# 216: Christie Marceau

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 7 Aug 2023, 49 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/56069551/morbidology_216_christie_marceau.mp3

Tracey Marceau had just woken up on the 7th of November, 2011, when she heard a knock at the front door of her home in Hillcrest, Auckland, New Zealand. When she opened up the front door, she saw a man standing there before her. She recognised him immediately. Before she even had time to react, he reached into his bag and pulled out a large knife. SPONSORS - Zocdoc: Thank you to Zocdoc for sponsoring this episode! Zocdoc is the only free app that lets you find and book doctors who are patient reviewed, take your insurance & are available when you need them. To find a & book a top rated doctor today, visit: https://zocdoc.com/morbidology June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. SHOW NOTES - https://www. morbidology-the-podcast-216-christie-marceau PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:48] Christi Morsu was at her home in Hillcrest, Auckland, New Zealand, when
[0:52] she received a phone call. On the other end of the line was a
[0:55] familiar voice among the Christie knew from work. The quint and told Christie that
[1:00] he was feeling sooth's sidal. Christie immediately dropped what she was doing and ran
[1:06] to his nearby home. Christie Morceaux's place in the family was a cherished one.
[1:23] Born as the second child to Tracy and Brian Morceaux, she arrived six
[1:27] years after her older sister Heather, giving her parents an unexpected gift they never
[1:32] thought that they would have nestled in the Hillcrest neighborhood of Auckland, New Zealand.
[1:38] The Morceau's lad a fulfilling life. Tracy dedicated herself to her role as
[1:42] an account's assistant, while Brian served as an avionics technician in the Air Force.
[1:49] Following in her father's footsteps, Heather pursued a career in the Air Force,
[1:53] working as a senior supply specialist stationed in Fanupie. Christie, on the
[1:57] other hand, immersed herself an academic mix at aut University. After completing her
[2:02] studies at ACG. Parnell College in two thousand and ten. Beyond her studies,
[2:07] Christie was an avid hockey player, contributing her talents to one of North
[2:12] Shore's United Seniors women's teams. Coach Mark Patterson spoke fondly of her natural happiness
[2:17] and outgoing nature, describing her as an exceptional team player who effortably fostered friendships
[2:23] among her teammates. Cycling also held a special place in Christie's heart. She
[2:30] actively participated in rides and time trials organized by the Auckland Central Cycling Club,
[2:35] showcasing her determination at the frontier of adulthood. Christie's caring and compassionate nature shone
[2:42] through and she was always looking out for the underdog. Her parents described her
[2:46] as a beautiful baby who grew into happy toddler, a mischievous and intelligent child,
[2:52] and a striking teenager with a huge heart and a smile that you couldn't
[2:55] help but be warmed by. Christmas held a special significance for the Marteau family,
[3:01] with festive celebrations bringing them together. Christie in particular embraced the holiday spirit,
[3:07] eagerly taking charge of putting up the Christmas tree and adorning it with decorations
[3:13] each year. Christie lived at home on Eban Avenue with her mother, father,
[3:17] and grandmother Shirley, who lived in a downstairs flat in the home.
[3:43] In two thousand and eleven, Christie found herself working at a local supermarket alongside
[3:46] an acquaintance, eighteen year old Akshay and Chant. Their connections stand from attending
[3:54] the same primary school for a brief period and living in close proximity. While
[4:00] their interactions were limited to occasional conversations on social media, they were by no
[4:04] means close friends. Chand was categorized as an odd and solitary individual and was
[4:12] often regarded as an outsider. Christie, however, had shown kindness to him
[4:15] when few others had. Chant had been born in Fiji on the eleventh of
[4:20] December nineteen ninety two, and when he was four years old, the family
[4:25] moved to Britain. They remained there until Chand was nine years old, when
[4:30] the family moved to New Zealand. Soon after, his parents separated and his
[4:34] father returned to Fiji and had very little contact with his son. As a
[4:41] young student, Chant had excelled in school, especially in English and maths.
[4:46] However, he always struggled in social conditions and never really made any friends.
[4:51] As he entered his teenage years, chance withdrawal intensified. By two thousand and
[4:58] eleven, he had experienced them acceptbacks, substantial weight loss, and have become
[5:02] increasingly isolated, spending the majority of his time engrossed in video games within the
[5:08] confines of his bedroom. A constrom. Those familiar with him revealed his tendency
[5:13] to give away significant sums of money, possibly in an effort to gain companionship.
[5:19] Christie was among the recipients of this generosity. While Chan displayed an obsession
[5:26] with Christie, she regarded him as nothing more than a friend from work.
[5:30] Nevertheless, chant with Linger outside the supermarket, fixated on catching a glimpse of
[5:36] her as she left work, He would often unload lengthy and rambling messages,
[5:43] venting about his life. Despite feeling unsettled, Christie, who was known for
[5:47] her compassionate nature and championing the underdog, tolerated Chand's strange behavior. She unwittingly
[5:56] became an outlet for his troubles, a person with whom he felt safe confiding
[6:00] without fear of judgment. Over time, Christie's concerns grew as she sensed chance
[6:08] deteriorating mental state and apprehended potential harm in his presence and beeknownst to Christie,
[6:15] however, by mid two thousand and eleven, Chant had started hearing voices in
[6:19] his head. Initially, Chant mistook them for his coworkers conversations beyond earshot.
