# Tarun Tejpal verdict, healthcare system crisis, and PoK elections

An episode of [3 Things](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1406730235), 11 Aug 2026, 34 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/73773662/3_things_2026_august_11_v2_1.mp3

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ National Legal Editor Apurva Vishwanath about the Bombay High Court’s conviction of former Tehelka editor Tarun Tejpal in a 2013 rape case, why it overturned his earlier acquittal, and its observation that the notion of a “perfect victim” is a myth. Next, we speak to The Indian Express’ Purnima Sah about the series of protests affecting Maharashtra’s healthcare system, including attacks on medical workers, staffing shortages and opposition to allowing certain homeopathy practitioners to register with the Maharashtra Medical Council after completing a bridge course. (18:20) And in the end, we look at the indefinite postponement of voting for seven seats in Pakistan-occupied Kashmir amid violent protests, allegations of electoral manipulation, a sweeping security crackdown and mounting international concern. (30:25) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: In today's episode, we look at why Maharashtra's healthcare system
[0:04] Speaker 1: has seen repeated protests over violence, staff shortages, and the
[0:08] Speaker 1: scope of medical practice. We also turned to elections in
[0:12] Speaker 1: Pakistan occupied Kashmir, where voting for seven seats has been
[0:16] Speaker 1: postponed amid protests, a security crackdown and questions over the
[0:21] Speaker 1: credibility of the polls itself. But first we talk about
[0:25] Speaker 1: the Bombay High Court's conviction of former Tahelka editor Taruntaje
[0:29] Speaker 1: Pal and its rejection of the idea that there is
[0:32] Speaker 1: a perfect way for a survivor to respond to sexual assault. Hi,
[0:40] Speaker 1: I'm a Chasharma and you're listening to three things the
[0:43] Speaker 1: Indian Express New show. Last week, the Bombay High Court
[0:52] Speaker 1: convicted journalist taruntaje Pal, the founder and former editor in
[0:56] Speaker 1: chief of Tehlka magazine, in a twenty thirteen rape case.
[1:00] Speaker 1: Taj Pal was once one of India's most prominent editors
[1:04] Speaker 1: and the allegations against him had made national headlines. These
[1:08] Speaker 1: allegations also affected the reputation of the Helka, which was
[1:12] Speaker 1: known for its hard hitting journalism. Now, in twenty twenty one,
[1:16] Speaker 1: a trial court had acquitted Taje Pal relying mainly on
[1:20] Speaker 1: its assessment of the survivor's conduct and character. But while
[1:24] Speaker 1: convicting him, the Bombay High Court underlined that the idea
[1:28] Speaker 1: of a perfect victim is a myth. It said, neither
[1:32] Speaker 1: the court nor the accused can decide how a survivor
[1:36] Speaker 1: should react to or process her trauma. Taj Pal has
[1:40] Speaker 1: been convicted of aggravated rape and other related offenses and
[1:44] Speaker 1: sentenced to ten years of rigorous imprisonment. To understand the
[1:48] Speaker 1: details of the case and the observations made by the court,
[1:51] Speaker 1: michaelik Shang Pharkav spoke to The Inexpress's national legal editor,
[1:56] Speaker 1: Apurva Vishwanath.
[1:59] Speaker 2: Can you begin by telling us what exactly was stage
[2:03] Speaker 2: Pal accused of and what do we know about what
[2:06] Speaker 2: happened in this case?
[2:08] Speaker 3: So the charge of aggravated rape against sarvantage Pal, this
[2:12] Speaker 3: case involves digital rape, which means non pino vaginal intercourse.
[2:18] Speaker 3: Of course, that is non consensual, which means it's not
[2:22] Speaker 3: that a penis was inserted into a vagina, but other
[2:26] Speaker 3: methods including digits which are your fingers. And this was
[2:30] Speaker 3: brought into the criminal law lexicon after twenty thirteen. So
[2:34] Speaker 3: this is posting it by incident. After protests in the country,
[2:38] Speaker 3: the law was amended to kind of make it more
[2:43] Speaker 3: broad and include more offenses into this actual assault definition.
[2:48] Speaker 3: So this case really becomes this emblematic case of digital
[2:52] Speaker 3: rape that we've seen since then. In fact, in fact,
[2:55] Speaker 3: there hasn't been another big case like this involving similar facts.
[3:00] Speaker 3: The idea of aggravated rape right that a man who
[3:03] Speaker 3: is in a position of power is actually assaulting the survivor.
[3:07] Speaker 3: This also came in with the twenty thirteen criminal law amendments,
[3:11] Speaker 3: so that was essentially the charge. Of course, Apart from that,
[3:14] Speaker 3: there is of course a sexual harassment charge against him,
[3:17] Speaker 3: and also the use of criminal force against a woman,
[3:21] Speaker 3: which is basically an assault charge.
[3:23] Speaker 2: And for those who are not familiar with what happened,
[3:26] Speaker 2: tell us what do we know about it?
