# 200: Levi and Christina Karlsen

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 17 Apr 2023, 58 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53234240/morbidology_200_levi_and_christina_karlense.mp3

Yale Farm Road in the small town of Varick, New York, was quiet on the afternoon of 20 November, 2008. Karl and Cindy Karlsen had just returned home from a family funeral. Before they left, Karl’s son, Levi, had come over to do some repair work to his truck in the garage. As they pulled up outside, they observed that Levi’s car was still parked in the driveway… SPONSORS - June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. Audible: Thank you so much for Audible for sponsoring this episode! Get unlimited plus catalog on Audible including Audible originals, podcasts, audiobooks and more. You can get a free 30-day trial: https://amzn.to/40a5vzc SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-200-levi-christina-karlsen PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] Mmmm, Well, when I broke the window, the fireball came out and
[0:38] burnt my eyes together, burned my face, I mean, blew me right
[0:42] off the get to and blew me off. Yale Farm Road in the small
[1:00] town of Varick, New York, was quiet on the afternoon of the twentieth
[1:06] of November two thousand and eight. Carlin Cindy Carlson had just returned home from
[1:11] a family funeral. Before they left, Carlson Levi had come over to do
[1:17] some repair work to his truck in the garage. As they pulled up outside,
[1:23] they observed that Levi's car was still parked in the driveway. Yale Farm
[1:38] Road is a rural road running alongside Reader Creek in the town of Varick,
[1:45] Seneca County, New York. It was this road that the Carlson family called
[1:49] home. In two thousand and eight. Carl Carlson owned a plot of land
[1:56] where he and his wife Cindy lived and ran their dock farm, which was
[2:00] named c in K Farms. Their home was surrounded in rolling fields with a
[2:07] picturesque lake to the side. The Carlton family had been a fixture in Seneca
[2:14] County for generations. Carl's father Ulgar Junior, also known as Junior, was
[2:22] a town highway superintendent in Varick. When he became Condee Highway superintendent, his
[2:30] father, who was Carl's grandfather, Ulgar Senior, took over the role of
[2:36] town highway superintendent. Carl's brother, Kurt, was a town counselor, and
[2:43] then Kurt's wife, Donna, was a town clerk. As for Carl.
[2:47] Before owning the farm with his second wife, he had been a nuclear missile
[2:52] specialist for the US Air Force. He and Cindy had been married since nineteen
[2:58] ninety three. Carl had three children from a previous marriage. There was his
[3:02] oldest son, twenty three year old Levi, who had just gone through a
[3:07] divorce. He was working at a glass manufacturing shop, which helped to support
[3:13] his two young children. There was also twenty four year old Erin and twenty
[3:19] one year old Katie. One was a park police officer for the state and
[3:23] the other was a translator for the military. On the twentieth of November two
[3:29] thousand and eight, Carlin Cindy were at home preparing to head to a funeral
[3:32] for one of Cindy's relatives. Levi had come over to the farm at the
[3:38] request of his father, there were some damaged power steering lines on Carl's pickup
[3:44] truck. Levi was always handy when it came to vehicle repairs. Before Carlin
[3:51] Cindy left the home at around midday, Carl went into the garage to thank
[3:55] Levi for helping and slip him a fifty dollar bill. Levi had the pickup
[4:01] truck lifted up on a railroad jack and was working away underneath it. At
[4:09] run four pm, Carl and Cindy returned home. They immediately noticed that Levi's
[4:15] car was still parked in the driveway. Carl later recalled it seemed weird.
[4:21] He hadn't left yet, you know when you have that feeling that something's not
[4:26] right. Carl opened up the garage door and saw that the pickup truck had
[4:32] slipped off the railroad jack. Levi's fate. We're sticking out from underneath.
[4:40] As Carl attempted to lift the car off Levi with the railroad jack, he
[4:45] had Cindy call police. Oh my god, we've been gone, so Solona,
[4:58] Okay, we're gonna start see pr Okay wanted to start to ruff.
[5:08] While Cindy was on the phone, Carl had managed to get Levi out from
[5:12] underneath the pickup truck. He recollected he was cooled, he was blue.
[5:18] By the time that emergency services arrived at the home, it could be seen
[5:23] that Levi's chest was caved in. Nearby lay a pair of broken eyeglasses and
[5:30] a baseball cap with sirens blazing. Levi was rushed by ambulance to Geneva General
[5:35] Hospital. Tragically. As soon as he arrived, he was pronounced stead.
[5:42] His cause of death was massive trauma to the chest. Seneca County Sheriff Jack
[5:49] Stamberg announced in a press conference there were no indications of file play, and
[5:56] from all signs, this appeared to be a very tragic accident. What made
[6:17] Levi's death all the more poignant was that seventeen years earlier, a different tragedy
[6:24] had befallen the Carlson family. On New Year's Day of nineteen ninety one,
[6:30] a fire engulfed the Carlson family home, which was at that point on the
[6:34] four six hundred block of Pennsylvania Gulch Road in Murphy's, California. The home
[6:43] was a very rural one, and it was in fact a former mining shock
[6:46] turned into a home It sat at her on two thousand, six hundred feet
[6:51] of elevation in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada, which straddle California and Nevada.
