# 239: Nicole Lovell

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 15 Jan 2024, 55 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/58197070/morbidology_239_nicole_lovell.mp3

Blacksburg is a town of roughly 43,000 residents in Montgomery County, Virginia, in the United States. Nestled in the picturesque New River Valley, enveloped by the Appalachian Mountains, the town boasts natural beauty with its hiking trails and parks. Notably recognised as the residence of Virginia Tech, Blacksburg is affectionately known as Hokie Nation, embodying a robust school spirit and pride. However, amidst its positive attributes, the town has witnessed tragic events. In April 2007, it became the backdrop for one of the deadliest school shootings in the United States—the Virginia Tech shooting. Less than ten years later, another tragedy unfolded, raising questions about teenager’s safety online. SPONSORS - Schedule35: Thank you to Schedule35 for sponsoring this episode! Schedule35 want to destigmatise and educate on the science and practical advantages of shrooms. Get 15% off your order with the code “MORBIDOLOGY” at: https://schedule35.co/ SmartLabels: Thank you to SmartLabels for sponsoring this episode! Say goodbye to countless minutes rummaging through storage bins for your Fall and Thanksgiving decorations with SmartLabels. Download their app on the app store and buy their QR labels at: https://www.amazon.com/QR-Smart-Labels-Scannable-Organization/dp/B0BJS364C6?maas=maas_adg_31EA81720AD78B3DA43CB84763549F2B_afap_abs&ref_=aa_maas&tag=maas Zocdoc: Thank you to Zocdoc for sponsoring this episode! Zocdoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient reviewed, take your insurance & are available when you need them. To find a & book a top rated doctor today. Visit: https://zocdoc.com/morbidology PODCAST PROMO - Mortal Musings Podcast: https://linktr.ee/mortalmusingspodcast SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-239-nicole-lovell PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:02] Brace yourself for a journey into the darkest corners of human nature with The Mortal
[0:07] Musings podcast, available wherever you get your podcast, join host Neil and Megan
[0:12] each week as they travel to the chilling world of true crime and macombs.
[0:17] Stories from fringe socialites with hidden secrets to chilling tales from death Row. They
[0:22] leave no stone unturned. They also bring you the strange and intriguing stories of
[0:26] oddities that will leave you questioning your very reality. Each episode of The Mortal
[0:31] Musing's podcast is a rollercoaster ride through the bizarre and unsettling. New episodes drop
[0:36] every Wednesday. The Mortal Musing's podcast is on Spotify, Apple Podcast, and
[0:41] all podcast platforms. If you crave the dark, the mysterious, and the
[0:45] utterly bizarre, you'll want to add The Mortal Musings podcast to your podcast playlist.
[0:50] The Mortal Musing's Podcast with host Neil and Meghan We take the cases seriously,
[0:55] but not ourselves, available wherever you get your podcast. If I was
[1:34] there, I would have stopped it. I would have stopped it. I
[1:38] wouldn't know why in anything if I even if I had to see to do
[1:45] that to her. Blacksburg is a town of roughly forty three thousand in Montgomery
[2:00] County, Virginia, in the United States. Nestled in the picturesque New River
[2:06] Valley enveloped by the Appalachian Mountains, the town boasts natural beauty with its hiking
[2:12] trails and parks. Notably recognized as the residence of Virginia Tech, Blacksburg is
[2:19] affectionately known as Hogy Nation, embodying a robust skill, spirit, and pride.
[2:24] However, amidst its positive attributes, the town has witnessed tragic events.
[2:30] In April of two thousand and seven, it became the backdrop for one of
[2:32] the deadliest school shootings in the United States, the Virginia Tech Massacre. Less
[2:38] than ten years later, another tragedy unfolded, raising many questions about the safety
[2:43] of teenagers online. On the morning of the twenty seventh of January two thousand
[2:59] and sixteen, sing Tammy wakes awoke in her Blacksburg apartment, located in the
[3:04] Lantern Ridge area. It was a Wednesday morning, and Tommy anticipated the usual
[3:09] hustle and bustle of her thirteen year old daughter in a cold lovel getting ready
[3:14] for school. However, an unusual silence enveloped the family's apartment, no signs
[3:21] of the shower, the hum of the hair dryer, or the familiar clatter
[3:24] of someone preparing breakfast in the kitchen. Puzzled by the quietness, Tammy approached
[3:30] her teenage daughter's bedroom and attempted to open the door. To her surprise,
[3:35] however, the door resisted. Tommy quickly realized something was pushed up against her
[3:40] daughter's bedroom door, preventing entry. Growing increasingly concerned, Tommy called out her
[3:47] daughter's name, only to be met with an eerie silence. Tommy exerted all
[3:53] of her strength to push the door open. After a determined effort, she
[3:57] managed to create enough space to squeeze in side. Tommy discovered nightstand had been
[4:02] strategically placed against the bedroom door. Scanning the vacant room, she noticed the
[4:10] open window with a breeze blowing the curtains. Further inspection revealed the absence of
[4:16] several items belonging to her daughter. This included black skinny jeans, a gray
[4:23] striped mossy oak shirt, brown and pink fat Boy Cowboy boots, and a
[4:28] Cole's Beloved Minions blanket. Tommy rushed to her bedroom and grabbed her cellphone.
[4:34] She desperately called Nicole, but it went straight to voicemail. She then texted
[4:41] David, Nicole's father, but was informed that he hadn't seen Nicole, nor
[4:45] had he heard from her. Tommy contacted Nicole's friends and other family members,
[4:50] yet nobody could account for Nicole's whereabouts. Panic had already set in by this
[4:57] stage. It wasn't like ni call to just vanish, but it appeared to
[5:02] Tammy as though she had climbed out of her bedroom window sometime in the middle
[5:06] of the night and then never returned. Fearing the worst, Tammy promptly reported
[5:13] her daughter missing to police. While waiting for their arrival, she comed the
[5:17] neighborhood on foot, questioning neighbors about Nicole. During her search, Tommy encountered
[5:25] Stacy Snyder, a nearby resident, who shared some unsettling news. Stacy's eight
[5:31] year old daughter revealed that Nicole had shown her a photograph of a man claiming
[5:35] that he was her boyfriend. Nicole had then told the little girl that she
[5:42] planned on sneaking out to meet him. Nicole Lovell was born to Tammy Wakes
[5:56] and David Madison Lovell in Radford City Virginia on the third of May two thousand
[6:00] and two. Fortunately, just a couple of weeks before Nicole was born,
[6:05] David left Tommy, thrusting her into the challenges of single motherhood with a newborn.
