# 201: Jordyn Dumont

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 24 Apr 2023, 45 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53294528/morbidology_201_jordyn_dumont.mp3

Bess Town Road is located on the outskirts of Bessemer City, North Carolina. It’s surrounded in rolling fields and dotted with various wooded areas. On the afternoon of 15 August, 2016, police were directed to the quaint road after a report of a missing girl came in… SPONSORS - June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] Austin County. Now one one Reynolds plus the advance of your team. M
[0:39] my oldest daughter. I was taking that. I just woke up and I
[0:41] can't find it anywhere. Best Horn Road is located on the old skirts of
[0:56] Bessemer City, North Carolina. It's surrounded in ruling fields and dotted with various
[1:00] wooded areas. On the afternoon of the fifteenth of August two thousand and sixteen,
[1:07] police were directed to this quaint road following a report of a missing girl.
[1:25] It was summer of two thousand and eleven when Joshua Kennett met Jay Lane
[1:30] Dumont in Hawaii. The couple headed off immediately and embarked on a romantic relationship.
[1:38] Sometime later, they moved in together to the Turtle Mountain Indian Reservation in
[1:42] North Dakota. On the seventh of September two thousand and twelve, they welcomed
[1:48] a baby girl into the world. They named her Jordan. Joshua said of
[1:53] his daughter, she was just so full of life and full of so much
[1:57] energy to play and listen to music and just enjoy life and learn new stuff.
[2:04] Jordan really enjoyed coloring and painting and blowing bubbles most morning. She loved
[2:09] nothing more than watching Mickey Moy's Clubhouse, and her favorite movie was Hotel Transylvania.
[2:15] Her father recalled how he must have watched the movie at least two hundred
[2:19] times. The relationship between the couple was somewhat on and off, but it
[2:25] fell into turmoil when jay Lene met a man named William Joseph McCullin. At
[2:30] the time, Jaylene was working at a gas station while McCullin was working for
[2:35] a concrete company. Mccollin told his sister Chrystell that he had met the love
[2:40] of his life. Jay Lene and Joshua called at quits for good, and
[2:46] jay Lene moved on with McCullen. The couple weren't married, but McCullin referred
[2:51] to jay Lene as his wife, and they later moved to a home along
[2:54] Best Hound Road in Bessemer City, North Carolina. In two thousand and fifteen,
[3:00] Jaylene and McCullin had a baby girl together. Angel McCullin had inherited the
[3:07] home where the family lived along with his sister, Crystal McCullin. It was
[3:12] the home that the siblings had grown up in. It was around three thirty
[3:38] pm on Monday, the fifteenth of August two thousand and sixteen, when a
[3:43] phone call came into police in Bessemer City. It was from twenty five year
[3:47] old William Joseph McCullin. He reported that he was at home looking after jay
[3:54] Lene's three year old daughter, Jordan Dumont, but she had gone missing justin
[4:00] ken now one one reynolds plus my oldest daughter. I was taking that.
[4:06] I just woke up and I can't find her anywhere. I went to the
[4:10] neighbors and then home and I don't know where she's at. How old is
[4:13] she? She's about before next month. I have a newborn with me too,
[4:16] on a one year old, and I got hurt and I can't find
[4:18] the other one. McCullin explained that he had put Jordan dawned for a knap
[4:24] and then fell asleep himself. He said that when he awoke the front door
[4:29] was wide open and Jordan was nowhere to be fined. Earlier that morning,
[4:35] Jordan's mother, jay Len, had left for work, leaving McCullin in charge
[4:41] of taking care of Jordan and Angel. During the phone call, the nine
[4:46] one month operator asked McCullin to double check the home, even checking underneath the
[4:51] beds. I really need to address bestown road. Have you looked under the
[5:00] beds and in the confess? No, ma'am. I called her name though
[5:03] I can't find her anywhere I went next door. I've been holding her name
[5:06] outside fighters. She may have fallen asleep. I need you to go look
[5:11] under the beds and stuff while I start people back way. Okay, call
[5:15] and left the phone for thirty seconds and went to check onto the beds.
[5:18] But Jordan was nowhere to be fined. Oh you's not here? Okay?
[5:26] Here a white don't work. She's about to be home, and I don't
[5:30] know where my mother is? She white? Female? Once where she's wearing
[5:38] a blue jeans in the long sleep Mickey Mell's shirt and what colors her hair?
