# 231: Billy Jack Gaither

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 20 Nov 2023, 45 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/57469592/morbidology_231_billy_jack_gaither.mp3

Sylacauga is a small town in central Alabama, nestled amid the rolling hills and forests of Talladega County. Back in the 1990s, this tight-knit community was so diminutive that it lacked fundamental establishments such as motels, restaurants, or even a solitary traffic signal. The town's limited size fostered a culture where nearly everyone was familiar with each other. Within the context of small-town Alabama, individuals within the LGBTQ+ community often chose to conceal their identities. Many found solace in relocating to the more embracing city of Birmingham. In 1999, the world would come to learn exactly why. SPONSORS - June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. SmartLabels: Thank you to SmartLabels for sponsoring this episode! Say goodbye to countless minutes rummaging through storage bins for your Halloween decorations with SmartLabels. Download their app on the app store and buy their QR labels at: https://www.qrsmartlabels.com/collections/frontpage SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-231-billy-jack-gaither PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:44] Silicoga is a small town in central Alabama, nestled the mid the rolling hills
[0:48] and forests of Talladega County. Back in the ninety nineties, this technic community
[0:53] was so diminutive that it lacked fundamental establishments such as motels or restaurants. The
[1:00] town's limited size fostered a culture where nearly everybody was familiar with each other.
[1:04] Within the context of smalltown Alabama, individuals within the LGBTQ plus community often chose
[1:11] to conceal their identities. Many found solace in relocating to the more embracing city
[1:17] of Birmingham in nineteen ninety The world would come to learn exactly why. It
[1:34] was a quiet Saturday morning in Silicaga, Alabama. On the twentieth of February
[1:40] nineteen ninety nine, the tranquility was shattered when a burning car was discovered alongside
[1:46] Alabama one four eight firefighters and police were dispatched to the area, and when
[1:52] the flames were extinguished, they let out a collective sigh of relief to find
[1:57] that the vehicle was empty. Detectives discovered that the burning car belonged to thirty
[2:02] nine year old Billy Jack Gaither. Billy Jack Gaither was born on the twenty
[2:12] first of January nineteen sixty. He was a member of a large family in
[2:16] central Alabama, with Marian and Annie as his parents. Growing up as one
[2:22] of seven siblings in a deeply religious household, attending church was a weekly ritual
[2:28] for the Gaither family. Of the four boys, Billy Jack was known for
[2:30] his kindness and his devotion to reading the Illustrated Bible before bed, as well
[2:37] as singing the church choir. With the bustling household, he always had somebody
[2:42] to play with, often enjoying fishing trips with his siblings on Lake Louise.
[2:46] It was during his upbringing that Billy Jack came to terms with his sexual orientation.
[2:53] Despite being aware of his own truth, he chose to keep this aspect
[2:57] of himself hidden from his conservative commune and his religious family. However, Billy
[3:04] Jack's siblings soon enough recognized his identity, but his parents were none the wiser.
[3:10] As his brother Greg said, we knew he was, We just knew.
[3:15] His sister, Kathy, was also a member of the LGBTQ plus community,
[3:21] which fostered a profound connection with her brother. Their relationship was characterized by
[3:27] mutual support and understanding, with Kathy playing a pivotal role in aiding Billy Jack's
[3:31] self acceptance journey regarding his own sexual orientation. Eventually, after the eleventh grade,
[3:39] billy Jack made the decision to drop out of high school, but he
[3:44] was determined to continue his education and acquired his ged. Following billy Jack's education,
[3:52] he enlisted in the Marines, though his time of service was relatively brief
[3:58] due to health concerns. Billy Jack returned home and started to explore his identity
[4:02] more openly in the gay bars of Birmingham and Atlanta. While he was open
[4:09] about his sexuality in environments where he felt secure, he never sought to draw
[4:14] attention. Living in a small southern town will do that to people. Deeply
[4:20] Concerned about hurting his parents, Billy Jack chose to keep the significant part of
[4:25] his life hidden, creating a barrier between his personal truth and the expectations of
[4:30] his religious upbringing. Despite his parents' lack of awareness about his personal life,
[4:36] Billy Jack shared a profound mutual respect with his mother and father. His father
[4:43] affectionately described him as the ideal son any parent could wish for, highlighting billy
[4:47] Jack's exceptional character. As of ninety ninety nine, billy Jack lived with his
[4:53] disabled parents in their white clapboard house on Pelham Street in Silicaga, ass attended
[5:00] to their every need, including cooking and cleaning each night. Billy Jack never
[5:05] went to bed without telling his parents good night and telling them how much he
[5:10] loved them. As Marion recalled, he would give you the shirt off his
[5:15] back. Despite often considering the possibility of leaving the confines of the small town
[5:21] for a more accepting environment in Birmingham, his devotion to his parents always prevented
