspended sentence for another. It was during this time
[14:35] that Stephanie and Nathan's romantic relationship blossomed, coinciding with Stephanie's divorce proceedings with Joe.
[14:43] Nathan openly expressed his feelings online, writing, instead of provoking my bad
[14:48] boys side, she respects it. She doesn't try and provoke me to protect
[14:54] her, but rather she loves me in ways I could and even ask her
[14:58] to. Stephanie also cammed on their relationship, steering we began with full discourse
[15:03] so that way our exes couldn't try and use things against us. Someone else's
[15:09] garbage is now my treasure. Though I loved my ex we just weren't meant
[15:13] to fit together like Nathan and I do. On April twenty eighth, when
[15:16] Stephanie's divorce from Joe was finalized, she and Ethan returned to Leyton, leaving
[15:22] Joe behind in Virginia. For the first few days after the move, Ethan
[15:28] maintained daily phone contact with his father. However, this communication abruptly ceased.
[15:35] Joe continued to call every day to speak with his son, but Stephanie provided
[15:39] various excuses for why Ethan couldn't come to the phone. She claimed that Ethan
[15:45] was misbehaving, which seemed out of character for him. During one of their
[15:48] phone conversations, Stephanie informed Joe that Ethan's jaw was in a terrible condition due
[15:54] to an allergic reaction to grapefruit. She also mentioned that she needed to trim
[15:58] Ethan's nails because he was scratching at his jaw. These explanations raised Joe's concerns
[16:04] further, and they didn't line with his knowledge of his son's behavior. What
[16:10] Joe remained unaware of was that shortly after Ethan arrived in Utah, Nathan began
[16:15] subjecting him to abuse. On the fifth of May, Nathan took Ethan into
[16:21] his bedroom, shutting the door behind them, and subjected him to a brutal
[16:25] beating with his fists. Stephanie entered the room and immediately saw the severe injuries
[16:30] on Ethan's face. Despite the extent of the injuries, Stephanie chose not to
[16:34] seek medical assistance. She've later explained to detectives that she feared Nathan would be
[16:40] arrested for child abuse if they sought Hell. Okay, took him into his
[16:45] bedroom him speaking him, I'm like, okay, what do you see?
[16:51] That's it? He kept doing it. What did you hear? Kept hearing
[16:56] a good screaming. I didn't know, no, no, and I think
[17:03] it's not crupp because I didn't bury him. My baby screaming, and never
[17:07] time we tried to go in there hitting, he grabbed him his throat brilliant
[17:12] against the all time belding. He's a little respect. If he's trying this,
[17:15] he's gonna be a chrissy. He's not gonna be a man. Okay,
[17:22] what kind of hitting noise to you? You said you hurt him hitting
[17:25] and what would your hear? His speck SPACs night like it was one about
[17:27] the first time. And then I heard and Smackley is following him, stack
[17:33] in his face. It's like a slap, like talking about this kind of
[17:38] yeah, like this back and for it. How many times you think you're
[17:42] hitting across the face? I don't know, because he was trying to be
[17:45] so quiet about it, and he grabbed I knew he grabbed his face like
[17:49] this. The subsequent day, Stephanie and Nathan exchanged files in Farmington. Notably,
[17:56] Ethan was absent, confined to his bedroom home. The beatings inflicted upon
[18:02] him had reached such severity that the couple feared that bringing Ethan to the wedding
[18:06] would draw the attention of authorities due to his visible injuries. Following their return
[18:11] from the wedding, the abuse persisted, with Nathan escalating the brutality. He
[18:18] determined that mere fists were insufficient, opting instead to scald Ethan with boiling water,
[18:25] resulting in burns covering seventeen point five percent of his body. Ethan was
[18:30] then coerced into consuming two sixteen ounce bottles of water, a sixteen oce bottle
[18:34] of coolid, and a glass of orange juice over the span of two oars.
[18:42] Four enthusiasts of classic mysteries packed with twists, June's Journey is the ultimate
[18:48] gaming delight. Embark on an adventure with the endearing amateur sleuth June Parker,
[18:55] uncovering the truth behind her sister's death and unearthing some long health family secrets.
