# 234: Nohema Graber

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 11 Dec 2023, 56 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/57926581/morbidology_234_nohema_graber.mp3

Nohema Graber had come from Mexico to Fairfield, Iowa, where she and her husband raised a family. As a devoted educator, her sudden disappearance one November afternoon in 2021 left her students deeply troubled. As detectives began their investigation, a local resident came forth. He reported seeing two teenagers driving Nohema’s car… SPONSORS - Babbel: Thank you to Babbel for sponsoring this episode! Learn a new language in as little as three weeks with Babbel. Their brief 10-minute lessons are curated by over 150 language experts. Get 55% off your Babbel subscription at: https://babbel.com/morbidology UNFOLD: Thank you to UNFOLD for sponsoring this episode! Are you ready to welcome a more balanced life? Morbidology listeners get a 15% discount and a complimentary 30-minute trial at: https://integralcoach.youcanbook.me/ June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-234-nohema-graber PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Epidemic Sound Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:00] Before we begin today's episode, I'd just like to let everybody know that we
[0:03] lost the most important member of Morbidology. Just before three p m. On
[0:07] the fifth of December, my Staffordshire bill terrier Louis, was helped a cross
[0:12] rainbow bridge at home with myself and my partner Joe by his side. As
[0:16] Morbidology listeners, you probably heard the powder of his fate, or even him
[0:20] snoozing in the background of some episodes. I never had the heart to close
[0:24] him out of the office when I recorded. To say that Louis made me
[0:28] a better person would be an understatement. He was the best boy and a
[0:32] great ambassador for such a misunderstood and stigmatized breed. Rest easy, my big
[0:38] man. I'll miss and love you forever. Once we found her body and
[1:17] we did the media release that Missus Graber's body had been recovered, we had
[1:23] students that were scared to death to attend class. We had teachers that didn't
[1:27] want to teach for concerns of their own safety. Noam mcgraeber had come from
[1:44] Mexico to Fairfield in Iowa, where she and her husband raised a family.
[1:49] As a devoted Spanish teacher. Her sudden disappearance on November afternoon in twenty twenty
[1:53] one left her students deeply troubled. As detectives began their investigation, a local
[2:00] resident came forward he reported seeing two teenagers driving Nueima's car after her disappearance.
[2:20] Nuima Castillo was born on the tenth of November nineteen fifty four in Halapa,
[2:24] Mexico, which is the capital state of Vera Cruz, around one hundred and
[2:29] eighty miles east of Mexico City. Following her high school graduation, she spent
[2:35] seventeen years working as a flight attendant in Mexico, yet she aspired for more
[2:38] significant achievements. Determined to realize her dreamed, Nueima pursued her passion for aviation,
[2:46] undergoing training to become one of Mexico's first female commercial airline pilots, breaking
[2:52] through traditional gender barriers. On the fourth of October nineteen eighty six, Nuima
[2:57] tied the knat with Paul Graber, she had known since their teenage years.
[3:02] Following their marriage, Nuema continued her successful trajectory in the airline industry, while
[3:07] Paul thrived as a consultant in Mexico City, utilizing his expertise to guide foreign
[3:14] enterprises through the intricacies of the Mexican bureaucracy. In nineteen ninety one, the
[3:20] couple celebrated the arrival of their first born, Christian. The subsequent year marked
[3:24] the birth of their second son, Jared. However, driven by their desire
[3:30] to provide their children with the safer environment free from the constraints of fortified windows,
[3:36] Nuima and Paul made the decision to relocate from Mexico not too long after
[3:40] Jarard was born. The family uprooted their lives and settled down in Fairfield,
[3:46] Iowa, Paul's home town. Fairfield was a small town with a population of
[3:51] around nine thousan four hundred people, but it had a sizeable foreign born population
[3:57] compared to the rest of Iowa. Twelve point six percent of the population is
[4:00] foreign born, which is more than double the five point three percent of the
[4:04] general Iowa population. One of the contributing factors to this diversity was the presence
[4:11] of Maharishi International University. This is a private educational institution founded by the renowned
[4:18] Indian spiritual leader Maharishi Mahishugi back in nineteen seventy one. The town has a
[4:27] vibrant Latino community, and Nuima seamlessly integrated herself into the cultural fabric of Fairfield.
[4:34] Levering her multi lingual ability. She served as a mentor and guide to
[4:40] many within the community, offering supporting guidance to those in need. A few
[4:46] years down the line, Nuima and Paul welcomed their third child, a daughter,
[4:48] whom they named Nuhima Marie. The family home was one filled with love
[4:54] and compassion, but the familial bond extended beyond the home. The Graver family
[5:00] were active in Saint Mary's Catholic Church. Nuima in particular demonstrated her unwavering devotion
[5:08] by attending maths every single day. She extended her hospitality to other churchgoers,
[5:14] providing solace through prayers and offering words of encouragement to those during their time of
[5:19] need. According to Father Nick Adams's recollections, Nuima was celebrated for her exceptional
[5:27] kindness, bondless compassion, and unwavering faith. Nuima always made sure to get
[5:31] involved in the church activities, and she sang in the church choir. She
[5:36] also assumed the crucial role of fostering a strong connection between the church and the
[5:41] burgeoning Latino community in Fairfield. Almost every single Latino family in the town knew
[5:47] Numa, and she became like extended family. It was rare to see a
[5:53] Latino family function from a kincierra to a birthday party and not see Nuema there.
