# 208: Ashley Zhao

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 12 Jun 2023, 38 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53903867/morbidology_209_ashley_zhao.mp3

China was governed by the Communist Party of China in the late 1990s, a regime that had held power since 1949. Consequently, a significant number of Chinese citizens emigrated from the country, with some choosing to settle in the United States. Among them were Ming Ming Chen and Liang Zhao, who arrived in Ohio and established their own restaurant. In 2017, however, tragedy struck, when a phone call came in to police from their restaurant. SPONSORS - June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-209-ashley-zhao PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] Yes, I need some help. Hey, what's going on? I can't
[0:38] find my daughter? Hey, hello to see five. She just turned five.
[0:53] China was governed by the Communist Party of China in the late ninety nineties,
[0:57] a regime that had held power since nineteen forty nine. Consequently, a
[1:00] significant number of Chinese citizens immigrated from the country, with some choosing to settle
[1:07] down in the United States. Among them were Ming Ming Chen and Liang Zhao,
[1:11] who arrived in Ohio and established their own restaurant in two and seventeen.
[1:17] However, tragedy struck when a phone call came into police from their restaurant.
[1:34] Liang Zoo immigrated to the United States from China in the late ninety nineties,
[1:40] first of all, settling down in New York in two thousand and eight.
[1:44] His paths would cross with Ming Ming Chen. Much like Liang, she too,
[1:49] had left China in August of two thousand and eight after paying a human
[1:53] smuggler sixty eight thousand dollars to sneak her into the United States. She flew
[1:59] from China to Mexico and then crossed the United States border hidden inside a vehicle.
[2:05] She was then driven to New York, where she met with an uncle
[2:07] who brought her to Ohio. In two thousand and nine, Ming Ming applied
[2:12] for asylum in the United States based on her religion, political opinion, and
[2:17] membership in a particular social group. She explained that she practiced faland Gong,
[2:23] the Chinese spiritual practice for which she claimed individuals were persecuted by the Chinese government.
[2:30] Falan Gong was a relatively new faith which combined ancient Chinese folk religion and
[2:36] medicine and Buddhist tenets at chigong, a series of exercises that are designed to
[2:42] hail and harness energy. It was founded in China in nineteen ninety two by
[2:46] Lee hong Zi, and came under persecution by Chinese Communist government in ninety ninety.
[2:53] They derided it as a cult and said that it was a threat to
[2:55] stability. According to critics, falang Gong is personality he driven, with Lee
[3:00] as the centerpiece. Critics accused him of making claims of being a savior with
[3:06] miraculous powers. In his ten Greatest Evils in the World teaching, he includes
[3:12] prohibitions against hostility, violence, drug abuse, gambling, premarital sex, adultery,
[3:20] homosexuality, democracy, and science, Mingmng wasn't incorrect in what she was
[3:27] saying. People in China who practiced the faith were being persecuted. There were
[3:32] even reports of them being tortured to death, and allegations that the government were
[3:37] forcibly harvesting organs from Falan Gong prisoners. Mingming explained to the US immigration authorities
[3:45] that she had turned to Falon Gong to cope with insomnia that was caused by
[3:49] work stress. While in China, Ming Ming had worked as an elementary school
[3:53] teacher. She said that she had fled from China after being arrested by police
[3:58] in April two thousand and eight during a raid on her home. She said
[4:02] that she was kept detained for a month, and that on one occasion,
[4:05] she was hid in the back with a baton and then pushed into a wall.
[4:11] She said that the officer ordered her to sign a statement promising not to
[4:15] practice fallon Goong. An immigration judge, however, determined that Ming Ming was
[4:19] incredible. This was in part due to inconsistencies between her testimony, written submissions,
[4:26] and supporting evidence, and she was ordered to be deported to China.
[4:31] Over the next four years, Ming Ming kept making appeals While doing so,
[4:36] she was also building a family. Ming Ming had met Liang when he was
[4:42] working for his sister's restaurant. He was helping out after the restaurant's delivery driver
[4:46] had an accident. Ming Ming and Liang were married in March of two and
[4:51] ten, and in October of that year, they welcomed their first child together,
[4:56] a little girl who they named Jojo. In summer of two thousand and
[5:00] eleven, Liang and Ming Ming opened up Ang's Asian Cuisine in the Gander Mountain
[5:06] Plaza. Lang and his father had run a Lucky Star restaurant for the past
[5:12] eleven years in the same plaza, but Liang and Ming Ming wanted something of
[5:15] their own. Mingming and Leang welcomed another daughter, Ashley, in December of
[5:21] that year. Running a bustling restaurant and raising a family proved to be a
[5:27] challenging juggling act. The couple were the sole employees of the restaurant, which
[5:31] was open six days a week. Complicating matters, Mingming was still fighting deportation
[5:38] back to China. In two thousand and twelve, she appealed the decision to
[5:42] the highest court available to her, the Sixth Circuit Court. Of Appeals.
