# 223: Misty Cockerill & Tanya Smith

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 25 Sep 2023, 57 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56635595/morbidology_223_misty_cockerill_and_tanya_smith_ad_free.mp3

Situated approximately 70 kilometres from Vancouver, Abbotsford stands as a bedroom community in Canada. The cityscape is marked by extensive farmlands, orchards, and rolling hills that lend to its quaint rural allure. However, in 1995, Abbotsford was shaken by a brutal assault on two teenage girls who were making their way home from a party. Following the grim incident, the assailant initiated a series of unsettling phone calls to the police, forewarning of impending acts of violence. Detectives raced against the clock to identify the individual before he could make good on his threats. SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-223-tanya-smith-misty-cockerill PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] Yeah, I want to market to let me know who I am. Guns
[0:39] Right's been really good. Situated approximately seventy kilometers from Vancouver, Abbotsford Stands is
[0:54] a bedroom community in Canada. The city skipe is marked by extensive farmlands orchard
[1:00] unrolling hills that lend to its quaint rural allure. However, in ninety ninety
[1:04] five, Abbotsford was shaken by a brutal assault on two teenage girls who were
[1:08] making their way home from a party. Following the grim incident, the assailant
[1:14] initiated a series of unsettling phone calls to the police forewarning of impending acts of
[1:19] violence. Detectives raised against the clock to identified the individual before he could make
[1:26] good on those threats. Abbotsford was home to sixteen year old Tanya Smith,
[1:42] an intelligent and amicable teenage girl whose familial bonds were exceptionally strong. Those close
[1:49] to her portrayed her as a warm and loyal companion to everybody. She showered
[1:53] affection on her younger brother, endearingly referring to him as her little baby,
[1:59] and she continued to use the term mommy for her mother. Tanya's passions encompassed
[2:05] poetry, music, and art, with Christmas holding a special place in the
[2:09] family's heart. Every Christmas Eve, Tanya would gather at her grandparents home to
[2:15] craft candies alongside her artistic pursuits. Tanya Harbord a profound love for music,
[2:22] particularly for artists like you two and Seal. As a student at Abertsford Senior
[2:27] Secondary, Tanya formed a profound friendship with Misty Cockerell, her best friend.
[2:34] Both girls excelled in their studies, effortlessly making friends and a consistently achieving high
[2:39] grades. On the night of October thirteenth, nineteen ninety five, Misty and
[2:46] Tanya were at McDonald's and they met up with two of their friends, Sat
[2:51] pal Lapp and Manny nee Her. They were invited out to a party in
[2:55] suburban Surrey, but when they arrived it turned out to just be a group
[3:00] of teenagers drinking near the Fraser Park. Miss Antania stayed for a couple of
[3:07] ours and they had a few drinks, but they weren't drunk by any means.
[3:13] At around midnight, Sat and Manny dropped Missy Antania off at the Abbotsford
[3:16] Junior Secondary School, which wasn't too far away from where they lived. They
[3:23] embarked on their journey homeward, the glow of street lights, guiding their way
[3:28] through the night. Amidst the quiet darkness, an unforeseen presence materialized. Man
[3:37] emerged from the bushes, clutching tightly to a baseball bat. He firmly asked
[3:44] Missy Antania, do you bitches want to party? They said no, but
[3:51] the man then forced them off the street and into the shadows of a nearby
[3:53] parking lot the other side of the bushes. Once onto the cover of darkness,
[4:01] the man ordered them to undress. In response, Misty courageously refused,
[4:08] urging the man to release them. She said that they would keep the encounter
[4:14] a secret, only to be met by the man snarling do you think I'm
[4:18] stupid? Tanya was seized by fear and found herself immobilized. As she began
[4:25] to remove her clothing, Misty intervened, insisting that Tanya stop on dressing.
[4:32] She was convinced that the man intended to kill them regardless of their compliance.
[4:40] As Tanya tearfully removed her clothing, Misty resorted to a quick thinking ruse,
[4:46] simulating an asthma attack. The man then ordered Tanya volunteer hands and knees,
[4:53] and as he began to unbotton his pants, Misty seized this brief window of
[4:58] distraction grabbed his baseball bat. Misty managed to hit the man on the back,
[5:03] and a brief intense struggle followed. The man prevailed due to superior strength,
[5:12] wrestling the bat from Misty's grip, He unleashed a brutal attack on her,
[5:16] leaving her battered and unconscious. Ours later, as consciousness gradually returned,
[5:24] Misty found herself isolated beside the parking lot. She had sustained the broken arm,
[5:31] a broken finger, and a large gash on her head. Tanya and
[5:36] the man were nowhere to be seen. Misty's resilience shone through despite her injuries,
[5:45] as she mustered the determination to reach MSA hospital in Abbotsford, a mere
[5:50] few blocks away. Nurses met her in astonishment, greeted by her battered appearance,
[5:58] swollen head and face, an ominous trickle of spinal fluid from her ear,
[6:02] and her broken arm hanging limp at her side. She was fully clothed
[6:09] and she was carrying two jean jackets that her temperature was extremely low. With
[6:15] two nurses rushed to her side, she collapsed in their arms. Kathy Habury,
[6:20] an emergency nurse, recalled she was quite dazed. She gave one word
[6:27] answers. Misty was put on a stretcher and taken into her room so that
[6:31] she could be assessed. Within thirty minutes, she had completely stopped responding and
[6:38] needed to be rushed to Royal Columbian Hospital in Westminster for surgery. Upon her
[6:45] arrival, she was in a coma. Doctor Richard Chan ordered a computer scan
[6:49] of her brain, which revealed an extensive fracture running from the midside of her
[6:55] head down to the base of the skull. He also found that her brain
[6:59] was swept. He estimated that she had been struck multiple times in the head
[7:03] with considerable force, noting that her skull was caved in at the back.