[6:00] As the couple's children flew the nest, Luima found herself yearning for a
[6:04] transformative chapter in her own life. Seizing the opportunity, she pursued a degree
[6:11] in English and a teaching certification from Iowa Wesleyan University in Mount Pleasant, a
[6:16] bold step that she took in her fifties. She originally anticipated a career as
[6:23] an English teacher, but upon her graduation in two thousand and six, she
[6:27] discovered a demand for Spanish teachers. Given her native fluency in the language,
[6:31] the role of a Spanish teacher appeared to be an ideal fit. Securing her
[6:38] first teaching position at Ottumwa High School, Nuima dedicated her efforts there from two
[6:43] thousand and six until two thousand and twelve. Subsequently, when a part time
[6:47] teaching position surfaced at Fairfield High School, she eagerly accepted the opportunity for seeing
[6:53] the potential for it to transition into a full time role. Nuima's decision paid
[6:58] off, and she quickly integrated herself within the fabric of the high school,
[7:02] leaving an indelible mark on her students, their families, and the faculty alike.
[7:09] Her genuine aspiration for her students' personal growth was evident, and when students
[7:14] left the school, many sent her letters thanking her. She probably displayed them
[7:19] in her classroom. During National Teacher Appreciation Week, one of her students dedicated
[7:26] a video to Nuima, have your teacher Appreciation Week, missus Graver. Thank
[7:30] you for all that you do in and out of the classroom. We really
[7:34] appreciate how much fun we have in your class and how much Spanish we learn,
[7:39] and we just hope you have a really good day Gracia. Another student,
[7:43] Willu Larson recollected her class was kind of hard at first, but she
[7:47] was a good teacher. She really pointed that stuff into your head so you
[7:51] would remember and help you with tests and stuff. We always made an effort
[7:58] to look out for students as well. If one ever came in Hungary or
[8:01] didn't appear to have warm clothing for the winter, Numa made sure that they
[8:05] were well fed and warm. She went the extra mile making phone calls to
[8:11] community members to ask for help and connecting those in need with resources. Then,
[8:16] in two thousand and six, Nuima and Paul decided to call it quits
[8:20] on their marriage, but it was on amicable terms. They still had a
[8:24] profound love for one another and were proud of the family they had created,
[8:30] but felt as though it was time to go their separate ways. The second
[8:37] of November two thousand and twenty one started out like just any other ordinary day
[8:43] for Numa. She took a group of her students to the town's library to
[8:48] appreciate a display commemorating the Day of the Dead, a Mexican holiday that honors
[8:54] and remembers deceased loved ones. While there, a news team happened to be
[8:58] present, and Nuima remarked to the reporter, we all know we're going to
[9:03] die. It's our way of laughing at death. Later, Nuima and the
[9:09] students returned to their school, where they wrapped up their classes for the day.
[9:15] That same day, Paul was out of town for work. Despite the
[9:18] divorce, he and Nuima still lived together along with their son, Jared.
[9:24] Jared had been born with a severe genetic disorder, which meant that he couldn't
[9:26] live independently. As for Paul, his health wasn't in the best condition.
[9:33] He had endured more than five years of dialysis, which was the side effect
[9:37] of severe diabetes. Paul had also received a kidney transplant, and Nuima was
[9:43] by his side every step of the way. The family bond was still strong
[9:48] as if Nuema and Paul had never divorced. Dinners were shared together and the
[9:54] family liked to settle down in front of the television together after a hard day's
[9:58] work to such a good show and chat. When Paul arrived back home the
[10:03] next morning, he was surprised to see that Nuima's car wasn't parked in the
[10:07] driveway. He put his key in the lock and proceeded through the home,
[10:13] only to find that Nuima wasn't there. At about eight thirty a m.
[10:18] That morning, Paul received a phone call from the school notifying him that Nuima
[10:22] had failed to show up for her class. It had been scheduled to begin
[10:26] at eight ten a m. But Nuima was a no shoe and she hadn't
[10:31] contacted the school to say that she was sick. Its unusual behavior was completely
[10:37] out of character for Nuima. It was known for her unwavering punctuality and reliability.
[10:43] Overwhelmed by a growing sense of foreboding, Paul contacted the police to report
[10:48] his ex wife as missing. The initial focus for the detectives was to determine
[10:52] the precise timeline of Nueima's disappearance. They established that she had been at the
[10:58] school the day before hand, as confirmed by the surveillance footage capturing her departing
[11:03] in her car. However, it remained unclear whether she had returned home or
[11:09] had driven elsewhere. Seeking to gain further insight into Nuima's typical routine, detectives
[11:16] spoke more with her family. They revealed that Nuima often went to Chautauqua Park
[11:22] after school. It was her routine to do three laps of the park before
[11:26] driving home before dinner. Acting on this information, the detectives directed their attention
[11:31] to the park. They considered the possibility that Nuima might have encountered a health
[11:37] emergency or served at an accident during her walk. However, upon arriving at
[11:43] the park, her vehicle was nowhere to be found in the parking lot.
[11:46] Undetered, they meticulously combed through the park on the path beside the surrounding woodland.
[11:54] Detective Trent Valletta noticed something on the ground. Yeah, there was quite
[12:00] a bit of blood kind of starting around that area and then along a half
[12:05] to the other river tracks. The detective had discovered blood on the park's northeastern
[12:09] perimeter, just beside a wooded area that led towards the train tracks. They
[12:15] decided to venture into the woodland. Done an embankment among the trees, detectives
[12:20] observed something unnatural to the landscape. It was a large pile of items,
[12:26] including a whalebarrow and railroad ties, that stuck out amongst the trees in foliage.