[6:27] Around the same time, his obsession with Karl Marx and his book Das Capital
[6:31] intensified. He developed affixiation on capitalism and ultimately quit his job, unable to
[6:39] reconcile government spending while witnessing the plight of starving children. On the sixth of
[6:45] September two thousand and eleven, Christie received a distressing phone call from chand at
[6:48] her home. He threatened to consume forty pills mixed in a drink unless she
[6:55] visited him immediately. Christie feared for his safety and responded swiftly. Given the
[7:01] proximity of the residence, she donned her jacket and set out to Chan's home,
[7:06] located just around a kilometer away. As they sat down in his bedroom,
[7:12] the atmosphere shifted and tension filled the air. Christie vividly recalled the harrowing
[7:17] moments that followed, he got really angry, and then he pulled a knife
[7:23] out of his back pocket. He got up and stood over me. His
[7:27] right hand was shaking it as he was waving it. It was a kitchen
[7:31] knife, like one of those ones that you pull out of a knife set.
[7:34] It was about twenty centimeters and it looked like he sharpened it. Johan
[7:40] then told Christy if she screamed or tried to escape and didn't obey him,
[7:44] then he would knife her. She recollected. When he said that to me,
[7:49] I started crying because I thought he was going to kill me. I've
[7:53] never been so terrified in my life. Then he told me to shut up
[7:57] and compose myself to Christie that his aim was to terrify her, get revenge,
[8:03] and then kill himself. He ordered her to strip naked, and she
[8:07] recollected. I started crying more because I was getting an idea of what he
[8:13] wanted to do. He held the knife out and said, you know what
[8:16] will happen, So I took them off nude other than for her underwear.
[8:22] Christie found herself seated in an armchair within Chan's bedroom, forced to endure his
[8:28] ramblings. He spoke of an encounter with the devil, claiming that one fateful
[8:33] night he was seized by an unseen force, plunging him into an unwinnable battle.
[8:41] Chand delved into a litany of troubles for the next half hour, before
[8:43] uttering I'm going to let you go, but I just want you to know
[8:48] that once you leave, I'm going to drink the drink. Christie quickly put
[8:52] on her clothes and discouraged him from taking his own life. She then seized
[8:58] the opportunity to escape and fled from the home and immediately reported her terrifying ordeal
[9:03] to her mother, who in turn called the police. John was charged with
[9:09] kidnapping, assault with intent to commit sexual violation, and threatening to do grievous
[9:13] bodily harm. He readily admitted to these offenses, but then on the fifth
[9:18] of October, he was granted beale with conditions that included he resided his mother's
[9:24] home on a twenty four hour curfew and did he knock near Christie's address or
[9:30] associate with her in any way. Chant had written a letter to the judge
[9:33] expressing remorse over his actions. It read him, part, given the chance,
[9:39] I will apologize to her. Her parents and anyone else affected. Ironically,
[9:45] the last thing she said to me was that she was sorry. It's
[9:48] only after the events of that day that she realized how much pain depression caused
[9:52] me and how much I needed her, and vice versa. Both the police
[9:56] and Christy vehemently opposed a chance release Beale, especially Jude to whose proximity to
[10:03] the family's home. In a heartfelt letter to the judge, Christie pleaded with
[10:07] him not a grant Bale, fearing for her safety and dreading the prospect that
[10:13] he could attempt to attack her again it's revenge. Despite the oppositions, Judge
[10:18] David McNaughton approved the Bale anyway. When Chand returned home, his mother hid
[10:24] all of the kitchen knives out of fear that he would harm himself or somebody
[10:28] else. His sister recollected. I knew what he had done and it terrified
[10:33] me. I remember putting even the small knives away. We did this because
[10:39] we were both scared about what he might do. I took every opportunity to
[10:43] step friend's houses so I didn't have to be at home. Chan's mother,
[10:48] Suchita, grew increasingly concerned about her son's well being. And decided to seek
[10:52] assistance for him. After his release on bale, she accompanied him to their
[10:56] family doctor on two separate occasions, hoping to find a solution. However,
[11:01] the visits proved insufficient in improving chance condition. Determined to help her son,
[11:07] Suchita took him to doctor A. J. McCall, a renowned practitioner at
[11:11] the Byron Medical Center. Following a thorough investigation, doctor macau prescribed Chan the
[11:16] dosage of twenty milligrams of satalopram, an antidepressant. Disappointingly, however, this
[11:24] medication yielded little improvement, prompting Suchita to revisit the doctor and half the prescription
[11:31] increased to thirty milligrams. In the aftermath of the terrifying ordeal, Christie underwent
[11:37] to perform transformation, becoming a mere shadow of her former self. Though outwardly
[11:43] still projecting an aura of happiness and lightheartedness, beneath the surface, she harbored
[11:48] a deep seated fear. Recollecting the aftermath, her mother Treacy stated, the
[11:54] greatest impact, though, is that from the day of the offending I was
[11:58] robbed of my daughter. She became closed, distant, and untrusting. The
[12:03] fear that Christie felt was only exacerbated by the fact that cham was on bale
[12:09] and lived only around the corner. By November, Christie eagerly anticipated a turning
[12:13] point in her life. Both she and her mother Tracy, had plans to
[12:18] fly to Adelaide, Australia and reunite with Brian, who had just recently secured
[12:24] employment in the area. Brian had already made the trip ahead of them to
[12:28] make the necessary arrangements. The impending move brought a surge of excitement for Christie
[12:35] as she looked forward to attending university in Adelaide. For Christie, the eleventh
[12:41] of November couldn't arrive soon enough. On this highly anticipated day, she and
[12:46] her mother were scheduled to embark on their flight, marking the long awaited moment
[12:52] when Christie would finally sever all ties with Chand once and for all. At
[13:13] about six thirty am on the morning of the seventh of November, Chand awoke,
[13:20] climbed out of bed and brushed his hair. He went to his closet
[13:24] where he had stashed a bag which contained a large butcher knife and a hammer.