[19:02] With over one thousand meticulously crafted scenes, hone your observational skills as you hunt
[19:07] for concealed clues and crucial information. Immerse yourself in the glamorous nineteen twenties through
[19:14] the captivating visuals and engaging gamesplay of June's Journey. I've been playing this mobile
[19:19] puzzle game for well over two years now, and i often find myself playing
[19:23] late at night as a way to unwind before bed. Among its highlights,
[19:27] June's Journey lets you craft your own island to state and become part of a
[19:32] detective club. Download June's Journey for free on iOS and Android. In an
[19:41] effort to alleviate the facial swelling caused by the injuries, the couple compelled Ethan
[19:47] to take motrin and benadryl. Over the next couple of days, Ethan was
[19:52] lethargic and vomiting, and he was unable to act. He was evidently exhibiting
[19:56] signs and symptoms of a possible head injury or brains sw Nathan disclosed to detectives
[20:03] that Stephanie had urged him to toughen Ethan up through frequent discipline, and he
[20:07] admitted to frequently slapping and punching Ethan. Both he and Stephanie subjected Ethan to
[20:14] further torment by making him stand with his nose against the wall while verbally abusing
[20:18] him. Detectives discovered blood spotter on the walls of Ethan's bedroom during their investigation.
[20:26] On the seventh of May, Stephanie returned to the apartment after a shopping
[20:30] trip to Walmart and discovered that Ethan had sustained severe burns. Nathan claimed it
[20:36] was an accidental burn that occurred in the bathtub. Tryck to leave Walmart,
[20:41] come home. How'd you find out your son's speed up the burn? I
[20:47] completely fausted. I could not believe way since he had looked, I didn't
[20:55] know what to do. Ethan, he put in socks over him and knowing
[20:57] that he didn't earned off names. But so his whole leg was burned all
[21:03] the way up to his buttocks area, so he had water to be pretty
[21:07] deep. Exactly his whole foot up, both feet were covered, a whole
[21:18] back of his legs on both sides, the back of his legs up the
[21:23] front and on the back. Just said, I didn't know the French just
[21:26] back burned to describe what you what you mean? It's red malistering. It
[21:32] wasn't mustering. There was red skin peeled. The skin did peel. Wow,
[21:38] small water. Yeah, And my first inclination was, there's no way
[21:45] my child did this. Stephanie express skepticism about Nathan's explanation, but she can
[21:52] fasted detectives that are fear of Nathan prevented her from seeking medical assistance. Nathan
[21:59] conjured this, accusing Stephanie of burning Ethan, telling detectives the skin's just coming
[22:04] off. I'm trying not to panic. Stephanie's panicking, She's freaking out.
[22:11] As Stephanie was examining Ethan's injuries, she noticed that there were feces inside his
[22:15] mouth. She pushed him into the bathroom and brushed his mouth until his gumbs
[22:21] were bleeding. When she was questioned about this, she said that she first
[22:25] of all, saw it in the bathroom. What about the vehicle material?
[22:30] Where does the feces tell me about the feces? Ali saw it on the
[22:37] tub, of all the tub and I only saw it on the tub.
[22:47] I didn't Is that all pregnant? Good side? She never saw Nathan.
[23:00] You just saw in the bathroom on the walls. Did you say, some
[23:03] smear it out on the walls. And how does that explain to you?
[23:10] Ethan reach toos dead branded it and my son doesn't do that. So sorry,
[23:15] I might have turk I kid now, but my kid doesn't do that.
[23:18] Okay, So what do you think happened? Honestly, I think he
[23:26] put ship in my kid's mouth, and I think he purposely turned the water
[23:30] up. And when she looked in Ethan's MOI she saw it there as well.
[23:36] So when you get home, Ethan was burned and pecs were smeared in
[23:40] the bathroom wall. I buy a panic. I had in all that mass,
[23:45] I had panics. I didn't know what to do with you burned so
[23:49] bad? Did how did you find this peces? And how did you find
[23:55] out that you had pieces in his mouth? He was in the tub and
[23:57] his mouth and he had ship in his mouth. Okay, my kid doesn't
[24:03] do that. My kid has never done that. Never. Then inter of
[24:10] my brush. See that's it. They didn't because he did the next day,
[24:12] but it brushing more ship out of his mouth the next day. So
[24:18] you've cleaned his mouth that night too, Friday night. Well you said,
[24:25] this is Friday night, Friday, late Friday night, they cleaned it,
[24:26] and then I think again on Saturday. Okay, so you found pieces in
[24:33] his mouth and you think you think that Nate was the one that did it.