[5:27] him. As his brother Randy said, billy Jack was nothing if not reliable,
[5:32] so he stayed in Silicougo with his parents. Within his bedroom, a
[5:38] portrayal of Vivian Lee and Clark Gable in the classic Gone with the Wind adorned
[5:43] his walls. Meanwhile, the living room bore depictions of Jesus and the Ten
[5:47] Commandments, underscoring his strong spiritual convictions. Life for Billy Jack was peaceful and
[5:55] it was routine. Every day he commuted almost sixty miles to his job at
[6:00] Russell's Athletic Distribution Center in Alexander City, where he worked loading and unloading materials
[6:08] off trucks. His commendable work ethic earned him a respective position, often leading
[6:14] him to stand in for his supervisor when needed. On the weekends, Billy
[6:19] Jack liked to visit the Tavern, a country music bar located along US Highway
[6:25] to Erie. The bear's choice was always Budweiser, and Billy Jack liked to
[6:30] nurse his bear for longer than the usual patron. He enjoyed playing pool and
[6:36] chatting with other familiar faces at the bar. Donough mckaye, one of the
[6:41] bar he had, said he was a gentle soul, He had a calming
[6:45] presence and never saw him get drunk cause problems. Having frequented the bar for
[6:50] two decades, Billy Jack fostered a close relationship with the owner, Marion Hammond,
[6:56] who candidly recalled that he was the first openly gay man she had ever
[7:00] encountered. She remembered, he knew what he was, and he was comfortable
[7:04] with it, and it was your problem if you weren't. Most nights,
[7:09] Billy Jack would linger in the bar until closing time at two a m.
[7:13] Before making his way back to his parents' home. Following the discovery of Billy
[7:20] Jack's torched car, detectives initiated efforts to establish contact with him. They reached
[7:27] out to his parents, Marion and Annie, and they reported that they hadn't
[7:30] seen him since the night before. They recounted how he had left home that
[7:35] night in his car to visit the tavern, but when they woke the next
[7:39] morning, they found that his bed hadn't been slept in and he was nowhere
[7:43] to be found. Subsequently, detectives visited the tavern, where an employee recalled
[7:48] Billy Jack's presence on Friday night. Although he had spent a considerable time there,
[7:55] the staff member couldn't recall the exact moment he left. She was preoccupied
[8:00] with attending to other guests. Detectives continued in their search for Billy Jack.
[8:05] Later that night, at about nine pm, a young man was walking along
[8:09] the banks of Peckerwood Creek, a stream in Talladega County, Alabama. Peckerwood
[8:16] Creek is situated along an infrequently traversed, purely lit highway flanked by quarries known
[8:22] for producing marble and granite for headstones. Historically, the creek had served as
[8:28] a site for baptisms. Approximately two hundred yards from a desolate road, this
[8:33] man was navigating through scattered debris, including discarded cans and bullets littering the ground.
[8:39] In the distance, a concrete slab protruding into the waters. A remnant
[8:45] of a dismantled bridge came into view. As the man drew closer, he
[8:50] discovered something smoldering. It was a charred body atop a stack of burning tires.
[9:00] Upon receiving the man's nine one one call, police swiftly arrived at the
[9:03] scene. Officer Michael Taylor, who was in his third year in the department,
[9:09] recounted the grizzly discovery as gruesome and heinous. He said it was the
[9:13] worst crime, saying he had ever seen in his entire life. The area
[9:20] was swiftly cordoned off with crime scene tape as the victim's body was transported to
[9:24] the medical examiner's office. Subsequent examination revealed the extent of the brutality inflicted upon
[9:31] the victim. It was determined that the man had suffered a slit throat and
[9:37] severe blunt force trauma to the head, presumably caused by a heavy object.
[9:43] The impact had resulted in three fractures in his skull, leading to the collapse
[9:48] of his facial structure. Additionally, burnmarks were found on the body, indicating
[9:54] post mortem infliction. The extent of the injuries painted a picture of an exceptionally
[10:00] brutal and prolonged assault. Based on the victim's appearance, detectives knew that they
[10:07] had just found Billy Jack Gaither. Once the body was identified as Billy Jack,
[10:18] detectives began their investigation, but it wouldn't be long before they got their
[10:22] first lead. That night, a concerned individual named Joey Breedlove contacted them.
[10:30] He related that his friend, Charles Butler Senior, had disclosed that his son
[10:33] had allegedly confessed to Billy Jack's murder. The son in question, twenty one
[10:39] year old Charles Butler Junior, had returned home in the early morning hours of
[10:43] Saturday, visibly distraught. According to Joey's account, Butler tearfully admitted to his
[10:50] father that they had taken somebody's life, proclaiming, we killed somebody. I
[10:56] kicked a queer's ass. Butler had then disclosed to his father that he and
[11:01] another friend, twenty five year old Stephen Eric Mullis, had killed Billy Jack
[11:07] because he was gay. Despite Butler Senior's reluctance to directly involved detectives. He
[11:13] confided in his friend Joey regarding his son's alleged confession. Without delay, Joey
[11:20] promptly called police Stephen. Eric Mullins was well known to law enforcement at the
[11:30] time, having racked up numerous charges dating back to when he was a juvenile.