[13:30] At the time, his mother was at work and his sister was fast
[13:33] asleep. From here, he walked the less than five minute walk to Christie's
[13:39] home, listening to up the ladder by radiohead on his iPod, which was
[13:43] on loop. He knocked on the front door and Tracy opened up. Chan
[13:48] stood there for a second and then reached into his bag and pulled out the
[13:52] butcher knife. As soon as Tracy caught sight of the knife, she began
[13:58] to scream. Chand pushed past Tracy and demanded to know who was in the
[14:03] home. Tracy bluffed and said the bran was in another room. Seconds later,
[14:09] however, Christie appeared at the top of the stairs that led down to
[14:13] her bedroom, having been awoken by her mother screaming. She saw Chan standing
[14:20] there with the knife in his hand and began to scream. Chand rushed at
[14:24] her and kicked her full force in the stomach, causing her to fall backwards
[14:30] down the stairs. Chrissie managed to get back up on her feet and scrambled
[14:35] out of the back door, but Chand was close behind her. Tracy ran
[14:39] to call one one one for assistance, while Christie ran to the back garden
[14:46] as she attempted to unlock the gate to put some distance between her and chanmed.
[14:50] He stabbed her once in the face, and then continued stabbing her in
[14:54] the head, neck, and torso as her screams echoed up and on the
[15:00] neighborhood. Christy was stabbed around ten times by Chant and had been stabbed with
[15:05] such force that the knife was bent ninety degrees. Despite this, Johan kept
[15:11] trying to stab her before finally stopping when he realized that the knife was unusable.
[15:18] Seconds later, Tracy emerged from the home. She ran to her daughter's
[15:22] side and cradled her in her arms. As her breath became fainter and fainter,
[15:28] Tracy bagged her daughter to hold on and that help was on the way.
[15:33] She recollected. I watched the live drain out of her while I was
[15:37] holding her. I felt her slip away from me. Officers responded to the
[15:43] scene in a matter of minutes, but when they arrived, it was already
[15:48] too late for Christie. She was dead. John was just standing there,
[15:52] listening to radiohead on his iPod, covered in blood, with a smirk on
[15:58] his face, the bent knife in his hand. One of the officers later
[16:03] commented that it looked as though he had achieved his purpose. He was asked
[16:08] by one of the officers why he was there, and he calmly responded reprisal.
[16:14] He then began to shake, and when an officer asked why he was
[16:18] shaking, he replied, it's not easy to kill someone, is it.
[16:23] Chand was immediately arrested at the scene and was reported to be devoid of emotion.
[16:30] He told the officers that he was a callous fiend, before adding that's
[16:33] just who I am. I murdered her in the face of unspeakable tragedy.
[16:40] Tracy shouldered the ardiest burden of informing her husband, thousands of miles away in
[16:45] Adelaide, of the heart wrenching news. So if the arranging for a return
[16:51] fled, he embarked on a long, solitary journey. Reflecting on those rs,
[16:56] he confessed, it was a long journey and no one wants to be
[17:00] sitting in a row of seats with some sobbing bastard, So I just kept
[17:04] it all to myself. I certainly don't feel the pain Tracy felt because she
[17:10] was there, but there's still that guilt but not being able to be there.
[17:26] The day after the murder, Chan appeared in court, where he was
[17:29] charged with Christie's murder. He was wearing a blue boiler suit and stood silently
[17:34] in the dock. There were several reporters in the courtroom, and chance defense
[17:41] attorney Mary Ann Lowe attempted to block some reporters from taking photographs of her client.
