# Behind Sonam Wangchuk removal, the cost of e-KYC, and Monsoon Session kicks off

An episode of [3 Things](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1406730235), 20 Jul 2026, 32 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/73061810/3_things_2026_july_20_v1.mp3

First, we speak to The Indian Express’ Pragynesh about the removal of activist Sonam Wangchuk from his hunger strike at Jantar Mantar, the Delhi High Court order cited by the police, and how the protest has evolved ahead of Parliament’s Monsoon Session. Next, we talk to The Indian Express’ Shubham Tigga about the death of a 75-year-old tuberculosis patient in Jharkhand, whose family spent months trying to access his own ₹8,000 pension savings because of an unresolved e-KYC issue. (18:45) And in the end, we look at the Monsoon Session of Parliament, where the Opposition plans to raise issues ranging from the NEET paper leak and Sonam Wangchuk’s protest to the Ayodhya Ram Temple donation controversy, even as shifting political equations reshape the balance inside Parliament. (29:30) Hosted by Ichha Sharma Produced and written by Shashank Bhargava and Ichha Sharma Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: In today's episode, we look at the story of a
[0:03] Speaker 1: seventy five year old Tubuk Losses patient in Sharkhand who
[0:07] Speaker 1: died waiting to withdraw his own life savings. We also
[0:11] Speaker 1: turned to Parliament's monsoon session, which begins today amid opposition walkout,
[0:16] Speaker 1: shifting political equations and a charged agenda. But we begin
[0:20] Speaker 1: today with how the removal of activist Sonam Bankchuk from
[0:24] Speaker 1: the protest site at Jhantarmantar has become a political flashpoint. Hi,
[0:32] Speaker 1: I'm a Chasharma and you're listening to three Things the
[0:35] Speaker 1: Indian Express New show. For nearly three weeks, activist Sonam
[0:44] Speaker 1: Bankchuk has been on a hunger strike demanding the resignation
[0:48] Speaker 1: of Education Minister the Remaindra Purdahan over the alleged Neat Yuji.
[0:52] Speaker 2: Paper League.
[0:54] Speaker 3: Resignation.
[0:55] Speaker 4: Yadaabh us Kibat Sahikyaka and I have there was a
[1:01] Speaker 4: Kilna Chai or Hamari's sunset so monsoon.
[1:10] Speaker 1: But things changed on Saturday morning when Delhi police officers
[1:14] Speaker 1: in plain clothes entered the protest site, moved wang Chuk
[1:18] Speaker 1: behind a white curtain and shifted him to Sada Junk Hospital,
[1:22] Speaker 1: saying they were acting on a High Court order and
[1:25] Speaker 1: medical advice because of concerns over his health. With wang
[1:39] Speaker 1: Chuk now in hospital, the focus at Juntar Mantar has
[1:43] Speaker 1: shifted to Cockroad Junta party founder Abijke who has announced
[1:47] Speaker 1: that he will continue the protest with an indefinite hunger strike.
[1:53] Speaker 5: I will continue the hunger strike and you will also
[1:55] Speaker 5: continue our march to the Parliament.
[1:57] Speaker 6: There is no change of planet.
[1:59] Speaker 5: That and built to the citizens of the country to
[2:02] Speaker 5: create a gentleman in each and every state and district
[2:05] Speaker 5: and to organize peaceful protests just like we are doing
[2:08] Speaker 5: a a gentleman.
[2:09] Speaker 6: For the last one month now.
[2:12] Speaker 1: This planned march to Parliament today has also added to
[2:15] Speaker 1: the tension, especially as the monsoon session begins.
[2:18] Speaker 2: So to make sense of what.
[2:19] Speaker 1: Exactly happened at Jandramatha and what happens to the protest now,
[2:24] Speaker 1: last evening we spoke to the Indian Expresses Pugnage, who
[2:27] Speaker 1: has been on ground covering the protests.
[2:29] Speaker 2: For the papers.
[2:31] Speaker 1: Many of our listeners would have seen videos of the
[2:34] Speaker 1: police operation where Sono wang Chuk was being picked up
[2:38] Speaker 1: and taken.
[2:38] Speaker 3: Away to the hospital.
[2:39] Speaker 1: Could you help us understand what exactly happened on Saturday morning,
[2:44] Speaker 1: like how did this unfold?