[7:10] It was consistent with being struck with a baseball bat. If Misty hadn't have
[7:15] regained consciousness and walked to the hospital, and she would eventually have died from
[7:20] her injuries. Misty was auburiated dawn, and she finally awoke the next morning
[7:27] in a great deal of pain and confusion. In the hospital, detectives were
[7:31] eager to interview Misty. Although she had suffered a severe head injury, sporting
[7:38] a sizable hole in her skull. Around here at am that same morning,
[7:43] approximately fifteen kilometers away from the site of Tanya and Misty's assault, a man
[7:47] named Terry Maxwell was fishing at the Veda River. As he cast his line,
[7:54] his attention was drawn to something on the river bank. It was the
[7:58] lifeless body of Tanya. Acting swiftly, he contacted police, who arrived promptly
[8:05] and cordoned off the scene. Unbeknownst to them at the time, Tanya and
[8:11] Misty had been attacked together. Within a cluster of shrubbery. Near Tanya's body,
[8:18] detectives stumbled upon her bloody soaked t shirt, suggesting that it had been
[8:22] forcibly torn from her. Tanya's remains were subsequently transported to the medical examiner's office,
[8:31] where it was discovered that she had been struck on the head multiple times
[8:33] with a baseball bat, there was a bite mark to her left breast,
[8:39] and she had also been sexually assaulted. However, Tanya's autopsy indicated that her
[8:46] death had ultimately occurred by drawing in the river. Nonetheless, the pathologist noted
[8:52] that even without the river's involvement, the severity of her head injuries would have
[8:56] proven fatal. Simultaneously, at the hospital, Misty had regained consciousness and was
[9:01] prepared to cooperate with detectives. She recalled the events involving the man who had
[9:07] intercepted her and Tanya as they journeyed homeward. It was the first time that
[9:13] detectives were able to connect the murder of Tanya with the assault of Misty.
[9:18] In her description, she painted a picture of a tall, lean man standing
[9:24] nearly seven feet tall, with a receding hairline, frizzy hair, mustache,
[9:30] and prominent bulging eyes. The discovery of Tanya's body and Misty's recollections spurred an
[9:37] immediate murder unattempted murder investigation, with the dedicated team of sixteen detectives assigned to
[9:43] the case. A public release of the man's description ensued, accompanied by a
[9:50] plea for anybody with potentially relevant information to come forward. Additionally, Misty's account
[9:58] hinted at the possibility of a two on the man's arm, although she couldn't
[10:01] confirm this detail. In light of these developments, detectives issued a cautionary advisory
[10:07] to women in the area, particularly those venturing alone or in small groups during
[10:13] the nighttime hours. Amid intensifying efforts in the investigation, a series of unsettling
[10:20] phone calls inundated the police lines. Detectives held firm in their belief that the
[10:26] calls originated from the very killer they were chasing by his accurate descriptions of the
[10:31] attack that had not yet been disclosed to the public. He made a reference
[10:37] to the bite mark on Tanya's right breast, something that had never been publicly
[10:41] revealed. I am really good. He described in great detail the location where
[10:52] he had left Tanya's body, and the operator had asked where he got that
[10:56] information from. Each responded I'm the killer, before adding you guys did a
[11:05] real thorough job, But do you think I would be stupid enough to leave
[11:09] fingerprints? Adding to the challenge, civilians manning the police communications center had taken
[11:16] each call, but they were so brief that the detective couldn't get to the
[11:20] phone in time to correspond with the killer personally. Phone calls had all come
[11:24] from local payphones, and when detectives went to fingerprint them, the killer called
[11:31] them again. A brazen catch me if you can demeanor came across his voice
[11:41] as he made threats of more violence. During one of the calls, the
[11:46] killer had warned, I'm giving you the chance to try and find me.
[11:50] I'll be cruising around looking for someone else moving around that The unnerving faucet of
[12:03] his taunting was not lost on detectives. It hinted at a disturbing satisfaction derived
[12:09] from the notoriety from the murder and attempted murder. This only hide in concerns
[12:16] of another attack so that he could feel that same high again. Constable Ellie
[12:22] saw Chalk announced, we have reason to believe this person will strike again.
[12:26] We want parents to keep their children in at night. The harrowing phone call
[12:31] struck a particularly painful chord within Tanya's family. Either Foger, her aunt,
[12:37] commented, this person is a sicko. He's a monster. After the threats
[12:45] from the killer came in, more detectives were assigned to investigate the case.
[12:50] It was imperative that they could catch whoever was responsible before he had the opportunity
[12:56] to strike again. The city of Abbotsford turned into a complete ghost horn as
[13:03] nightfall descended, as people were too petrified of venturing out even in small groups.
[13:09] Abbotsford taxis became increasingly popular as parents began sending their daughters to and from
[13:16] school in a taxi to prevent them from having to walk anywhere. A composite
[13:20] sketch of the killer was drawn up and it was distributed far and wide.
[13:26] Some people within the community thought that the killer looked familiar, but they couldn't
[13:31] put a name to the face. Laugh Banal, general manager of the park
[13:37] In hotel, commented, I know I've seen him before. The face looks
[13:41] very familiar. He's been in Abbotsford before. His comments were echoed by a
[13:48] bartender at the Fraser Valley Inn in downtown. He said that he had talked
[13:54] with other people at the hotel. He said that the killer had been in
[13:58] the hotel before. On October twenty second, a distressing incident unfolded in southeast
[14:07] Vancouver. The twenty seven year old woman was walking alongside her sister when a
[14:11] man in a worn of full sized car caught their attention. The car's alloyed
[14:18] muffler and repeated passes around them raised alarm. The man in the car honked
[14:22] incessantly, signaling for them to approach him. As they neared an intersection,
[14:28] The man abruptly parked, leapt out of his vehicle and forcefully grabbed one of
[14:33] the women's arms. He shouted, demanding that she get into his car.