[17:47] She said the publishing photographs of him would be a threat to his ongoing
[17:49] mental health issues. Judge David Burns responded and told her that it was in
[17:56] the public interest to publish photographs of Chant. Defense attorney low didn't apply for
[18:02] BALE, nor did she seek names suppression for her client, who was remanded
[18:07] in custody until the twenty ninth of November. While Chan didn't apply for BALE,
[18:11] detectives have prepared an opposition form in the event that he tried. It
[18:17] read in part. The defendant has stated that he feels absolutely no remorse for
[18:22] the victim and she deserved to die because she let me dawn. When he
[18:26] was previously baled in October, he took this opportunity to carefully plan and execute
[18:32] the murder of the victim. The victim involved in the initial charges is not
[18:37] dead at the hands of the defendant. Chan admitted killing Christie from day one
[18:42] and has never denied any of the facts. The Martial family have chosen not
[18:47] to speak about the case until Chant is sentenced. They were in court yesterday
[18:52] and heard every detail of Christie's death and the lead up to the tragedy discussed
[18:56] at great length. In the days after Christie's murder, tributes came flooding in
[19:02] from her loved ones. Boyfriend Joseph, who she had been dating for a
[19:07] round a month, posted a poignant tribute to her on Facebook. He posted
[19:11] photographs of them together along with the caption please don't forget me and please come
[19:17] back. Afterwards, he and Christie's family released a statement which read in part,
[19:22] I'm sure you will all understand that at this emotional time, my family
[19:27] and I, along with all of the Marshaw family, just needs space and
[19:32] privacy to grieve over the sudden loss of Christie. To all of Christie's friends
[19:37] out there, please stay strong and hold tight to all those happy memories we
[19:41] have of an amazing young woman who we've lost too soon. The statement also
[19:47] asked that those who knew Christie to remember her for who she was and to
[19:51] hold on to those happy memories. On the thirteenth of November, Christie was
[19:56] laid to rest in Albany outside the chapel. Person from the New Zealand Air
[20:00] Force, where Brian had worked formed a guard of honor. The service was
[20:06] an nonreligious service, during which Christie was described as vivacious, outgoing, friendly
[20:12] and very fond of animals. Five of Christie's friends mid poignant eulogies, while
[20:18] her family released a public notice which read, a bright light taken too early
[20:23] from us. Sleep well, my darling, Your beauty and vivaciousness will be
[20:27] sorely missed and never forgotten. As soon as details regarding Chan's previous attack on
[20:34] Christie were made public, there was a massive outcry, as well as fresh
[20:40] questions about baale legislation and whether tight or laws could prevent such tragedies from happening.
[20:45] The concept of bail is deeply entrenched in the fundamental principles of the legal
[20:51] system. It stems from the notion that every person is presumed innocent until proven
[20:56] guilty, and innocent people are not held in custody. In New Zealand,
[21:00] the approach to bail stands in stark contrast to the United States, where bale
[21:06] amounts tend to be exorbitant aiming to ensure the accused appearance in court. However,
[21:11] it became evident that serious flaws plague the administration of bail in New Zealand.
[21:18] Far too often judges appear to prioritize the rights of the accused, allowing
[21:22] them to remain at liberty while awaiting the resolution to their legal proceedings, often
[21:27] overshadowing the rights of the victims. The presumption of innocence, while a crucial
[21:33] pillar of justice, does not equate to an unconditional get out of jail card,
[21:38] its scope is not boundless, and it should not come the expense of
[21:42] safeguarding potential victims. The un settling realization that the system seemed to prioritize the
[21:49] accused rights over the safety of potential victims called for a crucial examination of the
[21:56] baille process. The tragic consequences unfolded in Christie's case underscored the urgent need for
[22:03] a revaluation of baal laws ensuring a delicate balance between the presumption of innocence and
[22:08] protecting the well being of society. On the twenty eighth of November, Chan
[22:14] appeared in court once more, where he was remanded in custody until the twenty
[22:18] first of December. After his appearance, Tracy and Brian spoke with the media
[22:23] for the first time since Christie was killed. They shared their plans to start
[22:29] a campaign called Christie's Law that would often baal laws in an effort to prevent
[22:33] other families from going through while they were currently going through. They were working
[22:38] alongside Sensible Sensing Trust and a group of friends to bring their ideas to freition.
[22:45] Tracy stated, this is the only thing keeping us going. Nothing is
[22:49] going to bring Christie back to us, but we need to do this for
[22:52] her. They shared their grief and Tracy said that she was feeling immense gilt
[22:59] over what at happened. She stated, I will never forgive myself. I
[23:04] have to live with that forever for the rest of my life. You know,
[23:08] it's not my fault, but it still goes through my mind. It's
[23:11] all I ever think about. Nothing would have changed the outcome. I know
[23:15] that now. Everyone says I should be glad that I was there with her,
[23:21] but we should never have had to go through that. We should have
[23:25] been safe. We shouldn't be dealing with this. Tracy and Bran began campaigning
[23:30] for a change in the law. They wanted the criteria for granting bail the
[23:34] people charged with serious offenses to be stricter, give more power and way to
[23:40] police and victim's statements opposing bail, and enforce more rigorous risk assessment testing for
[23:45] offenders. They also wanted victims to be given full details of their attackers bail
[23:52] conditions. Garth mcvickar, the director of Sensible Sensing Trust, said that Christie
[23:57] needed to be the catalyst for change. He also said that currentbal laws favored
[24:03] the accused rather than the victim. He stated, we have a criminal friendly
[24:08] legal process rather than a justice system that asked to change. We all have
[24:14] the right to live in safety. These people have been failed by the system.