[6:12] Adding to the difficulties, a couple of days after Nicole's birth, Tommy
[6:15] noticed changes in her daughter's abdomen. Extensive testing revealed a rare tumor in Nicole's
[6:21] liver, leading to a critical diagnosis at just ten months old. Nicole underwent
[6:28] a successful liver transplant, but the journey to recovery didn't end there. To
[6:33] survive, Nicole had to diligently take anti rejection medication twice a day. Nicole
[6:40] faced even more trials at the age of four, when she was diagnosed with
[6:44] non Hodgkins lymphoma. Subsequently, she developed acute respiratory distress syndrome, slipping into
[6:50] a coma for six months. Additionally, Nicole battled m r SA, a
[6:57] drug resistant bacterial infection. The doctors gave her a mere one percent chance of
[7:01] survival, but against all odds, she triumphed. Eight months later, Nicole
[7:08] was discharged from the hospital, marking the end of her arduous health struggles.
[7:14] Tammy referred to her daughter as God's gift, commenting God got her through all
[7:18] that, and she fought through all that. Tommy dedicated herself to establishing a
[7:25] stable life for her daughter, receiving support from her parents along the way.
[7:30] The four of them shared a household, and when Tammy headed off to work
[7:33] each morning, her parents took care of Nicole. Meanwhile, David's presence in
[7:39] his daughter's life was sporadic and their relationship strained as she grew older. David
[7:46] grappled with legal issues, serving time on a drug related charge. By twenty
[7:53] sixteen, Nicole was a thirteen year old seventh grader attending Blacksburg Middle School.
[7:59] However, her girl experience was marred by billying. Tearfully, she confided in
[8:03] her mother about girls taunting her with derogatory comments about her weight and mocking the
[8:09] scars left by her liver transplant on her throat and stomach. Some mornings,
[8:16] the thought of skill filled Nicole with dread, prompting her to plead with her
[8:18] mother for a sick note to avoid gym class. The intensity of the bullying
[8:24] led Tammy to occasionally allow a coal to stay home, but even in the
[8:28] refuge of her own home, online harassment persisted. Battling a struggle with confidence
[8:35] and loneliness, Nicole openly expressed her yearning for love on social media, convinced
[8:41] that nobody cared about her. Her father's inconsistent presence left her longing for his
[8:46] love and support, creating a void that Tammy and her grandparents worked hard to
[8:50] fill. Despite her challenging teenage experience, Nicole maintained a strong bond with her
[8:58] mother and grandparents. She was navigating the awkward stage of adolescence, where she
[9:03] held on the aspects of her childhood while exploring the realities of the adult world.
[9:09] Nicole enjoyed playing with younger children in the neighborhood, adored Panda's and the
[9:15] movie Minions, decorating her bedroom with the characters. While she cherished these youthful
[9:20] pursuits, Nicoll was also an active presence on social media, regularly sharing selfies
[9:26] on Instagram and Facebook. Faith played a significant role in Nicole's life, with
[9:31] her family all being regular attend days at the Auburn Baptist Church. Despite her
[9:37] hardships, Nicole nurtured dreams of starring on American Idol, showcasing her talent as
[9:43] a singer and dancer that was familiar with the family said that Tammy went above
[9:48] and beyond for her daughter. As neighbors, Stacy Snyder recalled, Tommy spoiled
[9:54] her, rotten, brought her everything she wanted everything. Following Nichole's reported disappearance
[10:09] by her mother, Tommy, detectives descended upon the neighborhood, initiating a thorough
[10:13] search. Tommy promptly shared the crucial tip she had received that Nicole had told
[10:20] the neighbor of her intention. Disney got to meet a boyfriend. Detectives interviewed
[10:26] this friend, who disclosed that Nicole had identified her boyfriend as an eighteen year
[10:31] old college student named David. They were slave riding in the snow in the
[10:37] back on the hill and she was talking about this boyfriend she had that was
[10:43] eighteen and went to college and his name was David, and showed some text
[10:46] messages off of kick and pictures. And that's what the girls told the police
[10:52] officers when they asked. As detectives delved into this lead to identify David,
[10:56] news of Nicole's disappearance rapidly spread throughout the town of Blacksburg. The community rallied
[11:03] in large numbers he had in the search, with a police source expressing uncertainty
[11:07] about whether it was a runaway situation or involved file play. The investigation covered
[11:15] every single angle, emphasizing the urgency of the situation. Detective stressed the significance
[11:22] of time, noting that Nicole had left without her daily liver transplant medication,
[11:26] which was essential for preventing permanent damage. It's one of the darkest and worst
[11:31] things that you can deal with, But Nicole also requires medication daily for a
[11:37] medical condition. We know that she's We're going on to thirty six plus hours
[11:41] without her not having the medication. Thousands of missing person posters were printed.
[11:46] The FBI was summoned to provide assistance. A command post was established in the
[11:52] family's neighborhood, with members of the Virginia Tech Corps of Cadets joining the efforts.