[14:39] She fought back, screaming, and managed to break free just as he attempted
[14:43] to drag her towards his vehicle. Later that evening, while at home,
[14:48] the sisters watched the news and sought a composite sketch of the man connected to
[14:52] the attacks on Tania and Misty. They recognized him as the same man who
[14:58] had tried to abduct one of them earlier. They immediately contacted police, prompting
[15:03] detectives to publicly speculate that the killer had made another attempt at murder. The
[15:09] sister, who was almost dragged into the vehicle, added her voice to detective
[15:13] warnings for residents to stay off the streets at night, telling BCTV please listen
[15:20] closely. He just avoid got me. It could be that next person who
[15:26] will not get away. I was one of the lucky ones. The warnings
[15:31] to stay indoors expanded to the entire Vancouver area, as people were warned it
[15:35] was too dangerous to even walk in groups. Meanwhile, more than four hundred
[15:41] mourners packed into a local church to bid Tanya one final farewell. Her parents
[15:46] spoke before the crowd. We will never hold her in her arms again on
[15:52] this earth. Will always hold her close in her heart until we meet again.
[15:58] Boy Friend Adam Underwood struggled to hold back tears as you read a poem
[16:03] called Lost Love. It read in part, when the song goes down and
[16:08] there are friends all around, there's been a lost love. When you look
[16:14] up at the sky and you feel you're going to cry, there's been a
[16:18] lost love. After Tanya was laid to rest, the investigation continued and a
[16:25] thirty thousand dollar reward for information that led to the apprehension and conviction of her
[16:30] killer was put forward. Widespread apprehension of the killery surfacing gripped Abbotsford and its
[16:36] surrounding regions. This concern propelled the community into action, prompting a local woman
[16:42] to organize an event titled Taking Back the Streets. Jennifer Oliver, The organizer,
[16:51] shared that her decision for orchestrating the rally was to demonstrate that the killer
[16:56] didn't hold sway over the community's way of life. Her aspiration was for this
[17:02] rally to become a weekly fixture until the apprehension of the perpetrator. The community
[17:07] came out in droves, and Jennifer said before the crowd, people say that
[17:11] one person can't make a difference, but they can. She emphasize that the
[17:15] ralligh aimed to send a clear message to the killer, raising the hurdles for
[17:21] his potential future victims. Commanding with a small memorial for Tanya, the event
[17:27] participants then undertook a walk around the nearby lake, the same location where Tanya's
[17:33] body was found. Mere days after the ralligh, on Halloween, the police
[17:40] received another ominous phone call from the killer. The caller placed the call from
[17:45] a phone booth, issuing further threats of violence. Detectives traced the call to
[17:52] a foam booth in Abbotsford, but by that time the killerhood already avaded to
[17:57] capture. Nevertheless, forensic experts were able to dust the phone booth for fingerprints.
[18:04] Subsequent to the public revelation of the phone call, a woman came forward
[18:10] with crucial information. She recounted encountering a man at the sports bar where she
[18:15] worked on Halloween night around eight pm. The man saw a payphone, but
[18:19] was informed that there wasn't one and an alternative offer to use the bar's telephone
[18:25] was extended. Declining the offer, the man promptly left the bar. The
[18:30] barmaid disclosed it upon his departure, she recognized him as the killer. She
[18:37] noted that his appearance had been altered. He had shaved off his mustache and
[18:41] was wearing a black hat and black T shirt. In the ensuing wakes,
[18:48] the community once again united for a twilight rally. Streets that were once stesilate
[18:53] now teamed with a round three hundred participants, predominantly women, as they embarked
[18:59] on a mission to reclaim the night. On the sixth of November, detectives
[19:06] made the decision to unveil segments of the phone conversations made by the killer in
[19:11] the hope that somebody might be able to identify his voice. As analyzed by
[19:17] a speech specialist in Vancouver, the man seemed to have adopted an inflection pattern
[19:22] that diverged from his usual manner of speech. The specialist noted that his age
[19:29] could possibly range between thirty and fifty, or somewhere in that vicinity. His
[19:34] speech bore the hallmarks of a standard Central North American accent, perhaps even hinting
[19:41] at a Canadian origin. Shortly after the release of the phone calls, rontoier
[19:47] m another distressing incident unfolded. A lone woman was targeted and assaulted while walking
[19:52] along a path nestled between two apartment buildings in the city. The attacker,
[20:00] although one arm, subjected her to a traumatic sexual assault before fleeing on foot
[20:03] into the night. The description provided by the victim aligned remarkably well with those
[20:11] from previous cases, leading detectives to suspect that he had once again acted upon
[20:17] his chilling threats. The investigation persisted with unwavering determination. On the tenth of
[20:25] November, detectives definitively ruled out any connection between the attempted abduction on the nineteenth
[20:30] of October in South Vancouver and the brutal murder of Tanya, along with the
[20:36] attempted murder of Misty. Similarly, they dismissed any link between the earlier rape
[20:41] case and the ongoing investigation. The sobering realization painted an even more unsettling picture
[20:51] the presence of not one, but at least two violent sexual predators operating within
[20:56] the vicinity. Then, on the first of December, a break through emerged.
[21:02] When detectives arrested a man named George Evanden. He was arrested on an
[21:07] assault charge, and detectives noticed that he looked remarkably similar to the composite sketch.
