# 217: Joanne Witt

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 14 Aug 2023, 46 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56175258/morbidology_217_joanne_witt.mp3

On Friday the 11th of June, 2009, Joanne Witt’s co-workers were concerned when she failed to show up for work. Over the weekend, they routinely checked at her home. The air conditioning was switched on, but nobody answered the door. By Monday, their concern had escalated so much that they promptly reported her missing. SPONSORS - Babbel: Thank you to Babbel for sponsoring this episode! Learn a new language in as little as three weeks with Babbel. Get 55% off at: https://babbel.com/morbidology 4Patriots: Thank you to 4Patriots for sponsoring this episode! With hurricane season fast approaching, it’s time to prepare with 4Patriot’s emergency food packages. Use the code “MORBIDOLOGY” for 10% off: https://4patriots.com/ Factor: Thank you to Factor for sponsering this episode! Take away the stress of cooking and get Factor’s delicious meals delivered right to your door. Get 50% off your order at: https://factormeals.com/morbidology50 PODCAST PROMO - Crimelines and Consequences SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-217-joanne-witt/ PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] I mean he rot in the helly rope so often about in his journals.
[0:50] On Friday, the eleventh of June two thousand and nine, Juan Whitzko workers
[0:54] were concerned when she failed to show up for work in El Dorado, California.
[0:59] Over the week. Again, they routinely checked at her home. The
[1:02] air conditioning was switched on, but nobody answered the door. By Monday,
[1:07] their concern had escalated so much that they promptly reported her missing. Juan Witt,
[1:23] a resident of El Dorado, California, was a dedicated single mother to
[1:27] her daughter, Tyler. Their relationship had faced a set back when Tyler was
[1:33] five years old was temporarily placed in the care of her grandfather by Child Protective
[1:38] Services. It's followed an incident where Joanne had struck her daughter in the face.
[1:46] However, Tyler was later returned to Joanne's custody and she wholeheartedly worked to
[1:49] provide the best life possible for her daughter. Despite the challenges they faced,
[1:56] Joanne was determined to give Tyler a well rounded upbringing. She introduced her to
[2:00] activities such as piano, violin, horseback riding, skiing, and she fostered
[2:07] her interests in music and acting as a single mother, Joanne tirelessly pursued her
[2:12] own career, having earned a master's degree in metallogy from California, a polytechnic
[2:19] state university. This allowed her to secure a position as an assistant in the
[2:23] engineering unit of the county's Department of Transportation. They lived in an upscale three
[2:28] thousand, two hundred square foot home in the two hundred block of Tattinger Court,
[2:31] a middle class neighborhood of brick and concrete stocko homes with well manicured lawns.
[2:38] Her former sister in law, Mary Wait fondly recalled whenever she saw something
[2:43] that needed to be done or someone needing help, she'd make sure it got
[2:46] done and got done right. At home, Joan liked to cook, and
[2:51] she enjoyed spending time in the outdoors. She was highly regarded at her workplace,
[2:55] and her co workers became close friends who enjoyed spending time together beyond office
[3:00] ours. One co worker, Vincent Katopano, praised her by saying she was
[3:06] smart, caring, fond to be around. Everybody at work just loved her.
[3:12] During Thanksgiving in two thousand and eight, Joanne generously treated all of her
[3:15] co workers to an office faced particulously preparing a turkey and all of the fixings.
[3:23] In addition to her successful career, Joanne actively participated in numerous charitable events,
[3:28] including walks for cancer. She genuinely cared for those around her and even
[3:34] extended her compassion to strangers. In December of two thousand and eight, Joanne's
[3:53] fourteen year old daughter, Tyler, was introduced to a nineteen year old man
[3:57] named Stephen Paul Culver. Among his friends, he was known as Boston and
[4:01] he had a deep fascination with Japanese culture, including anime, swords and knives.
[4:09] Stephen worked as a shift leader at Rubio's Restaurant and had graduated from oak
[4:13] Ridge High School in two thousand and eight. He aspired to become a maths
[4:17] teacher and had enrolled at Folsom Lake College. As recalled by a friend,
[4:24] Zachariah Erson, he was one of the few people who knew what he was
[4:27] doing in life. He had goals. Tyler was immediately smitten by the older
[4:32] man, who was five years her senior. Quickly, the relationship turned sexual,
[4:39] despite the fact that Tyler was a miner and Stephen was committing statutory rape.
[4:45] Tyler later said of Stephen, I trusted him more than I trusted to
[4:49] anyone, and I love him more than anybody or anything. If he told
[4:54] me to jump off a bridge and I asked him why and he said,
[4:57] just trust me, I would have done it. After school, Stephen would
[5:01] pick Tyler up in his car, and he quickly became a negative influence on
[5:05] her life as her grades began to fall. The duo also dabbled in drugs,
[5:12] including marijuana, cocaine, and ecstasy. Stephen's friends had tried to warn
[5:16] him about the implications of his relationship with Tyler, but he wouldn't listen.
