# 237: Ruth Pyne

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 1 Jan 2024, 54 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/58057606/morbidology_237_ruth_pyne.mp3

Mental illnesses can have a profound impact on a family, affecting various aspects of relationships, communication and overall well-being. They can exert strain on interpersonal connections, and 2011, the question of mental illness within a family raised questions as detectives scrambled to investigate a shocking murder of a mother. SPONSORS - Schedule35: Thank you to Schedule35 for sponsoring this episode! Schedule35 want to destigmatise and educate on the science and practical advantages of shrooms. Get 15% off your order with the code "MORBIDOLOGY" at: https://schedule35.co/ SmartLabels: Thank you to SmartLabels for sponsoring this episode! Say goodbye to countless minutes rummaging through storage bins for your Fall and Thanksgiving decorations with SmartLabels. Download their app on the app store and buy their QR labels at: https://www.amazon.com/QR-Smart-Labels-Scannable-Organization/dp/B0BJS364C6?maas=maas_adg_31EA81720AD78B3DA43CB84763549F2B_afap_abs&ref_=aa_maas&tag=maas SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-237-ruth-pyne PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] She believed her medication was sorcery and witchcraft, and therefore it was evil.
[0:51] Mental illness can have a profound impact on a family, affecting various aspects of
[0:56] relationships, communication, and overall well being. They can exert strain on interpersonal
[1:02] connections, and in twenty and eleven, the question of mental illness within a
[1:06] family raised questions as detective scrambled to investigate the shocking murder of a mother.
[1:23] Highland Township is located thirty miles northwest of Detroit in Michigan. It's a suburban
[1:30] area renowned for its blend of residential and rural charm. The area boasts a
[1:34] diverse landscape characterized by lakes, wooded expanses in open spaces. Nestled on the
[1:42] outskirts is Burwood Court, a picturesque residential neighborhood enveloped by woodlands. This was
[1:49] where the Pine family made their home. Ruth and Bernard were married for over
[1:53] thirty years, and they were the pillars of the Pine family. Their household
[1:57] included two children, Jeffrey, who was born in ninety ninety and Juliet,
[2:01] who was born a decade later. Before embracing family life, Ruth was a
[2:07] nineteen seventy seven graduate of South Leon High School. Jane Bernard had crossed paths
[2:14] in the nineteen seventies while working together at a hardware store. Ruth and Bernard
[2:19] were exceptionally proud of their two children and wanted the very best for them in
[2:23] life. Jeffrey's educational journey unfolded at West Highland Christian Academy, a private school
[2:29] that saw him from kindergarten through to the twelfth grade. At this institution,
[2:34] he earned praise from Christine Lepierre, his Christian music teacher. She described Jeffrey
[2:39] as hard working, excellent, academically, outstanding in athletics, and always respectful.
[2:46] In high school, Jeffrey was valedictorian of his class. Then in two
[2:51] thousand and eight, w x y Z, a local TV station, recognized
[2:54] him as one of the brightest and best high school seniors. After his graduation,
[3:00] Jeffrey embarked on a pre medical program at the University of Michigan Flint,
[3:05] nurturing aspirations of becoming a chiropractor. To support his college endeavors, he worked
[3:10] at Spicer Orchards. At twenty one years old, Jeffrey continued to live at
[3:15] home with his parents and younger sister. His father, Bernard, worked every
[3:21] day to provide for the family, while Ruth was his stead at home mother,
[3:24] varying Julia to him from school. Ruth was best known for her strict
[3:30] yet protective demeanor. She had temporarily bore Jeffrey from playing basketball in his junior
[3:35] year to prioritize his studies at school. It was a decision that proved successful,
[3:40] as Jeffrey maintained a four point zero gpa. Aside from managing the household,
[3:46] Ruth found solace in handcrafts such as crosshet and cross stitch. She liked
[3:53] to launcher on their swimming pool, reading and taking walks with her husband,
[3:57] Bernard throughout the neighborhood. It was a cool spring afternoon in Highland Township on
[4:05] the twenty seventh of May twenty and eleven written. Jeffrey were at home while
[4:11] Julia was at school, and Bernard was at the Highland Housed restaurant. He
[4:15] was there to celebrate the retirement of a former employee named Jake. Bernard arrived
[4:21] at the restaurant at about eleven forty five a m. And the small group
[4:26] had lunched together before leaving at about two pm. Jeffrey had work at three
[4:30] pm that afternoon, and Bernard was picking up Julia from school. He pulled
[4:36] up outside the school and Julia hopped into the car before they drove back home.
[4:42] Once home, Bernard went outside to take the pill cover off for a
[4:45] swim. Moments later, however, Julia came running out of the garage,
[4:49] repeatedly screaming mum and pointing towards the garage. Bernard immediately stopped what he was
[4:57] doing and rushed over to the garage, assuming that Ruth had somehow hurt herself
[5:00] when they were out. He tried to push open the door of the garage,
[5:04] but it appeared to be blocked by something. As he peered through the
[5:10] small gap, he saw Ruth's bloody hand split out on the garage floor.
[5:15] With urgency, Bernard barged his way into the garage and his eyes were immediately
[5:20] drawn to the corner where the door was. Ruth was lying on the ground,
[5:26] surrounded by a puddle of blood. Her hair was matted with blood,
[5:30] and part of her brain was exposed. Overcome with emotion, Bernard began to
[5:35] scream, alerting their next door neighbor. Day of Gilbert. As Dave made
[5:41] his way over to investigate the commotion, Bernard called nine one one on his
[5:45] cellphone. He was in a state of shock and found it difficult to articulate
[5:49] the situation for the nine one one operator. He wasn't entirely sure what had
[5:55] happened, but he knew that his wife was dead and more than In the
[6:06] background of the phone call, Julia could be heard whimpering and crying as Bernard
[6:12] struggled to speak with the nine one one operator. Dave peered his head into
[6:15] the garage. Bernard handed him the cell phone as he struggled to speak.
