# 198: Cherish Perrywinkle

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 3 Apr 2023, 1 h 10 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53081647/morbidology_198_cherish_perrywinkle.mp3

On the night of 21 June, 2013, Rayne Perrywinkle was shopping with her three daughters in a Dollar Tree in Jacksonville, Florida. Money was tight and Rayne struggled to purchase the clothes that the girls were wanting. Nearby, a white-haired man looked on before approaching Rayne and offering assistance. But there was a catch, they needed to come with him to Walmart… SPONSORS- Zocdoc: Thank you to Zocdoc for sponsoring this episode! Zocdoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient reviewed, take your insurance & are available when you need them. To find a & book a top rated doctor today, visit: https://zocdoc.com/morbidology Pranamat: Thank you to Pranamat for sponsoring this episode! Pranamat is an acupressure mat that can help with pain, prevent headaches, promote stress relief and give an energy boost. Listeners get a special offer at: https://pranamat.com/af/lnxbvlyx?coupon=morbidology SHOW NOTES - https://www.morbidology-the-podcast-198-cherish-perrywinkle PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:35] Maybe he was grooming her. Aunts good, he doesn't kill her. Not
[0:38] to God, he doesn't rape first. On the night of the twenty first
[0:51] of June two thousand and thirteen, r In Perrywinkle was shopping with her three
[0:55] daughters in a dollar tree in Jacksonville, Florida. Money was tight and Rain
[1:02] struggled to purchase the clothes that the girls were wanting. Nearby, a white
[1:07] haired man looked on before approaching Rain and offering assistance. But there was a
[1:14] catch. They needed to come with him to Walmart. Cherish Periwinkle was born
[1:33] on the twenty fourth of December two thousand and four in Jacksonville, Florida.
[1:38] Her mother, Rain referred to her as the best Christmas gift Cherish. His
[1:44] father was Billy Jiroux, a Moraine in the Navy who had met Rain at
[1:48] a strip club on San Juan Avenue in Jacksonville. He later said of the
[1:53] meeting that he was divorced and made a mistake. He purchased Rain a drink,
[2:00] and then they returned to his home, where they had what was anticipated
[2:05] to be a one night stand. Later, Rain learned that she was pregnant.
[2:12] When she informed Billy, he asked her to get a paternity test,
[2:15] but she refused. He cut off all contact with Rain and then denied that
[2:21] he was the father of Cherish. He later commented, it was wrong to
[2:27] do that. I should have hired a lawyer. When Cherish was born,
[2:31] Rain found herself a single mother, and she really struggled with this stark change
[2:37] in her life and dynamic. In two thousand and six, Rain and Cherish
[2:40] moved into a homeless shelter. Jerish was just two years old at the time,
[2:46] and dc F intervened after Rain failed to pick her up from daycare.
[2:51] Staff at the daycare had returned Cherish to the homeless shelter, but Rain wasn't
[2:55] there. She didn't show up until more than three hours later. And this
[3:00] wasn't the only instance of this happening. It happened a further five to seven
[3:06] times. Just a couple of months later, Rain shook Cherish while at the
[3:10] homeless shelter. DCF ruled that the action did not increase the risk to Cherish,
[3:16] but said that the agency would get involved to protect her. Rain was
[3:22] then offered and participated in a number of counseling services, including Healthy Families and
[3:29] Healthy Start. She also spoke with a psychologist and partook in other local,
[3:36] federal, and state programs. Then, in two thousand and seven, the
[3:40] state contact of Billy to inform him that Rain had taken a paternity tests which
[3:46] proved that he was the father. He paid her on twenty thousand dollars in
[3:51] child support payments for the years that Rain had struggled alone. As soon as
[3:55] he learned that he was Cherished his father, he stepped up to the plate.
[4:00] He didn't feel as though Rain was providing Cherish with a safe life,
[4:04] and he found himself embroiled in a messy custody battle. In two and ten,
[4:11] a judge granted shared responsibility between Rain and Billy, but with Rain keeping
[4:15] primary custody. This smant that Somers would be spent with Billy and weekends as
[4:21] well. Deep down, Billy always believed that the judge had made a wrong
[4:26] decision and that in time Rain would not be able to provide for Cherish and
[4:30] he would end up with primary custody. It was just a wearing game,
[4:35] he thought. Rain find love again with a man named Aaron Pearson, and
[4:41] they settled down and had two little girls, Destiny, who was born in
[4:45] two thousand and eight and Navea, who was born in two thousand and ten.
[4:50] Cherish took on the role as protective big sister rain Aaron and the girls
[4:57] moved into one story home on Arland Avenue, which was a tree lined neighborhood
[5:01] just west of Interstate ninety five and Lamb Turner Road. It was ideal for
[5:08] the girls, just a stone throw away from Carville Park, which boasted of
[5:13] a public swimming pool. Cherish was described by those who knew her as a
[5:16] happy, go lucky girl with a bright smile and a kind heart. She
[5:21] loved nothing more than curling up in front of the television with the Disney movie
[5:27] or cartoons. On the weekends, she enjoyed walking around to the swimming pool
[5:32] were having tea parties with her dolls. But just eight years old, Cherish
[5:38] was already extremely artistic and she adored drawing and painting, as well as playing
[5:44] with plaedo. Cherish also loved going to school. She was a second grader
[5:49] a Chaffey Trail Elementary School, and she had just learned how to ride her
[5:54] bicycle without training wheels. Billy lived over in San Diego and Californ, Ornya,
[6:00] and when Cherish came to visit, he always made the trip more than
[6:02] worthwhile his Facebook page was dominated with all of the trips he had taken Cherish
[6:09] on from Disneyland, to the Hoover Dam and even to the Grand Canyon.
[6:15] Much like Rain, Billy had found love again. He was now married with
[6:18] a young son, but he always had time for his daughter and he cherished
[6:24] the time that they spent together. Life a Cherish in the family on Allan
[6:30] Avenue was tumultuous at times. When Rain was pregnant with Navella, she attempted
[6:35] to take her own life by overdosing on benadryl. She was subsequently diagnosed with
[6:42] borderline personality disorder and she was institutionalized under the state's Baker Act. When she
[6:50] returned home, trouble only continued. Aaron had a son from a previous relationship,
[6:57] and on one occasion, during an argument, ran through a plate at
[7:01] the little boy after accusing him of being rude and disrespectful. D c F
[7:09] intervened and investigated the case. Arn explained that Rain was a great mother to
[7:15] the girls, but she didn't like boys, and therefore he could never leave
[7:19] Rayin alone with his son. Out of fear for his welfare. At around
[7:34] seven p m. On the twenty first of June two thousand and thirteen,
[7:39] Jersh went with her mother, Rain, and her two younger sisters to the
[7:43] Dollar General's store located on Edgewood Avenue West. The following morning, Cherish was
[7:48] scheduled to fly out to spend some time with her father for the summer,
[7:53] and Rayin wanted to purchase her a new dress. As they shopped, Rain
[7:58] couldn't help but notice that a man was staring at them. As in the
[8:01] shoe while trying on shoes with my children, I looked to my right and
[8:05] he was standing in the doorway and looking right at us. He seemed to
[8:09] be overly interested in whatever they were doing. He had white hair and was
[8:15] somewhere in his fifties. The man then vanished, and Ryan continued to shop
[8:20] with the girls. They had asked for various clothing, but unfortunately Ryan could
[8:26] only afford to pick up a few bits and pieces. After they left the
[8:31] store, the man who was staring at them earlier was now waiting for them
[8:35] outside. He struck up a conversation with Rain and identified himself as Dawn.