[24:40] I don't know. He SUPs the baby did it? The baby that
[24:42] respect to buttonneath his nails. So you looked at his nails nothing, of
[24:48] course I did his nails, my mommy. For if his nails, see,
[24:52] they'll get everything and you actually saw some fecal material of his mouth and
[25:00] Nathan's tom he did it to himself. Nathan admitted to detectives that he had
[25:04] placed faces in Ethan's mouth, but alleged that Stephanie had done the same.
[25:10] Additionally, evidence suggested that Ethan's genitals had been subjected to abuse, with Nathan
[25:15] attributing it to an incident involving sitting on the toilet seat improperly. The case
[25:22] had devolved into a he said, she said situation riddled with conflicting accounts.
[25:27] According to Stephanie, on the ninth of May, she left the apartment to
[25:30] run an errand at the store. Upon her return, Nathan informed her that
[25:36] Ethan was dead in his bedroom. Once again, Stephanie admitted to not seeking
[25:41] help. This time, her reluctance was driven by Nathan's assertion that he would
[25:45] face imprisonment due to the horrendous injuries inflicted on Ethan. Collaboratively, the couple
[25:52] devised a plan to dispose of Ethan's body and misleat detectives. Nathan grabbed a
[25:59] hammer and repeatedly struck Ethan's face to disfigure him and knock out his teeth.
[26:03] Simultaneously, Stephanie obtained two kinds of lighter fluid, intending for Nathan to incenterate
[26:10] Ethan's remains before burying them. As Nathan explained to detectives, Stephanie was concerned
[26:17] about dental records. She's also starting to talk to us a lot more.
[26:22] Okay, we could be talking when we told you guys everything, Well,
[26:26] we believe you've told us a lot of things. In the autopsy today we
[26:30] spent we actually spent about four or four and a half hours with Ethan.
[26:36] It's five and a half, five and a half hours with Ethan this morning.
[26:38] We started about eight o'clock in the morning with him, and when they
[26:42] unwrapped him and spread him out, and a lot of the things that you
[26:48] told us about or not me personally, but I know that you'd relay to
[26:52] Vashan or some of the other detectives has showing about the hammer blows to the
[26:57] head, Watson Rocks, did you tell something that you had hit him with
[27:03] the hammer? The partner could make me to her if I want to talk
[27:10] to Stephanie, he can't, he kin. He kept forcing me about the
[27:12] hammer thing. The hammer actually broke when we got when we got up there.
[27:19] So how did the hammer break? Whether you're turning when you're trying to
[27:23] stuff soil because I haven't had had quite a few rocks in it, and
[27:29] Stephanie was worried about him about him into records. When Stephanie was interviewed about
[27:37] this, she claimed that she had nothing to do with the disposal of Athan's
[27:40] body, but she was presented with surveillance footage of her purchasing the lighter fluid.
[27:47] I'm gonna have to call bullshit on that answer. You know why I
[27:49] can't remember because Detective Erickson has been up to Eden and I told you he
[27:53] was going to go up there, I know, and I can't remember.
[27:57] And you know what he finds up there on videotape, Happy Go Lucky,
[28:03] you buying two slushies a Maverick and buying lighter fluid the King's Market across the
[28:08] street. You have told me and my daddy what you saw and flows on
[28:14] banking and he said, and he couldn't, You'd be burying me next.
[28:18] Okay, this is Detective Erickson. He seen the video. Believe him.
[28:22] I totally believe him. So you were just being happy all by yourself with
[28:27] Nate already out of the car a mile or so away. I'm guessing I
[28:32] haven't been up there. He's up a trail, not even near you.
[28:37] He's all you had to do is flag down a sheriff's deputy or call nine
[28:40] to one to one and say, guess what, my husband's up this trail.
