# 211: Lola James

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 3 Jul 2023, 57 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/54051432/morbidology_211_lola_james.mp3

It is a parents duty to ensure the safety and well-being of their child. This includes exercising the utmost caution when it comes to welcoming people into the home. Unfortunately, some parents put their own needs before the safety of their children, and in Haverfordwest, Pembrokeshire, Wales, in July 2020, a disturbing incident highlighted this harsh reality. SPONSORS - 4Patriots: Thank you to 4Patriots for sponsoring this episode! With hurricane season fast approaching, it’s time to prepare with 4Patriot’s emergency food packages. Use the code “MORBIDOLOGY” for 10% off: https://4patriots.com/ SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-111-lola-james/ PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:34] The patient awake. You know she's it's two year old that's fallen down the
[0:38] stace. She's unconscious. They can't wake her up. It is apparents Judy.
[0:55] You ensure the safety and well being of their child. This include exercising
[1:00] the utmost caution when it comes to welcoming people into the home. Unfortunately,
[1:04] however, some parents put their own needs before the safety of their children,
[1:10] and in Haverford West, Pembrokeshire, Wales, in July of two thousand and
[1:14] twenty, a disturbing incident highlighted this harsh reality. Lula James was born in
[1:30] Haverford West to parents Stan and she Needed James on the thirtieth of September two
[1:36] thousand and seventeen. She had two half siblings, an older one born in
[1:40] two thousand and fourteen and a younger one born in two thousand and nineteen.
[1:45] Despite the challenges that come with being a middle child, Lula's personality shone through.
[1:52] She was known for her bubbly and cheerful demeanor and loved staying up late
[1:56] to watch her favorite movie Frozen. Grandmother Nichol recalled how she gave the best
[2:01] hugs and had a beautiful singing voice. She loved making up dances on the
[2:07] spot, especially to Rihanna's song Diamonds. Her mischievous never failed to put a
[2:13] smile on everybody's face, and she loved playing with her dolls. Her happy
[2:17] place was outside, where she loved keeping an eye out for bees and butterflies.
[2:23] Her father Dan said of her her laugh would fill the room with pure
[2:28] joy. Unfortunately, the relationship between Dan and she Need wasn't to last,
[2:32] and she Need began to date another man named Stephen Harris, who didn't treat
[2:37] her very well. In January of two thousand and Twansy, the family was
[2:42] visited by a health visitor, Leslie Steedman, who raised concerns about the homes
[2:46] cluttered and dirty conditions. Lula appeared to be unkemped and she had dirty fate.
[2:53] She Need raised concerns over Lula's tantrums. She shared her belief that her
[2:59] young daughter may have ADHD and said that she often threw items at her and
[3:04] behaved difficult. Leslie had concerns about she Need's ability to stay on top of
[3:09] home conditions, and she offered her support. Leslie agreed to make another visit,
[3:15] which came in February. This was the last time that Leslie saw she
[3:20] needed lowla face to face due to the coronavirus lockdown. She had attempted a
[3:25] few more appointments afterwards, but she Need never picked up the phone and she
[3:29] ignored any letters that were sent out. She also sought help from Wendy Rodriguez,
[3:37] a team manager at Pembrokeshire Council's Childcare Assessment Team. She had to complete
[3:42] interventions as part of a protection plan that included the Freedom Program, which offered
[3:47] supporting guidance for victims of domestic abuse and to help them recognize domestic abusers in
[3:53] the future. By this stage, she Need had broken up with Stephen and
[3:59] she met a new man over Facebook, Kyle Bevan. Did you struck up
[4:03] a relationship? Within just weeks, he had moved into the family home on
[4:10] Princess Royal Way. On the morning of the seventeenth of July two thousand and
[4:40] twenty nine, call came in from a woman named Alison Bevan. She was
[4:46] Kyle's mother, and she reported that her son had informed her that Lula had
[4:49] fallen down the stairs and was unconscious patient awake. You know she's a's two
[4:57] year old that's fallen down the day. She's unconscious. They can't wait her
[5:00] up. And then, okay, tell me exactly what's happened a two year
[5:04] olds. She's got ADHD. She's falling from top to bottom of the stairs.
[5:11] They can't wake her up. And then she's dipped the end of her
[5:14] tone because they're not sure if she's fitted, but she's flopped beef. They
[5:17] can't wake her up. And you're not with a patient now, and there's
[5:23] a patient. They've just rung me because I've got credit on my phone to
[5:27] ring an ambulance. Now. They said they can ring credit. They don't
[5:30] need credit to ring an ambulance. Oh they didn't. They panicked, they
[5:32] think so. And when did this happen this morning? I don't know the
[5:38] exact time. This must have just happened because they what caused the fall.
[5:44] So the trial woke up and she's falling down the stairs. Apparently she's a
[5:48] very serious bleeding. No, it's just a massive lump on the head.
[5:54] Calver told his mother that he had been awake all night watching UFC videos on
[5:59] YouTube when he saw Lola was awake in the early morning hours He said that
[6:03] he went to make some coffee when he saw her standing at the top of
[6:08] the stairs. Kyl said he asked Lola wherever she wanted some cereal, and
[6:13] she said yes. He recalled, I could hear footsteps on the sailing upstairs,
[6:19] and the next thing I heard was two or three massive bangs. Boom,
[6:24] boom, boom. He said that he ran out to find Lola had
[6:27] been knocked on the stairs by the family's American bulldog, Jesse. He stated,
[6:33] I thought she was out cold. I waited to say if she came
[6:38] around. I knew I shouldn't have. I realized she was snoring, and
[6:43] that's choking on your tongue. I put my hands in her mouth in a
[6:46] shade for her to chew on, so she would and chew her tongue.
[6:49] A bit of her tongue had come off a bit of chunk at the end.
