# 209: Rita Camilleri

An episode of [Morbidology](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1463979546), 19 Jun 2023, 57 min.

Audio: https://prefix.up.audio/s/dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/s.gum.fm/s-610c47a4222ada0024acb2d8/pscrb.fm/rss/p/prfx.byspotify.com/e/tracking.swap.fm/track/2IMk17EdnEqyRhJTIpIU/claritaspod.com/measure/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/53804136/morbidology_208_rita_camilleri.mp3

St. Clair, New South Wales, Australia, was enveloped in stillness on the night of 19 July, 2019, It was approaching midnight when the tranquility was pierced by piercing screams echoing up and down a neighbourhood. The screams were followed by a woman begging her neighbours to call police. SPONSORS - Glow Natural Wellness: Thank you to Glow Natural Wellness for sponsoring this episode! As we age, we experience fatigue, moodiness, weight gain and hot flashes. Take control of your hormones and sign up to their Hormone Restoration Masterclass for free: http://fixhormones.com/ June’s Journey: Thank you to June’s Journey for sponsoring this episode! The objective of this murder-mystery game is to find objects that are hidden within beautiful, colorful and carefully crafted scenes. Download June’s Journey for free on the Apple app store and Google Play. 4Patriots: Thank you to 4Patriots for sponsoring this episode! With hurricane season fast approaching, it's time to prepare with 4Patriot's emergency food packages. Use the code "MORBIDOLOGY" for 10% off: https://4patriots.com/ SHOW NOTES - https://morbidology.com/morbidology-the-podcast-208-rita-camilleri PATREON - https://www.patreon.com/morbidology Audio Credit: Evening of Chaos - Kevin MacLeod (incompetech.com) Empty Reflections - ErikMMusic - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bgq4SPKHlyI A Mothers Sacrifice - OurMusicBox - https://ourmusicbox.com/ Dark Tranquility - Anno Domini Beats - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F6mBav72Ak Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/morbidology--3527306/support.

## Transcript

[0:03] Let's start today's episode by discussing our sponsor, Glow Natural Wellness and their Hormone
[0:09] Restoration Masterclass. This course its top by doctor Michelle Sands, a board certified
[0:15] naturalpathic physician and best selling author. As we age, we may experience fatigue,
[0:22] moodiness, and weight gain, with hot flashes becoming a particular problem for
[0:26] women. However, there is a solution. With Glow Natural Wellnesses Hormone Restoration
[0:32] master Class, you can learn how to restore your hormone levels to a more
[0:36] youthful state, eliminating the frustrating symptoms of perimenopause and menopause, and reduce your
[0:43] risk of osteoporosis, heart disease, cancer, and Alzheimer's. My mother actually
[0:49] recently completed the master class and she couldn't stop praising it to everybody. She
[0:54] reported that her hot flashes disappeared, she no longer needed her afternoon nap,
[0:59] and felt more energized and focused. Overall, it's time to take control of
[1:03] your hormones. Sign up for the freemaster class today at free Hormone class dot
[1:08] com, slash morbidology or click the link in my description. One has had
[1:53] enough of me because I've made up being a challenge, and this undown thing
[1:56] has been done for months and months. Anyway, she she had enough of
[2:00] me. She grabbed me by the hair dragged me from my room all the
[2:02] way to the kitchen. Saint Clair, New South Wales, Australia, was
[2:16] enveloped in stillness on the night of the nineteenth of July twenty nineteen. It
[2:22] was approaching midnight when the tranquility was pierced by screams echoing up and down a
[2:27] neighborhood. These screams were followed by a woman begging her neighbors to call police.
[2:45] Rita Carmi Larry was a woman of proud Maltese heritage. She had come
[2:49] from a family that had migrated to the Saint Clair locality of New South Wales
[2:53] in Australia way back in the nineteen thirties. She'd grown up alongside her three
[3:00] sisters in the area and eventually settled down with a man named Vince. The
[3:05] couple were married and went on to have two daughters. First there was Christie,
[3:09] followed by Jessica. Both Rita and Vince worked hard to provide their girls
[3:15] with a nice life. Rita took great joy and cooking delicious smeals for the
[3:19] whole family. She also had a soft spot for the Scottish rock band the
[3:23] Bay City Rulers. She was described by her loved ones as fun, irreverent
[3:30] and vibrant. She was also very community minded and found it easy to connect
[3:35] with just about everybody due to her warm and welcoming nature. Jessica and Christie
[3:40] couldn't have been more different. Well. Christie excelled in school and made friends
[3:45] with ease, Jessica struggled. She battled with the multitude of severe mental health
[3:51] conditions, including bipolar disorder, extreme paranoia, and debilitating anxiety. Her struggles
[4:00] and in childhood when she was diagnosed with autism and a d h D,
[4:03] and was then later diagnosed with anxiety and rage disorder. She had a low
[4:10] IQ in fell years behind at school, which led to incessant bullying. After
[4:15] a violent incident in which Jessica physically assaulted a classmate, it was decided that
[4:20] it would be best for her to finish her education at the local tafe.