[11:35] After serving two and a half years in prison for burglary and forgery,
[11:39] he crossed paths with Billy Jack Gaither in a local bar. Despite their different
[11:43] backgrounds, the two men had struck up something of a friendship over the past
[11:48] year. They both drank in the tavern together and Billy Jack would drive Mullins
[11:54] to the grocery store. Mullins was known around the town as his skinhead wannabe
[11:58] who projected an imidating demeanor. His shaved head, racist themed t shirts and
[12:05] racist tattoos often led to confrontations. While Mullins was a familiar face at the
[12:11] tavern, his extremist views and racist remarks often resulted in him being kicked out
[12:16] of the premises. He once boasted to a fellow patron about wearing a KKK
[12:22] T shirt and deliberately positioning himself against a restaurant window so that black diners could
[12:28] see. According to Larry Hammond, who worked at the tavern, Mullins acted
[12:33] tough but back down quickly if he were ever challenged. He remarked, he
[12:39] tried to walk around like a bully, but he wasn't. He was mostly
[12:43] talk. The sentiment was shared by others, including Bruce Jones, who recounted
[12:48] an incident from the previous fall. During a night at the tavern, Mullins
[12:54] repeatedly shouldered Bruce in the back when he walked past, but the provocation stopped
[12:58] short of escale. Having lived with Butler's half brother for several years, Mullins
[13:05] had been acquainted with him. However, it was only a month earlier that
[13:07] the two men began spending time together. Butler was described as the more reserved
[13:13] of the two, standing just over five four inches tall, Mullins, who
[13:18] is over six foot, towered over him. He was a high school dropout
[13:24] and construction worker. You can't beat a classic who'd done it, especially one
[13:31] with as many twists and turns as Student's Journey. In this mobile puzzle game,
[13:35] you get to play as the eclectic June Parker, an amateur detective trying
[13:41] to solve her sister's murder and uncovering some family mysteries along the way. Engage
[13:46] your observation skills by searching for hidden clues and uncover key pieces of information.
[13:52] Is the mystery on folds. June's Journey is set in the glamorous nineteen twenties,
[13:58] and it has the most beautifully intricate scenes. There's actually over one thousand
[14:03] scenes that are filled with hidden clues. I've been playing June's Journey for well
[14:07] over a year now, and I find myself playing it late at night as
[14:11] a way to unwind. What's super fun is that you actually get to build
[14:15] your own island estate and outloads of cool features to it. You can even
[14:20] join a detective club. I'm currently on volume four, chapter four, where
[14:26] joe needs to find clues on a boat. Can you Crack the Case?
[14:31] Download June's Journey. Download Dune's Journey for free today on iOS and Android.
[14:41] Following Joey's revelation of Butler's confession to his father, Butler was arrested and detained
[14:46] over night. The next morning, he told detectives that he couldn't sleep and
[14:52] that God told him he needed to make a full confession. Butler was taken
[14:56] into the interrogation room, where he began to confess he recoined an oil.
[15:03] On the night of Billy Jack's murder, he was at the tavern with his
[15:07] father when Mullins entered the bar accompanied by Billy Jack. Butler said that while
[15:13] he was friends with Mullins, he had never met Billy Jack before. He
[15:18] said that Mullins walked over to him and struck up a conversation. He asked
[15:22] whether he wanted to go with him and Billy Jack to another nightclub. Butler
[15:28] agreed, and the three men left the bar together. Instead of going to
[15:31] another nightclub, however, Butler told detectives that they went to an isolated woodland
[15:37] in neighboring Clay County. The three men sat around, drinking some beers and
[15:43] chatting. According to Butler, Billy Jack made a pass at him, although
[15:48] he admitted that he never grabbed or touched him. He said to detectives,
[15:52] well, sir, he started, you know queer stuff, you know,
[15:58] and I just didn't want no part of it. Recalling the incident to detectives,
[16:02] Butler admitted to kicking billy Jack several times. He said that billy Jack
[16:07] fell to the ground, and he kicked him two or three more times.