[5:49] Brown? Is blonde? I gotta go next doore. I just want
[5:53] to take the neighbor's now. You stay with me for just a minute.
[5:56] I've already got okay, she said she has brown hair. Just no,
[6:01] all right? If she was wearing blue jeans and a long sleeping we're short
[6:05] jeans in a long sleep Mini Mini mouse blue jean shorts and a long sleep
[6:12] Minie Mouse shirt member. Okay, I don't know if she's just hiding or
[6:16] what. I don't know. I couldn't find anyway. You don't do it
[6:20] well. It was wide open and I could find it. Okay, listen
[6:25] to him. Was opened. I was all right, don't hang the phone
[6:30] up. Don't think if you need to write that units on the way too.
[6:33] You okay, so good, come back to me if you don't get
[6:36] it with an officer. Police immediately responded to the scene, and the search
[6:41] party was assembled. Jordan was described as standing at three feet two inches tall
[6:46] with a birthmark assembling the shape of a wayim Coolin said that when he put
[6:53] her down for a nap, she was wearing a pair of jean shorts and
[6:56] a long sleeved Mickey or Mini Moist T shirt. He directed police to Jaylene's
[7:01] Facebook page so that they could see a clear image of her. The responding
[7:08] officers asked McCullin whether it was possible that jay Lene had Jordan. O'cullin replied
[7:15] that it wasn't, but he admitted that he had not yet even made contact
[7:19] with jay Lene to ask or let her know that her daughter was missing.
[7:26] The search was assisted by Highway Patrol helicopters, as well as fire and rescue
[7:30] crews, and they found out around the home calling out Jordan's name. McCullin
[7:36] told the responding officers the same thing he had told the nine one one operator
[7:42] that when he woke up from a nap, Jordan was gone. He said
[7:46] that the only time he left the home was when he went with Jordan to
[7:49] collect the meal. As the search was ongoing, investigators searched the home where
[7:56] Jordan lived to see if there were any clues that could have been missed by
[8:00] McCullin. The first thing that all of them noticed when stabbing foot inside the
[8:05] home was high uncamped. It was, as Officer Christopher mcaulay recalled, there
[8:13] was a strong odor of fecal matter, rotten meat, and spoiled milk in
[8:18] the air. The bathroom, in particular, was filthy. McCullin told the
[8:24] responding officers that he and jay Lene slept on a mattress in the living room,
[8:30] while Jordan and an Angel had their own bedrooms. When Jordan's bedroom was
[8:35] searched, it was noticed that there was blood smeared across the walls. Detective
[8:41] Matt Sampson had arrived by now, and when McCullin was queried about the blood,
[8:48] he replied that the blood either belonged to him or jay Lene, not
[8:52] Jordan. The findings inside the home were very ominous, and investigators had since
[9:11] discovered that mccollin had a criminal record. In two thousand and ten, he
[9:16] was found guilty of driving while impaired. Between two thousand and eight and two
[9:22] thousand and eleven, he had four misdemeanor drug counts. As the search for
[9:28] Jordan continued, McCollum was taken to the police station for some routine questioning.
[9:35] The searching the vicinity of the family home had turned up a potted marijuana plant
[9:41] that was in the neighbor's yard. McCollum was questioned about this, and he
[9:46] admitted that it belonged to him. He stated, I may have thrown it
[9:52] over the fence. I'm not stupid. I don't want to get in trouble.
[9:56] I smoke pot every day. It was while at the police station that
[10:01] McCullin finally called jay Leane to let her know that Jordan had gone missing while
[10:07] he was looking after her. She immediately left work and rushed home to speak
[10:11] with investigators. That were now searching for her daughter. The interview of McCullin
[10:18] continued, and he cryptically commented, I hope you find it. He refused
[10:24] to elaborate any further, but investigators were more than suspicious by this point.
[10:33] Their suspicions were further cemented when they noticed that McCullin had scratches on his legs,
[10:39] but looked as though he had gone through some bushes. The officers took
[10:43] photographs of mccullin's body to preserve any potential evidence. The interview continued and investigators
[10:52] asked McCullin about the relationship he had with jay Lene. He stated, I've
[10:58] got a perfect wife and a perfect family. His comment was contrary to the
[11:03] picture portrayed at the family home. Then, in the same breath, mccollin
[11:09] said that on one occasion, jay Lene had hit him with a shovel.
