# 214: Father Ed Hinds

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 24 Jul 2023, 58 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/55991725/morbidology_214_father_ed_hinds_ad_free_1.mp3

On 23 October, 2009, the small town of Chatham, New Jersey, gathered at St. Patrick’s Church. They expected to see the priest, but they were met with an eerie silence. The search for the missing priest would reveal that darkness can lurk in even the most unexpected of places and sometimes, wolves can conceal themselves in sheep’s clothing. SPONSORS - 4Patriots: Thank you to 4Patriots for sponsoring this episode! With hurricane season fast approaching, it’s time to prepare with 4Patriot’s emergency food packages. Use the code “MORBIDOLOGY” for 10% off: https://4patriots.com/ SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-214-father-edward-hinds PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] Nine one one. Where is your emergency? I think Patrick's directory? Yes,
[0:37] what's the problem over there? Our pastor sel father edsel okay in the
[0:42] rectory? In the rectory, Yeah, okay. On the twenty third of
[0:56] October two thousand and nine, the small town of Chatham, New Jersey gathered
[1:00] at Saintpatrick's Church. They expected to see the priest, but they were met
[1:04] with an eerie silence. The search for the missing priest would reveal that darkness
[1:10] can lurk in even the most unexpected of places, and sometimes wolves can conceal
[1:15] themselves in sheep's clothing. Edward Hines was born in Chatham, New Jersey,
[1:33] where he attended Morris Town High School, followed by Selton Hall University. Chartham
[1:38] is known as a New York bedroom community, boasting of around ten thousand residents
[1:42] with the medium income of one hundred and thirty two thousand dollars. It's certainly
[1:47] a desirable place to raise a family, and as Edward grew he saw no
[1:52] reason to leave the town he had grown to love. His deep faith led
[1:56] him to enter the seminary at just twenty one years old, where he was
[2:00] sent by the diocese to study theology in the Heart of Rome. It was
[2:04] there that he was ordained as a priest on the twenty seventh of June nineteen
[2:07] seventy four at the youthful age of twenty five, quickly becoming known as Father
[2:14] Ed to the community. For four years, he served as a pastoral assistant
[2:19] at Saint Patrick's Church before being appointed as the Vice Chancellor of the Diocese of
[2:24] Patterson and Secretary to Bishop Frank Rodimer, where he served until nineteen eighty nine.
[2:30] During his tenure, he also served as a dedicated pastor to the faithful
[2:35] of Saint Michael Church in net Coong and Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church in
[2:40] Boonton. While at Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church, Father Ed oversaw various
[2:46] capital improvements that were undertaken for the anniversary in nineteen ninety seven. This included
[2:52] roof repairs, new stained glass doorways, new masonry and landscaping. As Kenneth
[2:58] Latch, a retired priest and close friend of Father Ed, said, Ed
[3:02] was a quiet man, genuinely kind and a priest in the best sense of
[3:07] the world. He was an excellent spiritual leader. He sincerely wanted to be
[3:13] the best pastor he could to all people. Then, in two thousand and
[3:17] three, father Ed returned to Saint Patrick's Church where he was appointed as the
[3:22] pastor. Saint Patrick's is a bustling parish with a congregation of approximately sixteen hundred
[3:29] devoted parishioners. As part of his new role, he moved into the two
[3:32] story church rectory where he resided alone. Described by many as a man of
[3:38] exceptional character, father Ed was widely admired for his unwathering faith and compassionate nature.
[3:46] Those who knew him spoke of his gentle spirit, keen insight, and
[3:50] warm personality. His generosity and selflessness were renowned throughout the community, and he
[3:55] never hesitated to lend a helping hand to those in need. With his deep
[4:01] faith and bondless compassion, Father Ed was well suited to his rule as a
[4:05] priest, and he was deeply committed to serving the spiritual needs of his congregation.
[4:11] He was beloved by his parishioners, who looked up to him as a
[4:14] leader and a friend. Despite the demands of his pastoral duties, Father always
[4:18] made time for those in his community, offering comfort, guidance and support to
[4:24] anybody who needed it. Father Ed was also a man of action, always
[4:30] striving to improve the church and ensure that his operations ran smoothly. He wasted
[4:35] no time in launching a comprehensive effort to identify areas that could benefit from upgrades.
[4:42] To this end, he distributed surveys among the church community, seeking their
[4:46] input on everything from outreach and ministry programs to upkeep of the church itself.
[4:54] The surveys were meticulously crafted with detailed questions designed to elicit thoughtful, actionable feedback.
[5:01] Father Ed poured over each response, carefully considering the insights offered by parishioners
[5:08] from all walks of life. As he sifted through the survey results, father
[5:13] Ed became increasingly concerned about the church's financial situation. It quickly became apparent that
[5:18] many parishioners shared these worries, and he knew that he needed to take action.
[5:25] Regrettably, this meant making some difficult decisions, including letting go of three
[5:30] church employees. One survey question stood out in particular, have we seen a
[5:38] detailed budget reviewing of costs of staff, budget of ministries, etc. This
[5:45] question struck a chord with father Ed, reminding him of the importance of careful
[5:49] financial planning in the church. Despite the challenges ahead, he was determined to
[5:55] steer the church towards a brighter future, one that was rooted in financial stability
[6:00] and responsible stewardship. Although Sampadrick serves a wealthy community, father Ed ran several
[6:08] outreach programs to help the homeless in other areas. His church had a reputation
[6:14] as a beacon for those in need. That didn't just mean homeless people,
[6:18] that those short of cash. Father Ed was always on hand to provide cash
[6:23] for gasoline or whatever else was needed. As Reverend Owen Morn from Saint Rose
[6:29] said, people knock on the door earlier at night all the time. It's
[6:33] up to the person to decide whether to open the door and help them out,
[6:38] and he was always helping people. Father Ed also served as a chaplain
[6:44] for the local fire department, and in its free time, he loved to
[6:47] go golfing. He was known for a golf shot that was straight and defective.