[12:00] Initially focusing on the vicinity surrounding Nicole's home, the search expanded to broader
[12:03] areas. Nicole's family, including her mother, father, and stepmother, actively
[12:09] participated in the search. Fully aware of the critical time factor. David express
[12:16] concern for his daughter's health, stating, at this point, I know she's
[12:20] sick, she's hurting, She's probably already into convulsions. Her liver is shutting
[12:26] down as we speak, wherever she is. He also appealed to her on
[12:31] the off chance that she had left willingly, emphasizing that they weren't angry,
[12:35] but just desperately wanted her home. Tommy and her father also made appeals on
[12:41] ws LS ten. He's later on my familied. He whoever has her is
[12:52] no sleeping at night, cleant, she needs HERDIC say really bad, she's
[13:03] good and critical and Nicole's home detectives quickly came across a lead when they discovered
[13:09] that she had written the user names and passwords of her online of cons on
[13:11] her bedroom wall on the back of her door. They also came across some
[13:16] writing which read I love David. They were still trying to figure out who
[13:22] David, her alleged older boyfriend, was, and turned to her social media.
[13:28] On her Facebook, they discovered that she was active in several teen dating
[13:31] groups, something which has been described as a parental nightmare. These groups consist
[13:37] of the full teen trifecta, sexting, cyber bullying, and strangers. They're
[13:43] an unmoderated public forum where anybody of any age can join and be whoever they
[13:48] want to be. After being bullied in school and on social media, Nicole
[13:54] had turned to these semi anonymous groups for some attention, albeit from strangers.
[14:00] On the first of January, she posted a photograph of herself along with the
[14:03] caption qu or na, which prompted three hundred and four responses, most of
[14:09] which were extremely cruel. Just a few weeks before this, Nicole's parents had
[14:13] found out that she was talking inappropriately with older men online. As David recalled,
[14:20] you could tell these older guys had fake profiles. Some of the things
[14:24] they said were way too grown up for the picture they had. Nicole had
[14:28] gotten a stern talking to by both Tommy and David, and they took her
[14:33] cellphone off her, but she later got it back without their knowledge. She
[14:37] continued chatting to strangers on social media. Persisting concerns for Nichole's parents and detectives
[14:45] centered around the possibility that she had encountered a man named David online and slurred
[14:50] away from her home in the middle of the night. Despite scanning the groups
[14:56] that Nicole had joined, detectives couldn't locate anybody named d David, who was
[15:00] interacting with her. While the search of Nicole's online activity continued, detectives heard
[15:05] from her friend Natasha Bryant. Natasha said that Nicole had told her she had
[15:11] a boyfriend named David. She described him as funny and really cute, and
[15:18] confided in Natasha about her intention to run away with him and start a family.
[15:24] Nicole had also posted about a boyfriend on Facebook, changing her relationship status
[15:30] to in a relationship and announcing that she had recently just had her very first
[15:33] kiss. This detective stalved into Nicole's private Instagram account. They stumbled upon a
[15:39] screenshot from a conversation she had posted a few months earlier. The conversation occurred
[15:46] on the app Kick with a username named doctor Tombstone. Kick is a popular
[15:52] chat app which is attractive to teenagers. Due to its anonymity features. Users
[15:58] could sign up without provide adding a cell phone number, ensuring the conversations remained
[16:03] private from their parents' knowledge. Nicole had signed up the Kick with the user
[16:07] name Nicole Lovell one five one four, and detectives put in an emergency disclosure
[16:14] request to Kick to gain access to her account. They soon discovered in the
[16:21] months leading up to Nicole's disappearance, she had been interacting with the user named
[16:25] doctor Tombstone almost every single day. It was clear that they had some form
[16:30] of a relationship. In early January, Nicole had said to him, Dear
[16:37] David, you're my crush. But I know you don't think of me like
[16:41] that, but I don't care. I will always be here. If you're
[16:44] looking for a good time, I'm here. When you have a bad day,
[16:48] i'm here, and I don't want that to change. I want to
[16:51] be in your life for as long as you can stand me. And I
[16:53] know i'm annoying and I ask for too much, but I'm a girl and
[16:57] I have a heart and feelings, and my feelings get hurt a lot,
[17:02] but it's never been hurt by you, and I like that. So yeah,
[17:06] I'm too stupid to think that you actually want to stay in my life.
[17:10] But if you don't, I'll just have a life by Doctor Tombstone responded.
[17:17] So here's what I'm thinking, and I'll give you some options. One,
[17:21] we take a break from talking for a bit until I get back to
[17:23] a semi normal routine, and then i'll message you a few weeks at most
[17:29] Two we keep talking just as friends and see how that goes. Three we
[17:33] don't talk again. Four we stay friends and keep in contact, and I'll
[17:38] be here when you need me. The last time that Nicole and Doctor Tombstone
[17:44] messaged was at twelve thirty nine a m. The night before Nicole has discovered
[17:48] missing from her bedroom. After this, all of Nicole's social media profiles turned
[17:52] silent. Detectives then made contact with Kick and they provided them with the name
[18:00] connected to the doctor Tombstone account, David A. The account was connected to
[18:06] the Gmail account d for Friends seven, leading detectives directly to David Eisenhower,
[18:12] an eighteen year old freshman engineering student at Virginia Tech. David Eisenhower had spent
[18:23] the majority of his childhood in Washington State, attending a small Christian school.
[18:30] Following his sophomore year, his father's transfer to Maryland prompted his family to purchase
[18:34] a six hundred and twenty thousand dollars home in Columbia. In two thousand and
[18:38] thirteen. Eisenhower distinguished himself as a celebrated student, consistently achieving straight as and
[18:47] gaining recognition as a high school track store. His competitive running journey began in
[18:52] middle school, and during his freshman year at Virginia Tech, he was red
[18:56] shirted, gaining prom eminence in college track circles. He was featured by WMAAR
[19:03] in Baltimore for a Student Athlete of the Year segment in March twenty and fifteen,
[19:08] where he was noted for making a name for himself on the truck.