[11:15] As darkness fell upon the area, the search needed to be called off,
[11:18] but it resumed as soon as dawn broke the following morning. By now,
[11:24] the community had been made aware of Jordan's disappearance, and they came out and
[11:28] droves in the morning to assist in the search. Round eleven am, police
[11:35] moved towards the woods off Beasthound Road, which was just around five hundred feet
[11:41] away from the family home. As an officer was scarring the area, he
[11:46] noticed something that was unnatural to the landscape. It appeared to be broken tree
[11:52] limbs and dry leaves piled up on the floor, and there was blackcloth sticking
[11:56] out from underneath. As he drew closer, he could see a white sock
[12:01] with bright colored stripes. The officer continued towards the object, and as he
[12:07] approached it, he could see flies crawling all over the sock. He recalled,
[12:15] I used to stick and poked it. It was obvious at that point
[12:20] it was the remains. Underneath, he found a small hole that had been
[12:24] dug into the ground. In the hole, he found the lifeless body of
[12:30] Jordan. She was wrapped in a fitted black sheet and was fully clothed in
[12:35] a long sleeved shirt with the words best Big Sister emblazoned on the front,
[12:41] with a pair of blue jeans and socks. Jordan's body was transported to the
[12:46] medical Examiner's office, where it was discovered that she had died of blunt force
[12:52] trauma. There were ten contusions to Jordan's chest and abdomen, as well as
[12:58] at least six contusions to her right arm and fourteen to her left. Jordan
[13:05] was hit with such force to the stomach that it caused cutson bleeding to her
[13:09] organs. There was bleeding between her skull and scalp, and vomit was noted
[13:15] in her mouth and nose. Jordan had died within twenty four to thirty six
[13:20] hours of her body being discovered. Shortly after the discovery of Jordan's body,
[13:39] investigators went to arrest McCullen. After his interview, he had been allowed to
[13:43] return home. However, investigators now couldn't find him. It wasn't until two
[13:50] hours later that they located him in the woods. He wasn't wearing shoes,
[13:56] and he told investigators that he had slept overnight the woods. He was arrested
[14:01] and charged with the first degree murder of Jordan. Shortly thereafter, mccollin asked
[14:09] to speak with investigators. He said that he wanted to make a full confession.
[14:16] He said that he was responsible for Jordan's death. He said that he
[14:20] was playfully swinging her around by her hands when she slipped and hit her head
[14:24] on the couch. He said that after she fell, she appeared to be
[14:30] fine. Mccollin's story didn't fit with the injuries inflicted on Jordan, and when
[14:37] he was informed of this, he then admitted that he slung Jordan across the
[14:41] room and then punched her three times in the stomach. He said that when
[14:46] he tried to feed her, she refused, He said to investigators, all
[14:52] she said is no, and she doesn't buy talk a lot. But that
[14:56] always made me mad. It pissed me off that she said no. He
[15:01] said that he then attempted to spank Jordan. He steated. I was trying
[15:07] to give her a spanking, but she rolled over onto her stomach and I
[15:11] was trying to rule her onto her butt so I could spank her butt.
[15:15] She said no, so she rolled onto her back and I punched her in
[15:18] the stomach. Day he didn't know, and she rolled back on a lot.
[15:41] I was trying to spanking. She rolled her sad and I was trying
[15:46] to She didn't know, Yeah, she said. Old Colin said that he
[15:58] punched Jordan too or three times. He stated, I made the biggest mistake
[16:03] of my life, and I want to die. He claimed that Jordan didn't
[16:08] cry during the beating, she screamed. He said that afterwards he laid Jordan
[16:14] dawn, and then when he returned she was unresponsive. He said he attempted
[16:19] CPR, but to noah fail. He said, I tried everything to bring
[16:26] her back and I couldn't. I didn't mean to kill her. I didn't.
[16:32] He claimed that he wasn't responsible for the numerous other bruises to Jordan's body.
[16:37] However, he did admit that he had struck Jordan before. He said
[16:41] that he had once used a drumstick to hit her fate and had struck her
[16:45] on the wrists before. According to McCullin, he panicked and then hit Jordan's
[16:51] body in the woods nearby, and said that he had done so because he
[16:55] thought it would have been easier on jay Lean if she thought her daughter was
[16:59] miss rather than knowing that she was dead. He admitted that he then reported
[17:04] Jordan missing, knowing all too well what happened to her. He told investigators
[17:11] that he wanted to come clean because he was haunted by saying Jordan's face whenever
[17:15] he closed his eyes. While making the confession, mccollin had the audacity to
[17:22] claim that he was always a good father to Jordan an Angel. In the
[17:29] wake of the charges, details began to emerge about the home life of Jordan.