[3:28] Speaker 3: So this case also kind of, you know, the facts
[3:31] Speaker 3: of it became a topic of such conversation because digital rape,
[3:35] Speaker 3: as we understood it, was being talked about for the
[3:38] Speaker 3: first time. And to top it off, the incident as
[3:41] Speaker 3: it happened, happened in a closed space which is inside
[3:45] Speaker 3: a lift, so there was no sincesty footage of what
[3:48] Speaker 3: really happened there, and given the kind of prominence Atage
[3:51] Speaker 3: Pal had at that time, you know, as one of
[3:54] Speaker 3: the most well known editors of a media house. So
[3:57] Speaker 3: all of these really put the case into spotlight. In
[4:01] Speaker 3: twenty twenty one, we had the Trialdhurt, which is a
[4:05] Speaker 3: sessions caught in Goa in almost a five hundred odd
[4:08] Speaker 3: paid judgment. A quit stage Pal and basically say that
[4:12] Speaker 3: you know, the survivor did not possibly behave like a
[4:15] Speaker 3: victim of sexual assault. Since this case kind of took
[4:19] Speaker 3: media center stage, there was a lot of conversation about
[4:23] Speaker 3: who the survivor is and the nature of the incident itself,
[4:28] Speaker 3: rather than on the prosecution and what happens after. The
[4:33] Speaker 3: other layer to this, of course, is like you've been
[4:36] Speaker 3: seeing even statements now from tage Pal and his family
[4:39] Speaker 3: that he started talking about a witch hunt by the
[4:43] Speaker 3: state because in this case the survivor only had filed
[4:46] Speaker 3: a POSH complaint within her organization. It is a state
[4:50] Speaker 3: which took up the issue and you know, initiated a
[4:53] Speaker 3: case of rape against him. I mean, there's nothing unlawful
[4:56] Speaker 3: about this, you know, any heenus crime. It is a
[5:00] Speaker 3: case which the state fights on your behalf, right, So
[5:03] Speaker 3: which is why you take any criminal case. It would say, say,
[5:06] Speaker 3: for example Sheshank versus State of Delhi. Right, So it's
[5:10] Speaker 3: really considered a crime against a society. So the state
[5:13] Speaker 3: fights for you. So there's nothing wrong in the state
[5:15] Speaker 3: somo to taking up the case. You know that is
[5:18] Speaker 3: somehow held up as if that the government really went
[5:21] Speaker 3: after the age Pal. But if there is a cognizable offense,
[5:24] Speaker 3: something like grape, the police is bound to take note
[5:27] Speaker 3: of it and file an fir, even if a report
[5:30] Speaker 3: doesn't come to them directly.
[5:32] Speaker 2: It was a page pall, like you mentioned, called this
[5:35] Speaker 2: witch hunt. But when this matter first came to light,
[5:38] Speaker 2: when the allegations were first made, did he deny them.
[5:42] Speaker 3: So the facts of the case, which have now been
[5:44] Speaker 3: recorded in both the court judgments, and we'd also seen
[5:48] Speaker 3: this in circulation on the media before that. When the
[5:51] Speaker 3: initial sexual harassment complaint was made within the HELCA stage,
[5:55] Speaker 3: Pal wrote two emails, one to the survivor herself directly
[5:59] Speaker 3: and two the staff at the HELCA, which is a
[6:02] Speaker 3: larger email in which he does accept responsibility, says that
[6:06] Speaker 3: you know, he is apologetic about the incident and that
[6:10] Speaker 3: this was unwanted attention to a colleague and then also
[6:16] Speaker 3: says that this is not sexual laison, that was consensual.
[6:20] Speaker 3: So these admissions happen in those emails. But having said that,
[6:23] Speaker 3: those emails are not really treated as direct evidence, right,
[6:27] Speaker 3: why not? I mean it was really part of the
[6:30] Speaker 3: court records in that way. It was of course used
[6:33] Speaker 3: to buttress the point that Pal had already you know,
[6:36] Speaker 3: sent these emails. But what you say before a magistrate
[6:40] Speaker 3: is what is admissible in the eyes of law, right,
[6:43] Speaker 3: So your statement has to be given before a magistrate,
[6:46] Speaker 3: and it is on that statement, against that statement that
[6:49] Speaker 3: you're cross examined and questioned by the prosecution. What you
[6:52] Speaker 3: say outside the system really doesn't count. So those emails
[6:56] Speaker 3: per se are not evidence, but of course used to
[7:00] Speaker 3: buttress the point that, you know, there was some kind
[7:03] Speaker 3: of an acceptance of guilt.
[7:05] Speaker 2: And like we mentioned earlier as well, the trial quote
[7:10] Speaker 2: in twenty twenty one had acquitted Tage Pal and had
[7:13] Speaker 2: many looked at the complainant's demeanor and her character. So
[7:18] Speaker 2: talk about what had it Why had it acquitted Tage Pal,
[7:21] Speaker 2: What exactly did it look at?
[7:24] Speaker 3: Yeah, so the sessions Coote had detailed the woman's complain,
[7:29] Speaker 3: you know, WhatsApp chats, email exchanges repeatedly to discredit her.
[7:33] Speaker 3: The style court judgments basically looked at her sexual relationships
[7:38] Speaker 3: in the past and even i've used on say consensual sex, drinking, smoking,
[7:42] Speaker 3: whether something is morally okay or not, and how she
[7:46] Speaker 3: seemed cheerful and happy and quote unquote far from traumatized
[7:50] Speaker 3: in the photographs that were taken right after the alleged assault,
[7:53] Speaker 3: right and after the event and GOA which was the
[7:57] Speaker 3: Telki event, and go I ended that she visited a
[8:01] Speaker 3: hotel suite of an actor she was chaperoning, and her
[8:04] Speaker 3: flirtations or sexual conversations over WhatsApp groups, all of this
[8:09] Speaker 3: was sort of discussed threadbare to say that she cannot
[8:12] Speaker 3: be called a trustworthy or reliable witness. In fact, you know,
[8:16] Speaker 3: this was really the basis of the trial court judgment.