[6:56] Shortly after Alison's phone call, another phone call came in to police from
[7:00] Lula's mother. She needed, okay, it's a patient to wakes not she's
[7:09] not. He's going to Okay, tell you exactly what's happened. There,
[7:15] Come my partner, because I was in bed. Who's up with it.
[7:19] Okay. She's falling down the stairs right, okay, from the top of
[7:26] the stairs to the bottom, and her head's all swollen and at the top
[7:30] of her tongue off, wasn't okay? Okay? How old is she too?
[7:46] I don't don't exactly got gonstand okay, So just to confay this,
[7:55] she conscious? Is she conscious? I don't even Yeah, she's conscious.
[7:59] She's pretty sleeping. So does she wake up when you respond? When you
[8:05] try to wake her? She's like moves when she do we try to wake
[8:09] about okay, really, it's good, okay. How far did she for?
[8:18] What the top of the stas? Okay? What caused the for the
[8:24] dogs that I had it bad? So it's just fut Okay. Is there
[8:28] any serious reading? Kyla's very seriously then it's very seriously no, okay,
[8:39] just just bruising in their heads. Also that the okay, So say on
[8:43] the line to know exactly what to do next. Do not move her unless
[8:46] she's in danger, and do not splint any injuries. Can I yeah,
[8:52] it's lowly, ja, don't move it. With sirens blazing, paramedics rush
[8:58] to the families home, where they found Lola motionless on the sofa curiously,
[9:03] she appeared to be soaking wet. Lula was rushed twify Bush General Hospital.
[9:11] While doctors were tending to her, Kyl was becoming agitated and hostile towards doctor
[9:16] Nicola Drake. She asked him some pretty generic questions about what happened to Lula,
[9:22] and he demanded to know whether the answers he gave would be confidential or
[9:26] not, if what had happened to Lula was an accident, and why would
[9:31] it matter if his answers were confidential. Doctor Drake replied that she had a
[9:37] statutory judy and that his answers were to be shared with external agencies such as
[9:41] social services. For one stage, Kyl became threatening and shouted at doctor Drake,
[9:48] if you take one step out of this room with those notes, I'll
[9:52] rip them out of your hands. Doctor Drake feared for her life. She
[9:58] stood up and said to Kyle that the police were going to be called,
[10:01] to which he replied, ha police. Back In the emergency room, it
[10:07] was discovered that Lola had sustained a number of brutal injuries, including bruises to
[10:13] her face, body, limbs, and even puncture wounds to her forehead.
[10:18] The most fatal injury, however, was a catastrophic head injury. She had
[10:24] sustained a total of one hundred and one external injuries, including damage to both
[10:30] of her eyes. The doctor's like and Lola's injuries to the candy would see
[10:35] in people involved in high speed car crashes or falls from great heights. They
[10:39] said that they were in no way consistent with an accidental fall like was claimed.
[10:45] Doctor Deborah Stalker, consultant pediatrician, said that the injuries to Lola's brain
[10:50] and eyes were explained by abusive head trauma, which would include violent shaking.
[10:56] Lola bore all the hallmarks of an abused child and the police were immediately contacted
[11:01] by staff at the hospital. Meanwhile, Lula was transported to Noah's Ark Children's
[11:07] Hospital in Cardiff. Detectives returned to the family home to analyze it and speak
[11:15] with Kyle. He told the same story that he had said before, that
[11:20] Lula had been knocked on the stairs by the dog boy waiting little one.
[11:28] I don't want to how good I didn't go that. Ed's the only thing
[11:37] right, be honest, if you passion he responsible for it to Suay,
[11:39] I was making it making he brought to do this back. Upon entering the
[11:46] home, detectives were immediately taken aback by how messy it was. There were
[11:50] toys, clutter, and food all throughout the home, as well as plates,
[11:56] cups and cutlery. There were used nappies and clothing littering every single floor.
[12:03] Lola's bedroom was in the same condition. Her bed had a grubby duvet
[12:07] cover that was stained with urine and crusted. However, in the bathroom,
[12:13] the bathtub had been scrubbed clean. It stood in a stark contrast to the
[12:16] rest of the home. Detectives continued searching the home and hidden in the corner
[12:24] of the living room, they found Lola's wet and vomit and blood stained gray
[12:28] onesie. In the washing machine. They found curtains in a shape. The
[12:35] findings were very ominous and suggested that not all was right in the family's household.
[12:41] As they continued in their search at the home, Kyle and Jinnide were
[12:46] texting one another. Kyle said the police suspected both him and her of harming
[12:50] Lola. Jeannie responded that he needed to calm down and the police were just
[12:56] doing their job. When it became him apparent to Kyl, the police were
[13:01] indeed suspicious of his claims. He texted, she Need. They're doing an
[13:07] investigation into harm to the child, and then we hade some reference about how
[13:11] police can manipulate children. Sometime later, Kyle texted, she need once more.
[13:18] We haven't hurt that girl. They can see that. She Need replied,
[13:24] they can do whatever they want. They can do their jobs, and
[13:26] I'll even let them do it. She's my princess. Kyl responded, telling
[13:31] she need he tried everything to bring Lula back around. He said that he
[13:37] would never hurt Lula, before adding neither would you. I know, babe,
[13:43] Lula loves you and she's got a love hate thing with me. Loll
[13:48] back. At the hospital, doctors continued to work on Lula, and while
[13:52] this was ongoing, Kyle message she Need that they needed to tell police the
[13:56] same story. He asked, well, what are you going to say?
[14:03] She needed? This is important, like she Need replied, what you told
[14:07] me. Kyle responded, yeah, obviously, but you've got to get a
[14:13] bang on like she needed for Fox's sake, like she Need texted back,
[14:18] well, I am saying exactly what you told me. I can remember what
[14:22] you said from word to word. Detective strongly believed that the family home was
[14:28] a crime scene, and they informed she Need that they were boarding it up
[14:31] to prevent contamination. In a clear display of a lack of emotion, Kyle
[14:37] texted she Need, how are we both going to go to sleep and chill
[14:41] later? However, neither Kyle nor she Need had to worry about that.