[17:34] Immediately, neighbors began reporting to the media that Jordan had lived in the
[17:40] violent and abusive environment. There was a couple named Michael and Nicole who lived
[17:45] nearby. They broke down in floods of tears and told Channel nine reporters there's
[17:52] no way possible I could put into words what I'm feeling right now, except
[17:56] I wish I could turn back time. Revealed that around a month earlier,
[18:02] they had noticed that Jordan had two black eyes. Michael said that he asked
[18:07] McCullin whether Jordan was all right, and he responded that she had fallen over.
[18:14] Michael commented to Channel nine, I gave him the benefit of the doubt.
[18:18] Nicole then questioned Jordan herself about what had happened, and she responded that
[18:23] her mother had given her the black eyes because she was mad at her father.
[18:30] Nicole commented, if anybody sees a child with a black eye and you've
[18:33] been told they fell down, don't take it for granted. Neither Michael nor
[18:38] Nicole reported the black eyes to police or to social services, but now they
[18:45] realized that they had made a grave mistake. Another neighbor said that just recently
[18:52] he had called police after jay Lene had come running over to his home.
[18:56] She was bleeding heavily from her head and said that mc collin had struck her
[19:02] repeatedly with an ashtray. According to next door neighbor Dusty Connered, it was
[19:08] evident that mc cullin was abusive. She said that on numerous occasions she could
[19:14] hear fighting going on inside the home and heard Jane Lene begging him to stop
[19:19] hitting her. The noises coming from the home were so disturbing that Dusty had
[19:25] called the police four times in the past six months. She stated, that's
[19:32] how bad it was. We could sit on our front porch and hear every
[19:36] word that was going on in there. She further said that around a month
[19:40] earlier, she had witnessed Jordan sitting on the porch crying when McCullin came outside,
[19:45] yelled at her, hid her across the chest with such force that she
[19:48] fell off the porch, and then dragged her inside. If you're a fan
[19:56] of classic mysteries filled with unexpected twist, and June's Journey is the game for
[20:02] you? Embark on a journey with the captivating amateur sleuth June Parker as you
[20:07] attempt to unravel the mystery of her sister's murder and uncover family secrets that have
[20:11] been kept hidden for years. With over a thousand intricately designed scenes to explore,
[20:18] you'll need to put your observation skills to the test as you search for
[20:22] hidden clues and crucial information. Step back in time to the glamorous nineteen twenties
[20:26] and immerse yourself in the visually stunning and engaging gameplay of June's Journey. As
[20:33] someone who's been captivated by this mobile puzzle game for well over a year,
[20:36] I can attest to what a fantastic game it is. You often find myself
[20:41] playing late at night as a wed to unwind before bed. One of the
[20:45] most exciting aspects of June's Journey is the opportunity to create your own island estate
[20:49] and join a detective club. Can you Crack the Case? Download June's Journey
[20:55] for free on iOS and Android. As a transpired Police had actually been called
[21:03] out to the family's home sixteen times in the past three years. The Gaston
[21:08] County Department of Social Services had also been called out to the family home five
[21:14] times between March eighteen and May nineteen of that year. On the fifteenth of
[21:21] March, DSS received a report for a family assessment of suspect and neglect,
[21:26] Judian proper supervision and substance abuse. Jordan's father, Joshua, had not been
[21:33] allowed to see his daughter for the past eighteen months. He had been allowed
[21:37] to speak to her on the phone, but even that stopped around a month
[21:41] before Jordan was found dead. Joshua recalled all the countless days of crying because
[21:48] I missed her. I just wanted to see her. He had his concerns
[21:52] about her welfare, and this concern then escalated when he received phone calls from
[21:57] jay Lene which she reported that McCullin was being physically abusive towards her. Joshua
[22:06] feared that Jordan was receiving the same kind of treatment, but anytime he talked
[22:11] to his daughter on the phone, she never made any mention of it.