[6:54] In two thousand and nine, sixty one year old father Ed welcomed somebody
[6:58] else into the fold. It was a cocker spaniel who he named Ginger.
[7:03] She lived in the rectory with father Ed providing companionship and comfort, and he
[7:10] took great pleasure walking her around the neighborhoods several times a day. This always
[7:15] included a late night walk around nine p m. Before bed. That year,
[7:19] life was looking good for father Ed. He was looking forward to an
[7:25] upcoming trip in two thousand and ten to Room where he was going to visit
[7:29] classmates from his seminar days at the Pontefactol North American College, a school close
[7:34] to the Vatican for highly regarded seminarians. Arling Conte, a long time Franz,
[7:41] stated he was an exceptional, exceptional ma'am. He didn't offend anybody.
[7:46] He didn't take on issues, he didn't use the pulpit to take on anything
[7:50] political. A lot of the time he'd talk and he'd say, well,
[7:57] where's God in this? That's the kind of man he was. On Friday,
[8:28] the twenty third of October two thousand and nine, congregants at Saint Patrick's
[8:33] Church arrived for their Mass service. Yet Am came and went and father Ed
[8:39] was a no shoe. The congregants were perplexed. Father Ed had never been
[8:46] late for a service, not wanting the congregation to wait any longer. A
[8:50] church deacon and Joseph Feliciano, the church's janitor, decided to go and search
[8:56] for father Ed. They entered the directory kitchen, where their eyes were immediately
[9:01] transfixed to the pools of blood on the floor. There was blood on the
[9:07] kitchen counter, and nearby the telephone had been ripped from the wall. Their
[9:11] eyes followed the blood to find the source of it. On the floor,
[9:16] they found father Ed crumpled in a ball. He was fully outfitted in formal
[9:22] black garb, which was stained with blood. Ginger was sitting close to father
[9:28] Ed's body, unharmed but under a serious amount of stress. Josaf Feliciano crouched
[9:35] down beside father Ed and began attempting life saving measures in the form of compressions.
[9:41] He turned to the deacon and solemnly stated, there's nothing we can do.
[9:48] Father Ed was far beyond saving. He had been stabbed a total of
[9:52] forty four times on the neck, face and torso, and even the back
[9:56] of his head. They were to hands of wounds to his hands and bruises
[10:01] to his face, indicating that he had fought fiercely for his life. But
[10:05] to new Aveal at eight o three am, just three minutes after mass should
[10:09] have begun, and nine one one call came into police to report the incident.
[10:15] Although the caller wasn't yet aware that father Ed had been stopped, he
[10:20] thought that he had simply fallen. Nine one one, where's your emergency?
[10:33] And Chatham. We're in Chatham Saints Church, Saint Patrick's Church. What's the
[10:37] problem that our priest has fallen and looks like he's unconscious? Okay, and
[10:45] we're in Where is he located at the church? Washington? He's in the
[10:50] rectory in the rectory, okay, So go in from the Washington amity side.
[10:54] That's fine, Okay. Is someone else there? Yeah? Okay,
[10:58] is it the door open? The door will be Tell him to go into
[11:03] the rect three side door of off Washington. I'm going to put you through
[11:07] this to the medics for pre arrival. The police fell he's unconscious. Hold
[11:13] on wph B two three zero. A Chatam emergency is cogently scoring into the
[11:35] borough eighty five Washington Avenue, Saint Patrick's Church in the rest three off of
[11:41] Washington Avenue. Mail fall is unconscious. Wall the borough riak check that will
[11:48] the township break WPGB two three zero, Chatham emergency is clad respawning into the
[11:54] borough eighty five Washington Avenue directory of Saint Patrick's Church, going the side door.
[12:01] Now fu is uncontrick well the count brig. I'm eight six Timber four
[12:05] three eight. Sir Deacon Joseph was Nasky came into the church and told all
[12:13] of the parishioners that service was not going to be held and the father Ed
[12:18] had an accident, and he asked everybody to pray for him. By the
[12:24] stricken lurk on the deacon's face, however, many could tell that something was
[12:28] seriously wrong. Meanwhile, a second phone call came into police from another member
[12:35] of the church. Nine one one, Where is your emergency at Saint Patrick's
[12:39] Rectory? I think we have somebody on the other line. N one one,
[12:41] Okay, what's the problem over there? Oh? Hello, Yes,
[12:48] what's the problem over there? Our pastor self father Ed Sky in the rectory
[12:52] in the rectory, yeah, okay, thanks. Investigators immediately descended on the
[12:58] scene. It took them just seconds to take in the carnage. Before them,
[13:03] father Ed was lying in the middle of the kitchen floor. He was
[13:07] on his back with his eyes closed. There were knife wounds mostly to the
[13:13] chest area, and he was covered in blood. Detective Kelly Zenawiks recalled of
[13:18] the scene, what stood out was that a pedestal based on the table clearly
[13:24] had blood on it, and quite a lot of blood was transferred onto the
[13:26] walls. It appeared as though someone was underneath the table bleeding through their clothing.