[28:42] He killed my son and he's burying him right now. That's all you
[28:47] had to do. Instead you're in buying slushies with a big smile on your
[28:48] face. Is try to you don't understand how he is. You tell me
[28:53] how much you loved Ethan to anyone that will tell you what I love my
[28:59] son. Okay, but you know your son's being buried in the mountains and
[29:03] your brand new husband's going to pour a lighter fluid on his body, because
[29:07] why else would you be buying lighter fluid for him, And he's going to
[29:12] you're gonna take it back to him. He's going to light your son's body
[29:17] on fire. And that's the mom that loves him so much. Right.
[29:22] Ethan's disfigured body was then stuffed into plastic garbage box. Nathan then drove out
[29:30] to Powder Mountain alone to bury Ethan. He then led Stephanie to the grave
[29:34] so that she could say her last goodbyes. The couple then returned home and
[29:40] continued life as though nothing had happened. Nathan tax Stephanie, that's same day,
[29:45] baby. Can you get antioxidant vitamins please? That would be great.
[29:49] I can't wait to take you to Happy Sumu memories. Love you. There
[29:55] were a handful of other sectually charged tax messages following which the couple clear the
[30:00] crime scene and then went out for a meal at a local restaurant. The
[30:04] next day, they reported Ethan missing. After the arrest of Stephanie and Nathan,
[30:08] detectives discovered that Stephanie's cell phone contained photographs and videos of Ethan's worsening condition
[30:15] beginning more than a week before he was found dead. They said that the
[30:19] injuries resulted from Nathan engaging in a systematic and progressively more violent pattern of abuse
[30:26] towards Ethan. In one chilling video, Ethan was wearing pajamas. He turned
[30:32] to the camera and said, I'm having fun with Nathan. He's not scary
[30:36] anymore. In the video, Ethan's cheeks are red and swollen. Ethan then
[30:41] repeatedly asked Ethan whether he wanted to stay in Utah or returned to Virginia.
[30:48] A crying Ethan then replied, my mom my, mom My mom. In
[30:53] another recording, Ethan looked bruised as Nathan said to him, tell your daddy
[30:59] how much you don't like him. Ethan quietly responded, I don't like you.
[31:06] In text messages detectives covered from the couple's cell phones, Nathan had written,
[31:11] I told you we had a pitbull on our hands, but they learn.
[31:17] Stephanie replied, just like mommy lull. Nathan then responded, I told
[31:22] you we had to break his ego. And break his ego they certainly did.
[31:29] A couple of days after this text message conversation, Stephanie wrote, he
[31:33] is broke, that's for sure. The revelation of the horrific abuse that Ethan
[31:41] had endured we heavily on his loved ones, particularly his father, who had
[31:45] never wanted to send him to Stephanie for the summer. He emotionally expressed he
[31:52] was a great boy, and even if he was a bad boy, he
[31:56] didn't deserve this. Nobody deserves this, but he was just a good,
[32:00] sweet boy. This disturbing situation raised questions about why Stephanie had been granted custody
[32:07] of Ethan for this summer, especially when Joe had previously voiced his concerns.
[32:14] It came to light that the custody agreement had been approved by Judge Morris Smith,
[32:17] who admitted that she had not thoroughly reviewed Joe's initial petition Expressing apprehensions about
[32:23] Stephanie's suitability as a parent, Judge Smith commented he should absolutely not blame himself
[32:30] at all. No parent should ever blame themselves for the unpredictable failures of another
[32:36] parent. According to Judge Smith, no arguments had been made in court regarding
[32:40] the possibility that Ethan would be in danger in Utah. She stated, sometimes
[32:46] both parties come to court to get their agreement approved and to get the divorce
[32:51] decree that incorporates the marital agreement, but there was no discussion about what was
[32:55] in that agreement other than some of the financial assets, and usually these cases
[33:01] last less than ten minutes. In fact, this wasn't the first time that
[33:06] Nathan had faced accusations of abuse. Prior to Marie and Stephanie, he'd been
[33:10] married to another woman named Jennifer Freeman, who described her ex husband as mentally
[33:15] unstable, violent, and exhibiting multiple personalities, including one prone to extreme anger.