[12:33] Detective Trent Valletta carefully began to disassemble the pile, uncovering a black torp
[12:39] beneath. Peeling back a section of the tarp revealed Nuima's lifeless body. She
[12:46] was cold to the touch, with evident signs of a severe head injury,
[12:50] with blood mooring her face and hair. Ah, you can see pretty clearly
[12:56] that there's no visible injuries on the front of her body, her arms,
[13:01] maybe some scratches that sort of thing from the woods, but nothing that would
[13:07] be fatal. However, when you look at her head, there looks like
[13:11] there's a very egregious injury there. It was pretty matted with blood, but
[13:18] you could tell that there had been a serious injury to her head. Willimu
[13:22] was also partially clothed. She was just wearing a braw Her pants were tended
[13:31] down around her ankles. It was pretty easy and when we were standing there
[13:37] we started looking around. We could see that like I think she had a
[13:41] turtle neck sweater was up in the trees, been thrown up in the trees,
[13:46] and another shirt had been thrown up in the trees. They weren't well
[13:50] hidden, but she was partially nude when we recovered her. Based on the
[13:58] blood evidence of the same, it appeared as though Nuima had first been attacked
[14:01] on the path. Detectives believed that she was then dragged into the forested area
[14:07] away from view, where she was ultimately killed by a heavy blue to the
[14:11] head with some kind of heavy object. The evidence also suggested that Numa's body
[14:18] had been moved with the wheelbarrow before it collapsed, so the investigation showed several
[14:26] different times that wheelbarrow was used to essentially transport the body of Annoyment greater.
[14:35] It appeared that they didn't calculate weight and what the wheelbarrow could hold, so
[14:41] the wheel barrow essentially came apart, broke apart, which is I I could
[14:48] only speculate that's why it was left there. Who would not have been easy
[14:52] to carry out, but it was part of the plan to move her in
[14:56] that wheel barrow. The area was vert and crime scene tape. As Nuima's
[15:01] body was transported to the Medical Examiner's office. Doctor Michelle Cavalier was tasked with
[15:07] performing the autopsy. She determined that Nuima had died from blunt force trauma to
[15:13] the head. News of Nuima's murder quickly spread throughout the area and the community
[15:22] graveled and makes sense of the senseless nature of what had happened. Nuima was
[15:28] a well loved member of the community. It had been attacked while out for
[15:31] a routine walk around to public park in broad daylight. It struck fear into
[15:37] the residents all throughout the small town of Fairfield. Lieutenant Julie Kinsella recollected once
[15:45] we found her body and we did the media release that missus Graver's body had
[15:50] been recovered. We had students that were scared to death to attend class.
[15:56] We had teachers that didn't want to teach for the constructer of their own safety.
[16:00] It was such a concern to the point where the schools shut down the
[16:04] schools they obtained counselors. I think for two and a half days that they
[16:10] got out early, and then like two and a half days there was no
[16:12] school. And then when the kids came back to school and teachers came back
[16:15] to school, there were counselors for both the teachers and the staff or the
[16:21] school. Lorie Noll, the superintendent of Fairfield Community School District, expressed her
[16:26] condolences in a statement which read, in her nine years with Fairfield High School,
[16:33] missus Greeber touched the lives of many students, parents, and staff.
[16:37] We extend our deepest condolences to the family, friends, on loved ones of
[16:41] missus Greeber. The he andus nature of the crime led to some within the
[16:47] community questioning whether it might have been racially motivated. One of Nouema's former students,
[16:53] Alison Reid, said, while missus Greeber was bilingual and fluent in English,
[17:00] she did struggle with slang and had an accent. I know some students
[17:03] made fun of her for that such concerns reverberated within Iowa's Latino communities, prompting
[17:11] Joe Henry, the state political director of a Latino civil rights organization, to
[17:17] express apprehension that Nuima's murder might have been indicative of a broader, unsettling trend.
[17:23] In a heartfelt tribute, Nuima's ex husband, Paul, said, to
[17:27] know Nuima was to love her. She was the kind of person every community
[17:32] longs to have in its midst, and we were blessed to have her in
[17:36] our lives. The outpouring of grief culminated in Fairfield High School organizing a candlelight
[17:41] vigil in Nuima's honor, a testament to the enduring impact of her life and
[17:45] work within the community. Before the event began, fellow teacher Fred Huck pled
[17:52] guitar and sang a song he had composed in Nuima's memory. It was titled
[17:56] A Light for Nuima, and in the song he called on the community to
[18:00] heal. He sang while someone else sorts out who's to blame. It's our
[18:06] job to tend to the living. Just the same as the vigil unfolded,
[18:11] those who knew and loved nueimas stepped forward to share anecdotes and tributes, all
[18:17] underscoring her warm and welcoming nature. Maria jim Andez in particular, express that
[18:22] Nuima had seamlessly integrated herself into the fabric of the Hispanic community and daring herself
[18:29] to each and every member who regarded her as an integral part of their extended
[18:33] family. Many in attendance were former students of Nuima, some now navigating college,
[18:41] while others had settled into their own families and careers. The sheer magnitude
[18:47] of the candlelight vigil stood as a testament to the profound impact that Nuima not
[18:51] only had on the lives of her students, but also on the entire community.
[19:00] As the tributes for Nuima continued to pour, in, detective stealth deeper
[19:04] into the mystery surrounding her murder. Their investigation led them to scrutinize surveillance footage
[19:11] obtained from Fairfield High School at the park where her lifeless body had been discovered.
[19:17] They were hoping to ascertain if anybody had followed Nuima from the school,
[19:22] or if any suspicious vehicles or people had been lurking in the vicinity. The
[19:26] footage captured Nuima leaving the school alone, adding to the park at about four
[19:32] pm, approximately forty two minutes later, her vehicle was seen leaving the park,
[19:37] but it wasn't Nuima behind the wheel. Instead, two elusive figures that
[19:44] appeared to be teenage boys had taken control of her vehicle. A theory began
[19:48] to formulate that Numa had been killed by these two teenage boys, but their
[19:53] identities remained elusive due to the grainy nature of the surveillance footage. Detective embarked
[20:00] on a round of interviews with the residents living in the vicinity of the park
[20:04] when I witness claimed to have seen two teenage boys hastily driving off in Nuima's
[20:10] vehicle. Another report surfaced from a man who recounted a peculiar sighting the night
[20:17] before Nueima's body was discovered. He had spotted a solitary teenage boy pushing a
[20:22] wheelbarrow in the direction of the park. It was a seemingly innocent sighting at
[20:29] the time, but now became significant in the wake of Nuema's murder, as
[20:33] her body was concealed underneath a wheelbarrow. The detectives were determined to locate the
[20:40] pair of teenage boys, and they found their breakthrough in the form of the
[20:44] timely and promising tip. This episode is sponsored by Unfold Integral Coaching. Hey,
[20:53] how many things are you doing right now listening to this podcast? That's
[20:57] one cooking, working out, scrolling through social media and what's on your mind?