[5:46] During the appeal, Mingming asserted that her brother had been arrested for practicing phallon
[5:51] gong shortly after she had left China for the US. She also claimed to
[5:57] have been detained in an education for a month, and that she owed her
[6:01] aunt twenty thousand dollars, which was borrowed from a snakehead who had smuggled her
[6:08] into the United States. In two thousand and twelve, Mingming's appeal for asylum
[6:14] was denied once more. She was ordered to be deported back to China and
[6:18] was expected to be deported immediately. However, Mingming just stayed where she was
[6:26] in an effort to manage the business better. Ashley and her sister, Jojo
[6:30] were sent to live with her grandparents for a while in New York, but
[6:34] they returned to their parents in Ohio in October of two thousand and fifteen.
[6:41] Ming Ming, Lean, Ashley, and Jojo settled into their routine. Jojo
[6:47] attended school with Liang handling the daily drop off and pick up duties. Since
[6:54] both parents worked at the restaurant, Ashley had no choice but to be there
[6:58] with them every single day since they couldn't afford childcare and had no family near
[7:02] by one school was out. Ashley's sister Jojo joined her at the restaurant.
[7:09] While Ming Ming and Liang tended to their customers. The girls occupied themselves by
[7:14] either sitting behind the cash register with the coloring book or tablet, or playing
[7:18] in the back room. Ashley was described as a very sociable little girl.
[7:24] Douglas Pansarello, who worked across the street and was a frequent customer at Ang's
[7:29] Asian Cuisine, said of her, a lot of five year olds are shy.
[7:32] She's very vocal and she's not afraid to talk to you. Another customer,
[7:38] Marty Shimali, agreed, He stated she's the sweetest little thing. Ming
[7:44] Ming and Leang worked long hours at the restaurant, and Ashley was always there
[7:47] with them, greeting each customer with a massive grin. No matter who came
[7:54] in for food, Ashley would chat away with them. Both Ashley and her
[7:58] sister were described out as daddy's girls, as Rebecca Decoy, a local customer,
[8:05] said they seemed like really good, hard working young parents. The family
[8:11] lived around a mile from the restaurant at Maple View Apartments on Sunset Strip Avenue.
[8:18] The rented apartment Number eleven was on the top floor. The restaurant closed
[8:24] each night at nine or ten pm, so the family were very rarely seen
[8:30] by their neighbors. Anytime that they did cross paths with them, they all
[8:35] commented on how polite and reserved they came across. It was a quiet night
[9:05] for police in Jackson County Township, Ohio on the ninth of January two thousand
[9:09] and seventeen. At around nine thirty pm. However, a phone call came
[9:15] in. It was from Liang and he reported that he couldn't find Ashley Jackson
[9:20] Township Police. Yes, I need from help. Okay, where are yet
[9:26] four nine two page Street four nine two portage? Yeah, okay, what's
[9:31] going on? I can't find my daughter? Heay, hello to see of
[9:37] five? Just turned five? S of stropic? Okay and yet Ames?
[9:41] Thanks? Yeah. What's the last time you've seen it? Uh? This
[9:48] afternoon? Probably around the time uh three maybe four? Wow? Damn far
[10:00] hours you saw her in? Five? Well? Was she wearing? Oh?
[10:05] Okay, what was wearing? Uh? She's wearing a purple winter coat.