[14:48] Four thirty pm, they were both arrested on suspicion of assault and neglect.
[14:54] At the police station, they were both interviewed. Kyle described Lola as accident
[14:58] prone and said to detectives, she's a nutcase, an idiot, protesting her
[15:03] for ADHD in autism. She's got no fear man. She always falls and
[15:09] smacks her face or lacks awareness it always happens to her. And she's too
[15:15] small. Like the reference to bruise on her nose, and commented, she's
[15:20] only two and she's made of steel. Man. That bruise on her nose
[15:22] was healing very well. I've seen adult healing not so quickly. Fair play
[15:28] to her. At first, she Need did stick to the same story that
[15:33] Kyle had told her, that Lola had been knocked on the stairs by their
[15:35] dog. However, in a later interview, she added something else. She
[15:41] said that after she went to sleep the night before, she heard a loud
[15:46] bang and a scream. About midnight, she got up and saw Kyle in
[15:50] Lula's bedroom. Kyle said to her, I've got this and she need said
[15:56] to detectives. She didn't want to cause a scene, so she glimbilly went
[16:00] back to sleep. When Kyle was informed of this, he first of all
[16:03] denied it before saying that was when he was changing Lula's bed sheets and she
[16:08] fell from the ladder of her bunk bed onto the floor. Four days later,
[16:14] Lula died at hospital. Her autopsy was performed by doctor Stephen led Better,
[16:19] who listed her cause of death a sub joural hematoma and swelling of the
[16:25] brain. He disputed Kyle's claims that Lula's injuries were caused by falling down the
[16:30] stairs. He stated, I do not consider that the account given to date
[16:36] of how Lula James came to be injured can be regarded as a complete explanation
[16:41] for the findings on her body. I cannot accept that the totality of injuries
[16:45] has arisen from a fall down the stairs. In the wake of Lola's death,
[17:11] her father Don Thomas released a statement through police which read, in part,
[17:15] from the first time I met my beautiful daughter, Lola Patricia James,
[17:19] my heart was filled with such joy, a happiness I'd never felt before,
[17:25] an unconditional love and need to always protect her for the rest of her life.
[17:30] Not in a million years did I think her life would be snatched away
[17:33] from her in such a cruel way. All the things she never had a
[17:37] chance to learn, see or say, and all the things I will never
[17:41] have a chance to teach her to write her name, ride a bike,
[17:45] or drive a car. Lola, you have left a hole in the heart
[17:49] of everyone you met. Don also thanked all of the staff at the hospital
[17:53] for their hard work and attempting to say of Lola's life. His mother,
[17:59] Nicola James, followed suit and provided her own tribute for Lola. She too
[18:03] thanked all of the staff at the hospital and thanked the community for their support.
[18:08] The family now had the heartbreaking task of arranging Lola's funeral. It took
[18:15] place at Saint David and Saint Patrick's Church. Following the service, the hearse
[18:19] traveled through Milford Haven before traveling to Captain James Hill, through Front Street and
[18:25] North Road and then across Marble Hall to Thornton Cemetery, where she was buried.
[18:32] The family had asked the public to clap chair or release a balloon as
[18:34] the hearse passed through in celebration of Lola's short life. Unfortunately, Lola's family
[18:41] couldn't afford a headstone, but Dan and his partner launched a fundraiser on go
[18:47] fund me, which quickly reached its seven thousand pound goal. There were a
[18:52] handful of pushbacks in the case due to the coronavirus. Both Kyl and Jinnied
[18:57] were granted beale while they investigator was ongoing, but in April of two thou
[19:03] and twenty two, they were both re arrested. Gyl was charged with the
[19:07] murder of Lola, while she Need was charged with causing or laying her death.
[19:11] She Need was expected to get bail, but it was decided she would
[19:15] be remanded in custody for her own safety. They both pleaded not guilty to
[19:21] the charges against them, and both denied that thead harmed Lula. According to
[19:26] Shaneede, she was asleep when the injury was sustained, and her defense attorney
[19:30] David Elias, said she had no reason to believe Kyle Bevan would behave in
[19:34] a way that he is alleged towards Lola. She need was then released on
[19:40] conditional bail, and shortly thereafter it was decided that she and Kyle should stand
[19:44] trial together and it was scheduled from March of two thousand and twenty three.
[19:49] While both Kyle and Shinnied vehemently denied any wrongdoing, an investigation uncovered the disturbing
[19:56] truth about Lola's home environment. Relationship between the couple was tumultuous, characterized by
[20:03] a Kyle's aggressive outbursts that only worsened as the relationship progressed. His temper was
[20:10] amplified by his regular use of controlled substances, especially amphetamines. Both Janeede and
[20:18] Kyle were on benefits, but instead of searching for a job or spending the
[20:22] benefits on necessities, they spent it mostly on alcohol and drugs. When Shaneede
[20:27] was away from the home, she left Lula in Kyle's care, and their
[20:32] Facebook messages highlighted the tumultuous relationship. In one message, Kyle wrote, come
[20:38] get your fucking child. You're being a fucking asshole. She need sly as
[20:44] fuck. I'm not bothering anymore. In another message, Shinide was angry that
[20:49] Kyle had seemingly kept Lula up into the early morning ours. She wrote,
[20:55] what's up with you? She needs to be in bed, it's four am.
[21:00] Cor responded, it was one fucking night, Schnade. She was falling
[21:03] asleep while playing and I was going to carry her up. I wanted to
[21:07] give her a cuddled sleep, but you fucked it up. Their conversations over
[21:12] time exposed a disturbing pattern of injuries to Lula. On the tenth of April
[21:18] two and twenty, Cow messaged she needed to say that Lula had suffered a
[21:22] bloody nose while he was in a different room. He commented that it could
[21:27] have been worse, and he hoped that the injury would teach Lula not to
[21:30] play on the stairs. Around a week later, a coyl centineered a photograph
[21:36] of Lola with the gravest chin, and he referred to her as a crazy
[21:40] kid and said that she had fallen over. On the nineteenth of April,
[21:45] he messaged she neade again, writing she smashed her face again. I've said
[21:49] about them stairs and leaving toys at the bottom of them loads of times.