[21:04] All those unanswered texts, that looming deadline, that worry about that issue
[21:08] that won't go away. You've got a lot going on in this crazy world.
[21:14] We all do, and we're losing touch with our natural ability for deep
[21:18] healing rest. That means most of us are living with a dysregulated nervous system
[21:22] that keeps us on edge during the day, wide awake at night, and
[21:26] snapping at the people we love the most. But here's the thing. You
[21:30] have the power to shift your body from fight or flight to rest and digest.
[21:33] And Christina Bonnet Acosta, a Stanford educated integral coach, wants to teach
[21:40] you how for free. She's offering a no cost, thirty minute coaching session
[21:45] to fifty of ninety thousand listeners for the holidays. You'll log out of Zoom
[21:49] feeling deeply relaxed and equipped with two proven techniques for finding calm in any chaos.
[21:56] Buddhist teacher Lama Pima Dragpa describes Christina is one of the most caring and
[22:00] insightful people he has ever encountered, and a past client said, for me,
[22:06] every session with Christina has meant real, long lasting transformation. So if
[22:11] you're tired of being held hostage by your own nervous system, grab your free
[22:15] session at www dot christinabonnet dot com. The link will be in the show
[22:18] notes before it goes back to its normal price of sixty five euros. You're
[22:23] just thirty minutes away from finding flow in your body, mind and life.
[22:32] That afternoon, a teenage boy named John Burnet appeared at the Fairfield Police station.
[22:37] He said to the officer at the desk that he had information about Noema's
[22:41] murder. He was taken into a separate room where he said that his sixteen
[22:45] year old friend Jeremy Gooddeal, had confessed to killing Noema over the messaging app
[22:51] Snapchat. In subsequent posts, good Deal brazenly implicated another one of his friends,
[22:59] sixteen year old Millard Miller, stating that they had orchestrated the murder of
[23:03] Nuemen together. His digital trail unfiled a premeditated plot, with Gooddal detailing their
[23:10] elaborate planning leading up to the fateful day as it emerged. Both Gooddale and
[23:15] Miller had been students of Nuema's, but it was Miller's plummeting grades that served
[23:19] as a catalyst to the murder. His bad grade in Spanish was damaging his
[23:25] GPA, and he decided that the only way to improve his grade was to
[23:29] get rid of his Spanish teacher. On the day of Nuema's disappearance, she
[23:33] had a meeting with Miller in her classroom, unaware that he was already conspiring
[23:37] to kill her. That afternoon, the two teenagers meticulously monitored Nuima's routine,
[23:44] identifying Shataka Park as the prime location for their plot. It was relatively secluded
[23:51] and offered the perfect setting for the murder. They decided that they could quickly
[23:55] dispose of any evidence without interruption. After discussing his grades with Nuema that afternoon,
[24:00] Miller proceeded to Chautauka Park, where he met up with Gooddal. Armed
[24:07] with a baseball bat, the two boys patiently waited for Nuema's arrival in the
[24:10] parking lot, unaware of their presence Numa strolled around the park with Miller and
[24:15] Gooddale tailing her. Upon reaching a secluded area of the park adjacent to a
[24:21] wooded path that led to the train tracks, Gooddale approached her. He was
[24:25] wearing a mask, and he frightened Nuima. He took the mask off,
[24:30] revealing to Numa that it was one of her students. She smiled at him
[24:34] and he smiled back. Before she got the chance to say hello, Miller
[24:40] snuck up behind her and struck her on the head with the baseball bat.
[24:45] Subsequently, Miller and Gooddale hauled Nueima into the woodland, where Gooddale too raised
[24:49] the bat and delivered another fatal blue. Once Nuima lay lifeless, Miller and
[24:55] Gooddale stole some of her belongings, including her carcase and classroom came. They
[25:00] drove away in her vehicle, eventually a bonding it on Middle Glasgow Road,
[25:06] which is a remote rural route. From here, Miller and a good deal
[25:10] walked on foot before they texted a friend named habib Sein and asked him to
[25:14] collect them in his car. Much like John Habibols, who spoke with detectives,
[25:19] yes, he told law enforcement that approximately four point fifty or so pm
[25:26] on November seven, he was contacted by Jeremy Goodale and asked for them to
[25:34] be picked up on Middle Glasgow Road. We were able then to find camera
[25:41] footage which corroborated what mister Saint said and chose two males walking down the road
[25:48] and then mister Saint's car coming into a driveway to paint them on. Following
[25:52] the snapchat information from John, detective swiftly located an apprehended Miller and good Deal.
[26:00] Miller was the initial suspect brought in for questioning at the police headquarters,
[26:03] where he was held without his mother's presence. He signed a juvenile waiver and
[26:08] was informed that the discussion pertained to his teacher, Nueima. In the early
[26:15] stages of the interrogation, Miller referred to Nuima as an asshole, citing her
[26:21] alleged on fair grading practices that adversely affected Schuden's GPAs. When the conversation shifted
[26:27] to Nuima's murder, Miller staunchly denied any involvement. Detectives then presented him with
[26:34] the incriminating evidence, refraining from revealing the snapchat content at that moment. They
[26:41] informed him that he had been identified as one of the teenagers spotted in Nuima's
[26:45] car post murder, and also as the figure observed near midnight with the wheelbarrow.