[5:23] One day, Stephen's friend Matt Bogert said to him, sooner or later,
[5:27] you're going to be talking to a police officer. Over at Stephen's home,
[5:31] his father was becoming annoyed with his unruly behavior and kicked him out of the
[5:35] house. Stephen knew exactly where to turn. Stephen and Tyler came up with
[5:48] a plan so that he could move in with her and Juanne. Tyler told
[5:53] her mother that he was gay and simply a platonic friend, and suggested that
[5:58] he ran to room in their home. Juan wasn't sure, but she took
[6:01] pity on Stephen. She thought that he seemed to be a good guy and
[6:04] he could even help Tyler with her tutoring. As Richard Lavalley, a co
[6:10] worker of Joanne, said, she took him off the streets. She gave
[6:14] him a place to stay. One evening, the trio mat with Stephen's father,
[6:18] Richard, at a restaurant and folsom to discuss the plan. The meeting
[6:25] was strange to Richard, who later commented, it was really odd. You
[6:30] could feel the tangion between Tyler and her mom. You could caught it with
[6:33] a knife. After that, it was decided that Stephen would move in with
[6:38] the Whip family and he could occupy the spare bedroom. In due course,
[6:43] however, juan would come to learn the truth about their disturbing relationship. On
[6:49] the fourteenth of May two thousand nine, juan returned home from work to find
[6:55] Stephen's bedroom door open. As she approached it, Stephen came out, partially
[7:00] clothed. Juanne called for her daughter, but there was no response, and
[7:06] ominous thaw came across Joanne and she barged into Stephen's bedroom to find Tyler naked
[7:13] in the closet. Joanne was furious. He quickly dawned on her that Stephen
[7:19] wasn't gay and that had been a ruse to allow him to move in with
[7:24] Tyler, her teenage daughter. She ordered Stephen to get out of the house
[7:29] and told him that if he left Tyler alone then she would impress charges against
[7:32] him. Tyler begged her mother to change her mind, telling her that changed
[7:38] Stephen were in love, but Joanne wouldn't have it. After all, Tyler
[7:43] was just fourteen years old and Stephen was committing statutory rape. While Stephen was
[7:48] packing his bags, Juanne called her co worker, Vincent and asked him to
[7:54] come over just in case the situation turned nasty. When he arrived, he
[7:59] suggested to Joanne that she go to police and report the incident because Tyler was
[8:03] a minor. Joanne said that she considered it. Tyler had insisted that she
[8:09] was in love and she didn't want to hurt her daughter. Despite Joanne forbidding
[8:15] Tyler from seeing Stephen, she still routinely snuck him into the home, and
[8:20] when Joanne caught wind of this, she had no choice other than to report
[8:24] him to police. When a detective called up Stephen. He denied that he
[8:28] was sexually abusing Tyler. He said to the detective, she's like a sister
[8:33] to me. I understand she's fourteen. I understand all this. I'm very,
[8:39] very scared at the moment. Shortly after this incident, Joanne was at
[8:43] home when she came across Tyler's journal. In the journal, Tyler wrote about
[8:48] how much she loved Stephen and went into explicit sexual detail about their relationship.
[8:54] She also wrote that she wasn't sure how long she could keep their relationship a
[8:58] secret from her mother. Tyler's anger towards her mother was evident in the journal,
[9:05] and she wrote about how she imagined her mother dying. She wrote,
[9:09] I would curse her with the plague of death if it didn't come back three
[9:13] times as hard. I imagine my mom slamming into a truck going fifty five
[9:18] miles per R, crushing her skull and pelvis. She dies from the impact.
[9:24] In another entry, Tyler had written, my mother is driving me insane.
[9:28] I can't stand her company for more than five minutes. I hate her.
[9:33] She's bipolar, insane, and it's turning me into the same thing.
[9:39] I just wish she would die somehow, some way and leave me the fuck
[9:43] alone. On the eleventh of June two thousand nine, Joanne took Tyler to
[9:48] El Dorado County detectives investigating the statutory rapecase. Tyler denied the sexual relationship,
[9:56] which resulted in Joanne handing the detect it's her journal, which went into great
[10:01] detail. Tyler was absolutely stunned. She began pacing back and forth and screamed
[10:09] obscenities at her mother. She then went into school that morning and chatted with
[10:13] her friend Dylan Dutch about wanting her mother dead. Tyler said to Dylan if
[10:20] she died, I wouldn't be sad. Dylan called her a liar and questioned,
[10:26] you really believe you wouldn't be sad. Tyler responded, no, I
[10:31] would be genuinely happy. Upon returning home, Tyler called Stephen over and they
[10:37] began speaking about their options. They knew that Stephen was going to be arrested
[10:43] for statutory rape, but they wanted to be together. The conversation quickly turned
[10:48] ominous, and Tyler suggested that they commit a Romeo and Juliet suicide pact.
[10:56] Their plan was to drive to San Francisco and take their live, but Tyler
[11:01] worried that as soon as her mother noticed the missing she would call police.