[8:19] Speaker 3: And now in the High Court judgment we actually found
[8:22] Speaker 3: out that it was a thousand page record of the
[8:26] Speaker 3: survivor's cross examination, which again you know, the prosecution said
[8:30] Speaker 3: it was as if that the survivor was on trial
[8:32] Speaker 3: and not stage pal. You know, it should have been
[8:34] Speaker 3: the other way around. But the trial court judgment was
[8:37] Speaker 3: largely hinged on this fact that the victim's testimony is unreliable.
[8:42] Speaker 3: Therefore the case falls apart. And I'll tell you why
[8:45] Speaker 3: this is important. Right, in a sexual assault case, the
[8:48] Speaker 3: statement of a victim is taken at face value, and
[8:52] Speaker 3: the only way to discredit that is to show loopholes
[8:56] Speaker 3: in it. Right, So the burden of proof is actually reversed.
[9:01] Speaker 3: So usually it is a prosecution which has to prove
[9:04] Speaker 3: that a crime took place, like which is a murder
[9:06] Speaker 3: or theft or something, and only this person did it
[9:09] Speaker 3: and nobody else could do it, you know, and all
[9:11] Speaker 3: of that. But in sexual assault cases, the black burden
[9:14] Speaker 3: of proof is reversed. The prosecutors makes a statement and
[9:18] Speaker 3: as long as that statement is not completely vitiated, it stands.
[9:23] Speaker 3: So the owners is actually on the accused to show
[9:26] Speaker 3: that the statement is unreliable. So which is why the
[9:30] Speaker 3: victim's role really becomes kind of, you know, problematic, and
[9:34] Speaker 3: it's so fraught in courtrooms.
[9:36] Speaker 2: Whether it does. This happen very often were a woman's
[9:39] Speaker 2: demeanor and her reaction post and assault is used against her.
[9:45] Speaker 3: I mean, this used to happen so often that there
[9:48] Speaker 3: was a huge protest letters written to the Chief Justice
[9:52] Speaker 3: of India at that time, and the CrPC was amended
[9:56] Speaker 3: to bring in a provision to say that a woman's
[9:59] Speaker 3: past or her sexual liaisons in the past should not
[10:03] Speaker 3: matter when a rape case is being heard. So you
[10:06] Speaker 3: can imagine how often this would happen. So this really
[10:09] Speaker 3: famous case called the Matura incident, a rape of a
[10:13] Speaker 3: woman in a police station happens, and this cop to
[10:16] Speaker 3: Karam is let off because the whole argument is that
[10:20] Speaker 3: Matura was habituated to having sex or that she had
[10:24] Speaker 3: premarital sex before and somehow that becomes okay to rape her, right.
[10:28] Speaker 3: So this case really shook how we understand this concept
[10:31] Speaker 3: or how frequently and often it's applied in court rooms.
[10:33] Speaker 3: So now there is a statutory embargo that a court
[10:36] Speaker 3: cannot really go into an inquiry about the victim's past
[10:40] Speaker 3: conduct when deciding a rape case. However, despite that, the
[10:44] Speaker 3: childhood seems to have completely sort of forgotten that and
[10:48] Speaker 3: talks so much about the victim's conduct after the event
[10:53] Speaker 3: to say that she really didn't have any trauma to
[10:56] Speaker 3: process and therefore her story of rape could not have
[10:59] Speaker 3: been show.
[11:00] Speaker 2: And so this matter obviously later on was appealed and
[11:04] Speaker 2: the bomb High Court looked at it, talk about why
[11:07] Speaker 2: I decided to do that? How did it come to
[11:09] Speaker 2: that conclusion that they needed to look at this case.
[11:13] Speaker 3: Yeah, So you know, an appeal in the High Court
[11:16] Speaker 3: is there's a higher threshold in law to sort of
[11:19] Speaker 3: clear because now there is a dual presumption of innocence,
[11:22] Speaker 3: you know, one which is a general for all criminal law. Right,
[11:25] Speaker 3: you're innocent under proven guilty. And then of course the
[11:29] Speaker 3: fact that a trial court has already acquitted you also
[11:32] Speaker 3: acts in some way positively for the accused. Right. So
[11:36] Speaker 3: now when the High Court is hearing this case, the
[11:39] Speaker 3: argument from the prosecution has to clear this double bar
[11:42] Speaker 3: so to speak. Right, so the court has to simply
[11:46] Speaker 3: find that the trial court's decision was directly contrary to
[11:50] Speaker 3: the evidence on record. That's it, whatever evidence that the
[11:52] Speaker 3: trial court has recorded, how the trialcoat interpreted that, or
[11:56] Speaker 3: how the trial courts kind of you know, join those dots.
[11:59] Speaker 3: That is so erroneous and it shows on a plane reading.
