# Should tobacco shops exist? The new weapon in the tobacco wars

An episode of [7am](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1461999702), 24 Mar 2026, 16 min.

Audio: https://p.podderapp.com/2544644999/traffic.omny.fm/d/clips/2fb3740d-3436-44af-8cc0-a91900716aa5/62723a1f-3e96-4fc4-882c-b25e0181da4d/94b60de7-b19d-40a7-950f-b41700693c6c/audio.mp3?utm_source=Podcast&in_playlist=70f29d90-2a63-48aa-bf8f-b25e0181da70

Australia’s tobacco wars are fuelling violence, with fire bombings and arson attacks spanning across the east coast. Now the federal government wants to treat these organised crime syndicates like ‘drug lords’ by going after them with wire tapping and seizing their assets. And the tobacconists are in trouble too, with calls to ban tobacco stores and only sell cigarettes in supermarkets. Today, Criminologist Dr James Martin, from Deakin University on how to reign in the multi billion dollar black market that’s created a gangsters paradise If you enjoy 7am, the best way you can support us is by making a contribution at 7ampodcast.com.au/support. Socials: Stay in touch with us on Instagram Guest: Criminologist Dr James Martin, Deakin University Photo: AAP Image/Joel Carrett See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.

## Transcript

[0:01] Speaker 1: I'm Nicole Johnston and you're listening to seven AM. Australia's
[0:10] Speaker 1: tobacco walls are fuelling violence with fire bombings and to
[0:14] Speaker 1: arson attacks. Now the government wants to treat these organized
[0:17] Speaker 1: crime syndicates like drug lords by going after them with
[0:21] Speaker 1: wired tapping and seizing their assets. And the tobacconists are
[0:25] Speaker 1: in trouble too, with calls to only sell cigarettes in supermarkets. Today,
[0:32] Speaker 1: criminologist doctor James Martin from Deacon University on how to
[0:36] Speaker 1: rain in the multi billion dollar black market that's created
[0:40] Speaker 1: Againster's Paradise. It's Wednesday, March twenty five. James. We've heard
[0:53] Speaker 1: a lot about these so called tobacco wars in recent years,
[0:57] Speaker 1: shops being fire bombed, extortion rackets, even murders linked to
[1:02] Speaker 1: the trade. Why does black market tobacco produce that kind
[1:07] Speaker 1: of violence.
[1:08] Speaker 2: Well, all illicit markets come with some at least risk
[1:11] Speaker 2: of systemic violence. And so because these are markets that
[1:15] Speaker 2: operate outside of the legal system, there's no recourse if
[1:19] Speaker 2: things go wrong. So you know, for example, if you
[1:22] Speaker 2: and I went and bought a car from a car dealer,
[1:24] Speaker 2: you know, and something was wrong with it, we could
[1:26] Speaker 2: go to small Claims court, we'd have, you know, things
[1:28] Speaker 2: that we could do to get our money back. But
[1:31] Speaker 2: in the drug dealing world and most nicotine is now
[1:34] Speaker 2: part of that world, if something goes wrong, then you
[1:38] Speaker 2: use violence.
[1:40] Speaker 1: A sudden scramble as a gunman opens fire, shooting indiscriminately
[1:46] Speaker 1: into a crowd of about a dozen outside an Altona
[1:49] Speaker 1: North shisha cafe.
[1:50] Speaker 2: It's a really popular way to compete with your rivals.
[1:54] Speaker 2: So you know, in a legal market you might do
[1:56] Speaker 2: that through price or better advertising campaign. But in illegal
[2:00] Speaker 2: markets people can simply eliminate the competition by, you know,
[2:03] Speaker 2: by using violence against them.
[2:05] Speaker 3: Melbourne's tobacco war is taking its toll, with eight fire
[2:09] Speaker 3: bombing attacks in just seven.
[2:11] Speaker 4: Those police and the Lunar Task Force have already been
[2:14] Speaker 4: investigating more than sixty fires across Melbourne.
[2:18] Speaker 2: The most newsworthy violence and one that I'm sure your
[2:21] Speaker 2: listeners are familiar with the being the arsen attacks that
[2:25] Speaker 2: have been well originally in Victoria but have now increasingly
[2:28] Speaker 2: spread across the country.
