# Thefts in the railway, behind tree fall deaths, and book bannings

An episode of [3 Things](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1406730235), 15 Jul 2026, 27 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/72979109/3_things_2026_july_15_v1.mp3

First, we speak with The Indian Express' Dheeraj Mishra about thefts that have been happening in the Indian Railways. He tells us that in the last few years 1.27 crore pieces of linen have been stolen by passengers from the bedroll kits provided to them in the Indian Railway AC coaches. He discusses the investigation, its findings, and the steps the railways are taking. Next, we speak with The Indian Express' Pratip Acharya about over 1800 trees collapsing in Mumbai, which led to three deaths and many people getting injured. He talks about the possible cause, what the BMC is saying, and the concerns such incidents raise regarding the management of the urban tree cover. (10:30) Lastly, we talk about a Jammu court allowing the Jammu and Kashmir Police to conduct a 10 day custodial questioning of three publishers arrested in connection with the publication of books allegedly glorifying separatists. (23:44) Hosted by Niharika Nanda Produced by Shashank Bhargava, Ichha Sharma, and Niharika Nanda Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: In this episode, we talk about over eighteen hundred trees
[0:03] Speaker 1: collapsing in Mumbai, killing three people and injuring over a dozen,
[0:08] Speaker 1: and how it has raised serious questions about the city's
[0:11] Speaker 1: management of its urban tree cover. We also talk about
[0:15] Speaker 1: a Jummu Coote allowing the Jamuyen Kashmed police to conduct
[0:18] Speaker 1: a ten day custorial questioning of three publishers arrested in
[0:23] Speaker 1: connection with the publication of books allegedly glorifying separatists. But
[0:28] Speaker 1: first we begin by talking about the ongoing cases of
[0:31] Speaker 1: theft inside Indian Railways. Hi, I am Aherri Kananda and
[0:39] Speaker 1: you are listening to three things in an Express news show.
[0:46] Speaker 1: Many of you would already know that as part of
[0:49] Speaker 1: their train ticket, passengers are provided with a bedroll kit
[0:53] Speaker 1: that includes two bed sheets, a blanket, a pillow, a
[0:56] Speaker 1: pillow cover and a face style for use during the journey. Now,
[1:00] Speaker 1: an Indian Express investigation has found that on average, one
[1:04] Speaker 1: in every one thousand passengers walks away with at least
[1:07] Speaker 1: one bedroll item at the end of a trip.
[1:11] Speaker 2: See this is a story of a trust between Indian
[1:15] Speaker 2: Railways and its passengers.
[1:17] Speaker 1: That's the Indian Expresses. Hirosh Mishra who covered the story
[1:21] Speaker 1: for the paper.
[1:22] Speaker 2: Why I am saying that this is about trust because
[1:25] Speaker 2: when linen's are distributed in the train, it is on
[1:27] Speaker 2: that thrust that after the completion of the journey it
[1:30] Speaker 2: will be returned back.
[1:31] Speaker 3: But that is not happening. What the data shows. What
[1:34] Speaker 3: our investigation shows.
[1:35] Speaker 2: That year after year, a number of linen which includes
[1:40] Speaker 2: a bedsheet, pilow, pillow, cover, towel and blanket.
[1:45] Speaker 3: So these five items which.
[1:47] Speaker 2: In railways turn we call bedroad it is being stolen
[1:50] Speaker 2: by the passengers from these ac coaches. So overall, the
[1:54] Speaker 2: data shows that since twenty twenty two to twenty twenty five,
[1:58] Speaker 2: in the four years the linen had has been increased
[2:00] Speaker 2: by fifty six percent.
[2:03] Speaker 1: Now to get this data HEREACH filed RTI applications with
[2:07] Speaker 1: all sixty nine divisions of the Indian Railways to understand
[2:10] Speaker 1: the scale of linen thefts since the pandemic, that is
[2:14] Speaker 1: between January twenty twenty two and May twenty twenty six.
[2:17] Speaker 1: And the data from fifty four divisions revealed that during
[2:21] Speaker 1: this period one point two seven corore bedroll items were stolen.
[2:26] Speaker 1: So to understand how significant these thefts are for the
[2:29] Speaker 1: Indian railways and who ultimately bears the cost. We speak
[2:33] Speaker 1: to Thaj in this segment, who begins by telling us
[2:36] Speaker 1: more about what the RTI is revealed.
[2:39] Speaker 3: So the break of.