[21:14] They accused him of being the Abbotsford killer and denied him bail. According
[21:19] to some of his acquaintances, he had bragged about assaulting Misty while another man
[21:25] raped Tanya. However, when George provided his dNaM bite marks, it became
[21:30] evident that he wasn't the killer. He accused those acquaintances of being drug addicts
[21:37] that were desperate to make bank on the reward fund. George was ultimately released,
[21:41] but his life was made a living hell from his association to the unsolved
[21:45] case. As the days turned into months, the momentum of the case waned
[21:52] and the elusive killer seemed to vanish without leaving a trace. However, the
[21:56] dark narrative resumed in February of the following year. This time the scene shifted
[22:03] to eighty five Radio Marx Radio station in Abertsford, where Mike Sison, an
[22:10] employee, found himself at the center of the unfolding drama. Amid his work
[22:15] duties, a sudden call demanded his attention. On the other end of the
[22:21] line was a voice instructing him to inspect the company vehicle situated within the parking
[22:26] lot. He recollected. My first thought was that someone who had our car
[22:30] and didn't have the nerve to tell us. The truth, however, was
[22:36] much more sinister stabbing outside, the perplexing site of a gravestone on top of
[22:42] their news cruiser came into sight. While the possibility of a prank initially loomed,
[22:48] a closer examination unveiled an unsettling truth. The gravestone on top of the
[22:55] news cruiser belonged to Tanya, and it had been removed from her resting place
[23:00] and positioned with calculated intent on the radio station's news cruiser. The gravestone bore
[23:08] evidence of jassecretion, its surface marred by crude inscriptions of profanity and threats.
[23:17] Among the chilling phrases were messages such as I'm looking for more and I'm still
[23:22] out there. However, the most unsettling of them all was the unequivocal threat
[23:27] that read, Misty Cockerell your next I'm still looking for you. The tip
[23:40] swiftly reached detectives from a vigilant member of the public who had observed an older
[23:45] model Volkswagen van, possibly adorned in shades of blue or teal, with an
[23:51] assortment of colors on its side, in close proximity to Tanya's grave site around
[23:56] midnight. Detectives urged the community to stellar for this distinctive vehicle, which could
[24:02] potentially be linked to the killer. They also encouraged anybody who encountered it to
[24:07] promptly communicate their findings. In short order, another phone call reached the detectives,
[24:14] originating from a payphone located just two blocks away from the station at a
[24:18] stadium. The voice on the opposite end of the line had grown familiar to
[24:23] those manning the dispatch center. It was none other than the killer himself,
[24:30] who proceeded to issue yet another threat of impending violence. Responding with urgency,
[24:36] detective sped towards the stadium's payphone, sirens wailing in the night, only to
[24:41] find that the killer had already vanished. Corporal John's GROUPA offered his perspective,
[24:48] remarking, as you can imagine, the boys were down there immediately. Somebody's
[24:52] having a good time watching from someplace. Who knows where This guy's playing games
[24:59] with us. The killer's recent actions underscored his continued presence within the Abbotsford vicinity.
[25:07] It was as if he was closely observing the detective struggles to catch him
[25:11] from nearby, Engaging in a relentless game of Captain Moyce. He taunted the
[25:15] authorities for their inability to apprehend him, seizing the psychological upper hand. It
[25:22] was apparent that he was prolonging the gratifaction derived from the crime by beating the
[25:26] detectives. Mike Webster, a police psychologist, analyzed the situation, affirming that
[25:33] the perpetrator sought to assert a form of control over detectives by showcasing his supremacy
[25:41] and intellect through the phone calls. Reconvening the task force originally assembled in October
[25:48] to probe the murder and attempted murder, detectives regroup and extended police protection to
[25:52] Misty, aware of the looming threat. After her release from the hospital,
[25:59] she had grasped, but she still suffered from headaches, dizziness, and she
[26:03] had difficulty hearing in her right ear. She also reported that she was irritable
[26:10] at times and had a short attention span. Just a couple of days later,
[26:15] the killer would rambob his chilling communication. On the twenty second of February,
[26:22] a disturbing incident unfolded just blocks away from the Homicide Task Forces headquarters.
[26:27] The Peters family became unwittingly involved as a ranch was hurled through their window,
[26:33] accompanied by a note from the elusive killer. Crystal Peters was at home with
[26:37] her eleven year old son when the note came smashing through her window. The
[26:44] note was stuffed inside an envelope which read from the abby Killer, Call nine
[26:49] one one. Crystal didn't touch the envelope before calling police. They arrived promptly
[26:56] and they examined the note. It ran, Hello, it's me. It
[27:02] was me that phone from Rotary Stadium that night. You cops getting pissed off
[27:07] yet or to catch someone who's smart, not like stupid crooks. Thee then
[27:12] made reference to a few more of my conquests before continuing, I told you
[27:18] it wasn't my first. It won't be my last either. I don't stay
[27:22] with the same modus operandi. I have done a few more after these ones.
[27:27] The killer then referenced three other sexual assaults that he had attempted to commit
[27:33] in the year leading up to the attack on Tania and Misty. The note
[27:37] then added, Hey, that was the same bat that was used on Misty
[27:41] and Tanya. Hey, guys, I'm bad. I will strike again one
[27:47] day. I will not be caught. I will not move from Abertsfurt.