[6:23] After a brief moment of surveying the sin, Dave said to the nine one
[6:27] one operator, Oh God, it doesn't look good. The nine one one
[6:30] operator dispatched officers to the sine, with Oakland County Deputy Michael Sayle arriving first.
[6:39] Upon arrival, he was greeted by Bernard, Julia, and two concerned
[6:42] neighbors, all gesturing towards the garage where Ruth's lifeless body lay. Squeezing through
[6:47] the garage door, he confronted the scene before him, bright red blood,
[6:53] a gaping hole in Ruth's skull, and the absence of her shoes. Systematically
[6:59] combing through the houst twice, he ensured that there were no additional victims or
[7:02] the presence of a potential killer. Noting the dead, bolted front door and
[7:08] the absence of anyone else inside, he swiftly coordinated the dispatch of paramedics to
[7:13] the scene. Amy Mackintosh, a paramedic, arrived promptly and was escorted into
[7:17] the garage at two fifty eight pm. She pronounced Ruth dead. It was
[7:24] evident that Ruth was the victim of a frenzied assault. Outside, Bernard and
[7:29] Julia anxiously waited in the back of the ambulance. Bernard urgently called their son,
[7:34] Jeffrey, who was at work, and told him he needed to come
[7:38] home immediately. As Amy delivered the heart wrenching news to Bernard and Julia that
[7:44] Ruth was dead, both were overcome with inconsolable grief. Bernard was evidently tormented
[7:49] by guilt and repeatedly uttered, if I would have staed home, this wouldn't
[7:55] have happened. Jeffrey hurried home from his job, joining his father and sister
[8:00] in the ambulance. Informed of his mother's death, he expressed, I was
[8:05] just here at one thirty. Over at the medical examiner's office, the grim
[8:11] reality of Ruth's death unfolded. The autopsy revealed a brutal assault, with Ruth
[8:16] and enduring thirteen or fourteen blows to the back of her head with an unidentified
[8:20] object. She was then turned over and subjected to sixteen stab wounds to the
[8:26] neck. The presence of hemorrhaging in these wounds suggested that Ruth's heart was still
[8:31] pulsing when the stabbings occurred. The fatal combination of her injuries included the combination
[8:37] of stab wounds, blunt force trauma to the head, and a crushed skull.
[8:43] Returning to the crime scene, observers noted Jeoffrey emerging from the ambulance visibly
[8:48] distressed. He dropped on his hands and knees and began to moan loudly and
[8:54] dry heave. After a while, Amy, the paramedic, offered to check
[8:58] the blood pressure of Bernard, Jeffrey, and Julia. They all agreed,
[9:03] but while getting their blood pressure taken, Jeffrey showed the paramedic some bandages on
[9:07] his hands and asked if she could help to change them. Beneath the bandages,
[9:13] blisters were revealed. Jeffrey explained to the paramedic that he had sustained these
[9:16] injuries while handling a pallet at work. Crime scene investigator swiftly descended upon the
[9:26] home, particulously scoring every inch for clues that could lead them to a suspect.
[9:31] The clear focal point was the garage, where the blood evidence indicated that
[9:35] Ruth had been attacked and killed. Here, blood spotter adorned the garage door,
[9:41] cement, walls, and various objects, suggesting a violent struggle. Ruth
[9:45] was repeatedly struck in the head, either as she fell or lay on the
[9:48] garage floor. Afterwards, she was turned over and stabbed multiple times in the
[9:54] neck. Detectives began to look into the possibility of who killed Ruth. Initially,
[10:00] they entertained the theory of a botched robbery, but they soon discarded this
[10:03] notion as the examination of the home revealed no signs of forced entry. The
[10:09] orderly home also lacked any signs of ransacking. Ruth's belongings, including her purse,
[10:15] cell phone, and money, remained undisturbed on a living room table in
[10:18] clear view, amid the absence of stolen valuables, Bernard observed a missing two
[10:24] by four board, prompting speculation that it could have been used as the murder
[10:30] weapon. It was normally kept in the garage where Ruth was found, but
[10:33] now it was absent. While the garage emerged as the primary crime scene,
[10:39] a curious discovery in the laundry room piqued detective's interest. Detectives found Ruth's blood
[10:45] on the sink handles, suggesting that the killer took the time to wash away
[10:50] evidence. Detectives expanded their search to the surrounding neighborhood, seeking any potential evidence
[10:56] that might lead them to the killer. They meticulously cold through ditches, fields,
[11:01] and diligently checked every bin and drain. As the broader investigation unfolded,
[11:07] the Pine family was transported to the police station for interviews. During Jeffrey's interrogation,
[11:13] detectives honed in on him. They had learned from the paramedic about the
[11:18] injuries to his hands, and this, combined with a lack of forced entry,
[11:22] led them to believe that the killer was somebody with access to the home.
[11:26] When he came into the police station, they noticed that he was carrying
[11:30] a lock blade knife in his front Pocket detectives immediately confiscated it and handed it
[11:35] over to Fransic specialists for further analysis. Jeffrey was then ushered into the interrogation
[11:41] room. In response to questioning, Jeffrey recounted his morning routine. So today,
[11:48] let's go back to today. So today you were You said you got
[11:50] up around ten? Yeah, about ten? Right? What did you do
[11:52] when you get up? At breakfast? I got on the computer. Um
[12:05] didn't really do. I knew a whole lot. She got home from grocery
[12:13] shopping, and I helped her bring groceries in and put some home away in.
[12:18] Where'd she go grocery shopping? In? Andiat mire? So was she
[12:22] home when you got up or shared a guard? No, she was gone,
[12:24] she got back. I don't know what time was, like eleven thirty
[12:28] or noon, something like that. He said that he assisted his mother and
[12:33] bringing in the groceries and putting them away. Jeffrey said that after his mother
[12:37] went upstairs to rest, he left the house to fulfill an odd job for
[12:41] a local woman named Diane need Him, involving the relocation of a lilac bush.