[4:27] Jessica had since faced a seemingly endless series of hurdles over the years. Her
[4:32] mental instability showed itself in bods of paranoid beliefs and increasing violence. As she
[4:41] got older, her violent outbursts escalated. She began assaulting people, sometimes family
[4:47] members, but also even complete strangers. She wants attacked a stranger in the
[4:53] parking lot at her local shopping center. She had also wants attacked her aunt
[4:58] and her mother in law by at their hair, other than one incident when
[5:02] she was fifteen years old, and bit a boy. All of the victims
[5:06] of Jessica's violent attacks were women. Rita and Vince struggled with Jessica's difficulties,
[5:15] which put a tremendous amount of pressure on the relationship. They tried their hardest
[5:19] to make it work, but eventually Rita and Vince were divorced and Vince moved
[5:25] out of the family home. Despite some discussion about the potential benefits of professional
[5:30] support services, Rita was vehemently opposed to the idea of her daughter receiving care
[5:36] from anybody other than herself. It was unanimously decided that Jessica would live with
[5:44] her mother, Rita full time, with Rita taking on the rule of her
[5:46] primary caregiver. When Rita assumed this responsibility, she discovered that the most effective
[5:54] way to manage Jessica's outbursts was by appeasing her. Jessica had volatile temper who
[6:00] was extremely demanding of her mother. According to Christie, Rita was submissive towards
[6:08] Jessica as she was unwilling to confront her explosive outbursts. Several times over the
[6:15] years, Jessica had been dealt with under the Mental Health Act, but her
[6:19] behavior only became more erratic. On one occasion, she assaulted a caseworker from
[6:25] a job support agency who was employed to help her find suitable work. Despite
[6:31] Rita's n way of ring support, other members of the family found it difficult
[6:35] to maintain a close relationship with Jessica due to concerns about her behavior. During
[6:43] the year of two and eighteen, Jessica's mental state took a turn for the
[6:46] worst, leading her to attack a woman in the waiting room of a local
[6:50] doctor's surgery. Varanoia had gotten the best of her and she needed to be
[6:57] physically restrained. As a result of the incident, Jessica was taken to Nepean
[7:01] Hospital in Western Sydney for further evaluation. However, her aggression didn't stop there
[7:09] all. Under the care of medical professionals, she became violent towards a female
[7:13] nurse. This ultimately led to her being admitted to the psychiatric unit for nine
[7:18] days to address her severe mood disorder. During her stay, Jessica was prescribed
[7:25] lithium for her bipolar disorder and antipsychotic medicine in hopes of managing her erratic behavior.
[7:32] In the end, Jessica was allowed to return home after Rita had discharged
[7:36] her, selling the caseworker that she would look after her at home. After
[7:42] this stint in the mental health unit, Jessica confided in family friend Jade Arena
[7:47] that she would rather kill somebody than go back to a place like that.
[7:53] The comments were very ominous, and Jade made Rita aware of what Jessica had
[7:58] said. Rita simply shook it off. Jessica's case was complex due to her
[8:05] persistent habit of vomiting up her medication. She'd been prescribed a number of different
[8:09] things over the years, including mood stabilizers, antipsychotics, and antidepressants, but
[8:16] they all have limited success. In early two thousand and nineteen, Rita explored
[8:22] alternative approaches to helping her daughter, including a self proclaimed spirit communicator who claimed
[8:28] that a spirit had overtaken Jessica's body. She quoted Rita a staggering sum of
[8:35] almost five thousand dollars to dispel the alleged demon. Neighbors were also well aware
[8:41] of Jessica's mental health struggles. One neighbor, Renee Bulbird, called an incident
[8:48] from June two thousand and nineteen, where Jessica stood outside her house and called
[8:52] for help. Upon hearing her cries, Renee went out and approached her.
[8:58] Jessica then asked if she could come to her house because she was scared.
[9:03] Jessica proceeded to tell Renee that her mother was calling an ambulance, but said
[9:07] that she didn't want to go back to a psychiatric hospital and asked whether she
[9:11] could come over to the house with her. Renee recalled how it was a
[9:16] really weird conversation. She said that Jessica told her everybody's probably talking about me,
[9:24] and you probably know that I'm mentally ill. During the conversation, Rida
[9:28] appeared and she assured Jessica that she wasn't calling an ambulance, that it was
[9:33] just another one of her paranoid episodes. Renee recalled, Rita just seemed so
[9:41] lovely and so apologetic that Jessica had bothered us. Rita confided in her friends
[9:46] about Jessica's struggles. While they sympathized with her, some of them were deeply
[9:50] concerned about the potential consequences of her daughter's actions. Her friend Jade expressed her
[9:58] fear that Jessica might want they caused serious harm to someone, even suggesting that
[10:03] she could end up killing somebody. Rita, however, dismissed these fears,
[10:09] insisting that Jessica wouldn't hurt a fly. Despite the problems at home, Jessica
[10:15] and Rita put on a united front. On the eighteenth of July twenty nineteen,
[10:20] Jessica posted a couple of photographs and an article referring to the horror movie
[10:24] Jeepers Creepers on her Facebook account. She wrote interesting story. Rita replied yes,
[10:33] interesting Indeed. That same day, they shared loving comments to one another,
[10:39] along with emoji kisses. Jessica had a pattern of not only engaging in
[10:43] physical violence, but also harassing individuals and making repeated threats over the phone.
[10:52] She had three favorite numbers, two, three, and five. She liked
[10:56] to repeat these numbers to form a random phone number. When somebody picked up,
[11:01] she threatened them. She called the number of an unknown Bangladeshi family up
[11:07] to one hundred times per day, simply because she liked their phone number.
[11:11] But above anybody else, Jessica liked to call up Matthew Layfield and meet business
[11:16] owner and his employees. Jessica would incessantly call them up on their mobile phones,
[11:22] making hundreds of calls a day. When they attempt to determinate the conversation,
[11:28] she would unleash a tirade of violent language. She often ended the conversation
[11:35] by threatening to stab them and cut their head off with a knife. Was
[11:41] calls went along the lines of you're going to die of fucking cancer. If
[11:46] not, I will stab you until you die, you motherfucker. Eventually,
[11:52] Matthew was able to trace the cause and he spoke with Rita about her daughter's
[11:56] behavior. Rita told him that Jessica had seen his photograph on the company's website
[12:03] and developed an obsessive crush on him. The phone calls only continued, and
[12:09] Rita confided in Matthew that she was at her wits end and didn't know how
[12:13] to control her daughter anymore. The phone calls didn't stop Jessica instead found the
[12:20] phone number of Matthew's wife and threatened to chop her head off and flush it
[12:24] down the toilet. The bizarre phone calls became so incessant that on the same
[12:31] day as the interaction on Facebook between Rita and Jessica, Rita ended up taking
[12:37] Jessica to Saint Mary's police station to report that she was constantly harassing Matthew,
[12:43] his employees, and his wife. Senior Constable A Lee Roth spoke to Jessica
[12:48] about the phone calls and ordered her to stop. If you're a fan of
[12:56] captivating mysteries with surprising plot twists, then look no further than June's Journey.
[13:01] This game is the perfect choice for those seeking a classic Who'd Done It.