[2:41] Speaker 2: Data is very interesting. So the toil is the top
[2:44] Speaker 2: linen item that is being stolen in the railways. So
[2:47] Speaker 2: the toil is on the top position with the forty
[2:49] Speaker 2: six point five to four thefteen four years and then
[2:53] Speaker 2: comes to the bed sheet, So bedsheet accounts for forty
[2:56] Speaker 2: one point one to three lack of theft in these
[3:00] Speaker 2: period After that comes pillow cover This is twenty three
[3:03] Speaker 2: point five nine lag. And then comes blanket one two
[3:06] Speaker 2: point ninety five lang, and then pilow two point seven
[3:09] Speaker 2: six lags. So the number of pilow is lower than
[3:11] Speaker 2: the other. There is one reason, of course, I mean
[3:14] Speaker 2: it is difficult to take pilow to steel pilow because.
[3:18] Speaker 3: You know, I mean it is difficult to get into
[3:20] Speaker 3: your bag very.
[3:21] Speaker 1: Quickly, right and the rich How widespread is this problem?
[3:26] Speaker 1: And are there particular railway zones or routes where thefts
[3:30] Speaker 1: are significantly higher?
[3:32] Speaker 2: Yes, So our investigation lists out top ten divisions which
[3:37] Speaker 2: accounts for sixty.
[3:39] Speaker 3: Percent of the total ninth theft.
[3:40] Speaker 2: So out of these fifty four there are ten divisions
[3:43] Speaker 2: which accounts for the maximum number of lanen theft almost
[3:45] Speaker 2: two thirds of and on the top position is Bacaner
[3:49] Speaker 2: in the Beaconet division twenty five point seven six leg
[3:51] Speaker 2: glenan item have been stolen since January twenty two to
[3:55] Speaker 2: May twenty twenty six.
[3:56] Speaker 3: Then comes to the.
[3:57] Speaker 2: Rachi with nine point three one legged theft, then comes
[4:00] Speaker 2: to Delhi. After this Mumbai, then Jodpur, Than Aha, Danapur.
[4:05] Speaker 3: So these are the key.
[4:06] Speaker 2: Divisions which accounts for a maximum number of theft.
[4:10] Speaker 3: Now there is more to it.
[4:11] Speaker 2: I mean if you go much deeper, that divisionies what
[4:15] Speaker 2: are the things that people are stolen in stealing it?
[4:19] Speaker 2: Which are the linen items which are being stolen mostly
[4:22] Speaker 2: in which divisions? So it's kind of that people have
[4:26] Speaker 2: different choices division wise to steal these linen So in
[4:29] Speaker 2: Bikaner bed sheet is on the top. It constitutes for
[4:32] Speaker 2: almost fifty percent of the total theft.
[4:34] Speaker 3: Then comes to the Toel.
[4:36] Speaker 2: Toel is top in Delhi Rachi Mumbaidpur division. Then pillow
[4:42] Speaker 2: covers is top the list in so on Pur and
[4:46] Speaker 2: Bilaspur division, Blanket are the primary target in Jodhpur with
[4:50] Speaker 2: over three point leg pieces taken, which is almost forty
[4:53] Speaker 2: two percent of the total theft of the line.
[4:56] Speaker 1: And what does the loss of over one point two
[4:58] Speaker 1: seven corde and items translate to in terms of financial
[5:04] Speaker 1: cost for the Indian Railways, So.
[5:06] Speaker 2: Our listeners should understand this is very clearly that these
[5:10] Speaker 2: linen thebs it does not cost anything to the Indian Railways.
[5:14] Speaker 2: So linin is a property of Indian Railways. They employ
[5:17] Speaker 2: contractors for the distingution of these linens and contractors in
[5:22] Speaker 2: turn employ a number of linen attendants. They are paid
[5:27] Speaker 2: on the daily basis, so their ever salary is I
[5:31] Speaker 2: would say it would be around fifteen to eighty thousand
[5:33] Speaker 2: piece per month. So whatever the linen is being stolen,
[5:37] Speaker 2: it is the linen attendant who have to pay from
[5:41] Speaker 2: their own pocket as a reimbursement for the help.
[5:44] Speaker 3: So these one point.
[5:46] Speaker 2: Twenty seven prore of linen items, the data shows, I
[5:48] Speaker 2: mean the DA replies shows that it collectively costs around
[5:52] Speaker 2: one hundred and.
[5:53] Speaker 3: Four coro rupees.
[5:55] Speaker 2: So all of these one zero four pro rupees mostly
[5:58] Speaker 2: it has been recovered from the lenin attendant. So imagine
[6:01] Speaker 2: a person who hardly gets fifteen sixteen thousand rupees in
[6:06] Speaker 2: a month or eighteen thousand rupiece in a month, and
[6:09] Speaker 2: if theft of let's say ten twenty thirty items happen
[6:12] Speaker 2: in the one month under his watch, so he or
[6:15] Speaker 2: she had to pay and that would be around two
[6:18] Speaker 2: to three thousand rupees.