[12:46] I claimed to have completed this errand at about three pm before heading to
[12:50] his job at Spicer Orchids, where he was when his father called him.
[12:56] Jeffrey was then informed that his mother wasn't just dead, she had been victim
[13:00] of a murder. Judge, See, you have no idea how your mom
[13:07] died or anything. Okay, your mom's murdered. Someone kills your mom.
[13:26] Okay, it not an accident. Who do you need to get to the
[13:33] bottom of it? Okay. So if there's anything else that you know about
[13:39] that you've been holding back, that you're afraid to tell us a thous of
[13:46] time. Okay, I don't know what to tell you because someone don't know
[13:52] if anyone who would want to hurt or Detective stalved into Jeffrey's hand injuries and
[13:58] he said that he got them at work where polyps slipped from his grass.
[14:03] Your hands, Uh, this was from work today. I was flipping over
[14:05] a palette on my way to check the bathrooms, and as I was flipping
[14:11] over, my hand got caught in there. Just tore off the sin is
[14:16] it? Can I see it? Can do that? You can't make you
[14:20] pull it back a little bit. I can't see it. Just I just
[14:22] kind of ripped the skin right off. If I don't want to. Yeah,
[14:31] so that look was grateful. It kind of stings when you push on
[14:35] it. I'm just trying to keep it covered up. So just just almost
[14:39] said I almost sten a blister. I it just tore the skin right off.
[14:45] There was like skin hanging on it, and I just like peeled it
[14:48] off, wash my hands, put some alcohol swat on it. I mean,
[14:54] I've moved a lot of pals before and I've never adn't where to where
[14:58] the wood grabs it. You might get a slippers of them, but I
[15:00] never had an injury from a palette like that. I just thought a sign
[15:03] there and my hand got caught and I just pulled back. It was anybody
[15:07] else they're helping you move those palets at all. No, I was on
[15:09] the way of the bathroom. However, the detectives harbored suspicions. They thought
[15:16] that the injury seemed consistent with wielding a board resembling the missing two by four
[15:20] from the family's garage. The detectives also observed some light scratches to Jeffrey's arms,
[15:26] but they weren't concerned about these. Did you have any altercation with your
[15:30] mom today? No type of fight, Some argument and rest me and I
[15:37] don't argue today. You say that you left to one thirty. Can anybody
[15:41] verify that you left at one thirty? How can we verify that? I
[15:50] I don't know those are formed. Yeah, I get scratched up a lot
[15:56] and from work. This was I go get the pen and we had to
[16:03] catch him and I'll go, Yeah, the petting farm. Your mom is
[16:11] a stay at home from information we've gathered, does not have a bunch of
[16:15] friends. She doesn't have any enemies. Why would somebody take your home in
[16:26] a very short time period and harm your mom? I don't know, jeff
[16:33] want to ask you a tough question. I'm gonna doka. Did you do
[16:40] anything? Did it all hurt your mom? No? No, any way,
[16:44] shape or form. Nothing. Did you have any arguments with your mom
[16:47] that I didn't say anything hurtful to her? I did nothing. Left alone
[16:52] in the entiregation room for a moment, Jeffrey's vulnerability emerged. Is He quietly
[16:56] questioned why is this happening? With his head in his hands, He rocked
[17:02] back and forth, visibly distraught, frequently biting into snails and fidgeting with the
[17:07] bandages. Following the interview. Detectives visited Jeffrey's workplace to scrutinize the broken wooden
[17:14] pallid he claimed had caused his hand injuries. Attempts to replicate these injuries using
[17:21] similar materials proved unsuccessful, raising further doubts. With mounting suspicions against Jeffrey and
[17:29] no evidence of an external intruder, he found himself arrested in connection with his
[17:33] mother's murder. On the twelfth of October, Jeffrey was arraigned at Oakland County
[17:42] Circuit Court on a first degree murder charge. Represented by defense attorney Jim Champion,
[17:48] Jeffrey pleaded not guilty, maintaining his innocence and asserting that Ruth's murder was
[17:52] the act of a disturbed individual, not her son. Defense attorney Champion saw
[18:00] bail for Jeffrey, emphasizing his clean criminal record and academic achievements as the valid
[18:04] ictorian of his senior class. However, the prosecution vehemently opposed, citing the
[18:11] brutal nature of the murder. Prosecutor John Skersinski asserted, I don't care if
[18:17] he's the best and brightest. This particular act is a heenous crime. During
[18:22] the proceedings, defense attorney Champion informed the judge that Jeffrey's family, including both
[18:29] parents, stood united in support of Jeffrey. In response, the prosecutor cynically
[18:34] remarked, Judge, I doubt very much that his mother stanced behind him,
[18:38] since he murdered his mother. Consequently, Geoffrey was ordered to be held without
[18:44] bond in the Oakland County Jail, facing a potential mandatory life sentence without parole
[18:48] if convicted. As the courtroom drama unfolded, Bernard expressed his unwavering belief in
[18:56] his son's innocence to a reporter outside. His conviction in Jeffrey's innocence remained steadfast,
[19:03] leading to a tragic incident. Later that day, Bernard was alerted by
[19:07] his house alarm while at work, and he raced home, fearing that his
[19:11] wife's killer had returned. In his haste, he was involved in a car
[19:15] accident, explaining to the responding officer, all I could think was the guy
[19:21] who killed my wife was back in my house. Driven home by the police
[19:26] officer, Bernard found that everything was in order. Supporters of Jeffrey adamantly vouched
[19:32] for his character, asserting that he could not have harmed his mother. Many
[19:36] contended that detectives had arrested the wrong suspect, allowing the real killer to go
[19:41] free. Adding a lair to the perplexing narrative. The wife of Dave,
[19:47] their next door neighbor, disclosed a noteworthy piece of information. She recounted witnessing
[19:52] a hooded figure walking the yards approximately a week before Ruth's murder. Firmly convinced
[19:57] that this mysterious figure was linked to Ruth's murder, she cast out on the
[20:02] investigative focus. In response, detectives dismissed these claims. They assured neighbors in
[20:10] a letter that they were not in jeopardy and that Ruth's death was a familial
[20:14] matter, urging them not to be alarmed. Nevertheless, this communication did little
[20:18] to calm the community anxiety. Just like the Pine family, many others remained
[20:26] unconvinced that the killer had been caught. They all said that Jeffrey would have
[20:30] no motivation to kill his mother, that they both loved one another. However,
[20:36] as an art of unfolded revelations about the family dynamic emerged. Despite outward
[20:48] appearances of normalcy, the Pines grappled with pervasive mental health challenges. Tragically,
[20:56] Ruth's life had been overshadowed by these challenges. She had been diagnosed with bipolar
[21:02] disorder, which profoundly impacted every falsehood of her life. In the fall of
[21:07] nineteen ninety eight, the gravity of her condition manifested when she made threats of
[21:12] suicide not only against herself but also seven year old Jeffrey First First Star.