[22:15] Joshua stated, I believe she would tell somebody. I didn't think he was
[22:21] doing it to my child. I thought about it, but no parent ever
[22:25] wants to think it. It just drives you to the point of insanity.
[22:30] In May, Joshua reported his concerns to the Gaston County Department of Social Services.
[22:36] In the phone call, he said that jay Lene had called him and
[22:40] reported that she was being abused by McCullin and that he was concerned for the
[22:44] welfare of his daughter. He asked them to check in on Jordan. He
[22:51] lived out of town and was concerned about her well being. The case was
[22:55] closed by DSS on the twentieth of May, less than twelve weeks before Jordan
[23:00] was killed. They reported that they found no evidence that children lacked supervision or
[23:07] were impacted by parental substance abuse. At the time, the only recommendations that
[23:14] were made for the family was to maintain drug free home and sober adult supervision.
[23:21] McCollum was also asked to obtain a substance abuse assessment. On the second
[23:26] of June, Joshua called police and asked them to check on Jordan. After
[23:30] not hearing from jay Lene for a while, he was unsatisfied with dss's findings
[23:37] and thought that the police could help him. The officers responded to the home
[23:41] and jay Lene said that she didn't want any contact from Joshua. The officer
[23:48] found no problems with Jordan or Angel. Four days later, Joshua called police
[23:53] once more and asked them to check on the welfare of the children. After
[23:59] receiving a letter from Gaston County Department of Health and Human Services saying that the
[24:04] case was closed. An officer responded, but he found no issues. Joshua
[24:11] was informed by a social worker that checks had been made at the family home
[24:15] and found that the environment was staple and that Jordan had good family support.
[24:22] As details of the disturbing family history became public knowledge, Joshua said that the
[24:27] Gaston County Department of Social Services was partly the blame for Jordan's murder. He
[24:34] stated, it just makes me angry. They either turned a blind eye or
[24:40] they just didn't say it. DSS commented in the media that they were heartbroken
[24:45] by what had happened to Jordan. In a statement, they said, while
[24:49] confidentiality laws prevent us from commenting about a specific case, we want the public
[24:56] to know that our professional stand to assist in any way possible. Chris Dobbins,
[25:04] the director of Gaston County DSS, further said that social workers often face
[25:10] a difficult task of documenting abuse or neglect. He stated you can walk in
[25:15] a house five days in a week and find five different situations. DSS were
[25:23] hit with the slew of criticism, but this wasn't the first time in recent
[25:27] history that they had come under fire. Back in two thousand and thirteen,
[25:33] Channel nine interviewed a former Gaston County Social Service worker who said that when she
[25:38] was working there, supervisors had forced her to close cases early. Gaston County
[25:45] Police were also under fire as well, and they responded to the scrutiny by
[25:51] publicly releasing a detailed list of sixteen visits that they had made to the family
[25:56] home in the twenty one months leading up to Jordan's murder. In addition to
[26:03] the domestic related incidents in November of two and fifteen, there were three calls
[26:08] relating to trespassing. On the third of November, mccollin reported somebody traspassing at
[26:15] the home. The week after, jay Lene reported that somebody was refusing to
[26:19] leave the home. By the time police arrived, the person had left.
[26:26] Jaylene called back later that day and shared her concerns that this person may come
[26:30] back. On the twenty third of December, Jaylene reported that somebody had stolen
[26:34] their vehicle, and then early the next year, Jaylene called police when McCullin
[26:40] left the house with her wallet. In February, police showed up at the
[26:45] home attempting to locate a stolen vehicle, and then in March, Jaylene reported
[26:51] larceny of lawn equipment. In April two and sixteen, somebody showed up at
[26:56] the home to retrieve medication, but McCullin and jay Len wouldn't let them in.
[27:02] In May, there was an argument reported between two people babysitting and the
[27:07] person reporting had concerns for the children's welfare. Police Captain Curtis Rosel stated the
[27:14] kids were mentioned because they were there, but it wasn't about the kids.