[7:00] At the time, Karl was married to Christina Carlson, Levi, Erin
[7:03] and Katie's mother, to whom he had been married for seven years. The
[7:10] couple had met while Carl was in the Air Force, and they were married
[7:13] in Grand Forks on New Year's Day of nineteen ninety one. Carl had been
[7:18] working in the garage when the blaze at the home began. Christina and five
[7:25] year old Levi were at home, as well as their two other children,
[7:29] six year old Erin and four year old Katie. Carl told investigators at the
[7:34] time that he was alerted to the fire by Christina's deafening screams. As he
[7:41] volted from the garage towards the home, he could see thick smoke billowing out
[7:45] from the windows. He could hear Christina screaming, get the children. Karl
[7:53] was able to pull Levi, Aron and Katie out of a bedroom window,
[7:58] but suddenly he was blown back by a small explosion. By now, Christina
[8:03] had fallen silent. Karl hollered his wife through the window, but she never
[8:11] appeared, and the fire had begun to engulf the home, making it impossible
[8:16] for Carl to enter. With the three children safely out of the home,
[8:22] they piled into the pickup truck and drove down the sparsely inhabited road to find
[8:28] somebody to call nine one one. Just a couple of miles away. Christina's
[8:33] father, Art Alexander, was at home when he received a phone call from
[8:37] a friend who owned a police scanner and had listened as the report of the
[8:43] fire came. In. Art's bed over to the family's home to see the
[8:48] home completely engulfed in flames. He could see the Carl and the children had
[8:54] escaped unharmed but traumatized, but his daughter was nowhere to be seen. Once
[9:01] the flames were extinguished, the fire department was able to find Christina. She
[9:07] had been trapped in the bathroom between the hallway where the fire had started.
[9:13] The bathroom window had been boarded up with a half thick inch sheet of plywood
[9:18] the Carl had nailed from the inside just stays earlier. He said to investigators
[9:24] that Christina had broken the window by trying to force it open with the plunger
[9:28] handle, and that he had boarded it up to keep the cold out.
[9:33] Christina was found huddled in the bathtub with a washcloth over her mouth for protection.
[9:39] According to Carl, in the days leading up to the fire, the
[9:43] water pipes had frozen, so we had hauled five gallon jugs of water inside.
[9:50] One night, Christina accidentally brought in a gallon of kerosene, mistaking it
[9:56] for a gallon of water. Explained to the investigators how this kerosene was then
[10:03] spilled. She was up in the bathroom and so somehow the way he says,
[10:11] because we had we had a puppy of Domatian puppy and we had a
[10:16] kerosene heaters in the house, and the dog spilt the kerosene like three four
[10:26] weeks before. Carl said that minutes before the fire, had been fixing an
[10:31] arctic fun and had laid a defective electric light on the china cupboard near the
[10:37] spilled kerosene was just outside the bathroom where Christina was taking a bath. Investigators
[10:46] determined that the fire was an accident and concluded that it had started after the
[10:50] kerosene was spilled onto the carpet and then ignited by the defective electric light.
[10:58] Over at the medical examiner's office. Christine Is autopsy showed that she had died
[11:01] from smoke into lash and they said she was she was dead when she opened
[11:05] the door, because they said where she was in the middle of the house.
[11:09] The house is like eighty two hundred feet long. I mean it was
[11:15] the windows to get out, no, no, and in the middle of
[11:20] the house, in the bathroom, they would absolutely the windows to jump out.
[11:24] Well, when I broke the window, the fireball came out and burnt
[11:30] my eyes together, burnt my face, I mean blew me right off.
[11:33] The after the kids to get to them, and it blew me off.
[11:37] And the kids are still in the house and my eyes were burnt shut.
[11:43] So I pulled them apart and couldn't see where shutting. And my son had
[11:48] got to the window, and I got him by the hair, yeah,
[11:52] and chucked him out, and and I got the girls. In the week
[11:58] of the fire, carl and the three children picked up their lives and moved
[12:03] to New York. In the wake of Levi's tragic death, life or the
[12:26] Carlson family continued as normal. Everybody in the small town of Varick had almost
[12:33] forgotten about the tragedy when in March of two thousand and twelve, Jackie Heimul
[12:39] called police. Jackie was a cousin of Cindy, Carl's second wife, and
[12:46] she shared her belief with police that Carl had murdered his son for financial gain.
[12:52] Investigators began looking into this, and they learned the just days before Levi
[12:56] had died, he had taken out a life insurance policy which listed his father
[13:01] as the sole beneficiary. He had handwritten a will which gave his father power
[13:07] of attorney. It stipulated that if anything should happen to him, he didn't
[13:13] want to be put on life support, and he wanted to donate his organs
[13:18] and have his body cremated. The will also stipulated that Carl distribute any assets
[13:24] to Levi's two young daughters. Then, when Levi went to buy the life
[13:30] insurance in Geneva, he was with his father, who did all of the
[13:33] talking. Carl told the financial adviser that Levi wanted the life insurance policy on
[13:39] himself to secure the future of his two young daughters. Carl explained that Levi
[13:46] didn't want his ex wife to have access to the money, so Levi was
[13:50] making him the sole beneficiary. Levi and Carl paid four hundred and seventy dollars
[13:56] for the first six months of the policy during that first meeting, which took
[14:01] place on the third of November two thousand and eight. The policy meant that
[14:05] if Levi were to die, the sole beneficiary, who was Carl, would
[14:11] be paid four hundred thousand dollars. Then, if Levi died in an accident,
[14:18] the policy would pay an additional three hundred thousand dollars, taking the grand
[14:22] total that Carl received to seven hundred thousand dollars. Then, on the twentieth
[14:30] of November, Levi had his handwritten will notarized at a Seneca County bank.
[14:35] Just ours later, he died and his death was ruled an accident. Four
[14:41] months after his death, his father was given in seven hundred and seven thousand
[14:45] dollars, which included interest. The financial advisor, Tony Chrissy, said that
[14:52] he looked into Levi's death but could find no reason to withhold the payment.