[11:05] Tyler then turned to Stephen and said that her mother needed to die. Later
[11:16] that afternoon, Joanne was at work when her phone began to ring. Her
[11:20] coworker, vincent recalled, she was handling the whole thing extraordinarily well, she
[11:26] would say, when you calmed down, we'll talk more about it. She
[11:31] was on the phone with her daughter, Tyler, and eventually Joanne left work
[11:35] early that day to return home and speak to your daughter. She was unaware
[11:41] of the grim plan that she and Stephen had just concocted ours Earlier that evening,
[11:48] Joanne sat down with a glass of brandy after a hated debate with Tyler.
[11:52] When Joanne retreated to bed for the night, Tyler texted Stephen he scaled
[11:58] a back fence to buy a neighborhood security git. Tyler then led him into
[12:03] the home armed with a knife from the restaurant where he worked. Meanwhile,
[12:09] Tyler obtained a knife from the kitchen. Stephen silently entered Joanne's bedroom, standing
[12:16] beside her bed while Tyler waited outside. Suddenly, Stephen raised the knife above
[12:22] his head, and stopped Joanne multiple times. Joann awoke during the brutal assault
[12:28] and valiantly fought back, sustaining defensive wounds to her hands. The attack left
[12:35] Joan with over twenty stab wounds, including a severe one that appeared to have
[12:39] slashed her throat. Covered in blood, Stephen emerged from the bedroom and Tyler
[12:46] swiftly went about securing this scene. Stephen covered her with a SpongeBob SquarePants blanket
[12:52] to prevent blood from spreading. Tyler then closed the windows and blinds and turned
[12:56] on the air conditioning to mask any odor and create the illusion that Joanne's present
[13:03] and alive. After the murder, Stephen and Tyler drove to their friend Matthew
[13:07] Woodman's house. They proceeded to dye their hair, raising Matthew's curiosity. When
[13:15] Matthew inquired about their actions, Stephen and Tyler claimed that they had planned to
[13:18] run away and end their lives, but refused to provide further details, promising
[13:24] to explain later. The trail then visited the town center to hang out before
[13:28] going to Stephen's father's house. Finding his father absent, they indulged in marijuana
[13:35] and cocaine. Later, Stephen retrieved a white shopping bag from his car,
[13:41] revealing a large, bloodstained knife to Matthew, confessing that he had killed Joanne.
[13:48] He described stabbing her in the throat and stomach while Tyler stood outside the
[13:52] bedroom. He then chillingly disclosed Joanne's final words, no Boston, No.
[14:00] Matthew later recalled, we talked a little and said our goodbyes. Then I
[14:05] went back home. That was the last I saw them. Matthew said that
[14:09] he didn't ask why they had killed Tyler's mother, nor did anything to report
[14:13] it to police, as he said he was shocked and surprised. Later that
[14:20] afternoon, Matthew called two friends who also knew the couple, Matt Bogert and
[14:24] Diylan Dutch. He asked them to meet him at a local Safeway store,
[14:28] which they did. Matthew informed Martin Dylan of Stephen's ominous confession, and matt
[14:35] immediately called up Stephen. He demanded, I want to know what you have
[14:39] to tell me. Stephen replied that he had killed Joanne and that her body
[14:45] was in the master bedroom covered with a blanket. During the phone call,
[14:50] Stephen also told mad that he and Tyler were driving to San Francisco to kill
[14:54] themselves. Mat attempted to talk Stephen out of it, but he said that
[14:58] it it was their only recourse to be together. He then added, I
[15:05] can't really live without her. We need to do this over the next arm
[15:09] I ch added with Stephen on the phone and tried to talk him out of
[15:13] the suicide pact, but Stephen said that there was no alternative. The following
[15:28] morning, Joanne field to appear at work as usual, causing concern among her
[15:31] co workers. Your Mers's attempts to reach her by phone went on answered,
[15:37] intensifying their worry. Joanne's close friend and co worker, Vincent, decided to
[15:43] visit her home after work. He knocked on the front door, but received
[15:48] no response. He laughed, but returned periodically over the weekend, hoping to
[15:54] find Joanne home, but each time nobody answered the door. As they arrived,
[16:00] and Joanne still hadn't shown up for work. Her co worker's concern escalated
[16:04] into fear. They knew Joanne to be punctual and reliable and her absence was
[16:11] highly unusual. Vincent took action and contacted the police, requesting a welfare check
[16:17] on Joanne. An officer made an initial called to Joanne's father, Norb,
[16:22] who agreed to meet him at Joanne's home. With the spare key in hand,
[16:27] nor opened the front door, but was instructed to wait outside while the
[16:32] officer conducted a search of the premises. Upstairs, the officer made a horrifying
[16:38] discovery. Joanne's lifeless body, stained with blood, was lying in her bed,
[16:44] covered by a blanket. News of Joanne's brutal murder quickly spread throughout the
[16:49] community, drawing attention from both neighbors and the media. Residents gathered outside,
[16:56] sharing their shock and disbelief. When Alban one neighbor voice the collective sentiment asking
[17:04] well could provoke something that's serious? Just days after the he and his murder,
[17:10] however, El Dorado Sheriff Sergeant Jim Byers made an annointment. He said
[17:17] that they were actively searching for stephen On Tyler in connection with Juan's murder.