[21:55] If that jar would have smashed, she'd never looked the same again. Then,
[21:59] on the worth of May, Kyle told she Need that Lula had caught
[22:02] her lip. He said that she had fallen off her bed and bit her
[22:06] lip when he had gone into her bedroom after hearing her crying. He wrote,
[22:11] then, when I was trying to help her because she was bleeding,
[22:15] she was making a stupid noise and kicking right off you, spitting at me
[22:19] and making a horrible noise. The whole thing upset me a bit. I
[22:23] only wanted to help her. I feel useless, and I feel like you
[22:29] don't trust me at all anymore. It was clear from the messages that something
[22:33] sinister was happening inside the family's home, and she Need must have had her
[22:37] suspicions. Despite this, she Need continued to keep Lula in that environment,
[22:42] exposing her to a significant risk of violence at the hands of Kyle. In
[22:48] fact, she Need had called her daughter all kinds of horrible names in the
[22:52] messages between her and Kyle. She had referred to Lula as a pain in
[22:56] the ars, a terror, and a little bitch in another message. She
[23:03] need wrote to Kyle, I've told everyone there's something not right with her.
[23:07] Kyle responded, Lola's a challenge, but not a bad kid. Lula will
[23:14] learn, babe, but she won't learn without routine. It worked with me.
[23:22] Did you know that hurricane season is fast approaching, which means it's time
[23:26] to prepare now. Hurricane and Ida's impact on the Gulf Coast serves as a
[23:30] stark reminder of the devastation it can cause. Countless homes were destroyed, leaving
[23:34] numerous people without access to essential resources such as food and clean water. Millions
[23:41] experience prolonged power outages and during weeks without electricity. The subsequent flooding resulted in
[23:47] road damage, hindering grocery stores from replenishing their supplies. To ensure your readiness,
[23:52] consider obtaining emergency food kits from four Patriots. These kids are unpacked in
[23:59] the United States and boast of a shelf life of up to twenty five years.
[24:03] They offer a diverse selection of breakfasts, lunches, and dinners to meet
[24:07] your dietary needs. While these survival food kits are crucial during natural disasters such
[24:12] as hurricanes, their significance extends far beyond such events. In today's world,
[24:18] characterized by uncertain supply chains and unpredictable emergencies, having a backup plan is more
[24:25] crucial than ever. And right now you can go to four Patriots dot com
[24:29] and use the code morbidology to get ten percent of your first purchase on anything
[24:33] in the store, including their emergency food supply kits designed to last up to
[24:38] twenty five years. Just head on over to four Patriots dot com and use
[24:42] the code morbidology to get ten percent off your first purchase of four Patriots survival
[24:48] food that is four Patriots dot com and use the code morbidology. Other people
[24:56] outside of the family recognize signs possible abuse. According to Casey Morgan, who
[25:03] was a friend if she Need, she had noticed Bruce's to Lola's leg when
[25:07] she was playing in the park in early July, and had later noticed that
[25:11] she had a nose injury and bruises to her eyes. When she was on
[25:15] a video call, she told her that Lola had fallen off the sofa and
[25:19] onto the coffee table. Casey never liked Kyle, and she believed that he
[25:25] was controlling towards she need. Controlling he certainly was. He had moved into
[25:30] the family home quickly and had taken she Neede's house, Kay and her debit
[25:33] cards. He often locked her out of the home and invited other people around.
[25:40] Casey also knew that Kyle often took amphetamines and other controlled drugs and drank
[25:45] heavily. She commented, I didn't like him. I made that clear to
[25:49] Sneed. I told her to get rid of him and that I didn't want
[25:53] him around my house or my kids. When Kyle was on drugs, he
[25:59] would fly into ray and trashed the families home. Lola began to stay regularly
[26:03] with Casey or with Kyle's mother, Nicola, when kyl was on drugs.
[26:08] On occasion, Casey witnessed Kyle being verbally abusive towards she Need, and said
[26:14] that when Lola stayed over, she cried that she didn't want to go home.
[26:18] Casey said of the family's home, it was dirty and horrible. Lula
[26:23] didn't want to go home. She was screaming she didn't want to go home.
[26:29] In early July, she Need had asked to come over to Casey's home,
[26:33] but Kyle arrived before her. She described how he was foaming at the
[26:37] mouth and his pupils word dilated. She recalled, he was aggressive and it
[26:44] was really scary. That day, she Need admitted to Casey and her partner
[26:48] that Kyle had threatened to rape her that morning. Casey said, from that
[26:53] day I knew something bad was going to happen. I told her that if
[26:59] she didn't get rid of him, he was going to hurt her. On
[27:03] the ninth of July, she Need and Kyle brought Lola to Casey's home.