[10:09] Uh. I don't know what those things are called, but they're not
[10:13] jeans. They're like, um leggings. Yeah, yeah, yeah, what
[10:16] color were they? Uh? British? Okay? And you haven't seen her
[10:22] in five hours? About Yeah, I mean she was there sleeping. I
[10:26] mean, you know where was she sleeping at in the restaurant? Yeah,
[10:30] yeah, she she was sleeping there. And I picked up my older daughter
[10:35] from school. We all saw her sleeping there. So and you know,
[10:37] we went to work and you know, we let her sleep and we got
[10:41] busy, and then uh uh, after we got busy, you know,
[10:48] we started cleaning up and and then you know, we opened her door because
[10:50] and she's got here. Hold on one second, okay. Leon said to
[10:56] the operator that he hadn't seen Ashley since the afternoon, but mingming could be
[11:01] heard in the background, shouting out five. He said that Ashley was tired,
[11:05] so she went to sleep in the back room of the restaurant. He
[11:09] went to pick his oldest daughter up from school and said that when they returned,
[11:13] they saw that Ashley was fast asleep. The restaurant then got busy,
[11:20] and when it died down at around nine p m. They found that Ashley
[11:24] had disappeared from the back room. The Ohio Attorney General's Office issued a missing
[11:30] child alert for Ashley, while the FBI were called in to assist, along
[11:35] with the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation. They suspected that while ming, Ming
[11:39] and Leang were working hard in the restaurant, Ashley wandered out the back door.
[11:46] It was something that she had done on previous occasions, but this time
[11:50] the weather outside was treacherous. It was extremely cold, and Ashley couldn't have
[11:56] remained out there on her own for too long, which led to concerns.
[12:01] A search party began at the restaurant, and they found out further afield,
[12:05] focusing their attention on a wooded area located towards the back. There was an
[12:11] immense fear that Ashley could have wandered out there and then gotten lost while trying
[12:16] to make her way back. There was thick brush and water between the Strip
[12:20] shopping plaza where the restaurant was located and Start State College. However, the
[12:26] search was hampered by the fact that it had been snowing as well. The
[12:31] Jackson Township Fire Department utilized their drone, knowing that it could scan the area
[12:37] much quicker than those on foot. While they were doing this, investigators searched
[12:41] inside the restaurant, nobody had actually seen Ashley wander off, indicating that she
[12:48] could very well still be inside, possibly stuck somewhere. Police Chief Mark brinkstated,
[12:56] we wanted to make sure that the child hadn't crawled into the dry a
[13:00] cubbyhole somewhere, that she had gone within that restaurant and still been there,
[13:05] so we searched the entire restaurant for the missing child. Unfortunately, however,
[13:11] Ashley was nowhere to be seen. As the search continued, the public were
[13:16] asked to contact police or the crime Stoppers line if they knew anything regarding her
[13:20] whereabouts. They described Ashley as standing at four feet tall and wearing around forty
[13:26] pounds. She had black hair and brown eyes, and her parents said that
[13:31] when she vanished, she was wearing a purple winter coat and gray leggings.
[13:35] Ashley's family were asked if they wanted to make a personal play in the media,
[13:41] which is commonplace in missing children cases. However, they opted out of
[13:46] it. Darkness had already descended on the area, but that didn't deter investigators,
[13:52] most of whom stayed out searching the entire night. At around eleven thirty
[13:58] am, investigators sent a statewide endangered Child advisory for Ashley. A statewide endangered
[14:05] child advisory is a notification system that alerts the public about a missing child who
[14:11] is believed to be in danger. This advisory is typically issued by law enforcement
[14:16] agencies in a particular state when they have reason to believe that a child is
[14:20] at risk of harm or has been abducted. It isn't too dissimilar to an
[14:26] amber alert, but that can only be issued when there's evidence of an abduction.
[14:31] When this was announced, investigators also asked anybody who had been at the
[14:35] family's restaurant on the Monday to get in contact. While searchers outside battled the
[14:41] cold and snowy conditions, others stayed inside the restaurant. They weren't yet sure
[14:48] if it was a crime scene, whether Ashley had been abducted, or what
[14:52] the situation was, so they needed to keep it secure. Investigators were searching
[14:58] in the kitchen when they noticed a crawl space above the walking cooler in the
[15:05] kitchen. It was the one place they hadn't yet searched, and it was
[15:09] big enough for a child to squeeze inside if they really wanted to. They
[15:16] opened it up and observed a large container which appeared to be filled with salt.
[15:22] As soon as they opened it, they could see a small hand poking
[15:26] out. It was Ashley and she was dead. Ashley's body was transported to
[15:50] the medical Examiner's office, where her autopsy concluded that she had died from blunt
[15:56] force trauma to the head and body. Both Ing Ming and Liang were immediately
[16:02] arrested. The discovery of Ashley's body was heartbreaking, and it was all the
[16:07] more poignant to know that she had been hidden inside the restaurant the entire time.