[2:46] Speaker 7: So at about three am on Saturday, punnics officials in
[2:50] Speaker 7: the New Dailhi district area were called at Mundhirmagh police station.
[2:54] Speaker 7: So they were beeped that there is going to be
[2:56] Speaker 7: a security drill before the monsoon session comvinces. So they
[3:01] Speaker 7: reached the station and there they were told by senior
[3:04] Speaker 7: cops that they have to remove Wang Chuk in a
[3:07] Speaker 7: space of just thirty seconds and that they needed to
[3:10] Speaker 7: plan for it. So all the planning was done there
[3:12] Speaker 7: that how he will be removed. After that, some jammers
[3:15] Speaker 7: were installed around the protest site and then at about
[3:19] Speaker 7: six thirty am, a group of ten to twelve policemen
[3:22] Speaker 7: in civilian clothes entered the vicinity. Now, from what the
[3:27] Speaker 7: protesters told me there that initially they claimed that they
[3:30] Speaker 7: were doctors, and that's when some of the protesters had
[3:34] Speaker 7: doubt on that because the timing for the doctor to
[3:37] Speaker 7: come at the site was around eight thirty am, so
[3:39] Speaker 7: they were two hours early. But by that time that
[3:42] Speaker 7: they could get a sense of what was happening, these
[3:45] Speaker 7: ten to twelve.
[3:46] Speaker 3: Guys had already reached the stage.
[3:48] Speaker 7: A couple of them were holding big linen bedsheets white colored,
[3:53] Speaker 7: and they spread out the bed sheet and they held
[3:57] Speaker 7: it in front of the stage area so that protesters
[4:00] Speaker 7: could not take a photo. Behind those bed sheets, A
[4:04] Speaker 7: couple of policemen picked up Sono Wangchuk. They wrapped him
[4:07] Speaker 7: in a white sheet as well, and they removed him
[4:09] Speaker 7: from the vicinity. So by seven am, Wangchuk was picked up,
[4:15] Speaker 7: loaded in the ambulance and he was taken to the
[4:17] Speaker 7: Subdijung Hospital. It was kind of a very like they
[4:20] Speaker 7: were trying to do something very Houdini like kind of
[4:23] Speaker 7: escape that now he's there, now he isn't. But it
[4:26] Speaker 7: was caught on camera and Wangchuk was seen protesting and
[4:29] Speaker 7: saying that I don't want to go. But regardless, he
[4:32] Speaker 7: was taken to subdigon at Sevdagan doctors examined him. They
[4:36] Speaker 7: said that he needs to be under constant monitoring as
[4:39] Speaker 7: he's losing muscle and his health is deteriorating. They also
[4:44] Speaker 7: said that he's still in a stable mind and his
[4:49] Speaker 7: senses are sound.
[4:50] Speaker 3: So that was what happened.
[4:52] Speaker 2: And Pugnish A lot of this debate revolves.
[4:54] Speaker 1: Around the Delhi High Coats Order and even the Deli
[4:57] Speaker 1: Pillars says that they acted under its talk about what
[5:01] Speaker 1: exactly had the code directed and how it was implemented
[5:04] Speaker 1: on ground.
[5:06] Speaker 7: So Deli High Court order, I mean, it did not
[5:10] Speaker 7: say that mister Sona Wangsu could be pigged according to
[5:14] Speaker 7: the whims and fantasies of the state. The logic behind
[5:17] Speaker 7: that order was that if mister wang Xu goes into
[5:21] Speaker 7: a condition in which he is not in a sound
[5:24] Speaker 7: state of mind and he cannot take a decision on
[5:27] Speaker 7: his own, or at least the doctor's declared that he
[5:30] Speaker 7: is not stable enough to make an informed decision whether
[5:34] Speaker 7: to continue or not continue the fast, then he could
[5:37] Speaker 7: be force fed. Force fed as in like ivy drips
[5:40] Speaker 7: are installed in his wings and then you know salin
[5:44] Speaker 7: and all that stuff with electrolytes goes inside. But as
[5:48] Speaker 7: the doctors themselves said, even at Subjung and his personal physician,
[5:53] Speaker 7: doctor Senja Lamba as well, that he is in a
[5:55] Speaker 7: sound state of mind, He's very alert, he's still sharp.