[27:07] Casey's grandmother, al Fair Morgan was there at the time. They were in
[27:11] the kitchen, and she Need asked them to look at Lula's nose because she
[27:15] was worried that it was broken. Lula stood in front of them, and
[27:19] her nose was purple with a dark bruise. El Fair then noticed that there
[27:25] were bruises to Lula's neck that looked as though somebody had grabbed her round the
[27:29] neck. Alfare suggested that Lula be seen by a doctor, but Kyle replied,
[27:36] we don't need to do that. She need them boded in and said
[27:38] that they had already sought medical advice. Al Fair thought that it was strange
[27:44] that Kyle said one thing while she need, said another, but it was
[27:48] left at that she needed. Kyle and Lola left, but later that evening
[27:53] they returned when Casey was alone. Casey told them that they needed to take
[27:59] Lola to A and E, but Kyle responded that his mother was a nurse
[28:03] and that she said it was okay. Casey described Lola as being withdrawn and
[28:08] upset, and not her normal, bubbly self. Casey's former partner, Mark
[28:14] John had observed injuries to Lola as well in the weeks leading up to her
[28:18] death. He had seen that she had a black eye and was told by
[28:22] Kyle that had been caused by the dog knocking her off the sofa. The
[28:26] home that the family lived in was unkempt. Every single room was covered in
[28:30] clutter, toys, food, and clothing. John James, she needs cousin,
[28:37] had even warned her that they needed to tidy the blaze up or they
[28:40] risked Social services becoming involved. Kyle was furious with the suggestion. As Sean
[28:47] recalled, he became aggravated and began swearing. I believed he was pacing back
[28:52] and forth. On the night of the sixteenth of July two thousand and Twinsy
[29:27] she need went to bed, leaving Lola downstairs with Kyle. The evening appeared
[29:33] to be off to a relatively normal start based on evidence found on Kyle's mobile
[29:37] phone. He took pictures of Lola awake and conscious, and had made searches
[29:42] on his phone for robe blocks. Then at four twenty six am the next
[29:48] morning, he took pictures of Lola where red marks could be seen on her
[29:52] body, although she was still awake and conscious. Then at sixty eighteen am,
[29:57] he googled amazing three D tattoos. But then at six thirty two am,
[30:03] he googled child and had injuries. One search term was my two year
[30:08] old has just taken a bang to the head and has gone all limp and
[30:12] snoring. What's wrong. His search history also included a visit to the website
[30:18] health children dot org and specifically looked up loss of consciousness. At six thirty
[30:25] nine am, Kyle took two more pictures of Lola where insignificant swelling could be
[30:29] seen to her head. He golden massaged his mother, Alison, who's a
[30:33] healthcare worker. When she awoke to the messages, she told Kyle he needed
[30:38] to wake up, chinned and get Lola to hospital because she could have a
[30:42] concussion or a bleed on the brain. After the messages, Kyle got out
[30:48] his mobile phone and hit the record button. As he tried to prop Lula
[30:52] up, her body was limp and her head was evidently swollen. He lifted
[30:57] up Lola, who was unresponsive, and tried to place her on her fate
[31:02] to get her to stand up. He then let her go, and a
[31:04] thud could be heard as Lola fell to the ground. Kyl then placed Lola
[31:11] on the sofa, where she could be heard making a snoring sound. He
[31:15] could be heard commenting, she's gone, She's gone. Kyl then send this
[31:22] twenty two second recording to his mother, Alison. She told him that he
[31:26] needed to call an ambulance immediately because she could have a bleed on the brain.
[31:32] He waited a further thirty minutes before once more contacting his mother and asking
[31:37] her to phone an ambulance. He claimed that his phone couldn't make calls.
[31:42] At seven twenty nine am, Alison called nine nine nine and said she was
[31:47] calling because her son didn't have credit. It was around this time that Kyle
[31:52] finally woke she needed up. He woke her up and said that Lola had
[31:56] fallen down the stairs. Disturbingly, he presented her with a piece of Lula's
[32:02] tongue that she had bitten off at some stage. She need recalled, Lulu
[32:07] was on the sofa and her head was swollen and her lips kyl told me
[32:12] she fell down the stairs. He said the dog pushed her and barged her.
[32:16] Just one minute after, Alison called nine nine nine, so did she
[32:20] need? She was audibly upset as she told them that her daughter had taken
[32:23] a fall on the stairs and that she was breathing but not responding. When
[32:30] paramedics arrived and transported Lola to the hospital, Alison texted her son to tell
[32:35] him that he had done nothing wrong and that he needed to stay calm as
[32:38] she need needed him. Other family members arrived at the home as they were
[32:45] made aware of the unfolding situation inside. They were all taken back by the
[32:50] state of the family's home. She Needs aunt Lynda Hughes commented on the possibility
[32:55] of social services becoming involved because of the situation. She recalled, Kyle turned
[33:01] and became really aggressive. It was something along the lines of, don't you
[33:07] fucking come in here after what I've just gone through while Kyl was in an
[33:12] aggressive mood. She need was said to be hysterical and crying and begging him
[33:16] to come down. Linda said he was there wanting to be a big man,
[33:22] wanting to shout and argue. After Kyl was arrested, he was asked
[33:28] why it had taken him so long to ring an ambulance. He responded,
[33:32] I had to stop or cheering on her tongue, put her on the sofa,
[33:37] put her clothes on, and put the dog out. I sat next
[33:39] to her and prayed. Really gy was then asked why he didn't wake she
[33:45] need up. He replied, I didn't want her to wake up with a
[33:50] dead child, but the inevitable happened anyway. I thought she was going to
[33:53] come around. The detective then asked Carl why he didn't go to a neighbor
[33:59] for some help, help since he claimed he couldn't call nine nine nine.
[34:01] He responded, it was five in the morning, Tracy, the neighbor would
[34:07] have punched my head in met. The detective then asked, five in the
[34:12] morning, did you need to get help at five in the morning. Kyle
[34:16] replied that he was just making a point that it was early over in the
[34:21] other interrogation room, she Nate was telling detectives how Lula had two left fate
[34:25] and how Kyle was amazing with her. She denied that he was ever abusive
[34:30] towards her, despite the fact she was constantly harmed when he was alone with
[34:34] her. She said the detectives, She's got two left fate. She's hyperactive.
[34:40] I've been telling the health visitor there's something wrong with her and she needs
[34:44] to be tested for ADHD and autism. She constantly slips and falls over literally
[34:51] and gets up and smiles and laughs. She tries to jump off walls,
[34:54] and I need to grab her. I wish I was awake, and wish
[34:58] I could have stopped it and helped her. I wish I was there for
[35:01] her, and I didn't know. I wish I could have been there.