[19:11] I make my personal goals achievable or just out of reach of achievable. That
[19:18] way, I'm always constantly striving to better myself. If that goal becomes a
[19:22] record, or if that goal is past a record or records get broken in
[19:25] the process, I consider that like a milestone goal. But that's not where
[19:29] I ultimately want to end up. Expressing ambitions beyond athletics, Eisenhower aspired to
[19:33] work for the Defense Advanced Research Project Agency, an organization specializing in developing military
[19:41] technology. Ever felt trapped by that persistent on at family gatherings, bombarding you
[19:48] with personal questions that makes you want to ban the truth just for them to
[19:52] judge you anyway. Questions about marriage promotions or why you haven't moved out of
[19:59] your parents' place. We've all been there, but when it comes to discussing
[20:03] your health issues with your doctor, you shouldn't have to endure a similar experience.
[20:07] That's where ZocDoc steps in. With ZocDoc, you can easily find the
[20:11] book doctors who prioritize your comfort and genuinely listen to your concerns. And it's
[20:18] not just a handful of doctors. We're talking about tens of thousands, each
[20:22] with patient reviews to help you make an informed choice. Zoctoc is a free
[20:26] app and website where you can search and compare highly rated in network doctors near
[20:30] you and instantly book appointments with them online. If only I had ZocDoc when
[20:36] I was searching for a reliable doctor, it would have made the process seemless.
[20:41] Go to ZocDoc dot com slash morbidology and download the ZocDoc app for free.
[20:45] Then find and book a top rated doctor today. That's zerocadoc dot com
[20:52] slash morbidology, ZocDoc dot com slash morbidology. After David Eisenhower was identified as
[21:03] doctor Tombstone, detectives arrived at his dorm at Virginia Tech as he was being
[21:08] transferred to the police headquarters for questioning in regards to Nichole's disappearance, detectives thoroughly
[21:15] searched his living quarters. During the search, Eisenhower's roommate, Jeremy Bissero arrived.
[21:23] Detectives informed Jeremy that Eisenhower was a person of interest in the investigation into
[21:29] Nichole's disappearance. Jeremy recounted that on the night that Nicole went missing, Eisenhower
[21:36] exhibited some unusual behavior. According to Jeremy, Eisenhower put on a pair of
[21:41] boots, left the dorm, and then returned in the early morning hours.
[21:48] Jeremy also mentioned that Eisenhower frequently kept a knife on his desk. However,
[21:55] during the comprehensive search of the dorm, this knife was noticeably absent. As
[22:00] the search continued, detectives discovered a piece of paper that had Nichole is a
[22:07] dress written on it. Over at the police headquarters, Eisenhower was presented with
[22:11] the kick conversations that he had with Nicole. He was informed that he was
[22:18] the last person that spoke with her before she vanished. He detailed her he
[22:22] and Nicole had first come into contact mid December. I remember correctly, I
[22:30] was born in my dorm room and logged onto a website where you go and
[22:34] he talked to random strangers. It's an anonymous kind of The website is called
[22:40] Oleagel if I believe correctly, okay, And she's like, hey, do
[22:44] you want to use my or like message me on some app called kick and
[22:48] I was like sure whatever. According to Eisenhower, Nicole had told him that
[22:53] she was either sixteen or seventeen years old, he couldn't remember, which accounted
[23:00] how he and Nicole had opened up to one another and had chaired an emotional
[23:03] connection, but when the Coal asked to meet up, he was put off.
[23:07] He said to detective that when the coll began referring to him as her
[23:11] boyfriend, he freaked out, but eventually he agreed to meet up with her
[23:15] for the first time. He admitted to driving over to Nicol's home the night
[23:21] that she disappeared. He said he pulled up outside and watched the Coal climb
[23:25] out of her bedroom window. I get there and then I see someone who
[23:29] probably looked like she was eleven years old climb out of a window and I
[23:32] was like, oh, ah, not for me. She walked over to
[23:36] the car, and Eisenhower said that he gave her a hug and she asked
[23:40] if they could run away together. According to Eisenhower, he realized that Nicole
[23:45] was much younger than sixteen or seventeen. He contended that he left on his
[23:49] own afterwards, never to see Nicole again. During the interrogation, Eisenhower rarely
[23:56] moved and stared directly at the detectives, first, daring because you can tell
[24:03] when people are lying based on their ears and their pupils, which is how
[24:07] I know that you are stuck. But unfortunately I cannot help you any further.
[24:11] Eisenhower then became angry, suggesting to detectives that they needed to look for
[24:17] a dead body instead of focus on the last person who saw Nicole alive.
[24:22] When Oscar is alibi for the night that Nicole disappeared, he said that he
[24:26] went to Walmart. Yeah, I have a shovel in my car. Bought
[24:30] it from Walmart right after snowshell. I think garden shovels. I got fifteen
[24:36] dollars shovel or something. Would have helped to mention I had someone else with
[24:40] me when I bought the shovel for snow purposes. Her name is a Natalie
[24:45] Keepers. After Eisenhower refused to answer any more questions and request and attorney immediately
[25:00] delved into Eisenhower's alibi and tracked on the friend that he was allegedly with that
[25:04] night at Walmart, nineteen year old Natalie Keepers. The two had crossed paths
[25:11] just before they began their freshman year at Virginia Tech, where they were both
[25:15] studying engineering. They had a fling in the summer, but became close friends
[25:21] as they entered the engineering program together. Keepers had been born into a family
[25:26] of strong Christian faith, and her parents, Sarah and Tim, said that
[25:30] she had been a good influence on her younger siblings. Much like Eisenhower,
[25:36] Keepers had a bright future ahead of her. She had interned at NASA's Goddard
[25:40] Space Flight Center and had led science experiments in her church's Bible School. She
[25:45] played junior varsity soccer at Hammond High School, but she wasn't a standout athlete
[25:51] like Eisenhower had been. Her interests were more diverse, as she joined the
[25:56] math team and modeled United Nations. She had also been a member of the
[26:02] National Honor Society and the National Science Honor Society. She had graduated high school
[26:07] in the top fifteen percent of her class, with a grade point average of
[26:11] three point two nine. As she began her freshman year at Virginia Tech,
[26:17] she had ambitions to follow in her father's footsteps as an aerospace engineer at NASA.
