# Do Jillian Segal's claims of ABC-fuelled antisemitism stack up?

An episode of [7am](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1461999702), 13 Jul 2026, 16 min.

Audio: https://p.podderapp.com/2544644999/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/2fb3740d-3436-44af-8cc0-a91900716aa5/62723a1f-3e96-4fc4-882c-b25e0181da4d/4d24c0c7-3305-4882-a271-b4860070e57b/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=70f29d90-2a63-48aa-bf8f-b25e0181da70

Is the media’s reporting on Israel’s attacks on Gaza fuelling antisemitism? That’s the question facing the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion – which has been examining the role of the public broadcasters – the ABC and SBS. Appearing before the commission was Australia’s Special Envoy to Combat Antisemitism, Jillian Segal – who came out swinging at the broadcasters’ Middle East coverage, reccomending it be overseen by an independent committee. But do Segal’s claims stack up? Today, former Media Watch host and ABC Alumni board member Jonathan Holmes, on the submission ABC Alumni put to the commission, and the role of the public broadcaster in reporting on war. If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Former media watch host Jonathan Holmes Photo: AAP Image/Dominic Giannini See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:01] Speaker 1: I'm Ruby Jones and you're listening to seven AM. Is
[0:10] Speaker 1: the media's reporting on Israel's attacks on Gaza fueling antisemitism?
[0:14] Speaker 1: That's the question facing the Royal Commission into Anti Semitism,
[0:18] Speaker 1: which has been examining the role of the public broadcasters
[0:21] Speaker 1: the ABC and SBS. Appearing before the Commission was Australia's
[0:25] Speaker 1: Envoy to combat Antisemitism, Jillian Siegel, who came out swinging
[0:29] Speaker 1: at the broadcaster's Middle East coverage and recommended it'd be
[0:32] Speaker 1: overseen by an independent committee. But de Seagull's claims stack up. Today.
[0:38] Speaker 1: Former Media Watch host and ABC Alumni board member Jonathan
[0:42] Speaker 1: Holmes on the submission ABC Alumni put to the Commission
[0:45] Speaker 1: and the role of the public broadcaster in reporting on war.
[0:53] Speaker 1: It's Tuesday, July fourteenth, Jonathan. The Royal Commission into Anti
[1:02] Speaker 1: Semitism in this most recent block of hearings last week,
[1:06] Speaker 1: one of the focuses was on the public broadcasters. So
[1:10] Speaker 1: to begin with, can you just tell me how it
[1:12] Speaker 1: came about that the ABC and the SBS are part
[1:17] Speaker 1: of this Royal Commission.
[1:18] Speaker 2: That's a very good question, Ruby. The hearing Block three,
[1:22] Speaker 2: as it was called, was largely concentrated on social media
[1:25] Speaker 2: for very good reasons. That's where there has been this
[1:29] Speaker 2: extraordinary upsurge of anti Semitis, and some of it really
[1:32] Speaker 2: vicious and horrible directed at Jewish people in Australia. But
[1:36] Speaker 2: one day out of the tender was devoted to alleged
[1:40] Speaker 2: systemic bias. I think I could say on the part
[1:43] Speaker 2: of public broadcasters ABC and SBS, and our point of
[1:48] Speaker 2: view is that this is hunt for a solution for
[1:52] Speaker 2: something that isn't a problem. We do not accept that
[1:57] Speaker 2: the public broadcasters are part of in any sense the
[2:01] Speaker 2: problem of antisemeterism. Indeed, they do a great deal to
[2:04] Speaker 2: try to increase social cohesion by delivering trusted, balanced, fair news.
[2:13] Speaker 2: And the problem is that a lot of Jewish Australians,
[2:17] Speaker 2: at least according to Julian Siegel, special Advisors of the
[2:21] Speaker 2: Royal Commission and of course the appointed Australian Special Envoy
[2:26] Speaker 2: to combat anti Semitism, she clearly believes and she says
[2:30] Speaker 2: that a great many Australians Jews believe the ABC and
[2:33] Speaker 2: SPS are biased against Israel. And that's really where the
[2:37] Speaker 2: problem is.