[27:52] Included with the note, we're newspaper clippings about the unsolved nineteen eighty five murders
[27:57] of Linda Tatrai, Calling Shook, and Kim Stolberg, all of whom had
[28:03] been stabbed to death. Detectives diligently connected the dots, pimpointing this sextual assault
[28:07] cases alluded to in the note, dating back to September nineteen ninety four,
[28:14] and continuing with two more occurrences during the summer of nineteen ninety five. Although
[28:19] these incidents had been documented at the time, the connections had escaped the detective's
[28:25] grasp, as they had occurred before Tanya's tragic murder. Upon revisiting the cases,
[28:32] detectives uncovered a crucial lead. One survivor recalled her rapist sporting a distinctive
[28:38] tattoo on his forearm, an anchor encircled by a rope, perhaps accompanied by
[28:44] the name Jamie. Detectives released an updated composite sketch of the suspect that included
[28:51] an anchor tattoo on his forearm. Shortly after the Ranch incident, detectives received
[28:56] another phone call from the killer. He queried, how would you like my
[29:03] present? I gave you? Guys, it won't be the last. Despite
[29:10] extensive efforts that had already incurred a cost of one point three million dollars,
[29:15] the investigation seemed to tread water. Descriptions of the killer, coupled with his
[29:22] distinct voice, were at hand, yet the final pieces of the puzzle evaded
[29:26] the detective's grasp. The communities on ease grew with the specter of another potential
[29:32] attack. A spring break approached, students were advised to stay vigilant against the
[29:37] looming threat known as the Abbotsford Killer, with recommendations including traveling in groups,
[29:45] staying alert during nighttime, and promptly reporting any suspicious activities. March brought further
[29:53] changes to the investigation, with the task forces numbers reduced from fifty five officers
[30:00] to thirty five. In a professional assessment, police psychologist Mike Webster revealed that
[30:07] the killer was unlikely to re engage with the authorities in the immediate future due
[30:11] to his sphear of capture. Webster explained the internal conflict within the killer,
[30:18] torn between his desire for control over the police and community and to simultaneous yearning
[30:25] to maintain his freedom. In early May, Tanya's parents spoke publicly for the
[30:30] very first time. Her mother, Gail Smith, wrote an open letter that
[30:34] was broadcast on regional television. She solemnly declared, I beg you, if
[30:42] you suspect or know the person who committed this crime, please call. You
[30:48] may love this person, who may not know what to do, but for
[30:52] the safety of all our children, please get him the help that he desperately
[30:56] needs and stop this happening to somebody Else's words would resonate with the community,
[31:02] but in particular with a mother who had been harboring some suspicions. Terry Driver,
[31:11] a thirty one year old married painter and father of two, was a
[31:14] resident of Abbotsford. Alongside him was his wife, Valerie, a credit union
[31:19] teller, and their children, six year old Kenny and three ruled an.
[31:26] The family was recognized for their unassuming nature, often keeping to themselves. Within
[31:30] their quiet existence, Givers found them amicable. A Driver frequently fostered community bond
[31:37] by hosting barbecues and sharing freshly caught fish with those nearby. Having previously served
[31:45] as a Scout leader in Burnaby under the title Scoyder, Terry Driver garnered respect
[31:49] from both the boys under his guidance and their parents. This aspect of his
[31:56] character illustrated his prowess as a capable, well regarded leader. At a recent
[32:01] high school reunion, Terry Driver probably showcased photographs of his wife and children while
[32:08] expressing his admiration for them. As the community grappled with the tension caused by
[32:15] the Abbotsford killer, Driver engaged his neighbors in discussions about the ongoing case.
[32:22] It was notable that Driver's father grant Driver at a background as retired Vancouver Police
[32:28] sergeant. This connection led neighbors to speculate the driver's keen interest in the case
[32:35] might be attributed to his familial ties, with police related items adorning his house
[32:42] and a pension for turning into the police scanner. Driver seemed to carry forward
[32:45] his father's legacy brand, a prominent figure in the community, had been celebrated
[32:52] for his acts of bravery. Notably, he had leapt into the frigid waters
[32:57] of English Bay in May nineteen seventy nine to rescue a woman in the middle
[33:01] of a suicide attempt. Additionally, his line of duty had subjected him to
[33:07] a gunshot wound and two stabbings in the early nineteen eighties. In Driver's school
[33:14] yearbook, he said that his hero was his father and that he too wanted
[33:19] to join the police force. After Gail pleaded for people to come forward and
[33:23] identify the killer, Terry Driver's mother, Audrey Teague, was conflicted. She
[33:30] and her other son Dawn, had listened to the phone calls from the Abbotsford
[33:35] killer. I thought they sounded remarkably similar to Terry Driver. They sat on
[33:42] and talked about it, and ultimately decided to call detectives and give them Terry's
[33:46] name as a potential suspect. Terry Driver was immediately arrested, and on the
[33:53] fifth of May he found himself facing charges of first degree murder in connection to
[34:00] Manya's murder. Alongside this grave of accusation, he was also charged with the
[34:05] attempted murder of Misty. As he stood in court, he positioned his arms
[34:09] across his chest, directing his gaze squarely at the judge, occasionally casting fleeting
[34:15] glances towards his father Grant. In the public gallery, Tanya's loved ones gathered,
[34:22] seeking their first glimpse of the man who stood accused of killing her.
[34:28] The arrest of Terry Driver sent shockwaves throughout those who had known him, as
[34:31] the community had spent the past six months envisioning the killer as an obvious outsider,
[34:38] somebody detached from their midst. Driver's outwardly demeanor had portrayed him as a
[34:45] contently married man and an affectionate father to his two young children, Adding to
[34:52] the community's sense of bewilderment. Driver bore little resemblance to the composite sketch.