[13:05] In June's Journey, you join forces with the charming amateur detective June Parker and
[13:11] embark on a quest to uncover the truth behind her sister's murder and on earth
[13:16] some long kept family secrets. With over one thousand meticulously designed scenes, your
[13:22] observation skills will be put to the test as you search for hidden clues and
[13:26] crucial information. Immerse yourself in the glamor and splendor of the nineteen twenties with
[13:31] June's Journey stunning graphics and engaging gameplay. I've personally been obsessed with its mobile
[13:37] puzzle game for well over a year now, often finding myself engrossed until the
[13:41] later hours of the night, using it as a way to unwind and relax.
[13:46] One of the best features of June's Journey for me personally is the opportunity
[13:50] to personalize your own island estate and collaborate with the Detective Club, where you
[13:56] can join forces with fellow sleuths. Can the Case Donald June's Journey for free
[14:01] on iOS and Android. As Jessica's obsession with the phone calls worsened, so
[14:11] did her obsession with horror movies. She had a keen fascination in the genre.
[14:18] The gorrier the better. Among her favorites were The Texas Chainsaw Massacre and
[14:22] Cheeper's Creepers, which she had thirteen copies of. As her older sister,
[14:26] Christie said she'd liked horror movies where there was killing and dismemberment. She also
[14:33] liked certain scenes in the movies and would often rewind to the most graphic parts.
[14:39] readA didn't think that the movies were doing her daughter any good, but
[14:43] still they kept her preoccupied. Unfortunately, Jessica's ongoing battle with mental health had
[14:50] created a rift in the family. Her behavior had left her sister feeling uneasy
[14:54] about entrusting her four year old grandson to read its care. Though she had
[15:01] complete faith in her own mother's abilities, the thought of leaving the child alone
[15:05] while Jessica was there was a source of great concern. Jessica went through periods
[15:09] where her conditions presented themselves in lesser ways, and as July two thousand and
[15:15] nineteen approached, there seemed to be some improvement in her mental state other than
[15:20] the incessant phone calls. While she had been making progress, she still experienced
[15:26] unpredictable bouts of instability due to her mental health struggles. As one Frand recalled,
[15:33] she may have been coping better recently, but she was severely paranoid.
[15:37] Sometimes the change can be instant. Jessica could be fine and going well,
[15:41] but that doesn't mean there aren't moments of instability. Rita's grandson was described as
[15:50] the light of her life, and on the twentieth of July two thousand and
[15:54] nineteen, she was over the moon. When Christie agreed that he could stay
[16:00] overnight. The night of the twentieth of July twenty nineteen was like any other
[16:23] night for Ali Bostani. It was close to midnight and he was winding down
[16:27] for the night, getting readied ahead to bed. Suddenly, the quiet night
[16:33] was pierced by deafening screams. Seconds later, he heard the desperate cries of
[16:38] a woman shouting for help. Before Ali even had a chance to look outside
[16:45] to search for the source of the noise, he heard a knock on his
[16:48] front door. Ali opened up the front door to see twenty five year old
[16:55] Jessica camal Arry standing there. Her face, hands, and night dress were
[17:00] covered in blood. Her eyes were wide and frantic as she yelled, I
[17:06] need help. Ali responded, what sort of help do you need? Jessica
[17:11] was exasperated as she said she needed him to call for police in an ambulance.
[17:18] Ali was afraid. He wondered if there was a killer lurking around the
[17:22] neighborhood. The presence of blood certainly indicated that something the faiius had happened.
[17:29] Jessica then chillingly announced, yeah, I had a fight with my mum.
[17:33] I killed my mum in the hours before Jessica showed up at Ali's front door.
[17:40] Jessica and Rieda had walked past a man in a local car park.
[17:44] Jessica's paranoia perceived this as her mother humiliating her in front of the man.
[17:51] Jessica's strange behavior continued into the night and resulted in Rida phoning an on call
[17:56] medical service. She told them that Jessica was feeling unwell and acting strange.
[18:03] A doctor came over to the family home, but she attempted to leave without
[18:07] giving a consultation. She felt as though Jessica was substance affected and had felt
[18:14] uncomfortable. She went to leave, Jessica chased her down the driveway. After
[18:21] the doctor left, Jessica repeatedly called up a fast food restaurant. She asked
[18:26] the worker on the other end of the line to tell her that she loved
[18:30] her. Rita was at a loss of what to do. She thought that
[18:36] Jessica had been improving, but today they were just back at square one.
[18:41] Reading through that Jessica needed psychiatric assistance, and she broached the subject once more
[18:45] with her daughter. This led to a disagreement between the mother and daughter.
[18:52] Jessica lashed out and Rita grabbed her cell phone to call Triple zero. Jessica
[18:57] knocked the phone out of her mother's hand with a slap. The argument quickly
[19:03] escalated, with Jessica pulling her mother's hair and dragging her into the kitchen,
[19:07] Ultimately reaching the knife drawer. She proceeded to open it and grabbed a knife.
[19:14] Rita's grandson had woken up by this point and watched in terror as the
[19:18] events on folded. As soon as Jessica seized the knife, he sought shelter.
[19:26] Jessica then proceeded to viciously stab Rita in the head and neck area,
[19:32] while Rita voliantly attempted to protect herself from her daughter. During the assault,
[19:37] Jessica used seven separate knives. The force of the stabbings had been so strong
[19:41] that three of them broke In a gruesome display of cruelty, Jessica then cut
[19:48] off her own mother's head. She then picked it up by the hair and
[19:55] carried it outside and tossed it onto the sidewalk outside her neighbor's home. Before
[20:02] Jessica alerted neighbors of the incident, she placed a triple zero call to police.
[20:08] Oh Hello, this is Allison from police. Emergency. We just received
[20:12] a call from this number. Yes, I need you to get the ambulance
[20:17] and the police out up immediately to witch address one hundred and twenty eight thank
[20:21] Clair Avenue. Please come, I need you. This is our immediate last
[20:25] or jestitu, I wish that verbile town? Is that in Sinclair Avenue?