[8:43] He said that he couldn't help, but notice that she was struggling to pay
[8:46] for clothes for her children and said that he would love to help her out.
[8:52] Dawn told Ryan that his wife had a one hundred and fifty dollars gift
[8:56] card from Walmart and the she could have it. Rain readily accept the help,
[9:03] telling Dawn that it was more than appreciated. However, she said that
[9:07] she didn't have a car to get to Walmart. Dawn had a solution.
[9:13] He said that his van was parked out in the parking lot and he could
[9:16] drive them over to Walmart that night, where they would meet his wife.
[9:22] Rain and the three girls piled into Dawn's van and they drove over to the
[9:26] nearby Walmart. Rain grabbed a trolley at the front door and began shopping in
[9:33] the clothing aisle. Rain picked out a handful of clothes for the girls.
[9:39] They were shopping for quite some time, and by ten PM, the girls
[9:41] were becoming restless. Ran explained to Dawn that it was because they hadn't yet
[9:46] eaten their dinner. Dawn suggested that he in Cherish go to the McDonald's that
[9:52] was inside the Walmart to get everybody from Hamburgers and fries. Rain agreed and
[9:58] they walked off. In the reaction of the restaurant, Rain continued chopping,
[10:03] and some twenty minutes later she noticed that the McDonald's inside the Walmart was closed.
[10:11] I quickened my pace. I looked through every ill at the register.
[10:18] There's no one there. An overwhelming sense of panic overcame Rain. She didn't
[10:24] have a cell phone and began to scream, call nine one one, my
[10:28] daughter's being taken. An employee rushed over to Rain and handed her his cell
[10:35] phone. It was around eleven twenty pm that night when Rain called nine one
[10:39] one to report cherished missing Jack for on one. Robinson, Hi, that
[10:45] Walmost an interesting and taken. What do you mean taken by stranger pider?
[10:56] Can you say you have the Walmart olin turner? Yes? How you okay?
[10:58] One? Was where did you last? He her at wa Man explained
[11:07] Hoyshi and her girls had met them on named Dawn. I met him in
[11:11] today Dollar General. He saw that I was struggling to buy them some clothes.
[11:16] Keep hervous here to buy us some clothes. And the only reason I
[11:22] went with him because she said his wife was gonna be here. Because I
[11:24] told him I don't take rides with strangers. Don't remember what clothes she's wearing.
[11:28] Because I'm panicking right now. I'm trying not to panic. Okay,
[11:33] and she was laughing. What this man is? He went? He said
[11:37] he was going to McDonald's and he he doesn't been there because the store is
[11:43] closed right now. Okay, is he a white man or a black man?
[11:48] A white man. He's got white short haired, he's got dark eyebrows,
[11:52] say dark, dark short hair. No, he's got white hair,
[11:58] a dark eyebrows. During the phone call, we knitted abundantly clear that she
[12:07] had her suspicions about Dawn before he even varnished with Cherish. I had a
[12:13] strange feeling about him when I first met him and he took her to the
[12:16] He took her to the to the dressing room twice, and I was hoping
[12:20] that she would be okay, and I was looking at the shoes and I
[12:24] didn't want him to think that I was overly protective freaking out. But now
[12:31] they're not here, and I find it very odd because he knew that,
[12:37] Okay, man, what call a vehicle does he drive? That's a white
[12:41] fan. He said, his name is Dawn. He said he was supposed
[12:48] to beat his wife here, and he's why they were shown up. And
[12:52] I couldn't figure out why his wife didn't even shot up at Dollar General.
[12:58] And he told you that y'all were going to meet his wife at the Walmart.
[13:03] Yes, first she was supposed to show up at Dollar General and then
[13:05] he was gonna meet with her at at Walmart. And we've been here probably
[13:11] two hours, and she didn't show up. And I had this cart full
[13:18] of clothes, and he said he was going to pay for with one hundred
[13:22] dollars gift card, and I excuse me. I had a bad feeling.
[13:26] I thought, well, I feel like pinching myself because this is too good
[13:31] to be true. So I got to the checkout. He's not here,
[13:35] isn't here? It quickly dawned on Rain. That's something terrible could be happening
[13:39] to Cherish. Now. I'm hoping he's not raping her right now, because
[13:45] I've had that done than me. It's not the five you think she's been
[13:50] hiking. You say you have other kids with you, Yes, I do.
[13:54] He was he was he was giving too much attention. He wanted her
[14:00] to buy these really tall shoes that were women's shoes, and I told him
[14:05] no, I said they're too high for her. I wouldn't even wear shoes
[14:09] had high. Maybe he was grooming her out. To God, he doesn't
[14:13] kill her, and not to God, he doesn't rape first. I don't
[14:18] want him to killers. Want to be one of those parents that the redrawn
[14:24] through this. I feel responsible because I told him my first minte that I
[14:35] says a little bit scared of it because I thought he was waiting to rub
[14:39] us outside the doll in general, because he was just staying there. Investigators
[14:45] were immediately dispatched to the walmart as a beyond the lookout was broadcast for Cherish
[14:50] and the man named Dawn. A search party was assembled and they scarred the
[14:54] area surrounding the walmart. There was no sign of Cherish or the mysterious man,
[15:01] so a helicopter was called in to scam the skies. While this was
[15:07] ongoing, investigators obtained surveillance footage from inside the Walmart down and the Periwinkle family
[15:15] league could clearly be observed on the footage. Dread immediately washed over as the
[15:22] footage then showed Cherish walking out of the Walmart with the man. Do any
[15:31] of you struggle with back pain and then that back pain makes it difficult to
[15:35] sleep at night. That was me up until recently when I got myself a
[15:41] Pranamat premium occupressure MATT. Pranomat is an accupressure MATT that can help with back
[15:46] pain, lag pain, fatigue, insomnia. Is effective at preventing headaches,
[15:52] promote stress relief, and gives an energy boost as well. It can also
[15:58] noticeably improve the appear of cellulite. Pranomat is practically an unlimited occupressure massage that
[16:06] you can use in the comfort of your own home. It provides immediate results
[16:10] within twenty minutes. It has a lotus flower design with little small spikes the
[16:15] target all of the key areas to increase blood and limp flu I use it
[16:19] for twenty minutes after work, while watching Netflix, and even before bed for
[16:23] a great night's sleep. Morbidology listeners have a special offer and you even get
[16:29] a gift, so please click the link in my show notes and check it
[16:33] out for yourself. You're going to love it as much as I do.