[5:58] Speaker 7: So in that sense, in that condition, his permission needs
[6:02] Speaker 7: to be taken for him to be force.
[6:04] Speaker 3: Fed or taken to the hospital, which was not taken
[6:07] Speaker 3: in that case.
[6:08] Speaker 7: So Delhi High Court order was very different from what
[6:10] Speaker 7: the police did, and ultimately he has not been force fed.
[6:14] Speaker 3: Also, he was.
[6:14] Speaker 7: Asked for his permission, his wife's permission at the hospital
[6:17] Speaker 7: and when they denied, the doctors did not force feed him,
[6:21] Speaker 7: which was the right thing to do. But in the
[6:23] Speaker 7: same sense, he should have also been asked for permission
[6:25] Speaker 7: when he was being picked up. So it seemed like
[6:28] Speaker 7: the police just wanted to remove him from.
[6:30] Speaker 1: The site, right And during a reportage, you spoke with
[6:33] Speaker 1: the protesters and you highlight how they insist this wasn't
[6:37] Speaker 1: just about protecting Wang Chuk's health, So how exactly do
[6:41] Speaker 1: they interpret the incident.
[6:43] Speaker 7: So they have basically said that in their view, the
[6:47] Speaker 7: purpose of removing Wangchuk was to dampen the protest because
[6:51] Speaker 7: tomorrow they have announced that they're going to march towards
[6:55] Speaker 7: the Parliament, and as per various norms and as it
[6:59] Speaker 7: should be, I mean, I'm not debating that protesters should
[7:02] Speaker 7: not be scouted when they're marching towards the parliament as
[7:04] Speaker 7: the Monschoon fishion is about to start. But the police
[7:07] Speaker 7: feared that Wang Chuk's presence will mobilize people more to
[7:12] Speaker 7: gather better numbers on the ground, and the fact that
[7:15] Speaker 7: sixty year old man is fasting and is part of
[7:18] Speaker 7: the protest. It will also hamper police's ability to kind
[7:22] Speaker 7: of strong arm people and you know, detain them.
[7:25] Speaker 3: So for that purpose he was removed from there.
[7:28] Speaker 7: The police expected that it would lead to a thinning
[7:31] Speaker 7: of the crowd and then eventually they could, you know,
[7:34] Speaker 7: like the strength of the crowd will just peter out
[7:37] Speaker 7: and they will be able to remove their remaining people
[7:40] Speaker 7: from the venue. But it has not happened like that. Actually,
[7:44] Speaker 7: the removal of wang Chuk has reignited the protest in
[7:47] Speaker 7: many ways. The numbers were huge. Even the police officials
[7:51] Speaker 7: confirmed to me that it was the strongest crowd that
[7:53] Speaker 7: they have seen in the past two weeks, at least
[7:55] Speaker 7: since Stavangchuk started his protest. And so yeah, the protesters
[8:01] Speaker 7: just think that it was a ploy to hamper their
[8:03] Speaker 7: march towards Parliament, but they're anyways gearing up for that
[8:07] Speaker 7: tomorrow and bubnished.
[8:09] Speaker 1: Wang Chuk was the face of this movement for nearly
[8:12] Speaker 1: three weeks, and as you mentioned, rather than dispersing the protesters,
[8:16] Speaker 1: his removal appears to have drawn larger crowds to Junkermanther.
[8:20] Speaker 1: So now that he has been removed, how is the
[8:23] Speaker 1: protest reorganizing itself?
[8:26] Speaker 7: So now see the protagonist of the protest has now changed.
[8:30] Speaker 7: Initially it was mister Wangsruk who was the guy who
[8:32] Speaker 7: was putting his health on the line, being his mind
[8:34] Speaker 7: and body on the.
[8:35] Speaker 3: Line by fasting.
[8:36] Speaker 7: And there were repeated questions even by us to mister
[8:39] Speaker 7: Deepkay and the other CGP members that why are they
[8:43] Speaker 7: not fasting, Why are they not you know, putting that
[8:46] Speaker 7: symbolic sacrifice, you know, on the stage. And their logic
[8:49] Speaker 7: was that if they were to do that, who's going
[8:51] Speaker 7: to organize the protest? Well, now that question is no
[8:54] Speaker 7: longer relevant because now mister Deepk has started an indefinite fast.