[26:23] Natalie Keepers was tracked on at her boyfriend's storm room and brought over to
[26:27] the police headquarters to be interviewed. Detectives told her that she was there to
[26:33] be questioned in relation to Nicole's disappearance after Eisenhoer identified her as his alibi for
[26:37] that night. At first, she denied any knowledge, before suddenly changing her
[26:44] tune and becoming unusually open. She told detectives that she wanted to help in
[26:49] their investigation and come clean, but first she asked if her name would be
[26:56] mentioned because she didn't want any angry pain parents. Keepers then stunningly revealed that
[27:03] Nicholl was dead and that she had played a role in the planning of her
[27:07] murder. According to Keepers, Nicoll had been killed by David Eisenhower, the
[27:14] man she had been speaking with online. Keepers told detectives that she had never
[27:18] met nor had she even spoken to Nicol, But despite this, when Eisenhower
[27:22] asked if she wanted to help him kill her, she agreed. She said
[27:29] that over the course of a few weeks, she and Eisenhower discussed several ways
[27:33] to kill Nicol. They considered drugging her, making it look like a suicide,
[27:38] and knocking her unconscious and leaving her to die of exposure. Keeper said
[27:44] that they then eventually settled on what she described as the official plan. This
[27:51] was to learn a caoll out of her home with the promise of a romantic
[27:53] walk with Eisenhower, grab her from behind, cover her mouth, and then
[28:00] at her throat. But first they needed to settle on a location. The
[28:04] more rural, the better, she said to detectives. He said he was
[28:10] looking for a good spot to talk to her, so that it was alone
[28:12] and out of the public eye. Keeper suggested Craig Creek Road and isolated and
[28:19] mountainous area just outside Blacksburg. Unsettled on the murder lucation, Eisenhower and Keepers
[28:26] purchased a shovel and some cleaning supplies. Keepers became emotional if she denied that
[28:33] she was present when Nicole was killed. If I was there, I would
[28:37] have stopped it. I would have stopped it. I wouldn't know why an
[28:41] if I even if I had to see him do that to her, And
[28:48] the first thing I would have done is started the card and drove because I
[28:56] didn't think damn couldn't do such a thing. As Keepers was being interrogated,
[29:02] detectives were examining her cell phone. The night that Nicole went missing, she
[29:07] had texted Eisenhower for an update on their plan. He chillingly responded, it's
[29:14] done. Keepers sold detectives that after Nicholl was killed, Eisenhower left her body
[29:19] in the woods. However, after her disappearance gained more traction than they had
[29:23] anticipated, they decided to move her. Eisenhower had texted Keepers that they needed
[29:30] Nichol's body to not be found for at least a week. He said that
[29:34] after that all of the evidence connecting them to the murder would be gone.
[29:41] He said that thousands of children go missing each year. They had hoped that
[29:45] Nicole would become another one of these grim statistics. In another message, Eisenhower
[29:51] had written, I looked up what police do for missing kids. There are
[29:56] twelve thousand missing kids in Virginia. They do basically nothing like It's sad.
[30:02] They get thirty reports of runaways a day, eighty seven percent that don't return
[30:07] after a few days are never found. I guess we figure out how people
[30:11] commit mass murder. Keepers and Eisenhower then drove out to the location where he
[30:15] had left Nichole's body in the woods on Craig Creek Road. Keepers admitted to
[30:21] helping Eisenhower drag Nicole's lifeless body into his car, and after turning off their
[30:26] cell phones, they drove her south of Blacksburg. Keeper said that Eisenhower had
[30:30] planned to bury Nicole on property near his grandparents' home outside glacks Instead, they
[30:37] drove just inside the North Carolina line to amount in a section of Surrey County,
[30:42] where they stripped Nicole naked and cleaned her with bleach to try and get
[30:45] rid of evidence. They then left her on the side of the road and
[30:51] drove over to Walmart, where they brought more cleaning supplies. From here,
[30:56] they went to McDonald's where they brought drinks and disposed of bloody cleaning wipes,
[31:00] and then on to West Virginia, where they dumped some of Nichol's belongings in
[31:03] the New River. The two then returned to their respective dormitories, where keepers
[31:10] taxed at Eisenhower, I smell like cleaning supplies. I mean I was close
[31:15] to a lot of blood. After making the confession, Keepers told detectives that
[31:21] she had willingly participated in the planning and disposal of Nichol's body because it made
[31:26] her feel like part of a special secret club. He made me feel like
[31:30] I was being a part of some like a secret club that only me and
[31:34] him were a part of. She said to detectives that it was the best
[31:38] club in the world because Eisenhower understood her. She referred to Eisenhower as a
[31:45] socioppath and to herself as a sociopath in training. In another tax message,
[31:52] sent just minutes before Keeper was taken to the police headquarters to be interviewed,
[31:57] she had warned Eisenhower with the single word police. She was then asked about
[32:05] this text message. She said that Eisenhower had wanted her to give him a
[32:08] twenty four ar head start if she were ever brought in to be questioned.
[32:15] They had come up with a code, and that was for Keepers to use
[32:17] her one phone call to call him and talk about vomiting. On the first
[32:22] day that they met, She explained that Eisenhower had planned on running away and
[32:28] changing his identity if detectives ever identified them as suspects in Nichole's murder. However,
[32:36] by the time the text message was sent, Eisenhower was already a prime
[32:40] suspect in the disappearance of Nicole. Following Keeper's confession, she drove out with
[32:46] detectives to various sites, including dumpsters, where they disposed of evidence. Detectives
[32:53] were able to recover a bleach bottle inside a Walmart bag and blue plastic gloves.