[16:41] Since Rain had been in the man's vehicle, she was able to provide a
[16:44] description of it. His vehicle had also been captured on surveillance leaving the Walmart
[16:49] parking lot, presumably with Cherish inside. It was a nineteen eighty nine white
[16:56] Dodge Fan with the Florida license late BCBK three two. As some investigators were
[17:07] searching the vicinity and searching for the vehicle in question, others were working around
[17:12] the clock to identify the man. They knew what kind of vehicle he was
[17:18] driving, they knew that his name may have been Dawn, and they knew
[17:22] what he looked like. On a hunch, they decided to check information unknown
[17:27] sex offenders, and by two am, they identified the man as fifty six
[17:33] year old Donald James Smith. Donald James Smith was a registered sex offender,
[17:52] but long before his criminal career, he was known as a local bully.
[17:57] While growing up, his neighbors in San Jose Forrest recalled a boy who was
[18:03] often armed with his father's Micheri and boasting about guns. Ron Radigan, who
[18:10] was five years younger than Smith, recalled, he picked on little kids,
[18:15] and he beat my ass a couple of times. His first brush with law
[18:18] enforcement came when he was seventeen years old, and he was later charged with
[18:23] burning a stolen car. Three years later, his sexual crimes against children began.
[18:30] He was driving his mother's car when he pulled up alongside two little girls
[18:33] who were selling cokes and masturbated in front of them. He asked, do
[18:38] you want some of this? Before driving off. Smith was arrested and he
[18:44] attempted to play insanity. A judge deemed him a mentally disordered sex offender,
[18:49] and he spent eighteen months in a state at hospital. Following his release,
[18:53] Smith continued to dabble in crime, and trouble followed him as he developed into
[18:59] an ardul He was arrested for various charges such as burglary, battery, stealing
[19:06] electricity, theft, worthless checks, and prowling. In nineteen ninety three,
[19:12] he served prison time for attempted kidnapping and lure and lavisseous assault on children.
[19:19] He had attempted to lure a thirteen year old girl over to his van.
[19:25] She refused and turned on her heels and began to run. Smith took off
[19:30] after her, and she crawled into a tubular slide. Smith couldn't climb in,
[19:36] but he stood outside and shouted, you'll have to come out sometime.
[19:41] He eventually gave up and continued in his pursuit of young girls. Just ours
[19:45] leader, He attempted to lure to girls over to his fan with pornographic magazines.
[19:52] He served five years for these convictions and was paroled in nineteen ninety seven.
[19:59] Just one year, he was arrested twice, including a lewd and lascivious
[20:03] conduct charge, and was sent back to prison for violating his parole. He
[20:08] was scheduled to be parolled on the ninth of March nineteen ninety nine, but
[20:12] DCF ordered a clinical interview. They find that Smith met the criteria of a
[20:18] violent sexual predator, which meant that he was to be held under a state
[20:22] law to keep sex offenders enforced treatment even after their prison sentence has expired.
[20:30] He was involuntarily committed at the Florida Civil Commitment Center, and he remained here
[20:36] for three years. However, prosecutors then dismissed the petition to keep him there,
[20:42] with the condition that he continued to be treated but at his own cost.
[20:48] While he was held involuntarily, prosecutors never took the steps to deem him
[20:52] a violent sexual predator in a civil proceeding, which would have made the commitment
[20:59] indefinite, so In two thousand and two, Smith was released from custoday after
[21:04] he agreed to receive drug and psychosexual treatment. Once released, his crimes only
[21:11] continued. Six months later, he was charged with passing worthless checks. In
[21:17] two thousand and three, he was charged with felony burglary and dealing in stolen
[21:22] property. The State Attorney's office could have revived the petition for commitment, but
[21:27] they didn't. In two thousand and eight, he was charged with child neglect
[21:32] after a teenager accused him of taking him to a crack den. These charges
[21:37] were dropped when the teenager recanted his statement. Just the following year, he
[21:42] was charged with attempted child abuse and attempting to impersonate a government employee. He
[21:48] had made obscene and threatening phone calls to a nine year old girl and had
[21:52] impersonated a Department of Children and Services officer. He had all the twelve year
[22:00] old boy on his cell phone and asked to speak to his nine year old
[22:03] sister, who he knew by name. The boy gave him his mother's cell
[22:07] phone number, and Smith then called her up and said that he was with
[22:11] dc F and was conducting an investigation relating to her young daughter. At the
[22:18] time, the little girl was with her grandparents, so he called them up
[22:22] and then spoke with the girl for a round twenty minutes. He had asked
[22:26] sexually explicit questions such as whether she wore a bra and questions regarding her body.
[22:33] He then told the little girl's grandmother that her father and grandfather were suspected
[22:40] of molesting her, and that if she told anybody of their conversation then she
[22:45] could go to jail. Smith then demanded the grandmother bring the little girl to
[22:52] McDonald's so that he could examine her. He demanded that the grandmother stay in
[22:57] the parking lot the little girl come inside. The grandmother instead accompanied the girl
[23:06] into the McDonald's and Smith didn't appear, presumably he was sitting somewhere nearby,
[23:11] and then fled from the scene when he noticed that the girl's grandmother was with
[23:17] her. In this case, the girl's mother gave police the man's phone number
[23:22] and it came back to Smith. When Smith was arrested, he claimed he
[23:26] couldn't remember making any of the phone calls because he had been on a crack
[23:32] cocaine bender. He suggested that somebody else had taken his phone and made the
[23:37] calls, but he was then informed that in between the phone calls to the
[23:41] girl and her family, he was making phone calls to members of his own
[23:45] family. In two and twelve, Smith pleaded guilty to the felony charges.
[23:52] It was part of a play agreement, which came with only a two year
[23:56] prison sentence, one year for each charge. The reason they had reached a
[24:03] play agreement was because the girl's mother really didn't want to put her through a
[24:07] trial which would see her having to testify against Smith. The play agreement also
[24:15] meant that Assistant State Attorney Terrence Martin dropped three felony charges and a habitual felony
[24:22] offender designation, which could have seen Smith facing a sentence of twenty years in
[24:29] prison. So to say that Smith had a long and disturbing criminal record involving
[24:34] crimes against children would be something of an understatement. He committed crime and crime
[24:41] again, and was led out time and time again, despite the fact that
[24:45] he was a routine offender. After Smith served his two year prison sentence on
[24:52] the attempted child abuse and attempting to impersonate a government employee charge, he was
[24:57] released from jail. This was on the thirty first of May two thousand and
[25:03] thirteen, less than a month before Cherish disappeared. In fact, on the
[25:11] morning of cherishes abduction, Smith had spoken with law enforcement when they called by
[25:15] his home for a routine address verification, which is state law for all sex
[25:21] offenders. Smith lived in a home on Segovia Avenue, located on South Side.