[33:22] When criticized during their divorce, she expressed fear for her life and the
[33:27] safety of their six year old daughter. Just a month before Stephanie and Nathan
[33:31] began dating, Nathan had left a profanity laced voicemail to Jennifer which said,
[33:38] I only wish now that I could fucking take you out of her life.
[33:43] I'm going to do every fucking thing possible within my power to take you the
[33:46] fuck out of her life. I don't give a fuck if I got to
[33:51] spend the rest of my fucking life in prison. Fuck you, I'm coming
[33:54] after your fucking throat. He had also made threats to kill Jennifer's bad boyfriend
[34:00] Mike, before warning You'll be next in line. Nathan and Jennifer had divorced
[34:06] back in August of two thousand and eight, and Jennifer had sought a permanent
[34:08] restraining order against him. As per the court documents, the wife has been
[34:15] the victim of domestic violence. The husband has a felony criminal history for drug
[34:20] related criminal activity, and has for years been diagnosed and traded for multiple personality
[34:25] disorders. The night following the discovery of Ethan's lifeless body, around one hundred
[34:31] people assembled for a candlelight vigil outside his former home. Within the gathering,
[34:37] conversations flowed as people expressed their wishes for Ethan to have found solace in a
[34:43] better place. Some attendees voiced their hope that Ethan's tragic death would serve as
[34:47] a stark reminder of the importance of neighbors actively monitoring the well being of children.
[34:54] Barbara Gough, who lived nearby, shared her prospective steering, I'm a
[35:00] mom too. I just can't imagine, not in a million years, would
[35:04] I let someone hurt my kids. The location of the candlelight vigil had transformed
[35:09] into an impromptu memorial for Ethan, growing with each passing hour. It adorned
[35:15] itself with stuffed animals, flowers, candles, balloons, and even a happy
[35:21] meal signed by the Leyton MacDonald's staff. Many cards, scribbled in the handwriting
[35:25] of neighborhood children who had not yet had the chance to meet their new neighbor
[35:30] before his tragic death, carried messages such as I'm sorry You're gone. In
[35:37] addition to the candlelight vigil, in the growing memorial. Several Facebook pages sprung
[35:40] up in memory of Ethan, resonating with people around the world as they grappled
[35:45] with the heart wrenching loss. The community sought ways to provide support for Ethan's
[35:52] graving family and to others in need. Valerie Lingle, a general manager at
[35:57] the Iceberg Ice Cream Shop ORCS, treated a Teddy Bear drive with the intention
[36:01] of collecting Teddy Bears for police officers and firefighters to offer to children in distressing
[36:07] situations. She stressed the importance of taking action, starting, I really want
[36:14] people to stop and think about Ethan's death. People need to take action.
[36:20] To alleviate the financial burden, A memorial fund was established to assist Athan's family
[36:25] in covering feneral expenses and facilitating the transportation of his body back to his father.
[36:37] On May the fifteenth, the community was deeply disturbed when the district attorney
[36:40] announced that there was insufficient evidence at that moment to charge Stephanie and Nathan with
[36:46] murder. However, this did not signify the changes were not forthcoming, as
[36:52] District Attorney Troy Rawlings emphasized, make no mistake, we plan to file charges.
[37:00] We don't want to make any mistakes in our charging decision. The couple
[37:04] remained in custody on other charges, which provided a measure of relief to the
[37:07] community. The delay in filing murder charges was primarily due to depending autopsy report
[37:14] for Ethan. District Attorney rulings clarified, before we decide on what is the
[37:20] appropriate and most serious charge we can credibly file, we need to understand the
[37:23] cause of death. While the legal proceedings unfolded, Ethan's body was transported to
[37:30] Virginia. His father, Joe, spoke to the media and expressed his understanding
[37:35] of the delay in filing charges. He asserted, I don't want any mistakes
[37:39] to be made. I don't want them getting out of this in any sort
[37:43] of way. They need to pay for taking my son away from me.
[37:47] He also indicated his full supportive prosecutors chose to pursue the death penalty. Ethan's
[37:54] funeral took place on the nineteenth of May at the Grundy Funeral Home Chapel.