[2:29] Speaker 4: Nunity Services were called a good Street in Westmey this
[2:32] Speaker 4: is in Sydney, just before midnight to find two vehicles
[2:35] Speaker 4: engulfed in.
[2:36] Speaker 2: Flames, kidnapping, torture, homicides.
[2:40] Speaker 3: One am in Glenroy, a gunman unleashes on a tobacco stool,
[2:44] Speaker 3: detectives revealing arsonists killed an innocent woman in a tragic
[2:49] Speaker 3: case of your staken idea.
[2:51] Speaker 2: We also see violence used to intimidate potential witnesses as well.
[2:55] Speaker 2: So this is one of the problems that to ramp
[2:57] Speaker 2: up penalties and make the environ more hostile for criminal groups,
[3:02] Speaker 2: you can increase the likelihood that they'll use violence against
[3:05] Speaker 2: people who think they might inform on them to police,
[3:07] Speaker 2: for example.
[3:08] Speaker 1: So, James, is this a legal trade really one of
[3:12] Speaker 1: the biggest black markets in the country, and what is
[3:15] Speaker 1: the size of it?
[3:16] Speaker 5: Yeah, so it is.
[3:18] Speaker 2: Sadly now it's absolutely massive. A majority of tobacco and
[3:22] Speaker 2: nearly all the vaping products sold in Australia is now illicit.
[3:27] Speaker 2: So we're looking at yearly expenditure something in the order
[3:30] Speaker 2: of around seven billion dollars, which is roughly forty percent
[3:34] Speaker 2: of our entire illicit drug economy. So nicotine is now
[3:37] Speaker 2: worth more to criminals than cannabis, cocaine, heroin and ecstasy combined.
[3:43] Speaker 2: And sadly, it's nearly all of it is going into
[3:45] Speaker 2: the hands of very serious organized criminal groups. So these
[3:49] Speaker 2: are groups that already involved in very dangerous criminal activities
[3:54] Speaker 2: everything you know the government has said, from trafficking of
[3:57] Speaker 2: other illicit drugs, sex trafficking, human traffic in cyber crimes.
[4:01] Speaker 2: So the extraordinary profits of expenditure on these products is
[4:07] Speaker 2: going directly into the pockets of those organizations.
[4:09] Speaker 5: So some of the most dangerous people in the country.
[4:11] Speaker 1: And how did we actually get to this point? How
[4:14] Speaker 1: did cigarettes become this major criminal enterprise.
[4:18] Speaker 2: Well, we started to see real shift in government policy
[4:21] Speaker 2: in the twenty tens. So up until that point, price
[4:25] Speaker 2: was used as a sort of nudging, increasing the price
[4:29] Speaker 2: of cigarettes a little bit to try and get people
[4:31] Speaker 2: who smoke to reconsider purchasing. But this shift implicitly went
[4:35] Speaker 2: from sending those smaller pricing signals to actually making cigarettes unaffordable.
[4:41] Speaker 2: So someone who has a packa dat habit these days
[4:44] Speaker 2: is looking at a yearly bill of around fifteen thousand dollars.
[4:48] Speaker 2: And we know that smokers are disproportionately concentrated in disadvantage
[4:51] Speaker 2: populations who simply can't afford that, So it's a de
[4:54] Speaker 2: facto form of prohibition.
[4:56] Speaker 4: This federal labor government has been too slow and too
[4:59] Speaker 4: weak and too soft in stopping the supply chains to
[5:03] Speaker 4: this trial, small.
[5:04] Speaker 3: Businesses are continuing to get ram rated.
[5:06] Speaker 1: Retail staff are worried about being assaulted.
[5:09] Speaker 4: We have criminal gangs running our streets in Melbourne, in Sydney,
[5:14] Speaker 4: in Brisbane because this government won't act.
[5:18] Speaker 1: So obviously this is becoming a major problem for the government.
[5:21] Speaker 1: Why is it that it just can't get on top
[5:23] Speaker 1: of it.