[25:29] His mother had owned the home for decades, and the majority of his
[25:33] neighbors knew of his sady past. His one neighbor, Kevin Shiver, said,
[25:40] we don't need people like this in the neighborhood. Smith had previously worked
[25:45] as a painting contractor and a handyman, and he was often spotted maintaining his
[25:49] yard. Neighbors also said that after he was released from prison in May,
[25:56] they knew that he had returned home, but they said that they rarely saw
[26:00] him. Investigators now had an identification and they knew the vehicle that Smith was
[26:19] driving. They now just needed to find him since there was evidence of a
[26:26] kidnapping. The Florida Department of Law Enforcement issued an Amber Alert, which included
[26:32] the vehicle in question, as well as Cherishes identification and Smith's identification. It
[26:38] was activated at around four thirty am, sending a series of messages to state
[26:44] agencies and others. That afternoon, Smith's van was observed driving down Interstate ninety
[26:51] five. Investigators responded to the scene and were able to pull him over without
[26:56] incident. They ordered him out of the vehicle and he complied curiously. He
[27:03] was wet from the waist. Dawn Cherish wasn't in the van. Smith was
[27:10] placed under arrest and transported to jail. Shortly thereafter, a phone call came
[27:15] into police from somebody who reported seeing a suspicious van near the Highlands Baptist Church
[27:22] in the two one hundred block of Broward Road. They said that at a
[27:26] round at forty five am or nine am that morning, they had observed a
[27:32] van parked on a bridge over the creek. They thought that it was a
[27:36] strange place for a vehicle to be parked, and even more strange by the
[27:41] fact that nobody appeared to be in the van. The creek backed onto a
[27:45] heavily wooded area and investigators descended on the scene with sniffer dogs. Charlie Wilkie,
[27:55] one of the handlers, set off in his search almost idiately. His
[28:00] dog picked up a scent and let him straight up the creek. Give him.
[28:04] We have a German We use earth commands in German, and I gave
[28:07] him a German command called suk, which simply means track. And so we
[28:11] initiated out on the edge of the woodline and hopes that he would find the
[28:15] track that led us into the I knew I needed to get to the creek,
[28:18] and so I knew that if he could find that track, he could
[28:21] take me right to where hopefully the victim was going to be. In the
[28:23] distance, Charlie could see an old tree that had fallen dawn into the grassy
[28:27] marsh area of the creek. His dog went straight over to it and alerted
[28:33] to a scent. Next, I put Gator in the down so I had
[28:37] him stay on the shoreline and I could see out beside me. I could
[28:41] see a tree that was laying on its side, and then looking at the
[28:45] reeds that were kind of pushed down that were a little bit ahead of me,
[28:48] It almost looked like a triangulation. There was reeds pushed down in a
[28:52] path that Gator had come down. And then I'm looking from my vantage point
[28:55] and I'm looking out and it just everything's lining up with this tree. That
[28:57] strike we ahead of me in the water, but it's in the water.
[29:02] I walked over that point and walked over to the water, and from what
[29:04] I could see, up underneath the trunk of the tree was Cherish laying on
[29:07] her left side, and she was facing away from me, and her hair
[29:11] was kind of floating in the water. She was under several inches of water.
[29:15] As Charlie got closer, he recoiled in horror to find the lifeless body
[29:19] of a little girl wedged underneath the tree. It was Cherish. She was
[29:26] still wearing the orange dress with a fruit pattern on it that she was wearing
[29:30] the night before in Dollar Tree and Walmart. The area was enveloped and crime
[29:37] scene to as Cherish's body was transported to the medical Examiner's office. She had
[29:44] been ripped, smothered, and it's a stand plump forced trauma to the back
[29:48] of her head. It had been a brutal murder, with bruising and scratching
[29:53] all across her body, indicating that she had put up a fierce fight for
[29:57] her life. She had also been sexually assaulted with such brutality that her anatomy
[30:06] was unrecognizable. As the tragic optated in the case winded throughout the area.
[30:30] Cherish's loved ones gathered at the home of Rain to try and make sense of
[30:34] the situation. Richard Harvey, one of Rain's best friends, briefly spoke with
[30:41] the media. He described Rain as a protective mother, stating, I was
[30:47] telling her it's going to be all right, that God never makes a mistake.
[30:52] She was drying her tears and drying my tears. We finally let go.
[30:57] He said that all throughout the day, Rain drifted in and out of
[31:00] shock. There was a familiar face among those who were supporting Cherish's family.
[31:07] It was Deana Thompson, the mother of Summer Thompson, who was abducted and
[31:11] killed in two thousand and nine. I covered the tragic case of Summer Thompson
[31:17] on episode one six two of Morbidology. Cherish's case brought back horrific memories for
[31:22] Dina, and she commented in the media that Rain's nightmares were just getting started.
[31:30] She also commented that Smith should never have been on the streets. As
[31:34] mentioned, he had a lengthy criminal record with many crimes against children. Dina
[31:41] stated, this is someone who should never have been out of prison. It's
[31:47] definitely a failure for the state of Florida. It certainly was a failure.
[31:52] Smith had shown time and time again that he was not to be trusted around
[31:56] children, yet he was a freeman, and even more disturbing, he lived
[32:01] relatively close to an elementary school. In the wake of his arrest, Representative
[32:07] Janet Adkins announced that she wanted a Duval County legislative delegation to review state laws
[32:15] regarding sex offenders. She highlighted various issues that needed reviewed, such as sentencing,
[32:22] community control, treatment, and housing options for convicted sex offenders. The
[32:29] mother of the child victim who was lured to McDonald's, Stephanie Thornton, also
[32:34] came forward and identified herself. She accused Assistant state Attorney Terrence Martin of promising
[32:40] her that with the play agreement, Smith would have served five years in prison,
[32:46] not two. She also said that he never told her the outcome of
[32:51] the case and never told her that Smith had been released from prison. Back
[32:54] in May, as news of cherished subduction and subse quent murder dominated the headlines
[33:01] across the nation and even further afield, a number of people, especially on
[33:07] social media, began to blame Rain for what happened. People said that she
[33:13] was irresponsible for allowing Cherish to go off with somebody who was essentially a stranger,
[33:20] and others suggested that she should be charged with child abuse. As for
[33:25] Billy, Cherish's father, he posted online that he blamed the courts for what
[33:30] had happened because they didn't grant him custody of Cherish. In fact, the
[33:37] custody evaluator in that case, Robert Wood, commented, the Billy really should
[33:43] have been given full custody of Cherish. He said that when he heard the
[33:47] Cherish was abducted and killed, he wasn't really surprised. He had fought for
[33:53] Billy to get custody, but ultimately Judge Lynda McCallum granted the memory cost Today
[34:00] to reign, he stated, I don't think it's enough to love her kid.