[2:38] Speaker 1: And so when you say our point of view, you
[2:40] Speaker 1: were the lead author of the ABC alumni submission to
[2:44] Speaker 1: the Royal Commission. So tell me more about the central
[2:47] Speaker 1: concern that you wanted to put before the inquiry.
[2:50] Speaker 2: Our central concern. Let me make it clear, the ABC
[2:52] Speaker 2: alumni is a group of former ABC people that doesn't
[2:55] Speaker 2: have any direct connection with the ABC, and we don't
[2:57] Speaker 2: speak for the ABC. It's important to understand that. And
[3:00] Speaker 2: we didn't consult the ABC and making our submission to
[3:03] Speaker 2: the Royal Commission. But we read Jillian Seguard's original report
[3:07] Speaker 2: back in July twenty twenty five, long before the Bondei massacre,
[3:11] Speaker 2: about combating anti Semitism, and we were alarmed that in
[3:16] Speaker 2: several places in that report she singles out the public
[3:18] Speaker 2: broadcast as ABC and SBS as being part of the
[3:21] Speaker 2: problem because she says that in the way that it reports,
[3:26] Speaker 2: it exacerbates antisemitism by emphasizing stories that are unfavorable and
[3:33] Speaker 2: cast Israel in a bad light, and by a process
[3:36] Speaker 2: of what she calls conflation bad news about Israel taken
[3:41] Speaker 2: by ordinary people in Australia as a kind of excuse
[3:45] Speaker 2: or reason to attack Australian Jews. She was proposing in
[3:49] Speaker 2: that report that she the Special Envoy should have a
[3:52] Speaker 2: special role in helping the broadcasters to amend their editorial
[4:00] Speaker 2: sidelines and to cover the Middle East conflicts, particularly in
[4:05] Speaker 2: a way that would be more favorable to Israel. At
[4:09] Speaker 2: least that's the way I understood, And we thought this
[4:12] Speaker 2: was extraordinarily don inteous that this person, who is after
[4:15] Speaker 2: all the mediate past president of the Executive Committee of
[4:18] Speaker 2: Australian Jury, which is the leading representative body of Australian Jews,
[4:24] Speaker 2: I certainly claims to be, and has been attacking the
[4:27] Speaker 2: ABC's perceived bias for decades, for decades, that she should
[4:33] Speaker 2: set herself up as a sort of impartial arbiter of
[4:36] Speaker 2: what is or isn't fair reporting.
[4:39] Speaker 3: And my contention is that that whole system is not
[4:42] Speaker 3: working to assure all of us that the reporting is
[4:48] Speaker 3: as per required. And that's why I make the suggestion
[4:52] Speaker 3: of an oversight exercise, a standing committee.
[4:55] Speaker 1: And so when Gillian Siegel actually gave evidence, what she
[5:00] Speaker 1: she seemed to be proposing was some kind of standing
[5:03] Speaker 1: committee or external oversight body for the ABC and SBS,
[5:08] Speaker 1: not necessarily something that would personally involve her. Tell me
[5:11] Speaker 1: what you made of what she was proposing.
[5:13] Speaker 2: So Julian Siegel, in her evidence to the Royal Commission,
[5:18] Speaker 2: came up with a new proposal which apparently is included
[5:22] Speaker 2: in an action plan additional to her original plan that
[5:26] Speaker 2: she submitted to the government in January but which none
[5:28] Speaker 2: of us have seen. But from her evidence it's clear
[5:32] Speaker 2: that she is now saying, oh, no, no, it's not
[5:35] Speaker 2: me that's going to do the monitoring of a public broadcast.
[5:38] Speaker 2: Is what I suggest is a standing committee of independent
[5:42] Speaker 2: people who would become the arbiters of whether the overall
[5:48] Speaker 2: coverage of Middle East conflicts is fair and impartial and accurate.