[14:56] He delivered the check himself to Carl and his wife, Cindy, and he
[15:01] said that they withdrew the money instantly. In fact, they withdrew the money
[15:07] so quickly that they paid penalties of sixty thousand dollars for early withdrawal. The
[15:16] money was anticipated to go towards Levi's two children, like Carl and Levi had
[15:22] mentioned during the meeting, unlike the will had stipulated. However, Levi's children
[15:28] didn't see a single cent. Carl was brought in for questioning, and he
[15:33] stuck to the same story he had stuck to back in two thousand and eight.
[15:39] You guys don't want know what happened that day the David my son died
[15:43] him, Her and I we had a funeral to go to. Left at
[15:48] eleven thirty quarter twelve, somewhere like that. It was on the other side
[15:52] of son of Helake son was there. He helped me. Was he working
[15:56] on the truck changing the transmission lines, break lines a whole nine yard you
[16:02] know. Talked to him say goodbye. He was going to work on his
[16:03] truck later in the afternoon because he had a change something I don't I can't
[16:07] remember what it was. So then we left, come back a little left
[16:11] for four and went out there then found it. Did you say anything before
[16:17] you left? Just see you later and thanks you know. I mean,
[16:22] just so you're going out to the car with your wife, and then you
[16:26] went into the barn. Yep, because I forgot to give him the line.
[16:30] Did you give him the money? Yep, fifty dollars? And then
[16:32] what happened? And then what else happened? And then and then I left.
[16:36] He was between he was in front of the bumper. Was a radio
[16:38] on it back one? Yep, it wasn't funny. I don't know,
[16:44] I don't know. And then I left. You presume to go away to
[16:48] her, and I believe it was to the reception just a short time.
[16:52] And then we got back at like it was after four. I went in
[16:55] the garage and because we were surprised he was still there. If the truck
[16:59] is this way, he was, he was laying this way. And and
[17:03] then I went in yells, banging on the door and told her to call
[17:11] animals, and started jacking it up, and she come out. You know,
[17:15] there's no doubt. I mean, the only jack that was there was
[17:18] the big railroad jack, which my father's, and it was an old one
[17:22] that they used to use way back when I guess we were told is it
[17:26] lifted up the old railroad irons, they come in and tried doing CPR,
[17:30] and he was already gone. On the twenty fourth of November two thy twelve,
[17:37] Carl was arrested and charged with the second degree murder of Levi. Investigators
[17:42] were working on the theory that he had purposefully knocked the jack, causing the
[17:47] pickup truck to fall onto Levi. They speculated that as Levi lay crushed,
[17:52] Carlin Cindy went to the family funeral, and when they returned, Carl staged
[17:59] the discovery of Levi underneath the truck. In announcing the new development, Sheriff
[18:06] Stemberg stated to think that a father could cause a vehicle to fall off a
[18:11] jack, crushing his son, and then leave for four hours, knowing all
[18:15] the time that his song was pinned under the truck apparently dead, is unconscionable.
[18:22] Car was also charged with fraud. This charge stemmed from the fact that
[18:26] Carl did not disclose with Tony, the financial adviser, that Levi had been
[18:30] treated for serious swallowing problems. In fact, Levi had died just one day
[18:37] before he was scheduled to attend a physical exam that is required by New York
[18:42] Life Insurance Co. Which was who the policy was with. If that problem
[18:48] had been mentioned back when applying, then the policy may have been delayed or
[18:52] not even approved. Then if the problem was discovered during the physical exam,
[18:57] then there was every chance that the lie insurance policy would have been canceled.
[19:12] In the wake of the arrest, it was announced that investigators we're now wanting
[19:17] to re examine the nineteen ninety one fire that had killed Christina. In the
[19:22] wake of Christina's death, carl had ended up with two hundred thousand dollars in
[19:27] life insurance money, and he left California for New York in less than seventy
[19:33] two hours. He and the children had left before Christina was even buried.
[19:41] The sheriff commented, we'll be talking with investigators in California in the coming days,
[19:48] as there are certain events surrounding the death of Carlson's first wife that cause
[19:52] us concern. If you love a good old fashioned mystery with loss of surprises,
[20:00] then June's Journey is the perfect game for you. As you join forces
[20:04] with the charming amateur detective June Parker, you'll set out to unravel the mystery
[20:10] behind her sister's murder and discover some long health family secrets. Get ready to
[20:15] put your observation skills to the test as you scan over one thousand intricately designed
[20:21] scenes, searching for hidden clues and vital pieces of information. Transport yourself back
[20:26] to the dazzling nineteen twenty thiees, and lose yourself in the stunning visuals immersive
[20:32] gameplay of June's Journey. I've been hooked on this mobile puzzle game for well
[20:36] over a year now, often finding myself playing lad at night as a way
[20:41] to unwind. I'm currently on volume four, Chapter four, where June needs
[20:45] to find clues on a boat. One of the coolest features of June's Journey
[20:51] is the ability to create your own island estate and even join a detective club.
[20:56] Can you Crack the Case? Download June's Journey for free on iOS and
[21:00] Android. The decision to relook at Christina's death was welcomed by her father Art.
[21:11] He commented that he always had questions about the fire, but he was
[21:15] terrified that if he broached the subject with Karl, he would be cut off
[21:19] from his three grandchildren. He stated, it just to keep it bottled up.