[16:12] Police Chief Brink commented, it ripped your heart out. We worked very
[16:18] hard on this case, and the one thing that we wanted at the end
[16:21] of the day was to recover that little girl alive. And you just work
[16:25] hard for that goal and then all of a sudden that goal has ripped away
[16:29] from you. Ming Ming was charged with murder and felonious assault, while Liang
[16:33] was charged with complicity to murder and complicity to commit felonious assault. They were
[16:40] both ordered to be held on five million dollar bond. The bond was so
[16:44] high because Mingming could face deportation since she was in the country undocumented. As
[16:49] for Liang, he had relatives in New York, and there was a fear
[16:53] that he could flee. With Ming Ming and Liang behind bars. Stark County
[16:59] Job Family Services took temporary custody of Jojo after no immediate relatives could be found.
[17:07] Meanwhile, a makeshift memorial began to form outside the family's restaurant. Grief
[17:11] stricken members of the public left staffed animals and bouquets of flowers, along with
[17:17] cards of condolences that seemed night A steady stream of people made their way to
[17:22] the front of the restaurant for a vigil in Ashley's memory. Patrick Jacobs,
[17:27] who helped to organize the events, stated, we felt something needed to be
[17:32] said. What happens to children is unforgivable. Many members of the community and
[17:37] attendance spoke of the family. They were familiar faces in the area due to
[17:42] the restaurant, and everybody commented that they never saw any signs of abuse or
[17:48] neglect. Antoineque and Eddie said she was simply adorable, so cute. You'd
[17:53] see her coloring, so I brought her a coloring book and crayons. Those
[17:59] who knew a family, Liang in particular, couldn't reconcile the man on the
[18:03] news charged with such a horrific crime as the man they knew as such a
[18:08] loving father. Nina Arman, whose daughter went to school with Ashley's sister,
[18:14] tearfully said he would never hurt them himself or intend for this to happen.
[18:19] And I know he panicked. I know the parents were extremely protective of them,
[18:25] like she couldn't go on played it's her birthday parties unless a parent could
[18:29] leave and stay with her there. However, abuse can be concealed in many
[18:34] ways. It was discovered that after Ashley returned to her parents from New York,
[18:41] ming Ming frequently abused her. She said that Ashley was a difficult child
[18:47] who refused to listen and lashed out at her sister when she didn't get her
[18:52] way. Whenever Ashley misbehaved, her mother would hit her in the head or
[18:57] torso. After ming Ming and Leon were arrested, they were separated and brought
[19:04] into interrogation rooms at the police station. Early on in the interrogation, ming
[19:11] Ming was informed that Ashley was deceased. According to the investigator, she showed
[19:15] no emotion. After repeated denials, ming Ming eventually admitted that she had killed
[19:22] her daughter. Did you're not crying? You said, I don't have nothing
[19:26] left? Is never you told me you don't have enough tears left? You
[19:30] don't have nothing left? Ming, your daughter is dead? What happened?
[19:34] How did she die? Just here her? And did she die? Did
[19:41] you hit her? Yeah? Okay? How did you? How did you
[19:45] hit her? How? Yeah? Yeah? And to do that? Okay?
[19:52] I told my husband, kay kidding? Okay, so you're talking your
[20:00] husband. I told my husband to be cured. I only cantured everything.
[20:07] I only have two hands on that whole hand. Girl on two hands.
[20:14] I was the one dude had to ash But you can't control yourself sometimes.
[20:18] She then told investigators that she had been overwhelmed trying to take care of Ashley
[20:23] and run the business. She said that she had two hands, not four,
[20:29] and was struggling to juggle both aspects of her life. According to ming
[20:33] Ming, Ashulely never listened to her or her husband throughout the interrogation. She
[20:38] repeatedly asked whether she could speak with her husband, but she was told no.
[20:45] When ming Ming was asked what happened with Ashley's body, she replied,
[20:49] I told my husband to take care of it and I don't know how he
[20:52] took care of it. Ming Ming was then asked whether she hit Ashley and
[20:59] she responded she had. She was asked what caused her to hit her daughter,
[21:03] and she responded, I forget, just be angry. If you're a
[21:12] fan of captivating mysteries with unexpected twists and turns, then June's Journey is the
[21:18] game for you. Prepare to be enthralled as you joined forces with the delightful
[21:22] amateur detective June Parker and embark on a quest you unravel the enigma of her
[21:26] sister's murder, while uncovering some closely guarded family secrets along the way. Get
[21:32] ready to put your powers of observation to the test as you delve into over
[21:37] one thousand meticulously crafted scenes, hunting for hidden clues and essential pieces of information.