[21:19] Back when I was seven. She was more depressed back then, like bipolar,
[21:27] you're depressed and manic. She was more depressed at that time for a
[21:33] few years. And then my sister was born in two thousand and She was
[21:38] good up until about two thousand and eight, right after I graduated high school,
[21:44] and she just went manic. It changed. She wasn't depressed anymore.
[21:48] She just got crazy. As her struggles intensified, Ruth grew increasingly irate,
[21:55] with drawn, and harbored on found of beliefs that others were conspiring against her,
[22:00] resulting in her hospitalization. Under examination, a doctor diagnosed Ruth with bipolar
[22:07] disorder, characterized by manic and psychotic episodes. Prescribed medication initially showed signs of
[22:15] improvement, that these positive effects were fleeting Ruth's behavior took a distressing turn,
[22:22] marked by unprovoked, prolonged laughter and alarming threats of self harm. At times,
[22:27] she would exhibit peculiar behavior, including staring into the distance, making strange
[22:33] faces, and muttering under her breath. Despite having prescription medication, Ruth grappled
[22:40] with a religious obsession and to hallucinations. These included the conviction that God instructed
[22:47] her not to take her prescribe medication. Whenever Ruth stopped taking her medication,
[22:52] her anger escalated, leading to outbursts directed at her children. Into the thousand
[23:00] and nine, she was hospitalized twice following incidents where she struck Jeffrey. Witnessing
[23:06] his wife taken away on a stretcher. Bernard was distraught, repeatedly expressing,
[23:11] I can't believe it's come to this. She was doing so well. After
[23:17] her release from hospital, Ruth's religious fixation intensified, prompting Bernard to file a
[23:22] petition in July of twenty ten to have her hospitalized again. He said that
[23:29] Ruth wasn't sleeping, had religious preoccupations, and prolonged periods spent with the Bible,
[23:34] even in the bathroom. One of Ruth's hallucinations involved an invented religion that
[23:40] condemned all medication as a form of sorcery, leading her to outright refuse prescribed
[23:45] drugs. Non compliance with medication exacerbated her condition, culminating in physical abuse towards
[23:53] Jeffrey and Julia. Jeffrey mostly silently grappled with his mother's mental health struggles,
[24:00] but once he expressed to a teacher his desire to help cure her, I
[24:03] havevery never explicitly disclosed the extent of her mental illness. In one distressing incident,
[24:11] Ruth resorted to violence, grabbing Jeffrey by the throat during an attempt alongside
[24:15] his father to persuade her to take her prescribed medication. The escalation of Ruth's
[24:21] mental health struggles reached a distressing climax when she spot on Bernard's face Jess Jeffrey
[24:27] hit him and then strangled him. I heard my parents yelling back and forth
[24:33] and woke me up, and I walked into the room because the door was
[24:37] open, and they were just screaming at each other, and she came at
[24:47] me. She launched out of the bed and grabbed me by the throat and
[24:49] started hitting me and stuff. But I mean she didn't hurt me or anything.
[24:56] It was she was manic, wasn't herself right. Responding to the scene,
[25:03] the police observed red marks on Jeffrey's neck, leading to Ruth's arrest on
[25:07] charges of domestic assault and battery, a misdemeanor offense. In the bedroom,
[25:12] Ruth was found in bed. When questioned about the incident, her response was,
[25:18] I plead the fifth. Bernard ultimately had to testify against Ruth in court.