[26:51] Confronted with the evidence, Miller altered his narrative, conceding that he was
[26:55] present during Nuema's murder, but asserted that he wasn't involved. He claimed to
[27:00] have chanced upon a group of youths carrying Nuima's lifeless body in the park.
[27:06] According to his account, when they noticed him, they coerced him into fetching
[27:10] a whale barrow to transport her and compelled him to take her van from the
[27:15] park. Detectives knew that this was false, based on Gooddale's snapchat confession.
[27:21] When he was presented with this, Miller eventually admitted that he was there when
[27:25] the murder occurred. However, he distanced himself from the murderer and claimed that
[27:30] it was Gooddale who carried it out. According to Miller's account, he played
[27:33] a role in orchestrating the murder, but claimed to have merely served as a
[27:38] lookout while Gooddale delivered the fatal blows to Nuima. Miller admitted that initially they
[27:45] had left Nuima's body exposed in the woodland only the later fair potential discovery.
[27:51] They decided to relocate the body, with Miller using a whale barrow from his
[27:55] home to conceal her remains beneath railroad ties and to torp within the park.
[28:00] Simultaneously, detectives obtained search warrants for Miller's home. In his bedroom, they
[28:06] came across a baseball bat and blood stained clothing. Furthermore, a search warrant
[28:11] for his computer revealed incriminating searches about the potential consequences for its students' grades if
[28:18] a teacher were to pass away or suffer severe injury during the term. In
[28:22] his bedroom, they discovered a baseball bat and blood stained clothing. A search
[28:26] of his cell phone uncovered an ominous list which it included items such as a
[28:30] baseball bat, hammer, knife, garden gloves, plastic gloves, trash bags,
[28:37] and wet wipes. As Miller was arrested. Following his interrogation, good
[28:41] Deal sat down and spoke with detectives. However, his version of events diverged
[28:48] from Miller's. While Miller attempted to distance himself from the murder, Goodal claimed
[28:53] full responsibility. He said that Miller had initiated the attack while he had dealt
[28:59] the fatal second flew. He kind of gave me like a nod, saying,
[29:07] here she comes. And I had the signal it's all clear, and
[29:12] she walked by. Hit her in the back of the head, and then
[29:18] I said, I hoped shit to make sure she's dead. So we hit
[29:22] her a couple more times, and then I tracked her off towards the access
[29:29] trail, and I wasn't sure she was alive or not. And I took
[29:36] the bad time, made sure she was a fly for breath, and shady
[29:45] wasn't there that only you stand her on the trail. I'm just saying,
[29:49] sure nobody else is kind of long. Miller and good Deal were subsequently charged
[29:56] as adults with first degree murder on conspiracy to commit first degree murder. As
[30:02] per Iowa law, cases involving juveniles aged fourteen and above can be transferred to
[30:07] adult court. Each of them were ordered to be detained on a one million
[30:11] dollar bond, prompting Miller's defense attorneys to file a motion seeking a reduction.
[30:17] The defense argued that Miller had no prior criminal record or skill disciplinarian fractions,
[30:22] proposing that with the lowered bond, Miller would abide by GPS monitoring and remain
[30:27] under constant adult supervision. The prosecution opposed the motion, piloting the severity of
[30:33] the charges against Miller and his numerous self incriminating statements. They contended that no
[30:40] conditions of release could guarantee the safety of the community where Miller resided. Moreover,
[30:47] the prosecution deemed the suggestion of home supervision inadequate, citing that the crime
[30:52] had occurred while Miller was presumably under the supervision of his parents. On the
[30:57] twelfth of November, both Miller and goes Deal were formally indicted with first degree
[31:02] murder and conspiracy to commit murder. They both pleaded not guilty to all of
[31:07] the charges against them, and both way of their right to a speedy trial.
[31:11] This meant that prosecutors wouldn't have to try them within ninety days of them
[31:15] being charged. Shortly thereafter, both Miller and good Deal's defense teams tried to
[31:21] get their bonds lowered in court. Good Deal's defense attorney, Nicole Jensen,
[31:26] argued that her client had lived in Fairfield his entire life and said that his
[31:32] father, who worked in construction, could likely post ten thousand dollars bond at
[31:37] most. She said the good Deal didn't have a passport or a driver's license,
[31:41] so didn't have the ability to flee from the prosecution even if he wanted
[31:45] to. Assistant. Iowa Attorney General Scott Brown, however, argued that the
[31:51] bond should actually be increased to two million dollars. He highlighted the extremely brutal
[31:56] nature of the murder, along with the evident plans that went into it,
[32:00] as the reasons to warrant such a high bond. Judge Juli Ye had ultimately
[32:05] denied the request to lower the bond, and it remained at one million dollars
[32:08] cash. Only. When that field, Miller's defense attorney requested that disclient to
[32:14] be tried as a juvenile instead of an adult. If the judge agreed and
[32:17] Miller were convicted as a juvenile, he could be released in less than twenty
[32:22] four months. Good Deal's defense attorney followed suit and requested that his case be
[32:28] transferred to juvenile court as well. While this was ongoing, both good Deal
[32:32] and Miller requested that all of their hearings remain closed. District Attorney Chauncey Moulding
[32:38] argued that they should be open and commented there are no secret murder trials in
[32:44] America. The judge rejected their request, which meant that the preceding court hearings
[32:49] would be open Commeeporal. Good Deal attempted once more to have his case transferred
[32:53] to juvenile court, and his defense team appeared in court alongside the prosecution.