[12:03] Speaker 3: So that is the only bar. So, like you can imagine,
[12:05] Speaker 3: it's not an easy case to kind of win. So
[12:08] Speaker 3: hear what the High Court says is that the trial
[12:11] Speaker 3: court completely erred in finding these so called inconsistencies in
[12:16] Speaker 3: the statements of the survivor. They were not material contradictions
[12:20] Speaker 3: and they were minor inconsistencies, and which is what the
[12:24] Speaker 3: High Court says that the trialcourt record, the evidence shows,
[12:27] Speaker 3: and of course this whole conversation the trialcourt had about
[12:31] Speaker 3: being a perfect victim, that you have to behave in
[12:33] Speaker 3: a certain way, you have to be subdued, you have
[12:35] Speaker 3: to set in crime a room or all of those
[12:37] Speaker 3: notions that you have about a perfect victim.
[12:39] Speaker 2: Yeah, there's a stereotype that people have that if you're
[12:42] Speaker 2: a victim of you know, sexual assault, these are the
[12:45] Speaker 2: ways in which you will behave Otherwise you know, this
[12:47] Speaker 2: might not have happened to you.
[12:49] Speaker 3: Yeah, absolutely that.
[12:50] Speaker 2: You know.
[12:50] Speaker 3: The fact that the survivor in this case went in
[12:53] Speaker 3: first confided to male colleagues and not like a female
[12:57] Speaker 3: was also something that the trial court highlighted. So these
[13:00] Speaker 3: notions of how women should behave are the High Court
[13:04] Speaker 3: says that intrinsically wrong. They don't have to fit into
[13:06] Speaker 3: the mold of this narrow mold at the court or
[13:08] Speaker 3: the society carries and each one of course processes their
[13:12] Speaker 3: trauma in different ways and the court shouldn't be making
[13:15] Speaker 3: judgments based on that right. So this becomes really the
[13:20] Speaker 3: divergent view and how the High Court reads the same evidence,
[13:24] Speaker 3: the same statements, the same testimony, and how the Child
[13:27] Speaker 3: Court kind of records it. I'll give you one example.
[13:30] Speaker 3: The victim's statement is made and there are at least
[13:33] Speaker 3: seven other witnesses who stand their ground in cross examination
[13:39] Speaker 3: to support the victim statement. Okay, so these are witnesses
[13:42] Speaker 3: who the survivor has gone in confided to after the incident.
[13:47] Speaker 3: So and despite like some very serious cross examination, they've
[13:50] Speaker 3: all kind of stood their ground.
[13:52] Speaker 4: Right.
[13:53] Speaker 3: So here the High Court says, you know, you are
[13:56] Speaker 3: essentially saying that the inconsistencies and the victims statements are
[14:01] Speaker 3: some sort of you know, fatal to the case. They're
[14:03] Speaker 3: fatal contradictions. But that's not true. The other testimonies, you know,
[14:08] Speaker 3: this includes the mother, the man she later married, her
[14:12] Speaker 3: other colleagues. These seven testimonies all kind of remained unshaken
[14:16] Speaker 3: as for the High Court findings. So they say that,
[14:19] Speaker 3: you know, the victim has to firm in her testimony.
[14:21] Speaker 3: Other people have to form and corabborated her narration, so
[14:25] Speaker 3: there should be no hesitation to believe her testimony. So
[14:28] Speaker 3: that's how the High Court says that you know, you're
[14:30] Speaker 3: these inconsistencies. If you put that aside, the rest of
[14:34] Speaker 3: the things stands not only in her statement but also
[14:36] Speaker 3: in seven other statements that have been made.
[14:39] Speaker 4: Right.
[14:39] Speaker 3: So this sort of reading is what the High Court
[14:41] Speaker 3: brings into it, which the trial court kind of unfortunately overlooked.
[14:45] Speaker 2: And can you talk about what was the defense's argument
[14:48] Speaker 2: in the High Court.
[14:49] Speaker 3: So you know, one of the key arguments that the
[14:52] Speaker 3: defense made is that about manipulation of the lift. Right.
[14:58] Speaker 3: So again, how the defense argues right cases basically to find,
[15:01] Speaker 3: like I said, inconsistencies in the survivor's narration of events.
[15:05] Speaker 4: Right.
[15:06] Speaker 3: So, the victim and her testimony said that sh Pal
[15:09] Speaker 3: had pressed some buttons on the lift to kind of
[15:12] Speaker 3: hold the lift closed while the alleged incident took place
[15:15] Speaker 3: in the lift.
[15:16] Speaker 4: Right.
[15:16] Speaker 3: So the defense's argument was that you couldn't actually stop
[15:19] Speaker 3: the lift by manipulating those buttons, that such a mechanism
[15:23] Speaker 3: didn't exist at all. Right, And whereas the High Court
[15:27] Speaker 3: looked at the testimony of the hotel security manager a
[15:30] Speaker 3: lift technician, and they found that the doors could indeed
[15:33] Speaker 3: be kept closed by holding the close button. So this
[15:37] Speaker 3: kind of undercuts the argument that the defense made right.
[15:40] Speaker 3: And also CCTV footage of that floor which is available
[15:44] Speaker 3: shows the victim and the complainant entering and exiting the
[15:48] Speaker 3: lift exactly at the times within the time interval that
[15:51] Speaker 3: the victim narrated. And also the fact that she was say,
[15:55] Speaker 3: kind of seen adjusting her dress after she moved out.