[21:25] It was the hardest thing I ever did in my life. He said
[21:29] that there were several occasions where he considered bringing the fire up to Carl,
[21:33] but opted against it. According to Art, at the scene of the fire,
[21:38] his suspicions were aroused by the fact that a friend had showed him multiple
[21:42] flashpoints where the fire had started, but if it were an accident, then
[21:48] there really should have only been one. Suspicions mounted when Art learned that Carl
[21:53] had an insurance policy that he hadn't paid the first payment on yet. Then
[22:00] when Art learned about the board at a bathroom door, he was sure that
[22:04] something nefarious had happened to his daughter. While Art was satisfied with the new
[22:10] developments in the case, Carl's brothers weren't so forthcoming. His brother Thomas said
[22:17] to the Post Standard, I'm really not in the mood to answer any questions.
[22:22] You probably know more or as much as I do, so at this
[22:26] point I'm just waiting for whatever investigation takes place to take place. I'm waiting
[22:32] to find out what the heck's going on, just as much as you are.
[22:36] To be perfectly honest with you, the people who owned the home that
[22:40] Carl and Christina were ranting from were also pleased to hear that the case was
[22:45] being reopened. Much like Art, they too had their suspicions. While Carl
[22:52] had a two hundred thousand dollar life insurance policy on Christina, you oftentimes couldn't
[22:57] make the three hundred dollars in rent. John Lucero, the homeowner, revealed
[23:04] that after the fire, they had filed a negligence lawsuit against Carl. They
[23:10] had done so in the hopes that he would be forced to return to California
[23:14] for a deposition. Carl did returned to California and he was disposed in the
[23:22] office of the Lucero's attorney. They had hoped that with Carl back in California,
[23:27] he would be interviewed regarding Christina's death, but that never happened and the
[23:33] investigation was never reopened. Afterwards, Carl just returned to New York and continued
[23:41] life as normal. In the end, the Luceros were awarded seven thousand,
[23:45] five hundred dollars for the damage to the home. The fire damage was estimated
[23:49] to be eighty thousand dollars, but unfortunately the home wasn't insured. It was
[23:56] looking more and more likely that something sinister had happened to Christina as well as
[24:02] Levi. A New York State Police investigator, Jeff Arnold, announced that he
[24:07] would be flying out to California to interview Art and several other family members in
[24:12] relation to the fire. On the twenty ninth of November, Karl was indicted
[24:18] on two kinds of second degree murder and insurance fraud in relation to Levi's death.
[24:25] Christina's mother and father flew from California to New York to attend the arraignment.
[24:30] Her mother, Christine said, I've come here to see justice done.
[24:34] I've always known in my heart that he was involved in all of this,
[24:38] but it had to come from the right people to bring it out. During
[24:41] the arraignment, Karl entered a plea of not guilty. He appeared without an
[24:47] attorney to represent him and told the judge that he had applied for a court
[24:51] appointed attorney. He stated that this was the second time in making the request.
[24:57] He said they denied me at first because I have property and money.
[25:03] I'm going through a divorce, so it's all tied up in that. At
[25:07] the time of Karl's arrest, he and Christie had broken up, with Karl
[25:11] behind bars. The investigation into Christine as death continued. There were a number
[25:17] of suspicious elements, the board at a bathroom window, the fact that Karl
[25:22] left California within days, and the two hundred thousand dollars insurance policy. In
[25:30] fact, investigators at the time were suspicious Karl was the only adult to witness
[25:36] the fire at the dead end of the remote road that the family had called
[25:40] home. He was questioned, but then quickly moved to another state before further
[25:45] questions could be asked. As California Department of Forestry's Deputy fire Warden Robert Monson
[25:52] recalled, once he got to New York, it was virtually impossible at that
[25:56] point for us to follow up. We certainly would have liked to. He
[26:03] further commented, the sequence of events that he gave were just incredible, for
[26:07] lack of a better term. You break a window in the bathroom, so
[26:11] you board the window up. The solvent was there, the ignition source was
[26:17] there. There were so many accidents that occurred to create the fatality that had
[26:22] just raised flags. Investigators soon learned of two other suspicious fires at the Carlson
[26:27] home. There was one at the barn and then another one that involved a
[26:32] carl that Karl was laid at making payments on In two thousand and two,
[26:37] a barn fire engulfed a barn at the family's home, killing Karl's prized Belgian
[26:41] draft horses. Karl claimed that it was an accident caused by aging cloth insulation
[26:48] on wires. He collected around eighty thousand dollars in insurance money. There were
[26:55] other ominous incidents that Carl was involved in as well. He and Levi had
[27:00] always had a contentious relationship, and this was marred by abuse at the hands
[27:04] of Carl. When Levi was just fifteen years old and two thousand, he
[27:11] filed a complaint against his father. He said that his father was angry over
[27:17] stolen money as well as a note he had written to a girl, when
[27:21] he slammed Levi's head into a kitchen counter, choked him, and then threatened
[27:26] to kill him. Levi said to police. He asked me whether I wanted
[27:32] to die or not? I said no. Levi had married young, and
[27:37] he and his wife and daughters had moved into a four bedroom home in Clifton
[27:41] Springs, the Carl disapproved of. In two thousand and five, the home
[27:47] mysteriously burned down when Levi was working a night shift. No cause of the
[27:52] fire was ever determined. Levi had apparently always been suspicious about his mother's death,
[28:00] and when he one day suggested that his father was involved, Karl choked
[28:04] him and beat him. After Karl was charged with his son's murderer, he
[28:10] permitted an interview with the post stander from behind bars. He insisted that he
[28:17] had nothing to do with the death of Levi or Christine. In a rambling
[28:22] three or interview, he stated, there's no way you can kill somebody for
[28:26] money. You just don't. To be accused of killing your son for money
[28:32] is beyond, as his voice trailed off. He then spoke about all of
[28:37] the other incidents that had befallen him, including the fire at the barn.