[32:59] They had hired psychologist Branda Paine, who examined Good Deal and reported he would
[33:02] benefit from juvenile court treatment and services. She said that she conducted several tests
[33:08] on Good Deal and found that he was bright and had above average problem solving
[33:13] skills and no mental health issues. She diagnosed him with the tension deficit hyperactivity
[33:17] disorder, which affected his impulse control and focus ability. According to doctor Pain,
[33:23] juveniles with eddi HD are very influenced by peers and have difficulty controlling their
[33:29] emotions. During her talk with good Deal, she said that he was grieving
[33:34] for all of the grief he had caused. She said that according to her
[33:37] recent study, a juvenile doesn't have a fully developed brain and doesn't have formed
[33:42] character or personality traits as somebody later in their life. In her opinion,
[33:46] Good Deal would benefit from his case being moved on from adult court to juvenile
[33:51] court. Doctor Pain spoke about this in court, but she admitted she hadn't
[33:54] reviewed any police reports about the crime and had only reviewed the juvenile court all
[34:00] summary. She further admitted that there was no treatment door services in juvenile court
[34:05] for those who had committed such a crime that good Deal had committed. Assistant
[34:09] Jefferson County Attorney Patrick McGavin then asked whether good Deal was grieving for Nuema classmates,
[34:15] parents, or himself. He suggested the good Deal may have only felt
[34:20] grieved because he was caught and was now in custody facing an adult trial that
[34:24] could see him locked away for life. Even if good Deal could have been
[34:29] rehabilitated, he was only eight months away from turning eighteen, and there was
[34:32] no way he could be rehabilitated in such a short time before he were released
[34:37] if his case was transferred to juvenile court. More and more people are interested
[34:45] in learning new languages, especially during the fall. Babel is a great option
[34:50] if you want to start speaking a new language in just three weeks, which
[34:53] is perfect for showing off your skills during the holidays instead of spending a fortune
[34:59] on prime at tutors or using apps that just don't work well. Bable offers
[35:04] short, ten minute lessons. These lessons are created by more than one hundred
[35:07] and fifty language experts to help you learn quickly. I've personally used Babble during
[35:14] my travels to ma Yorka, and it helped me understand Spanish menus and arrange
[35:17] transportation easily. I could even chat with the locals. Here's a special limited
[35:22] time deal for morbidology listeners to get you started right now. Get fifty five
[35:28] percent off your Babbel subscription, but only for morbidology listeners at babble dot com
[35:34] slash morbidology. Get fifty five percent off at babble dot com slash Morbidology spelled
[35:42] B A, B B E L dot com slash morbidology. Rules and restrictions
[35:47] may apply. While the judge was still making his decision. In May,
[35:55] Miller's defense team appeared in court and made the same request test as good Deal's
[36:00] defense team to have the case move to juvenile court. They hired psychologist Craig
[36:07] Rimper, who testified that Miller was a different person he was now than in
[36:12] November when the murder had happened because of the rapid brain development that occurs in
[36:16] juveniles. He said the brain development in teenagers is significant because it affects the
[36:22] adolescence decision making, empathy, and knowing right from wrong. According to doctor
[36:29] Rympa, Miller was ripe for change and said that if his case was moved
[36:34] to juvenile court, he could receive treatment in programming that would help develop these
[36:38] traits. He said that he had analyzed Miller and found him to be kind
[36:44] with age appropriate compassionate behavior. He also found him to be impressionable, easily
[36:50] persuaded by others, and to be more of a follower than a leader.
[36:53] Again, the prosecution argued that Miller was so close to turning eighteen that he
[36:59] wouldn't be rehabilitated in time for his release if his case were transferred to juvenile
[37:04] court. The judge ultimately denied both requests, which meant that both Miller and
[37:08] good Deal would be standing trial as adults. The judge said that there was
[37:14] limited time to rehabilitate either if they were tried as juveniles before their release.
[37:20] He wrote, the juvenile courts dwindling time to rehability. It is simply insufficient
[37:25] for a crime of such magnitude based on the nature of the offenses described in
[37:30] the minutes of testimony. This meant that if Miller and good Deal were convicted,
[37:35] they could be looking at a sentence of life in prison. Shortly after
[37:39] the decision, Miller requested that his trial be moved out of Jefferson County due
[37:44] to pretile publicity. The media interest in the case was high, and his
[37:49] defense team argued he would be unable to get a fair trial because of the
[37:52] extensive media coverage. The judge agreed, and Miller's trial was moved to Council
[37:55] Bluffs in western Iowa. Good Deal followed. Food and his attorneys filed the
[38:00] motion for a change of venue. They argued the good Deal would be denied
[38:05] his constitutional right to an impartial trial if the case proceeded in Jefferson County because
[38:10] of the publicity. The judge agreed and moved his trial to Scott County.
[38:16] The case continued demander through the justice system as the defense and prosecution were preparing
[38:22] for the two upcoming trials. In March of twenty twenty three, good Deal
[38:27] agreed to testify against Miller in his upcoming trial. On the eighteenth of April,
[38:31] However, both Miller and good Deal appeared at separate hearings where they both
[38:37] changed their place to guilty. During his court appearance, good Deal provided a
[38:40] comprehensive confession regarding his involvement in the murder. On November two of twenty twenty
[38:49] one, I met Willard Miller at Chicaugo Park. I've understood that he had
[38:58] the intent to kill missus Graver. Shayden had brought a bat among other supplies
[39:08] to go through with the murder, and after he had struck Nohema Graver,
[39:17] we then moved her off of the trail where I then struck her and she
[39:24] died as a result. Afterwards, we removed any evidence that we could And
[39:39] that was my recollection of the events on November seven. And you wanted to
[39:45] do that, Jayden, No wonder for waters who assisted in the murder of
[39:55] Wilhelma murder who had Wable died star within that day? Correct, I didn't
[40:00] bring anything with him and he had previously uh asked for ask you if you
[40:09] would assist him, if he would just feel a little bread and you a
[40:14] great correct, correct, And just to de clarify the record, and you've
[40:22] already maybe you stayed in this under of but uh, on November the second
[40:30] you observe Jady Miller strike from the river first, is that correct? Correct?