[20:30] Sinclair? And what's the nearest cross road please? In the film call,
[20:34] Jessica claimed that her mother had enough of her and got a knife out an
[20:37] attempted to stab her. According to Jessica, she grabbed the knife from Rita's
[20:42] hand and stabbed her instead. On the film call, Jessica could be heard
[20:48] starting, I just kept starving and stabbing and stabbing her. I took off
[20:53] her head. Had enough of me because I'd made up being a challenge in
[20:57] this ongoing thing's been going for months and months. Anyway, she had enough
[21:03] of me. She grabbed me by the hair and dragged me from my room
[21:06] all the way to the kitchen, and she got a knife and she tried
[21:08] to stab me with it, and I grabbed a knife of her because I
[21:11] thought she was going to stab me, So I stabbed her back, and
[21:15] I was so heated up with anger. I just kept stabbing and stabbing and
[21:18] stabbing her, and I took off her head. Her head is I ran
[21:23] to my neighbor, not this neighbor, my other neighbor before this month.
[21:27] He was on the other side. He was at work. I told him
[21:30] to call the Ambliance and the police immediately. He's going to do so,
[21:33] but no one's at home because everyone in the family is at work now,
[21:36] so he wasn't as much help. He said, all I can do is
[21:38] off call the police and the Ambliance to my address. And I thought it
[21:41] was going to take a bit of time. So I ran to my other
[21:44] neighbor on the other side, and I had my mum's head in my hand.
[21:48] I know this sounds insane. She also commented that she had taken Reader's
[21:52] head to show the neighbors. During the call, Jaska handed the phone over
[21:56] to your neighbor, explaining, my hands bleeding. Listen, can you can
[22:02] you talk to the neighbor on clustered? Can you just talk to you?
[22:06] What Rochford Street is it? Could you because on my hands bleeding? Yes?
[22:10] Thank you? Can you talk to Oh? Yeah, what happened?
[22:17] I don't know. It was just at home, but that she just come
[22:22] in and screaming for help. And when Solndia opened the door, she said
[22:26] that just helped me and called the police or embulance. And she said to
[22:30] me she had a tried with her mom. I think, okay, um,
[22:34] my mom trying to SI and ipic. So did she just say her
[22:40] mom tried to stab her? I don't know, because yes, I don't
[22:44] know, and I I think I killed her. Yeah. Can you tell
[22:48] them to come immediately? Yeah? Can you please just come immediately? Please?
[22:52] Okay, So she believed that she may have killed her her mother.
[22:56] This neighbor wasn't totally aware of the situation, and he hadn't noticed to read
[23:00] his head that was lying nearby on the sidewalk. He said to the operator,
[23:07] she said she had a fight with her mum. I think. Jessica
[23:11] could be heard in the background telling the neighbor, can you tell them to
[23:14] come immediately? My fingers are broken. Jessica then took the phone back and
[23:19] told the operator that her mom had enough of her because she had been a
[23:22] challenge. She stated, she grabbed me by the hair and dragged me all
[23:27] the way to the kitchen and she got a knife and tried to stab me
[23:32] with it. With sirens blazing, police and paramedics rushed to the crime scene.
[23:48] Upon arrival, Jessica was standing in the front yard of Ali's home.
[23:52] She was covered in blood and clutching tightly to a bottle of water. As
[23:56] soon as police approached her, she told them that she had killed her mother
[24:00] and pointed towards Rita's decapitated head. During the conversation, Jessica's profound struggles with
[24:07] mental health became apparent when she asked whether it was possible to bring somebody back
[24:11] to life after their head had been severed. Senior Constable Anthony Dagostino responded,
[24:19] no, that's a bit of a stretch. Jessica replied, I'm sorry,
[24:25] but my mom's had enough of me. She then continuously asked for confirmation that
[24:29] there was nothing that could be done to bring Rita back to life. The
[24:33] constable replied, I'm certain that once you lose your head, that's it.
[24:38] As the officers placed Jessica into handcuffs, she continued to talk about the incident.
[24:45] She said, this was self defense. My mom picked up the knife
[24:49] first. This is all self defense. But nobody's going to believe me,
[24:55] She continued, stating, I've been in and out of a mental health unit.
[25:00] I've got a mental illness. I've got a lot of things. I
[25:03] can't really explain it to you much. At one point, she told the
[25:07] constable that she had never murdered anybody in her life. She then added this
[25:12] is a first, and then questioned whether in a decade, if this will
[25:17] pass. She then said, I'm sure I can apologize to her in heaven.
[25:22] When I crossed to the other side once more, Jessica then said,
[25:27] listen, officer, I know I've asked this like twenty million times. Now
[25:33] I'm going to ask you one more time. There's nothing you can do.
[25:36] She's a goner, isn't she. He replied, she's deceased. Unfortunately yes.
[25:42] Throughout the conversation, Jessica repeatedly claimed that her mother was abusive and that
[25:48] she had been provoked. It was, sadly, just another display of Jessica's
[25:52] profound mental illness. Either she was making it up or her mental illness made
[25:59] her believe that what she was saying was actually true. At one stage,
[26:03] Jessica appeared to be concerned as to what was going to happen to her.
[26:08] She asked, is anything going to happen to me? Do I get the
[26:12] death penalty? The constable responded, we don't do the death penalty in Australia.
[26:19] Jessica appeared to be relieved as she said, okay, so I've got
[26:25] nothing to worry about. As Jessica was placed into handcuffs, the responding officers
[26:30] followed the trail of blood into the family home. Here they were made by
[26:34] a scene that none of them would ever forget. They followed the blood into
[26:40] the kitchen, where they found Rita's headless body. She was lying faced down
[26:45] between a cutlery drawer and a paltry. Underneath her neck were two intact eyeballs.