[27:18] No light shined on an issue with the children. The night after Jordan's body
[27:34] was discovered, hundreds of members of the community gathered at an outdoor arena for
[27:40] a candlelight vigil for Jordan. Joshua's in attendance and a pastor led the crowd
[27:45] into prayer. During the vigil, Joshua said, I'm really at a loss
[27:52] for words right now. I'm just so overwhelmed by all of the support and
[27:56] the care and love that everybody has. Jayleene wasn't in attendance, but she
[28:02] issued a statements shortly thereafter, thanking the community for their support. She stated,
[28:08] this has been the most challenging, heart wrenching time of my life,
[28:12] and I appreciate the outpouring of support for me and my family. It is
[28:18] my sincere hope that justice will be done in this case. My family and
[28:22] I intend to honor Jordan by living lives worthy of her joyful heart and tender
[28:26] spirit. The community really wanted to do something to help pay for Jordan's upcoming
[28:33] funeral. Two local women, Brandy Houser and Courtney Sherbert, planned of fondraisers
[28:40] selling plates of hot dogs, and hundreds of people came out to show their
[28:44] support. Many of them had dedicated their time in searching for Jordan, and
[28:49] it only seemed right for them to try and offer any help possible. They
[28:55] sold one thousand, five hundred dollars worth of hot dogs and made almost one
[28:59] thousand dollors in donations. Joshua commented of the fundraiser, I can't even imagine
[29:06] someone else going through this. It warms my heart to know that people care.
[29:11] On the twenty third of August, Representative John tourbid. A state lawmaker
[29:17] called for an independent investigation into the Department of Social Services in Gaston County.
[29:23] By state law, a task force reviews all cases involving a child's death,
[29:29] and he said that if the review found that all procedures were followed correctly and
[29:33] something was missed and perhaps procedures needed to change, he stated it I'm asking
[29:40] for after the report comes out, I may ask for an independent or a
[29:45] set of fresh eyes to look at the process and how the process is implemented.
[29:49] We cannot just rest until we understand that we are doing everything we can.
[29:56] Towards the end of the month, a memorial service was held in honor
[29:59] of George. Since Joshua wasn't a churchgoer, he decided to have the memorial
[30:04] service at Children's Memorial Park and he invited everybody to come. Joshua sat at
[30:11] the front as poignant stories about Jordan were recited. One person in an attendance
[30:18] said, there's no more sad stories to tell. There's no more pain where
[30:22] she's at right now. I think about the fact that there is no more
[30:26] sorrow where she is. There's no hurt, and there's no broken promises.
[30:32] At the end of the service, they've released dozens of pink and purple balloons.
[30:37] Then in September, the social worker involved directly with the family's case resigned.
[30:45] The following month, mccollin appeared in court, where his arraignment was delayed.
[30:49] His defense attorney, Brent Rachford, said that his client was more than
[30:55] distraught about the situation he and his family were facing. Jay Lene didn't attend
[31:00] the court hearing out of fear, she said the people who'd been sending her
[31:06] death threats. Despite the comments from neighbors and the fact that Jordan had been
[31:11] beaten to death, Jaylene said that her children were never abused. In the
[31:17] wake of the murderer, Angel was removed from Jaylene's custody. Mccollins's defense attorney
[31:23] subsequently entered a plea of not guilty on his behalf, and prosecutors announced that
[31:29] if he were convicted, they would be seeking a sentence of life in prison
[31:33] as opposed to the death penalty. The decision was met with backlash from the
[31:38] community, with neighbor Cynthia Tazner commenting, it's not right. I'm furious.
[31:45] It makes me want to get on my knees and cry like a baby.
[31:49] Mc collin was ordered to be held on two million dollars bombed. In early
[31:55] two thousand and seventeen, mc collins's attorney requested that the upcoming trial moved to
[32:00] Shelby, where there was significantly less coverage of the case. Prosecutors didn't opposed
[32:07] to the request, but many locals did. Among them was Sandra Payne,
[32:12] who said, because it didn't happen there, it happened here. They're not
[32:16] familiar with this child. This countee was familiar with this child. The judge
[32:23] ultimately agreed to have the trial moved to Shelby. A couple of months later,
[32:29] in March, it was announced that Jordan's murder had sparked talks of a
[32:32] new change in the law. A new bill was introduced that would make it
[32:37] a felony for a parent to leave their child with a partner that isn't the
[32:42] biological parent that results in a homicide. Her father welcomed the new bill,
[32:47] commenting they might as well signed Jordan's death certificate. The law was named Jordan's
[32:54] Law in her honor, and it was introduced by Senator Cathy Harrington. It
[33:00] would require d s as to contact a non custodial parent when an investigation reveals
[33:06] abuse or neglect. In announcing the new bill, Senator Harrington said that the
[33:12] law would provide transparency for the non custodial parent, allowing them to be aware
[33:17] of their child's home environment when allegations of abuse arise, giving them the opportunity
[33:23] to be an advocate for the safety and well being of their child. In
[33:39] July of two eighteen, it was almost two years since Jordan's murder, a
[33:45] jury selection was ready to begin. By the twenty third, a jury consisting
[33:50] of twelve members of the public were selected. By the twenty fourth, they
[33:53] were seated, and the trial was ready to commence. During opening statements,
[33:59] prosecutor Megan Rodin revealed to the jury that McCullin had claimed responsibility for Jordan's death,
[34:05] but claimed that he hadn't intended it. You're going to listen as he
[34:08] describes the massive internal injuries that caused her death, the internal injuries that were
[34:15] inflicted at the hands of Baman. As she said this, she pointed directly
[34:20] at McCullin, who was sitting alongside his defense attorney. During defense attorney Brent
[34:25] Rachford's opening statements, He said that he intended on showing the jury that Jordan's
[34:30] death did not constitute his first degree murder in the eyes of the law.