[35:06] She Need was then confronted by detectives who said, every time your children get
[35:12] injured, it's always Kyle round. Why is that? As detectives had learned
[35:17] she Need's youngest daughter had been harmed when she was being cared for by Kyle
[35:22] as well. She too had allegedly hit her head on the coffee table,
[35:27] and had also allegedly been knocked over by the dog. The detective said that
[35:30] she Need, You've got three kids there under the age of ten, they're
[35:36] at risk. She Need replied, I know, I'm horrified. The detective
[35:43] then said it's happened when Kyle has been around the children, But you feel
[35:46] to do anything about that, haven't you? Your children are getting harmed?
[35:52] She made them proceeded to say that Kyle took a bomb of aumpherdomine's once a
[35:55] week, smoked cannabis every day, and took zannak two or three times instead.
[36:00] It made him go off his head. She said that he had hit
[36:05] her lamp, punched her walls, and then took a hammer to the light
[36:07] switch. She was then asked whether she allowed Kyle to take drugs in the
[36:12] house with the children present, and she replied that he wasn't allowed to take
[36:16] it in front of her children, but instead in another room or outside.
[36:22] While she had denied the Kyle had abused her, detectives presented the text message
[36:28] from her to Kyle, in which she said, you've been abusing me,
[36:31] get out now, offering the police if you carry on. She admitted that
[36:37] when Kyle blamed their dog for a lot of the injuries to the children.
[36:42] She had never once seen their dog knocked the children over or jump at them.
[36:46] She need Have soon enough changed her tune, and she admitted to detectives
[36:51] the cow was controlling. She further said that he refused to comply with the
[36:55] Claire's Law request for information, which discloses the other a partner has an abusive
[37:00] past. He had said that she need I don't have to give it to
[37:06] you. They won't find anything on me. Despite the fact that he had
[37:09] refused to comply, she need still welcomed him into her home and had trusted
[37:15] him to care for her children. She said the detectives, I'm too scared
[37:21] to leave him. I don't like confrontation. I don't like intimidation. I'm
[37:27] petrified, I really am. I'm scared he'll whack me in Lola and I
[37:31] will have no one then. She need then admitted that over the course of
[37:36] her relationship with Kyle, she had begun taking umphetamines as well. She maintained
[37:43] that she hadn't taken any for a week when Loudo was killed. She said,
[37:47] I used to drink more. I never used to take drugs at all
[37:51] until I got with Kyle, I was dead, agains drugs and didn't drink
[37:54] as much as I was with Kyle. She was asked why she rank more,
[38:00] and she responded, I don't know, peer pressure because he was drinking
[38:06] and I thought I may as well drink with him. The atmosphere at Swansea
[38:36] cron Court was tense on the eighth of March twenty twenty three as Lula's loved
[38:40] ones arrived at the beginning of the trial. During opening stamens, Prosecutor Caroline
[38:45] Reese said that Kyle had subjected Lula to a brutal assault while he was alone
[38:51] with her between the evening of the sixteenth of July and the morning of the
[38:54] seventeenth July. She told the jury how he claimed he had found Lola at
[39:00] the bottom of the staircase after the family dog Jesse, had knocked her down
[39:04] the stairs. She then gave an overview of the case the prosecution had built,
[39:09] including the disturbing video of Lola after the brutal attack that cost her life.
[39:16] Prosecutor Race said again the prosecution asked the question if this really was an
[39:22] accident, while was cal Bevan spending time staging and recording like this rather than
[39:27] doing everything he could to contact the emergency services. She then focused on the
[39:32] dirty home, which stood in stark contrast to the spotless bathtub. She also
[39:39] spoke about the blood and vomit soaked onesie that was found and said it was
[39:44] evident that after Lola was beaten, cal had attempted to cover up his actions
[39:49] by putting Lola in the bathtub to clean off any blood and vomit, and
[39:53] then hiding her stained onesie. He then attempted to conceal the fact he had
[39:58] done this by scrubbing the bath This theory was further bolstered by the fact that
[40:02] when Lula came to hospital, temporary tattoos that she had been wearing had been
[40:07] scrubbed off. The prosecutor stated, we say that rather than face up to
[40:13] what he did to that little girl, Kalbevan immediately tried to see of himself.
[40:17] She further said that it was the prosecution's case that the injuries sustained by
[40:22] Lolla were inconsistent with an accidental injury and instead the result of a frenzied,
[40:29] brutal and violent attack at the hands of somebody. She should have been able
[40:32] to Trust Prosecutor Race then said that the jury accepted the claims that she Neede
[40:37] was asleep when the injuries were caused, but said that she must have been
[40:40] aware of the thread that Kyle posed to Lola due to the previous incidents against
[40:46] her. She stated, we do say that she was, or at least
[40:52] should have been well aware of the risk of violence which Kalbevan posed to her
[40:55] child, but she did nothing to protect Lola from the danger which he presented,
[41:00] instead choosing to prioritize her relationship with him over her own daughter's physical safety.
[41:07] She Needs friend Casey Morgan was among the first witnesses to testify. She
[41:12] told the courtroom about the tumultuous relationship between Kyle and she Need, and said
[41:16] that she had tried to encourage she Need to leave him. She said that
[41:21] she Need repeatedly called her for help when Kyle was on one of his benders
[41:24] and smashed up the home. Kyle's mother, Alison, also testified. She
[41:30] said that her son had been diagnosed with ADHD when he was six years old,
[41:35] and then described him as a bit thick. She told the court that
[41:39] she knew of one instance where Kyle had grabbed she need's arm, and she
[41:44] kicked him out. She testified about the photographs and the video that Kyle had
[41:47] sent her that morning and said, I could kick myself and that's what I've
[41:52] got to live with for the rest of my life. I should have acted
[41:55] quicker. She then revealed that she never actually watched the video which Kyle had
[42:00] sent, telling the jury, I was too frightened to watch it. I
[42:06] was worried in case that poor child had passed away and he was trying to
[42:08] do something with her. The prosecution then presented Facebook messages to further solidify the
[42:15] abusive nature of Kyle and Janet's relationship. There were text messages between Shinead and
[42:22] Kyle's former girlfriend's mother. He warned her that Kyle was a danger to children.