[24:18] It's unbearable from their perspective. In February the following year, Tracy and
[24:25] Brian were ready to launch Christie's Law. The launch took place outside the High
[24:29] Court in Auckland and they asked everybody in attendance to wear turquoise, which was
[24:33] Christie's favorite color, to pay tribute. Tour around five hundred people gathered a
[24:40] demand tougher beal laws and they brandished signs such as judges must be held accountable
[24:45] and Who's next. Tracy and Brian weren't the only family members bereaved by violence
[24:52] in attendance. Charlie Borell was also there, whose son Augustine was killed in
[24:59] two thousand and seven by Hayden Davis, who was out on bail. Robin
[25:03] Hansen was there as well, whose niece's mother, Vanetsa Pickering, was murdered
[25:07] by Malcolm Chaston, who was also out on bail. Charlie stated, there
[25:14] are some real dumb laws. We all thought that this stuff wouldn't happen to
[25:18] us, but believe me, you're not immune. This stuff could happen to
[25:22] you. Next after the speeches, the crowd marched from the High Court to
[25:27] Bridamart. Labor and National were both backing Christie's law, with Prime Minister John
[25:33] Kaye announcing that the government had campaigned on top for Baill laws the previous November
[25:40] and that a bill would soon be introduced to Parliament. After the first reading,
[25:45] it would go to Your Select Committee for public submissions, which would give
[25:48] Christie's law campaigners the chance to put their case to MPAs as Tracy and Brian
[25:56] were fighting for a change. In April, it was announced the cham was
[26:00] order to undergo a psychiatric examination. He was remanded to Mason Clinic for two
[26:04] weeks so the dissors could prepare reports on his mental health and fitness to stand
[26:11] trial. He was ruled fit to stand trial, and he pleaded not guilty
[26:15] to Christie's murder. It was also announced that he was facing further charges of
[26:19] threatening Christie with grievous bodily harm and assaulting her with intent to commit sexual violence.
[26:26] These related to the earlier kidnapping incident. He pleaded not guilty to these
[26:32] charges as well, and launched an application to have separate trials, one for
[26:37] the murder charge and another for the remaining charges. It was a request that
[26:42] deeply upset Christie's family, as it meant that they would need to attend two
[26:47] trials. As Tressy said, the thought makes me feel really sick. It's
[26:53] going to bring up memories that my counselors and doctors have been working so hard
[26:57] to relieve. I've basically got to start from scratch again. I've started to
[27:03] reach a point in my life where I was dealing with these things. Now
[27:07] I've got to relive those last moments of Christie's life. To be honest,
[27:11] I don't know how I'm going to deal with that. Despite the competency ruling,
[27:18] Chand was going to use an insanity defense when he went on trial.
[27:22] Moreover, it was then decided the Chand would be facing one trial for all
[27:26] the charges. In a noteworthy development, a bill aimed at imposing stricter conditions
[27:48] for granting bailed to serious offenders was presented in Parliament during its inaugural reading in
[27:56] May. The bill, which gained momentum following the launch of Christie's Law,
[28:00] required individuals facing charges of severe violent crimes, sexual offenses or Class A felony
[28:07] drug offenses to demonstrate to the Crown that their release would not pose a threat
[28:12] to public safety. Towards the end of the month, Tracy took her case
[28:17] to Parliament, submitting a petition adorned with fifty eight thousand signatures in support of
[28:22] Christie's Law. Additionally, she appealed for the renaming of the aforementioned bill to
[28:27] Christie's Law, asserting that a mere numerical reference lacked the significance and commemoration that
[28:33] a victim deserved. Tracy emphasized an amendment number holds no meaning by renaming it,
[28:41] She and those who came before her will forever be remembered and honored for
[28:45] their sacrifice. Alarming statistics revealed that over a span of five years, twenty
[28:52] three individuals were convicted of murders committed while on bail, with an additional twenty
[28:56] one found guilty of homicide related offenses is committed during their release. These offenses
[29:03] encompassed manslaughter, attempted murder, and driving causing death. Shockingly, nearly seventy
[29:10] thousand defenders committed new crimes subsequent to their release on bail. In September,
[29:15] Chan made a court appearance pleading guilty to charges of kidnapping Christie, making threats
[29:21] of grievous bodily harm, and intending to sexually violate her. This change in
[29:26] play occurred following psychological assessments which concluded that at the time of the abduction,
[29:33] Chan did not definitively meet the legal criteria for insanity. If you're a fan
[29:40] of enthralling mysteries filled with unexpected twists, then look no further than June's Journey.