[17:22] Information developed by detectives through their investigation has led us to believe that they've changed
[17:27] their appearance and are trying to avoid law enforcement. And why wait until today
[17:33] to release this information? That this is something you believed yesterday, Well,
[17:36] it wasn't information we believed yesterday. It was part of the ongoing investigation.
[17:41] Initially, the daughter was simply a missing persons She wasn't at the home.
[17:45] We had no ties through the night. The detectives have worked on this and
[17:49] through their investigation they've developed the information and now we are confident that both the
[17:56] daughter and the boyfriend or suspects detect as were aware of the previous incident involving
[18:02] the statutory reebligation. Furthermore, Matthew and matt had come forward informing detectives that
[18:07] Stephen had confessed to them about the murder and their planned to flee to San
[18:12] Francisco and their lives. Did you catch wind of the University of Arizona's latest
[18:21] forecasts. They're signing the alarm for the upcoming two and twenty three hurricane season,
[18:26] predicting that it will resemble the intensity of two thousand and seventeen. With
[18:30] that in mind, they're urging everybody to gear up and be ready for whatever
[18:33] might come our way. Have you ever considered the shear devastation a hurricane can
[18:38] cause. Let's take Hurricane Ida's blow to the Gulf Coast as an example.
[18:42] Homes were obliterated, leaving people without basic essentials such as food and clean water.
[18:48] Power vanished for countless and the floods turned roads into rivers, shutting down
[18:52] grocery supply chains. Here's the scoop on seefeguarding your family during these scenarios.
[18:57] For Patriots urgency food kits. These kids offer long lasting, tasty grub designed
[19:03] to keep you fueled when it matters. Most these kits are handpicked in the
[19:07] US, are good for up to twenty five years, and are packed with
[19:11] a diverse range of delicious meals. And trust me, thousands of five star
[19:15] reviews back them up. For Patriots, survival food isn't just for natural disasters.
[19:21] In today's topsy turvy world, where supply chains waiver and emergency services surprise
[19:26] us, having a solid backup plan is crucial, and right now, you
[19:29] can go to four Patriots dot com and use the code morbidology to get ten
[19:33] percent off your first purchase on anything in the store, including their emergency food
[19:37] supply kits designed to last up to twenty five years. Just go to four
[19:41] Patriots dot com and use the code morbidology to get ten percent off your first
[19:45] purchase a four Patriots survival food that's for Patriots dot com. And use the
[19:51] code more bidology that's in morning. Detectives had found the vehicle the pair had
[20:00] been driving in a construction zone in downtown sam Francisco. When they searched the
[20:04] car, they found a suicide note that Stephen had written to his mother.
[20:10] In it, he thanked her for instilling in him a sense of moral justice
[20:14] and said that she had brought him up to be considerate to others at all
[20:17] times. He also expressed his regret for not appreciating her when he had the
[20:22] chance. It read him part, I love her very much and I wish
[20:26] I could have been a better son to her. The note also mentioned Tyler,
[20:30] reading I could go to Hell and back for her bear eternal domnition,
[20:34] just to be with her and know that she's happy. The note then continued,
[20:41] I have always viewed suicide as the permanent solution to the week. If
[20:45] I kill myself, it proves the world is stronger than I. Detectus released
[20:51] photographs of the fugitive pair, describing Stephen as six foot one inch tall and
[20:56] Tyler as five foot one inch tall. They alerted the public to the fact
[21:00] that Stephen and Tyler may have altered their appearance in attempt to evade capture.
[21:06] The revelation that Stephen and Tyler were the main suspects in the murderer horrified those
[21:11] who knew the family. According to neighbors, they appeared to be just your
[21:15] average American family. Once news broke, Stephen and Tyler's friends began posting on
[21:21] their Facebook accounts urging them to hand themselves in. One of Stephen's friends pleaded
[21:27] with him to stop running and warned that he was only making it worse.
[21:33] Another friend posted, dude, You've got to quit running. We're all worried
[21:37] about you here. Please, Boston. You once told me that you would
[21:41] never be capable of such a thing. Prove me right, prove yourself right.