[40:38] I was posted as a lookout. Well, Jayden struck her in the
[40:44] back of the head with his bat and as you've discussed, you understood at
[40:49] that point if you have, you're partisipated in the planning. You worked for
[40:52] the stol what was going on, and upon seeing that, Uh, Jad
[41:00] rons braver, he also struck the taser act. In contrast, during Miller's
[41:12] court hearing, he offered a contradictory version of events in an effort to distance
[41:15] himself from the murder. He contended that only good Deal had physically assaulted Nuima
[41:22] and maintained that he merely played the role of a lookout. His version of
[41:27] events was contradicted by good Deal. An Assistant Attorney General Scott Brown responded and
[41:32] said that there was evidence that both teenagers had struck her. He stated it
[41:38] was our intention at trial that the evidence would be that mister Miller planned the
[41:43] murder of Graeber, and his plan was in place with Jeremy good Deal,
[41:47] and that they both acted as principles as well as Aiters and the Betters in
[41:52] the planning of the death of Nuema Greeber. Tragically, Paul wasn't present to
[41:58] witness the conclusion of the case, as he had passed away just recently due
[42:02] to cancer. His brother Tom expressed that had Nuima is still being alive,
[42:07] the councer might have been diagnosed earlier. Paul was deeply and understandably depressed by
[42:14] the murder of NeiMa, and his life ended last week from the ravages of
[42:19] a metastatic cancer that would have been caught and treated far sooner had Noema been
[42:24] there. I am certain from knowing knowinga for more than thirty five years,
[42:32] that she would have made all see the doctor much sooner for the new pains
[42:39] and skin lesions he got experiencing late last year. She would not have let
[42:45] him ignored these symptoms, and she would have insisted he get them checked instead.
[42:52] Depressed as he was over this map over her murder, he delayed seeking
[42:57] treatment until the very end of March, and that was dead at the early
[43:00] age of sixty eight. Tom later commented, We're glad the defendants have pleaded
[43:07] guilty. We're disappointed that one is not still owning up to his full role.
[43:13] But he is at least pleaded guilty and we look forward to sentencing with
[43:17] both Nuema and Paul Gonne. Their eldest son, Christian, found himself the
[43:22] primary caregiver of his brother Jared. The sentencing phases were to follow, and
[43:29] Miller was the first to be sentenced. He appeared in court looking solemn on
[43:34] the sixth of July. The public gallery was filled with all of Nueima's loved
[43:38] ones, her family, her friends, and even since students she had taught
[43:44] over the years. Assistant Iowa Attorney General Scott Brown stated this was a cruel
[43:51] he and us act by two individuals. I cannot imagine anything really worse than
[43:57] to be attacked in the manner what she was for what agreed. This defendant
[44:01] deserves every day he gets in prison, every single one. Miller was asked
[44:07] if he wanted to make a statement before his sentence was imposed. He stood
[44:13] before the microphone and said, I would like to apologize for my actions.
[44:17] First and foremost to the family. I am sincerely sorry for the distress that
[44:22] I caused you and the devastation that I caused your family. I'm realizing just
[44:28] the magnitude of my actions. And I know it's wrong, and I knew
[44:30] it was wrong, and yet I still carried through. I still did what
[44:36] I did, and I accept responsibility for that. He then turned to the
[44:40] judge and asked that he'd be given a second chance at life, not apologized.
[44:45] It's all artist, everyone affected it. It's my comedience, my family,
[44:49] it's the graver's course. And I asked, when you're a chance.
[44:54] And I don't want to be institutionalist. I don't don't want to be in
[44:58] so long as I forget about it, you know, more matter where I
[45:00] come from and what I need to do. During the presentation of victim impact
[45:05] statements, Nuima's brother in law, Tom emotionally expressed this case has had an
[45:10] enormous impact on Noima's family, Fairfield High School, and the Fairfield community at
[45:17] large. Not only was Noima robbed of thirty some of the best years of
[45:22] her life, her murdered deprived Paul Graber of the love of his life and
[45:30] certainly hastened Paul's own premature death. Has also had major impacts in the lives
[45:37] of their children, Christian Jared and NeiMa Maruvi. Nuima's son Christian also had
[45:44] some words to say, hello everyone. I think you'll give you a moment
[45:49] to speak here. I want to get this kind of short said, I
[45:52] want to get him soon, but I want to talk to you directly.
[45:57] Seen. I've gotten a hate in my heart for you of it, and
[46:00] I've mentioned mother on certain occasions of it, had good conversations. She seems
[46:06] like a decent woman and allways to your kind of suspect, and I mentioned
[46:10] them with yesterday with with funeral, my father and we have decent conversations,
[46:16] and I feel sorry for you, and I think if you're sorry for your
[46:20] mother, your grandmother, and your family, they see one of decent people.
[46:23] And I still think that there's a potential for you to be from a
[46:27] decent person as well. I don't see it at the moment, but I
[46:30] really hope that, oney, you can be. During the sentencing, Judge
[46:35] Sean Shower is addressed Miller, emphasizing that his actions were sinister and evil.
[46:39] I find that your intent and actions were sinister and evil. Those acts resulted
[46:45] in the intentional laws of human life in a boral fashion. There's no excuse.
[46:52] There is not a systemic societal problem that experience or justifies your actions.
[46:57] While the prosecution had requested a minimum of thirty years, the judge decided to
[47:01] exceed this recommendation, imposing a life sentence on Willard Miller, with the possibility
[47:08] of parole after thirty five years. In handing done the sentence, the judge
[47:14] said to him, your horrific actions led to the death of Nueme mcgraeber,
[47:17] and her family will never be able to fill that void. He further noted
[47:22] that he would have considered a sentence of life in prison without the possibility of
[47:25] parole if state law had permitted it. However, due to twenty sixteen law
[47:31] in Iowa that prohibited such sentences for juvenile defendants, the judge's hands were tied.