[21:42] In this game, you're transported back to the dazzling nineteen twenties, where
[21:47] the glitz and glamour come alive in the stunning graphics and immersive gameplay of June's
[21:52] Journey. I've been playing this game for well over a year now, often
[21:56] finding myself losing track of time as I unwind with its fun challenges, laid
[22:00] into the night. But that's not all. One of the most exciting features
[22:04] of June's Journey for me personally is the opportunity to unleash my creativity and design
[22:11] my own island estate. Plus, you can even team up with a detective
[22:15] club and collaborate with other sleuths, adding a thrilling element of community and teamwork
[22:19] to your gaming experience. Can you crack the Guess? Donload June's Journey for
[22:25] free on iOS and Android. Investigators had secured a confession over in the other
[22:34] interrogation room. Leang confessed to his role. The murder had happened at the
[22:41] family's apartment, and while Ming Ming failed to give a motivation for the fatal
[22:45] beating, Liang provided one. He said that Ming Ming was angry because she
[22:51] discovered that actually had soiled her diaper was her banker, and she poked her
[23:00] banker. I know this doesn't sound like a big deal, but she's five
[23:06] years old. She's not the hutty training like e her and I was playing
[23:11] that a little later, but so that got my wife angry. And you
[23:18] know, you said a few days like, you know you're years old.
[23:22] You know five years old, you deal don't know how to go potti and
[23:26] poopy, and she had my wife's room and she was outside of the living
[23:33] room after she pood a potty and niper. You know, my wife knows
[23:37] that she had issues with pie training, so she was dealing. But then
[23:41] she took off her niper again, so back got my wife angry. And
[23:51] so you know, when you're five years old, you know, I still
[23:52] don't have the potty, and my wife got angry and in her head on
[23:59] the card, you know, he stated. I know, this doesn't sound
[24:06] like a big deal, but she's five years old and she's not potty trained.
[24:11] He said that ming Ming hit Ashley's head off the floor several times and
[24:15] hit her in the head and body with her fist. He said that he
[24:18] watched the entire thing on fold, but said that after this, Ashley appeared
[24:23] to be breathing, but she was just lying on the floor. Okay,
[24:30] So right then she wasn't breathing, you know, so she's still okay anything
[24:45] was she walking, but she was flying down and I thought she was going
[24:52] to come out of it a little bit, you know, so she's got
[24:56] but I didn't realize, she said, I thought she was doing normally now
[25:00] because she was gasping like it was. It was I can't really remember every
[25:07] call exactly what, but it was a lack heavy than normal. Um so
[25:12] he sounded like a snore, almost head so at that point she started,
[25:17] he thought, so she's pretty normally now, so there was an attention to
[25:21] it. And then later you know, hold her, just confuel right because
[25:29] I checked her heart as he said, he thought she was going to snap
[25:34] out of it, but within moments she appeared to be gasping for air.
[25:38] He described it like a snore. Sometime later, Leang said he went to
[25:44] check on Ashley and found that she wasn't breathing and that there was green fluid
[25:48] coming from her moith. He told investigators. He took Ashley into the bathroom,
[25:53] where she washed her face, and noticed that she had stopped breathing.
[25:59] He said that he had tempted to perform CPR on Ashley, but he couldn't
[26:02] revive her After this ming ming, and Leang strapped Ashley into her car seat
[26:08] and took her body to the restaurant to give her sister the impression that she
[26:12] was simply asleep. He said that six year old Jojo was very impressionable,
[26:18] and they believed that she could be persuaded to believe that Ashley was okay.
[26:22] They took Ashley into the back room and lay her down while they went to
[26:26] work serving their customers and serving up food. He said the plan was for
[26:33] Jojo to come home and see that she was there, then I would tie
[26:37] her up. He said that he eventually stuffed Ashley's body into a plastic container
[26:42] and put her in the walk in freezer, as he said, so she
[26:47] wouldn't stink Leang was asked what the ultimate plan was, and he said he
[26:52] intended on burning her, burying her, or throwing her into the ocean when
[26:57] investigators left the rest durant, but thankfully they never did. Two days after
[27:18] the arrest, there was a custody hearing for Jojo. It was decided that
[27:22] she was going to remain in the custody of Stark County Job and Family Services.