[34:37] I'm gonna ask you to believe that this is colbla premitted, had thought about
[34:42] meant to do it. He told the jury that they could consider all their
[34:49] charges, ranging from second degree murder to manslaughter. It was evident by the
[34:54] opening statements that the defense was not disputing that McCullin was responsible for Ordon's death,
[35:00] but instead was trying to claim that it wasn't first degree murder. Early
[35:06] on in the trial, the jury saw graphic crime scene photos depicting Jordan's badly
[35:10] battered body. Mccollin refused to look. They then her testimony regarding the discovery
[35:17] of her body. Sergeant Anderson Holder, a canine officer with the Gaston County
[35:23] Police, testified next. He was one of the first responders on the scene
[35:30] and said he was surprised to learn that mccollin hadn't even informed jay Lene that
[35:34] her daughter was missing. He stated he had this look on his face,
[35:38] like I said something I shouldn't have. The jury would also hear from the
[35:45] medical examiner, who had performed Jordan's autopsy. He said that some of the
[35:51] bruises to Jordan were in varying stages of healing, and that some were inflicted
[35:55] in the days leading up to her murder. Defend Its attorney Rachford said not
[36:01] all of the bruises came from him. When McCollum was interviewed, he told
[36:07] investigators that jay Lene sometimes punched Jordan in the face if she was moithy.
[36:14] The medical examiner, doctor Jonathan Prevett, found bruising to Jordan's chin and abrasions
[36:20] to the lips. According to the defense, these came from jay Lean,
[36:24] but she wasn't facing charges in Jordan's murder. Doctor Pravet then presented photographs of
[36:31] Jordan at the medical Examiner's office and testified that she had been struck so hard
[36:37] in the stomach that it caused cuts and bleeding to her organs. He said
[36:43] that she had bleeding between her skull and scalp and that there was vomit found
[36:47] inside her mouth. Doctor Pravett said to the jury, you can bleed to
[36:52] death quickly, which is what I believe happened in this case. He said
[36:58] that the injury to Jordan's head, which had caused the bleeding between her skull
[37:01] and scalp could have caused significant injury. He stated. Head injuries like this
[37:08] can be fatal. He said that in his professional opinion, however, it
[37:14] was the blows to her stomach that caused internal bleeding that had killed her.
[37:20] The jury were then shown the recorded interviews between detectives that the police station and
[37:24] McCullen. Detective Matt Sampson testified about the comment McCullin had made, I hope
[37:30] you find it. He said that McCullin was clearly referring to Jordan as it
[37:37] as opposed to her, and it was a sign to him that the search
[37:40] was not going to have a happy ending. He said, I know from
[37:45] my years she was probably dead. He was probably responsible for it. The
[37:52] confession of McCullin really bolstered the prosecution's case, and the defense knew this.
[37:59] McCullin was by the judge. Do you wish to testify on your own behalf?