[16:11] After billy Jack struggled to regy in his footing, Butler excused himself to use
[16:18] the bathroom, leaving the scene briefly. As he walked away, he said
[16:23] he heard a commotion from behind and turned around to see Mullins jumping on billy
[16:29] Jack. He then described how Mullins lunged at billy Jack, causing blood to
[16:34] gush from his throat. Billy Jack's throat had been slashed with a penknife,
[16:40] yet he was still alive. Despite Billy Jack's desperate place for mercy and attempts
[16:47] to rise, Mullens stabbed him twice in the rib cage. Subsequently, Mullens
[16:52] forced Billy Jack into the trunk of his own vehicle, with Mullens assuming the
[16:57] driver's seat Butler seated in the front. They drove to Mullin's trailer, where
[17:03] they grabbed tires, kerosene, and an axe handle. Proceeding to Peckerwood,
[17:08] Craig Mullins forcibly dragged billy Jack from the trunk, his clothing drenched in blood
[17:14] as he clutched his neck in the dim light. The grim sight became apparent
[17:18] to Billy Jack the presence of tires, kerosene and Mullins holding an axe handle.
[17:26] Acutely aware of the dark circumstances, billy Jack played desperately for his release,
[17:33] vowing to keep what happened as sacret In response, Mullins hurled homophobic slurs
[17:40] at him. Seizing a fleeting chance to break free, Billy Jack forcefully shoved
[17:45] Mullin's sending him tumbling into the creek, before jumping into the driver's seat of
[17:51] his own car. Meanwhile, Butler claimed that he fled into the nearby woods.
[17:57] Mullin swiftly recovered from the wall, dangling the car keys before retrieving Billy
[18:03] Jack from the vehicle. He then struck billy Jack again and again with the
[18:07] axe handle. During the interrogation, Butler acknowledged his complicity in the subsequent events.
[18:15] He confessed to helping burn Billy Jack's body atop the pile of tires and
[18:21] then setting fire to Billy Jack's car, all in a bid to obliterate any
[18:25] incriminating evidence. Shortly after Butler was arrested, Mullins was also picked up and
[18:30] informed of Butler's confession. He too sat down with the detectives to offer them
[18:36] his version of what happened that night. He told detectives that the murder of
[18:41] Billy Jack had in fact been planned for two weeks by himself and Butler.
[18:48] He said he thought he could trust Butler because he was just as homophobic as
[18:52] he was. According to Mullins, billy Jack had made a pass at him
[18:56] a round two weeks earlier over the phone, and from that moment and dawn
[19:00] he began plotting to kill him. He later said he broke that respect line.
[19:06] It started eating at me and it bothered me a lot. He let
[19:10] Butler in on his plans, and he said that he wanted to be a
[19:12] part of it. But Mullins admitted that he never physically carried out the murder.
[19:18] Mullins said that on the night of the murder, he had called up
[19:21] Billy Jack and asked him to pick him up so they could go to the
[19:23] bar. Billy Jack collected him at about seven pm and they drove around while
[19:30] Mullins drank some bottles of beer. He then drove over to the tavern,
[19:34] where Mullins called Butler. He asked him to meet them at the bar and
[19:40] said that he was with Billy Jack. He said, I told him what
[19:44] I was thinking about doing killing Billy Jack. Butler arrived, and, according
[19:49] to Mullins, they lured billy Jack into the woods under the pretense of engaging
[19:53] in sexual activity. Mullins admitted to slitting Billy Jack's throat, but contended that
[20:00] it was Butler's suggestion to transport him to Peckerwood Creek to burn him. Contrary
[20:07] to Butler's account of events, Mullens claimed that Butler had offered him a pocket
[20:11] knife to slip Billy Jack's throat a second time. Instead, he confessed to
[20:18] bludgeoning billy Jack to death with an axe handle, recounting that he continued the
[20:22] assault until he was physically exhausted. On the first of March, both Butler
[20:30] and Mullins were officially charged with the murder of Billy Jack. Their bill was
[20:36] set at five hundred thousand dollars each. Despite their respect of confessions. Butler
[20:42] had reportedly communicated to his family that he initially anticipated a mere physical altercation with
[20:49] Billy Jack. His stepmother attested that she had never once heard her son express
[20:56] any form of animosity towards members of the LG Beats TQ plus community. She
[21:02] commented, it wasn't a big issue here, but it might have been when
[21:07] he was out with his friends. His grandmother, Willne White, also expressed
[21:11] disbelief that Butler had known what was going to happen to Billy Jack. She
[21:17] stated, he ain't ever been in a lot of trouble. He's just a
[21:22] typical boy. It's hard for me to believe he did it. Upon the
[21:26] revelation of the gruesome details surrounding Billy Jack's murder, the entire nation was left
[21:30] in a state of horror. While the LGBTQ plus community was particularly gripped by
[21:37] fear. Individuals living in small southern towns were especially affected, feeling a chilling
[21:45] sense of proximity to the tragic incident, as if it could have easily been
[21:49] any of them in Billy Jack's place. Some said that there was an unwritten
[21:55] rule in rural Alabama about keeping their sexuality hidden. The memory of Matthew Shepherd's
[22:03] tragic death in a homophobic attack in Wyoming the previous year was still fresh in
[22:07] people's minds. Likewise, the racially motivated murder of James Bird Junior during the
[22:14] same period served as a stark reminder of the prevalence of hate fueled violence in
[22:19] society. Compounding the tragedy was the fact that Alabama was among nineteen states that
[22:26] didn't have hate crime laws that included provisions for offenses related to sexual orientation.