[25:23] No. I don't want to have to take medicine either, but it
[25:26] seems like when she doesn't, all kinds of bad things happened. I judge
[25:29] then imposed a ten thousand dollars bond and issued a new contact order with her
[25:33] son or their home. However, the judge later stipulated that Ruth could be
[25:37] released on a personal bond if she sought treatment at have Him With Hospital,
[25:41] a facility specializing in psychiatric and substance abuse care. Agreeing to these terms,
[25:48] Ruth underwent treatment, and the prosecutor ultimately dropped the charges against her. During
[25:53] Jeffrey's interrogation, question centered on his mother's mental health. That she had started
[26:00] a new medication in September and claimed that since then, conditions at home had
[26:04] improved. According to Jeffrey, his mother attributed all of her problems to his
[26:10] father, and aside from her assistance to medication, he claimed not to have
[26:15] any issues with her. Contrary to Jeffrey's portrayal of an improving atmosphere at home,
[26:21] the reality was a tense environment that had become so strained that Bernard was
[26:25] contemplating divorce. Despite years of efforts to keep the family together, the deteriorating
[26:32] mental health and the absence of improvement left him despondent. Jeffrey had confided in
[26:38] coworkers about the stress caused by his mother. Then, in March of twenty
[26:44] eleven, Jeffrey's stress intensified further when he and his girlfriend Holly Freeman parted ways
[26:49] due to him lying about meeting an old girlfriend. Geoffrey and Holly, who
[26:55] had initially connected on MySpace, had visited the Pine Home together a multiple ca
[27:00] well. Holly had a good relationship with Ruth. Jeffrey had shared the challenges
[27:04] of his mother's worsening mental health with her. He described his mother's all behavior
[27:10] on bad days, strange laughter, talking under her breath, and racing up
[27:15] and down the stairs Holly recollected some of the problems that Ruth faced. She
[27:21] believed her medication was sorcery and witchcraft, and therefore it was evil. She
[27:27] had been storing knives in the headboard of her bed. She watched the religious
[27:36] channel, walked around and put the Bible. Detective strongly suspected that Jeffrey was
[27:41] worn do by his mother's deteriorating mental health and reached breaking point. They believed
[27:48] that he feared for both his aunt his sister's safety in the household, compounded
[27:53] by his recent breakup. Detectives theorized that a heated argument with his mother triggered
[27:59] Jeffrey to last shout. Considering Ruth's history, Another possibility explored was that Jeffrey
[28:04] had acted in self defense. However, Michigan's legal landscapes don't recognize diminished responsibility
[28:11] as a valid defense. This means that prior abuse cannot be presented in court
[28:17] to demonstrate its impact on a defendant's ability to form criminal intent. Nevertheless,
[28:23] Jeffrey's defense could potentially use this information to argue that he suffered from mental illness
[28:30] as a result of the abuse he endured at the hands of his mother.
[28:33] Detective scrutinized Jeffrey's alibi, which initially seemed solid. He claimed to be doing
[28:40] an odd job for a woman named Diane at the crucial time when Ruth was
[28:44] killed. Jeffrey often did odd jobs for Diane, and at the time,
[28:48] Diane was out of the house. When detective spoke with her, She confirmed
[28:53] that Jeffrey had done some work for her and he left her a voicemail bail
[29:00] being over to her house a few times, but I thought you're well coming
[29:03] home. I was just order for about an hour, so it's kind of
[29:07] sweet glow God checking things out. I'm hoping you'll be there. Diane confirmed
[29:12] that Jeffrey had moved lilac bushes for her like he told detectives, but the
[29:17] timing didn't match up. Jeffrey had actually completed the task the previous Monday,
[29:22] not on the Friday when Ruth was killed. Furthermore, Diane said that when
[29:26] she got home, it didn't appear as though Jeffrey had done any work.
[29:32] She also added the Jeffrey never left her voicemails, something that stuck out in
[29:37] the detective's minds. Step into the new year with the resolution to declutter and
[29:45] organize and let smart Labels be your guiding light. Say goodbye to the chaos
[29:49] of misplaced items entangled messes. Welcome a world of order and deficiency with their
[29:55] cutting edge AH and Cure Labels. Simply purchase their color coded smart labels from
[30:00] their website Cure smart Labels dot Com, Amazon, or Walmart. Then download
[30:07] the smart label's app from the Apple App Store or Google Play to effortlessly create
[30:11] a digital inventory of each box. No more lost moments searching for that one
[30:17] item you know you packed away somewhere, and ensure that your new year's resolution
[30:22] to be more organized becomes a reality. Embrace the future of streamlined living where
[30:26] technology meets tidiness. Make sure to click the link in my show notes to
[30:32] simplify your storage organization today. Further probing into Jeffrey's life led detectives to its
[30:41] workplace and conversations with co workers the night before Ruth was killed. While closing
[30:48] O'Malley's bar with his coworker Nicholas Brere, Jeffrey exhibited signs of tension. He
[30:55] only discussed his recent breakup and home troubles, revealing that his mother had once
[30:59] attempt to kill his little sister, Nicholas recalled Jeffrey's account of Ruth's mental health
[31:04] struggles, noting her paranoia, bipolar disorder, and the ongoing efforts to keep
[31:11] her on medication. Geoffrey also confided that his parents were contemplating divorce if the
[31:15] situation at home didn't improve. The following day, as Ruth's body was being
[31:22] discovered, Geoffrey appeared to be on edge and uptight when he arrived at work.
[31:26] His demeanor changed abruptly after receiving a phone call from his father informing him
[31:33] of his mother's death. In April, Geoffrey returned to court facing in order
[31:42] to stand trial. Judge Leo Bowman scheduled the trial for the tenth of September.
[31:49] Outside of the courtroom, defense attorney Champion addressed the media, acknowledging the
[31:53] challenges that Geoffrey faced, but highlighted his maturity in handling the situation. He
[32:00] refuted the prosecution's theory, arguing that the only evidence against Geoffrey was a cut
[32:05] on his hand and a strained relationship with his mentally ill mother. Jeffrey's father,
[32:09] Bernard, staunchly supported his son, and in May he organized a fundraiser
[32:15] to assist with his legal expenses. The event was arranged for the following month
[32:20] at Striking Lanes. Speaking about the fundraiser, Bernard said, everyone who knows
[32:25] Jeffrey understands he didn't commit this crime. Expressing the financial strain on the family,
[32:31] Bernard emphasized the daunting costs of confronting the government's unlimited resources with only middle
[32:37] class means. The entire family, spanning both Bernard and Ruth's sides, attended
[32:43] the fundraiser, with Jeffrey's aunt Gale, highlighting the significant financial burden. At
[32:49] the event, the family united in support, vehemently asserting Jeffrey's innocence and suggesting
[32:53] that the true perpetrator remained at large while Jeffrey languished in jail. The trial
[33:00] was then pushed back until November, when jury selection began. The jury was
[33:05] seated by the sixteenth and the proceedings were ready to begin. The courtroom was
[33:09] packed with friends and family, and they talked in harsh tones about what potential
[33:15] evidence the prosecution may have. During opening statements, prosecutor John Skersinski wove a
[33:22] narrative portraying Ruth's mental illness and other factors as leading up to Jeffrey's alleged act
[33:28] of murder. Drawing a comparison to a mosaic or jigsaw puzzle, he told
[33:31] the jury, this is like a mosaic, a jigsaw puzzle, but when
[33:37] you see the pieces, the evidence will show he is responsible. Prosecutor Skursinsky
[33:43] emphasized key pieces of evidence, including Jeffrey's false alibi and the injuries to his
[33:47] hands. He described the murder as an angry outburst resulting from years of living
[33:53] with the challenging bipolar individual. When the police came, there was no evidence
[34:00] of a break in. There was no evidence of anything going. As a
[34:02] matter of fact, Ruth's husband, Bernie, took an inventory of the whole
[34:07] house. There was nothing gone. Her purse was wide open on the dining
[34:12] room table. Nothing gone except you thought it. Two by four. An
[34:17] obscure portion of the garage was missing. Ruth was not sexually assaulted. Now.