[21:48] Early the next morning, Stephen and Tyler were spotted sleeping outside a strip
[21:52] mall in sam Bruno. Detectives quickly descended on the scene and arrested them without
[21:57] incident. Stephen was booked into the Samteo County Jail, while Tyler was sent
[22:03] to juvenile Hall, while both awaiting extradition back to Eldorado. In announcing the
[22:10] arrest, Captain Craig thur Gilston stated, we can all breathe a collective sigh
[22:15] of relief. During their time on the run, Stephen and Tyler had sought
[22:18] refuge at a holiday inn, as detectives later discovered. A search of Stephen's
[22:25] bankcard records revealed the hotel booking. When detectives come through the hotel room,
[22:30] they stumbled upon another suicide note. Additionally, they found two balls filled with
[22:36] cereal and rap poison. The suicide note contained a chilling message, you will
[22:41] find us together dead on a beach. Among the items recovered at the hotel
[22:48] was marijuana, condoms and a DVD of the movie Donnie Darko. It was
[22:53] apparent that the couple had consumed some of the rap poison mixed with fruit loops
[22:59] and cake, although it had failed to be fatal. By the next day,
[23:03] both Stephen and Tyler had been extradited, and prosecutors annoyed that they were
[23:07] considering whether to charge Tyler as an adult in the murder. If she were
[23:12] tried as an adult and convicted, then she could be facing a sentence of
[23:17] life in prison. If convicted as a juvenile, however, she would be
[23:22] free at the age of twenty five. District Attorney Lasette Suitor wanted her charge
[23:26] as an adult due to the seriousness of the crime, the circumstances, and
[23:32] the gravity. Tyler's defan's attorney Mark Ralphs, however, said that he was
[23:37] going to argue that she should be charged as a miner. Meanwhile, Stephen
[23:42] was charged with the murder of Juanne and was ordered to be held without bal
[23:48] In November, a hearing was held to determine whether Tyler should be charged as
[23:52] an adult. Testimony was presented regarding her rule in the gruesome murder of her
[23:56] mother. Her journal also entered into evidence. District attorney Suitor said that the
[24:03] testimony showed Tyler's sophistication in committing the crime. Defense attorney Ralphs, however,
[24:11] suggested that Tyler was merely following the instructions of an older participant. The judge
[24:17] ultimately decided that Tyler could be tried as an adult in Juan's murder. When
[24:22] announcing the decision, Judge James Waggener stated, there is no graver crime the
[24:27] matracide. He said that he didn't believe that Tyler could be rehabilitated in ten
[24:33] years, staring this was not an easy decision to reach, but said that
[24:38] evidence showed criminal sophistication. Both Tyler and Stephen were ordered to stand trial for
[24:45] the murder together, and prosecutors announced that they weren't seeking the death penalty.
[24:56] In February, Tyler pleaded not guilty by reason of the insanity, while Stephen
[25:00] pleaded not guilty. Tyler's plea meant that if the case proceeded to trial and
[25:06] she were found guilty, the second trial would take place regarding her mental competency.
[25:11] Her defense attorney would need to prove that she didn't understand the nature of
[25:15] the murder or that she couldn't distinguish right from wrong. There was then a
[25:21] debate over the trials and whether Stephen and Tyler would be tried separately. It
[25:26] had been discovered that after committing the murderer, Tyler had written a short story
[25:30] titled A Raven and His Killer. The story was said in medieval times,
[25:37] but it paralleled the murder of her mother, Joanne. A detailed teen lovers
[25:41] driven to murder after their dreams were shattered by a woman who handed over the
[25:47] girl's journal to police. The judge ruled that if the prosecution wanted to enter
[25:52] the story into evidence, then the two trials could be separated. However,
[25:57] the judge then ruled that Stephen and Tyler would be standing trial together. He
[26:03] also ruled that the story could be entered into evidence. In September, Tyler
[26:08] appeared in court where she dramatically changed her not guilty plea to a guilty plea.
[26:15] She pleaded guilty to first degree murder and admitted to the special circumstance of
[26:18] lying in wait and the special circumstances for being witness to a crime. It
[26:26] was part of a plea agreement in which she would cooperate with prosecutors in Stephen's
[26:30] upcoming trial for a more lenient sentence. If you cooperated fully, the special
[26:36] circumstances would be stricken, the charge would be reduced to second degree murder.
[26:41] This would reduce her sentence in prison from twenty five years to life to fifteen
[26:45] years to life. After the plea, Stephen's defense attorney dam Wiener suggested that
[26:52] it demonstrated his client's innocence. He stated, what young girl would plead guilty
[27:00] if she didn't do it. He then suggested that Stephen had arrived at the
[27:03] home after the murder had been carried out by Tyler. On the seventeenth of
[27:17] May, the murder trial for Stephen commenced with the seating of the jury.
[27:22] During the opening stamens, it became apparent that the defense intended to shift the
[27:26] blame for Juan's murder onto Tyler. Defense attorney down Weiner asserted that it was
[27:33] Tyler who had committed the act, claiming that when Stephen had arrived at the
[27:36] Whit home that fateful night, she greeted him at the door holding a blood
[27:41] stained knife. According to defense attorney Weener, Tyler confessed to killing her mother
[27:48] to Stephen. He further suggested that Stephen's confession to eat the murder was driven
[27:52] by his love for Tyler, stating that was a lie, a lie he
[27:57] told to protect Tyler wit he took responsibility for an act he did not commit.