[5:24] Speaker 2: Well, I think the problem at the moment really stems
[5:27] Speaker 2: from a lack of appreciation of what the limits of
[5:30] Speaker 2: enforcement are in this space. So enforcement can work in
[5:34] Speaker 2: illicit markets. So you know, that's everything from seizures at
[5:38] Speaker 2: the border or even beyond the border, working with international
[5:41] Speaker 2: partners all the way down through you know, to the
[5:44] Speaker 2: retail level, trying to close stores and so on. You know,
[5:47] Speaker 2: you'll hear the government talking about seizures and raids, but
[5:50] Speaker 2: those things actually don't produce any meaningful impacts on the
[5:54] Speaker 2: market themselves. And that's because when a market gets beyond
[5:56] Speaker 2: a certain point, While you can you know, severely hacked
[6:00] Speaker 2: or disrupt individual criminal networks, there are so many other
[6:04] Speaker 2: players in the space that they don't interpret, you know,
[6:07] Speaker 2: some other rival being shut down as a deterrent.
[6:10] Speaker 5: They see that as.
[6:11] Speaker 2: An invitation to expand their operations and take over a
[6:14] Speaker 2: greater market share. So I think as long as the
[6:17] Speaker 2: government remains wedded to an enforcement oriented solution like this,
[6:22] Speaker 2: we're going to see these problems continue. I think the
[6:27] Speaker 2: government and actually many in the public health space as well,
[6:30] Speaker 2: really sort of trying to fight the last war all
[6:34] Speaker 2: over again, thinking that the worst players in this space
[6:37] Speaker 2: are the western tobacco companies. But that's no longer the case.
[6:41] Speaker 2: The worst players in the space, and those that actually
[6:43] Speaker 2: have a dominant share of the market now are criminal
[6:46] Speaker 2: organizations and at the moment, government policies actually played directly
[6:50] Speaker 2: into their hands. Every tax increase, you know, all the
[6:52] Speaker 2: increasing restrictions we see on the legal sector actually strengthen
[6:56] Speaker 2: the hand of the illisit sector?
[6:58] Speaker 5: And that's the last thing which if you're doing right.
[7:00] Speaker 1: Now coming up? Is it time to ban tobacco shops
[7:05] Speaker 1: all together? James, you were in Canberra last week there
[7:19] Speaker 1: was this conference on the illicit trade in tobacco and
[7:23] Speaker 1: the federal government announced new plans to try and tackle it.
[7:26] Speaker 1: What is it that they want to.
[7:28] Speaker 2: Do, so you're talking about the federal government basically doing
[7:31] Speaker 2: more of the same, so expanding police powers, increasing penalties,
[7:36] Speaker 2: more funding for law enforcement. A lot of these powers
[7:40] Speaker 2: are similarly kind of in place, so you know, we
[7:43] Speaker 2: have unexplained wealth powers for example, that allows enforcement agencies
[7:46] Speaker 2: to seize items that may have been accrued through illicit
[7:51] Speaker 2: market activity. The government has talked about ramping up why
[7:56] Speaker 2: tap powers, so you know, allowing elicted tobacco, for example,
[7:59] Speaker 2: to be an offense that would trigger extra forms of
[8:02] Speaker 2: police surveillance, but nothing really on the table. I think
[8:06] Speaker 2: that would fundamentally change the environment that the police are
[8:10] Speaker 2: working in such that they could actually get a handle
[8:12] Speaker 2: on the market. But I mean, illicit drugs are really
[8:14] Speaker 2: instructive in this regard. So over the last fifteen years
[8:17] Speaker 2: or so, we've tripled our drug law enforcement budget, and
[8:20] Speaker 2: that was intended to make drugs harder to get, and
[8:24] Speaker 2: those drugs that did hit the street because they were
[8:25] Speaker 2: more scarce, were supposed to be more expensive and more pure.
[8:29] Speaker 2: We're seeing record levels of arrest, record volume proceidures year
[8:32] Speaker 2: on year, but when again, when you actually look at
[8:34] Speaker 2: the impact on the market, there's been no change in
[8:36] Speaker 2: the availability of any of the illicit drug types. We're
[8:39] Speaker 2: actually seeing purity increase and prices declined substantially.
[8:43] Speaker 4: Anyone who tried to deny that Australia has a massive
[8:46] Speaker 4: problem with illegal tobacco is either diluted or lying. Cheap
[8:53] Speaker 4: smokes are everywhere with a now ubiquitous, ridiculous retail distribution network.