[13:33] The brutal murder had a profound impact on the small, peaceful town,
[13:37] where violent crimes were a rare occurrence. The community was shaken to its core,
[13:43] and a pervasive sense of fear gripped streets. The possibility of a sadistic
[13:48] killer on the loose loomed over the town, casting a shadow of uncertainty over
[13:54] daily life. Parents removed their children from the parish school as it went in
[14:00] to lockdown. For johnet Gilmartin, who lived just across the street from the
[14:03] crime scene, the fear was particularly acute. She commented in the media that
[14:09] she couldn't help but wonder if the killer had been lurking in the area when
[14:13] she had been outside with her daughter and grandson earlier that morning. John had
[14:18] expressed the community's sense of horror, staring it's frightening to think that the person
[14:24] who did this thing might have been running across the street this morning when my
[14:28] daughter was stopping outside to take my grandson to school. Investigators closed several roads
[14:35] around the Saint Patrick's campus and began their investigation. Prosecutor Robert Byankee warned the
[14:43] community to remain vigilant that there was a killer on the loose. Chada Mayor
[14:48] Nelson Vaughan steated, this is almost unbelievable. I've lived here since nineteen fifty
[14:56] and this is the second homicide in town I know of. It's a peaceful,
[15:01] quiet and framly town. Meanwhile, father Ed's body was transported to the
[15:05] Medical Examiner's office, where it was found that he had sustained forty four separate
[15:09] stab wounds. Six wounds were fatal, including one to the neck that was
[15:16] deep enough it fractured the windpipe. Five other wounds to his chest broke ribs
[15:20] and perforated the diaphram. The injuries were so severe that more than a third
[15:26] of father Ed's blood was not in a blood vessel. The pathologist also noted
[15:31] that blood spotter indicated that both father Ed and his killer were moving as the
[15:37] attack unfolded. Investigators were keen to identify a suspect in the murder, but
[15:43] they, the same as everybody else, were baffled. Father Ed did not
[15:48] have an enemy in the world. Bishop Arthur sarah Telli of the diocese if
[15:54] Patterson stated, this makes no sense. There would be no reason for anybody
[15:58] to do this. In fact, all throughout father Ed's life and career,
[16:03] he had never received one complaint nor one disciplinary action. Immediately, the first
[16:11] theory that crossed everyone's mind was that father Ed had been killed by somebody.
[16:15] He had opened up his arms too during their time of need. Prosecutor Bianche
[16:21] commented, maybe one of those individuals was involved. That kind of generosity is
[16:26] preyed upon. Investigators quickly began retracing father Ed's last known movements to try and
[16:34] establish exactly when he was killed. The night before his body was discovered,
[16:38] there had been a safety seminar held by police in the church. During the
[16:44] seminar, they fingerprinted and photographed young children. It was noted that father Ed
[16:48] wasn't present, which was extremely unusual anytime there was an event at the church.
[16:55] Father Ed would always make an appearance. As the hours continued, Toss,
[17:00] a makeshift memorial appeared at eighty five Washington Avenue. Members of the community
[17:04] brought along tokens of condolences, including candles and flowers. There were hand drawn
[17:11] cars from the children at the church's elementary school. While woman shar Nooner commented
[17:18] to the media how father Ed had visited her son every day after he was
[17:22] born and kept in the neo needle intensive care unit, her eyes welled with
[17:26] tears as she added he was a good man father. Owen by Moorn,
[17:33] the pastor at Saint Rose of Lyman Church in East Hanover, was appointed temporary
[17:37] spiritual leader of Saint Patrick's Church, and at eight am the next morning he
[17:42] officiated the first mass since father Ed's passing. The church's website was updated with
[17:48] the photograph of father Ed along with the poignant message we the Parish of Saint
[17:55] Patrick more in the tragic death of our beloved Pastor ed Hain. We pray
[18:00] for the repose of his soul. We pray for courage and strength during this
[18:04] sad and difficult time. As the investigation into the murder was underway, it
[18:11] was uncovered that a nine one one call had come into local police around five
[18:15] thirty pm the evening before father Ed's body was discovered. It was from a
[18:22] man who was struggling to speak. He said that he needed hell, but
[18:26] eighty five Washington Avenue the address of the church. Nine one one, Where's
[18:32] emergency? Washington Avenue? Hello, Hello, Hello. The phone call then
[18:48] went muffled before the line went dead. The operator called back and it went
[18:53] straight to voicemail. They called back a second time and somebody else picked up
[18:59] the phone and said that they didn't need help. In the background, however,
[19:03] another man's voice can be heard starting, yes we do. This is
[19:11] the state police who call nine on one. Do you have an emergency?
[19:17] Now? Oh well, thank you all right. Unfortunately, the call had
[19:22] come from a cell phone and it couldn't be traced. While the state had
[19:26] spent at least sixty million dollars on upgrades in the past five years, outdated
[19:30] phone technology still humbered emergency efforts. However, the caller had given eighty five
[19:37] Washington Avenue as the address for the emergency, which was the address of Saint
[19:42] Patrick's church. Investigators theorized that this first phone call was from father Ed during
[19:49] the assault that cost him his life. He speculated that when they called back,
[19:55] it was father Ed's killer who picked up and said that help wasn't needed.
[20:00] For reasons unknown, the nine one one operator didn't think to send help.
[20:03] Investigators were keen to see if there were any potential clues on father Ed's
[20:08] cell phone that could lead them to a potential suspect. They were curious to
[20:12] see if maybe had made an appointment to meet somebody that could shed some light
[20:17] on the circumstances surrounding his murder. However, after an exhaustive search at the
[20:22] rectory, father Ed's cell phone couldn't be found naturally, investigators assumed that his
[20:30] killer had stolen it and decided that they needed to track it down immediately.
[20:34] It led them to a home in Easton, Pennsylvania. They immediately descended on
[20:41] the home and pointed on the front door. They waited for a response,
[20:45] and after a tense few moments, a man opened up the front door.