[42:27] The previous owner of Jasse, the American bulldog that the family owned,
[42:30] testified next. Coral Barker said that Jasse had never been aggressive with her four
[42:36] children and described her as a nanny dog that loved cuddles and kisses. However,
[42:43] she revealed the Jasse had been put to sleep a couple of months before
[42:46] the trial because she allegedly injured somebody. Ian Summons a consultant pediatric ophtomologists testified
[42:54] next. He said to the jury that he found multiple spots of blood behind
[42:59] Bulla's eyes and said it was his belief that such an injury would be impossible
[43:02] from falling out of a bunk bed or falling down the stairs. He said
[43:07] the most likely cause of her injuries is a form of abusive head trauma,
[43:12] possibly with some kind of impact. Neuro Radiologist doctor Neil Stutely agreed. He
[43:17] said that the area of bleeding in which Lola's brain was found in between the
[43:22] juror layer, which is closer to the skull, and the aricknoid, which
[43:27] is the next layer down. He said that in a normally healthy person nothing
[43:31] would be found between these two layers. He said that the injury had been
[43:36] caused recently and said that it wouldn't have been caused by an accidental fall.
[43:42] There was further testimony regarding Lola's injuries. The jury were told that her brain
[43:46] injuries were most likely caused by shaking. There were also gripping injuries to her
[43:52] neck and bruising to her ears, which is rarely the result of an accident.
[43:59] The jury also heard that there were injuries to Lula's back and legs that
[44:02] looked as though they had been caused by three or four blows with some kind
[44:06] of a weapon. Doctor Deborah Stalker, a pediatrician, said an extensive subjural
[44:13] hemorrhage is usually the result of a high velocity road traffic collision where a child
[44:17] is thrown from the collision, or a fall from a great height, such
[44:22] as a fall from a balcony or bedroom window of more than ten feet.
[44:25] The very severe and extensive injuries on Loula are not explained by a fall dawn
[44:30] domestic stairs. The most likely cause, in my opinion, is non accidental
[44:37] injury, purposefully inflicted injury, or physical abuse. The three terms are synonymous.
[44:45] She Need was then called as a prosecution witness, and she described that
[44:49] the jury how Kyle had smashed up their home with a hammer after taking drugs.
[44:53] She said that she took the girls to Casey's home and the following day
[44:58] that was allegedly a aimed and agreed not to take drugs in the home anymore.
[45:02] She said to the jury that Kyle had never acted violently towards her or
[45:07] her children, except for one occasion when he grabbed her arm and left a
[45:10] bruise. She claimed that he was really good with the children and that she
[45:15] was never worried about him hurting them. She stated it he would cook dinner
[45:21] for them and do things for them. He liked buying them lots of stuff
[45:24] that they didn't need, but he just wanted to treat them. However,
[45:29] in the same breath she needed them, recalled an incident wearing Kyle pushed their
[45:34] boggy into the road with Lola's sister in it and shouted, fuck it.
[45:40] She then took the jury through the morning Lola was fatally injured and said,
[45:45] if I had forgott him out of the house, my daughter would still be
[45:49] alive today. I've got to live with that every single day. She then
[45:54] added that kyl was a monster who needed to rot in hell. Also said
[46:00] that if Lola had fallen down the stairs, she would have heard it as
[46:02] she slept with her bedroom door open and it was right beside the stairs.
[46:07] Under cross examination, Prosecutor Race said to she Need, you took no steps
[46:13] to check Kyle Bevan was safe to have in your house. You let this
[46:16] man who was a virtual stranger stay at your house. She Need replied,
[46:22] you don't expect someone to kill your child. I didn't let him kill my
[46:27] child, The prosecutor responded, you saw his anger, You saw he was
[46:32] unpredictable. You saw him push your baby into the road. She Need replied,
[46:39] I didn't think he'd hurt my children, despite the fact he pushed my
[46:43] buggy onto the road. During closing arguments, Prosecutor Race stated on July sixteen,
[46:51] two and twenty, Lula James, a beautiful, bright little girl,
[46:55] went to bed without, according to her mother, a bump, bruise or
[47:00] scrape on her body, apart from a bruise to her nose. At six
[47:05] thirty two am the next morning, Lula was battered, scratched, unheavily bruised
[47:10] from head to two. She was in the care of kyl Bevan a chinade
[47:15] Jam slept upstairs. She said that Lula's extensive injuries were the result of blunt
[47:21] force trauma and forceful shaking. She suggested that Lula must have rendered unconscious early
[47:28] in the attack, since Schinneed was not woken. She said that the jury
[47:32] every single expert concluded Lula's injuries were non accidental and not consistent with a fold
[47:38] on the stairs. This was a deliberate assault and not an accident. She
[47:44] said that if Lula had indeed received her injuries during an accident, then Kyle
[47:49] should have immediately called nine nine nine. She stated, we say how Bevin
[47:54] needed that are to concoct lies to protect himself. He needed that time to
[48:00] cover his tracks. She then turned her attention to she need and said that
[48:04] although she had sympathy for she Need, losing her child and having a history
[48:07] of being a victim of domestic abuse, she should have protected her daughter.
[48:14] She stated it she knew, or at the very least ought to have known,
[48:19] that at the time of Lola's death, Kyle Bevin posed a significant risk
[48:22] in causing Lola harm. Despite all the facts she needed, James takes no
[48:29] reasonable steps to protect her children, including Lola, from the risks posed by
[48:34] Kyle Bevan. She needed. James had been educated in responses to domestic violent
[48:39] situations and the impact on children. She had been given advice about bringing adults
[48:45] into the home, but she ignored them. This is someone who has been
[48:51] given every opportunity to make better decisions, but has failed to do so.