[28:42] He commented, if anybody had ship luck, I've got it. He complained
[28:48] about the fact that he needed to walk with the frame. He said that
[28:52] he had surgeries on his back and shoulders and had been kicked by a draft
[28:56] horse. He commented, I'm like a seventy five year old man physically.
[29:03] He said that in the years before and after Levi's death, he had taken
[29:07] up to thirty five pain pills per day. If out to fight the case
[29:12] and commented, I will never plead guilty to this, not hell or high
[29:18] water. Will anybody make me plead guilty to this. He then commented that
[29:23] if he were to go to trial, he would not want his children to
[29:26] be called as witnesses. He stated, to see them on the stand,
[29:32] I don't think I could take it. I would rather sit in jail for
[29:36] twenty five years of my life knowing my kids would not have to be ripped
[29:40] open. During the interview, Karl actually blamed Sinday for his arrest. Since
[29:47] Levi's death, their form had closed due to Karl's ailing health. He stated,
[29:52] you live with me for three and a half years after Levi's death,
[29:56] and now all of a sudden, we got a divorce coming and this happens.
[30:00] What a coincidence? Don't you think There was actually some truth behind his
[30:07] comments. Cindy had actually been working with investigators. By the summer of two
[30:12] thousand and eleven, Cindy had begun to suspect that Carl was responsible for Levi's
[30:18] death. Cindy left Carl and she hired a private detective named Stephen Brown,
[30:26] who discovered that Carl had used some of the proceeds from Levi's life insurance settlement
[30:33] to buy a policy on her. This meant that if she died, Carl
[30:37] would receive one point two million dollars. In early two thousand and twelve,
[30:44] Cindy and the sun she had with Carl fled to Syracuse out of fear that
[30:48] Carl would somehow try to kill them. Eventually, Cindy went to investigators with
[30:53] her concerns after her cousin informed her that she had reported her own suspicions to
[31:00] lease, Cindy agreed to wear a wire and try to lure Carl into a
[31:06] confession. One afternoon, they met at a restaurant while investigators sat nearby.
[31:12] At one stage, Carl talked about the Bible and said that he was going
[31:17] to have to face God. The conversation then turned to the day that Levi
[31:22] died. Carl said that he had removed the trucks front tires and raised it
[31:26] on a jack before asking Levi I to get underneath and repair the break and
[31:30] transmission lines. Garl could be heard stating it was so wobbly. Cindy then
[31:38] implored Carl to tell the truth. He responded, it was never meant to
[31:45] be it was never planned from day one to go that way. In a
[31:49] later recording, Carl said that he accidentally hit the jack, causing the car
[31:56] to fall. You're sorry about it, right, And I asked you if
[32:08] I said, I mean nothing to do, but I said. Cindy said
[32:15] to Carl that he would need to push hard to knock the truck off the
[32:19] jack. He responded, no, it pushed easy. Cindy then asked whether
[32:25] Levi I felt any pin and Carl responded that he didn't think so, that
[32:30] he believed Levi's death was instant. Carl stopped short of making a confession,
[32:38] but this story that he provided was different than the story that he had told
[32:43] police four years earlier, and he was arrested shortly thereafter. When Carl was
[32:50] first of all arrested, he sat with investigators and repeatedly said that Cindy was
[32:54] setting him up to take the blame. After they disclosed that they had recorded
[33:00] the conversation Sunday, I do I really do even to I mean, even
[33:06] to this minute. She hit her demons coming into the marriage, which was
[33:10] her alcohol, you know, But at the time I never knew that I
[33:15] would She try to say yeah to get everything. The house. That doesn't
[33:23] really right. I mean he's armed. That's three hundred and some thousand.
[33:28] Because she knew what I was going to go after her for the house and
[33:31] the money for the girls. She has nothing. He was once more asked
[33:37] whether he had anything to do with Levi's death. Your son, unfortunately,
[33:42] was spot like everybody else. And just like you told your wife and multiple
[33:47] times that you did what you had to do. You took an opportunity to
[33:52] benefit your family. You cannot now take those words back. You can't do
[33:58] that. Well, it doesn't benefit your Fai's completely against your character and it
[34:01] doesn't help you one. You were at your finest moment, when you were
[34:06] making decisions to benefit your family. That they call that murder. I never
[34:09] called that murder. I do you're that's what you're nervous about now? No,
[34:14] I you hire that you did the right thing, and now you're sitting
[34:15] here saying, oh my god, I'm trying to help my O. You
[34:19] now in trouble. Okay, give me doll it. We want to find
[34:23] out what's in your heart so we know what to call it. I would
[34:25] call that murder. Why don't you talk to us about what really happened,
[34:30] and I would I would call that murder. You don't kill your son,
[34:35] You don't kill anybody for money. Listen, who's that anything about money?
[34:38] What are you talking about? And nobody thinks because of what happened to LEVI
[34:43] that you're any loss of a person. I actually think in my heart that
[34:46] I have children and it must have been the most difficult thing in the world.
[34:51] But you were able to do it. And I'm not saying that's right.
[34:54] Don't get me wrong. I'm saying that you made a difficult decision and
[34:58] now you have to live with that decision. I'm not asking you. I'm
[35:00] telling you what we know to be true that came out of your own words.
[35:05] You pushed the car over on your son. You said it, We've
[35:08] heard it. It's a matter of evidence, along with several other things that
[35:12] will prove the same thing. Do not make yourself look like a monster.