[34:28] The windows were broken onunder the door. As a matter of fact,
[34:30] the front door was deadlocked from the inside, dead bolted. Later, when
[34:37] the police talked to Jeffrey Pine, he lied. He lied about where he
[34:44] was, he lied about what he was doing. He lied about how he
[34:49] got the blisters. In contrast, defans attorney James Champion rejected the notion that
[34:53] Jeffrey was responsible for his mother's murder. Acknowledging the tragic nature of murder,
[35:00] he argued that the evidence against Jeffrey was entirely circumstantial. His gaze moved from
[35:07] Duror to Juror, as he maintained, somebody else committed this crime. Nobody
[35:14] who knows Ruth Pine. And the question isn't whether he could have committed the
[35:16] crime. The only question is did he. Defense's attorney, Champion reminded the
[35:22] jury of the prosecution's burden of proof, clarifying that he wouldn't be arguing self
[35:29] defense, insanity, or any other form of excusable homicide. He expressed his
[35:35] belief that the police had rushed to judgment in the case, challenging the foundation
[35:38] of the prosecution's narrative. The first witnesses in the trial included the nine one
[35:45] one operator and the Pines neighbor, Dave Gilbert. Dave recounted the events of
[35:51] that fateful morning, describing how he took the cell phone from Bernard, who
[35:54] was on the line with nine one one. He testified that he was aware
[36:00] of Ruth's bipolar condition and her frequent refusal to take medication. Dave also mentioned
[36:06] a concerning incident a week earlier, when his wife observed an individual in a
[36:10] hooded sweatshirt cutting through yards. Though she reported it after Ruth's death, police
[36:16] reassured the neighborhood that the incident was a family matter. Despite this, Stave
[36:22] remained apprehensive, installing new floodlights for added security. Nicholas Brady, Jeffries coworker,
[36:30] then took the witness. Stunted, the prosecutor presented photographs of wooden polyots
[36:36] stocked behind spicers and images of the injuries to Jeffries Hans, do you handle
[36:43] pallets and boxes off in wooding palas and boxes? Yes? A lot?
[36:47] Yes? Have you ever injured your hands doing that? I smashed my finger
[36:55] between a box before. Yes. You get slivers of her every once in
[37:00] a while, not very often. Let me just show you lan marks Unders
[37:09] fourteen to fifteen proposings of its fourteen, fifteen and sixteen. I just want
[37:16] to show his ease and ask you if you have ever had injuries like this
[37:23] from lifting a pellet or working with a pellet. No. During his testimony,
[37:28] Nicholas shared details of conversations with Jeffrey, highlighting his emotional distress. On
[37:34] one occasion, Jeffrey had conveyed his concern that his mother might eventually pose a
[37:37] threat to his sister's safety. Following Nicholas's testimony, William Cartwright, a farmer
[37:45] at Spicer's orchards, took to the stunt. On May twenty seventh, Jeffrey
[37:51] arrived for work around three pm with bondages on his hands, claiming he'd injured
[37:55] himself throwing polets. William found this explain odd as the injuries didn't resemble those
[38:01] from handling palettes, but rather looked more like somebody entered a batting cage without
[38:07] a glove. William observed that Jeffrey, who was typically talkative, was unusually
[38:15] quiet that day, a behavior he associated with his mother, upsetting him.
[38:20] Oakland Deputy William Sale, the first officer at the crime scene, provided detailed
[38:24] ac coins of the post murder search conducted by him and fellow officers. During
[38:30] cross examination, defense attorney Champion accused them of mishandling the investigation. He pointed
[38:37] out that there were incomplete records and the absence of proper protective gear during the
[38:42] initial sweep of the home. The officer's failure to wear protective gear raised concerns
[38:47] about potential contamination of the crime scene. Paramedic Amy Macintosh, who pronounced Ruth
[38:54] dead, testified about Jeffrey's reaction upon learning of his mother's death. She described
[39:00] his initial cries and mounds, but noted the absence of tears when Jeffrey stood
[39:06] up. She found it unusual and it raised suspicions of possible acting on his
[39:13] part. Deputy Ronald Chatterson took the stand to discuss the knife confiscated from Jeffrey
[39:19] during his police station interrogation. He confirmed that Jeffrey hadn't attempted to conceal the
[39:24] knife. During cross examination by defense, Chatterson addressed the question of whether it
[39:30] was typical for a murderer to return to the crime scene with a knife.
[39:36] He confirmed that this wasn't typical. Deputy Chatterson and various detectives consistently noted that
[39:42] in the oars following Ruth's murder, Jeffrey displayed an apparent lack of emotion.