[48:55] She needs. Defense Attorney David Elias said that never in a million years did
[49:00] his client think that anything bad would have happened to Lulda? He said she
[49:05] awoke to every parent's worst nightmare and that she had no clue what had happened.
[49:10] He said, she need James has spent her life as a mother dealing
[49:15] with abusive men and protecting her children. She's always done that as they're her
[49:20] world. With the hindsight she has now, she is always going to blame
[49:24] herself for what happened to Lula, but that doesn't make her guilty of this
[49:29] offense. As for Kyle's defense, attorney John Hipkin, he said he admitted
[49:35] that Kyle had character failures and issues with drugs. He then added, but
[49:39] does that make him a child murderer? He suggested the Casey's testimony was biased
[49:45] simply because she didn't like Kyle, and she admitted to that. He said
[49:50] that Kyle still stuck to the same story that Lula was pushed on the stairs
[49:54] by the dog. The jury were then sent off to deliberate, and after
[50:00] ten hours they returned with the verdict. They found Kyle Bevan guilty of murder
[50:06] and she need James guilty of causing or alloying her daughter's death. After the
[50:10] verdict glueless. Father Dan paid tribute to her in a statement that was read
[50:15] alloyed by his family liaison officer on behalf of Daniel Thomas, father of Lola
[50:20] James. The pain and grief I feel every time I close my eyes and
[50:23] see your perfect little face is unbearable. The pain I feel thinking of all
[50:29] the smiles you gave to me, that all the smiles I won't get a
[50:31] chance to give back to you hurt so much. Even to say your name
[50:37] shutters my heart to know you can't hear my voice anymore. The only reason
[50:42] I can stand here today is the hope that you can see me, see
[50:45] that you were loved and that you deserve to live a full, happy,
[50:50] safe life surrounded by the joy that you gave to others. I'm so sorry
[50:57] your short life was filled with so much pain. You are so loved,
[51:00] Lola, and so missed every single day. A great team with much passion
[51:07] has worked together for the day since you've left us. A special thanks to
[51:12] the investigation team for not leaving any question unanswered or stone unturned, and my
[51:17] family support officers for keeping me focused and guiding me through the darkest hours along
[51:22] with my closest friends and family. The outcome here will never stop the hurt
[51:29] you felt or the hurt that lives inside of me. It's been a long
[51:34] time coming to see justice, and I can only pray that these cruel,
[51:38] evil people that hurt you and allowed you to be hurt, suffer pain and
[51:44] torment until they take their last breath. The sentencing Fears was to follow,
[51:50] and Dan provided a victim impact statement which highlighted his grief all too well.
[51:55] It read, in part, Lola won't have another birthday, or ride a
[52:00] bike, or listen to your favorite story. She won't sing her favorite songs,
[52:06] and I will never get to meet my daughter as a teenager or a
[52:08] woman. All I have left or memories of a beautiful baby and dreams of
[52:14] the child she can never become. He said that Lula didn't just die,
[52:20] she was taken away from him in the worst way possible, and that she
[52:23] never stood a chance. Defense attorney Hipkin did not offer any personal mitigation in
[52:30] behalf of his client. The judge then addressed the couple That night, the
[52:36] night of the sixteenth to seventeenth of July, Chaney James was woken at midnight
[52:42] by a bang followed by Lola screaming. She got up and saw Kyle Bevan
[52:50] holding Lola by her bed, but when he said I've got this, she
[52:57] just went away. She did not go into Lola's bedroom or have a proper
[53:04] look at what had happened. She went back to her own bed and left
[53:09] Lola alone with Kyle while she slept. During that night, he carried out
[53:16] the further attacks on Lola, which killed her. By four twenty six a
[53:23] m. Kyle had Lola downstairs and was photographing injuries he had inflicted on her
[53:32] back. By six thirty a m. He had inflicted a total of over
[53:39] one hundred visible injuries all over her body. Some of them were caused by
[53:47] a weapon, although the weapon used was not recovered or identified. They included
[53:54] injuries to Lola's right thigh with circular elements in a linear pattern caused by a
[54:01] weapon, and bleeding puncture wounds to her forehead, also caused by a weapon.
[54:10] Kyle Bevan hit the side of Lowles's head with such force that it caused
[54:17] ear bruising and subdural bleeding in her skull on that side. He shook her
[54:25] head backwards and forwards so violently that she lost consciousness and died from brain damage.
[54:37] Karl was sentenced to life in prison with a minimum term of twenty eight
[54:40] years, while she needed sentenced to just six years in prison. Laula James's
[54:49] short life was marked by squalor and chaos. Her mother, who should have
[54:52] been her protector, made a degree of mistake by welcoming a man she met
[54:57] on Facebook into their home. In just a few short weeks, Kyle Bavan
[55:02] was allowed to indulge in alcohol and drugs despite young children being present in the
[55:07] home. This perilous situation culminated with Lola paying the ultimate price. Well,
[55:36] Bessie's that is it for this episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you
[55:39] so so much for listening, and I'd like to say a big massive thank
[55:44] you to my new support of on Patreon Ariel. If you'd like to support
[55:47] the show of on Patreon, in exchange, you get odd free and early
[55:52] release episodes, bonus episodes of Morbidology plus that aren't on the regular podcast platforms
[55:58] behind the Scenes which includes go on as, audio video and case files,
[56:02] and I also send out a handwritten thank you card along with some cool march
[56:08] If you'd like to support the show in another way, Could you please consider
[56:12] leaving me a rating or review on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever else
[56:16] you're listening. It's a super easy way to support a show that you like,
[56:21] and I genuinely do appreciate the feedback and support. Remember to check us
[56:28] out at more biology dot com for more information about this episode and to read
[56:31] or true crime articles. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay
[56:36] safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