[28:03] He bent to Tyler as the mastermind behind the murder and said that she
[28:07] had a deep rooted animosity for her mother that predated Stephen. He then went
[28:12] on to describe Tyler as a pathological liar and said that she had threatened her
[28:18] mother with a knife weeks before the murder. In her opening statements, Prosecutor
[28:23] Lazette's suitor countered the defense's narrative asserting that while the murder was planned by the
[28:29] couple, it was Stephen who carried it out. Prosecutor Suitor claimed that after
[28:33] Stephen and Tyler went upstairs to Joanne's bedroom, Tyler witnessed Stephen raising his knife
[28:41] above his head. According to the prosecution, Tyler dropped her own knife and
[28:47] assumed a fetal position, allowing Stephen to proceed with the murder alone. Prosecutor
[28:52] Suitor read aloud a text message Stephen had sent to a friend after Joan forbade
[28:57] him from seeing Tyler. In the text message, he expressed frustration with Joanne's
[29:03] actions, insinuating that she was trying to ruin his life. Prosecutor suit Her
[29:10] then stated, this is a case about a nineteen year old man and a
[29:14] fourteen year old girl with a forbidden love affair to the point of statistic murder.
[29:21] Both the prosecution and the defense agreed that Stephen and Tyler had attempted to
[29:23] take their own lives by jesting rab poison shortly after committing the murder. During
[29:32] the first day of the trial, Matthew Wideman testified about Stephen and Tyler's visit
[29:36] to his home following the murder. He expressed shock upon hearing Stephen's confession,
[29:41] stating he never struck me as the kind of person to do something like that.
[29:47] During cross examination by defense attorney Weener, Matthew noted that Tyler didn't appear
[29:52] to be upset over her mother's death. In fact, he recalled Tyler previously
[29:56] expressing that her life would improve if her there were no longer around. Matt
[30:03] Bogert also testified about the confession Stephen had made to him. Another friend,
[30:08] Edward Graham, testified next, telling the jury that after he became aware of
[30:12] the confession, he sent a message to Tyler on my Space. He said,
[30:19] you second me beyond anything, you really killed her. Tyler replied,
[30:26] I didn't say that. Now she's gone, I'm weeping that I'm free.
[30:32] She then added loll in capital letters. Stephen's father, Richard, took the
[30:48] stand and provided testimony about the dinner he had with Stephen, Tyler, and
[30:53] Juan. He explained that he had arrived at the family's home to pick them
[30:57] up, but his son in formed him that Juan was asleep and basically passed
[31:03] out drunk. However, when they met at the restaurant, Joanne didn't appear
[31:07] to be impaired. Richard described his son as a calming influence in the relationship
[31:14] with Tyler, stating that he was supportive and helpful, which aligned with his
[31:18] personality. During the dinner, he observed Tyler and Joanne engaging inoverable exchange regarding
[31:25] their intelligence. Joanne expressed frustration with accepting a job below her intellectual capabilities,
[31:33] and Tyler interjected boasting about her own intelligence, describing herself as genius level.
[31:41] Following his testimony, the prosecution star witness took to the stand, Tyler Witt.
[31:48] She calmly described how she and Stephen had planned the murder and matter fatly
[31:52] stated that they resorted to using a knife simply because they couldn't obtain a gun.
[31:57] Tyler proceeded to discuss her relationship with her mother, alleging that Joanne had
[32:02] physically abused her during her childhood. She claimed that her mother would kick the
[32:07] living crap out of her, but it only choked her on a couple of
[32:12] occasions. Tyler then revealed to the jury that she had various aspects of herself,
[32:17] almost like multiple personalities. She mentioned one named Toby, who she described
[32:24] as a demon from Hell residing within her. Another personality she mentioned was Alex,
[32:31] who she referred to as an angel. She explained three souls crowded in
[32:37] one body. According to Tyler, she experienced black Ey's when she became enraged.
[32:44] She proceeded to recoind the details of the murder plan and then the suicide
[32:47] pact. Tyler admitted to devising the plan. While Stephen responded that suicide would
[32:54] be the last resort, Tyler informed him that it was indeed their last resort
[33:00] because he would go to prison, leading to their separation. Tyler said to
[33:06] the jury, the only person who would notice me gone and call the police
[33:09] and point to finger at Boston would be my mother. Therefore, the plan
[33:15] then transformed and included the murder of Juan before the suicide pact. Mon podcast
[33:23] we play thanks to Babel. I know what that means, do you?
[33:28] Literally? I've been all about learning French with Babel and you totally should give
[33:31] it a whirl as well. Seriously, in just three weeks, Babele can
[33:36] have you speaking a whole new language. The dream way to learn a language
[33:39] is by diving into a native speaking country, but unfortunately that's not always on
[33:44] the cards for everybody. But guess what Babble's got Your back is the next
[33:47] best thing, and as quick as just three weeks, you can pick up
[33:51] a new language with Babel. As somebody who's all about exploring new places,
[33:54] let me tell you, Babel's been my sidekick. With Babel, you've got
[34:00] a golden opportunity to embark on your language adventure. Instead of dishing out of
[34:04] fortune on private tutors, Bubble hooks you up with these super quick ten minute
[34:07] sessions designed by over one hundred and fifty language experts. These bite size lessons
[34:14] are a game changer. They've been my secret weapon for kneeling stuff such as
[34:17] ordering food at a restaurant, calling a taxi, and just chatting with the
[34:22] locals. Babble even has this super fancy speech recognition technology that polishes your pronunciation
[34:28] and gives you that legit accent. Here's a special, limited time deal for
[34:32] my listeners to get you started right now. Get fifty five percent off your
[34:37] Bible subscription, but only for Morbidology listeners. Bible dot com slash Morbidology.