[20:51] They recognized the man right away, standing less than one foot away from the
[21:11] investigators with sixty four year old jose Feliciano, the janitor at Sampatrick's Church who
[21:19] had fond father Ed's body. Feliciano immediately waived his miranda rights and made a
[21:26] full confession to Father Ed's murder. He told investigators that he and father Ed
[21:33] had gotten into an argument while at the rectory over the prospect of Feliciano losing
[21:37] his job. He claimed that after the argument, he turned away, but
[21:42] father Ed grabbed him. He alleged the discuffle ensued, during which he grabbed
[21:48] a knife and stopped father Ed repeatedly. Feliciano was arrasted and charged with murder
[21:55] on possession of a weapon. Is arrassed him as a massive shop to the
[22:00] entire community. It's like father Ed. He too, was a familiar face
[22:04] in the town. He had been working as custodian at the church since nineteen
[22:10] ninety two, and he and his family had at one stage lived in a
[22:12] house on the church's grounds. His son had graduated from the Catholic school associated
[22:19] with the church, and his daughter was currently enrolled there. He too,
[22:23] was described as a devoted Catholic and a dedicated family man who brought males to
[22:29] his neighbors whenever they were sick. One of them, Joshua Kaiser, said,
[22:33] you would think he was pushed to do it. It seemed that something
[22:37] would have happened to do that. In fact, some within the community even
[22:41] said that Feliciano was seen as a second father at many children in Saint Patrick's.
[22:48] Charlie Spencer, a longtime parishioner at the church, revealed to the public
[22:51] that Feliciano had been sick in recent months and he wondered whether something had snapped
[22:56] in his mind. The community would soon come to learn that Feliciano wasn't exactly
[23:03] who he said he was. As mentioned, he had begun working as custodian
[23:08] at Saint Patrick's Church back in nineteen ninety two. At the time of Father
[23:14] Ed's murder, he had been considering some staffing changes due to financial issues.
[23:18] On the chopping block was Feliciano. He and his wife, Marisol had been
[23:22] struggling financially. Both of them worked two jobs, but earlier in the year
[23:27] Feliciano had left his second job at electronics store. One of the neighborers of
[23:33] the couple were called. They had very long days. They would leave the
[23:37] house at five thirty a m. And wouldn't get back home until seven thirty
[23:41] or eight thirty at night. Father Ed had just recently performed a background check
[23:45] on Feliciano and learned that he hadn't arrest warrant in Philadelphia from nineteen eighty eight
[23:52] for indecent assault without consent, simple assault, and corruption of a miner.
[23:56] He had touched a woman seven year old daughter in an inappropriate manner. Since
[24:02] then, Feliciano had used fake names and fake identities for decades to hide his
[24:07] past. On the second of April nineteen eighty eight, he had been arrested,
[24:12] but he failed to appear for his hearing the following month, at which
[24:15] time a bench warrant was issued. He had adopted various aliases, including Carlos
[24:22] Feliciano and Jose Lobo, and had changed his date of birth and Social Security
[24:27] number several times. Father Ed had discovered that Feliciano's employment history lacked the necessary
[24:34] documentation to confirm that he had successfully passed a background check. He had never
[24:40] provided a fingerprint background check. The discovery was brought to father Ed's attention due
[24:45] to her recent diocesan push to ensure that all parishes and schools were in strict
[24:52] compliance with the policies surrounding criminal background checks for every single employee. Going back
[24:57] to nineteen eighty six, state laws mandated the public schools performed background checks on
[25:03] their staff. Three years later, private and religious institutions were granted access to
[25:08] government resources for the same purpose. Although it wasn't a requirement, all five
[25:15] Roman Catholic dioceses in the state implemented this measure immediately. The clergy sex abuse
[25:22] scandal that rocked the Catholic Church in two thousand and three led to change in
[25:26] policy. In addition to employees, volunteers were also mandated to undergo background checks.
[25:33] Kenneth Maliana, an attorney for the Patterson Diocese, said in March it
[25:37] just so happens. We re emphasized and redoubled our efforts to ensure that every
[25:42] single school, every single parish was compliant. My speculation is that perhaps the
[25:48] current issue had to do with that effort. Father Ed had used two different
[25:53] websites to research Feliciano's background and to pay for the services with his credit card.
[26:00] Upon making the ominous discovery, father Ed told the principle of Saint Patrick's
[26:03] Church, Marrying Hobby, that he would need to fire Feliciano. This was
[26:10] evidently what the argument of the church had been about. After killing father Ed,
[26:15] Feliciano attempted to clean up the crime scene, mopping up some blood with
[26:18] rags. It had been a frenzied attack in Feliciano's T shirt was stained with
[26:23] blood. He took it off and along with the rags, he tossed them
[26:27] into a black plastic bag. He then stole father Add's cellphone and waited for
[26:33] his wife and daughter to collect him. Following his shift, he disposed of
[26:37] the plastic bag and a garbage can in a park around fifty yards from his
[26:41] home. After Feliciano's confession, investigators found father Adds cellphone and the murder weapon
[26:48] inside his home. They then found a bloody T shirt and rags in the
[26:52] bin in the park. The following morning, around three hundred mourners gathered at
[27:18] Simpatrick's Church school for a memorial mass for father Ed. They arrived in small
[27:23] groups and took their seats to reminisce about father Ed. Joe Garrison, a
[27:30] parishioner, stated, for the leader of our church to be taken down this
[27:34] way, we just feel awful. Kenneth Lash had been handpicked by father Ed
[27:40] before his death to deliver his eulogy in the event of his death. Amongst
[27:45] themselves, the mourners spoke about father Ed and Feliciano. The regular Sunday service
[27:52] came on Sunday, and that service was led by Reverend Owen Morn, who
[27:57] stood in for father Ed. He said to the parishioners, father Ed would
[28:03] have forgiven Jose. He probably had forgiven him before he died. His comment
[28:08] was met by grumbles of displeasure. Meanwhile, investigators began looking into the nine
[28:15] one one call that a preceded father Ed's murder. The voices on the phone
[28:19] call had been identified as father Ed and Feluciano. Nine one one calls from
[28:26] cell phones are routinely rooted through headquarters in West Trenton. Captain Gerald Lewis announced
[28:32] his agency would be looking into whether one of his despatchers handled the call,
[28:37] and if so, they were going to investigate how it was handled. As
[28:41] the end of October approach, the community gathered ats Impatrick's Church to pay their
[28:45] respects to father Ed. The somber atmosphere was palpable as mourners filed into the
[28:52] church, their faces etched with grief. Father Ed's casket was brought in through
[28:57] a row of members of the fire department that stood guard outside. His casket
[29:03] was placed at the front of the church, and the service was led by
[29:07] Reverend Morn, who spoke passionately about Father Ed's life and work. He stated
[29:12] one of his attributes was that he was very kind with the second dying,
[29:18] preparing and counseling their families. Over a thousand mourners attended the viewing, a
[29:23] testament to Father Ed's legacy. The right of reception of the body marked the
[29:30] beginning of the ceremony as priests from all over Northern New Jersey paid their final
[29:34] respects. Reverend Martin McDonnell of Saint Anthony Parrish echoed the sentiments of many,
[29:41] speaking of Father Ed's deep love for its parishioners and fellow priests. Early the
[29:47] next month, stay at Police Lieutenant Gerald Lewis said that a preliminary investigation into
[29:52] the nine one one call the Father Ed had made concluded that the operator had
[29:56] followed proper procedure. The case was moving through the justice system when early the
[30:03] next year, it was announced that Reverend Robert Mitchell was taking over Father Ed's
[30:07] role at Saint Patrick's Church. He became known to the community as Father Bob
[30:14] and they welcomed him with open arms. Meanwhile, a grand jury ended of
[30:18] Feliciano on charges of murder, robbery, weapons offenses, and hindering apprehension.