[35:00] He was stalky, fresh faced, and blonde haired, and he looked like
[35:04] the average guy next door. The composite sketch conversely depicted a slender individual with
[35:12] a lean face and bolding, raddish hair. Moreover, Driver didn't possessed the
[35:19] described forearm. Tattu Constable Sawchok said of the discrepancies, a composite sketch's a
[35:25] guidance. It's the best tool we have based on a victim's recollection. The
[35:32] accuracy of such sketches can be influenced by numerous factors, including the victim's injuries
[35:37] and trauma, both of which Misty had experienced. The discrepancies raised concerns that
[35:45] detectives might have arrasted the wrong person. Driver's employer, Bob Dick with steadfast
[35:52] in his belief in Driver's innocence, stating to the media, He's an excellent
[35:57] worker and an excellent guy. He's honest to a fault. Others who were
[36:04] familiar with Terry Driver echoed this sentiment. Enid Larsen voiced her thoughts, steering,
[36:10] we all like Terry, and I won't believe it's him who's the killer
[36:15] until they come up with DNA evidence to prove it. However, society often
[36:21] yearns from monstrous figures to be easily distinguishable. There exists a collective desire for
[36:28] sex killers to stand out, yet the reality is quite the opposite. These
[36:34] sinister characters often have a knock for seamlessly assimilating into the very fabric of our
[36:40] communities, the deptly camouflaging themselves the seemingly unremarkable individuals. Those who defended Terry
[36:50] Driver would soon come to learn that he had managed to conceal the depths of
[36:54] his depravity from everyone. During his childhood, Terry Driver had been diagnosed with
[37:02] both threat syndrome and attention deficit disorder. These conditions exposed him to the harsh
[37:07] realities of bullying, which he later channeled into cruel acts against small animals.
[37:15] He took his reajoit on these animals, killing them and also engaging in petty
[37:21] theft. During his youth, his aspiration was to follow in his father's footsteps
[37:27] and become a police officer, but he faced disappointment when he failed the entrance
[37:30] test for the force. The setback deeply affected Driver, leaving him with a
[37:37] sense of inadequacy and failure. As a young man, Driver frequented sex workers,
[37:44] a behavior he continued even after his marriage in nineteen ninety. Although Driver
[37:50] had surfaced in the investigation in Titania's murder, he had never been considered a
[37:54] suspect or a person of interest. He only surfaced when he was caught on
[38:00] detective surveillance footage of Tanya's funeral, bringing along with him his two young children.
[38:09] However, when Driver was eventually apprehended, he was requested to provide both
[38:15] fingerprints and DNA samples. During the analysis of the node attached to the wrench
[38:21] that had been thrown through Crystal Peter's window, an unidentified fingerprint was discovered on
[38:27] the adhesive side of the tape securing the envelope to the wrench. Strikingly,
[38:32] when Driver's finger prints were compared, they were a perfect match to the previously
[38:38] unattributed print. The evidence became even more damming when the semen formed inside Tanya
[38:45] was found to be a complete match to Terry Driver's DNA. The revelations proved
[38:52] the far too often wolves can lurk in sheep's clothing. Terry Driver was ultimately
[39:00] ordered to stand trial for the murder and attempted murder. As the case was
[39:05] making its way through the justice system, detectives working on the investigation brought Tanya
[39:09] a new gravestone. On the fourth of July. They gathered by her grave
[39:15] site alongside her parents, Gail and Terry, to dedicate the new gravestone.
[39:21] The old one was secured in evidence storage was expected to be part of the
[39:24] upcoming trial. Gail thanked the detectives for their unwavering support and their dedication to
[39:30] cracking the case. She said that their younger daughter Kristen, was still unable
[39:36] to talk about Tanya's murder. As for their four year old son, Brandon,
[39:40] all he ever talked about was his sister. Through tears, Gaale said,
[39:47] it's been pretty hard these past eight months. I'm still in shock.
[39:52] I'm still basically numb. The hard part was it took so long. We
[39:57] never thought this would end. In November, Driver was charged with sexual assault,
[40:02] assault causing bodily harm, and aggravated assault. These charges related to the
[40:07] cases he had divulged in, the latter attached to the ranch that he heard
[40:12] through a local family's home. By the ninth of September nineteen ninety seven,
[40:16] Terry Driver's trial was set to begin before Judge Wally Opal. The proceedings were
[40:22] conducted without a jury in New Westminster. On that morning. The courtroom was
[40:27] filled with all of Tanya and Misty's loved ones. During the opening statements,
[40:31] prosecutor Neil mackenzie revealed the harrowing details of the attack that claimed Tanya's life.
[40:38] He then informed the jury that despite Driver's not guilty plea for murder and attempted
[40:43] murderer, he had acknowledged that his seaman was discovered within Tanya's body. Moreover,
[40:49] a driver had confessed to making the phone calls to police following the murder.
[40:53] Driver's defense attorney Glenn Orris conceded that his client would also admit to defeate
[41:00] sing Tanya's grave stone and leaving it outside the radio station. He acknowledged the
[41:05] driver confessed to writing the note attached to the wrench. However, defense attorney
[41:09] Orris stated the disclient would testify that somebody else had committed the assault on Tanya
[41:15] and Misty. Driver's defense was that he merely stumbled upon Tanya's lifeless body.
[41:23] Testimony swiftly commenced, featuring accounts from various doctors and nurses at the hospital where
[41:30] Misty was treated. The two boys who had driven Tanya and Misty back to
[41:34] Abbotsford, Zat and Many, also testified. They were questioned about any sexual
[41:40] encounters with Tanya or if they had caused the bite mark on her breast.