[26:52] To the right of her leg was her tongue, and near the fridge,
[26:56] the officers found the tip of her nose. Being transported to Saint Mary's
[27:00] Police station, Jessica was taken into an interrogation room, where she told investigators
[27:07] that she had argued with her mother. According to Jessica, Rita had threatened
[27:11] to have her admitted to a mental health facility. Jessica alleged that Rita told
[27:18] her, I want you out of my life. I deserve to have a
[27:22] free and happy life. Jessica further claimed that Rita grabbed her by the hair
[27:26] and dragged her into the kitchen, where a frantic struggle ensued. She alleged
[27:32] that her mother grabbed a knife first. She commented, she wanted to kill
[27:37] me. I don't know what her intentions were. She was so frustrated and
[27:41] confused. Jessica said that she got the knife off of Rita and then stabbed
[27:47] her more than eighty five times. She chillingly added that she wanted to give
[27:52] her mother a taste of her own medication. According to Jessica, however,
[27:56] she never intended on killing her mother, even though she had been stabbed more
[28:00] than one hundred times and her head had been cut off. She said that
[28:03] she only wanted to stab her enough to make her unconscious. She then admitted
[28:08] that she couldn't stop herself and continued to stab her long after she fell unconscious.
[28:15] She stated, she tried to do it to me. I thought she
[28:18] was going to do it to me. That's why I beat her to it.
[28:23] During the interview, Jessica also said that she wasn't fit to go to
[28:27] jail. She stated, I've got a really bad illness. The only place
[28:33] I'm probably fit for is a group home. She then added, I understand
[28:38] my family or probably not going to want me after this, she wants more.
[28:44] Claimed that Rita had grabbed her by her hair and threatened her with the
[28:47] knife. She estimated that she had stabbed her mother more than eighty five times.
[28:53] Jessica had wasted no time in attributing the responsibility for her mother's murder on
[28:59] to reader her. Along with her claim of acting in self defense, Jessica
[29:04] also asserted that her mother had previously physically assaulted her. This was in stark
[29:10] contrast to the general perception of the relationship between Jessica and Rita is everybody believed
[29:15] that Jessica was the violent one, while Rita attended to be submissive and avoid
[29:22] confrontation by complying with her youngest daughter's demands. In announcing the gruesome murder to
[29:27] the public, Detective Superintendent Brett McFadden said that it was up there as one
[29:33] of the most significant and horrific scenes that investigators had ever faced. He said,
[29:40] there's no stepping away from the fact that this was horrific and a significant
[29:44] attack. The injuries that the fickth them suffered were extensive. The scene was
[29:49] so horrific, in fact, that support was immediately provided to the paramedics and
[29:55] officers who responded to the residents. Detective superintend McFadden stated, there are things
[30:02] police are required to do on a day to day basis, but this is
[30:06] one of the most horrific and distressing scenes. Jessica appeared in court via video
[30:12] link the following day, where no application was made for bale. During the
[30:18] brief court hearing, she said that she needed medical attention. She said,
[30:22] I can't move my fingers because of the incident. My whole body is an
[30:26] agony. I couldn't even wash myself in the shower to get all the blood
[30:30] off. Jessica's defense attorney told the judge that his clients suffered from severe mental
[30:36] health issues. Jessica then said to the judge that she had borderline autism,
[30:41] bipolar disorder, and anxiety. The judge ordered that she be sent to the
[30:45] hospital for a medical assessment. In the week of the murder, Jessica's friends
[30:52] and relatives expressed the opinion the prison would not be the appropriate place for her
[30:56] if she were convicted. One friend did, prison isn't what anybody wants to
[31:03] see. She needs to be somewhere that she will get help she needs.
[31:07] Following the murder, section thirty two of the Mental Health Act came under fire.
[31:12] The Mental Health Act ninety ninety. Section thirty two confers the court with
[31:17] the authority to redirect and offender who has a mental health condition towards the care
[31:22] and treatment of mental health experts instead of prosecuting them through the criminal justice system.
[31:29] This meant that the family of a mentally ill person could negotiate their discharge
[31:33] from a mental health unit if it was determined that there was no risk to
[31:37] themselves or to the general public. Tragically, however, that could often back
[31:42] fire. There was no coordinating body to link all of the services, so
[31:48] it often fell upon families to carry the responsibility, and it could often be
[31:52] very complicated. Jessica had been charged unreleased four times under section thirty two,
[32:00] and data showed that there had been a steady increase in charge is dismissed under
[32:05] section thirty two from four thousand and thirty four and two thousand and seventeen,
[32:12] four thousand, five hundred and eighty five and two thousand and eighteen and four
[32:15] thousand, seven hundred and sixty five and two thousand and nineteen. The majority
[32:21] of those grandad as Saction thirty two were sent to live with a loved one.
[32:24] The week after Reader was killed, the Office of Attorney General Mark Speakman
[32:30] said that they were going to review what orders were made by magistrate under Section
[32:35] thirty two At the time. Professor Ian Hickey, a prominent psychiatrist from Sydney's
[32:40] University Brandon Mind Center, urged for an immediate reassessment of the assistance offered to
[32:46] mental health caregivers. He stated, it's very rare and bizarre that somebody who
[32:52] is mentally ill becomes violent. It throws into question the effectiveness of the mental
[32:58] health system and whether this tragedy could have been avoided. What he said was
[33:02] true. It's a common misconception that those who are mentally ill pose a significant
[33:07] danger to society, but studies have shown that they are in fact more likely
[33:12] to be a danger to themselves than to others. People who struggle with mental
[33:16] illness are often at a higher risk of suicide and self harm as opposed to
[33:22] homicide. Did you know that the University of our Zona's forecasters have issued a
[33:30] warning regarding the upcoming hurricane season in two thousand and twenty three that it's projected
[33:35] to be similar to that of two thousand and seventeen. In light of this,
[33:38] they strongly urge everybody to take necessary precautions and be prepared for any potential
[33:44] impact. Have you ever wondered just how catastrophic hurricane can be. Consider the
[33:49] impact of Hurricane Ida on the Gulf Coast. Countless homes were destroyed, power
[33:52] outages affected millions, and resulting floods rendered roads impossible, which made it impossible
[33:59] for growing three stores to replenish their supplies. There's a way to ensure your
[34:02] family's well being in such crisises emergency food kits from four Patriots. These kits
[34:08] consist of long lasting and tasty food options, purposefully crafted to provide sustenance when
[34:15] you need it most. Their food kits are handpicked in the United States,
[34:17] last up to twenty five years and offer a wide variety of delicious meals.