[30:26] The grand jury also handed up a finding of aggravating factors, that the murder
[30:30] was outrageously vile, horrible, or inhuman, and that it involved torture or
[30:37] depravity of the mind. These findings could lead to a stricter sentence if Feliciano
[30:41] were convicted. As the congregation continued to mourn father ed, they were continuing
[30:48] to practice what they preached. Feliciano's daughter was still attending the church's elementary school,
[30:56] and his wife, Marisol, remained a member of the home and school
[30:59] parishes. Church trustee John Paullinin commented in the media, the parish community will
[31:06] be glad to know the process is moving forward. An indictment is an important
[31:11] step. We're glad to know the prosecutor is making this a priority so we
[31:15] can have some closure. He also said that everybody in the church community was
[31:21] trying to forgive and allowed Feliciano's family to remain at the church. That in
[31:26] March, Feliciano pleaded not guilty to all of the charges against him, while
[31:52] for Liciano had made a confession to father Ed's murder. As his trial date
[31:56] was approaching, it became apparent he was seeking a new defense. According to
[32:00] Feliciano, he had been having a four year sexual affair with father Ed.
[32:06] You know. I claimed that he told father Ed on the evening of his
[32:08] murder that he no longer wanted to be in the relationship. He then claimed
[32:14] that father Ed told him that if he didn't continue the relationship then he would
[32:17] be fired. During the confession, Feliciano had stated, I couldn't have a
[32:24] relationship with him anymore. I'm not gay. He further said that he stabbed
[32:30] father Ed a lot of times, before adding I felt so sorry for him.
[32:35] Feliciano then broked on in sobs, and through those sobs he stated,
[32:39] my poor wife. According to Feliciano, while he was a young boy,
[32:44] he was sexually abused a number of times by a priest in Brooklyn. He
[32:49] said that he had told father Ed about this five years earlier, and claimed
[32:52] that he was defensive, but also had done some counseling with father Ed.
[32:58] He said that Ronde year later, father Ed had come to him with the
[33:00] possibility of letting him go. He then added, and he started touching me
[33:07] all over. He started touching my privacy. Feliciano said that the investigators that
[33:14] he didn't like being touched by father Ed, but he had reminded him about
[33:19] his employment. He stated, then, before you knew it, he was
[33:23] having a relationship with me. The prosecution immediately countered this the thorough investigation into
[33:30] father Ed's murder had proved beyond to doubt that he had uncovered the truth about
[33:35] Feliciano ced he passed and was preparing to fire him. While past criminal history
[33:42] isn't always permitted as evidence in a trial, Assistant prosecutor John McNamara Junior argued
[33:47] that Feliciano's past lies we're at the heart of the murderer of father Ed.
[33:53] He also revealed that there hadn't been a shred of evidence to back up the
[33:57] claims of a love affair between the two men. Prosecutor mc namara wrote,
[34:01] the investigation into the defendant's criminal history is relevant to impeach his self serving claim
[34:07] that he had a homosexual relationship with the victim as the basis for stabbing the
[34:12] victim dozens of times. Feliciano's defense attorney, Neil Hamilton then claimed that Feliciano
[34:17] had made the confession while in the hospital psychiatric ward, and that he may
[34:22] have been effected by prescription drugs at the time. He said he was in
[34:27] the process of finding out what medication, if any, Feliciano was under at
[34:31] the time and whether it had any effect on his voluntary statement in which he
[34:36] confessed to the murder. As these issues were being ironed out and coured,
[34:40] a grand jury issued a revised indictment. It was essentially the same, but
[34:45] added a second coin of first degree robbery for the theft of father Ed's cell
[34:50] phone. In October, Feliciano was seeking a new defense, an insanity defense.
[34:57] Defense attorney Hamilton said that he was going to fall in notice have said
[35:00] defense for Feliciano, while in February the following year, it was announced that
[35:05] Feliciano was no longer pursuing an insanity defense. The defense then claimed that Feliciano
[35:10] had been tricked into believing that he would get favorable treatment if he told the
[35:15] truth about father Ed's murder to the investigators. Defense attorney Hamilton argued that Captain
[35:22] Jeoffrey Paul had made Feliciano feel so comfortable during his interview that he didn't want
[35:27] the captain to leave the room. He said that Captain Paul told Feliciano he
[35:31] had a relative at the hospital, but this wasn't true. He accused him
[35:37] of trying to gain a report with Feliciano. Captain Paul responded, I was
[35:43] talking to a killer. I didn't have a problem. Captain Paul was asked
[35:47] whether he told Feliciano his family would benefit if he told the truth, and
[35:52] he confirmed he told Feliciano he would make an effort to ensure his daughter could
[35:57] remain at the school, which she did. The judge ultimately ruled that the
[36:01] confession could be entered into evidence in the upcoming murder trial. It was scheduled
[36:07] for the middle of two thousand and eleven, but during a pre trial hearing,
[36:10] Feliciano experienced dizziness, chest palpitations, and shortness of breath. After he
[36:17] left the court room, he fell out of his wheel chair and was transported
[36:21] to hospital, pushing the trial back. In July of two thousand and eleven,
[36:24] a pleadial was offered to Feliciano in exchange for a guilty plead to the
[36:30] murder and robbery prosecutors would be seeking a sentence of thirty years to life in
[36:35] prison. He rejected the deal and jury selection for the upcoming trial began.