[6:19] Speaker 1: Right, And talking about that, did you get the opportunity
[6:23] Speaker 1: to speak to some of these lenin attendants, what did
[6:27] Speaker 1: they have to say about the system?
[6:30] Speaker 2: Yeah, I spoke to a number of lenin attendants and
[6:32] Speaker 2: contractors from different divisions of the country and they said
[6:37] Speaker 2: the same thing that you know, the theat are happening
[6:40] Speaker 2: and the amount is being recovered from their own salary.
[6:43] Speaker 2: For instance, if somebody steals a pillow, so the lenin
[6:47] Speaker 2: attendant will have to pay rupees one one five for
[6:50] Speaker 2: a pillow, rupees one nine eight for a bed sheet,
[6:53] Speaker 2: eighty five rupees for a pillow cover, forty eight rupees
[6:56] Speaker 2: for a phase tawel, and.
[6:58] Speaker 3: Three forty three rupees for a blanket. So the cost
[7:02] Speaker 3: it's higher.
[7:03] Speaker 2: And when you will calculate in the maximum number of
[7:06] Speaker 2: lines being stolen, so this would account to on an
[7:09] Speaker 2: average two to three thousand years from each linen attendant's salary.
[7:14] Speaker 2: I mean, imagine how would a person feel. So it's
[7:16] Speaker 2: a kind of very bad situation that you know a
[7:19] Speaker 2: person who I mean someone who is not in any
[7:21] Speaker 2: way linked with this.
[7:22] Speaker 3: These theft cases, they have to be all of these costs.
[7:26] Speaker 1: And Dirich has the railways taken any measures to prevent
[7:30] Speaker 1: these incidents.
[7:32] Speaker 2: So the primary measure of preventing these theft cases is
[7:35] Speaker 2: to counsel the linen attendant. They keep instructing them that
[7:39] Speaker 2: you have to keep an eye, you have given watch,
[7:41] Speaker 2: you have to be attentive. I mean, all of these
[7:44] Speaker 2: things in a directional approach. So this is the one thing.
[7:48] Speaker 2: There is coaching app that Indian Railways have, so the
[7:51] Speaker 2: coach with app, the monitor, number of linen being handed out, number.
[7:55] Speaker 3: Of lanen coming back to the system, all of these things.
[7:57] Speaker 2: Then there are some divisions have deployed ces TV cameras
[8:00] Speaker 2: in you know, from where the linens are being taken,
[8:04] Speaker 2: then from where the linens are coming back.
[8:06] Speaker 3: All of these things. There is a railroboad circular.
[8:08] Speaker 2: Also in twenty fifteen, the railway boat send the circler
[8:11] Speaker 2: to all the divisions of the in railways and ask
[8:13] Speaker 2: them that the linen should be taken from the passengers thirteen.
[8:17] Speaker 3: Minutes before their arrival station.
[8:20] Speaker 2: So some of the divisions do this, but I don't
[8:22] Speaker 2: think I mean, I have not personally also seen that
[8:25] Speaker 2: mostly the linens are taken back after a passenger deboard
[8:29] Speaker 2: the train, and even if a linen attendant wanted to
[8:32] Speaker 2: do so, the practically it is not possible because many
[8:35] Speaker 2: passengers they say that you know, I will not take it.
[8:38] Speaker 2: I will not give it back to you until I
[8:40] Speaker 2: arrive at the station.
[8:42] Speaker 3: I'm still on the journey.
[8:43] Speaker 2: So I mean again, en attends are they're not that
[8:46] Speaker 2: much empowered to argue so much with the passenger, so
[8:49] Speaker 2: they do this practically after all of the passengers devote
[8:53] Speaker 2: the train. So these are some broad thing that what
[8:56] Speaker 2: railways have taken and what divisions are right.
[9:01] Speaker 1: But what is the solution to this issue, What operational
[9:05] Speaker 1: changes could realistically reduce these incidents of winen theft.
[9:10] Speaker 2: I mean, I'm not sure that what can be done
[9:13] Speaker 2: in this regard, but I think it is largely the
[9:15] Speaker 2: responsibility of the passengers as well, So I would say
[9:18] Speaker 2: that I think passengers should be aware of this that
[9:21] Speaker 2: who is actually bearing the cost of these theat there
[9:25] Speaker 2: should be more sensitive and it is responsibly of the
[9:27] Speaker 2: passengers also to.
[9:28] Speaker 3: Give it back.
[9:29] Speaker 2: And then ultimately it's a public property.
[9:32] Speaker 3: It is not personal property. It is railways property.