[15:57] Speaker 3: These are all things that are in her statement, and
[16:00] Speaker 3: these kind of held up even in this CCTV footage,
[16:04] Speaker 3: So that central argument of the defense was kind of,
[16:07] Speaker 3: you know, completely negated by the High Court findings. The other,
[16:11] Speaker 3: of course, is the defense also had this overarching narrative
[16:15] Speaker 3: in their arguments that the prosecutricks or the survivor, was
[16:19] Speaker 3: trying to some way extract money or some benefit from
[16:24] Speaker 3: making this rape allegation. Right. One of the things that
[16:28] Speaker 3: the defense lawyer argued is, you know, a conversation which
[16:32] Speaker 3: is on her phone between the survivor and her stepmother
[16:36] Speaker 3: where she's being advised to take what is due to
[16:39] Speaker 3: her right. So the defense says, look, this is proof
[16:43] Speaker 3: that she was doing this for money, right, that she
[16:46] Speaker 3: wanted a severance package and whatever. So and they actually
[16:50] Speaker 3: use the word extortion here. The High Court says, Look,
[16:53] Speaker 3: someone who's losing their job, you know, based on an
[16:56] Speaker 3: incident that happened in this manner, is of course entitled
[17:00] Speaker 3: to get her fair wages, right, which includes the severance package.
[17:04] Speaker 3: A severance package cannot be considered like a ransom package.
[17:09] Speaker 3: So it seems like it's common sense. But the High
[17:12] Speaker 3: Court had to tell us this in the judgment.
[17:15] Speaker 2: Does this verdict set any sort of precedent?
[17:19] Speaker 3: Look, a High Court ruling is a judgment by a
[17:21] Speaker 3: constitutional court. In terms of where this judgment really takes
[17:25] Speaker 3: the law forward or its reatation, is very welcome is
[17:29] Speaker 3: in how the High Court kind of deconstructs this notion
[17:33] Speaker 3: we have about this ideal victim or a perfect victim.
[17:36] Speaker 4: Right.
[17:36] Speaker 3: So to trial courtes, this should be like a very
[17:39] Speaker 3: key learning that you cannot be looking for an ideal victim.
[17:44] Speaker 3: And this is especially only an issue in sexual assault cases. Right,
[17:49] Speaker 3: nobody is looking for an ideal theft victim, you know.
[17:52] Speaker 3: But women are put under scrutiny in this way. And
[17:55] Speaker 3: it's also a male gaze on how a woman is
[17:58] Speaker 3: supposed to react to sexual assault, and of course there
[18:00] Speaker 3: is class education, a lot of other dynamics involved in
[18:05] Speaker 3: how people react to a situation, and that is not
[18:08] Speaker 3: something that the trial courts should kind of examine to
[18:11] Speaker 3: come to conclusion whether the complainant is a sexual assault
[18:15] Speaker 3: survivor or not.
[18:21] Speaker 1: And next we talk about Maharashtra, where the healthcare system
[18:25] Speaker 1: has seen one protest after another over the past few weeks.
[18:29] Speaker 1: Over the past two months, Maharashtra has witnessed a series
[18:33] Speaker 1: of protests across its healthcare system. What began with anger
[18:38] Speaker 1: over attacks on doctors and nurses has expanded into a
[18:42] Speaker 1: larger unrest involving staff shortages and the regulation of medical practice.
[18:48] Speaker 1: And the latest controversy centers on the state government's decision
[18:52] Speaker 1: to allow certain homeopathy practitioners who have completed a one
[18:57] Speaker 1: year bridge course in Modern pharmacology to register with the
[19:01] Speaker 1: Maharashtra Medical Council.
[19:03] Speaker 2: Now.
[19:03] Speaker 1: Doctors and medical bodies opposing the move argue that it
[19:07] Speaker 1: could blur the distinction between mbb's doctors and practitioners who
[19:12] Speaker 1: have completed the bridge course. They feared this could leave
[19:15] Speaker 1: patients unclear about a practitioner's qualifications and the scope of
[19:19] Speaker 1: treatment they are legally allowed to provide. So to understand
[19:23] Speaker 1: why has Maharashtra's health care sector been witnessing the repeated
[19:27] Speaker 1: protests and where does the bridge course controversy stand. We
[19:31] Speaker 1: are joined by The Indian Express's Saha, who reported on
[19:34] Speaker 1: the story for the newspaper. Before we talk about the
[19:38] Speaker 1: latest row, could you help us understand why are we
[19:41] Speaker 1: seeing so many protests at the same time in the
[19:45] Speaker 1: state's health care system.
[19:46] Speaker 5: So this may look like several unrelated protests happening at once,
[19:50] Speaker 5: but they are actually symptoms for.
[19:53] Speaker 4: A much larger problem.
[19:54] Speaker 5: For nearly a year, Maharastra's healthcare sector has seen growing
[19:58] Speaker 5: frustration over workplace safety, staff shortages, policy decisions, leading to
[20:03] Speaker 5: what many doctors describe as a widening trust deficit between
[20:07] Speaker 5: the medical fraternity and the government. Take workplace violence, for instance,
[20:12] Speaker 5: the immediate trigger was the assault on doctors and nurses
[20:15] Speaker 5: in the month of July at kdmc's Shaski Hospital in Dombieville,
[20:20] Speaker 5: where a shifts in, a corporator and his supporters attacked
[20:23] Speaker 5: healthcare workers after a pregnant patient was referred to another hospital.
[20:28] Speaker 5: Because that particular hospitals and ICU was full that incident
[20:31] Speaker 5: sparked statewide protest by resident doctors and the Indian Medical Association,
[20:37] Speaker 5: but this wasn't an isolated incident on attack on doctors.