[22:33] This legendice of gap created a profound dilemma, as the nature of the crime
[22:37] clearly pointed towards a hate crime, yet the legal framework fell short in addressing
[22:44] it adequately. Consequently, the inability to file hate crime charges despite the evident
[22:49] bias driven nature of the murder, underscored the pressing need for comprehensive and inclusive
[22:56] hate crime legislation. Very Steel, editor of The Advocate, an LGBTQ plus
[23:03] magazine, said, there are a lot of people still out there who believe
[23:07] the game lesbian people are a threat. Until that is educated away, these
[23:11] sorts of things will continue to happen. By this point, State Rep.
[23:17] Alvin Holmes had already filed a bill that would extend Alabama's laws to cover hate
[23:22] crimes motivated by homophobia. He was moved to file the bill in the wake
[23:26] of Matthew Shepherd's murder. Upon learning of Billy Jack's murder, he reintroduced a
[23:33] bill that would increase the penalties for somebody convicted of a crime motivated by the
[23:37] victim's sexual orientation. He had previously attempted to introduce this bill, but it
[23:44] failed because there was no documentation that such crimes occurred. However, that was
[23:49] only because Alabama didn't recognize such murders to be hate crimes. In the wake
[23:56] of Billy Jack's murder, people demanded for Alabama to up their stance on hate
[24:00] crimes. Laurie Wood of the Southern Poverty Law Center commented that sexual orientation was
[24:07] becoming one of the top motivations behind biased crimes. She said that the murders
[24:12] against members of the LGBTQ plus community were among the most violent. She stated,
[24:19] in attacks against homosexuals, often we see the overkill approach, where there
[24:26] is so much anger directed to that person that the attack is overly brutal.
[24:30] Billy Jack's murder certainly had the hallmarks of a hate crime. In several cases
[24:37] of this nature, perpetrators often attempt to rationalize their actions by alleging that the
[24:41] victim had made unwelcome sexual advances. This was precisely the defense that Butler and
[24:48] Mullins put forth. Upon the revelation of their motives, Marion and Annie struggled
[24:55] to come to terms with the shocking reality. The discovery of their sons secret
[25:00] life struck them with disbelief, particularly Marian, who grappled with the nile regarding
[25:04] his son's sexuality, even cided a past relationship with a woman his evidence that
[25:11] his son was straight. His mother, Annie said, if he was gay,
[25:17] he sure never showed it. He never flaunded himself as being gay or
[25:21] talked about it. And whether he was or not, it don't make me
[25:25] love him any less. She seemed to acknowledge Billy Jack's sexuality by adding,
[25:33] whatever he did, he never brought it home. Marian then added, if
[25:38] he was gay, he kept it from me. I couldn't have asked for
[25:41] a better son. He was always there for me. He was very protective
[25:45] of his Mamma and me. He said that he wanted his son to be
[25:49] remembered as a loving and caring person who loved life. Marian added that in
[25:56] his soul, he believed that his son was in heaven. As newspapers began
[26:00] reporting on the alleged motivation that Billy Jack had hit on Butler and Mullins,
[26:06] those who knew his truth came to his defense. They all said that billy
[26:11] Jack wasn't the type of man to hit on somebody. As the owner of
[26:15] the tavern, Marion Hammond, said he didn't ever put anybody in an awkward
[26:22] position. Billy Jack's brother Ricky agreed, stating they may have come up and
[26:27] talked to billy Jack because billy Jack wouldn't approach anybody that didn't approach him.
[26:33] He didn't push himself on people. With Butler and Mullins behind bars, the
[26:45] grig where billy Jack lost his life became a makeshift memorial. On Friday morning,
[26:52] a pair of holy men and a woman of the cloth cast blessed water
[26:56] and laid a golden floor. They read prayers for commendation at the time of
[27:00] death from the Book of Matthew. Timothy Holder, rector at Grace Episcopal Church,
[27:07] said evil has happened here. It is very important to face evil immediately
[27:12] with love. Love will conquer it, and that's why we're here. As
[27:21] autumn sets in and Thanksgiving approaches, it's time to grab your seasonal decorations.
[27:26] The familiar struggle of locating the right storage bin can be a thing of the
[27:32] past. Introducing smart labels your solution for hassle free organization. No more opening
[27:40] multiple bins, making a mess, and feeling frustrated. With smart labels,
[27:45] easily locate your items within your storage bins. How does it work? Simply
[27:51] purchase their color coded and cure coded smart labels from their website, Amazon or
[27:56] Walmart. Then download the smart Labels app the Apple App Store or Google Play.