[5:54] Speaker 2: And I guess would advise the ABC and SBS on
[5:58] Speaker 2: how to avoid this problem of increasing the antagonism to
[6:02] Speaker 2: Australians used because of bad views about Israel.
[6:05] Speaker 3: I'm hearing from important stakeholders of mind, how concerned they are,
[6:10] Speaker 3: how grieved they are, how they feel that they're trusted
[6:13] Speaker 3: broadcaster is not being fair and accurate. I would like
[6:19] Speaker 3: the ABC to be as good as it possibly could be. Okay,
[6:24] Speaker 3: not in any way to restrict it or constrain it
[6:29] Speaker 3: from being independent, but just to be as good as
[6:32] Speaker 3: it could be. And I do think a structure where
[6:36] Speaker 3: independent group of people look at what is happening, and
[6:40] Speaker 3: they can give it a huge tick, or they can
[6:43] Speaker 3: give it guidance as to the fact that it needs
[6:47] Speaker 3: to understand this particular hatred we're focused on better.
[6:53] Speaker 2: Now that's almost worse than we had feared. I mean,
[6:58] Speaker 2: who is going to be this independent and constity at
[7:01] Speaker 2: this independent committee. By definition, if it's going to change
[7:07] Speaker 2: the overall coverage of the Middle East conflicts, it would
[7:11] Speaker 2: have to consist of people who have a more favorable
[7:15] Speaker 2: view of Israel had its actions than the current onwardsman
[7:20] Speaker 2: at the ABC and SBS, or indeed the official regulator
[7:24] Speaker 2: ATMA that has because those bodies have not accepted almost
[7:28] Speaker 2: any of the constant complaints about bias that they've been
[7:32] Speaker 2: receiving over decades. And no organization that I can think
[7:37] Speaker 2: of devolves all its complaints handling too some completely outside body,
[7:42] Speaker 2: as Jillian Siegel seems to be recommending, It would be
[7:46] Speaker 2: an absolute abandonment of its independence. Now, I mean, where
[7:51] Speaker 2: does that leave the ABC's reputation for impartiality? Above all,
[7:56] Speaker 2: the UBC's job is to report the facts as actually
[8:00] Speaker 2: is it can and to reflect the diverse views right
[8:04] Speaker 2: across the community of what's going on.
[8:06] Speaker 1: So there were these criticisms of the complaints process, but
[8:09] Speaker 1: then there was also this kind of broader criticism of
[8:13] Speaker 1: the ABC's balance in how it covers the Middle East,
[8:16] Speaker 1: particularly Gaza. Tell me what you made of the way
[8:18] Speaker 1: that Siegel characterized that.
[8:21] Speaker 2: So what Segel is recommending, I mean, among other things,
[8:25] Speaker 2: and this is to be honest for any professional journalists,
[8:28] Speaker 2: that kind of bizarre suggestion that if the ABC reporters
[8:34] Speaker 2: understood this problem of conslation better, they would be trying
[8:38] Speaker 2: to help to solve it by, for example, reporting more
[8:43] Speaker 2: positive stories about Israel as well as negative wise.
[8:46] Speaker 3: And we should find a way where they also run
[8:50] Speaker 3: positive stories. And I've said this in my statement, that
[8:53] Speaker 3: they could run positive stories about other things. Israel is
[8:57] Speaker 3: doing an amazing startup nation, things like that. They very
[9:02] Speaker 3: rarely do that. There's no attempt at that part of
[9:06] Speaker 3: the agenda.
[9:07] Speaker 2: And she gives the example of all these wonderful startups
[9:10] Speaker 2: that are happening in the Australian economy, and why don't
[9:13] Speaker 2: we talk about that instead of all banging on a
[9:15] Speaker 2: band garza all the time? Now, if we're reporting on
[9:20] Speaker 2: I don't know, the ice activities in the United States,
[9:24] Speaker 2: and the killing of innocent civilians in Minnesota. Do we
[9:29] Speaker 2: feel the necessity to balance that with a story about
[9:32] Speaker 2: a Hollywood blockbuster or the success of AI or something.