[29:45] This captivating game offers a perfect blend of intrigue and classicoot on it elements
[29:51] in June's Journey, You'll team up with a charismatic amateur detective June Parker,
[29:55] as you delve into a quest to unravel the truth behind her sister's tragic murder
[29:59] and ravel some long held family secrets. With meticulously crafted scenes numbering over one
[30:06] thousand, your keen observation skills will be put to the test as you search
[30:10] for concealed clues and vital information. Immerse yourself in the opulence and allure of
[30:15] the nineteen twenties thanks to June's Journeys, stunning graphics and captivating gameplay. Personally,
[30:21] I've been captivated by this mobile puzzle game for well over a year,
[30:25] often finding myself absorbed until the late hours of the night, using it as
[30:29] a way to unwind and relax before bed. A standout feature of June's Journey
[30:33] is the ability to personalize your very own island estate and collaborate with the Detective
[30:37] Club, where you can join forces with like minded sleuths. Can you Crack
[30:42] the Case? Download June's Journey for free on iOS and Android. The subsequent
[30:51] month saw Chand return to court for sentencing. Prior to delivering the sentence,
[30:56] Judge Helen Winkelman acknowledge the immense impact of his action not only on Christie,
[31:00] but also on her entire family, who still grappled with fear for their safety
[31:07] despite having relocated to Australia. Judge Winckelman remarked, your intention was to terrorize
[31:12] Christie and you succeeded. Initially considering a starting point of five years, the
[31:19] judge subsequently deduced two years from the sentence, taking into account chance clean record,
[31:26] his mental illness, and his guilty plea. Consequently, Chan received a
[31:32] three year sentence, with the stipulation that he served as a special patient in
[31:37] a secure mental health facility. However, during the sentencing proceedings, it was
[31:42] revealed the chance plea of insanity for Christie's murder had been accepted. Two psychiatric
[31:48] experts, one appointed by the defense and another by the prosecution, had examined
[31:55] Chan and independently concluded that he suffered from schizophrenic psychosis at the time of the
[32:00] murder. With a bleak prospect of recovery. John's mantel state had deteriorated drastically
[32:07] jansforming a once healthy and intelligent young man into someone plagued by delusions. He
[32:15] firmly believed that he had cervical cancer and claimed to hear the voice of a
[32:20] girl named Pauline in his head, who commanded him to kill Christie, who
[32:23] he believed to be possessed by the devil. Furthermore, Chand admitted that the
[32:29] letter he wrote to the judge appealing for beale in the kidnapping case was merely
[32:34] a ploy to secure his release from jail so that he could execute his plan
[32:37] to end Christie's life, a plan he had formulated while incarcerated. Following Chan's
[32:45] arrest, he divulged to detectives that he had knowledge of an acquaintance planning to
[32:50] commit two additional murders, but he refused to disclose the person's identity. However,
[32:55] in a subsequent interview, he revealed that the acquaintances none other than paul
[33:00] Leane, the voice inside his head. The psychiatric experts assigned to evaluate Chant
[33:07] concluded that his actions were influenced by schizophrenic psychosis, rendering him unaware of the
[33:13] moral wrongness of his deeds. Professor Graham Melsop, who examined Chan, attested
[33:19] to the authenticity of his insanity, starting if you had Sigmund Freud and Richard
[33:24] Burton rolled into one. They could not have portrayed schizophrenia as convincingly. Doctor
[33:30] David Chaplow, who was hired by the defense, further affirmed the Chan lacked
[33:36] moral comprehension and insight induced culpability at the time of the crime. Upon acceptance
[33:42] of the insanity plea, Justice Winckelmann ordered Chan's detention in a secure psychiatric facility
[33:47] for treatment. He would remain detained until the Minister of Health deemed him no
[33:52] longer a public threat. Prosecutor Simon Murry made it clear that the insanity verdict
[33:59] should not be miss construed as Chant getting off lightly. He emphasized that the
[34:04] detention was indefinite with no specified end. The sole condition for his release was
[34:09] the Minister of Health satisfaction the chand no longer posed a risk to the public.
[34:15] More stress, the absence of winners in this deeply tragic case, stating
[34:21] at every level, this is a desperately tragic case. It's horrible. Nobody
[34:25] can leave the courtroom feeling like it's a great outcome, but under the circumstances,
[34:30] it's probably the best resolution we could have reached. In the aftermath of
[34:49] the determination that Chand was not guilty by reason of insanity, Christie's family experienced
[34:54] profound devastation. They maintained their conviction the Chant was in a murderer. Regardless
[35:00] of the verdict. Brian expressed their anguish, staring to us, he will
[35:07] always be Christie's murderer, and in our eyes he will always be guilty.
[35:12] I can't reconcile somebody being both guilty and not guilty at the same time.
[35:17] Undeterred, the family vowed to persist in their crusade. The whole judge is
[35:21] accountable. An advocate for stricter bial laws, Tracy asserted, we firmly believe
[35:28] that Christie should still be with us. She should be alive. Given all
[35:32] that it's transpired in court over the past couple of days, it strongly suggests
[35:37] that she was unjustly taken away from us. In twenty and thirteen, a
[35:42] shocking revelation emerged regarding Judge McNaughton, the judge who granted bail to Chant.
