# Labor’s budget promises fairness – does it deliver?

An episode of [7am](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1461999702), 12 May 2026, 17 min.

Audio: https://p.podderapp.com/2544644999/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/2fb3740d-3436-44af-8cc0-a91900716aa5/62723a1f-3e96-4fc4-882c-b25e0181da4d/bfa2f95e-9268-4f5e-bf1b-b44800e6c50f/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=70f29d90-2a63-48aa-bf8f-b25e0181da70

It was a budget framed around fairness for workers and for young people locked out of the housing market. Treasurer Jim Chalmers’ fifth budget restricts negative gearing – though not for anyone who was already doing it – while also promising to increase housing supply and deliver a $250 tax cut for workers. Chalmers wants the budget to be seen as ambitious – but is it? Today, press gallery journalist Karen Middleton, on what the Treasurer is promising - and whether it delivers. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Press gallery journalist, Karen Middleton Photo: AAP Image/Lukas Coch See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: Australia's long standing housing shortage is making homes unaffordable. This
[0:06] Speaker 1: challenge hits young workers and families hard, and we're addressing
[0:09] Speaker 1: it from every responsible angle.
[0:12] Speaker 2: It was a budget framed around fairness for workers and
[0:15] Speaker 2: for young people locked out of the housing market. The
[0:18] Speaker 2: Treasurer Jim Chalmer's fifth budget restricts negative gearing, though not
[0:22] Speaker 2: for anyone who was already doing it, while also promising
[0:26] Speaker 2: to increase housing supply and delivering a two hundred and
[0:29] Speaker 2: fifty dollars tax cut for workers.
[0:31] Speaker 1: Speaker, this is the most important and ambitious budget in decades.
[0:36] Speaker 1: Important because the world is throwing a lot of us
[0:39] Speaker 1: and this budget is about helping Australia deal with those challenges.
[0:43] Speaker 2: Charmers wants this budget to be seen as ambitious, but
[0:47] Speaker 2: is it. I'm Ruby Jones and you're listening to seven
[0:52] Speaker 2: Am Today Press Gallery journalist Karen Middleton on what the
[0:57] Speaker 2: Treasurer is promising and whether it delivers. It's Wednesday, May thirteenth,
[1:09] Speaker 2: so Karen, hello and welcome back to the show.
[1:12] Speaker 3: Thanks Ruby.
[1:13] Speaker 2: It's eight point thirty at night on Budget Night, which
[1:15] Speaker 2: is late, so let's get into it. I thought we
[1:18] Speaker 2: could begin with the part of the budget that everyone
[1:20] Speaker 2: has been talking about in the days and weeks leading
[1:23] Speaker 2: up to tonight. Housing we know that now that negative
[1:27] Speaker 2: gearing will be restricted to new homes as of tonight,
[1:31] Speaker 2: and capital gains tax concessions are also going to be
[1:34] Speaker 2: wound back. So tell me how all of this works.
[1:37] Speaker 4: That's right, So as of budget night tonight, anyone buying
[1:41] Speaker 4: a property will only be able to negatively gear it
[1:44] Speaker 4: if it's a newly built property, not an established one.
[1:48] Speaker 3: Anyone who's already got an established property will be able
[1:50] Speaker 3: to continue to negatively gear it.
[1:54] Speaker 4: In terms of capital gains tax, the fifty percent capital
[1:57] Speaker 4: gains tax discount that exists now is going to be
[2:00] Speaker 4: replaced by a return to what was the old system,
[2:03] Speaker 4: an inflation based cost assessment system. They'll also have a
[2:07] Speaker 4: minimum thirty percent tax applied now.
[2:10] Speaker 3: People buying new properties.
[2:12] Speaker 4: Will be able to choose which version of the system
[2:14] Speaker 4: they access to minimize their tax again to try and
[2:18] Speaker 4: boost the sale of new properties, but those with established
[2:22] Speaker 4: properties are going to lose that fifty percent discount now.