[35:16] You you did what was in your heart, and now you're trying to You're
[35:21] trying to pull back because you're now, for the first time in your life,
[35:22] you're worried about you. Before you worry about your family, Now you're
[35:25] already worried about me. Investigators pressed carl for more information and revealed to him
[35:32] that they believe that leave I was already dead by the time he left to
[35:37] go to the funeral with Cindy astonishingly call them broke Dawn and changed the same
[35:45] story that he had been saying for the past four years. If you really
[35:50] true, fellow, you what you did was right, in which I think
[35:52] you got it. I did not tell me. There's no way I could
[35:57] have that he was dead when I went in there. Okay, how was
[36:00] about that? You can do it? You can do it. Could let's
[36:06] talk about what you whead. I walked in there and walked in there to
[36:10] you know, give him his money, and holy and I just why,
[36:20] just Parrish, d of your life? Why should you keep it a secret?
[36:25] For sol what taking enough less a life away? It was, I
[36:50] mean, it was an extent and it's I blame myself every day, just
[36:54] like you said. So when he went back in, he was, he
[36:59] was, and I just like, They're like, there's no way, you
[37:08] know, I mean, it's just I would give my wife for that kid.
[37:15] For the first time, Carloy claimed that when he entered the garage to
[37:19] say goodbye to his son, the truck was already on top of him and
[37:23] he was deceased. He must have been refund on something because he still had
[37:28] the wrenches in his hands. I had to break it, almost break his
[37:30] fingers to get the wrenches out of his hands. When we come home,
[37:38] if I don't give him for giving twenty billion dollars. Later in the interrogation,
[37:45] Carl changed his story once more. He said that he was with his
[37:50] son in the garage when he was crushed. He said that he had accidentally
[37:54] knocked the railroad jack that had been supporting the truck. I opened the truck
[38:05] door, okay, when they did very you're very close card. I didn't
[38:14] do it. I think how you did not? All? No way,
[38:22] I didn't. There was but I need to do it. And then I
[38:30] put the door and stepped in. I'm back the truck door because I had
[38:42] to get inside and move the linkage for the truck. And when I did
[38:49] it tipped it in just fell over. He said that as his son lay
[38:53] injured, he asked him to move the jacked up truck. Instead of helping
[39:00] his son, Karl now claimed that he simply laughed him there. One of
[39:06] the investigators asked the truck fell on your son, and instead of jacking the
[39:12] car up, you ran. It would have taken you less than a minute
[39:15] to get that truck off him. Karl replied, I got out of there
[39:21] like a kid who threw a rock through a window that didn't want to get
[39:24] caught. Deputy John Clear then asked, why did you push the truck on
[39:30] him. Karl responded I didn't. The deputy then said, you can say
[39:37] it all you want and nobody's going to believe you. Karl. You don't
[39:42] walk away leaving the son you love so much for four hours. Karl replied,
[39:47] I did, and I don't know why. The deputy then said,
[39:52] maybe you're ashamed of something. Karl responded, I am ashamed. I' shamed
[40:00] of the whole thing. You didn't kill him intentionally, no, accidentally,
[40:06] Yeah, it wasn't. And just where I fell around him instead of going
[40:08] mind was aimed as rescue of your son. You said, Nah, it
[40:14] wasn't. He's he's good to die if I don't help him. So I'm
[40:17] not going to help him. What did you say, I don't want him
[40:20] go? Nothing? It just you just now did didn't choose you were the
[40:25] military, didn't you tell me in rescular earlier that you made me kill people,
[40:29] saying you go blank, you I went blank. It's my kid.
[40:32] It's just so nobody goes blank of that regard. In February the following year,
[40:37] Carl was arraigned on charges he killed Levi in a staged accident to collect
[40:42] his life insurance. He pleaded not guilty and was ordered to stand trial after
[40:47] rejecting a plea deal. This plea deal stipulated that if Carl pleaded guilty to
[40:53] one kind of homicide, then it would have satisfied the charges he could potentially
[40:59] face and Chris Dina's death, the investigation into that case was still ongoing.
[41:07] I've recently signed up for Audible Plus and I genuinely can't recommend it enough.
[41:14] You get Unlimited Plus Catalog, and that includes Audible originals, podcasts, audiobooks,
[41:21] and more. There's thousands of titles that you can stream or download for
[41:23] later. I'm a massive reader, and Audible has really helped me find some
[41:29] amazing new books, my favorite of which are always true crime and fictional thrillers.
[41:35] There's also some amazing podcasts on there that I never would have discovered if
[41:38] not for my subscription. It's fantastic to have everything I need up on one
[41:43] handy app. They've even sponsored this episode. Just click the link in my
[41:46] show notes to get a free thirty day trial, and trust me, you're
[41:52] going to love it as much as I do. Carl was also charged with
[41:59] holding the hand written will that he took Levi to have notarized just ours before
[42:04] his death. He was charged with concealing a will, perjury, making apparently
[42:09] false statements, and offering a false instrument for filing. A grand jury had
[42:15] found that when Carl went to settle his son's estate on the twenty fourth of
[42:20] December two thousand and eight, he filed the paper were claiming that Levi had
[42:24] no will. Investigators believed that Karl was concerned about the stipulation in the will
[42:31] that he distribute any assets to Levi's daughters. Sheriff Stamberg stated, it's extremely
[42:38] coincidental. We believe this substantiates that Karl was responsible for the death of Levi.
[42:45] Investigators were also looking into whether Karl had forced Levi to write the will.