[38:04] He responded no, sir. He was then asked do you wish to
[38:08] call any other witnesses or have your attorney do so. McCollum replied no,
[38:15] sir. The defense then rested their case without calling a single witness. Mccollin
[38:22] then said to the judge that his confession spoke for itself. He stated,
[38:28] I just didn't want everyone to think I'm some monster. Closing arguments were presented
[38:34] next. District Attorney Debbie Gullege stated William McCollum was the killer. He didn't
[38:40] plan Jordan Dumont's death, but his guilt is plain and simple because mccollin tortured
[38:47] the three year old to death by beating and abusing her. She then held
[38:53] up a photograph of Jordan smiling, and through tears, she said, tiny
[39:00] little three year old girl, so happy and full of life. This child
[39:05] deserves justice. Do the right thing. Guilty of first degree murder. The
[39:10] defense, on the other hand, claimed that Jordan's death was an accident.
[39:16] They stated McCullin is a product of his upbringing, as he was taught and
[39:22] endured corporal punishment by his parents growing up. Mccollin physically disciplined Jordan, but
[39:29] he didn't mean to kill her. The jury were then sent off to deliberate.
[39:34] It took them just twenty two minutes to find William McCullum guilty of first
[39:38] degree murder by torture. They also found him guilty of felony murder. He
[39:45] was automatically handed a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of parole.
[39:51] Outside of court, mccullin's sister, Christal said that she was torn following the
[39:55] conviction. She said that she didn't want to believe that her brother was capable
[40:00] of such a horrific crime, adding that she was sorry for Jordan's family.
[40:07] Jordan's grandmother, Jesselyne, also had some comments. She said that she hoped
[40:14] punishment for mccollin would go beyond just prison walls. She stared it, I
[40:20] hope when he closes his eyes he sees what he did to her. I
[40:23] hope he thinks about where he buried her in the woods. I hope he
[40:28] thinks about her every minute of the day. Neither she nor jay Lene attended
[40:34] the trial. She also defended her daughter. A number of people within the
[40:38] community believed that she too, was involved in Jordan's abuse. She stated,
[40:45] not one time did I ever see jay Lene discipline her child by hitting her.
[40:50] In the wake of mccollin's arrass, Jaylene's other daughter, Angel was removed
[40:54] from her care and was sent to live with another relative. According to Jesselyn,
[41:00] this relative didn't want to give Angel back. She stated, they didn't
[41:05] want to give her back. We fought hard to get her back. They
[41:08] put her in three or four foster homes over about ten or eleven months.
[41:15] Shortly after mccollin was sentenced to life in prison, Jordan's father, Joshua,
[41:22] filed a lawsuit against both McCullin and jay Lene. According to the lawsuit,
[41:28] jay Lene had failed to provide Jordan with a safe home and participated in some
[41:31] of the abuse. The lawsuit accused jay Lene of being negligent in her role
[41:37] as a mother, feeling to protect Jordan from abuse, neglect, torture,
[41:43] and assault by failing to remove her from an unsafe environment. He was seeking
[41:47] more than twenty five thousand dollars impunitive damages from McCullin and jay Lene. This
[41:54] lawsuit was later amended and the total was twelve million dollars. Joshua's attorney said
[42:01] that it was unlikely that if they won the lawsuit that Jaylene or McCullin could
[42:07] pay. However, he said it would send a message to other parents in
[42:10] the same situation. In February of two, twenty Superior Judge Robert Bell awarded
[42:17] Joshua three million dollars in damages and further nine million dollars impunitive damages. He
[42:24] wrote, the court finds that this is a negligent action in which Jordan Dumont
[42:30] was injured, neglected, and abuse resulting in her death by the negligence of
[42:36] the defendants William Joseph McCullin and Jay Lenquerene Dumont. There are numerous services put
[42:43] in place for the protection of the most vulnerable citizens within a community. These
[42:49] include police and social services. For months, they'd be made aware of the
[42:53] disturbing environment that Jordan Dumont was living in the time and time again they to
[43:00] take key to the warning signs. In the end, it was Jordan that
[43:05] suffered because of their inaction. Will Besties. That is it for this episode
[43:27] of Morbidology. As always, thank you so so much for listening, and
[43:30] a massive, massive, massive thank you to my nurse supporter of bom Patreon.
[43:37] Please do check Morbidology out on Patreon if you like to support the show
[43:40] in exchange for bonus episodes, add free and early release episodes behind the scenes,
[43:46] and march the support on Patreon seriously go such a long way, and
[43:52] I really am eternally grateful. As always, the link is in the show
[43:55] notes. Remember to check us out at morbidology dot com for more information.
[44:00] Avoid this episode on to read or three crime articles. Until next time,
[44:06] take care of yourselves, stay safe, and half an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