[9:34] Speaker 2: It is meant to be used for a particular fixed
[9:37] Speaker 2: period of time, So that is what one can do. Another,
[9:41] Speaker 2: of course, the more watch on the passengers. So what
[9:45] Speaker 2: Railways have started this initiative installing CCTV cameras in all
[9:50] Speaker 2: coaches of the railways. So all of these the new
[9:53] Speaker 2: trains which are coming into the operation, all new reeks
[9:57] Speaker 2: of the railways, they have CCTV camera and coaches, but
[10:00] Speaker 2: not in the older trains.
[10:02] Speaker 3: Male express trains.
[10:03] Speaker 2: So Railways is installing these cctvken I think that might
[10:07] Speaker 2: be kind of helpful in reducing these theft cases. But
[10:11] Speaker 2: I think, I mean Railways has to take something in
[10:13] Speaker 2: this regard that you know, linen attendance do not.
[10:15] Speaker 3: Have to pay for these charges. So I think the
[10:19] Speaker 3: solution had to be thought through at the government level.
[10:22] Speaker 2: And yeah, I mean government has to think it more
[10:26] Speaker 2: in a practical manner that what can be done in
[10:28] Speaker 2: this regard.
[10:33] Speaker 1: And next we talk about a series of three falls
[10:36] Speaker 1: during the monsoon that has raised serious questions about how
[10:40] Speaker 1: Mumbai manages its urban tree cover. Between thirtieth of June
[10:44] Speaker 1: and tenth of July, more than eighteen hundred trees collapsed
[10:48] Speaker 1: across the city, killing three people and injuring over a dozen.
[10:52] Speaker 1: Among those who died was an eleven year old boy
[10:55] Speaker 1: after three fell on his school bus in Chambur. Now.
[10:59] Speaker 1: The BMC, the local civic body, has pointed to unusually
[11:02] Speaker 1: strong winds during this period, but records examined by The
[11:06] Speaker 1: Indian Express suggest that the problem goes much deeper. Mumbai
[11:11] Speaker 1: has nearly thirty lac trees, but BMC still relies largely
[11:15] Speaker 1: on visual inspection and citizen complaints to identify dangerous trees.
[11:20] Speaker 1: And besides this, experts also point to another major concern,
[11:24] Speaker 1: road concretization. So to understand why so many trees are
[11:28] Speaker 1: collapsing in Mumbai and how can the city prevent the
[11:31] Speaker 1: next fatal treefall, my colleague Ashasharma is joined by the
[11:35] Speaker 1: Indian expresses Acharya Pati.
[11:38] Speaker 4: Most people naturally associate falling trees with unusual weather, but
[11:43] Speaker 4: more than eighteen hundred trees collapsing within just eleven days,
[11:47] Speaker 4: Is this really just because of heavy rain?
[11:51] Speaker 5: So there are with three instances of which the trees
[11:55] Speaker 5: that had collapsed or the branches from the trees that
[11:58] Speaker 5: had collapsed were winning the roads that have been newly councreatized.
[12:03] Speaker 5: So after this incident started to happen, Mumbai's Principal commissioners,
[12:07] Speaker 5: she took a press conference and she said that the
[12:09] Speaker 5: trees are collapsing mainly because of a climatic phenomenon because
[12:13] Speaker 5: during those first few days of July when there were
[12:16] Speaker 5: rains were happening, the wind speed was also very fairly high,
[12:20] Speaker 5: which is rightly so because the average wind speed that
[12:23] Speaker 5: blew over the past two three days, like between July
[12:26] Speaker 5: five and July seven, like the winds blew around seventy
[12:29] Speaker 5: to eighty kilometer hour for Mumbai. The normal rains during
[12:32] Speaker 5: monsoon is around twenty to thirty kilometer para, which was
[12:35] Speaker 5: more than three times. So the administration is saying that
[12:39] Speaker 5: it is mainly because the high wind speed that the
[12:41] Speaker 5: trees are losing the balance. But an expert that we interviewed,
[12:46] Speaker 5: his name is doctor Rajen Rashinde. He's a former Principal
[12:50] Speaker 5: of Mumbai Sinxevier's College, and he used to be the
[12:52] Speaker 5: head of the department of the botany department in Sinxevia's
[12:55] Speaker 5: College as well as he also served as the principal
[12:57] Speaker 5: of the same college. And he was also the coordinator
[13:01] Speaker 5: of Mumbai's first tree sensors that took part in nineteen
[13:04] Speaker 5: ninety eight. So he told us that this is not
[13:08] Speaker 5: entirely a climatic phenomenon. Firstly, Secondly, it has to do
[13:12] Speaker 5: a lot with the concretization of tree because since the
[13:15] Speaker 5: base of the trees are getting concretized, the roots can't grow.