[27:27] The details of Ming Ming's play to stay in the United States became public
[27:32] knowledge. Tianlong Jian, a Falngong practitioner, shared his thoughts that Ming Ming
[27:38] was of the faith. He stated, Falangong teaches people to be truthful,
[27:45] compassionate, and tolerant. It teaches people to be good, not lie.
[27:49] It teaches you to be kind to everyone, and of course that would include
[27:53] your daughter. Tian long lived in the area, and he said that if
[27:57] Ming Ming was a practitioner, then somebody would recognize her. He said that
[28:03] she hadn't approached anybody within the community and suggested that Ming Ming had used the
[28:07] faith as an excuse not to return to China. He stated many Chinese youths
[28:14] fallon gong as an excuse to secure asylum. Meanwhile, it was decided that
[28:18] Ashley was going to be led to rest in New York, where Liang's family
[28:22] lived. On the seventh of March, a grand jury indicted Ming Ming and
[28:27] Liyang on a murder charge. They were also charged with endangering children, tampering
[28:33] with evidence, obstructing justice, and gross abuse of a corpse. Prosecutor John
[28:40] Varrero said that based on evidence in the case, the death penalty didn't apply.
[28:45] He commented, anytime you have a child victim, everybody takes it personally
[28:51] as well as the whole community, not just my office. The following week,
[28:56] Ming Ming and Leyang pleaded not guilty to the charges against the Mingming's defense
[29:00] attorney requested that she received a psychiatric evaluation, and Judge CHRISA. Hartnett granted
[29:07] the request. The defense attorney, Richard Drucker, wanted to see if Ming
[29:12] Ming were competent to stand trial. He said that he routinely requested such evaluations
[29:18] of his clients, but said that this did not necessarily mean that he was
[29:22] planning on pursuing an insanity defense. Before the results of that were public,
[29:29] Lang appeared in court in September, where he dramatically changed his plea. He
[29:34] instead pleaded guilty to obstructing justice, corpse abuse, tampering with evidence, and
[29:40] endangering children. It was part of a play agreement in which he agreed to
[29:45] testify against Ming Ming in her upcoming trial in exchange for a sentence of twelve
[29:51] years. After the plea, it was announced that Ming Ming's defense team were
[29:55] indeed seeking an insanity defense. They also announced their were wanting to get ming
[30:00] Ming's interrogation thrown out of evidence. Defense attorney Drucker said he wanted the statements
[30:07] suppressed because ming Ming didn't knowingly and intelligently waive her miranda rights due to her
[30:14] limited understanding of the English language and the criminal justice system in the United States
[30:21] FBI Chinese translator Lynn Taie was in the room for the earlier part of the
[30:25] interrogation. It was after she left that Ming Ming made the confession. The
[30:30] defense and prosecution appeared in court to discuss the issue, and the prosecution noted
[30:36] that Ming Ming had never asked for the translator to be back inside the room
[30:40] before she made the confession. They also argued that Mingming had signed the paperwork
[30:45] waiving her constitutional rights regarding the questioning, and that she never indicated she didn't
[30:49] understand any of the questions. More than an hour passed before Ming Ming made
[30:56] the confession, after she first of all denied knowing what had happened to Ashley.
[31:02] It was soon disclosed that Mingming was claiming that she was a battered woman.
[31:07] During ming ming psychological examination, she claimed to the psychologist that she was
[31:12] a battered woman and was subjected to physical and psychological abuse at the hands of
[31:18] Liang, and that she suffered from anxiety, depression, and panic attacks.
[31:23] The psychologist made no conclusion or finding regarding her status as a battered woman,
[31:29] recommended that her statements to investigators be considered in the context of her dependence on
[31:34] Liang, her fear of him, her low self esteem, and her sense
[31:40] of helplessness as mentioned earlier. Throughout the interrogation, ming Ming asked to speak
[31:45] with Liang. She told the psychologist that her husband had actually caused Ashley's death,
[31:52] but he had told her to tell investigators that it was her. She
[31:56] said that he explained that if she confessed and he would be able to get
[32:00] out of jail and take care of Ashley's sister. He warned that if she
[32:05] didn't confess, then Ashley's sister would be placed into care, which she ultimately
[32:10] was. Mingman was ordered to stand trial in January, but just after Christmas,
[32:16] she shuffled into court and agreed to a plea deal in which the murder
[32:21] charge was reduced to involuntary manslaughter. She pleaded guilty to that, along with
[32:25] pleading guilty to two kinds of endangering children, tampering with evidence, obstructing justice,
[32:31] and gross abuse of a corpse. Defense attorney Drucker said to the court
[32:37] room that the stress of running the family's restaurant, which was practically a twenty
[32:42] four to seven operation, led to violence within the home. He said that
[32:46] an unfortunate byproduct of that violence was the death of Ashley. He said she's
[32:53] very saddened by the loss of her child and ask for everybody's forgiveness. Mingming
[33:00] had written a short statement which was read allowed by an interpreter. She says
[33:05] she felt sorry for what happened, especially to her daughter, and that she
[33:08] wanted to be a good person. Mingming was ordered to serve twenty two years
[33:14] in prison, which included eleven years for the involuntary manslaughter or charge, eight
[33:19] years for one count of endangering children, and three years for tampering with evidence.