[39:49] Detective Stephen Stradowski emphasized the stark contrast between Jeffrey and Bernard's reactions. He described
[39:57] Bernard as despondent upon receiving the news that his wife had been murdered, while
[40:01] Jeffrey showed minimal emotional response. He testified he put his hand up to his
[40:07] face, wiping away tears that weren't there. While acknowledging that people respond differently
[40:14] to trauma, the detectives highlighted that Jeffrey's reaction was not normal, especially considering
[40:19] his ability to function, which is uncommon for someone in shock. Gary Bonham,
[40:25] an EMS worker at the SINE, echoed similar observations. He noted that
[40:30] Jeffrey collapsed to the ground and made signs that sounded like crying, but there
[40:37] were no tears. He testified it looked like he got up and thought,
[40:43] well, now I've got to get back in the ambulance because I'm dumb putting
[40:45] on a show. Detectives also testified that there were no signs of forest entry
[40:51] into the family's home. The focus then shifted to blood evidence, with Detective
[40:57] William Foreman discussing Ruth's blood found on the taps. Despite the common tendency for
[41:04] those who knew the victim to clean up the crime scene, Forensic evidence linking
[41:07] Jeffrey to his mother's murder was notably absent. No murder weapon was discovered,
[41:14] and Ruth's DNA wasn't found on any of Jeffrey's clothes or the knife confiscated from
[41:19] him at the police station. The garage also lacked fingerprints or footprints, and
[41:24] the DNA found in the blood solely belonged to Ruth. The prosecution then introduced
[41:30] the palate on which Jeffrey allegedly injured his hands. They said that no blood
[41:36] or tissue was found to support his claim. Doctor Terry Melton revealed that herrer
[41:42] found inside Ruth's hands had a profile matching either Ruth or one of her relatives.
[41:47] The absence of forensic evidence connecting Jeffrey to the murder raised questions about the
[41:52] prosecution's case. To reinforce their narrative, the prosecution then called Kip Conley,
[42:00] one of the Pine's neighbors, is the next witness. During his testimony,
[42:05] Kip stated that jeffreys vehicle was present at the Pine home less than an hour
[42:08] before Ruth was discovered dead, placing him at the crime scene around the likely
[42:14] time of the murder. The nardive then shifted to cell phone data, with
[42:19] Detective Jerry Derosia testifying about Jeffrey's cell phone records. He said that the received
[42:25] call section of Jeffrey's cell phone was empty, a detail that he deemed as
[42:30] being unusual. The trial's focus then turned to Jeffrey's alibi of planting lilac bushes
[42:37] at Diane's home. Diane testified that he had completed this task on May twenty
[42:42] third, contrary to Jeffrey's claim of doing it on the twenty seventh. She
[42:47] expressed fear for Jeffrey upon learning of Ruth's death, explaining, Ruth had expressed
[42:54] such strong opinions, I was afraid that Jeffrey had been engaging in some behavior
[43:00] that set her off. Donald McKinnon, Diane's neighbor, corroborated her testimony by
[43:06] confirming that Jeffrey wasn't at her home on the day Ruth was killed. The
[43:10] jury then heard from Holly, Jeffrey's ex girlfriend, who described him as sensitive
[43:15] and stated that he never exhibited any anger around her. She emphasized that Jeffrey
[43:22] never retaliated with violence even when his mother attacked him. Holly revealed that Jeffrey
[43:28] struggled profoundly with his mother's mental health, sharing a moment when he confided in
[43:32] her, saying that he couldn't endure the situation any longer. This testimony provided
[43:38] a nuanced perspective on Jeffrey's character and his relationship with his mother. According to
[43:45] Holly, Jeffrey was afraid of leaving his sister at home alone with their mother,
[43:50] something that she herself agreed with. I did not think it was a
[43:53] good idea for Julia to ever be left along with Ruth in the house.
[43:58] Holly also shared her perspective on Bernard, describing him as a jerk. According
[44:04] to her, Bernard was tough on both Jeffrey and Julia, displaying a hot
[44:07] temper that made Julia hesitant to practice piano in front of him due to his
[44:12] harsh criticism. While he also presented her own theory on Ruth's killer, implicating
[44:20] Bernard, she initially suspected him based on the belief that Bernard wanted Ruth out
[44:25] of his life. Jeffrey had also told her that if his mother and father
[44:30] were to divorce, his father didn't want to pay alimony. Additionally, Jeffrey
[44:36] had informed detectives about Bernard seeing another woman and having an affair on his mother.
[44:43] However, Bernard had a corroborated alibi. He was at the restaurant during
[44:49] the critical time, and although the pathologists couldn't pinpoint the exact time of Ruth's
[44:52] death, Jeffrey had told detectives he saw her shortly before he left the home
[44:58] at one thirty PM. Bernard's presence at the restaurant was confirmed from eleven forty
[45:04] five a m. Until after two pm, dismissing the suspicion that he could
[45:08] be involved in Ruth's murder. After an extensive four week trial, the proceedings
[45:14] culminated in the delivery of closing arguments. The prosecutor candidly acknowledged the circumstantial nature
[45:21] of their case, but asserted its substantial strength as very good circumstantial evidence.