[8:58] Speaker 7: So with that, people have mobilized around him. In the
[9:03] Speaker 7: name of mister Wangchuk, they have mobilized around him, or
[9:06] Speaker 7: the sheer fact that state has recognized the protest. Now
[9:09] Speaker 7: the removal of mister wang Chuk has showed them. It
[9:12] Speaker 7: is like you know, the hounds have seen the blood.
[9:14] Speaker 7: Now they feel that the state is scared of where
[9:17] Speaker 7: this protest will go. The state is scared that it
[9:20] Speaker 7: might become way bigger than they thought it will become.
[9:22] Speaker 7: So the numbers are now increasing even at four am,
[9:26] Speaker 7: like last night, there was a good chunk of people
[9:29] Speaker 7: who are on the ground police personnel which used to
[9:31] Speaker 7: be around you know, eighty two hundred on most week days,
[9:34] Speaker 7: they have been increased to two hundred to three hundred
[9:37] Speaker 7: around the area. People who were like two hundred to
[9:40] Speaker 7: three hundred people will gather every day.
[9:42] Speaker 3: I think there was a eight hundred two thousand strong.
[9:44] Speaker 7: Crowd which I could say was their last evening, discounting
[9:48] Speaker 7: the media personal and the YouTubers and the influencier. So
[9:52] Speaker 7: I think in that sense, the protest has gathered pace
[9:56] Speaker 7: and if police has to actually stop it before starting,
[10:00] Speaker 7: then they will need to do something tonight itself or
[10:04] Speaker 7: else in the morning. It could become a little bit
[10:07] Speaker 7: more difficult for them to handle the protesters. Right.
[10:10] Speaker 1: And now it appears that the focus of the public
[10:12] Speaker 1: debate around these protests has evolved a bit, because we
[10:16] Speaker 1: know that the protest began over the alleged Neat paper leak,
[10:20] Speaker 1: But after Saturday, has the issue shifted from that to
[10:24] Speaker 1: the right to protest itself?
[10:26] Speaker 3: I think after mister Wangchuk's removal, yes, kind of.
[10:30] Speaker 7: And now there are like significant shouts about and significant
[10:34] Speaker 7: discussions in the protest site where even people are giving
[10:37] Speaker 7: bites to the media and talking as much about how
[10:41] Speaker 7: the government is trying to curb their right to protest,
[10:44] Speaker 7: right to you know, show dissent, right to even fast
[10:48] Speaker 7: as much as they have been talking about the NEAT
[10:51] Speaker 7: exams and the leaks. But I think the core issue
[10:55] Speaker 7: the CGP is still trying to keep it around neat
[10:57] Speaker 7: because this is one of the criticisms that has been
[11:00] Speaker 7: bundle towards them that other organizations which have helped them
[11:04] Speaker 7: in mobilizing people, like the ISA and other left student organizations,
[11:09] Speaker 7: they have kind of crept in their issues as part
[11:12] Speaker 7: of the protest as well, and you see people there
[11:16] Speaker 7: wearing save many put t shirts and things like that.
[11:20] Speaker 7: Even other political parties like the PDP yesterday declared that
[11:24] Speaker 7: their condition to join the protest is if the statehood
[11:27] Speaker 7: of Jammu and KASHMIRI is going to be one of
[11:29] Speaker 7: the talking points of that.
[11:30] Speaker 3: Protest as well. So yeah, now there is more diversity
[11:34] Speaker 3: of topics to talk about.
[11:35] Speaker 7: There is also more focus on a person's right to protest,
[11:38] Speaker 7: right to dissent, but the cp is still trying to
[11:42] Speaker 7: weave its narrative around the neat paper leaks so that
[11:45] Speaker 7: the government doesn't have, you know, any other reason, or
[11:49] Speaker 7: they don't come up with any sort of logic to
[11:52] Speaker 7: curb it by saying that, you know, the protest was
[11:54] Speaker 7: going away from what it was supposed to do and
[11:57] Speaker 7: the so called quote and quote anti national mints were
[12:00] Speaker 7: becoming a part of it. So right now the focus
[12:03] Speaker 7: is to keep it around neat as much as possible
[12:05] Speaker 7: and drudnish.