[33:24] It was also decided that once her sentence was complete, she was to
[33:29] be deported to China. When handing down the sentence, Judge Hartnett told ming
[33:35] Ming that it was with great pain that she referred to her as a mother
[33:38] when speaking with her. She said that children should be able to rely on
[33:43] their parents for love, safety and protection. She then added, and in
[33:47] this case, I can't imagine the horror for your child, Ashley. She
[33:53] said that no amount of years would constitute a long enough prison term, but
[33:58] said that avoiding a trial to preserve Ashley's memory for her sister was desirable.
[34:06] The judge also said she felt comfort knowing that Ashley's sister was far better off
[34:10] without having her as a parent. Jojo was still under temporary custody of Stark
[34:16] County Job and Family Services, but she was living with relatives in New York,
[34:22] where her sister's ashes were buried. Assistant Prosecutor Dennis Barr commented, this
[34:29] was a tragic case, but part of the reason that we did this was
[34:34] we know she'll be in prison long enough, and when she gets out,
[34:37] Jojo will be a grown adult and able to protect herself. Following this court
[34:43] hearing, Liang was formally sentenced to twelve years in prison. He was allowed
[34:49] to provide a statement to the court, and through tears, he said he
[34:52] had dreams about his family being whole. While addressing the court, he said
[34:58] that Ashley would have turned sick two weeks earlier. He stated, it goes
[35:04] without saying that I wish the situation was different, not because I'm going to
[35:07] prison, but because my daughter's gone. No one's going to remember her,
[35:13] no one but the people in my family. I don't want to be rude,
[35:17] but none of you will remember her, none of you. At the
[35:22] hearing, the prosecution asserted that Ming Ming was solely responsible for the abuse that
[35:27] Ashley had suffered before her death. They maintained that Liang had knowledge of the
[35:31] abuse, but there was no evidence to suggest that he had participated in mistreating
[35:37] Ashley, either on the day of her death or at any point leading up
[35:42] to it. Judge Hartnett alluded to horrible choices made by both Ming Ming and
[35:47] Liang, commenting, I think you know that while you didn't necessarily take her
[35:53] life, that you compounded things. I know how much you care about your
[35:59] other daughter as well, and had you made different choices, there's the chance
[36:04] you could have been there for the surviving daughter. Ming Ming Chen and Liang
[36:10] Zhao migrated to the United States with the hopes of improving their lives. To
[36:15] external observers, they seem to be pursuing the quintessential American dream that so many
[36:22] immigrants aspire to attain. However, and beknownst to outsiders, the challenges of
[36:29] managing a business while raising two young children had been accumulating for some time,
[36:36] culminating in the tragic death of Ashley Zoo Well, Bessie's that is it for
[37:02] this episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you so so much for listening,
[37:07] and I'd like to say the biggest thank you to my new supporter off
[37:10] on Patreon, Kelsey, because y'all know, Morbidology is a one woman team,
[37:15] so the support up on Patreon seriously goes such a long way. I
[37:21] research, right, post and produce the episodes myself, and in exchange for
[37:24] your support up on Patreon, I upload bonus episodes of Morbidology plus that aren't
[37:30] on the regular podcast platforms, add free and early release episodes behind the scenes,
[37:36] and of course, the most important you get my undying love. So
[37:39] if you'd like to support the show that way, then please do feel free
[37:42] to check Morbidology out on Patreon. If not, then the worries remember to
[37:47] check us out on morbidology dot com for more information, avoid this episode and
[37:52] to read or true crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves,
[37:57] stay safe, and have an amazing week. B

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