[33:00] Keepers also pointed out tire tracks from Eisenhower's car and their footprints in the
[33:05] blood spattered snow where Nichole was killed. She attempted to find the knife that
[33:09] Eisenhower had disposed of in a wooded area, but was unsuccessful. Finally,
[33:16] in Keeper's dorm room, they came across a bloody jim bag. Inside they
[33:22] found a bloody stick and a call's blood spattered minion's blanket. Natalie Keepers was
[33:32] subsequently charged with one felony count of improper disposal of a dead body and one
[33:37] misdemeanor count of accessory after the fact in the commission of a felony. Armed
[33:44] with her confession, detectives promptly charged David Eisenhower with Nicholl's murder. Seeing keepers
[33:51] were booked into jail. Detectives descended on the area that Nicole said they had
[33:54] disposed of Nicole's body. They arrived at a wooded area just off Route eighty
[34:00] nine inside Sorry County, North Carolina. The location was about seven miles south
[34:06] of Gallics and less than two miles outside of Greyson County, to areas that
[34:09] Eisenhower was familiar with. He had family who owned land in both areas.
[34:16] Just at the side of the road, they came across Nicole's nude body.
[34:22] One of the detectives recollected to A and E. Nicole was located off the
[34:25] main road, going off the side of a mountain. She was stabbed a
[34:29] number of times. She was not bayed. They apparently had just tossed her
[34:35] from the age. Nicole was transported to the Office of Medical Examiner in Roanoke,
[34:39] Virginia for an autopsy. The pathologist, doctor Gale Suzuki, found that
[34:45] Nicole had been stabbed fourteen times, mostly to the head and neck, but
[34:51] also several to the chest. There were external bruises and scrapes to her body,
[34:57] as well as bruising to the inside of her scalp. Nicole had also
[35:00] sustained a broken bone to her neck that was caused by blunt force trauma.
[35:06] Evidence indicated that Nicole was still alive when she sustained this injury. As news
[35:12] of the discovery swept throughout the area, Tommy spoke at a press conference to
[35:16] pay tribute to her daughter. Her favorite color was blue. Nicholl was very
[35:22] lovable person. Nicole touched many people throughout her short life. The next day,
[35:30] hundreds of people gathered for a vigil for Nicole at the River of Life
[35:35] Church. Pastor Mike Connacher asked for those in attendance to pray for Nicole's family
[35:40] and to try and do more to protect and guard children. Blacksburg Middle School
[35:45] announced that they would have extra councilors on hand when school resumed on the Monday.
[35:52] Just a few days later, the charges against Keepers were upgraded. She
[35:55] was additionally charged with accessory before the fact to win, willfully, deliberately,
[36:00] and with premeditation, kill and murder Nicole in the first gree Keeper's defense attorney
[36:07] Christopher Ullan requested bail, telling the judge, we understand the allegations are disturbing
[36:14] and serious, but they are just allegations. He said the keepers had been
[36:19] struggling behind bars where she was being kept in isolation for her own safety.
[36:25] He also said that she was allergic to the gluten in the food that was
[36:29] being served at the jail. Keeper spoke to the judge during her court appearance
[36:35] and described how she had self harmed since she was an eighth grader. Much
[36:39] like Nicole, she too had been bullied at school and said that she had
[36:44] been in therapy to overcome the years of bullying and had been on the antidepressant
[36:49] prozac. Judge Robert Weyers Junior turned on the request, ordering that keepers remain
[36:54] behind bars. Then on the third of February, a steady stream of cars
[37:00] filled the parking lot of a McCoy funeral home as people came together to pay
[37:06] their respects to Nicole. Among those in attendance was Jane Lillian Vance, an
[37:12] instructional assistant at Blacksburg Middle School. She chatted with some of the reporters outside
[37:17] and said that she had bonded with Nicole over her love for animals. She
[37:22] commented her smile. Everybody's going to tell you that they'll miss her smile because
[37:29] she had some kind of magic under her eyes and around her mouth. I
[37:32] will miss her potential. I looked forward to Nicole years from nou. A
[37:38] family friend, Katie Wilson poignantly said of Nicole, she fought so hard to
[37:44] get to this point in her life, and you have people like that that
[37:47] just take her innocence from her. With both Eisenhower and Keepers behind bars,
[37:59] the investigation into Nicole's murder continued. Detectives wanted to figure out exactly why Eisenhower
[38:06] had wanted Nicole dead, but they had an idea. He was a nineteen
[38:09] year old man, whereas Nicole was just a thirteen year old girl, and
[38:14] he had clearly been grooming her over the Internet. Step into the new year
[38:22] with the resolution to declutter and organize and let Smart Labels be your guiding light.
[38:28] Say goodbye to the chaos of misplaced items, entangled messes. Welcome a
[38:31] world of order and deficiency with their cutting edge app and qre Labels. Simply
[38:37] purchase their color coded smart labels from their website Cure smart Labels dot Com,
[38:43] Amazon or Walmart. Then download the smart Labels app from the Apple App Store
[38:47] or Google Play to effortlessly create a digital inventory of each box. No more
[38:53] lost moments searching for that one item you know you packed away somewhere, and
[38:58] ensure that your new year's resolution to be more organized becomes a reality. Embrace
[39:04] the future of streamlined living where technology meets tidiness. Make sure to click the
[39:09] link in my show notes to simplify your storage organization today. Detective soon received
[39:19] a tip from a man named Bryce Dustan that brought the motivation to the forefront.
[39:25] Bryce and Eisenhower had begun communicating through online gaming, although they never had
[39:30] met in person. Nevertheless, they had built up a friendship and they had
[39:36] a level of trust in one another. They had exchanged phone numbers and texted
[39:40] quite frequently for over the previous year. Eisenhower had gone to Bryce around a
[39:47] year earlier, asking for advice on how to kiss a girl. According to
[39:53] Bryce, these conversations took a dark turn when Eisenhower later asked him if he
[40:00] where to hide a body. At first, Bryce thought that Eisenhower was joking.