[35:49] It was uncovered that he had not been given the option of electronic bill despite
[35:53] instructions from another judge to assess its suitability for Chant. The procedure for electronic
[36:00] bale involves defendants wearing electronic bracelets that trigger and alarm with the police if they
[36:05] venture beyond designated areas. Had Chan been granted electronic baale, his departure from
[36:10] the home, that fateful mourning would have alerted the authorities immediately. Judge Barbara
[36:16] Morris, who had originally denied Chan's bale, had specifically requested a psychiatric assessment
[36:22] for him and recommended medication before considering bale again. However, court staff neglected
[36:30] to follow up on her request, and the transcript documenting her instruction was never
[36:34] sent. During the same year, Tracy expressed her dismay to Justice Minister Judith
[36:38] Collins over the retractive process of amending the Bill Act. Collins assured her that
[36:45] bolstering BIAL laws remained a priority and that the Bal Amendment Act had passed the
[36:51] Select committee stage, awaiting its second reading in Parliament. This legislative effort was
[36:58] notably prompted by the introduction of Christie's Law. On the twenty ninth of August
[37:02] twenty and thirteen, the Bial Amendment Act finally passed into law with an overwhelming
[37:08] majority of one hundred and two votes to nineteen. The legislation mandated that individuals
[37:15] facing murder charges or multiple charges related to violence, drugs, or sex must
[37:21] convince a judge that their release would not jeopardize public safety. The passage of
[37:25] this bill was directly influenced by the advocacy surrounding Christie's law. Then, in
[37:31] December of that year, Chand became eligible for parole after serving his three years
[37:37] sentence for the kidnapping charge. However, his parole was denied by the Parole
[37:42] Board, citing his continued risk to community safety. While acknowledging his progress in
[37:47] addressing paranoid schizophrenia, the board still noted that he was not yet symped them
[37:52] free and still in the early stages of comprehending the connections between his illness,
[37:58] personality, and criminal behavior. Shortly thereafter, it was announced that a coroner's
[38:01] inquest was finally being held to look into the murder of Christie. The purpose
[38:07] of such an inquest is to investigate the wider circumstances surrounding at death to see
[38:12] whether something could have been done to prevent something similar happening again. The start
[38:17] of the inquest faced substantial delays, leaving Christie's family in a state of uncertainty
[38:22] and anguish. Tracy expressed their ongoing struggle and stated, we have never grieved
[38:30] properly because we know that we still have to reface the trauma of the day
[38:34] that Christie was killed at an inquest. The delays are cruel and have caused
[38:37] us great physical and emotional harm. Finally, in June of two seventeen,
[38:43] the much awaited inquest commenced, allowing Tracy and Bryan to deliver emotionally charged testimonies
[38:50] that she had lied on the miscommunication leading to Chance Bill. Tracy revealed the
[38:54] prior to his release, court advisor Andreas Wagger had called her indicating the Chant
[39:00] was likely to be granted bail. The absence of electronic monitoring upon his release
[39:06] left her devastated and Christy was left terrified. Brian took the stand next,
[39:13] recounting his conversation with Detective arn Armonger, the lead detective in the case.
[39:19] Brian shared he assured Tracy and me the police patrols were making frequent visits to
[39:23] Chance bail address to ensure the restrictions were being complied with. I admit that
[39:30] I believe this statement. The actions of the police were a deterrent. This
[39:35] obviously was not the case. I regret not being more critical and questioning how
[39:39] they could be so sure that the police were providing a secure cordon. The
[39:45] court also heard evidence regarding Judge Morris's request for electronic monitoring, but court manager
[39:51] Karl Learns testified that it was unclear whether Judge McNaughton, who granted Chant bail
[39:55] without monitoring, had access to the decision during chance subsequent baill hearing. Senior
[40:02] police prosecutor Adam Pell testified next and told the courtroom he was concerned to learn
[40:08] that Chant was going to be granted bail. He had vigorously opposed to his
[40:14] release after he heard Chance admissions to police that he wanted revenge against Christie because
[40:20] he felt as though she had wronged him. He was so concerned about the
[40:23] prospect of Chant being free that he spoke with the officers in charge of the
[40:27] case to request the full details of Chance statements be made available to prosecutors for
[40:32] the purpose of opposing bail. In an email the detective Armonger, he stated,
[40:38] I'm just curious as to high on earth someone with admissions with these kind
[40:43] of charges could possibly be bailed to that address. Detective Armonger testified next.
[40:50] He said he advised Tracy to be vigilant, to keep the doors locked and
[40:54] make the rest of the home secure. He commented, even though and was
[41:00] on curfew, he could probably still get there before police. He said that
[41:05] as soon as he was made aware that Chant was granted bail with relaxed conditions,
[41:08] he called up Tracy to apologize. According to Sergeant Rona Stass, the
[41:15] police prosecutor in charge of Chance file, Judge McNaughton was seemingly disinterested in police
[41:21] his concerns about Chance bail. She said that she was not given the opportunity
[41:25] to outline the police position on bail and essentially it was simply granted. She
[41:31] said. The judge was more focused on Chance treatment and the ability of mental
[41:37] health services to manage him at home. Startling revelations emerged during the inquest,
[41:43] shedding light on the mishandling of Chance case both before and after his arrest.
[41:47] One crucial detail that surfaced was the exclusion of psychiatrist Ian Goodwin's report from the
[41:53] court file despite his examination of Chant following the kidnapping incident. Doctor Goodwin's report,
[42:01] which branded Chant as a textbooks psychopath with no prospects of being granted beale
[42:07] mysteriously failed to make its way into the court records. While doctor Goodwin's assessment
[42:14] focused on chance fitness to stand trial rather than his eligibility for beale. Forensic
[42:20] nurse Ellen Wilson testified that she felt compelled to hardly complete her assessment as chance
[42:25] first hearing on the kidnapping charge loomed. Regrettably, her report did not reach
[42:30] the judge in time. A judak time constraints Suchita Chan's mother also testified during
[42:37] the inquest. She expressed her lack of awareness regarding the conditions of her son's
[42:43] bal She claimed that she had not been consulted regarding her ability or willingness to
[42:49] supervise him if he were to be released on beale to live at their home.