[42:52] Carl Plea did not guilty to those charges as well. As the case
[42:57] was meandering through the Justice system. District Attorney Barbara Yuke announced that she had
[43:02] appointed a prosecutor with experience in Arson investigations to the case involving Christina. Their
[43:10] investigation was assisted by New York investigators, and one of them, Jeff Arnold,
[43:15] commented, it is unfortunate that car was not brought to justice back in
[43:21] nineteen ninety one. Christina's family shared their belief the California investigators were only now
[43:28] beginning to properly investigate her death now that New York investigators were assisting. Christina's
[43:35] sister Colette said, it's the same thing that my family and I have gotten
[43:40] ever since my sister's death. Oh, we're working on it. There isn't
[43:45] any evidence, I said, I expect communication. That is all my family
[43:51] asks for. Let us know you're working on it, and I can't even
[43:54] get that. The California investigators were hit by criticism that they weren't taking the
[44:00] investigation as seriously as the New York investigation. In July, Carl's defense team
[44:07] attempted to get the video taped interrogation excluded from evidence. Defense attorney Laurence Casparac
[44:15] said that it was evident that the investigators were trying to force Carl to confess,
[44:21] and noted that they had sworn at Carl told him he didn't love his
[44:24] son and that they were badgering him and refusing to provide him with pain medication.
[44:31] Several times throughout the interrogation, Carl had said that he was in pain,
[44:36] and at one point he asked, should I get a lawyer? I
[44:39] don't know? His defense attorney stated, nobody could go through nine hours of
[44:45] this. This is a law abiding citizen who thinks he's cooperating with police and
[44:52] that they're cooperating with him. In August, a judge dismissed the charges that
[44:57] Carl had concealed Levi's will, perjury, making an apparently false statement, and
[45:02] offering a false instrument for filing. The judge had found that Levi's handwritten will
[45:08] was not valid or a testamentary instrument. The judge then ruled that the incriminating
[45:15] statements that Karl had made to Cindy and to investigators were allowed to be endured
[45:20] as evidence during the upcoming murder trial. By November of twenty and thirteen,
[45:25] the murder trial was ready to begin. Just the day before the first day.
[45:30] However, Karl shuffled into court and changed his plea. He instead pleaded
[45:37] guilty to the second degree murder of Levi. He was asked by Judge Dennis
[45:43] Bender, do you acknowledge that Levi was unable to help himself when you left,
[45:50] and without help he was highly likely to die? Karl replied correct.
[45:57] Outside of court, Christina's sister, collect commented, I feel that justice was
[46:02] served today for my nephew, but my nephew would not be dead if California
[46:07] had done its job. Carl's daughter, who was Levi's sister, Erin,
[46:15] also said she was pleased that her father had been brought to justice for Levi's
[46:20] murder. She also said that she hoped for similar closure in her mother's death.
[46:28] It was revealed afterwards that in addition to taking out a life insurance policy
[46:32] on Cindy, Carl had taken out life insurance policies on Levi's two young children,
[46:40] worth almost seven hundred and fifty thousand dollars. Cindy commented how easy it
[46:49] would have been for him to lure them up into that barn and have an
[46:52] accident with some kind of equipment. I can guarantee you that was one of
[46:58] his plans. In fact, the fall before Carl was arrested, he had
[47:04] asked to take the two girls out of school to cut down Christmas trees with
[47:08] him in the woods. Levi's two children, Alitra and Ivy, never saw
[47:15] any money from their father's life insurance policy, even though various funds had been
[47:20] set aside for them. Karl had taken all of the money, and he
[47:24] and Cindy had purchased new cars and gone on vacation. Their mother, who
[47:30] was Levi's ex wife, commented, he killed his own son for money that
[47:35] should have gone to his grandchildren, and then he stole it from them.
[47:39] I can't even fathom that. In December, Karl Carlson was sentenced to fifteen
[47:45] years in prison. In handing down the sentence, judge Dennis Benders stated,
[47:50] it you belong in prison, and I suggest you belong there until you die.
[47:57] He then told Carl that he was not fully human. When he was
[48:02] asked whether he had anything to say, he said no. Afterwards, District
[48:07] Attorney Barry Poor stated no remorse, no I'm sorry, no apologies. Nothing.
[48:15] A parent would do anything to say of a child's life if they have
[48:19] the option, and he did the opposite kill his son. The investigation over
[48:35] in California continued, and in August of twenty fourteen, Carl was charged with
[48:39] the first degree murder of Christina. He was exordited to California to stand trial.
[48:47] Aaron, who was not an adult, had revealed that on the day
[48:51] her mother died, her father had taken her and her siblings outside to show
[48:57] them how quickly a house fire could stop. He took their dried up Christmas
[49:01] tree, poured kerosene on it, and then lit it with a match.
[49:07] Later, their mother took them inside for a nap. She and her sister
[49:12] Katie were in their bedroom while Levi I was in his. The next thing
[49:16] Aaron remembered was hearing her mother screaming Carl get the kids. She said that
[49:22] their bedroom door was ajar and when she looked out of it, she saft
[49:27] lambs. She recalled how she shut the door and went to open the bedroom
[49:31] window, but somebody had moved the drasser from the closet to block the window.
[49:38] Aaron couldn't move it aside, so she awoke her sister and then covered
[49:43] them with a blanket on the floor. A couple of minutes later, Carl
[49:47] either opened the window or broke through the window from outside and shoved the drasser
[49:52] to the side. Aaron recollected how she and her sister were placed into the
[49:58] truck by their father. Their dog, Lydia, was already in the truck.