[9:36] Speaker 2: I mean, it's just a bizarre notion.
[9:42] Speaker 1: Coming up. What's at stake for the ABC, Jonathan. The
[9:55] Speaker 1: ABC is used to being accused of bias. It happens
[9:58] Speaker 1: all the time on many day fin issues. But what
[10:01] Speaker 1: do you think changes when the accusation is not just
[10:03] Speaker 1: about bias but about contributing to anti Semitism or social division.
[10:08] Speaker 2: Well, this is this is where this problem becomes even
[10:11] Speaker 2: more dire. I mean, as I said, I think Julian
[10:15] Speaker 2: Siegel is unfortunately right that Israel these early defense force
[10:20] Speaker 2: and its actions, especially in Guards, but also on the
[10:23] Speaker 2: West Bank, adding Lebanon and so on, all of this
[10:27] Speaker 2: bad news exacerbates anti Semitism. It's a huge problem, and
[10:32] Speaker 2: the Royal Commission has quite rightly spent a great deal
[10:34] Speaker 2: of time on that. But these things are happening. You
[10:38] Speaker 2: can't deny that they are happening. If the ABC reports
[10:43] Speaker 2: the news inaccurately or in a bias fashion genuinely, then
[10:47] Speaker 2: absolutely it should correct itself, and it should do it
[10:50] Speaker 2: as soon as possible. But you know, there's only been,
[10:53] Speaker 2: for example, for instances, out of the thousands of complaints
[10:59] Speaker 2: that the ABC Ongots has received of bias or inaccuracy
[11:02] Speaker 2: in the Middle East coverage that she is upheld and
[11:06] Speaker 2: the ACMA, the AKMA has not uphold a single complaint
[11:12] Speaker 2: about Middle East coverage of ABC or SBS since I
[11:16] Speaker 2: don't think two thousand and three, So those regulators don't
[11:20] Speaker 2: believe it's a problem. Julian Siegel does believe it's a problem.
[11:24] Speaker 2: So her solution is to change the regulators.
[11:27] Speaker 1: How precarious do you think this time is for the
[11:29] Speaker 1: ABC in terms of the pressure that it's currently under,
[11:33] Speaker 1: because as well as this Royal Commission, there has been
[11:36] Speaker 1: criticism from other arenas. One nation recently barred the ABC
[11:41] Speaker 1: from reporting at their events. How does all of that
[11:45] Speaker 1: shape the stakes here?
[11:47] Speaker 2: Well, it's a critical time at the moment, and the
[11:50] Speaker 2: ABC doesn't have as many friends as one would wish
[11:54] Speaker 2: that it did have. I mean, News Corporation, which is
[11:57] Speaker 2: very powerful, especially Sky News, which is watched widely in
[12:01] Speaker 2: the regions on through Jeet Television, keeps up a continuous
[12:04] Speaker 2: rain of crutiusism of the ABC. Night after Night One Nation,
[12:09] Speaker 2: as you say, is implacably opposed to the ABC. It
[12:12] Speaker 2: wants to basically defunded except for some elements of what
[12:16] Speaker 2: it does in the regions. But I mean Julian and Lisa,
[12:19] Speaker 2: the well respected front bencher, the Ripple Party front bencher,
[12:23] Speaker 2: was on the radio just this morning saying he's not
[12:27] Speaker 2: the communications spokesman, but he is a prominent and respected
[12:31] Speaker 2: Jewish member of Parliament, saying that he accepted the sequels
[12:36] Speaker 2: recommendations and he thought the ABC should pay attention to them,
[12:39] Speaker 2: and there's a serious problem and so on and so on.