[41:45] Both denied any involvement. On the trial second day, the prosecution's key witness
[41:52] took to the stand, Misty Cockerell. She was asked to identify the man
[41:58] responsible for the attack on her Tanya. Misty pointed directly a driver who was
[42:04] seated with his defense team. In response, he nervously smiled at her and
[42:08] then nodded. Misty proceeded to recoint the attack, describing how she managed to
[42:15] wrestle the baseball bat from driver's grip. She recalled that he had insulted her
[42:21] with the derogatory language, calling her a fat bitch and telling her that she
[42:25] was going to die. She spoke of Tanya, describing her as the most
[42:31] forgiving and sweetest person she had ever known. Misty expressed her enduring sense of
[42:37] low, stating I missed her lots still. During cross examination, Misty acknowledged
[42:44] that she had been unable to positively identify driver from a police lineup on the
[42:49] day he was arrested. Nevertheless, she noted that the driver had similar eyes
[42:53] to the man who had assaulted her and Tanya. Following court that day,
[42:59] Misty spoke to several reporters and touched upon the disparities between her description and driver's
[43:05] appearance. She stated, you have to see someone in person to actually recognize
[43:12] somebody. If he was four foot eleven in real life, I'd think he
[43:15] was seven feet I think anybody looks taller when they're beating you up and scaring
[43:22] you. During the trial, the forensic evidence against Driver was presented, including
[43:29] his fingerprint on the note and to seaman found inside Tanya. Driver's best friend,
[43:35] Cliff Sharer, next took to the stand to provide his testimony. He
[43:40] recounted an unsettling incident where Driver had brought his young children to Tanya's funeral,
[43:46] an event that had been captured on detective's cameras. This could be a common
[43:52] occurrence in unsolved murders, in particular murders where the perpetrator likes to taunt the
[43:58] detectives. Cliff further shared that on October fourteenth, Driver had dialed him from
[44:04] his cell phone, revealing that he was by the Verda River surveying a crime
[44:08] scene gordoned off with yellow tape. He recounted Driver's words, he said he
[44:15] was going down there with his kids to see what was going on. This
[44:21] stretch of the Veta River was familiar territory for Driver, as it was a
[44:24] favored fishing spot for both him and Cliff. Cliff recalled how he and Driver
[44:30] had once listened to the radio together, tuning in to the killer's unsettling phone
[44:35] calls to the police. In a moment of eerie insight, Cliff had commented
[44:42] that voice sounds like you. Driver's reply had been swift and resolute, No,
[44:49] it's not me. Bring the matter to a close. Later, George
[44:53] Evanstone took to the stand. Having previously been considered a suspect, he recoined
[45:00] being at home shortly after eleven pm on the night of the murder. The
[45:04] defense attempted to establish him as a potential alternative suspect, suggesting his involvement in
[45:09] the crime. However, no substantive evidence linked him to the attack or the
[45:15] subsequent community wide terror. Following George's testimony, the prosecution concluded their case and
[45:22] the defense commenced theirs. Terry Driver was called upon as a defense witness,
[45:29] leaving the courtroom in a state of shock with his astonishing claim. He asserted
[45:35] that he had chanced upon Tanya and Misty after the attack had transpired. According
[45:40] to Driver, he had been drawn to the scene by the side of a
[45:44] man fleeing as he arrived. Expressing hesitation due to his father's former police profession,
[45:51] he opted against summoning help, fearing the detectives would unjustly pin the crime
[45:55] on him. In a harrowing twist, Or detailed his alleged disturbing actions that
[46:01] night. He said that he first left the crime scene before deciding to return.
[46:08] He recalled, the picture of what I had seen kept popping into my
[46:14] mind, particularly the picture of the naked woman lying on the ground. I
[46:20] decided I could go back, find where the place was, half sex with
[46:23] Tanya, leave, then go make an anonymous call. He claimed that he
[46:30] sexually assaulted Tanya, explaining how his seamen had ended up inside of her.
[46:36] He maintained that she was alive during the assault but had convulsed. Subsequently,
[46:40] he disclosed how he disposed of Tanya's body in the Vetta River, aiming to
[46:45] raise any evidence of the assault. He also claimed he transported Misty to a
[46:51] location near MSA Hospital. According to Driver, when he put Tanya in Vetta
[46:58] River, he believed that she's already dead. Driver's testimony was so horrific that
[47:04] most of Tanya's family left the courtroom in disgust. Under cross examination, Driver
[47:12] refused to say that he had raped Tanya, instead saying he had sex with
[47:16] her. Prosecutor Mardigan bluntly responded, you raped her Driver then shot back,
[47:23] I sexually assaulted her. Driver was then asked about why he had attended Tanya's
[47:30] funeral and he replied it was my way of thinking of dealing with what happened
[47:36] and to say sorry to her. He was also asked about why he had
[47:38] made the threatening phone calls and the letter, but he said that they were
[47:43] impulses he wasn't able to explain. He then later said that he was just
[47:47] giving the media what they wanted. On the witness stand, Driver also admitted
[47:52] to using a crew bar to pry up Tanya's grave stone. Testimony regarding his
[47:59] Turets syndrome was then presented. His Devents team called on doctor mort Dorn,
[48:05] who testified about the disorder in an effort to explain his alleged impulses to make
[48:09] the phone calls. Driver was also diagnosed with a tension deficit disorder, and
[48:15] doctor Dorn said the people with such a disorder do not process information in a
[48:21] conventional manner. He said that they often say something before they think. Driver
[48:27] was a hyperactive child who often destroyed things and only slept for a round four
[48:31] hours a night. When he was eight years old, he was placed in
[48:35] the Children's Foundation Home. Psychiatrist roy O'Shaughnessy testified next and said the driver's idolization
[48:44] of his father and his desire to be a police officer could have explained the
[48:47] taunting of the police. He revealed the during an interview, Driver had initially
[48:53] said that he acted himself. Defence Misty had said that she hit her assailant
[49:00] with a baseball bat. However, Driver, who was obviously anxious, then
[49:07] switched his story and claimed he stumbled upon the scene. Since Driver had felt
[49:13] like a failure because he couldn't join the police force, it was suggested that
[49:16] the taunting phone calls made him feel powerful. Once the testimony was complete,
[49:22] closing arguments were presented, Prosecutor Sean Mardigan said of Driver, this is one
[49:29] of the more incredible witnesses you will ever see. He said that the case
[49:34] was one of the worst he had ever seen, but said that it was
[49:37] papered over with psychological evidence. He stated, if this man were pleading insanity,
[49:44] I might say there's an idea, but he's not, and there's no
[49:47] evidence he's insane. Defense attorney Glenn Or has said that his client should be
[49:52] convicted of manslaughter instead since he was responsible for Tanya's inadvertent death, but said
[50:00] that he was not the assailant and therefore not responsible. The crux of the
[50:06] case hinged on whether or not the judge believed driver's claims that he just so
[50:10] happened to stumble across the crime scene it's actually as Sultanne, and then throw
[50:15] her Invertera River to die. The judge also needed to believe the driver made
[50:21] the taunting phone calls Stoltania's grave stone and wrote the threatening note not because he
[50:27] was the killer, but simply because he felt the urge to do so.