[34:07] There's no question that the child bonded to her mother. I can see
[34:10] how a judge may view the mother as a better parent, but the mental
[34:15] health trumped all. The topic of blame was a hot one, and Florida
[34:21] Department of Children and Families made a couple of statements on child's safety. Their
[34:27] spokesman John Smith, there's parents to assume that there are people out there who
[34:32] want to harm their children. He said that if something appeared to be too
[34:37] good to be true, then yes, one should most likely be skeptical.
[34:42] He stated parents should not let their children out of their sight, especially when
[34:47] you're talking about strangers. Questions were also raised in the aftermath as to why
[34:54] it took so long for the public to be made aware of cherishes abduction.
[35:00] The phone call to police had come in at eleven p m. And investigators
[35:05] had began searching for Cherish and Smith right away. However, the public weren't
[35:10] notified until around four thirty a m. Straight off the bad investigators had a
[35:16] description of the abductor and his vehicle, and they very well could have informed
[35:22] the public right away, urging them to keep an eye out. It's common
[35:25] knowledge that the first few hours after an abduction, or the most critical.
[35:30] As the hours continued to pass, hope that the victim will be found alive
[35:36] begins to fade. Jacksonville Sheriff John Rutherford announced that he had ordered an internal
[35:43] investigation to uncover why it took so long for information about Charis's abduction to be
[35:49] made public. He stated, we should have handled this differently from the beginning.
[35:55] He said he wouldn't comment further until the investigation was complete, but he
[36:00] hinted that the problem lay much higher up in the chain of command. The
[36:07] night after Smith was arrested and Cherished his body found, hundreds of people packed
[36:12] into Highlands Baptist Church on the north Side to pray for Cherish and her loved
[36:16] ones. Outside there were three posters lined up from warners to write down any
[36:22] words of condolences. It becomes something of a makeshift memorial with stuffed animals and
[36:28] balloons which had steadily grown over the past two days. There were a handful
[36:34] of drawings and notes, including one that depicted Cherish on a bicycle cycling towards
[36:39] the gates of Heaven. The mood inside the church was somber as the prayer
[36:45] vigil began, followed by a candle lighting. One of Cherish's younger sisters,
[36:52] Destiny, sang Twinkle Twinkle, while a couple of her school friends sang Jesus
[36:57] Loves Me. At one point in the song, one of the girls became
[37:00] so overcome with the motion that she couldn't finish. Ran and the rest of
[37:06] the family were in attendance, but she couldn't bring herself to speak before the
[37:10] group of mourners, and Dugger, a victim's advocate, instead spoke on her
[37:16] behalf. She described cherish, telling the crowd she liked to draw like her
[37:22] mother, She likes to paint faces, She liked to pretend that she was
[37:27] a teacher. She then spoke about the ploy that Smith had used to gain
[37:31] her trust, telling the group she was trying to make sure her child was
[37:36] presentable. Her child looked good to see her. Daddy. You don't have
[37:40] the money, you don't have the wherewithal, and somebody comes up and offers
[37:45] to help. After she spoke past her art, Taylor made a few comments
[37:50] and tried to make sense of what had happened. He stated, some people
[37:54] might ask, why did God allow this to happen? God not cause this
[38:00] tragedy. But there is the reality of wickedness, and there's the reality of
[38:06] evil of our world, in our community. It manifests itself in the wicked
[38:10] deeds of man. That same day, Smith was charged with kidnapping and murder
[38:16] and was denied bill. Prosecutor Mark Khalil announced that he was considering the death
[38:22] penalty. Later Smith was brought into an interview room, where it was observed
[38:29] that he had bruising on his body. Photographs of the bruises were taken,
[38:34] and then Smith sat down with investigators. They first of all asked him whether
[38:38] he needed anything. He asked him to call his mother to hire Anne Finnel,
[38:45] a prominent defense attorney. As he was led back to its cell,
[38:49] he commented, tell my mother, don't call Anne Finnel. They're going to
[38:53] kill me anyway. There's no sense in spending the money. The twenty seventh
[39:00] of June, Cherish was led to rest. Before the service, there was
[39:05] a viewing at Paxton Revival Centered Church, where Cherish had been a familiar face,
[39:10] often attending the children's services. Billy had traveled from California, and he
[39:16] attended the viewing at aroundi at PM, after everybody had already left. He
[39:22] wanted a few moments alone with his daughter before the service the following morning.
[39:29] The community had really come together for the family, with Hardage Giddon's Town and
[39:34] County Funeral Home donating their services and a cemetery plot. The service the next
[39:40] morning was led by Reverend Steve Dobbs, Senior pastor at Paxton Revival centered church,
[39:49] soobs emanated in the church as cherishes lavender casket was wheeled in and carefully
[39:53] placed at the front. He began his eulogy by staring, Pastor, but
[40:00] I'm upset, but it's all right. We're going to make it through.
[40:06] At the front of the church, two giant screens had been erected and they
[40:09] displayed photographs of Cherish throughout her short life. There were photographs of her playing
[40:15] with her sisters, holding a cat, playing on the beach, and tucked
[40:21] up in her pajamas. The reverend said that his heart went out to Rain
[40:25] and Billy. Before a dressing the media, he stated, I know the
[40:30] news reporters are here. Let me talk to the news reporters. I know
[40:36] you want the hottest story, and I know we want to blame the judge,
[40:39] and we want to blame the mamma, and we want to blame the
[40:42] cops. We need to blame the law that allows this man to go free.
[40:47] Before the end of the service, the pastor asked everybody to pray for
[40:52] Cherish his family. In early June, Smith was indicted on charges of first
[40:58] degree murder, kidnapping, and capital sexual battery. He bleeded not guilty to
[41:04] all of the charges. Shortly after the plea, his mother visited him in
[41:08] jail. The meeting was recorded, and Smith said to his mother that he
[41:14] couldn't go to prison because he knew that he would be raped and murdered,
[41:20] Quite an ironic statement for a man who now stood accused of the same thing.