[20:42] Speaker 5: Just a few months earlier, relatives of a patient assaulted
[20:45] Speaker 5: a nurse and security guards at Mombi's Came Hospital after
[20:49] Speaker 5: a liver transplant patient died, once again, raising concerns about
[20:53] Speaker 5: the safety of healthcare workers. The doctors also often pointed
[20:56] Speaker 5: to the twenty fifteen assault on Came doctors after the
[21:00] Speaker 5: death of a Dengi patient as a reminder that attacks
[21:04] Speaker 5: on healthcare workers have continued for years, while convictions remain rare.
[21:08] Speaker 5: Alongside the government, nurses across Maharashtra have also been protesting
[21:13] Speaker 5: over long standing staffing shortages and poor working conditions. Their
[21:18] Speaker 5: primary demand is the implementation of the Indian Nursing Council's
[21:21] Speaker 5: prescribed nurs patient ratios, which the Maharashtra government had promised
[21:26] Speaker 5: through a government resolution in June twenty twenty five as
[21:30] Speaker 5: part of its one fifty day action program. Nurses say
[21:34] Speaker 5: that the promise has largely remained on paper, many government
[21:37] Speaker 5: hospitals continuing to function under hundreds of vacant nursing posts,
[21:41] Speaker 5: forcing a single loss to look after far more patients
[21:45] Speaker 5: than recommend it, especially in critical care areas such as
[21:48] Speaker 5: is use, emergency departments and labor rooms Biden.
[21:52] Speaker 1: Now there is this controversy concerning homeopathic practitioners who have
[21:57] Speaker 1: been allowed to register with the Maharashtra Medical count if
[22:00] Speaker 1: they complete a one year bridge course in Modern Pharmacology.
[22:05] Speaker 1: This is the CCMP course. So talk about what this
[22:08] Speaker 1: bridge course is and why it has triggered such strong
[22:12] Speaker 1: opposition from medical bodies.
[22:15] Speaker 5: So CCMP stands for the Certificate Course in Modern Pharmacology,
[22:20] Speaker 5: a one year bridge course conducted by the Maharashtra University
[22:24] Speaker 5: of Health Sciences for Bachelor of Homeopathic Medicine and Surgery.
[22:28] Speaker 5: This is DHMS graduates. The course was introduced after the
[22:32] Speaker 5: Maharashtra Legislature passed an amendment in twenty fourteen allowing BHMS
[22:37] Speaker 5: doctors to successfully complete the CCMP to prescribe specified allopathic
[22:42] Speaker 5: medicines and practice modern scientific medicine within the scope of
[22:46] Speaker 5: their training. The law also provides for maintaining a separate
[22:50] Speaker 5: register for these practitioners under the Maharastra Medical Council, which
[22:54] Speaker 5: is MMC.
[22:55] Speaker 4: Although the law has existed for.
[22:57] Speaker 5: More than a decade now, it was never implemented, leaving
[23:00] Speaker 5: thousands of doctors who completed the course waiting for registration.
[23:04] Speaker 5: This controversy resurfaced after the Maharashta government moved to operationalize
[23:10] Speaker 5: this provision and constituted an expert committee to define the
[23:13] Speaker 5: competency's scope of practice, ethical guidelines and standard operating procedures
[23:20] Speaker 5: before registrations began. Alabatic doctors, including the IMA and the
[23:24] Speaker 5: Maharashtra Association of Resident Doctors, say they are not opposed
[23:29] Speaker 5: to the bridge course itself. Their objection is to CCMP
[23:33] Speaker 5: qualified practitioners being registered under the MMC, the statutory regulator
[23:39] Speaker 5: for modern medicine. They argue that even though the law
[23:42] Speaker 5: provides for a separate register, having both MPD's doctors and
[23:46] Speaker 5: Bridge course qualified practitioners under the same regulator could blur
[23:50] Speaker 5: the distinction between their qualifications, create confusion among patients, and
[23:54] Speaker 5: dilute professional and regulatory standards. They also contend that a
[23:59] Speaker 5: one year of bridge course cannot be equated with the
[24:02] Speaker 5: five and a half years of MBBAS education and compulsory
[24:05] Speaker 5: internship and punama.
[24:07] Speaker 1: As you mentioned earlier, the law allowing this bridge course
[24:11] Speaker 1: has existed since twenty fourteen, so why has implementation taken
[24:16] Speaker 1: more than a decade.
[24:17] Speaker 5: So that's really the central question in this entire controversy.
[24:21] Speaker 5: The legal framework itself isn't new. Maharastra passed the Maharastra
[24:25] Speaker 5: Homeopathic Practitioners and Maharashtra Medical Council Amendment Act in twenty fourteen,
[24:31] Speaker 5: creating a legal provision for BHMS doctors who complete the
[24:36] Speaker 5: CCMP to prescribe a specified allopathic medicines and be registered
[24:41] Speaker 5: under a separate register maintained by MMC.
[24:44] Speaker 4: Thousands of doctors.
[24:45] Speaker 5: Completed the course over the years, but the registration process
[24:49] Speaker 5: was never operationalized. The government hasn't officially explained why implementation
[24:54] Speaker 5: remained stalled for more than a decade. However, are USh
[24:58] Speaker 5: organizations say successive went simply failed to imployment a law
[25:03] Speaker 5: that had already been passed by the legislature despite repeated
[25:06] Speaker 5: approvals and assurances. On the other hand, allopathic medical bodies
[25:11] Speaker 5: have consistently opposed the move, arging the registration under the
[25:15] Speaker 5: Maharastra Medical Council would blood the distinction between mbia's doctors
[25:19] Speaker 5: and the risk course qualified doctors.