[13:18] Speaker 5: And also due to the concretings of his water can't
[13:21] Speaker 5: percolate inside the like the ground level, due to which
[13:25] Speaker 5: the roots are like the mouth of the tree. They
[13:27] Speaker 5: won't get the nutrition in a way. With time that
[13:30] Speaker 5: gets decayed. And at many times, you know, the experts
[13:33] Speaker 5: are saying that concretes are like put on the roots,
[13:36] Speaker 5: so which literally is like an acid putting on your skin,
[13:39] Speaker 5: and this kills the roots. So experts are saying that
[13:42] Speaker 5: it is not entirely a climatic situation and it is
[13:46] Speaker 5: mostly man made. So basically the viewpoint that the government
[13:50] Speaker 5: or the administration has and the viewpoint that the experts
[13:53] Speaker 5: that have are very much contradictory to each other.
[13:56] Speaker 4: Right, And during your reportage you examine the BMC's own records.
[14:00] Speaker 4: So what did you discover about how the civic body
[14:03] Speaker 4: monitors tree health?
[14:05] Speaker 5: So for that we have to understand a little bit
[14:07] Speaker 5: about you know, what is the system of tree management
[14:10] Speaker 5: in Mumbai. So basically, the BMC, which is our one
[14:13] Speaker 5: local body, they have a tree authority and it's like
[14:16] Speaker 5: a committee statutory committee whose members are elected representatives across
[14:21] Speaker 5: party lines, and the chairperson of the committee is the
[14:23] Speaker 5: Mumbais Municipal Commission. So basically, whenever there is a proposal
[14:27] Speaker 5: that would you require cutting off trees or you know,
[14:31] Speaker 5: alignment of a road or if you're making a bridge
[14:35] Speaker 5: that would affect some trees that are falling over there,
[14:37] Speaker 5: so that department have to submit a proposal to that
[14:41] Speaker 5: committee and then the committee scrutinizes it, gives their inputs
[14:45] Speaker 5: and on the basis of their inputs, on the basis
[14:46] Speaker 5: of how the proposal looks like, they either clear it
[14:49] Speaker 5: or they hold that. So this is what the Tree
[14:52] Speaker 5: committee does. So basically, when this I mean road congretization
[14:57] Speaker 5: project was mooted, it was proposed to three and between
[15:00] Speaker 5: twenty twenty two and twenty twenty six, there were no
[15:04] Speaker 5: elected representatives in Mumbai in the Mumbai Savi.
[15:07] Speaker 4: Body right And for those who may not be familiar
[15:09] Speaker 4: with this, BMC elections didn't take place for nearly four
[15:13] Speaker 4: years after March twenty twenty two because of a combination
[15:16] Speaker 4: of factors like the pandemic, prolonged legal disputes over reservation
[15:21] Speaker 4: and unresolved issues related to delimitation of wards. And this
[15:25] Speaker 4: went on until the Supreme Court's August twenty twenty five
[15:28] Speaker 4: directive which forced the elections to be held this year.
[15:32] Speaker 5: So yeah, and the BMC was running under a public
[15:36] Speaker 5: administrator's rule. As a result, there was no scope of
[15:39] Speaker 5: you know, consulting with public representatives. There was no scope
[15:43] Speaker 5: of consulting with tree Authority and everything. And even though
[15:46] Speaker 5: while the elected representatives were not there, the Principal Commissioner
[15:50] Speaker 5: had the power of the Tree Authority. So as a result,
[15:53] Speaker 5: the Roads Department could have sent the proposal to the
[15:58] Speaker 5: Chief Committee or the Uncipal commission sighting like so many
[16:01] Speaker 5: but these things were not done. First and foremost, and secondly,
[16:05] Speaker 5: there is no kind of tree management I mean in
[16:08] Speaker 5: other cities. For if you look at Hydrabada, you look
[16:10] Speaker 5: at it, there are literally arbor raised or there are
[16:13] Speaker 5: botanists who carry out you know, surveys checking trees health,
[16:17] Speaker 5: you know, the structural stability of a tree. But in
[16:19] Speaker 5: Mumbai that is not in place. The only thing that
[16:23] Speaker 5: BFC does there are two things that deencibles when it
[16:25] Speaker 5: comes to tree health management. One is this you know cutting,
[16:28] Speaker 5: like pulling out these nails, these holdings and these concrete
[16:32] Speaker 5: slabs that are being put around the tree or put
[16:35] Speaker 5: on the tree for a while. That is the one
[16:37] Speaker 5: thing they do. And the second thing they do is
[16:39] Speaker 5: you know they remove you know, overgrown branches, this overgrown
[16:43] Speaker 5: leaves just before monsoon. It is called a preuning rag
[16:46] Speaker 5: to ensure that the tree doesn't become overweight and it
[16:48] Speaker 5: doesn't collapse. So these two things they do, and these
[16:51] Speaker 5: are mainly complaint. Mumbai doesn't have a you know preemptive
[16:54] Speaker 5: mechanism in place where you know, arbos or botanists would
[16:58] Speaker 5: check our tree's here, would keep our tap on this
[17:00] Speaker 5: old trees, these heritage trees. And then you find out
[17:05] Speaker 5: mitigation measures and how to tackle them, how to take
[17:07] Speaker 5: care of them. So these things are not there in.