[8:59] Speaker 2: And penalties for selling on this it's bacco or already
[9:02] Speaker 2: really high. Here in Victoria they're around maximum fifteen years imprisonment,
[9:06] Speaker 2: and we contrast that in the list of drug space
[9:08] Speaker 2: the average sentence that a large scale commercial drug trafficker
[9:11] Speaker 2: gets is around ten years. So you know, the penalties
[9:14] Speaker 2: and the powers I think are largely in place, and
[9:17] Speaker 2: I don't see much potential reform there that would really
[9:20] Speaker 2: fundamentally alter the situation that we're in now.
[9:23] Speaker 4: Now, Stradan's will rightly think that any public official who
[9:26] Speaker 4: stands up, whether a politician or a commissioner or a
[9:29] Speaker 4: CEO or anyone in this room who stands up talk's
[9:33] Speaker 4: tough about seizures, is not living in the real world
[9:37] Speaker 4: unless and until the illegal retail shop fronts a shutdown.
[9:41] Speaker 1: We had Julian Hill, the assistant Minister for Customs actually
[9:45] Speaker 1: raise a question that was first posed by health groups,
[9:48] Speaker 1: which should be standalone tobacco shops even exist. So how
[9:53] Speaker 1: would a tobacco shop ben actually work.
[9:57] Speaker 2: I don't think it's actually even possible to do, because
[10:00] Speaker 2: illicit operators by definition don't really care what the law is.
[10:04] Speaker 2: And we actually saw an earlier kind of rerun of
[10:07] Speaker 2: this when vape stores were shut down a few years ago.
[10:10] Speaker 2: So you know, the government was concerned about vaping and
[10:14] Speaker 2: decided that it wanted to shut down all the vape retailers.
[10:17] Speaker 2: And so when the government banned all the vape stores,
[10:20] Speaker 2: all they did was actually shut down all the legal stores,
[10:22] Speaker 2: which gave all of the market share to the illicit stores.
[10:26] Speaker 2: And I think we'd see a similar kind of thing here.
[10:28] Speaker 2: We'd see black market adaptation. We'd see these forty thousand retailers,
[10:32] Speaker 2: which is an astounding number, simply rebranded. They just take
[10:36] Speaker 2: tobacconists off their sign or they just continue to operate illegally.
[10:41] Speaker 1: And we also heard from Hill that those forty thousand
[10:43] Speaker 1: tobacco stores are serving just eight percent of the population,
[10:47] Speaker 1: so it seems like a huge amount. Do we need
[10:50] Speaker 1: that many?
[10:51] Speaker 5: No?
[10:52] Speaker 2: I don't think we do, but unfortunately, the market doesn't
[10:56] Speaker 2: really care what I think or what the minister thinks.
[10:59] Speaker 5: You know, these are the product of government policy.
[11:02] Speaker 2: We have way more of them now than we did
[11:05] Speaker 2: even a few years ago, and the reason for that
[11:07] Speaker 2: is because government policies have made elicit tobacco such an
[11:10] Speaker 2: attractive criminal commodity. So simply passing laws to try and
[11:15] Speaker 2: get rid of those, because criminal players don't really care
[11:18] Speaker 2: what the laws are, I think will be largely ineffective.
[11:21] Speaker 1: So what would be effective? Then what would actually have
[11:24] Speaker 1: an impact and finally end the tobacco wars?
[11:28] Speaker 2: So I think there are a few options that need
[11:30] Speaker 2: to be considered. One of those is increased enforcement. You know,
[11:34] Speaker 2: we are going to require increased enforcement to take place,
[11:38] Speaker 2: but again, illicit markets are very very resistant to law
[11:42] Speaker 2: enforcement when they're at the scale that they clearly are
[11:45] Speaker 2: now with the illicit nicotine market. So what we need
[11:48] Speaker 2: to do is try and use other measures to shrink
[11:50] Speaker 2: the illicit market as much as possible. And there's two
[11:53] Speaker 2: principal ways I think we can do that. One is
[11:56] Speaker 2: to lower tobacco excise back to a point that you
[11:59] Speaker 2: would get a credit massive consumers shifting back to the
[12:02] Speaker 2: legal market. And the other one would be to do
[12:05] Speaker 2: what other countries around the world like New Zealand or
[12:07] Speaker 2: the UK have done, and that is created a legal,
[12:09] Speaker 2: regulated market for vaging products and other less harmful nicotine products.