[42:53] Daring her frustration, she stated, neither the court nor the police provided
[42:59] me with any imation about the bail conditions or what was expected of me while
[43:04] Chand was still at home on bail. At no time I was given to
[43:07] understand that I had a responsibility to ensure the chant was supervised by an adult
[43:13] at my home twenty four seven because of my work commitments. There's no way
[43:17] I could have done that. The inquest laid bear a series of errors in
[43:22] chance hambling, including crucial admissions from the case file and the failure to bring
[43:28] important information to the attention of Judge McNaughton. At these details being included,
[43:34] there is a strong possibility that Bill would have been denied. Upon the conclusion
[43:38] of the inquest, Coroner Catherine Gregg released her findings calling for immediate action.
[43:46] She recommended that the chief executives of the Ministry of Justice and Corrections, along
[43:52] with the Police Commissioner, engaging consultations with key stakeholders to establish guidelines for bail
[43:58] applications involving serious offenses, particularly those warranting at twenty four R curfew. The
[44:05] inm was to ensure that evidence was presented to the court in a comprehensive and
[44:08] appropriate format for all similar applications. Additionally, she advocated for potential legislative amendments
[44:16] to be considered within the framework of these consultations, emphasizing the need for systematic
[44:23] changes to prevent similar oversights in the future. Another issue examined in the findings
[44:29] was chance psychotic stayed around the time of the murder which had alluded clinicians despite
[44:34] a dozen mental health checks. The coroner was satisfied that on the twelve occasions
[44:39] Chand was seen by a mental health professional in the lead up to the murder,
[44:44] he was appropriately assessed for psychosis. The issue was the Chant never admitted
[44:50] to the symptoms he was experiencing. She wrote, it is clear only with
[44:54] hindsight that mister Chand was so terribly dangerous to Christie because of psychiatric condition.
[45:01] In August of twenty and seven, it was reported in the media that Chant
[45:05] had been spotted in fast food restaurants and shops. He had been quietly granted
[45:09] escorted outings, and Christie's family hadn't even been made aware. After he was
[45:15] spotted by members of the public, the Health Board confirmed that he had been
[45:19] recently allowed escorted outings. It was devastagatting to Christie's family, who were assured
[45:25] that if he were ever granted leave, they would have been notified. However,
[45:30] there was a loophole in the Victim's Right Act, which meant that legally
[45:36] they only needed to be notified when the leave was unescorted. Dressy commented,
[45:42] after everything we have been through, this is another kick in the face.
[45:46] He's out there and people need to be extremely, extremely vigilant. I do
[45:52] believe that he is extremely dangerous. The story of Christy Marshau is a poignant
[45:59] tragedy that reverberates on multiple levels. It lays bare the glaring flaws within New
[46:06] Zealand's bale system that often put the perpetrator above the victim, but also shed
[46:10] light on the grave consequences of untreated mental illness. In the wake of Christie's
[46:16] death, however, her parents embarked on a bottle for justice, leading to
[46:22] a pivotal change in legislation. Through this transformative change, there emerges a glimmer
[46:29] of hope that the faith that befell Christie shall hopefully not befall another innocent victim
[46:55] while beasties. That is it for this episode of Morbidology. As always,
[47:00] thank you so so much for listening, and I'd like to say a massive
[47:04] thank you to my new supporters off on Patreon, Jannon Jordan and Emily.
[47:09] The support seriously goes such a long way and I am eternally grateful. If
[47:15] you'd like to support this one woman show. The link to Patreon is in
[47:17] the show notes in exchange for your support, I upload bonus episodes of more
[47:23] Biology plus that aren't on the regular podcast platforms. I also upload ad free
[47:29] and early release episodes behind the scenes, which includes bonus audio videos and case
[47:34] files. And I also send out a handwritten thank you card and some merch
[47:38] including stickers, T shirts, pens, badges, key chains, and fridge
[47:44] magnets. Remember to check us out at more bitology dot com for more information
[47:49] about this episode and to read our true crime articles. Until next time,
[47:52] take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week. Hello
[48:14] Twisted Humans. Do you find yourself wanting to know more about the latest murder,
[48:20] conspiracy, cult or haunting, then this is the podcast for you.
[48:23] In nineteen fifty two, there was a record high of UFOs reported fifteen hundred
[48:30] sightings. There has been evidence of human sacrifice, double warship, and it
[48:37] is haunted by more spirits than can be counted. A family of two adults
[48:42] and two kids reportedly saw a giant flying thing with glowing red eyes. And
[48:47] meanwhile the family is nanny that helped Veronica to care for her and Lucia's children,
[48:52] plus found bludgeoned to death in the basement of their family home. I'm
[48:57] Alicia and I'm Sierra and this is twisted and uncorked

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