[38:00] His casket, adorned in blue, was wheeled into the chapel surrounded by photographs
[38:05] chronicling his short life. As mourner settled into the pews of video montage captured
[38:09] happier moments from Ethan's life, including hiking, fishing, and days out with
[38:15] his father. Minister Mike Rife presided over the service, leading it nearly two
[38:21] hundred mourners into prayer. He poignantly remarked, you know, our hearts are
[38:27] in a million pieces, but there's no doubt in my mind you can put
[38:30] together all these hearts. During the funeral, Joe spoke, chosing to focus
[38:36] on the joyful memories of Athan's life rather than dwelling on the tragic circumstances of
[38:40] his death. He stated, you never realize how many good people are out
[38:46] there until something bad happens. Minister Rife then told the mourners that if Ethan
[38:52] were here, he would tell everybody that life is precious and do not take
[38:57] it for granted. He stated, he'd say God is in control and I'm
[39:01] okay, I'm safe. Before concluding the service, attendees were given blue and
[39:07] yellow ribbons as symbols to raise awareness about child abuse. Following the service,
[39:14] Ethan was laid to rest at Clinch Valley Memorial Cemetery. With Ethan's burial complete,
[39:21] his loved ones and the community engaged in discussions about how to prevent such
[39:24] a tragedy from recurring. They contemplated the creation of the federal law that would
[39:30] establish due process for parents who had abandoned their children and sought to regain custody
[39:36] in visitation rites. They proposed naming this law Ethan's Law, in memory of
[39:40] Ethan, with the objective of preventing judges and officials from easily returning custody to
[39:45] parents who had abandoned their children, as was the case with Stephanie. A
[39:52] petition advocating for Ethan's Law garnered thousands of signatures in Utah, emphasizing the urgent
[39:58] need for reform. In an effort to raise awareness about child abuse and honor
[40:02] Ethan's memory, hundreds of individuals participated in a ten mile walk on the twenty
[40:07] second of May. The walk commenced at the apartment where Ethan tragically lost his
[40:14] life and then continued to the day of his County Justice center. Calvin Kin,
[40:20] a local father of three, remarked, this is all too little and
[40:22] way too late, but maybe this is the bit of good that can be
[40:25] had from this whole sorry mess. It's the kind of thing you can't make
[40:30] sense of, and you don't want to because you don't want to believe anyone
[40:34] could do something like that to a child. Meanwhile, Stephanie and Nathan remained
[40:38] incarcerated, and media outlets sought interviews with them. Towards the end of the
[40:45] month. Stephanie responded to one such request from a b C with a mocking
[40:50] tone, writing ha ha ha, I've invoked my right to remain silent,
[40:54] or didn't my attorney already say that this letter did nothing to bolster Stephanie's case
[41:01] and only portrayed her as unremorseful. Just the day after receiving the letter,
[41:07] Georges were finally filed against both Stephanie and Nathan. They faced charges of aggravated
[41:14] murder, child abuse, obstruction of justice, and abuse or desecration of a
[41:19] body, with all charges classified as felonies. As per the court documents,
[41:27] the criminal acts included beatings, burning, drugging, isolating, malnourishing, leaving
[41:32] the child alone and unattended while suffering, and refusing to seek vital life sustaining
[41:38] medical attention. Shortly after the charges were officially filed, Stephanie asserted that she
[41:45] had been coersed into marrying Nathan and expressed her desire to have the marriage annulled.
[41:52] In a court petition, she wrote that her involvement in the marriage was
[41:54] not voluntary and was the result of product of physical dress by Nathan. These
[42:00] claims sharply contradicted her previous online expressions of Nathan as her soulmate and the love
[42:06] of her life before her arrest. Joe speculated that Stephanie might be seeking the
[42:10] annullnment to share the last surname as Ethan, and added, I would be
[42:15] real surprised if a judge accepts that. He further commented, she looks like
[42:22] a complete idiot, because she's the one who set that website up and said
[42:24] all those things about how in love with Nathan she was. After the annunment
[42:30] request, Stephanie and Nathan appeared in court for a hearing related to their charges.