[50:05] Carl then got Levi and asked them to keep their heads down and not
[50:08] look, but Aaron looked anyway. She said that she saw her father approaching
[50:14] the house and kicking the concrete foundations. He didn't once try to break into
[50:20] the bathroom window, he didn't attempt to re enter the home whatsoever, or
[50:25] appeared to be moving particularly fast. Aaron said that it was her who implored
[50:31] her father to go and get help. In the years that followed, Carl
[50:37] told his children a totally different story than that he told police. He claimed
[50:44] to them that a bathroom heater had sparked the fire and that the washer dryer
[50:49] had started it. As mentioned earlier, Carl had claimed that the window had
[50:54] been broken by Christina in the days leading up to the fire, hence the
[50:59] ply would boards. However, one of Christina's friends, Tracy Carpenter, had
[51:04] been at the home on the thirtieth of December and the window wasn't broken up
[51:08] or boarded, despite the fact that Carl said he boarded it. On the
[51:13] twenty ninth, during a preliminary hearing, Aaron testified about the abusive upbringing that
[51:20] they had at the hands of their father. She said that she and her
[51:23] siblings were often beaten and choked by Carl. She said that on one occasion
[51:29] he had held her by her shirt backward over the barn rafters. Levi had
[51:35] got the brunt of the abuse. She said that he was beaten by Carl
[51:38] with belts, pitchforks, electric cattle prods, shovels, and fists on a
[51:45] regular basis. She said that she had never reported the abuse because Carl had
[51:51] threatened to kill them. She further revealed that after Karl was arrested for Levi's
[51:55] murderer, she visited him in jail. She stated, I told him I
[52:01] knew what he'd done to my brother and mother. He smiled like a cheshire
[52:07] cat and said, it's been twenty years and they haven't caught me yet.
[52:12] They haven't caught me yet, and they're not going to get me now.
[52:15] Just a month before Christina had died, Carl had lifted out a two hundred
[52:20] thousand dollars life insurance policy on her. He also took out a one hundred
[52:24] thousand dollar policy for each of his three children. According to an Arson investigator,
[52:31] the kerosene on the carpet had been spilled less than an hour before the
[52:36] blaze. Karl had claimed that it was spilled on the thirtieth of December.
[52:42] The murder trial was scheduled for two thousand and eighteen, but the day it
[52:45] was vacated after Karl's defense attorney requested a mental competency evaluation. Garls found competent
[52:53] to stand trial and began on the thirteenth of January two thousand and twenty.
[53:00] Arrant testified during the trial and divulged the events leading up to the house fire.
[53:06] She also testified about confronting Karl after he was arrested for Levi's murder.
[53:12] She was asked by defense attorney Richard Esquivel whether her conclusions about her father had
[53:17] distorted her memory. She responded and pretty impartial to him. I don't hate
[53:23] him. I think his actions are reprehensible. Ken Thurston, retired firefighter who
[53:30] had attended the blaze, said to the court room that he was struck by
[53:34] the normalcy of Karl's demeanor. He stated, I didn't get the sense that
[53:38] he was saddened. There were a few things which really made me question what
[53:44] was going on. I would have been a basket case. Testimony was then
[53:49] presented by Heather Gower Small, a former fire claim representative. She said she
[53:55] had broached the subject of whether Karl had done anything, even inadvertently, to
[54:00] cause the house fire. Carl responded by banging his hands on the table,
[54:07] yelling, and then running down the hallway. She stated he was very angry.
[54:15] Carl then returned and said to her, if I had been in it
[54:17] for the money, why not the kids, I'd be a rich man.
[54:22] I'd have millions of dollars. Carl hadn't even waited a month before inquiring about
[54:28] the status of the life insurance policy. He was desperate to withdraw the money
[54:34] as quickly as possible, much like he was when leave I died. During
[54:39] closing arguments, District Attorney Barbara Yuke said to the jury, it's time to
[54:44] tell the defendant that life is more important than money. It's time to tell
[54:49] him he will not get away with Christina's death any longer. Christina Alexander Carlson
[54:54] was so many things to so many people. The defendant, she was no
[55:00] more than a piece of property. He extinguished the life that was Christina,
[55:05] and he did it on purpose. The jury ultimately found Carl Carlson guilty of
[55:10] the first degree murder of Christina Carlson. He was then sentenced to life in
[55:16] prison without the possibility of parole. They say that money is the root of
[55:23] all evil, and for decades, Carl Carlson had been thinking of ways to
[55:29] obtain more and more money. After successfully obtaining two hundred thousand dollars from Christina's
[55:37] death in nineteen ninety one, Carl continued lifting out life insurance policies on those
[55:44] closest to him. It wasn't until his second wife became suspicious that the floodgates
[55:51] finally opened, revealing Carl Carlson for who he truly was. Well, Bestie,
[56:20] thought is it for this episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you
[56:23] so so much for listening. I'd like to say a big, massive thank
[56:28] you to my nurse supporter off on Patreon, Ashley, because you all know
[56:32] Morpidology as a one woman team, so the support off on Patreon seriously go
[56:37] such a long way, and I really am eternally grateful for your love and
[56:40] support. The link to Patreon is in the show notes if you'd like to
[56:45] check it out. There are absolutely new obligations, you can cancel any time,
[56:50] and you can join for as little as one dollar a month. I
[56:53] upload odd, free and early release episodes, bonus episodes behind the Scene which
[57:00] includes case files, bonus audio, and bonus videos, and I also send
[57:05] out a hundred and thank you card along with some coolmer Remember to check us
[57:09] out a more bitology dot com for more information about this episode and to read
[57:14] or treat crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay
[57:19] safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