[41:24] During the conversation, Smith spoke about how big the murder case was,
[41:30] comparing it to the Casey Anthony case and others, and we're there for case
[41:40] okay, Yeah, than that he got every major component because I mean they
[42:01] have upgraded, they have upgraded. You know, I'm trying to scare they
[42:07] have upgrading my case to premeditated capital family murder. The worst coals to argate,
[42:15] who are charging a history of anything. The worst capital is to charge
[42:22] capital sexual battery on a minor under the age of twelve and kidnapping from a
[42:31] lawmart. Those ingredients right there are a nuclear ball. He then spoke about
[42:40] death row instead. If he were sentenced to death, then his death would
[42:45] be simple, happy and peaceful. Since death row inmates are segregated from regular
[42:51] inmates. Smith knew that if he were sentenced to death, then he wouldn't
[42:55] need to fear reprisals from other inmates. It manifests itself in a million different
[43:02] ways. But every year I would think, well, what am I going
[43:14] to do about it? This year? Am I going to just go to
[43:17] my grave sick and hiding and alone? What am I going to do something
[43:30] about it? Too much to face. I'll never be able to work through
[43:35] it, you know. That's what I'm telling myself. Never be able to
[43:37] work through all this. Never, I'll never be okay. So rather than
[43:42] spending the master of my life being humiliated by myself tying all this crap in
[43:47] my head, I might as well just die with it. Easier to just
[43:52] die with it, because I'll probably never get through it anyway, That's what
[43:55] my brain's telling me. Never be able to work it all up anyway.
[44:00] Don't have a cut of the capacity that much, honesty. I don't know
[44:02] if I can handle. I don't know if I can face that much.
[44:07] At one point, Smith's mother complained that she couldn't sit on her porch without
[44:12] being hounded, You say, Rain, she doesn't have an opportunity. Her
[44:27] daughter is gone, her daughter is gone. No ask words, no as
[44:40] I love you, whatever. Smith also asked his mother to bring him a
[44:45] copy of the most recent DSM, which is A Guy to Mental Disorders,
[44:52] so that he could study them and assist in a mental health defense. Much
[44:57] of the videotaped meeting is inaudible without the assistance of subtitles, so while by
[45:01] uploading these videos with subtitles on Patreon. Just a couple of days later,
[45:07] Rain was hit with further heartbreak when Destiny and Navella were removed from her care
[45:14] by the Department of Children and Families. Her husband, Aaron had actually left
[45:20] her just the week after Cherish was killed. He had left the home that
[45:23] they shared, leaving their two children in her custody. DCF never really disclosed
[45:30] why they removed the girls, other than to say it was for their own
[45:34] safety. Both Aaron and his father wanted custody of the two girls. Aaron
[45:39] was given a custody case plan from dc F which called for him to attend
[45:44] parenting classes twice a week, keep the steady job, rent to two bedroom
[45:49] apartment, received grief counseling, and pass the psychological evaluation. As for his
[45:54] father, Tom Pearson, he had suggested that he take the girls temporarily after
[46:00] Cherish was killed, so that Rain would have time to grieve. Rain was
[46:05] allegedly furious by this suggestion. He said that before Cherish was abducted, he
[46:10] had raised concerns about the children's welfare. He stated, the kids were always
[46:16] in danger over there. I want the best for her, I really do,
[46:22] but not right now, not with my grandkids. While Aaron was fighting
[46:27] to get custody of his girls, DCF announced that they were reviewing their criteria
[46:31] for which sex offenders should be held in civil confinement. Dan Montalde, administrator
[46:38] of the state Sexually Violent Predator Program, stated, it's important for us to
[46:44] look at all of our programs to make sure we're keeping everyone safe, particularly
[46:50] children in our state. In September, a public meeting was held between state
[46:54] lawmakers, law enforcers, and experts on criminal actual tendencies. They met to
[47:02] discuss ways that current laws could be changed and new ones implemented to stop a
[47:07] similar crime from happening again. The public were all now aware of Smith's criminal
[47:13] history, with Representative Adkins steering never again. These are the words I said
[47:20] to myself when I heard about what happened to Cherish Periwinkle. Raham was also
[47:24] in attendance, and she asked why the panel hadn't been held years ago and
[47:30] why the laws hadn't already been changed. She said that people were blaming her
[47:36] for what happened to Cherish, and then said that she never actually trusted Smith.
[47:42] During the meeting, it was revealed that only no point six percent of
[47:45] sexual offenders in Florida were referred for civil confinement. Under the Jimmy Rice Act,
[47:52] sexual offenders can't be held indefinitely if they are considered a violent sexual predator,
[48:00] much like Smith was. The meeting called for implementing a risk assessment requirement
[48:06] for every single person sentenced for a sex crime, improving supervision of sexual predators,
[48:13] simplifying laws regarding sexual battery and lewd battery, strengthening community involvement in education,
[48:21] and establishing longer sentences for sex crimes against children. Later that month,
[48:27] for officers and a sergeant who worked on the abduction case were reprimanded for how
[48:30] it was handled. The internal investigation found that Sergeant Lonnie Mills, who led
[48:37] the squad of investigators, dispatched to Walmart at concerns regarding Rain's response and felt
[48:43] that it was not unrealistic that she may have been lying. Rain had commented
[48:49] to investigators at the scene that she didn't want Cherish to go to California to
[48:52] be with her father. Furthermore, she was reportedly not crying and allegedly seemed
[48:59] blase as she said the Cherish was probably raped and murdered or eavy. This
[49:05] led to some of the investigators Sergeant Mills included to consider the chad effect the
[49:09] abduction to prevent Cherish from flying to California the next day. It wasn't until
[49:15] he watched the surveillance that he realized she was in fact telling the truth.
[49:21] As for the other officers, they had failed to update the initial missing person
[49:24] report to an abduction, and they were accused of not calling in an air
[49:29] unit as quickly as they should have and failing to notify a response team that
[49:35] handles child abductions. Meanwhile, the debate on the state sexual offender of law
[49:40] continued. Senate and House committees met and began discussing what they could do to
[49:46] keep offenders either locked up or properly supervised ever released. House Criminal Justice Chairman
[49:54] Matt gat said, one of the things we were going to do is ratchett
[50:00] some of the penalties on people who abuse children, sexually abuse seniors, abuse
[50:06] they develop mentally disabled. We're also going to make sure that when people get
[50:09] out of GEL we don't just release them back into the wild and hope for
[50:15] the best. Just before the end of November, there was a custody hearing
[50:20] regarding Destiny and Novaya. They were currently in foster care and it was decided
[50:24] that they would remain there. In the meantime, Aaron had limited visitation rights
[50:30] with the girls, while Rain had none. They were reported to be doing
[50:35] really well and receiving all of the care and services that they needed. Towards
[50:40] the end of December, as families across the globe, we're celebrating the festive
[50:45] period with friends and family, the Senate filed sweeping reforms that were designed to
[50:52] strength and floored as sexual predator laws. The reforms were going to make it
[50:57] easier to keep sexual predators to teen and tough and sentencing laws for those convicted
[51:01] of committing certain sexual offenses on a minor. Disturbingly, figures had shown the
[51:08] predators released from the Sexually Violent Predators Act, just like Smith had gone on
[51:15] to molast more than four hundred and sixty children, rape one hundred and twenty
[51:21] women, and kill fourteen. The evidence that something needed to be done was
[51:27] overwhelming, and finally change was happening. Four bills were filed, and Senate
[51:32] President Dawn gatestated together, these bills will make Florida scorched earth for those who
[51:39] seek to harm our children. Another bill was filed the following month in the
[51:45] Senate that would make it a mist a manor to a law a registered sexual
[51:49] predator to borrow your vehicle. Then if the sexual predator committed a crime governed
[51:57] by state sexual predator or sex offenders, then the owner could lose their driver's
[52:01] license for a year. Smith had borrowed his mother's vehicle to abduct Cherish.