[25:21] Speaker 4: So the issue resurfaced in twenty twenty.
[25:24] Speaker 5: Five when the Medical Education Department wrote to MC asking
[25:28] Speaker 5: it to begin registrations. That prompted the Indian Medical Association
[25:33] Speaker 5: to challenge the move before the Bombay High Court. While
[25:35] Speaker 5: the court did not stay the process, it clarified that
[25:38] Speaker 5: any registrations would remain subject with the final outcome of
[25:42] Speaker 5: the case.
[25:43] Speaker 1: And putting on these three disputes we just spoke of
[25:46] Speaker 1: violence against doctors, staffing shortages, and now the scope of
[25:51] Speaker 1: practice debates all pointed to different pressures on the healthcare workforce.
[25:57] Speaker 1: So do they collectively point to for deeper workforce crisis
[26:01] Speaker 1: in the state's public healthcare system.
[26:04] Speaker 4: Yes, they do.
[26:05] Speaker 5: While this protests may appear unrelated, they all expose different
[26:10] Speaker 5: facets of a much deeper workforce crisis in my Arrastra's
[26:13] Speaker 5: healthcare system right now. On one hand, doctors are demanding
[26:17] Speaker 5: safer workplaces because repeated incidents of violence have made many
[26:21] Speaker 5: healthcare professionals feel unsafe at work.
[26:24] Speaker 4: Nurses, meanwhile, are.
[26:25] Speaker 5: Highlighting droning vacancies, delay in recruitment and promotions, and the
[26:29] Speaker 5: failure to implement the prescribed nurse station ratios. Are going
[26:33] Speaker 5: that hospitals are operating with far fewer staff than required.
[26:38] Speaker 5: These are issues that directly affect existing healthcare workforce. At
[26:42] Speaker 5: the same time, the CCMP controversy reflects a different aspects
[26:46] Speaker 5: of the workforce debate. The government argues that allowing CCMP
[26:50] Speaker 5: qualified homoepathy practitioners to practice modern medicine within a defiant
[26:55] Speaker 5: scope could help bridge gaps in healthcare delivery, particularly in
[26:59] Speaker 5: the rural and undeserved areas where there is a shortage
[27:02] Speaker 5: of doctors. Allopathic medical bodies. However, counter that Maharastra today
[27:07] Speaker 5: produces nearly eleven thousand MBS graduates every year and point
[27:11] Speaker 5: out that the state has even had to cancel compulsory
[27:15] Speaker 5: bond postings in the recent years because they were not
[27:17] Speaker 5: enough government vacancies. They argue that the real problem is
[27:21] Speaker 5: not a shortage of qualified doctors, but inadequate recruitment into
[27:26] Speaker 5: the public health system and poor workforce planning.
[27:29] Speaker 4: So in many ways, this protest raise a.
[27:31] Speaker 5: Much larger question that is Maharashtra facing a shortage of
[27:36] Speaker 5: healthcare professionals or is it facing a shortage of sanctioned posts,
[27:40] Speaker 5: recruitment and effective deployment of the workforce it already has.
[27:45] Speaker 5: That's the debate at the heart of the current controversy. Ultimately,
[27:50] Speaker 5: all sides agree on one thing that Maharashtra right now
[27:53] Speaker 5: needs a stronger healthcare workforce. Where they all differ is
[27:57] Speaker 5: how to achieve that. The government sees the CCM the
[28:00] Speaker 5: framework as one of the ways to expand access to healthcare,
[28:03] Speaker 5: while doctors and nurses argue that the priority should be
[28:06] Speaker 5: given to filling the vacancies, improving working conditions, ensuring workplace safety,
[28:12] Speaker 5: and strengthening the existing public health care system. That broader
[28:15] Speaker 5: debate is likely to continue even after the current protests subside.
[28:19] Speaker 1: And so, Puma, what do these protests mean for patients?
[28:23] Speaker 1: Because of course this affects the delivery of health care
[28:26] Speaker 1: itself right.
[28:27] Speaker 5: Right, So patients have perhaps been the most immediate casualties
[28:32] Speaker 5: of this unrest because each of his disused directly or
[28:35] Speaker 5: indirectly affects access to healthcare services. During the recent protests,
[28:39] Speaker 5: resident doctors, private practitioners and nurses health strikes and work boycotts,
[28:44] Speaker 5: leading to disruption of routine out patient services, postponement of
[28:48] Speaker 5: non emergency procedures, and delayed consultation in several hospitals, although
[28:54] Speaker 5: emergency services continued and doctors repeatedly said that they did
[28:57] Speaker 5: not want patient care to suffer any disruption in a
[29:01] Speaker 5: state as large as Maharashtra affects thousands of people who
[29:05] Speaker 5: depend on public hospitals every day. For example, in several
[29:09] Speaker 5: hospitals when we visited in KM there were patients waiting
[29:12] Speaker 5: for surgeries. You know, there was one woman we met
[29:15] Speaker 5: yesterday and she was just pulled back from the operation theater.