[12:06] Speaker 1: As someone who has been reporting extensively on the scale
[12:10] Speaker 1: and evolution of the protest, what do you make of
[12:13] Speaker 1: the trajectory.
[12:14] Speaker 3: Of the movement.
[12:15] Speaker 7: I think in the last forty eight hours it has
[12:18] Speaker 7: become way stronger than it seemed it was. I mean,
[12:23] Speaker 7: apart from the first day when the protest started, the
[12:25] Speaker 7: first couple of days, I think it had kind of
[12:28] Speaker 7: escaped the general conscience of most of the reporters, at
[12:33] Speaker 7: least with the legacy media organizations. Even after mister Wangchuk started,
[12:38] Speaker 7: you know, his hunger strike, even then, there was not
[12:42] Speaker 7: much mobilization around him because the numbers were not there.
[12:46] Speaker 7: Not many people were coming in, and if one went
[12:49] Speaker 7: to the site at that time, you will see that
[12:51] Speaker 7: most of these people are part of some student organization
[12:54] Speaker 7: or political organization, and many were just influencers in YouTuber,
[12:58] Speaker 7: so who would like kind of filling the arena. But
[13:01] Speaker 7: I think in the last forty eight hours there has
[13:03] Speaker 7: been a genuine kind of interest among the people. The
[13:07] Speaker 7: videos of a man being carried by three four staunch
[13:12] Speaker 7: six feet something policemen and being bundled inside ambulance, it
[13:16] Speaker 7: has kind of mobilized people and many people who are
[13:20] Speaker 7: joining now, even if they have no relation to need
[13:22] Speaker 7: or any exams or any students whatsoever. The sheer fact
[13:26] Speaker 7: that a state can you know, come down on someone
[13:28] Speaker 7: who is peacefully protesting has mobilized people around it. So
[13:33] Speaker 7: I think the march to Parliament tomorrow has become a
[13:37] Speaker 7: way bigger headache for the administration in the last forty
[13:40] Speaker 7: eight hours as it was before, because the numbers were
[13:43] Speaker 7: not there.
[13:44] Speaker 3: They were desperately trying to get people.
[13:46] Speaker 7: They were kind of even you know, giving guilt to
[13:49] Speaker 7: the public by saying that, you know, we are doing
[13:51] Speaker 7: so much and elderly man is pasting and still you're
[13:54] Speaker 7: not coming in all that.
[13:55] Speaker 3: But that's not a problem anymore. There are genuine.
[13:58] Speaker 7: People who have participated in the propose there is genuine
[14:01] Speaker 7: interest in the movement amongst the people now and we'll
[14:05] Speaker 7: see how it goes in the next twenty four hours
[14:08] Speaker 7: or so.
[14:09] Speaker 1: Rton, Because we spoke about the evolution earlier, the k
[14:12] Speaker 1: had categorically mentioned how CGP as an entity is not
[14:16] Speaker 1: aligned with the political party and will never be. So
[14:19] Speaker 1: the searge of support and appearances by political figures and organizations,
[14:25] Speaker 1: how do we read that?
[14:27] Speaker 7: See, I feel that, like the numbers they have got
[14:30] Speaker 7: in the last forty eight hours, if they managed to
[14:32] Speaker 7: get that before and if whatever happened with mister Wangchuk,
[14:36] Speaker 7: if a similar thing had been you know then by
[14:38] Speaker 7: the administration before and the mobilization was there, maybe the
[14:43] Speaker 7: CGP would have stuck to their promise of not involving
[14:46] Speaker 7: any political personalities whatsoever. But the thing is that apart
[14:49] Speaker 7: from the last two days, the numbers was so low
[14:52] Speaker 7: that it had reached a point where any support was welcome,
[14:55] Speaker 7: like any kind of you know, shout out, if I
[14:58] Speaker 7: may say, from any significant political figure. The CGP thought
[15:02] Speaker 7: it would help them in one way or another. So
[15:05] Speaker 7: despite staying like saying that thing and still maintaining by
[15:09] Speaker 7: the way that people have come to the stage on
[15:11] Speaker 7: their own accord, and the CGP has not announced its
[15:15] Speaker 7: alliance to any political party or any political person as such.
[15:19] Speaker 7: They have been easy on political personalities joining because they
[15:23] Speaker 7: thought that any support that these figures could generate in
[15:28] Speaker 7: the capital would be welcome. So that's why I think
[15:30] Speaker 7: there was a little bit of shift from that thing.