[28:03] Attach the smart label to your storage bin, scan it with the app,
[28:07] and assign a specific name such as Thanksgiving. You can even describe the
[28:11] contents for easy reference. Say goodbye to spending precious time rummaging through boxes to
[28:18] find your Thanksgiving or Fall decorations. Visit QR smart Labels dot com now to
[28:23] simplify your storage organization. On the tenth of March, people from all across
[28:33] Alabama grammed into the Confident Metropolitan Church to remember Billy Jack and to demand an
[28:38] end to hate crimes perpetrated against members of the LGBTQ plus community. There were
[28:45] people from all walks of life at the service, and Reverend Marge Ragna said
[28:49] that the size amazed and gladdened her to applause. She said, this is
[28:56] far beyond my wildest dreams. We are amazed. So many felt you needed
[29:00] to be here just as we needed to be here. She urged the crowd
[29:04] not to remain silent in the wake of Billy Jack's murder and denounced Christians who
[29:10] used the Bible as justification to treat members of the LGBTQ plus community differently.
[29:17] During the service, many talkers urged legislators to add such crimes to the state's
[29:22] list of hate crimes. After the two hour service, people lit small candles
[29:26] and stood outside the church, where they sang this little light of mine.
[29:32] There was a little nine year old boy there, Max Griffy's, holding up
[29:37] a sign that read God Loves all people. His mother, Leah, said
[29:41] that it was important for her son to know that you don't kill people,
[29:44] regardless of who they are and especially for what they believe in. Across the
[29:51] street, a handful of protesters from the Westboro Baptist Church in Kansas held signs
[29:56] attacking members of the LGBTQ plus community, some even specifically targeted Billy Jack.
[30:08] In March, Mullins and Butler were indicted on capital murder charges by a grand
[30:12] jury. This men that have convicted, they could both be facing execution in
[30:17] Alabama's electric chair. Butler pleaded innocent by reason of insanity, while Mullins just
[30:25] pleaded innocent. The next month, President Bill Clinton announced he was endorsing a
[30:30] bill that would expand federal hate crime laws to include offenses based on sexual orientation.
[30:37] Congress had failed to act on a similar legislation just the year Beforehunt.
[30:41] The President also ordered the Education Department to begin collecting data on hate crimes and
[30:48] college campuses. By this point, there had been numerous protests all throughout the
[30:53] United States, and various states were demanding that the state law be amended as
[30:59] well. In May, an Alabama House committee voted to add hate crimes based
[31:03] on sexual orientation to be added to the state's hate crime law. However,
[31:08] the following month that bill failed. Despite this, Representative Alvin Wholms said that
[31:15] it would not be his last with the measure. He said that he was
[31:18] going to keep fighting for a change in law. On the twenty fourth of
[31:23] June, Mullins returned to court alone. The courtroom was filled with Billy Jack's
[31:29] loved ones. As Mullins changed his play to guilty, he stood up at
[31:34] the podium and stated, I kidnapped mister Gaither, forced him into the car,
[31:41] and killed him intentionally. Mullins had agreed to the play to avoid the
[31:45] electric chair, but prosecutors were going to be seeking its sentence of life in
[31:49] prison without parole. According to his defense attorney Rod gettings, his client and
[31:56] Butler had been motivated to kill Billy Jack because he allegedly meant he had apossit
[32:00] them. He distanced his client to the killers of Matthew Shepherd and said that
[32:06] he wasn't going out to target a gay person. That same day, Butler
[32:09] also appeared in court and withdrew his insanity defense, but still kept his not
[32:14] guilty plea. After the court hearings, Billy Jack's brother, William said that
[32:20] he wanted to see both men sentenced to death. Billy Jack's father, Marian,
[32:25] didn't agree, commenting, I don't believe in the death penalty. I
[32:30] think it will be harder for them in prison. The guilty plea meant that
[32:36] just Butler would be standing trial alone. Much like Mullins, he too had
[32:40] been offered a plea deal. He called for him to plead guilty in exchange
[32:45] for a guarantee he wouldn't get the death penalty. Butler decided against the plea,
[32:50] which meant he would be proceeding to trial. According to his defense attorney,
[32:54] they were confident in their defense. While at first Butler was going for
[33:00] an insanity defense, they had decided instead to present a defense that he was
[33:05] innocent. It was their argument that while Butler was there when billy Jack was
[33:09] killed, he didn't participate in it. The murder trial began on the third
[33:15] of August nineteen ninety nine. During opening, Stamen's defense attorney Billy Hill claimed
[33:21] that the three men were drinking beer in the woods when billy Jack propositioned Butler.