[34:43] Get up to fifty five percent off of Bible dot com slash Morbidology spelled babbel
[34:50] dot com slash morbidology rules and restrictions may apply. Her testimony and shifted to
[35:00] the knight of the murder, describing how she and Stephen approached Joanne's bedroom door.
[35:06] She recalled Stephen practicing slashing motions with the knife and she fell to her
[35:10] knees, unable to go through with the murder. Tyler explained, a knife
[35:16] in my hand, I turned to go into the room. I stood up
[35:20] and I was in the doorway, but I couldn't do it. As Stephen
[35:24] knife Joanne to death. Tyler said that she covered her eyes and hummed.
[35:30] She recoined it how Stephen a merch from Joanne's bedroom with blood soaked pants and
[35:34] a tear of blood on his face. She recollected he was holding the knife.
[35:40] He was just standing there at the stairs. I told him everything was
[35:45] going to be okay. Stephen appeared to be in shock and began crying.
[35:51] Tyler said that she began to comfort him. She remembered, I don't know
[35:55] if he specifically had blood on his hands, but I knew what he had
[36:00] just done. Afterwards, they went to Stephen's father's vacant tomb, where they
[36:05] burned Stephen's bloody clothing in the fireplace and washed up in the kitchen sink.
[36:10] Tyler told the jury how she noticed the tear drop of blood near Stephen's eye
[36:15] and expressed her desire for him not to wash it away. She explained,
[36:21] when I saw it on his face, the first thing I thought was how
[36:23] ironic it was. She referred to tear drop tattoos beneath the eyes of killers
[36:29] in prison, suggesting that it symbolized something significant. During cross examination by defense
[36:36] attorney Weener, he suggested that Tyler had killed her mother during a psychological blackout
[36:42] when her other personality, Toby, took control. He asserted, the truth
[36:47] is that it was you who killed your mother. Tyler responded firmly no.
[36:54] Following her testimony, it was revealed that Tyler had agreed to lead detectives to
[36:59] the murder web, which she said was tossed on a large dree and outside
[37:02] Stephen's father's home. However, the murder webin had never been recovered, part
[37:08] of Tyler's plea hinged on her complete honesty with detectives. Testimony in the trial
[37:15] then shifted to DNA evidence. Senior criminologist Deanna Kaiser told the jury that Meal
[37:21] DNA was found in the right hand and left hand scrapings of Juan. There
[37:25] was also meal DNA found on blood samples from her legs. She couldn't say
[37:30] whether the DNA had come from Stephen himself, only that it was male DNA.
[37:37] Defense attorney Robert Blazer attacked her findings and pointed out that it was impossible
[37:42] to determine when DNA deposits were created on an object. He wondered whether the
[37:47] meal DNA could have come from multiple sources. Deanna was adamant that the scrapings
[37:52] came through direct contact and not an innocent transfer. On the second week of
[38:02] the trial, Stephen took to the witness stand, recointing his version of events
[38:07] for the jury. He claimed that Tyler had called him to her house,
[38:10] where he found her holding a kitchen knife with a blood stain on her trousers.
[38:15] According to Stephen, Tyler confessed, I did it. I finally did
[38:21] it. My mom's gone forever. Stephen said. He asked her, what
[38:24] the hell did you do? Tyler allegedly collapsed in his arms, saying that
[38:30] she did it for them. He asserted that their original plan was to take
[38:35] their own lives and killing Joanne was never part of that plan. Stephen was
[38:39] then subjected to cross examination by the prosecution, who asked about the male DNA
[38:45] found on Juan. Stephen claimed that the DNA on her leg had come from
[38:49] him touching her after she was dead, as he said, he wasn't sure
[38:53] whether she was dead or not, so he touched her leg to see.
[38:59] Prosecuted, however, said that the DNA had gotten there when Joan was fighting
[39:04] Stephen for her life. Following its testimony, the prosecution and defense presented their
[39:09] closing arguments. Defense attorney Weener again told the jury that Tyler had committed the
[39:15] murder, describing her as mentally unstable. He stated, it wasn't just her,
[39:22] it was Toby the demon, it was Alex the angel. All three
[39:25] of them would die. They all had to have Stephen to survive. Prosecutor
[39:31] sued Or, however, reminded the jury of the male DNA found on Joanne's
[39:36] leg and underneath her finger nails. She steated a violent, calculated, desperate
[39:43] slang of Joan Witt. It is the only way to keep them out of
[39:45] jail so that they could be with each other in eternity. The jury were
[39:52] then sent off to deliberate. They returned just three hours later with the verdict.