[17:10] Speaker 4: Place and to keep Another striking detail that you highlight
[17:14] Speaker 4: is that the BMC doesn't even have the equipment needed
[17:17] Speaker 4: to detect hidden decay. Talk about why does that matter
[17:20] Speaker 4: so much?
[17:21] Speaker 5: So yeah, so why I was speaking with a few
[17:23] Speaker 5: officials as well as an expert. It was called a recistograph.
[17:27] Speaker 5: So it's like a drilling machine which is being put
[17:29] Speaker 5: inside a tree like it's a non damaging drill. It's
[17:33] Speaker 5: just like spoking a small needle like hole, and that
[17:36] Speaker 5: gives you a general idea whether a tree is decayed
[17:39] Speaker 5: from inside or hollow from inside, or some it has
[17:41] Speaker 5: a fungal infection or some kind of infection, it is
[17:44] Speaker 5: having some decay or for that matter. So when I
[17:47] Speaker 5: spoke with officials, they said, we don't have that machine
[17:50] Speaker 5: because usually when we do this kind of stuff, we
[17:53] Speaker 5: hire a contractor they have their own equipments, because the
[17:57] Speaker 5: BMC don't have enough ADA quit bandpower or they don't
[18:01] Speaker 5: have adequate infrastructure to carry out this kind of drive.
[18:05] Speaker 5: Because usually even that, like I said, the tree pruning
[18:08] Speaker 5: drive where they you know, cut overgrown branches and leaves
[18:11] Speaker 5: just before Bonso this has also being done by third
[18:14] Speaker 5: party contractors.
[18:16] Speaker 4: And can you talk about when did the city start
[18:18] Speaker 4: concretizing roads in this manner.
[18:21] Speaker 5: Yeah, So this road concretization is a project that was
[18:24] Speaker 5: you know, is the brainchild of Deputy Chief Minister who
[18:27] Speaker 5: was then Chief Minister Ikna Chinwe in twenty twenty two,
[18:30] Speaker 5: who said all the roads of Mumbai will be concretized
[18:33] Speaker 5: to make sure that the problem pertaining to the porthole
[18:36] Speaker 5: problem doesn't exist anymore. So according to the administration of
[18:40] Speaker 5: that time in Mumbai, the roads have portals because they
[18:43] Speaker 5: are made of asphalt and vitamin so if you congretize it,
[18:47] Speaker 5: concrete road don't have portholes. So that's why all the
[18:49] Speaker 5: roads were decided to be concretized. So now these trees
[18:52] Speaker 5: that are just in the periphery of the road or
[18:55] Speaker 5: they are just lining the roads of Mumbai, they have
[18:57] Speaker 5: a tree base which is the route of tree basically,
[19:00] Speaker 5: so these roots hold the ground very firmly. So when
[19:03] Speaker 5: you're making that potion a concrete surface root of the trees,
[19:07] Speaker 5: they can't penetrate deep inside the ground and these roots
[19:11] Speaker 5: loses their foundation.
[19:13] Speaker 4: Right, and climate change has become part of this conversation.
[19:16] Speaker 4: But after speaking to experts, how much of this problem
[19:20] Speaker 4: is really about extreme weather.
[19:23] Speaker 5: One of the interesting things that the expert told me
[19:25] Speaker 5: is like, if it has to be a really climatological factor,
[19:28] Speaker 5: then trees must be falling inside Sanjayan, the National park
[19:31] Speaker 5: inside Adoba. These are forests, no concrete has not reached there,
[19:35] Speaker 5: and obviously there are more number of trees than we
[19:37] Speaker 5: have in Mombai inside the city. So then we should
[19:41] Speaker 5: do an analysis of hormone trees that has fallen inside
[19:43] Speaker 5: a fallen inside the roads of them, and then you
[19:47] Speaker 5: will clearly get chalk and cheese like which is what
[19:50] Speaker 5: is driven by what Like within twenty four hours spent
[19:54] Speaker 5: more than five hundred trees are collapsing, which is very alarming.
[19:57] Speaker 5: So yeah, and to think this is.