[36:40] While this was ongoing, investigators uncovered some more disturbing information about Feliciano's background.
[36:47] It was uncovered that he had impregnated his eleven year old step daughter years earlier.
[36:52] The prosecution revealed that if Feliciano were to take the witness stand, they
[36:57] would question him on this as well as questioned him on the indecent assoul charge
[37:01] against the seven year old girl. On the twentieth of October twenty eleven,
[37:27] the courtroom was filled with an air of anticipation as the jury was selected and
[37:30] the trial was ready to begin. Prosecutor Robert Bianchi stepped forward to deliver his
[37:37] opening statements. He painted a vivid picture of Feliciano as a cold and calculated
[37:43] liar who had meticulously planned the murder and cover up. His voice bellowed through
[37:49] the courtroom as he detailed the lengths that Feliciano had gone to carry out the
[37:52] crime, including stealing Father Ed's cell phone and ripping the rectory telephone from the
[37:59] wall. He then revealed a shocking piece of evidence to back up the claims
[38:04] that father Ed was firing Feliciano. He had written jose last day beside the
[38:10] date October twenty third in his calendar. He then played a Lloyd the nine
[38:15] one one call that father had made, followed by the callback phone call.
[38:20] He then stated, that's a man who is deceiving, covering up his crime,
[38:25] a liar, a fabricator that doesn't care he's murdering another human being.
[38:32] The defense team, however, had a different story to tell. They claimed
[38:37] that Feliciano had acted under immense pressure against alleged threats from father Ed, ultimately
[38:44] causing him to snap. Defense attorney Hamilton didn't mention explicitly that the allegations of
[38:50] the affair that Feliciano had made, but defense attorney Hamilton alluded to the high
[38:54] price father Ed had forced Feliciano to pay in exchange for keeping by it about
[39:00] the discovery of his CD passed. Defense attorney Hamilton questioned why if father Ed
[39:07] had discovered this information out did not automatically fire Feliciano. He said that father
[39:13] Ed waited until a compliance audited of the church, which was just one week
[39:16] away. He said for the price father Ed made mister Feliciano pay for the
[39:22] things he made mister Feliciano do. He provoked mister Feliciano so much that a
[39:29] reasonable person would fly into a homicidal rage. It was evident from his statement
[39:35] that the defense was arguing that father Ed had held the information he uncovered about
[39:39] Feliciano over his head as a way to continue the alleged affair that they were
[39:45] having. They were going down the passion provocation manslaughter route and weren't denying that
[39:52] Feliciano had killed father Ed. The reason that there was no mention of the
[39:57] alleged affair was because Judge Thomas manahan And wrote that it could not be made
[40:00] during opening statements and it could only be brought up if Feliciano testified. On
[40:07] the first step the trial, evidence was presented regarding the murder weapon. It
[40:12] had been found just across the street from where Feliciano had lived. There was
[40:16] also evidence that father Ed's cell phone, which was found snapped in half near
[40:21] Feliciano's home, he had told investigators where to find these pieces of evidence.
[40:28] They also recovered blood stained clothing and blood stained towels. Testing on these items
[40:32] came back as a match for father Ed's blood. Afterwards, the jury once
[40:37] more heard the nine one one call that father Ed had made its frand Justin
[40:43] Ann Kong identified the voice as his. She broke down as she stated,
[40:49] it sounds like Ed. It sounds like he's tortured, like he's in pain.
[40:53] The jury also heard about the digging father Ed had done on Feliciano in
[40:58] order to uncover his criminal history. After learning about his past, father Ed
[41:02] was sent information about the charges against Feliciano by a Pennsylvania state trooper. It
[41:09] was also disclosed during trial that a supervisor at the church had wanted to fire
[41:13] Feliciano long before his past was uncovered. According to maintenance supervisor John Gallagher,
[41:20] Feliciano was always leaving the buildings sturdy. However, top officials, including father
[41:25] Ed, didn't want to fire him because he was only a couple of months
[41:29] away from retirement age. Father Ed was concerned for Feliciano's family and hoped that
[41:36] he would retire on his own. Virginia donnellan church business administrator, testified the
[41:40] Feliciano was aware that John wasn't satisfied with his work quality. She said that
[41:46] one day Feliciano came to her very nervous and spoke about the prospect of being
[41:52] fired. She stated he was shaking, very distraught, and in near tears.
[41:59] His ed was bowed down. I found his behavior almost offensive. He
[42:04] was being too subservient sometimes I felt he was putting on an act to get
[42:07] the reaction he wanted out of me. While father Ed had wanted to keep
[42:13] Feluciano on, when he found out about his prior history, he had no
[42:16] other option than to fire him. Afterwards, the jury would hear statements between
[42:22] investigators and Feliciano's fourteen year old daughter. She hadn't been required to testify,
[42:29] but the comments she made to investigators were allowed to be presented. She told
[42:34] investigators that on the day that father Ed was killed, her father wasn't his
[42:37] usual jovial self. Her mother picked both her and her father up from church
[42:44] like she always did, but that day her father was fifteen minutes late.