[29:19] Speaker 5: She was almost reavy to go for the operation, but
[29:22] Speaker 5: because there were no doctors, she was told that, you know,
[29:25] Speaker 5: they will do your surgery after the strike is over.
[29:28] Speaker 5: So beyond the strikes, doctors and nurses argue that the
[29:31] Speaker 5: deeper issues such as violence against healthcare workers, staff shortages,
[29:35] Speaker 5: and delay in recruitment have a direct impact on patient care.
[29:39] Speaker 5: Nor says say many hospitals are functioning with far fewer
[29:42] Speaker 5: staff than required under prescribed nurse patient ratios as I mentioned.
[29:47] Speaker 5: Doctors meanwhile, say that concerns over safety and poor working
[29:50] Speaker 5: conditions affect morale and retention of healthcare workers. So now
[29:54] Speaker 5: with this CCMP controversy also has implications for patients because
[29:58] Speaker 5: it raises questions about who can provide what kind of
[30:02] Speaker 5: treatment and how different systems of medicine should be regulated. Ultimately,
[30:07] Speaker 5: what patients want is a healthcare system that is safe,
[30:10] Speaker 5: adequately staffed, and at visible. The current dispute have highlighted
[30:14] Speaker 5: that the workplace planning, hospital staffing, safety of healthcare workers,
[30:18] Speaker 5: and clear regulatory framework are not just issues for doctors
[30:21] Speaker 5: and nurses. They haven't direct pairing on the quality, continuity
[30:25] Speaker 5: and trustworthiness of patient care in marast.
[30:33] Speaker 1: And in the end we talk about elections in Pakistan
[30:36] Speaker 1: Occupied Kashmir, where voting for seven seats has been postponed
[30:41] Speaker 1: indefinitely amid violent protests, a worsening security situation, and growing
[30:47] Speaker 1: international concern over the crackdown. Now, polling for four of
[30:51] Speaker 1: the eleven seats scheduled in the final phase was held yesterday,
[30:55] Speaker 1: while voting for the remaining seven was deferred, as reported
[30:59] Speaker 1: by the Inner Expresses the VIA, the elections have been
[31:03] Speaker 1: overshadowed by weeks of protests and allegations of widespread rigging.
[31:07] Speaker 3: In the first two phases.
[31:09] Speaker 1: Held on twenty seventh of July and second of August,
[31:12] Speaker 1: thirty four of the forty five directly elected seats went
[31:16] Speaker 1: to the posts. The Pakistan Muslim League INN has already
[31:20] Speaker 1: claimed victory in twenty four seats, which could return it
[31:23] Speaker 1: to power in the region after a decade, but the
[31:27] Speaker 1: now banned Joint Avarmi Action Committee or JAAC, has called
[31:32] Speaker 1: for a boycott of the elections. The group, formed in
[31:34] Speaker 1: twenty twenty three, has been leading protests over economic hardship,
[31:38] Speaker 1: restrictions on civil liberties, and demands for greater political rights.
[31:43] Speaker 1: One of the biggest points of contention is the system
[31:46] Speaker 1: of seats reserved for refugees where voting takes place outside
[31:50] Speaker 1: the region. Protesters argue that this gives people living elsewhere
[31:55] Speaker 1: disproportionate influence over the politics of pok The protests have
[31:59] Speaker 1: also triggered a severe security crackdown. India's Ministry of External
[32:04] Speaker 1: Affairs has said that at least ninety civilians have been
[32:07] Speaker 1: killed by Pakistani forces since June. The United Nations has
[32:12] Speaker 1: now expressed concern as well. A spokesperson for UN Secretary
[32:16] Speaker 1: General said authorities must allow peaceful protests and that there
[32:21] Speaker 1: should be accountability if people have been harmed while demonstrating peacefully. Earlier,
[32:27] Speaker 1: UN Human Rights Chief Wolkerthirk had called for an impartial
[32:31] Speaker 1: investigation into protested debts, as well as Pakistan's ban on
[32:36] Speaker 1: the JAAC and arrests of its leaders. India, meanwhile, has
[32:40] Speaker 1: described the elections as a farce, arguing that they are
[32:44] Speaker 1: being used by Pakistan to legitimize what New Delhi considers
[32:48] Speaker 1: its illegal occupation of the territory and to distract from
[32:52] Speaker 1: alleged human rights violations. The situation has been further complicated
[32:57] Speaker 1: by an intimate shutdown and new restricts requiring foreign journalists
[33:01] Speaker 1: and Pakistani journalists working for international organizations to seek prior
[33:07] Speaker 1: approval before reporting outside Islamabad, Lahore and Karachi. So while
[33:12] Speaker 1: authorities say the electoral process may still be completed this month,
[33:16] Speaker 1: the postponement has deepened questions over the credibility of the
[33:20] Speaker 1: polls and the scale of the unrest surrounding them. You
[33:26] Speaker 1: were listening to Three Things by the Indian Express. Today's
[33:29] Speaker 1: show was edited and mixed by Sash Pawar and produced
[33:33] Speaker 1: by Shishang Haghov and me Ichasharma. If you like the show,
[33:36] Speaker 1: do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast. You
[33:39] Speaker 1: can also recommend it to someone you think may like it,
[33:42] Speaker 1: with a friend or in your family. This is the
[33:44] Speaker 1: best way for people to get to know about us.
[33:46] Speaker 1: You can also tweet us at Express Podcasts or write
[33:49] Speaker 1: to us at podcast at indian express dot com

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