[12:42] Speaker 2: So there are a great many people who are happy
[12:45] Speaker 2: to climb onto this what I'm tempted to call bandwagon
[12:50] Speaker 2: of criticizing the ABC, because it is the nearest thing
[12:56] Speaker 2: we have to an impartial news service and it doesn't
[12:58] Speaker 2: takes sights whereas Course News Corp does.
[13:01] Speaker 1: Looking ahead, I mean, what kind of recommendation from this
[13:05] Speaker 1: Royal Commission would worry you? And conversely, I mean, what
[13:08] Speaker 1: do you think might actually be useful here?
[13:10] Speaker 2: I think the most useful thing the Royal Commission can
[13:12] Speaker 2: do is simply not to accept any of the recommendations
[13:17] Speaker 2: of Julian Siegel, where they have to do with the
[13:20] Speaker 2: public broadcasters. I mean she has picked on the public broadcasters,
[13:23] Speaker 2: not on any other media organization in the country. When
[13:26] Speaker 2: you look at news corporations coverage, it's not hard to
[13:29] Speaker 2: work out perhaps why, But the public broadcasters are simply
[13:33] Speaker 2: not the problem. There is no evidence whatsoever. I don't
[13:36] Speaker 2: think even Julian Siegel came up with any evidence that
[13:39] Speaker 2: the ABC's in somehow directly and disability and anti senatism
[13:43] Speaker 2: within Australia. It's all about its coverative affairs in the
[13:46] Speaker 2: Middle East. My own reading may be right, maybe wrong.
[13:51] Speaker 2: Of the Royal Commissioner and her council assisting Richard Lancaster
[13:55] Speaker 2: is that neither of them were particularly sympathetic to what
[13:59] Speaker 2: Siegel was saying. They were asking quite pointed questions about
[14:02] Speaker 2: how on earth this independent committee would actually improve the
[14:07] Speaker 2: ABC's reputation for independence or into partiality. So I'm hoping
[14:12] Speaker 2: that just as the Government ignored Miss Siegal's recommendations about
[14:18] Speaker 2: the Public Broadcast in its response to her original report,
[14:21] Speaker 2: I'm hoping that the Role Commission will either simply kind
[14:25] Speaker 2: of leave that on one side or recommend men that
[14:28] Speaker 2: that things stay as they are. That's the most useful
[14:30] Speaker 2: thing they can do. I mean, there are two really
[14:33] Speaker 2: trusted news organizations in this country at the moment. One
[14:37] Speaker 2: of them is Yes and the other is the ABC.
[14:40] Speaker 2: Their complaints systems are working pretty well and frankly, if
[14:44] Speaker 2: it's not bust, don't go fixing it.
[14:49] Speaker 1: Jonathan, thank you so much for your time.
[14:51] Speaker 2: You're welcome.
[15:02] Speaker 1: Also in the news, the Royal Commission into Anti Semitism
[15:05] Speaker 1: and Social Cohesion has also begun examining the lived experiences
[15:09] Speaker 1: of Jewish students and academics, including the response of universities
[15:13] Speaker 1: to hate on campus. A University of New South Wales
[15:16] Speaker 1: tudor and PhD candidate has told the Commission he was
[15:19] Speaker 1: subjected to Nazi salutes by four students in his business
[15:23] Speaker 1: class for international students in twenty twenty four. The Commission
[15:27] Speaker 1: has also had evidence that Jewish students felt pressured to
[15:30] Speaker 1: hide their identity on campus after the October seven attacks.
[15:34] Speaker 1: And actor Sam Neil Starr of the Jurassic Park movies,
[15:37] Speaker 1: The Piano and the Dish has died at the age
[15:40] Speaker 1: of seventy eight. He passed away on Monday, surrounded by
[15:43] Speaker 1: his family. It followed the actor's recent revelation that he
[15:46] Speaker 1: was living cancer free after being diagnosed with blood cancer
[15:50] Speaker 1: in March twenty twenty two. I'm Ruby Jones. This is
[15:53] Speaker 1: seven AM. Thanks for listening. The blow on un

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