[42:50] This was when he was carrying out the murder. After getting into the car,
[42:53] Feliciano only said that he was busy. He was quiet on the way
[42:58] home and not telling jokes. And stories like he normally did on their drive
[43:01] back home. When they arrived, Feliciano had a shore and then walked the
[43:07] dog. This was when he disposed of the evidence. She testified that her
[43:12] father had been worried about losing his job. Robert Cager, a volunteer who
[43:16] worked lunch at Saint Patrick's school, testified about Feliciano's demeanor that same day as
[43:22] well. He said that at lunchtime, Feliciano was usually upbeat and happy as
[43:27] he gave milk to students in clean tables. This day, however, he
[43:31] said, the Feliciano sat with his head thawn and he wasn't helping. He
[43:37] testified he looked like he had the weight of the world on his shoulders.
[43:40] The prosecution speculated that Feliciano had been fired by father ed that morning. His
[43:46] calendar listed a meeting with Feliciano at nine forty five am along with the note
[43:52] Jose's last day. This indicated that Feliciano's last day would be the following day.
[44:00] Marie LA's Cleaves testified next, and she said that at the end of
[44:04] the work day, Feliciano appeared to be rushed and said he needed to leave
[44:07] quickly because there was something he needed to do. This was around thirty minutes
[44:12] before father Ed was stabbed to death. They supported the prosecution's theory that the
[44:17] murder had been premeditated. After this, the prosecution rested their case and it
[44:22] was now time for the defense to present theirs. They called on John Bongo,
[44:28] a fellow ex custodian at the church. He was fired a year before
[44:31] the murder, and he testified that father Ed had told him, I hate
[44:36] to do this, but because of budget cuts in the financial situation at the
[44:39] parish, we have to lay you off. He claimed that the church was
[44:44] suffering because some parishioners were leaving Jude dissatisfaction with father Ed. He stated sometimes
[44:52] he'd say hi, and other times he'd blew right by you, not saying
[44:55] anything. Under cross examination by the prosecution, he said he wasn't aware of
[45:00] any romantic relationship between father Ed and Feliciano, and admitted that he told investigators
[45:07] so that if there were any kind of relationship, he would have known.
[45:12] After his testimony, Feliciano took to the witness stand. The courtroom fell silent
[45:16] as he claimed that father Ed had touched him sexually in exchange for keeping silent
[45:21] about the criminal charges he was facing. He claimed it in two thousand and
[45:25] three, he told Father Ed he couldn't comply with the fingerprinting program because of
[45:30] an outstanding warrant. When he ran my privacy, I pushed on to the
[45:36] side, and I said, Father he was known, why are you touching?
[45:40] With filus in his arms? Was not to worry about it. He
[45:52] ran my privacy merely alive, and he invaried himself, mister Feliciano, how
[46:06] did that make you feel? Him? Feel really bad and feel very a
[46:20] lot of amoration? Father. He claimed that Father d told him not to
[46:24] worry, but then changed his tune the following year when he disclosed the charge
[46:30] related to an incident involving a child. He said the Father Ed was upset
[46:35] about the reveliation and ordered him and his family to move out of a church's
[46:39] own property, which they did. Feliciano claimed that for the next four years
[46:45] he allowed Father Ed to touch him privately in exchange for his silence. This
[46:51] testimony, however, didn't match up with Father Ed's Internet searches, which showed
[46:55] that he had only just discovered Feliciano's past. According to Feliciano, father Ed
[47:02] called him into the rectory and fired him. He stated, all this time
[47:07] he's been using me, and now he's saying I have to go. I
[47:12] told him you promised me. We got into a very heated argument and I
[47:16] pleaded with him not to do that to me, he said. The father
[47:21] Ed then began to belittle him and said that he was like a child,
[47:24] crying and begging. Feliciano told the jury that it was at this stage he
[47:29] noticed the knife on the table. He said, he grabbed it and went
[47:34] crazy. Prosecutor Bianchie poked holes in Feliciano's testimony and pointed out discrepancies between his
[47:40] court testimony and statements he gave to police, and a lot of things that
[47:45] you just testified to jury that are very different than when we said to catch
[47:53] no sa not really, He asked, is your memory of the incident better
[48:00] now than it was right after it happened. The difference between his statements where
[48:06] that Feliciano was not claiming that father Ed had indeed fire him. However,
[48:10] during his confession there was absolutely no mention of this. He claimed during his
[48:15] confession that the argument was about Feliciano attempting to end the relationship. Moreover,
[48:21] Feliciano was now claiming that he was retiring, so it wouldn't matter whether he
[48:25] lost his job or not. He hadn't mentioned this at all during his confession.
[48:31] You know, I claimed that father Ed had made a promise to him
[48:35] to allow him to work until he turned sixty five in March of two ten.
[48:39] Feliciano then admitted that he lied during the first eighty two pages of the
[48:44] interview. When he first of all denied the murder, he stated, I
[48:50] didn't want to get caught. I didn't want anybody to know. The confession
[48:53] had only come when Feliciano was informed of the evidence collected against him, including
[49:00] the fact that father Ed's cell phone was pinging to towers alongside his home.
[49:05] During cross examination, Feliciano agreed that he would have been fired and his reputation
[49:08] would have been obliterated if the criminal charges he faced were revealed. He also
[49:15] disclosed that his wife and daughter had no knowledge about his earlier charges. After
[49:21] his testimony, sister Catherine Moristet testified she had counseled Feliciano, and he claimed
[49:27] to investigators that he was sexually abused by a priest when he was a young
[49:30] boy. He maintained he had told father Ed and sister Catherine about this,
[49:36] but when she took to the witness stand, she denied that he had ever
[49:39] mentioned it to her. She said that he was troubled instead by gang activity
[49:45] as a young man. Furthermore, she revealed that he had expressed tremendous respect
[49:49] and appreciation for father Ed and said he had welcomed him and his family into
[49:54] their community. She also counted his claim that father Ed had forced him and
[50:00] his family to move out of the house on the grounds of Saint Patrick's.