[33:25] He admitted the Butler was the first to hit billy Jack that night,
[33:29] but maintained that everything else he did was under orders from Mullins. He described
[33:35] his client as a small framed boy who was intimidated by Mullins, who stood
[33:39] at six foot one and weid two hundred pounds. According to defense attorney Hill,
[33:45] Mullins was solely responsible for billy Jack's death. He said that he and
[33:51] billy Jack had developed a relationship of sorts and had been talking on a regular
[33:55] basis. Prosecutor Fred Thompson, during his opening statements, acknowledged that Butler didn't
[34:02] cut Billy Jack's throat or beat him to death. However, he said that
[34:07] he played a key role in the murder. He went on to say that
[34:09] Billy Jack was gay and that was the only reason that he was killed.
[34:15] He stated it was pure, simple hatred, hatred of someone perceived to be
[34:21] different. He said that Butler had aided in the crime, partly by setting
[34:25] the tires on fire and burning Billy Jack's car to hide evidence. He told
[34:30] the jury that somebody didn't need to be the trigger man to be guilty of
[34:35] capital murder. He stated, not one time are you going to hear evidence
[34:39] that Charles Butler did anything to assist Billy Jack Gaither he was there, he
[34:45] participated. While the defense team claimed that Mullins had not participated in the murder,
[34:52] the prosecution said it was their theory that the murder had actually been planned.
[34:58] The trial got underway promptly in the jury heard the tape of the confession
[35:00] Butler had made to Detective Kelly Johnson. Butler's father, Charles Butler Senior,
[35:08] testified that his son returned home that night at about three a m and began
[35:14] crying. He then recounted the murder of Billy Jack, telling his father,
[35:19] we just killed a fellow. His father said that his son told him I
[35:24] kicked a queer's ass. Prosecutor Jeff Willis then moved quickly to show that Butler
[35:30] had in fact plotted with Mullins to kill Billy Jack two weeks before the murder.
[35:36] Stephen Eric mullins confession was entered into evidence, where he said that the
[35:40] murder was planned by the two men. Mullins was then called to the witness
[35:45] stand. He testified that Butler didn't strike the fatal blows that killed billy Jack,
[35:52] but said that he had spoken to him in the past about wanting to
[35:54] kill Billy Jack. He said that he plotted to kill billy Jack to steal
[35:59] his mud and because he had made a posit him. He testified, I
[36:05] was looking to get some money from him because I didn't have any and was
[36:07] unemployed. In his words, he invited Butler to help because he didn't like
[36:13] queers either. As he testified, Butler stared at him from the defense table
[36:17] intently. Mullins described how they lured Billy Jack to the forest with the promise
[36:23] of a threesome. He admitted that he had carried out the murder himself,
[36:28] had set the butler ran away when he was beating billy Jack to death.
[36:32] He set the butler returned after he called him several times had said that.
[36:37] He then offered him his pen knife in case he wanted to slip Billy Jock's
[36:42] throat again. He testified, I told him it was good enough. Defense.
[36:47] Attorney Hill then asked Mullins, are you telling these ladies and gentlemen that
[36:52] one of the reasons you set Billy Jack either up was because he was gay?
[36:58] Mullins replied, yes, sir. He was then asked, and you
[37:02] hate gays? Mullins responded yes sir. The prosecution then summoned Jimmy Deemed the
[37:09] witness stand to challenge Mullens's claims of being prejudiced against the LGBTQ plus community.
[37:17] The alleged an alternative narrative, suggesting that Mullins himself might have been concealing his
[37:23] true sexual orientation. They theorized that Billy Jack may not have been killed because
[37:29] he was gay, but instead because he and Mullins had been in something of
[37:32] relationship and Mullins was afraid that this would become public knowledge in the town.
[37:39] Jimmy Dean, an openly gay man, testified that he had oral sex with
[37:45] Mullins during a party the previous fall. Two women also testified about the party
[37:51] and said they saw Jimmy and Mullins dancing together. They said that Mullins was
[37:55] concerned about whether anybody from Silicigo would see him at the party. Others testified
[38:02] that they knew Mullens had performed sex acts on other men for money. Mullens
[38:08] testified again following this testimony, and he admitted to being at the party.
[38:14] He denied questions from defense attorney Hill about having oral sex or having a sexual
[38:20] relationship with Billy Jack. The defense attorney then said, for a man who
[38:25] hates gays, you seem to hang out with gays an awful lot. Butler
[38:30] was called to testify on his own behalf, and he stalked to the same
[38:35] story he had told detectives. He said that when Mullen slipped Billy Jack's throat,
[38:40] he was in shock and didn't know what to do. He said that
[38:45] he only went along with what was happening that night because he was terrified of
[38:49] Mullin's and didn't want him to think that he was going to rot on him.