[2:24] Speaker 1: This will help rebalance the system, which is more generous
[2:27] Speaker 1: to assets than it is to labor, and help rebalance
[2:30] Speaker 1: a system where house prices have decoupled from incomes. Since
[2:35] Speaker 1: nineteen ninety nine, house prices have risen over four hundred percent,
[2:40] Speaker 1: more than twice as fast as average incomes. Our tax
[2:44] Speaker 1: changes will help about seventy five thousand Australians achieve the
[2:47] Speaker 1: dream of home ownership.
[2:49] Speaker 2: Okay, So these changes to negative gearing, as you say,
[2:52] Speaker 2: they come into effect now. So if you're buying a
[2:55] Speaker 2: house as of tonight, no negative gearing unless it's a
[2:58] Speaker 2: brand new property. That means, though, is that anyone who
[3:02] Speaker 2: has already been negative gearing for the past few decades
[3:05] Speaker 2: or years, they can just continue to do that for
[3:08] Speaker 2: however long their loan goes for. So the intergenerational inequity
[3:13] Speaker 2: that exists right now that the government says that it
[3:16] Speaker 2: is trying to address, how much does that really change?
[3:19] Speaker 3: Well, that's the.
[3:19] Speaker 4: Question the government's going to have to answer, and I
[3:21] Speaker 4: reckon I'll get that question quite a lot in the
[3:23] Speaker 4: next few days, because there'll be people who argue that
[3:27] Speaker 4: it's still inequitable.
[3:28] Speaker 3: If the people already in the market who've had.
[3:31] Speaker 4: The advantage and been able to access the housing market
[3:34] Speaker 4: my investment properties can continue to negatively gear them whereas
[3:38] Speaker 4: the people who had aspired to do that one day
[3:41] Speaker 4: will only be able to do that on new properties.
[3:43] Speaker 4: Now they will still be able to do that on
[3:45] Speaker 4: new properties, but there will be this debate I think
[3:47] Speaker 4: about whether it goes far enough to addressing the intergenerational
[3:51] Speaker 4: inequity issue. The government argues that there was no perfect
[3:55] Speaker 4: way to do this and that they had to have
[3:57] Speaker 4: a transition arrangement because they couldn't sort of holdless bolus
[4:01] Speaker 4: change the tax system for everyone already in the market.
[4:05] Speaker 4: But it's going to raise those kinds of questions and
[4:07] Speaker 4: maybe criticisms, Okay, And.
[4:10] Speaker 2: This is of course something that Anthony Albanizi said that
[4:13] Speaker 2: he wouldn't do. He went to the last election saying
[4:16] Speaker 2: that there would be no changes to negative gearing because
[4:18] Speaker 2: we've got a chance to rule it out now, and
[4:20] Speaker 2: I think it's important you rule it out if you
[4:22] Speaker 2: don't plan on.
[4:22] Speaker 3: Doing it, well, I have no plans to do it.
[4:25] Speaker 2: It's not our policy. His treasurer has now explicitly done
[4:29] Speaker 2: the opposite, and a lot is being made of that
[4:31] Speaker 2: broken promise. So why is the Albanesi government doing this now?
[4:36] Speaker 4: Well, it's fascinating Ruby because you're right. They said it
[4:39] Speaker 4: the election emphatically. In fact, the Prime Minister was quite
[4:42] Speaker 4: forceful with journalists who were asking him about this that
[4:45] Speaker 4: they were not going to make these changes. And they've
[4:48] Speaker 4: changed and they say that things have changed since the election.
[4:52] Speaker 4: And I think circumstances have changed, but there's going to
[4:55] Speaker 4: be a question about whether people accept the reasoning and
[4:58] Speaker 4: the argument in favor of breaking the promise. You've got
[5:01] Speaker 4: these kind of competing constituencies. You've got the people who
[5:06] Speaker 4: say we want the government to do something. It's got
[5:09] Speaker 4: a huge majority, it needs to do something to fix
[5:12] Speaker 4: a broken tax system. And those are people who don't
[5:15] Speaker 4: want to wait till the next election to have the
[5:17] Speaker 4: government come up with an idea and then get it indoors.