[40:07] Before this conversation, Eisenhower had asked Bryce for some advice. He said
[40:13] that he had met a girl at a party, but later learned that she
[40:15] was underage. While he didn't name the girl. In the text messages,
[40:21] he said that he was concerned because she wanted to be with him and wanted
[40:24] him to be her boyfriend. Bryce said to detectives he was older and she
[40:30] was younger. He was saying that she was going to expose him. Bryce
[40:36] had suggested a plan for Eisenhower to just ignore the girl until she got over
[40:39] it and moved on. A couple of days later, however, Eisenhower texted
[40:45] Bryce once more and told him that the plan had failed. He then added,
[40:52] I need to know where to hide a body. Bryce never responded to
[40:55] the text message, but then when he saw Eisenhower on the new Who's charged
[41:00] with the Coll's murder? He put turned two together and called detectives. With
[41:06] this new information, detectives firmly believed that Eisenhower had killed Nicoll because she was
[41:10] going to expose him as a child predator. When detectives spoke with Keepers about
[41:15] the motivation behind the murder, she provided them with some more information. While
[41:21] Eisenhower intended detectives that the first time he met Nicole was when she climbed out
[41:24] of her bedroom window, this wasn't the truth. Keepers told detectives that he
[41:30] had met Nicole before at a local high school party, both at attendant.
[41:37] Eisenhower had told Keepers that he had blacked out at the party and woke up
[41:39] the next day in a ditch. A friend had told him that he had
[41:44] been making out with the girl at the party, and shortly thereafter he began
[41:47] receiving messages from Nicole on kick. She told him that they had master around,
[41:54] which he understood to mean sexually. According to Keepers, eye, Eisenhower
[42:00] had feared that he had gotten the coal pregnant and that she had wanted to
[42:04] be in a relationship with him. He also alleged that Nicole had threatened to
[42:08] take her own life unless he visited her. While Eisenhower may have been fearful
[42:15] that he got Nical pregnant, her autopsy showed otherwise. In July, Eisenhower
[42:22] and Keepers were indicted by a grand jury. Eisenhower was indicted on charges of
[42:28] first degree murder, abduction, and hiding a body. Keepers was indicted on
[42:34] charges of being an accessory to kidnapping, murder, and helping to hide a
[42:37] body. While many had called for prosecutors to seek capital punishment against Eisenhower,
[42:45] they couldn't because there was no physical evidence that he had sexually assaulted Nicole.
[42:50] Prosecutors would have had to show he had producted her with the intent to sexually
[42:53] assault her in order to pursue capital murder charges against him. It was decided
[43:00] that they would stand trial separately, with Eisenhower's standing trial first in March of
[43:06] two thousand and seventeen, followed by Keepers later in the month, whose states
[43:12] were then pushed back as it was decided that some of Keeper's interrogation couldn't be
[43:15] entered into evidence. The judge had ruled the detectives hadn't read Keeper's her Miranda
[43:22] rights early enough. David Eisenhower's trial began on the sixth of February two thousand
[43:29] and eighteen. During opening statements, it became apparent that his defense was to
[43:35] blame Natalie Keeper's defense attorney John Lichenstein stated, the evidence in the case will
[43:43] be that the presence of somebody else at that scene, and the presence of
[43:46] somebody else who was steeply motivated to commit that murder, will leave you with
[43:51] that reasonable doubt. He described Keepers as somebody having a history of mental illness,
[43:58] a fascination with knives, and that she was excited When discussing the murder
[44:02] of Nicole during the prosecution's opening statements, Mary Petite refuted the keepers was to
[44:08] blame for Nichole's murder. She confidently said to the jury, he has a
[44:15] problem, and his problem is Nicole Lovel. She revealed for the first time
[44:21] that Eisenhower's DNA was discovered underneath Nicholl's finger nails, and that her blood was
[44:25] discovered in the trunk of his car. She described how Nicole had snuck out
[44:30] of the house for what she believed was a date with Eisenhower. Instead,
[44:37] she was lured to the woods, stabbed numerous times, and then left to
[44:40] die in the snow. The motivation, the prosecution said, was that Eisenhower
[44:46] was afraid Nichole would expose their relationship. Testimony then promptly got under way with
[44:52] Tommy Weekes, Nicholl's mother. She described finding Nicole missing from her bedroom with
[44:59] the windo wide open. When she was asked when the last time she saw
[45:04] her daughter was, she softly replied in her coffin. The jury then got
[45:09] to hear evidence about how Eisenhower was connected to the kick acount that had been
[45:14] speaking with Nicol. Forensic scientist Corey Barteau testified about Eisenhower's fingerprints. They had
[45:22] been found on a bottle of bleach found in the backseat of his car and
[45:25] the shovel that was also found in his car. Keeper's fingerprints were also discovered
[45:30] on the same bottle of bleach and shovel. The fingerprints that had been discovered
[45:37] on the shovel were in blood. Furthermore, detectives had found a pair of
[45:42] bloodstained boots that belonged to Keepers in her dorm room. They were spattered with
[45:45] blood and DNA testing showed that this blood had come from the coal. Fingernail
[45:52] clippings from the coal had contained foreign DNA. Keeper's DNA was ruled out,
[45:58] but Eisenhower's DNA couldn't be ruled doubt. Within Eisenhower's car, forensic experts also
[46:04] found Nicole's blood on the tire, trunk, and backseat, as well as
[46:08] on a container of wet wipes and on the shovel. Deanna Jones from the
[46:13] Blacksburg Police Department testified next, telling the jury about the GPS on Eisenhower's car.
[46:21] It showed his movements on the night of Nicole's murder, placing him at
[46:23] her apartment in Craig Creek Road, where she was killed. The evidence against
[46:29] Eisenhower was so overwhelming that after two days of testimony, his defense team asked
[46:35] the judge to rearrayin him. Eisenhower then entered plays of new contest to all
[46:40] of the charges he was facing. This meant that he acknowledged that there was
[46:45] enough evidence to convict him, but didn't admit that he actually committed the crimes.
[46:51] Essentially, it has the same effect as a guilty play. Eisenhower then
[46:55] waived his right to a trial, along with his right to defend himself or
[47:00] make an appeal in the case. The judge then found Eisenhower guilty on all
[47:04] of the charges against him, putting an end to the murder trial. If
[47:08] the trial were to continue, the jury were set to hear the series of
[47:13] text messages between himself and keepers, as well as messages between himself and Nicole.