[45:29] As prosecutor Skarsinski addressed the jurors, his gaze traversed from one to another,
[45:35] emphasizing a stark reality as he said that their house was clean a neighbor told
[45:39] you, but there were problems inside and it was not what it appeared to
[45:44] be. With conviction, the prosecutor characterized the case as one marked by overkill
[45:50] perpetrated by an individual harboring some sort of relationship with the victim ruth. Pointing
[45:55] to Holly's testimony, he stated he told Holly, I can't take it anymore,
[46:01] and he felt helpless, helpless about a vicious cycle at home and her
[46:06] refusal to take medication. Drawing attention to Jeffrey's hand injuries, he asserted that
[46:13] they resulted from wielding a two by four wooden panel. The prosecutor also didn't
[46:17] shy away from highlighting what investigators deemed a feigned reaction to the news of his
[46:22] mother's death, telling the jury he pretends because he already knows what happened,
[46:28] but he does this little act so people won't be suspicious. In contrast,
[46:34] defense attorney Champion, during his closing arguments, hammered home the central theme that
[46:37] the case rested solely uncircumstantial evidence. He scrutinized the investigative process, casting doubt
[46:45] on its rigor and adherence to protocol. He bluntly reminded the jury they didn't
[46:51] take any time going through the garage or that house. Why not they were
[46:55] sure they had their guy Orretti in the arena of Leake Discourse two, contrasting
[47:00] narratives clashed. One ought to establish guilt thy interpretation of circumstantial evidence, the
[47:07] other challenged the detective's integrity, imploring the jury to cast out on the prosecution's
[47:13] narrative. The jury were then sent off to deliberate in the people of the
[47:19] State of Michigan versus Jeffrey Pine, who the jury find the defendant guilty of
[47:23] a second degree murder. Jeffrey Pine was ultimately found guilty of the second degree
[47:28] murder of his mother, Ruth Pine. As a verdict was announced, Jeffrey
[47:32] shook his head slightly As he was escorted out of the courtroom. He turned
[47:37] to his father and mouthed, I'm okay. Outside of court, Bernard spoke
[47:43] with the media. I'd like to say that there's been no measure of justice
[47:51] served for my wife, for my son, or for my fears. There's
[47:57] no evidence tying my son to this crime, and there's a good reason for
[48:00] that. He didn't do it. Innocent. He's always going he is innocent.
[48:07] People who are innocent don't say they're guilty. I want to say this
[48:12] that he was convicted on a story that was based on hunches and speculation.
[48:20] Somewhere in the mix the presumption of innocence and the definition of reasonable doubt was
[48:29] lost. I can't explain that. I know that. I know my son
[48:35] is a tender heart, and I'm telling you right now he did not commit
[48:38] this crime. His mother's illness made him an easy target. Ruth's sister Linda
[48:45] also said to reporters, my sister was a victim. She wasn't a monster.
[48:50] The media portrayed her eyes. She was a victim. The sentencing phase
[49:00] followed on the twenty ninth of January, but before then, one of the
[49:04] jurors called up Jeffrey's attorney and expressed regret for the decision to convict him.
[49:10] Defense attorney Champion referred to this as splitting the baby. He said that the
[49:15] jury clearly had enough doubts that they didn't convict him of first degree murder,
[49:20] but since they weren't sure what happened, they convicted him of the lesser charge.
[49:25] During the sentencing phase, it was apparent that jeffreys family still stood by
[49:29] his side. Ruth's sister Susan read a Loydle letter from her mother stating,
[49:36] he is a good boy and I do not believe he did this. Bernard
[49:38] also read a loydal letter from Julia, Jeffrey's sister. She wrote what a
[49:45] good big brother he had been and asked for him to come home soon.
[49:49] However, Ruth's other sister, Linda, said she believed that Jeffrey was exactly
[49:53] where he deserved to be. She shared her belief in his guilt, adding
[49:59] that she wanted him to come clean so that he could get the help he
[50:01] needed. Bernard touched on this and said that Ruth didn't have any kind of
[50:07] relationship with her sister Linda. He said he wasn't sure why she now seemed
[50:12] concerned about Ruth. Bernard then read aloud his own victim impact statement. He
[50:19] asked that his son come home as soon as possible to be with his family
[50:22] where he belonged. Jeffrey was allowed to read aloud from a letter he had
[50:25] written, thanking his family and supporters. He maintained his innocence, stating,
[50:32] I hope that someday the truth may be known and I may be acquitted.
[50:37] He then added, I asked that you consider the facts presented at trial a
[50:42] complete absence of evidence that connects me to this crime. My family, especially
[50:46] my father and sister, want and need me home. So we can begin
[50:50] to move on and heal from this tragedy. Before handing down the sentence,
[50:54] Judge Bowman said he received numerous letters and cards from people who supported Jeffrey.
[51:00] He said some argue that there was a lack of evidence to convict him,
[51:05] but he disputed that. He highlighted in particular the time frame in which the
[51:09] crime must have been committed. He stated, crucial in this case was at
[51:15] the window of opportunity for any other individual to have committed this offense was approximately
[51:22] forty five minutes to an r. The jurors in this case were satisfied with
[51:25] the people's theory that no other person entered the house in this case and committed
[51:30] the offense. They were satisfied that it was mister Pine. I can't say
[51:36] that the jury was wrong. Jeffrey Pine was then sentenced to twenty to sixty
[51:42] years in prison. To this day, the public remain sharply divided in their
[51:46] opinions regarding Jeffrey Pine's guilt. Some perceive him as a killer who cracked under
[51:52] the immense strain of caring for a mentally ill mother. Others staunchly believe in
[51:58] his innocence, contending that he is a man wrongly convicted of one of the
[52:02] most heinous crimes imaginable, the murder of his own mother. Well, Bestie's
[52:22] That is it for this episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you so
[52:27] much for listening, and i'd like to say a massive thank you to my
[52:30] new supporter upon Patreon, Melissa. As y'all know, Morbidology is a one
[52:36] woman teams of the support up on Patreon seriously goes such a long way.
[52:40] If you'd like to join me up on Patreon, the link is in the
[52:44] show notes. In exchange for your support, I upload ad free in early
[52:47] release episodes of Morbidology, bonus episodes of Morbidology plus behind the Scenes, which
[52:52] includes bonus audio videos and case files, and I also send out some merch
[52:58] along with a handwritten thank you card. If you'd like to support the show
[53:02] in another way, please consider leaving me a rating and review on Apple Podcasts,
[53:07] Spotify, or wherever else you're listening. Really do appreciate the feedback and
[53:12] love to read your comments. Remember to check us out at morbidology dot com
[53:15] for more information about this episode and to read or trick grime articles. Until
[53:21] next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