[15:33] Speaker 7: But I don't think now they need it as such.
[15:36] Speaker 7: I think now on their own they will be able
[15:39] Speaker 7: to gather a good number of people and pugnage.
[15:42] Speaker 1: Given the escalation we have seen in the past forty
[15:45] Speaker 1: eight hours, could you just remind our listeners what exactly
[15:49] Speaker 1: are the core demands of the protesters.
[15:52] Speaker 3: The core demand still rests around the Hermande Pradhan's resignation
[15:56] Speaker 3: the Education Minister. Now, after mister was.
[16:00] Speaker 7: Picked up, the said in his speech that it is
[16:03] Speaker 7: all happening because the Prime Minister wants it to happen,
[16:07] Speaker 7: so he demanded the Prime minister's resignation is as well.
[16:11] Speaker 7: But that still is not a core demand of CGP.
[16:13] Speaker 7: If they are being realistic, of course is still their
[16:17] Speaker 7: core issue. But from what mister Wangchuk was saying before
[16:20] Speaker 7: he was taken away, I feel they are ready to
[16:22] Speaker 7: settle it even a dialogue.
[16:23] Speaker 3: They want the government to engage with them, So anyone
[16:26] Speaker 3: from the government.
[16:27] Speaker 7: Coming up and ready to talk to them about what
[16:30] Speaker 7: could be done about these need paper leaks. What do
[16:33] Speaker 7: they exactly want and what is a sort of a
[16:35] Speaker 7: compromise which could be reached between the government and the protesters.
[16:40] Speaker 3: This is the bare minimum they want.
[16:42] Speaker 7: If that condition is satisfied, we could see a calling
[16:45] Speaker 7: off of protest and then some kind of deadline being
[16:48] Speaker 7: even by CGPKE. If this doesn't happen till that date,
[16:53] Speaker 7: we will re ignite the protest. But as of now,
[16:55] Speaker 7: their co demands our engagement with the government and mister Turmind.
[17:01] Speaker 1: And lastly, ahead of the monsoon session and the march,
[17:04] Speaker 1: what would be your watch points for the movement and
[17:08] Speaker 1: the parliament.
[17:09] Speaker 7: See, the monsoon session is going to start and the
[17:12] Speaker 7: police will definitely not let the protesters reach Parliament to
[17:15] Speaker 7: that's for sure.
[17:16] Speaker 3: That's not going to happen.
[17:17] Speaker 7: After the police detains them and after it eventually releases them,
[17:21] Speaker 7: which I'm expecting, until and unless, you know, they come
[17:23] Speaker 7: up with some kind of reason to slap them with
[17:26] Speaker 7: some act which keeps them detained for longer periods. It
[17:30] Speaker 7: would be interesting to see what happens after twentieth of
[17:34] Speaker 7: July once the protesters have been detained and released, what
[17:37] Speaker 7: they're going to do next, where they are going to
[17:39] Speaker 7: mobilize next. Now what I talked to, like the CGP people,
[17:44] Speaker 7: they are still coming up with the plan. They're still
[17:46] Speaker 7: thinking over about how to go about that, because one
[17:49] Speaker 7: logic is there that maybe the police wants them to
[17:52] Speaker 7: march towards Parliament because once they get out of the
[17:55] Speaker 7: gentleman the protest side, they also know they are not
[17:57] Speaker 7: going to reach Parliament, so the police will do it
[18:00] Speaker 7: in them. In between, they will take them to police
[18:02] Speaker 7: station and in that time period, gentleman, that protest site
[18:06] Speaker 7: would be seized, so for them there will be no
[18:08] Speaker 7: place to come back to either. So there are recommendations
[18:11] Speaker 7: inside CGP which are saying that if gentleman there is
[18:15] Speaker 7: not made available and we don't reach Parliament, we will
[18:18] Speaker 7: organize smaller protests in different cities of the country, which
[18:22] Speaker 7: they did.
[18:23] Speaker 3: You know some time back, like in Jeopard and in Pune.
[18:26] Speaker 7: So that is like one idea that they have, but
[18:28] Speaker 7: they have still not come up with a proper blueprint
[18:31] Speaker 7: on what they are going to do, or at least
[18:33] Speaker 7: they have not told or shared it with the media.