[12:13] Speaker 1: Smokers in England are being encouraged to take up feeping
[12:16] Speaker 1: in a government led initiative to get them to give
[12:19] Speaker 1: off cigarettes.
[12:20] Speaker 2: So get people switching back to legal products and preferably
[12:23] Speaker 2: less harmful nicotine products, and giving smokers somewhere to go.
[12:27] Speaker 2: Both the UK and New Zealand, for example, have free
[12:29] Speaker 2: switch to quit schemes where they give vapes for free
[12:33] Speaker 2: to people who smoke to try and get them to quit.
[12:35] Speaker 2: That shrinks the market and therefore that enables law enforcement
[12:39] Speaker 2: and regulatory agencies to have the best chance of success.
[12:42] Speaker 1: But isn't the government saying that there's actually no evidence
[12:45] Speaker 1: that cutting the tobacco excize would make any difference.
[12:49] Speaker 2: Yeah, I think the government has said they haven't seen
[12:51] Speaker 2: any evidents. I don't think that's the same as there
[12:54] Speaker 2: being no evidence. Look, it is true that some smokers
[12:58] Speaker 2: now that elicit tobaccos entrenched widely available across the country.
[13:02] Speaker 2: There are some smokers who just won't be prepared to
[13:05] Speaker 2: pay a cent more for legal tobacco. But there are
[13:08] Speaker 2: other customers that it's not like they're wedded to criminal activity.
[13:13] Speaker 5: It's the magnitude of the price difference.
[13:15] Speaker 2: So they might be prepared to pay thirty dollars or
[13:16] Speaker 2: forty dollars for a pack, but not fifty sixty seventy
[13:19] Speaker 2: dollars like we're seeing now, and so it's really trying
[13:21] Speaker 2: to get those people who sit somewhere in the middle
[13:24] Speaker 2: of that spectrum back to the legal market.
[13:27] Speaker 1: James, more broadly, what are the consequences do you think
[13:31] Speaker 1: if we don't get this under control, especially because we're
[13:34] Speaker 1: now seeing smoking rates looking set to increase for the
[13:38] Speaker 1: first time since the nineties.
[13:40] Speaker 2: Yeah, that's right, So I mean, well, that's an obvious
[13:42] Speaker 2: consequence right there. I mean, no other Western country has
[13:45] Speaker 2: seen anything like this, so that's obviously very poor public
[13:49] Speaker 2: health outcome. We're going to see the increases in systemic
[13:53] Speaker 2: violence as the illicit market share continues to grow. But
[13:57] Speaker 2: I think we're looking down the barrel of one of
[13:59] Speaker 2: the greatest public policy failures in living memory. There's harve
[14:04] Speaker 2: a metric that you could consider our current tobacco control
[14:08] Speaker 2: policies a success, you know, increasing smoking rates, or at
[14:11] Speaker 2: least their early evidence thereof increasing violence. Billions and billions
[14:15] Speaker 2: lost in excise, hundreds of millions extra dollars going into enforcement.
[14:20] Speaker 5: Yeah, it's really failures poor around at the moment.
[14:22] Speaker 1: Sadly, James, thank you so much for talking to us
[14:28] Speaker 1: about it.
[14:29] Speaker 5: Thanks for copping.
[14:42] Speaker 1: Also in the news, after eight years of negotiations, Australia
[14:45] Speaker 1: and the European Union have signed a free trade deal.
[14:49] Speaker 1: Anthony Albanezi and European Commissioned President Ursula Vonderline announced the
[14:54] Speaker 1: ten billion dollar agreement yesterday. The PM says it will
[14:57] Speaker 1: eliminate tariffs on exports like wine, seafood and horticulture, as
[15:02] Speaker 1: well as give Australians access to EU beef, dairy, rice
[15:05] Speaker 1: and sugar. And the company responsible for the ninety six
[15:10] Speaker 1: million dollar Bureau of Meteorology website has scored a new
[15:13] Speaker 1: government contract. Despite being highly criticized for its redesign of
[15:18] Speaker 1: the bomb site, which blew out by ninety million dollars
[15:21] Speaker 1: last year, it's now won a sixteen million dollar contract
[15:24] Speaker 1: to build a climate data website for the government. I'm
[15:28] Speaker 1: Nicole Johnston. This is seven am. Thanks for listening.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