[39:57] They found Stephen Culver guilty of the first green murder of Juam Wit.
[40:01] They also convicted him on a special circumstance enhancement of lying in Wit, which
[40:07] meant that he would never be eligible for parole. Both Stephen and Tyler returned
[40:13] to court in August to hear their sentences. Before the sentences were imposed,
[40:17] victim impact statements were presented. Juan's two brothers express their ill views of Stephen,
[40:24] with Mike steating, my hope is on the prison system, that the
[40:29] prison system will somehow create a slow and painful death. Young Men like mister
[40:34] Culver are five times as likely to be attacked and brutalised in prison, and
[40:39] I actually find that to be a comforting statistic. There are ten times as
[40:44] more likely to incur deadly sexual diseases. Mike then added that he felt society
[40:51] should still carry out public executions such as hangings and beheadings as a way to
[40:55] provide closure to Victims's other brother, Stephen, said that there was no punishment
[41:02] to truly do justice in the case. He then added, but a lifetime
[41:08] behind bars is a good start. I hope he has good luck with his
[41:13] new friends in prison, and I hope they embraced him warmly. The judge
[41:19] also heard from Joanne's father, Tyler's grandfather, norb. He said that he
[41:24] and his wife had seen their health deteriorated since their daughter's murder by way of
[41:30] stress and lack of sleep. He then turned his attention to Stephen. Stephen
[41:35] Culver had a dark side. He took a fourteen year old girl and turned
[41:38] turned her into a heavy drug user, sex shatic and murderer me he wrote
[41:44] in the hell he wrote so often about in his journals. Stephen was then
[41:46] sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of perule, while Tyler sentenced to
[41:52] fifteen years to life. Judge probably then stated, it's a sad day when
[41:58] I have to sendence exteen year ould to such a long prison term. And
[42:02] it's even sadder did it be for a brutal murder she'd admitted to. He
[42:07] then turned to Tyler and stated, Juan Witt loved her daughter. She was
[42:13] a protective and caring mother. She tried her best. I'm sorry, miss
[42:17] Witt, because the person who loved you more than anything in the world without
[42:21] reservation is gone. After the sentence was handed down and Stephen and Tyler were
[42:27] carted off to custody, Tyler granted an interview with ABC. She told the
[42:32] reporter that she was upset that Stephen had turned on her and claimed that the
[42:37] murder was committed by her. She stated, when I found out that he
[42:42] was going to point the finger at me, the only thing I could question
[42:45] was that he told me that he was going to love me no matter what,
[42:49] forever, for all eternity ever. And I guess that's not true anymore.
[42:55] On the twenty sixth of August two and twenty two, Tyler Witt was
[43:00] granted parole. Juann Witt had devoted herself to giving her daughter a wonderful life.
[43:07] Although they had faced challenges in their relationship when Tyler was young, Joanne
[43:13] had proven to be a committed and loving mother, ensuring that her daughter had
[43:15] everything she needed. It's truly heartbreaking that in the end, Tyler repaid her
[43:22] mother's love and care in the most unimaginable way by sacrificing her life to protect
[43:29] a child predator. Well, Bessie thought, is it for this episode of
[44:00] Orbidology? It's always thank you so so much for listening, and I'd like
[44:02] to say the biggest thank you to my new supporters up on Patreon, Cilia,
[44:07] Alicia, Marcia and Jessica. The support up on their seriously goes such
[44:13] a long way and I am eternally grateful. If you'd like to support Morbidology
[44:16] on Patreon, the link is in the show notes. In exchange for your
[44:21] support, I upload ad free and early release episodes bonus episodes of Morbidology,
[44:25] plus they're on on the regular podcast platforms behind the scenes, including bonus videos,
[44:32] audio, and case files, and I also send out a handwritten thank
[44:37] you card along with some cool merch. If you'd like to support the show
[44:40] in another way, you can always leave me a rating and review on Apple
[44:44] Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever else you're listening. Remember to check us out
[44:49] at morbidology dot com for more information about this episode and to read Artrey crime
[44:53] articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and
[44:58] have an amazing week. I'm Eric carter Landin, the host of True Consequences
[45:16] podcasts and a family advocate, and I'm Charlie World, the host of Crime
[45:22] Lines and a passionate storyteller. We've come together to create a new show,
[45:27] Crime Lines and Consequences. In each episode, we will explore cases, bringing
[45:31] in our unique perspectives and our shared belief that true crime is more than entertainment.
[45:37] These human experiences can change the way we see the world. So come
[45:40] along and eavesdrop on our conversations about cases you've heard of and some you haven't,
[45:47] and then joined the conversation on social media by searching for Crime Lines and
[45:52] Consequences on Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter. Crime Lines and Consequences is available
[45:57] now in your favorite podcast app and on YouTube.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