[42:35] During the proceedings, prosecutors revealed that they were still deliberating whether to pursue
[42:38] the death penalty against the couple if they were convicted. In a surprising turn
[42:45] of events, as Nathan stood in the holding area before entering the courtroom,
[42:50] he shouted, I love you, Stephanie, indicating his awareness of her attempt
[42:53] to annul their marriage. Additionally, it was announced that Stephanie and Nathan would
[42:59] be tried separately. Following the hearing, the couple returned to jail, and
[43:02] ABC four released a series of letters that Stephanie had penned from behind bars.
[43:08] In her correspondence, she claimed ignorance about Nathan disfiguring Ethan before burying him.
[43:15] She admitted to purchasing lighter fluid, but asserted it was intended for the grill.
[43:21] Stephanie also referred to Ethan as Mommy's little man and expressed a bleak outlook
[43:27] on life. Jill responded to the letters and branded Stephanie as a bad,
[43:30] pathological liar. He stated if she wanted to trade places with Ethan, she
[43:37] should have. Stephanie knew that Ethan needed medical attention, but didn't do anything
[43:42] about it. Stephanie then engaged in a jail house phone call with a reporter
[43:46] from ABC four, during which she asserted that Ethan's death was an accident,
[43:52] despite the evident signs of torture, starvation, and a denial of medical attention.
[43:58] She stated, as far as what happened with Ethan, I can't get
[44:01] into that, but as far as I'm concerned. I thought he'd always stop.
[44:06] She said she didn't believe that Nathan intended on killing Ethan, but the
[44:09] things just got out of control. Meanwhile, the annoyment case was proceeding,
[44:15] but when Stephanie was informed that the case wouldn't be sealed, she decided to
[44:19] drop it. There was a lot of legal back and forth over the next
[44:23] year. In July twenty twelve, Nathan pleaded not guilty to Ethan's murder.
[44:30] Prosecutors then announced that they'd be seeking the death penalty for him if convicted.
[44:35] Preliminary hearing for Nathan was held in March the following year. During the hearing,
[44:39] it was revealed that Ethan had died from scalding, blunt trauma, aspiration,
[44:45] pneumonia, dehydration, and over medication. Prosecutor David Cole said that Nathan
[44:51] was responsible and that his reckless indifference to human life had caused Ethan's death.
[44:57] Doctor David Andronak testified during the p pliminary hearing that the concentration of xanax and
[45:02] benadryl found in Ethan's body were at adult levels, but they were not the
[45:07] sole cause of his death. He stated, it's a whole picture in considering
[45:12] how Ethan might have died. Some of the drugs that were found in Ethan's
[45:15] system were Nathan's prescription drugs. Ethan had suffered burns on seventeen point five percent
[45:22] of his body, and according to doctor Jeffrey Sapfel, these burns would have
[45:27] caused a tremendous amount of pain. The burns were to the lower half of
[45:30] Ethan's body, and some skin was burned so severely that it had blistered and
[45:36] fallen off. They were so severe, in fact, that they would have
[45:39] required skin grafting. Nathan was ordered to stand trial, but before then,
[45:45] his defense team challenged the legality of Shelby's law. According to this law,
[45:51] if a child dies any time after an act of abuse, prosecutors could seek
[45:54] the death penalty. The judge ultimately decided that the death penalty could be applied
[45:59] to the case. However, in February of two thousand and fourteen, Nathan
[46:04] changed his play and instead he pleaded guilty to the murder of Ethan. He
[46:08] pleaded guilty but mentally ill in order to avoid the death penalty. In exchange
[46:14] for the play, he was going to be facing a sentence of twenty five
[46:16] years to life in prison. Nathan appeared in court where he made this statement,
[46:23] reckless indifference was my state of mind in two thousand and nine, in
[46:27] two thousand and ten, I was reckless and indifferent in that time of my
[46:31] life, and in the end, it was my reckless behavior and indifference to
[46:35] life that Ethan got caught up in. I'm accountable for my actions. That
[46:40] boyd died on my watch, and I'm horribly sorry. Joe was in court
[46:45] to see Nathan plead guilty to the murder of his son. Afterwards, he
[46:50] went out to the area where his son's body had been found. He stated,
[46:54] it was hard. I've seen all the pictures, but I knew I
[46:58] wanted to go up there and see where they found him at. Part of
[47:01] it was trying to get some closure, but I guess there never will be.