[18:36] Speaker 3: So as of now, it.
[18:37] Speaker 7: Seems that come tomorrow there won't be any place left
[18:42] Speaker 7: for the CGP to reignite their protest if they exit.
[18:45] Speaker 3: Gentleman are wants.
[18:51] Speaker 1: And next we talk about the story of a seventy
[18:54] Speaker 1: five year old tubuk losses patient in Sharkhund who died
[18:58] Speaker 1: waiting for his own life savings a.
[19:01] Speaker 2: Mere eight thousand rupees.
[19:03] Speaker 1: Ratan Lakra was from Badgad village located in the Gird district.
[19:07] Speaker 1: His family had been trying.
[19:09] Speaker 2: For nearly a year to withdraw his old.
[19:11] Speaker 1: Age pension from the Jharkan Gramin Bank so they could
[19:15] Speaker 1: get him treated. The hold up was an eks he
[19:18] Speaker 1: update the bank said was spending so.
[19:22] Speaker 8: His condition was not at all good for last few months.
[19:25] Speaker 8: For nearly four months, he had been asking his family
[19:28] Speaker 8: members to take him to hospital because his condition was
[19:31] Speaker 8: getting worse.
[19:33] Speaker 1: That's the inexpress is Shubham Tiga who reported on the
[19:36] Speaker 1: story for the newspaper.
[19:39] Speaker 8: And the irony is that the money needed for his
[19:42] Speaker 8: treatment was actually his own pension savings in his bank accounts.
[19:46] Speaker 8: It was Grammid Bank account. The rural bank. So the
[19:49] Speaker 8: family says they couldn't withdraw it because last October or
[19:53] Speaker 8: November the bank suddenly insisted on completing an eks first,
[19:58] Speaker 8: so his daughter in law of Fulma Laka, she kept
[20:01] Speaker 8: visiting the bank from March onwards because I think before
[20:04] Speaker 8: that Ratan's wife, Ripa Lakara was going but she couldn't
[20:08] Speaker 8: understand what was happening with her, so she came and
[20:11] Speaker 8: she complained to full money. Then since March, full money
[20:14] Speaker 8: was made to run from one counter to another and
[20:18] Speaker 8: for very basic things like to get a form. She
[20:20] Speaker 8: was facing difficulties and anyhow she gets some help from
[20:25] Speaker 8: strangers and filled the farm. But then the file remained
[20:28] Speaker 8: pending for months and eventually the kias He was completed
[20:32] Speaker 8: on June nine, I guess, but by then it was
[20:35] Speaker 8: too late. So Ratan died before the family could get
[20:38] Speaker 8: money for his treatment. And after his death they placed
[20:42] Speaker 8: his body outside the bank and protested villagers were gathered
[20:46] Speaker 8: and accusing the officials of dealing the process. So the
[20:50] Speaker 8: protest was the part of this. And she called me
[20:54] Speaker 8: and informed me that she received seven thousand which they
[20:57] Speaker 8: are now using it for Ratan's last rights and funeral.
[21:02] Speaker 1: Now, eky see is something that many of you may
[21:04] Speaker 1: have completed yourselves without much difficulty, because usually it is
[21:10] Speaker 1: a quick process, a few minutes to a few working days.
[21:14] Speaker 1: But for Rattan's daughter in law full Money, a daily
[21:17] Speaker 1: wager and the family sole breadwinner, it's stretched into months.
[21:22] Speaker 8: So now, on paper it's a fairly routine process. But
[21:27] Speaker 8: what this case shows is that for many people in
[21:30] Speaker 8: rural India, rural Jharkhunt, especially for the tribal community and
[21:35] Speaker 8: the elderly beneficiaries, I think this isn't simple at all.
[21:39] Speaker 8: We have seen so many cases. Full Money is illiterate, Okay,
[21:43] Speaker 8: she says that she has no idea about the education.
[21:47] Speaker 8: She can't write, she can't read, so even filling the
[21:51] Speaker 8: form became difficult for her.
[21:53] Speaker 6: So she says no.
[21:55] Speaker 8: One at the bank guided her and she spent almost
[21:58] Speaker 8: a month just trying to get the correct form and
[22:01] Speaker 8: then another couple of months waiting for the bank manager's signature.