[20:00] Speaker 4: The first warning, right. Many of these problems were identified
[20:03] Speaker 4: years ago, and in twenty twenty one, the BMC commissioned
[20:07] Speaker 4: a scientific assessment of aging trees, but the report was
[20:11] Speaker 4: never made public. Then it also announced ward level tree
[20:14] Speaker 4: surgeons in twenty twenty two, but the proposal was never implemented.
[20:18] Speaker 4: So why did these earlier recommendations never got translated into
[20:23] Speaker 4: systems like I.
[20:24] Speaker 5: Said, there is a tree authority who only looks after
[20:27] Speaker 5: you know, permissions pertaining to whether a tree should be
[20:30] Speaker 5: cut or what will be the compersate re affortation all this,
[20:33] Speaker 5: So there is no proper scientific lick like impaneled body
[20:37] Speaker 5: inside the BMC that will look after a tree's health.
[20:39] Speaker 5: Maybe that is why so when it comes to you know,
[20:43] Speaker 5: proper scientific and there is no warning system as such.
[20:46] Speaker 5: I mean, the tree department had warned the Road Department
[20:49] Speaker 5: that you are damaging our roots, but it has been unwarning.
[20:53] Speaker 5: Like we can see like nothing was done after that.
[20:55] Speaker 5: There were two warnings that were sent, so nothing was
[20:57] Speaker 5: done after one was last year and one was in
[20:59] Speaker 5: this March our February twenty six or the first quarter
[21:03] Speaker 5: of this year. So nothing was done right, and so.
[21:06] Speaker 4: What reforms is the BMC now considering.
[21:09] Speaker 5: So basically the municipal commissioner calling out a press conference,
[21:12] Speaker 5: she said that she's going to, you know, look into
[21:15] Speaker 5: this matter very seriously and they want to appoint experts
[21:18] Speaker 5: with from Muma University or an I Bombay who would
[21:21] Speaker 5: give recommendation, carry out a study and everything. So after
[21:24] Speaker 5: the unfortunately an incident that happened on June thirty when
[21:28] Speaker 5: like a eleven year old lost his life. Vihans was
[21:32] Speaker 5: was the name of the boy. The municipal administration had
[21:34] Speaker 5: constituted committee. I mean it was being headed by two
[21:37] Speaker 5: deputy municipal Commissioners and there were multiple members as well,
[21:42] Speaker 5: and the job of the committee was to find out,
[21:44] Speaker 5: you know, ways to so that this kind of doesn't
[21:47] Speaker 5: happen in the future. So they have givens of recommendations.
[21:50] Speaker 5: For example, one of the main key takeaways that they
[21:53] Speaker 5: have suggested was, you know, to going forward, all the
[21:56] Speaker 5: civic contracts infrastructure contracts will have a closet that ten
[22:00] Speaker 5: that will say that the contractors should be responsible for
[22:03] Speaker 5: maintaining and to ensure that the tree health or the
[22:07] Speaker 5: tree roots of that are in periphery of the walk
[22:10] Speaker 5: site where the project has been executed are being taken
[22:13] Speaker 5: care of and if any damage is being happens to
[22:16] Speaker 5: the tree going forward or during the project or after
[22:19] Speaker 5: the it is going to damage the contractor and it
[22:22] Speaker 5: is going to be the constructor responsibility that why it
[22:26] Speaker 5: is happening. The BMC has also proposed you know a
[22:29] Speaker 5: drive called Riksha Mithra driver. They will you know, rope
[22:32] Speaker 5: in citizens. They will rope in angios and everyone to
[22:36] Speaker 5: ensure that tree protection, tree conservation is being done at
[22:39] Speaker 5: a grassroot level in the city, so the public illness
[22:41] Speaker 5: is also their public participation is also there so that
[22:44] Speaker 5: citizens have better knowledge, like if in my neighborhood I
[22:47] Speaker 5: have a tree that is in a precarious condition, I
[22:49] Speaker 5: will be able to inform BMC. I will be able
[22:52] Speaker 5: to take care of it if I'm being provided some
[22:54] Speaker 5: means or something. And also another important thing that has
[22:57] Speaker 5: been suggested is to you know, impan arborist biologists in
[23:02] Speaker 5: the BMC, so they will be you know, overseeing projects
[23:04] Speaker 5: that are being siving in for such a project that
[23:06] Speaker 5: would have taken up, they will be giving their own understanding.