[52:08] On the sixteenth of January, all of these bills were passed by two House
[52:14] and two Senate panels. The House Appropriations Committee subsequently approved the bills as well.
[52:21] In March, the Florida Senate passed all five bills. They were passed
[52:25] unanimously without debate. In April it was signed into law. This meant that
[52:31] going forward, sexual offenders needed to list all cars registered to their address.
[52:37] It also doubled the mandatory minimum sentence for child rapists and sexually dangerous offenders to
[52:45] fifty years in prison. It also meant that the Jimmy Rice Act was strengthened,
[52:51] which was the act that allowed the civil confinement of sexual predators once their
[52:54] prisons sentence is complete. The one year Anniverse ready to cherish his abduction and
[53:00] murder ruled around in June of two and fourteen. It had been an extremely
[53:06] stressful and emotional year for all of her loved ones. In the past year,
[53:12] parents in Florida had kept a closer eye on their children while children were
[53:15] being taught about stranger danger in a way they maybe had him before. It's
[53:22] a known fact the predators often exploit of family's vulnerabilities, whether that be a
[53:28] lack of transport, childcare, money, or even a place to stay.
[53:34] Tragically, some families fail to recognize this as a form of grooming until it's
[53:39] much too late. That same week as the anniversary, the dependency hearing was
[53:46] held regarding the custody of Destiny and Navya. N had since regained her visitation
[53:52] rights, but there was a debate over whether she would ever gain custody of
[53:55] them. The people who were currently caring for the girl was commented in the
[54:00] media that neither Rain nor Aaron were ready to regain custody of the girls and
[54:07] that neither could adequately care for them. By November, Smith's trial date was
[54:13] fast approaching. His defense team argued for a jury from Miami as opposed to
[54:19] Jacksonville. They argued that the immense media attention could make it impossible for them
[54:23] to find an impartial jury. Judge Mullory Cooper said she wasn't going to rule
[54:30] emotion to move the trial and that she would try to find a jury in
[54:34] Jacksonville. If she couldn't find an impartial jury, then she said she would
[54:38] consider moving the trial to Miami. Ultimately, a jury was elected from Jacksonville,
[54:45] and by the eleventh the February, they were seated and the trial was
[54:50] ready to begin. During opening statements, state attorney Melissa Nelson said, Jerish
[54:57] Perrywinkle was eight years old, sixty seven pounds, separated from her mother,
[55:04] from her little sisters, from all she knew what was safe in this world.
[55:08] She spent the last petrifying hours with him. After pausing for a moment
[55:15] to allow the details to sink in, she continued by laying out the scene
[55:20] in Walmart. She spoke of the surveillance showing Cherish following Smith right out the
[55:25] front door and to her untimely death. She said no one noticed. It
[55:34] looked like a grandfather and a granddaughter. She then revealed the Cherish had been
[55:38] strangled with such violence that her eyes had begun to bleed. She stated it
[55:46] Cherish did not die quickly, and she did not die easily. In fact,
[55:52] hers was a brutal and tortured death. Defense attorney Julie Schlax so as
[56:00] to the jury that Rain had made a poor decision that night to get into
[56:02] Smith's vehicle. It was apparent that the defense weren't really denying that Smith was
[56:07] guilty of the murder. They were hoping that they would be able to get
[56:13] Smith off a death sentence by suggesting that Rain was partly to blame. Among
[56:20] the first witnesses to testify was Rain. She slowly walked up to the witness
[56:24] stand and sat down. She was clutching tightly to a tissue as she took
[56:30] the jury through the night that her life changed forever. She said that she
[56:36] was wary of Smith at first, but was reassured when he said that his
[56:39] wife would be meeting them at Walmart. She stated he looked into my face
[56:45] and told me I was safe. Prosecutor Mark Khalil asked, did you want
[56:52] to believe him? Rain replied very much so. Smith's defense team had wanted
[56:59] to cross examine Rain, but Smith asked them not to. He said to
[57:02] the judge, I don't want her to have to go through anything she doesn't
[57:07] have to go through. I'm done. Her testimony was followed by testimony from
[57:14] doctor Valeria raw, Jacksonville chief medical examiner. She took the jury through the
[57:20] injuries that were inflicted on Cherish. She described them as severe as grim photographs
[57:25] were displayed. At one point during her testimony, she became so overcome with
[57:30] the motion that she needed to stop for a while. She later continued detailing
[57:37] all of the injuries the Cherish had sustained. She described how there was bruising
[57:43] on her chest from excessive sucking, bruises on her botocks, and a ligature
[57:50] mark on her neck from the strangulation. She stated there was tremendous force on
[57:55] her neck such that she could not Breathe suffered swelling of the brain. Testimony
[58:02] also revealed that Smith's DNA was found on cherish his body. It was revealed
[58:07] during the trial that a covert recording device had been hidden in a pipe between
[58:12] Smith's jail cell and the adjoining jail cell. Over the course of the next
[58:17] week, the conversations that Smith had with another inmate were recorded. The other
[58:23] inmate asked Smith whether Cherish had quote unquote some bought on her. Smith replied
[58:34] she had a lot for a white girl. The recording device also picked up
[58:37] their conversation. When a group of twelve to thirteen year old girls toward the
[58:42] jail, Smith commented that he wouldn't mind running into those girls in Walmart,
[58:47] and the twelve to thirteen year old girls were his preference. During closing arguments,
[58:52] the prosecutor said that Cherish had endured a nightmare that no child should ever
[58:59] have to endure. He said that Smith had made Cherish and Rain feel safe
[59:04] through lies and deception. She got into that hand and no one ever saw
[59:13] again. He stole her from her. She took her for the purpose of
[59:24] satisfying his desires, for his pleasure. He took her aware no one would
[59:32] see, no one would hear, and then he right silence. He destroyed
[59:50] her sessual hand, and when he's done pleasure himself, he looked at that
[59:59] child. He once more took the jury through all of the evidence against Smith,
[1:00:15] including the surveillance footage and his DNA. The defense opted out of providing
[1:00:22] a closing argument. They also failed to call any witnesses to testify on Smith's
[1:00:28] defense. The jury were then sent off to deliberate, and they returned with
[1:00:34] the verdict after just fifteen minutes. They found Donald James Smith guilty of the
[1:00:39] abduction, rape, and murder of Cherish Periwinkle. The trial then entered its
[1:00:45] sentencing phase. The jury could either decide that Smith should spend the rest of
[1:00:51] his life in prison or be sentenced to death. He needed to be a
[1:00:55] unanimous decision. The prosecution called on an unexpected witness. It was a former
[1:01:02] victim of Smith. She told the jury high in nineteen ninety two, Smith
[1:01:08] attempted to lure her into his car when she was thirteen years old. How
[1:01:15] did he defend approach? Man? Um, he was coming towards me and
[1:01:22] um it's out, um, he told more towards my side of the road
[1:01:28] and asked if I knew a girl, lady Susie. Well, if you're
[1:01:34] fast wowness. He uh. He asked me if I wanted to Southside Middle
[1:01:45] School, and I also I did it, but I told him no.