[5:20] Speaker 3: They say that's too slow.
[5:21] Speaker 4: Those people are putting pressure on the government now to
[5:24] Speaker 4: do something. And then you've got the people who quite
[5:27] Speaker 4: rightly say this is a broken promise. It's an egregious
[5:30] Speaker 4: broken promise. They said they wouldn't do it. I believe them,
[5:34] Speaker 4: and this is a breach of trust. And the government
[5:37] Speaker 4: is choosing to act on the first lot of people's
[5:41] Speaker 4: demands and thinks that it can manage the second lot
[5:45] Speaker 4: and it's interesting because I think because of the size
[5:48] Speaker 4: of their majority, that the number of seats they want
[5:50] Speaker 4: at the election, A lot of people are telling, you know,
[5:53] Speaker 4: focus groups, social researchers, polsters that they sort of were
[5:58] Speaker 4: surprised by the size of the majority already the government
[6:00] Speaker 4: got and that it now has the opportunity to do
[6:02] Speaker 4: something like a once in a generation thing because of
[6:05] Speaker 4: that majority, and it should act fast. So in some ways,
[6:08] Speaker 4: the old rules or the standard rules of don't break
[6:11] Speaker 4: a promise get flexibly interpreted even by voters. I think
[6:16] Speaker 4: when they decide that there's something that warrants doing something
[6:20] Speaker 4: about it right now, and that is what the government
[6:22] Speaker 4: is looking to and pointing to in its decision to
[6:25] Speaker 4: break the promise and make these changes.
[6:27] Speaker 1: I think people will be most focused on the positive
[6:30] Speaker 1: change that we're making in the tax system and in
[6:32] Speaker 1: the housing market. It has obviously involved a level of
[6:37] Speaker 1: political risk because we come to a different view. And
[6:40] Speaker 1: I've said in recent days and I really mean it,
[6:43] Speaker 1: one of the reasons I'm here taking these characteristically difficult
[6:47] Speaker 1: questions from you, Sarah, is because I do understand when
[6:49] Speaker 1: you come to a different view, you have to front
[6:50] Speaker 1: up and explain why and that's why I'm doing so.
[6:52] Speaker 2: Is the risk here, then, Karen, that no one is
[6:55] Speaker 2: happy with this policy, that property investors and the housing
[6:58] Speaker 2: lobby don't want the bubble to but for young people
[7:01] Speaker 2: who are trying to get into the market, that this
[7:03] Speaker 2: policy doesn't actually make a meaningful difference to them. So
[7:06] Speaker 2: all this political capital is being spent on something that
[7:09] Speaker 2: actually doesn't deliver.
[7:10] Speaker 3: That is the risk.
[7:11] Speaker 4: You know, what's the old saying that you can't please
[7:13] Speaker 4: all the people all the time, but you try to
[7:14] Speaker 4: please some of the people some of the time, and
[7:16] Speaker 4: the risk is that you upset all of the people
[7:19] Speaker 4: all at once. And that's what the government will be
[7:21] Speaker 4: hoping that it isn't doing. I guess it depends on
[7:25] Speaker 4: how effective its explanation is and how people receive that,
[7:29] Speaker 4: whether they decide that this is an important move to
[7:33] Speaker 4: fix the system, whether they accept that there has to
[7:36] Speaker 4: be a transition which entrenches some of that unfairness for
[7:40] Speaker 4: a while, or whether they think it doesn't go far
[7:44] Speaker 4: enough and we're going to punish the government accordingly.
[7:50] Speaker 2: Still to come tax cuts for working Australians parent A
[7:59] Speaker 2: central concern of this budget has been how the government
[8:01] Speaker 2: can weigh cost of living relief measures against the inflation risk.