[50:05] She said the real reason they moved out was because the parish wanted to sell
[50:07] the house. She said that Feliciano appeared to be excited about moving out,
[50:14] as she said it was the American dream for them. As the trial drew
[50:19] to a close, both the prosecutor and defense attorney presented their final arguments to
[50:22] the jury. Prosecutor Bianche painted a vivid picture of the defendant Feliciano as a
[50:30] meticulous, itself absorbed individual with a shady past who had meticulously planned the murder
[50:36] of father Ed, as a desperate attempt to salvage his reputation. On the
[50:42] other hand, defense attorney Hamilton portrayed him as a victim of sexual blackmail who
[50:46] had been pushed to the brink and lost control of his actions. The food
[50:52] of Feliciano now rested in the hands of the jury, who had the arduous
[50:54] task of determining whether his actions constituted murder or slaughter. The jury took their
[51:01] time, deliberating for five pence staking ours before arriving at a verdict. It
[51:07] was a moment of grid anticipation as everyone held their breath waiting to hear the
[51:12] decision. On the charge of fellowing murder? How do you find the defender
[51:17] jew murder? Charge of possession of a weapon for an unlawful purpose? Having
[51:23] you find charge lawful possession of a weapon? How do you find the defendi
[51:31] on the charge of injury shown apprehension? How do you find on the charge
[51:40] of murder? How do you find the defending murder? On the charge of
[51:49] robbery? How do you find the defensage rogery? Joseph Feliciano was fund guilty
[51:55] of the murder of father ed and is clearm of provocation? Was swiftly dismissed.
[52:02] In addition, he was found guilty on two kinds of robbery, hindering
[52:06] apprehension, and two weapons charges. The decision was welcome relief to all of
[52:12] those who loved Father Ed. Outside of court, his cousin Daniel Silas Miller
[52:16] stated it, the happy part is that his reputation gets restored. It was
[52:22] just disgusting. It's like he was slaughtered twice. Everything this man has said
[52:28] was nothing but lies and a force to say of his own skin. It's
[52:30] a shame that this pig was able to take such a precious commodity from our
[52:35] community. Ed Haines was a good man. Prosecutor Bianchie also commented, I'm
[52:42] proud in honor to have been part of a process to vindicate Father heinz murder
[52:46] and the slander of his reputation, which obviously the jury soundly did not believe.
[52:52] I can think of no greater Christmas gift to Father Heinz's soul and for
[52:57] those who loved him, that this conviction happens at Christmas time. On the
[53:01] twentieth of April twenty and twelve, the courtroom was filled with tense anticipation as
[53:07] everyone awaited the sentencing of Jose Feliciano. Prosecutor Bianchie once again addressed the court,
[53:14] making reference to Feliciano's claims of sexual blackmail. Despite a thorough investigation,
[53:19] not a shred of evidence could be found to support his outrageous allegations. The
[53:23] family of father Ed were present, along with other members of the parish who
[53:28] held him dear. The case was especially disturbing due to the vile accusation that
[53:34] had been made against father Ed, a man who was universally loved for his
[53:38] gentle kind nature. Feliciano, on the other hand, had led a life
[53:44] of deceit, with multiple identities and a long history of disturbing crimes against children.
[53:51] He had even impregnated his own stepdaughter, a fact that wasn't allowed to
[53:55] be mentioned during trial. Prosecutor Bianchie became emotional as he asked Judge Thomas Manahan
[54:01] to impose the maximum sentence. The judge did just that. He sentenced jo
[54:07] Save Luciano to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Before the sentence
[54:13] was handed down, for Luciano was given the opportunity to provide a statement,
[54:16] but he turned down the offer. Outside of court, Prosecutor Bianche expressed his
[54:22] deep sadness at the loss of father Ed, a man whose life had been
[54:27] dedicated to serving others. He spoke of the senselessness of his death, staring,
[54:32] this man's life was dedicated twenty four seven to helping people. He died
[54:37] literally trying to protect God's children, and he paid for it with his own.
[54:44] Three days later, a ceremony honoring father Ed and other crime victims was
[54:47] held at Saint Patrick's Church. There was an underlying tone of hope and resilience,
[54:53] with his friend Judith Ann Cook commenting, let us turn mourning into dancing.
[55:00] Around one hundred and fifty people attended, including Prosecutor Bianche. He stated,
[55:07] trying this case was probably the greatest honor I have ever had as a
[55:10] trial attorney. Prosecutor Bianche was filled with the sense of purpose and determination,
[55:17] and just the following year he opened up his own law practice. With his
[55:22] father. Father Ed Huns was a shining example of kindness and compassion, always
[55:29] ready to lend a helping hand to those in need. When the idea was
[55:32] floated to fire Jose Feliciano, father Ed refused to let that happen. He
[55:38] knew that he was struggling financially, and he went out of his way to
[55:43] ensure he remained employed. However, Feliciano's dark secrets finally caught up with him,
[55:50] and instead of showing gratitude for everything that father Ed had done for him,
[55:54] he repaid him in one final act of violence. Well, Bessie's that
[56:15] is it for this episode of Morbidology. It's always thank you so so much
[56:20] for listening, and I'd like to say a massive thank you to my new
[56:22] supporters up on Patreon, katreenne Becca and Lauren. The support on there seriously
[56:29] goes such a long way, and I genuinely am eternally grateful. Please do
[56:34] check more about allodio out on Padreon if you'd like to support the show.
[56:37] But if you'd like to support the show in another way, you can leave
[56:39] me a reading and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify or wherever else you're listening
[56:46] reading some reviews or an easy way to support a show that you like,
[56:50] and I genuinely do appreciate the feedback. Remember to check us out at morbidology
[56:54] dot com for more information about this episode and to read our Troop Prime article.
[57:00] Cool Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and
[57:05] have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