[34:22] Remember, Four Patriots survival food is not limited to natural disasters. In today's
[34:28] world, where supply chains are uncertain and emergencies are unpredictable, it's more crucial
[34:31] than ever to have a backup plan and right now you can go to four
[34:36] Patriot stock Com and use the code more bidology to get ten percent of your
[34:39] first purchase on anything in the store, including the emergency food supply kits designed
[34:45] to last up to twenty five years. Just go to four patriot stock Com
[34:50] and use the code more bidology to get ten percent off your first purchase four
[34:54] Patriots Survival Food that's for Patriots dot com and use the code morbidology. As
[35:05] the case was making its way through the justice system, Rita's grandson was left
[35:09] traumatized by the ordeal. His grandfather said to The Daily Telegraph, he's not
[35:15] too bad considering, but he's shaken up. We're keeping him close. We're
[35:21] staying with him twenty four seven. To help him cope, the family arranged
[35:25] for him to receive counseling from a child psychologist, who encouraged him to express
[35:30] his feelings through art and communication. The family also kept a watchful eye on
[35:35] his behavior, as he had become noticeably quiet and withdrawn. Then, on
[35:40] the tenth of August, Jessica was back in court. Investigators were given permission
[35:46] to analyze psychological samples from Jessica, which included swabs of blood, nail clippings
[35:52] and hair samples. When she was asked whether she understood the nature of the
[35:58] procedure, she responded yes and no. It's just that I have a disability.
[36:02] It's very hard for me to comprehend things and understand things. Jessica appeared
[36:08] to be on the verge of tears as she added, I don't remember what
[36:13] was done. There were so many things done on that night when that happened.
[36:19] Towards the end of the month, Rada's other daughter, Christie said,
[36:23] my mother and sister are both gone. We're going through hell. She made
[36:28] reference to Jessica's mental instability and commented, jess is really really not well,
[36:35] accompering myself to talk about what we're going through. There was a review in
[36:40] the Mental Health Act under way, and in January of two thousand and twenty,
[36:45] the attention turned to the mentally ill and how magistrate's decided on whether to
[36:49] release them into treatment or give them a criminal sentence. Attorney General Marks Speakman
[36:55] spoke about Rada's murder during a review. He st did the death of Raiatea
[37:00] camill Arry is a horrific tragedy. I cannot begin to comprehend the pain and
[37:06] trauma her family have suffered. The New South Wales government has listened to the
[37:10] concerns of the community, with the Department of Communities and Justice consulting more than
[37:15] thirty experts and members of the community as part of this ongoing review. Meanwhile,
[37:23] Jessica was ordered to undergo a psychiatric assessment to determine whether she was competent
[37:28] to stand trial. She appeared in court via video link in May, where
[37:32] her defense attorney, Nathan Steele, revealed that a medical professional determined that she
[37:37] was fit to stand trial. He said an issue of fitness was raised at
[37:43] local court, hence the matter has been committed up to the Supreme Court.
[37:47] Since that was raised, we have received a report from Professor Greenberg. He's
[37:52] of the view that missus Cami Larry is fit to stand trial. He revealed
[37:58] that the defense team was also part of the view that she was competent for
[38:01] the case to proceed to trial. Jessica subsequently pleaded not guilty to the murder
[38:07] of her mother, and she requested a bench trial as opposed to a jury
[38:12] trial. A bench trial is illegal proceeding in which a judge hears and decides
[38:16] a case without a jury present. In a bench trial, the judge acts
[38:22] as both the fact finder and the decision maker, assessing the evidence presented and
[38:28] applying the relevant law to determine the outcome of the case. Ultimately, the
[38:34] judge denied her request and said that she would be tried in front of a
[38:37] jury. He set the trial date for November of two and twenty. Before
[38:44] leaving court, Jessica said sure, thank you very much, your honor.
[38:49] See you then on December first, two thousand and twenty, the trial was
[39:05] set to commence with a jury in place. Both the prosecution and defense agreed
[39:09] that Jessica had stabbed her mother to death, but they differed on the charge.
[39:15] The prosecution contended that Jessica was guilty of murder, while the defense argued
[39:20] that it should be reduced to manslaughter due to her substantial impairment of the mind,
[39:25] which made it impossible for her to control her actions at the time.
[39:30] During opening, Stateman's prosecutor Tony McCarthy said that Rita was said to be overly
[39:35] protective and defensive of Jessica's behavior, and said that she often implicated her to
[39:39] avoid a conflict. He informed the jury that Jessica had claimed on the Triple
[39:45] zero phone call and in a police interrogation that her mother had grabbed the knife
[39:49] first, but he said that it was the prosecution's case that the murder was
[39:53] in no way self defense. Defense attorney Nathan Steele urged the jury to put
[39:59] their emotion sympathy to the side and decide the case based on evidence. He
[40:04] said that Jessica had injured a build up of stressers. He said that dude
[40:08] of the effects of her mental illness, she had an impaired capacity at the
[40:12] time of the events. He said to the jury that they would hear from
[40:15] forensic psychiatrists who agreed that his client was substantially impaired from long standing mental illness.
[40:23] Among the first witnesses to testify where Kirsty, Rita's other daughter, and
[40:29] family friend Jane Arena. They quickly got to dispelling Jessica's claims that Rita had
[40:34] been violent with her in the past. They both said how Jessica was extremely
[40:39] demanding of her mother, would often shout and scream at her. Despite this,
[40:45] Rita always stood up for Jessica. Kirsty said that she had never once
[40:50] seen her mother behave in a violent martyr Rather Rita would alloy Jessica off the
[40:54] hook for any negative behavior, would always give in to her demand. Professor
[41:00] David Greenberg testified next. He said that Jessica was increasingly concerned aboy being sent
[41:07] to a psychiatric hospital that she saw red. He had interviewed Jessica after the
[41:13] murder and said that she was in a fit of rage when she dragged Rita
[41:15] by her hair during the corridor before opening up the knife drawer to scare her.