[8:05] Speaker 2: So given that, can we talk a little about what
[8:08] Speaker 2: is in the budget that might help reduce costs for people.
[8:12] Speaker 4: Yeah, So there's been some speculation in the last week
[8:14] Speaker 4: or so that there might be some kind of extra
[8:16] Speaker 4: tax measure, and we have in fact seen that in
[8:18] Speaker 4: the budget tonight. It's called a Working Australian's tax offset
[8:22] Speaker 4: of two hundred and fifty dollars.
[8:24] Speaker 1: This offset is targeted to workers and it represents the
[8:28] Speaker 1: most meaningful permanent increase to the effective tax free threshold
[8:32] Speaker 1: since labor increased it more than a decade ago.
[8:36] Speaker 4: It doesn't come in until the second half of twenty
[8:39] Speaker 4: twenty seven and it won't be claimable until the end.
[8:43] Speaker 3: Of that tax year.
[8:44] Speaker 4: So really we're talking about an extra measure that people
[8:48] Speaker 4: would get in their pockets after probably the next election,
[8:51] Speaker 4: so it's a while away. But the other measure that
[8:54] Speaker 4: the government's introduced is this one thousand dollars to instant
[8:57] Speaker 4: tax deduction, and that's aimed at people who are claiming
[9:01] Speaker 4: lots of work related expenses in their tax return. It's
[9:04] Speaker 4: allowing them to claim up to one thousand dollars without
[9:07] Speaker 4: having to provide receipts. And now, yes, that's going to
[9:09] Speaker 4: be pretty welcome to a lot of people for whom
[9:11] Speaker 4: doing the tax is a huge headache. If you want
[9:14] Speaker 4: to claim more than one thousand dollars, you are going
[9:16] Speaker 4: to have to provide receipts. But up to one thousand
[9:19] Speaker 4: dollars you're be able to claim that instantly. It'll be
[9:21] Speaker 4: a faster way to do your tax. So that's going
[9:24] Speaker 4: to appeal to a lot of people. I think Treasury
[9:27] Speaker 4: is saying that something like six million people, working people
[9:30] Speaker 4: are going to benefit from that proposal that makes tax
[9:33] Speaker 4: time a little bit easier. One of the key things
[9:36] Speaker 4: the government is emphasizing is that all the money that
[9:39] Speaker 4: it's saving from the tax measures that it's making is
[9:42] Speaker 4: going towards funding other tax measures, like the tax cuts
[9:46] Speaker 4: that it announced a couple of years ago. So it's
[9:48] Speaker 4: talking about a broadly revenue neutral budget and it's trumpeting
[9:52] Speaker 4: the fact that it's re employing that money to the
[9:54] Speaker 4: benefit of the electric.
[9:57] Speaker 2: And this budget also cuts the permanent migration intake, which
[10:01] Speaker 2: is interesting. So is that an economic decision or a
[10:04] Speaker 2: political one?
[10:06] Speaker 4: Well, that's a very interesting question. On face value, it
[10:10] Speaker 4: looks to me like a political decision. The government's setting
[10:13] Speaker 4: the twenty twenty six twenty seven permanent Migration program planning
[10:17] Speaker 4: level at one hundred and eighty five thousand places, and
[10:20] Speaker 4: most of those over seventy percent are going to go
[10:23] Speaker 4: to skilled migrants. They're also going to prioritize applications from
[10:27] Speaker 4: people who are already on shore and those that are
[10:30] Speaker 4: offered to offshore applicants that are going to be targeting
[10:35] Speaker 4: high skilled migrants with high levels of education. But there
[10:38] Speaker 4: is also an admission in the budget papers that the
[10:41] Speaker 4: government's forecast net overseas migration levels have blown out. So
[10:46] Speaker 4: they had forecast in the midyear budget update that the
[10:50] Speaker 4: twenty twenty five twenty six level of net overseas migration
[10:54] Speaker 4: would be two hundred and sixty thousand. In fact, they're
[10:57] Speaker 4: now saying it's going to be two hundred and ninety
[10:59] Speaker 4: five thousand, So that's a blowout of thirty five thousand.