[38:53] He testified that he didn't hate Billy Jack and that he never wanted him
[38:58] to die. To have Mullins sell me it's backed up the claims that Butler
[39:01] didn't know that Billy Jack was going to die that night. One said that
[39:07] Mullins told him, you should have seen the look on Butler's face when I
[39:10] knocked Billy Jack's teeth out. He turned white as a ghost. After the
[39:15] testimony was presented, it was time for closing arguments. Prosecutor Thompson told the
[39:22] jury that both Mullins and Butler were two pieces of evil. He said that,
[39:27] well, Butler may not have carried out the murder physically, he was
[39:30] there every step of the way, aiding and assisting. Defend's attorney Hill,
[39:36] on the other hand, referred to his client as an innocent boy, telling
[39:40] the jury he did not kill him Stephen Eric Mullins did. Mullins is a
[39:46] hustler. He's hustled my client, He's hustled Billy Jack Gaither, He's hustled
[39:52] the district attorney, and he's trying to hustle you. The jury deliberated for
[39:57] just two and a half hours before finding Charles Bully Junior guilty of Billy Jack's
[40:01] murder. After Billy Jack's family requested that the death penalty be taken off the
[40:07] table, but there was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
[40:14] It's out of court, Marion said. The family were placed. He
[40:17] stated, I can't see taking another human's life no matter what. He then
[40:22] shared his desire for his son to be remembered as one of the finest sons
[40:28] a man could want. The following day, Mullins returned to court to be
[40:31] formally sentenced. The details of the crime were read aloud, following which Mullins
[40:37] was asked how he felt. He responded, very sorry that it happened.
[40:44] I'm sorry. I wish I could change it all. Steve Mullins was then
[40:49] sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. Both Butler and Mullins
[41:02] were corded off to begin serving their life sentences. In December of nineteen ninety
[41:08] nine, Mullins did an interview with twenty twenty and said that Billy Jack was
[41:13] spending eternity in hell because he was gay. He said that he had repented
[41:20] and that he was carrying no guilt for the murder because God had forgiven him.
[41:23] Butler did his own interview with PBS Frontline, and much like Mullins,
[41:28] he appeared to have no guilt. He stated, Billy Jack started talking about
[41:34] some gay issues, wanting to have a threesome or whatever. Steve jumped on
[41:39] him and cut his throat. There. I didn't even know the man for
[41:44] him to be hitting on me, Tempers just flared. It's like he didn't
[41:47] have no respect. Over his incarceration, Mullens allegedly disavoid neo Nazism. He
[41:55] said that at one point he believed that every other race other than white was
[42:00] evil and didn't belong on earth. He also said he felt as though the
[42:04] person who killed Billy Jack was another person, not him. On the twenty
[42:09] sixth of February two thousand and nineteen, forty five year old Stephen Mullins was
[42:15] stabbed to death in a housing area at the Saint Clair Correctional Facility. He
[42:20] had been killed by fifty year old Christopher Scott Jones, who was serving time
[42:24] for killing five men in Shelby County in two thousand and eight. In the
[42:30] days and weeks before his murder, Mullins had repeatedly asked for protection. He
[42:36] reported that he had been threatened with violence and couldn't live safely without protection housing.
[42:43] According to the Equal Justice Initiative, rather than be placed in a protective
[42:46] unit, Mullins was placed in a dorm known for violent and serious assaults.
[42:53] Although Mullins purportedly renounced his previous association with neo Nazism, his visible racist tattoos
[43:00] potentially made him an easy target, particularly for an individual like Jones, who
[43:07] had previously taken the lives of five people. Billy Jack Gaither led a modest
[43:14] and harmonious existence, keeping his homosexuality somewhat discreet within his conservative Alabama community.
[43:22] He had every right to freely love whoever he chose, but found himself victim
[43:27] to the heat he was trying to prevent. Even today, Alabama's hate crime
[43:30] law does not apply to crimes committed on account of sexual orientation or gender identity.
[43:37] But that's not for a lack of trying. Well, Bestie's that is
[44:05] it for this episode of Morbidology. It was always thank you so so much
[44:08] for listening, And I'd like to say a big massive thank you to my
[44:12] newest supporters up on Patreon, Stephanie and Rebecca. If you'd like to support
[44:16] Morbidology on Patreon, the link is in the show notes, and in exchange
[44:21] for your support, I upload bonus episodes of Morbidology plus that are on the
[44:24] regular podcast platforms. I also upload ad free in early release episodes behind the
[44:31] Scenes, which includes bonus audio, video and case files. And I also
[44:36] send out a hand written thank you card along with some cool merch so you'll
[44:40] know. Morbidology is a one woman's team, so the support upon Patreon seriously
[44:45] goes such a long way. If you'd like to support the show in another
[44:49] way, please consider leaving me a rating and review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify,
[44:53] or wherever else you may be listening. Ratings and reviews are a super
[44:58] easy way to support an independent didn't show that you like, and I genuinely
[45:01] do appreciate the feedback. Remember to check us out at morbiology dot com for
[45:07] more information about this episode and to read or true crime articles. Until next
[45:12] time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