[41:23] Her comments to Professor Greenberg contradicted her earlier comments to police that Rita had
[41:29] dragged her by her hair into the kitchen to grab a knife. Jessica had
[41:35] even admitted to Professor Greenberg that Rita had never grabbed her by the hair,
[41:38] but said that she had slapped her on the arm and leg with an open
[41:43] hand. She said that her mother had done this because she was at her
[41:46] wits end with her behavior. The professor then asked Jessica how parts of Rita's
[41:52] face had come off, including her tongue, nose, and eyes. She
[41:59] replied, I think I did that. I was so angry. I think
[42:04] I had sick thoughts. I used to watch horror movies. I got off
[42:07] on horror movies, one of them where this guy kills all the guys.
[42:13] I remember he cut off their heads and removed their eyes and tongue. She
[42:17] continued telling the doctor about this aspect of the crime. She said that she
[42:22] had opened up Rida's eyes and pulled out her eyeballs to see whether the stab
[42:29] wounds were coming through her eyes. She then admitted to biting off the tip
[42:34] of her mother's nose and said that her tongue had come off when she was
[42:38] decapitated. Both Professor Greenberg and doctor Richard First testified that Jessica was suffering from
[42:46] a mental impairment and couldn't control herself during the attack on Rida. They both
[42:52] diagnosed her with an intellectual disability and autism spectrum disorder. The features on fixation
[43:00] on horror movies and figurings. When her bedroom was searched, investigators found a
[43:06] crocodile dondfiguring that was missing its head. Doctor First said that Jessica had a
[43:13] warped response to the film's and violent fantasy may have been a subconscious driving factor
[43:17] during the attack, possibly providing at template in which to act when the anger
[43:22] came out. He testified once things escaluted to that point that the knife was
[43:29] there, that subconscious driver was what drove her to that extreme end. She
[43:34] had a longstanding deficiency in her capacity for self control when emotionally stressed and angry,
[43:40] and also when come it's like kids having tantrums. This is an adult
[43:45] version of that. Doctor First also attributed Jessica's impairment to obsessive compulsive disorder.
[43:52] Professor Greenberg diagnosed her with an intermittent explosive disorder, which is a mental health
[43:58] condition category rised by episodes of impulsive, aggressive, and violent behavior that are
[44:05] out of proportion to the situation. He said that this was behind her long
[44:09] history of anger based impulsive outbursts disproportionate to provocation. He said that she understood
[44:16] wrong from right, but when she lost control, she exploded like a bomb.
[44:21] He proceeded to explain that Jessica's outbursts stemmed from anger rather than premeditation or
[44:27] a calculated plan. He stated that something is minor as a stranger looking at
[44:31] her the wrong way could trigger her, but if somebody physically touched her,
[44:36] she would completely lose her composure. He informed the jury that Jessica held an
[44:40] unreasonable expectation of receiving preferential treatment, had a history of seeking attention, and
[44:47] had struggled with low self esteem, yet maintained a sense of entitlement. He
[44:52] further testified that Jessica's obsession with violent movies could have resulted in her learning how
[44:58] to have gold erect and targeted aggression. He told the jury that people with
[45:02] AFT lack the ability to understand others feelings. He stated, when she reveals
[45:09] Macabe details about how she killed her mother, she doesn't use social gestures in
[45:15] the sense of communicating that. There's a bland lack of emotion on her face
[45:20] when she's discussing these difficult emotional topics. According to doctor Greenberg, it was
[45:27] his opinion that, based on the comorbid psychiatric diagnosis, Jessica's ability to control
[45:32] herself was substantially impaired by her abnormality of mind arising from her underlying conditions.
[45:40] Doctor First disagreed about the diagnosis of intermittent explosive disorder and said that her outbursts
[45:47] could have been explained with the scope of the other two disorders. He said,
[45:53] basically, it's like a kid having tantrums. Following the doctor's testimony trial
[46:00] concluded and it was now time for closing arguments. Prosecutor McCarthy said that what
[46:06] Jessica had done with her mother's head after cutting it off, including the mutilation,
[46:10] showed a curiosity with death as opposed to it being an indicator of her
[46:15] losing control. He stated, the crime submits to you that these acts he
[46:20] accused, explanation why she did them, or evidence that they accused, was
[46:24] at least at that point operating out of a morbid curiosity with death, dismemberment
[46:30] and decapitation. The prosecutor went on to say that it was their opinion that
[46:35] Jessica had set out that night to decapitate her mother. He revealed that there
[46:38] were numerous stab wounds to raid his head and neck and only two superficial stab
[46:44] wounds to her lower torsu. He said that the only inference available to the
[46:50] jury from the evidence of the stab wounds is that the focus during the attack
[46:53] was to raid his head and neck. Rita also had a number of defensive
[46:59] wounds to the hands, suggesting that she had attempted to defend herself. In
[47:05] fact, there were over ninety defensive wounds which showed that Rada was alive,
[47:09] as each one of those wounds was inflicted. Defense attorney Steele said to the
[47:15] jury during his closing address the Jessica's attack on her mother was not premeditated and
[47:20] that it was instead a spontaneous anger based response to multiple stressors. That stressor,
[47:25] he suggested, was Rita wanting to try and ring at triple zero to
[47:30] get Jessica help, combined with her trip to the police station for the harassing
[47:35] phone calls and the doctor who came out earlier in the night but left without
[47:39] addressing her. He went on to say that Jessica was Rada's only friend in
[47:44] life. He stated the person she was attacking was her sole supporter and carer,
[47:52] and in effect, her only friend. If the jury determined that Jessica's
[47:57] mental disorders constituted a significant can impairment, the partial defense of substantial impairment would
[48:04] apply. In such a scenario, the jury could find her guilty of manslaughter
[48:08] as opposed to murder. After concluding the closing arguments, the jury were dismissed
[48:15] to deliberate. Before their deliberation, Justice Helen Wilson provided a summary of the
[48:21] case and emphasize that their verdict hinged on whether Jessica was guilty of murder or
[48:25] manslaughter based on her mental state at the time of the offense. She stated,
[48:31] this is a question where your role as representatives of the community is particularly
[48:37] important because you're asked to consider whether the impairment was so substantial as to warrant