[11:02] Speaker 4: They say that's because not as many people are leaving
[11:04] Speaker 4: the country as there had been before. But on the
[11:07] Speaker 4: whole there's a new emphasis or an even greater emphasis,
[11:10] Speaker 4: on skilled migrants, on highly educated migrants, and on people
[11:15] Speaker 4: already here in Australia, so they're kind of pulling the
[11:17] Speaker 4: drawbridge up a little bit on new migrants, and you've
[11:20] Speaker 4: got to assume that that's at least in part response
[11:24] Speaker 4: to the sort of political climate we're seeing that delivered
[11:28] Speaker 4: paul En Hansen and her One Nation Party a seat
[11:31] Speaker 4: in the electron of Parah on the weekend, and that
[11:34] Speaker 4: is becoming a big issue around Australia, with the connection
[11:37] Speaker 4: between the number of migrants since the COVID lockdowns and
[11:41] Speaker 4: border closures and the economic pressures people are facing. Whether
[11:45] Speaker 4: or not those connections are fair, that's certainly something that
[11:48] Speaker 4: people are feeling. And the government is making a point
[11:52] Speaker 4: of emphasizing a tightening of the migration system in this
[11:56] Speaker 4: budget and it seems to be looking to those sort
[11:59] Speaker 4: of sentiments.
[12:00] Speaker 2: And the big message of this budget every budget has one,
[12:03] Speaker 2: is around fairness. Yet the biggest cut has been from
[12:06] Speaker 2: disability support thirty six billion from the NDAs, and when
[12:10] Speaker 2: it comes to intergenerational inequality, there are these real questions
[12:13] Speaker 2: I think about whether or not this budget will address
[12:16] Speaker 2: that in any meaningful way. So what is your assessment
[12:20] Speaker 2: of that messaging and whether the budget actually backs it up.
[12:25] Speaker 4: I think it's I mean, I think it's certainly moving
[12:27] Speaker 4: in that direction, and as we've been saying, there'll be
[12:30] Speaker 4: debate about whether it goes far enough. Certainly there is
[12:33] Speaker 4: some in new community that will point to what is
[12:35] Speaker 4: still being spent on things like the Orcus submarine deal
[12:40] Speaker 4: and things that weren't done, like the decision not to
[12:43] Speaker 4: tax the gas industry in a more onerous manner, and
[12:48] Speaker 4: say well, you know, why are you sort of doing
[12:50] Speaker 4: these things and not doing those things? And there are
[12:52] Speaker 4: places you could be saving money. But I think they
[12:54] Speaker 4: have made some pretty hard decisions here that will probably
[12:58] Speaker 4: ultimately be beneficial for the economy and fairer for the economy.
[13:03] Speaker 3: But they're going to be hard to manage them in
[13:04] Speaker 3: the short term.
[13:06] Speaker 4: It's interesting going back to the point we discussed about
[13:10] Speaker 4: the feedback they're getting from Australians about the desperation and
[13:14] Speaker 4: the desire for them to do something to change the system.
[13:17] Speaker 4: You know, I've got a piece in the Monthly this
[13:19] Speaker 4: month looking at the levels of anxiety in the community
[13:22] Speaker 4: and the sorts of sentiment that is delivering support to
[13:24] Speaker 4: Paul Enhancement's One Nation and talked.
[13:27] Speaker 3: To some polsters and social researchers about that.
[13:30] Speaker 4: And one of the messages that came through there from people,
[13:32] Speaker 4: which I thought was really fascinating, was the sentiment that
[13:35] Speaker 4: if you've got two houses, the tax system helps you
[13:38] Speaker 4: more than if you've got two jobs. And that is
[13:42] Speaker 4: the sentiment really that we've heard from Jim Chalmers in
[13:44] Speaker 4: the delivery of his budget, the press conference that he
[13:46] Speaker 4: gave explaining the budget in the lock up to journalists,
[13:49] Speaker 4: he was talking very much about that.