[47:19] Detectives had also extracted information from his computer. He had visited websites about
[47:24] human decomposition and had researched how long it takes for police to search for somebody
[47:30] after they run away. He had also conducted searches on how long it takes
[47:34] to burn a body, what melts through flesh, and how bodies are identified.
[47:39] Outside of court, Tommy choked back tears as she said to reporters,
[47:45] I was blessed to be Nicole's mother, to be her friend for thirteen years.
[47:50] We fought every fight together. She was a great and beautiful girl.
[47:54] David Eisenhower returned to court on the twenty sixth of June to be sentenced for
[48:00] Cole's murder. Ol of Nichole's family were in attendance and provided victim impact statements
[48:07] highlighting their loss from her murder. Her father, David said, there is
[48:13] nothing that will happen in this courtroom that will fix it. You cannot put
[48:16] a band aid on my daughter's life. Tommy recounted celebrating what would have been
[48:22] her daughter's sixteenth birthday at her gravesite that year and said that everything reminded her
[48:28] of her daughter. Eisenhower's defense him were hoping for a more lenient sentence,
[48:35] and they called on a neuropsychologist who concluded that he had autism. While very
[48:40] intelligent, he was bad at handling situations where there were no clear rules.
[48:46] They said that Eisenhower couldn't deal well with anxiety. And fear. This evidence
[48:52] contrasted with the findings of a tech psychologist who had seen Eisenhower in the fall
[48:57] of two thousand and fifteen, concluded that he tried to manipulate those around him.
[49:04] David Eisenhower was then asked whether he wanted to make a statement. He
[49:08] stood up and stared on at a note he had written. I am sorry
[49:13] for the paint that my actions had caused Nicole Level and her family. Nothing
[49:16] can ever undo what has been done, and for that I am deeply,
[49:20] sincerely and forever start. Judge Robert Turk then sentenced David Eisenhower to sixty years
[49:25] for first degree murder, ten years for abduction, and five years for concealing
[49:30] Nicole's body. He ordered that the sentences rung consecutively for a total term of
[49:37] seventy five years, with twenty five to be suspended. After Eisenhower served fifty
[49:43] years. The remainder would be served on probation, with David Eisenhower beginning his
[49:50] sentence behind bars. Natalie Keepers was preparing for her own trial. However,
[49:55] in August of twenty eighteen, she pleaded guilty to helping con Nichole's body.
[50:01] This meant that she would be facing trial on the more serious charge of being
[50:06] an accessory to murder. During opening statements, prosecutor Mary Petite led out the
[50:12] case against Keepers, telling the jury, the reason we're here is because Natalie
[50:16] Keepers helped plan this murder. She detailed how she and Eisenhower had purchased a
[50:22] shovel together, discussed the murder, and then planned out the spot to carry
[50:28] it out. She said the Keepers referred to herself as of sociopath in training
[50:34] and highlighted how she told detectives that she felt like she was part of the
[50:37] secret Club. Fan's attorney John Robertson, in his opening statements, stated,
[50:44] the primary question you will have to ask yourself and answer is what Natalie Keepers
[50:47] intended. Most of Keeper's confession was played allowed for the jury, and it
[50:53] proved to be damning. It showed that she had taken part in the planning
[50:58] of Nicole's murder the disposal of her body. In the interrogation, Keepers had
[51:05] often rambled about things that were completely unrelated to the case. She even told
[51:09] detectives she had dated a secret government to Sassin. The majority of the evidence
[51:15] presented was the same evidence presented during Eisenhower's trial, including the forensic evidence that
[51:21] linked both him and Keepers to Nicole's murder. The text messages between Keepers and
[51:27] Eisenhower were also presented, during which they spoke about Nicole's death. Keepers,
[51:34] we can run a game plan, Osenhower Yeah. Message her asked to come
[51:39] over, delete my name, all info associated with me, and kick on
[51:45] her phone and outmad or apod Sorry. Oisenhower then g TFO. The evidence
[51:52] against Natalie Keepers was overwhelming. The jury unanimously found the independant Natalie Marie Keepers
[51:59] guilty of being an accessory before the factor first degree murder. In the end,
[52:02] she was found guilty for her role in Nicole's murder. During her sentencing
[52:08] phase, she was asked whether she had anything to say. She turned to
[52:13] Nicole's family, I am crying for your family over name. I'm so sorry.
[52:22] I wish I could a thought I never intended from the up. Natalie
[52:36] Keepers was ultimately sentenced to forty years in prison. The pursuit of affirmation has
[52:42] long been a fundamental aspect of human nature. However, with the widespread influence
[52:47] of social media, individuals can now cast their emotional nets into a vast global
[52:52] abyss teaming with unknown persons. Nicole was grappling with the aftermath of relentless Bil
[53:00] when she sought solace in the digital realm, hoping to forge meaningful connections.
[53:07] Did you know that this seemingly bondless online space would prove to be a double
[53:12] edged sword, ultimately costing her her life? Well, Bestie's That is it
[53:34] for this episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you so much for listening,
[53:37] and I'd like to say a massive thank you to my new Patreon supporter
[53:40] Joe. If you'd like to join us up on Patreon, the link is
[53:45] in the show notes. Morbiology is just a one woman team, so the
[53:49] support up on Patreon seriously go such a long way, and I really really
[53:52] do appreciate the support. I mentioned it last week, but I'd like to
[53:58] mention again. My new true crime book, Killer's cod was published last year.
[54:04] You can purchase it on Amazon and in all good bookstores as well as
[54:07] a few supermarkets in America including Walmart and Target. If any of Europe on
[54:14] Facebook, I'd love for you to join my private Facebook group for the podcast.
[54:17] Just search for Morbidology and it should chew up. Remember to check us
[54:22] out at morbidology dot com for more information about this episode and to read our
[54:27] true crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe,
[54:30] and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