[1:01:52] Why did she tell him? Because he was a stranger. What happened that
[1:01:59] he told him? Rod? He mean that I hate the fend he he
[1:02:07] told me to get the fuck the pen. How would you describe the boys?
[1:02:14] I mean scary what he said to see? Hey, Head, where
[1:02:22] did you run? It's had in TRD. I'm TRD my friend Tamper's house
[1:02:29] at the time of it, stefing and thinking to do did the defendant chase
[1:02:35] after you and that man he did? Did you try to run to some
[1:02:38] place to find a place to say? I tried to run to two Tamper's
[1:02:46] house at one point Head had cut me off across the road and I just
[1:02:53] kept money and it didn't make get two Tamper's house. There is a small
[1:03:20] playground and there okay, guys. Testimony would also be presented regarding Smith's mental
[1:03:37] health had their homes of forensic psychologist diagnosed him with an antisocial disorder, borderline
[1:03:45] personality disorder, clinical depression, severe cocaine disorder, and pedophilia disorder. It
[1:03:52] was revealed that he had taken crack in the bathroom of the walmart before he
[1:03:57] learned Cherish away, and that when he was arrested, he blamed her for
[1:04:01] her own murder, saying he had to kill her because she got in his
[1:04:06] fan. Joseph Sesta, a neuropsychologist hired by the defense, told the jury
[1:04:13] that Smith was most certainly a psychopath. He said that his brain was far
[1:04:17] from normal and that he lacked control over his impulses. They disclosed that not
[1:04:24] long before Cherish was killed, Smith attempted to get mental health help through a
[1:04:29] Baker Act, but was turned away. The defense tried to humanize Smith by
[1:04:33] displaying various photographs throughout his life, photographs of him doing ordinary things such as
[1:04:41] walking down a church aisle, playing on a beach, and riding a bicycle.
[1:04:46] In the end, the jury weren't swayed by the defense, and they
[1:04:49] decided that Donald James Smith deserved to die for his actions. It was to
[1:04:56] be formally sentenced to a leader did by the judge, but before leaving court
[1:05:01] that afternoon, Rain was allowed to make a statement. She stared directly at
[1:05:08] Smith and said, I will never see her get married and enjoy her life.
[1:05:14] He has taken that from me and it can never be returned. I
[1:05:17] have so much rage inside of me because of what he did. I've never
[1:05:23] felt this much hatred in my life. I see reminders daily of what he
[1:05:28] took from me. Every way van I see is a horrible reminder of what
[1:05:31] he did and how she suffered. Every school bus I see is a reminder
[1:05:36] of Cherish. Jerish loved riding the school bus. I would go eagerly wait
[1:05:43] for her to come home and share her day with me. I feel the
[1:05:46] pain of losing Cherish every day. It has been four years and nine months,
[1:05:53] but for me it will always feel like yesterday. Billy also provided a
[1:05:59] statement that was readied lawed by Attorney General Wilkerson. He said that his life
[1:06:03] had been changed immeasurably by his daughter's death and that he never believed in angels
[1:06:10] until she died. He further stated he never really believed in monsters. I
[1:06:16] do now and forever. The images of my child's last minutes on this earth
[1:06:21] will play out in my mind like a private internal hell that never ends.
[1:06:28] On the first of May, Smith returned to court where Judge Mullory Cooper sentenced
[1:06:32] him to death. She stated, Donald Smith, you have not only forfeited
[1:06:39] your right to live among us, you've forfeited your right to life at all.
[1:06:45] Two years later, Smith appealed his death sentence. His attorney argued that
[1:06:49] the trial should have been moved out of Duval County and the graphic photographs of
[1:06:55] Cherish his body should never have been shown to the jury. His appeal was
[1:06:59] denied. As for Destiny and Navya, they were adopted by their aunt who
[1:07:04] lived in Australia. The custody proceedings were assailed by a judge, but it
[1:07:11] was disclosed that neither Rain nor Aaron had met the criteria to regain custody of
[1:07:15] their girls. This meant that the state had no other choice than to put
[1:07:20] them up for adoption. Protecting the most vulnerable citizens in a community is one
[1:07:29] of the most basic functions of a government. Time and time again, Donald
[1:07:33] James Smith showed what a dangerous predator he was with each crime he committed.
[1:07:40] He was escalating even further when he abdogged and killed Cherished Periwinkle. He should
[1:07:46] never have been a freeman. The state had three opportunities to detain him indefinitely
[1:07:54] under the Sexually Violent Predators Act, but they failed to do so and in
[1:07:59] turn Field Cherish. However, Jerish's death will not be in vain. It
[1:08:05] led to a swift reform of state sexual predator laws, reforms that will hopefully
[1:08:11] better protect children from other predators just like Smith in the future while beasties.
[1:08:39] That is it for this episode of Morphidology. As always, thank you so
[1:08:43] so much for listening, and I'd like to say a big, big,
[1:08:45] massive thank you to my newest Padreon supporters, Mercedes and Jams. As you
[1:08:50] all know Morphidology as a one woman teams with the support up on Padreon,
[1:08:55] seriously go such a long way. I have some bonus con tent from this
[1:09:00] episode that I'm going to be uploading there next week, so please do check
[1:09:05] more biology Ooid on Padreon if you want some bonus content, odd free and
[1:09:10] early release episode, behind the scenes and more. The link is in the
[1:09:15] show notes and you can cancel anytime there's absolutely new obligations. Remember to check
[1:09:20] us out at more aboutolity dot com for more information about this episode on to
[1:09:25] read or true crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves,
[1:09:29] stay safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