[13:51] Speaker 1: This is about better aligning the taxes paid on these
[13:55] Speaker 1: types of income with the taxes paid on wages. These
[13:59] Speaker 1: changes will all the playing field for workers and first
[14:01] Speaker 1: home buyers and support investment in productive assets including new
[14:05] Speaker 1: housing supply, and they will find our new round of
[14:09] Speaker 1: tax relief for more than thirty million Australian workers.
[14:13] Speaker 4: He was saying, we want the tax system to be
[14:16] Speaker 4: fairer to people who earn their income through working and
[14:20] Speaker 4: not as generous to people who earn their income from
[14:23] Speaker 4: passive investments and assets, because he says it's out of whack,
[14:27] Speaker 4: it's out of balance and it needs to be rebalanced,
[14:30] Speaker 4: and that's very much the emphasis. So in that sense,
[14:32] Speaker 4: it's a very labor budget. It is really trying to
[14:36] Speaker 4: shift that back to be fair to working people.
[14:39] Speaker 3: But it's not going to be without some pain in
[14:41] Speaker 3: the short.
[14:41] Speaker 4: Term, and certainly there are some groups that are going
[14:44] Speaker 4: to find it very difficult. I mean, there are some
[14:48] Speaker 4: changes to the tax for business as well to try
[14:51] Speaker 4: and protect business from the worst of the economic crisis,
[14:55] Speaker 4: and there are some pretty dire forecasts in here.
[14:57] Speaker 1: In this budget, Treasury also presents some more severe scenario
[15:01] Speaker 1: where the your price peaks at two hundred dollars a
[15:03] Speaker 1: barrel and takes three years to fall back down. We'd
[15:07] Speaker 1: still avoid a recession, but unemployment would spike to pre
[15:11] Speaker 1: pandemic levels and inflation would peak above seven percent.
[15:15] Speaker 4: And so you know, there's a lot of sort of
[15:17] Speaker 4: uncertainty about all of this, and the government.
[15:21] Speaker 3: Has taken a big risk, a big political risk in.
[15:24] Speaker 4: Making these changes in this tough budget at this time,
[15:27] Speaker 4: but they've decided they've got the political capital they need
[15:30] Speaker 4: to spend it and that Australians are calling out for
[15:33] Speaker 4: something to change.
[15:37] Speaker 2: Well, Karen, thank you so much for your time.
[15:40] Speaker 3: Thanks Ruby.
[15:52] Speaker 2: Also in the news, the government has been accused of
[15:55] Speaker 2: trying to bury its response to the Peter Murphy Report
[15:58] Speaker 2: on gambling reform by release it on Budget Eve. Leading
[16:02] Speaker 2: advocate Tim Costello says it's very disappointing, particularly since the
[16:06] Speaker 2: government is only tackling four of the thirty one recommendations.
[16:10] Speaker 2: The official government response, released more than a thousand days
[16:13] Speaker 2: after the report, ignores calls for an online gambling regulator
[16:17] Speaker 2: and comprehensive ban of online gambling advertising, and a Canberra
[16:22] Speaker 2: teenager has been charged with planning a terrorist attack in
[16:25] Speaker 2: the Act. The seventeen year old is accused of planning
[16:29] Speaker 2: an attack motivated by views aligned with nationalist and racist extremism.
[16:34] Speaker 2: Counter Terrorism police say it's alarming to see young Australians
[16:38] Speaker 2: exposed to violent extremist material and propaganda. I'm Ruby Jones
[16:43] Speaker 2: and we'll be back with a special Budget Bonus episode
[16:46] Speaker 2: this afternoon, where we'll break down exactly what the government's
[16:49] Speaker 2: changes mean for house prices and people trying to get
[16:52] Speaker 2: into the property market. Thanks for listening, you m

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