[48:43] Miss Camillarry's liability for murder being reduced to manslaughter. The jury deliberated for two
[48:50] days before returning with the verdict. They found Jessica Camillarry guilty of manslaughter instead
[48:57] of murder. As the verdict was annoyed, Jessica began to smile and nod
[49:02] outside of court. Or defense team said that she was relieved with the decision,
[49:07] while Detective Sergeant Grant Gilbert said that there were no winners. In February
[49:23] of two and twenty one, the sentencing phase took place, preceded by the
[49:29] presentation of victim impact statements. During this phase, Christie expressed that she could
[49:35] neither forgive nor forget her sister for her actions. She recounted how her mother
[49:40] was killed and butcher like she was nothing, all because of a fit of
[49:45] rage. She held back tears as she described her mother as having a heart
[49:50] of gold and always putting people before herself, including her daughter. She described
[49:57] how her sister had all the support she needed, but said that she refused
[50:00] the help because she preferred the attention that her behavior attracted. Instead, she
[50:07] said that despite Jessica's increasing disturbing behavior, Rider had believed her love could protect
[50:13] her from the world. The courtland fell silent as Rita's sister, Mary Hill,
[50:20] took the stand. Her sorrow was palpable as she struggled to articulately at
[50:24] the magnitude of her loss, describing it as a double edged sword that went
[50:30] beyond trauma. Mary went on to reflect Rita's remarkable love for her daughter,
[50:36] steering Rita's unconditional love for her daughter was remarkable. She was blindsided and couldn't
[50:43] see what I could see. Mary went on to say that the family had
[50:47] been let on time and time again by the mental health services. She said,
[50:53] until more resources in funding is put towards essential mental health services, there
[50:59] will more tragic cases that come before the courts like ours. Her emotional stamens
[51:05] were followed by Stephanie Cook, Rita's niece. She described the incident as a
[51:09] tragedy the family had been trying to avoid for half of Jessica's life. She
[51:15] described how Jessica had controlled and bullied her mother through her dominant behavior, and
[51:20] said that she was slowly killing her even before the incident. She said,
[51:25] I knew she was deeply disturbed for a long time. She frightened me at
[51:30] the best of times. The family all said that they feared for the day
[51:35] that Jessica was released from prison. A fred that she would come for them
[51:39] next. Missus Camillary, would you stand up please? You may stand as
[51:45] well if you think that assists Miss support Officer for the manslaughter of Rica Camillary
[51:54] on the twentieth of July twenty nineteen. The offender is sentenced to a term
[51:59] of prisonment for twenty one years and seven months, commencing on the twentieth of
[52:04] July twenty nineteen and expiring on the nineteenth of February twenty forty one. The
[52:09] non parole period is one of sixteen years and two months imprisonment, which will
[52:15] expire on the nineteenth of September twenty thirty five. You can sit down,
[52:20] miss Camilarry. Justice Helen Wilson sentenced to Jessica to twenty one years and seven
[52:25] months in prison in order that she must serve at least sixteen years and two
[52:30] months before being eligible for parole. The maximum sandence that could have been implosed
[52:36] for manslaughter was twenty five years. As the verdict was announced, Kirsty led
[52:42] out an audible gasp and said thank you, before she and the rest of
[52:46] the family erupted into sobs. In hunting down the santence, the judge referred
[52:52] to the attack as among the most serious instances of manslaughter. She said that
[52:59] the brutality was at worse by the fact that it was committed in Rider's own
[53:01] home and by her own beloved daughter. She further said that it was obvious
[53:07] Jessica knew that what she had done was wrong, because she lied to police
[53:12] right away and claimed that it was self defense. However, she accabted that
[53:15] Jessica was substantially impaired by multiple mental disorders. In any event, considerations of
[53:22] remorse and what remorse may or may not say about rehabilitation are largely irrelevant in
[53:29] the present instance, due to the offender's autism. Immediately after killing her mother,
[53:36] the offender's concern was for herself. She invented an account of having been
[53:40] attacked by her mother in an attempt to avoid responsibility for what she had done.
[53:46] In interviews with police officers, she repeatedly asked about her own future and
[53:52] what would happen to her, perhaps reflecting the narcissistic trays that Professor Greenberg identified.
[54:00] Professor Greenberg did not consider that the offender had any real capacity for remorse.
[54:05] He noted that she raised details of her mother's killing in a concrete,
[54:08] matter of fact manner and tone, without any emotion or remorse. In November
[54:16] of twenty twenty one, Jessica found herself in trouble once more after she was
[54:22] charged with attacking two prison officers, which included ripping the hair out of one
[54:25] of them. She had also assaulted another enemyate, who she accused of bullying
[54:30] her. It appeared as though no matter where Jessica went, trouble always followed.
[54:37] In September of the following year, Jessica appealed her sentence in the Court
[54:42] of Criminal Appeal. She argued that her loss of control during the attack was
[54:46] not properly considered by the jury. That appeal is still underway. Ritta carm
[54:54] Larry was painfully familiar with her daughter's struggles. She had tried seeking how from
[55:00] mental health professionals numerous times, but her daughter's pleased to return home always won
[55:06] her over. Day by day, Jessica's violent tendencies were escalating, but Rita
[55:12] couldn't have fathom that her own daughter would ever direct her violence towards her.
[55:17] However, that notion was completely shattered on that fitful day in July of two
[55:23] nineteen. Well, Bessie's that is it for this episode of Morbidology. As
[55:50] always, thank you so so much for listening. I'd like to say the
[55:53] biggest thank you to my newest supporters of on Petreon, Hannah, Crystal and
[55:59] Jennifer. If you'd like to support the show up on Patreon, you can
[56:02] do for as little as one dollar a month. There are absolutely no obligations
[56:07] and you can cancel anytime In exchange for your support, I upload bonus episodes
[56:13] of Morbitology, plus they're on on the regular podcast platforms. They also do
[56:17] add free and early release episodes behind the Scenes, which includes case files,
[56:23] bonus audio and videos, and I also send out a hundwritten thank you card
[56:29] along with some cool merch. Remember to check us out at moorbitology dot com
[56:34] for more information about this episode and to read or true farm articles. Until
[56:38] next time, take care of yourselves, stay safe, and have an amazing week.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