[47:37] Good Deal returned to court to be sentenced for his role in the murder
[47:40] on the sixteenth of November. He wore a gray suit and took his respective
[47:45] police alongside his defensed him for the proceedings. Good Deal was asked whether he
[47:51] wanted to make a statement, and he confirmed that he did. I want
[47:54] to say I'm grateful for this chance to speak my peace. I offer my
[48:00] sincerest apologies to the Graper family, but I know my words won't ever be
[48:05] enough. I've had time to think on what to say, and I'm sorry,
[48:10] truly sorry. What I've taken can ever be replaced. Every day,
[48:17] I wish I could go back and stop myself, prevent this loss and this
[48:22] pain that I've caused everyone, everyone in the community and outside of it,
[48:30] those closest to me, and those closest to the Graper family as well as
[48:34] the Graper family. I didn't know how taking this Graper's life would affect you.
[48:43] I can't comprehend losing a loved one in such an awful way. I'm
[48:51] sorry I didn't stop this from happening in the first place. And I'm understanding
[49:00] now that miss Scraper meant so much to so many people. She was a
[49:08] support to the community and goes close to her, and she was a caregiver
[49:20] to her family, to her children, and to her own husband. I'm
[49:34] so sorry. After he read aloud his statement, his nose started to gush
[49:38] blood, which holded the proceedings for several moments until it stopped buoynant. Victim
[49:45] impact statements were presented from Nuema's loved ones again. Paul's brother Tom described how
[49:50] the murder had devastated the entire family and had hastened his brother's death. Tom
[49:55] said the good Deal saunedd and looked remorseful, but still question the authenticity of
[50:00] his apology, stating, I must say your actions to me undercut that you're
[50:07] not an adult. You're over the age of eighteen, and yet you have
[50:10] your counsel to represent you, arguing on your behalf to escape punishment for this
[50:15] horrific crime. That doesn't sound like remorse to me. He was referring to
[50:20] the fact that good Deal's defense team were seeking a lenient sentence. As the
[50:23] statements were read aloud, good Deal struggled to maintain his composure and hold back
[50:29] his tears. Goodell's family also testified during the hearing, including his father Dean.
[50:36] He spoke about his son's home life and how he survived as a single
[50:38] father after Goodal's mother abandoned them. How did COVID impact German's day to day
[50:44] routine? You know? Is he a mom kind of ben? Hey,
[51:00] take your time. Interpersonal relationships were so important, can and we spent two
[51:10] and a half years in a global war against interpersonal interactions. It devastated him.
[51:21] He then address Nuima's family. When this first happened, my first instinct
[51:28] goes to reach out to the Graver family. Upon receiving advice from legal counsel,
[51:37] I was advised not to do that. I'm just so sorry. Okay,
[51:59] yeah, that's why Jeremy good Deal was sentenced to life in prison with
[52:08] the possibility of parole in twenty five years. In announcing the sentence, Judge
[52:14] Showers said it was clear to him that good Deal was remorseful and didn't take
[52:19] into consideration the repercussions of killing Numa. However, he also noted that good
[52:23] Deal was a smart young man who could have easily stopped the murder from being
[52:28] carried out. The judge also wished good Deal good luck and said he hoped
[52:32] that everybody in the courtroom could eventually heal. Louima Greeber had lived an eventful
[52:38] and fulfilling life, from making history as one of Mexico's first female commercial airline
[52:45] pilots, to packing up and moving to a brand new country and taking on
[52:49] a brand new role as a teacher. A devoted mother, wife, and
[52:53] caregiver for her ex husband and son. She extended her compassion to her shooting's
[52:59] her bring a sincere desire to enhance their academic success. Tragically, the culmination
[53:05] of her altruistic efforts took a devastating turn when one of her shootings repaid her
[53:10] kindness in the most unimaginable way. Well, Bestie's that is it for this
[53:35] episode of Morbidology. As always, thank you so much for listening, and
[53:38] I'd like to say a massive thank you to my new supporter up on Patreon,
[53:42] Audra. If you'd like to join Morbidology up on Patreon, the link
[53:45] is in the show notes. In exchangeuryer support, I upload bonus episodes of
[53:50] Morbidology plus that aren't on the regular podcast platforms. I also upload odfrey in
[53:54] early release episodes behind the scenes which includes bonus audio, video and files,
[54:00] and I also send out some cool merch. Morbidology is just a one woman
[54:05] team, so the support dot com Patreon seriously goes such a long way and
[54:07] I am eternally grateful. Remember to check us out at morbidology dot com for
[54:13] more information about this episode and to read or true crime articles. Please stay
[54:17] tuned to the end of this episode. Dear promo for the amazing podcast or
[54:22] true crime podcast. Until next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe
[54:28] and have an amazing week. Hear that jingle jingle, It could be Chris
[54:52] Kringle, or a home invader coming down the chimney, a jilted lover flashing
[54:57] a knife under the mistletoe, or a disgruntled co worker at the office Christmas
[55:00] party lacing the punch with arsenic It's disgusting. Jin and Cam, the hosts
[55:07] of our true crime podcast, are always on Santa's Nice List, but this
[55:12] holiday season, they're filling your stockings with twelve nightmarish crimes committed by the lowest
[55:16] scumbags on the naughty list. It happened in Florida, so everybody's now going
[55:21] uh. They'll be coming down the chimney, counting down the twelve nights till
[55:27] Christmas, gonna say six four five, with a different true crime case every
[55:32] night, each one naughtier than the last. This one is a doozy,
[55:37] So spike your egg. It's gonna make you want to regurch tape because you'll
[55:40] need it for our true crime podcasts. Twelve Nightmares before Christmas. They're coming
[55:46] to town. December thirteenth through twenty fourth. Listen to our true crime podcast
[55:52] on your favorite podcast apps, well, I cannot wait Hitney with it.
[55:57] Let's hear it, let's hear it. Dive right in

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