[47:07] He said that the plea deal wasn't what he was hoping for, but
[47:09] said he believed it was the most that they could get. He commented,
[47:15] I don't even think if we went to trial and he got the death penalty,
[47:17] it still wouldn't be justice for what he did. He took my son.
[47:22] There's no way to get him back. There's no justice at all.
[47:28] In November, Stephanie appeared in court where she too pleaded guilty to the murder
[47:30] of Ethan. She was sentenced to at least twenty years in prison. During
[47:37] the sentencing, Stephanie essentially blamed her actions on prescription medication. My selfish behavior
[47:44] is the reason I am staying for the day. He pleaded guilty to these
[47:47] charges. Ethan is it is a child, and I will carry his desk
[47:53] as long as I live. Like kitty bird, It's going to get heavier.
[48:00] The difference thing. I can't make it go away because it's part of
[48:04] who I am now eat Its death under these circumstances at times has too much
[48:10] to bear. But the fact is I am entirely responsible because I'm his mommy.
[48:19] I failed to take care of it properly, because I couldn't even to
[48:22] take care of myself my selfishness and failures. There comes punking Dutch, but
[48:30] there's no changing the fact that I'm the one responsible. Aside from selfishness,
[48:37] my addiction to prescription medications tell you to get help pave the way for this.
[48:44] I recognize I fail to recognize the science, but rather I just out
[48:47] down and ignore them doing what I always wanted to do. Like always,
[48:53] my selfishness wouldn't let me accept the fact that I had problems, let alone
[49:05] guilty today, because I'm just that I charged obviously dedication to the point I
[49:10] was unable to make some choices and decisions, this causing to be reckless and
[49:15] it different my baby's life. Her defense team had tried to suggest that after
[49:21] Ethan was found dead, Stephanie took prescription medication and passed out and didn't awake
[49:25] until after Ethan was buried. This, however, was a blatant lie.
[49:30] She was picked up on surveillance purchasing the lighter fluid that was found in Ethan's
[49:35] grave. Even with the guilty play and all of the evidence, Stephanie was
[49:39] still trying to claim innocence. After the sentencing, Davis County Attorney Troy Rowlins
[49:47] wrote a letter to the Utah Board of Pardons and Parole in which he said
[49:52] that Stephanie should never be released from prison. He wrote, Ethan stays he
[49:57] died because his mother, Stephanie Sloop, was fixated on herself. She cared
[50:01] about her own lifestyle a lot. Tragically, Stephanie did not care much about
[50:07] the life of her young son. After Ethan was dead, the Sloop celebrated
[50:12] their own lives by dining at favorite restaurants. For the remainder of her life,
[50:16] Factual culpability and justice demand that Stephanie Sloop should only dine in the Utah
[50:22] State a prison. Both Nathan and Stephanie Sloop can seek parole from two thousand
[50:29] and fifty five onwards. Numerous safeguards exist to ensure the well being of children,
[50:37] but what happens when one of these protective systems fails. Joe Stacey had
[50:42] voiced apprehensions regarding his son Ethan, spending the summer with his mother. Despite
[50:47] these reservations, Ethan was dispatched to Utah, where he would tragically meet his
[50:52] fate in the very apartment he was sent to. Well Bestie's that visit for
[51:17] this episode of Morbidology. So ways, thank you so so much for listening,
[51:22] And I'd like to say a massive thank you to my newest supporters of
[51:25] Banpatreon, Emma and Jane. Orphanology is just a one woman team, so
[51:30] the support of competre and seriously goes such a long way, and I am
[51:35] eternally grateful Please do check it out if you want boonus episodes that are on
[51:38] the regular podcast platforms add free in early please episodes behind the scenes, and
[51:45] some cool merch. Remember to check us out at morbidology dot com for more
[51:50] information about this episode and to read or three crime articles. Until next time,
[51:53] take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week.
[52:00] Just to bust, just to put a pain the f

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