[50:31] He returned with a verdict the following week and Foundary Driver guilty of first degree
[50:37] murder and attempted murder. Driver was then sentenced to life in prison without the
[50:43] possibility of parole for at least twenty five years. In hunting John the sentence,
[50:49] Judge Apples stated, I cannot find the words to accurately describe and depicture
[50:54] horrible crimes. He suggested the Driver had enjoyed the notoriety of being the Abbotsford
[51:01] killer and said he didn't believe his unusual story. He commented, I watched
[51:07] you give your evidence. There did not seem to be the slightest remorse.
[51:13] It was extraordinary outside of Courtsanya's family said they were pleased with the verdict,
[51:17] but lamented on the impact the loss of their daughter had Her father, Terry
[51:22] stated, I drive to the school to pick up Kristen and it's almost across
[51:29] the street from where it happened. I drive past Rotary Stadium and see the
[51:34] phone booth where Driver made one of his phone calls. We used to go
[51:38] for picnics at the Vettera River. If I had my way, I'd moved
[51:43] far away from Abbotsford. But I can't do that to the kids. All
[51:47] their friends are here. In the aftermath of the verdict, it was announced
[51:53] that the thirty thousand dollar reward fund was going to Terry Driver's family for providing
[51:59] detectives with his name. However, there was a massive debate on whether or
[52:04] not they would actually receive it. Driver's mother and brother had stood by his
[52:08] side and claimed that he was innocent of the murder. A special committee was
[52:15] put together to make a decision on whether or not the reward would go to
[52:19] the family. Meanwhile, Driver's mother, Audrey, shared that she wished she
[52:25] never turned her son in at all. During an appearance on Open for Discussion,
[52:30] she said, I wouldn't do it again. If I had to do
[52:34] it over again, I would take him to the side and I would get
[52:37] help for him privately. It was ultimately decided that Audrey and Dawn would share
[52:43] ten thousand dollars of the reward fund. Then, in May of nineteen ninety
[52:47] eight, it was announced that Terry Driver was going to stand trial on five
[52:52] sex related charges between nineteen ninety four and nineteen ninety five. He was convicted
[52:58] of attacking to women, but the jury acquitted him on charges involving a third
[53:02] woman. The following year, prosecutors saw to have Driver declared a dangerous offender
[53:08] and given an indeterminate sentence. During a hearing, it was revealed that he
[53:15] admitted to still fantasizing about sexually assaulting unconscious women. He had also admitted to
[53:22] still fantasizing about sexually assaulting Tanya. Driver was ultimately declared a dangerous offender,
[53:31] but instead of the usual indeterminate prison sentence, his designation only lasted fifteen years.
[53:39] Mister Cockerrell went on to become a massive victim and survivor's advocate, sharing
[53:45] her experience. During various crime awareness talks, she stated, I can't stand
[53:52] the stigma of being a victim. I hate that label because some people think
[53:55] they're a victim for the rest of their lives. She went on to become
[54:00] a mother of two and earned a social worker diploma at uc F FEE.
[54:07] She said that one day she hoped to learn why Driver did what he did,
[54:10] but unfortunately she never got the chance. On the twenty third of August
[54:16] two, twenty one, fifty six year old Terry Driver died of natural causes
[54:22] in prison. In the wake of its death, Misty said, I'm not
[54:28] sad about it at all, but it's still a lot of shock and trying
[54:31] to process what's going on. This is kind of a new fine chapter of
[54:36] freedom. I don't have to worry about upcoming parole hearings. I don't have
[54:40] to worry about whether he'll be released or not, and whether my family safe.
[54:45] Now I know that they are, and that's a relief. Beneath the
[54:53] facade of a seemingly affectionate husband and devoted father to his two children, Terry
[54:59] Driver for concealed a sinister side, rife with twisted and sadistic tendencies. Towards
[55:05] women. Unbeknownst to Manny, he had nurtured these malevolent faults for years,
[55:10] a dangerous undercurrent beneath his outward veneer. His history was marked by several attempts
[55:16] at its actual assault, each unsettling incident escalating in its intensity, culminating in
[55:23] the violent and he and his attacks on Tanya Smith and Misty cockerel In the
[55:29] end, the very individuals who had seen him as the loving figurehead were the
[55:34] ones who ultimately unmasked the chilling reality. The wolves can often hide in Sheep's
[55:39] clothing while Bessie's That is it for this episode of Morbidology. As always,
[56:02] thank you so so much for listening, and I like to say the biggest
[56:07] thank you to my new supporter of on Patreon, Kelsey. As you all
[56:10] know, Morbidology is a one woman team, so the support up on Patreon
[56:14] seriously go such a long way. If you'd like to check it out,
[56:17] the link is in the show notes, or alternatively, you can just search
[56:21] for Morbidology on the Patreon app or website. In exchange for your support,
[56:27] I upload ad free and early release episodes, bonus episodes of Morbidology, plus
[56:31] that aren't on the regular podcast platforms Behind the Scenes which includes bonus audio videos
[56:37] and case files, and I also send out a handwritten thank you card along
[56:44] with some col merch which includes stickers, pins, badges, fridge magnets,
[56:50] key chains, and T shirts. Remember to check us out at morbidology dot
[56:53] com for more information about this episode and to read artary crime articles. Until
[57:00] next time, take care of yourselves, stay see and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