[23:09] Speaker 5: They will be giving their own sharing, their own knowledge,
[23:12] Speaker 5: their guidance and how much to avoid this kind of
[23:14] Speaker 5: incidence in the future. For example, if you are taking
[23:17] Speaker 5: a similar project with in line with this road competition project,
[23:21] Speaker 5: there will be arbo raised or horticulture is who will
[23:24] Speaker 5: actually guide you to tell you no, you shouldn't be
[23:26] Speaker 5: doing like this way. You should maintain this much cap
[23:29] Speaker 5: between the tree and the road so there is an
[23:31] Speaker 5: adequate space for the tree roots to grow and roots
[23:34] Speaker 5: to spread so the tree stays healthy. And at the
[23:36] Speaker 5: same time it is also a public security crisis. So
[23:39] Speaker 5: if a tree falls, you and I anybody can get damaged.
[23:42] Speaker 5: So just to avoid these things, the BMC is planning
[23:44] Speaker 5: to hold this kind of mechanisms.
[23:51] Speaker 1: And in the end we talk about a jump voat
[23:53] Speaker 1: allowing the counter and Intelligence unit of the Jumpointushed Police
[23:57] Speaker 1: to conduct at tendak sterudial questioning of free publishers arrested
[24:01] Speaker 1: in connection with the publication and distribution of two books
[24:05] Speaker 1: allegedly containing contents glorifying separatists and mertants. The Indian Expresses
[24:11] Speaker 1: Around Sharma reported that the publishers, identified as inter Paul
[24:14] Speaker 1: sing from Obrooi Book Service Jammu and Amadeep Singh and
[24:18] Speaker 1: Griish Arora from Neuda based Dominant Publishers, were arrested on
[24:22] Speaker 1: Sunday as a part of an investigation into the publication
[24:25] Speaker 1: and supply of two books, Personalities and Legends of Jenk
[24:30] Speaker 1: and Great Personalities of Chamuyen Kashmir to government school libraries
[24:34] Speaker 1: in Chamuyen Kashmir. The first book is authored by Hilal
[24:37] Speaker 1: Ehmert and Santoshmina and the second one is authored by
[24:41] Speaker 1: Sushanth Green. While searches are in progress to track down
[24:44] Speaker 1: the authors, officials said, the arrested publishers were virtually produced
[24:49] Speaker 1: before the court, which granted ten days police remand to
[24:52] Speaker 1: facilitate further investigation into the case. After the books were
[24:56] Speaker 1: withdrawn from school libraries, the JNK Police had registered a
[25:00] Speaker 1: case under BNS sections forty nine avetment of an offense,
[25:04] Speaker 1: sixty one to two criminal conspiracy, one fifty two endangering
[25:08] Speaker 1: the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India, one ninety six
[25:12] Speaker 1: promoting enemity disharmony and three fifty three publishing or circulating
[25:17] Speaker 1: false statements, rumors or reports, besides Section thirteen of the
[25:21] Speaker 1: Unlawful Activities Prevention Act. Officials said the counterintelligence personnel of
[25:26] Speaker 1: the JNK Police had conducted searches on the premises of
[25:29] Speaker 1: both the publication houses on sixth of July. As many
[25:33] Speaker 1: as two fifty one copies of the books had been
[25:35] Speaker 1: distributed in Jammu, ramban, Udampur and Baramulla districts of Jenk
[25:40] Speaker 1: and all copies have been withdrawn. The government had also
[25:43] Speaker 1: ordered a high level inquiry into the matter around writes
[25:46] Speaker 1: that the action followed objections raised by BJP Congress and
[25:50] Speaker 1: other political groups who claimed that the books glorified separatism.
[25:54] Speaker 1: One of the books purportedly called mcgoulbat, co founder of
[25:57] Speaker 1: the separatist Jammu Kashmir Liberation Front and who was hanged
[26:01] Speaker 1: in the Hard Jail on two murder charges Matyr. It
[26:04] Speaker 1: also purportedly describes separateist political leader and JIMO in Kashmir
[26:08] Speaker 1: Democratic Freedom Party founder President Shabishah as quote, one of
[26:13] Speaker 1: the highest profile campaigners for Kashmir independence, who campaigned for
[26:17] Speaker 1: self determination in Kashmir since the late nineteen sixties and
[26:20] Speaker 1: had spent much of his life in Indian Jail's un quote,
[26:27] Speaker 1: you were listening to three Things by the Indian Express.
[26:30] Speaker 1: Today's episode was edited and mixed by Surish Babar and
[26:34] Speaker 1: produced by Ichasharma and me Nihari Kananda. If you like
[26:38] Speaker 1: the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get
[26:40] Speaker 1: your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone
[26:43] Speaker 1: you think we'll like it, share it with a friend
[26:45] Speaker 1: or someone in your family. It's the best way for
[26:48] Speaker 1: people to get to know about us. You can also
[26:50] Speaker 1: tweet us at Express podcast and write to us at
[26:53] Speaker 1: podcasts at indian express dot com.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