[22:06] Speaker 6: So the issue wasn't just technology.
[22:08] Speaker 8: It was about access, it was about assistance, It was
[22:13] Speaker 8: about sensitivity and the way the process was handled. So
[22:17] Speaker 8: I think ekys might be easy in some areas, but
[22:21] Speaker 8: the administration the bureaucracy failure is also a truth in
[22:25] Speaker 8: remote areas of India, I think today also in twenty
[22:29] Speaker 8: twenty six, So that was the problem as far as
[22:32] Speaker 8: I understood.
[22:33] Speaker 1: In this case, Rata Lacrat died on the sixth of July.
[22:37] Speaker 1: Hours later, his family placed his mortal remains outside the
[22:41] Speaker 1: bank's Garva branch and protested, prompting Chief Minister him and
[22:46] Speaker 1: Seraine to order an inquiry.
[22:49] Speaker 8: So during investigation, RM Regional Manager he acknowledged that there
[22:54] Speaker 8: was lapsis, but.
[22:56] Speaker 6: It disputes that the delay directly caused the death.
[23:00] Speaker 8: So while talking to Indian Express, he was saying that
[23:02] Speaker 8: the local party intervened. The representatives from the local party
[23:06] Speaker 8: informed them that Ratan couldn't visit the branch because he
[23:10] Speaker 8: was not well and he couldn't walk. Bank arranged the
[23:13] Speaker 8: EQYIC to be done at his home. They went to
[23:16] Speaker 8: Rathan's home and finally on June ninth, they completed the EQIC. So,
[23:21] Speaker 8: after happening all this thing, the family responded that why
[23:24] Speaker 8: couldn't they do this before? It was so easy, The
[23:27] Speaker 8: process was so easy. You just have to come home
[23:30] Speaker 8: and you have to do the biometric procedures. So it
[23:32] Speaker 8: was so easy. So now, according to bank, the family
[23:35] Speaker 8: was informed that they could withdraw the money afterwards. The
[23:39] Speaker 8: bank also says that during the inquiry, the family told
[23:42] Speaker 8: that they couldn't immediately come to withdraw the money because
[23:45] Speaker 8: there was a wedding in the household. And at the
[23:47] Speaker 8: same time, the bank has taken action internally, so the
[23:50] Speaker 8: bank manager has been shifted to back off his position
[23:54] Speaker 8: and the inquiry is pending, and the contractual messenger who
[23:58] Speaker 8: was the main accused in this case has been removed
[24:00] Speaker 8: from the service.
[24:02] Speaker 2: And Shubam notes that's the contested space in the story.
[24:06] Speaker 1: While subdivisional magistrate, who conducted a spot inquiry, has acknowledged
[24:11] Speaker 1: that preliminary finding.
[24:12] Speaker 2: Suggested lapses, he has also suggested.
[24:15] Speaker 1: That the delay in KIC cannot be directly linked to
[24:19] Speaker 1: Rattan Lacas's death.
[24:21] Speaker 8: To be honest, we have no idea what exactly the
[24:24] Speaker 8: investigation is about. And when we ask officials, whether a
[24:28] Speaker 8: police or administrative authorities, they say that investigation is underway,
[24:33] Speaker 8: but they rarely explain what exactly they are investigating. It's
[24:37] Speaker 8: actually quite funny to hear that an investigation is ongoing
[24:41] Speaker 8: without knowing its precise scope. So the first allegation was
[24:44] Speaker 8: about the delay in the EKIC process, and the SGM
[24:47] Speaker 8: has already acknowledged everything that there were lapses, but the
[24:50] Speaker 8: branch manager has only been transferred to a back off
[24:54] Speaker 8: his posting okay, and no final action has been taken
[24:57] Speaker 8: against him. And the second allegation was made by several villagers.
[25:01] Speaker 8: When I spoke to two three villagers, they claimed that
[25:04] Speaker 8: the contractual messenger, the bank messenger, who was the main
[25:07] Speaker 8: accused in this case, he used to demand money from
[25:10] Speaker 8: customers and passed it or you can say, give some
[25:13] Speaker 8: part to the bank manager also.
[25:15] Speaker 6: So I think the investigations should come here.
[25:18] Speaker 8: I mean the exact point to be investigated should be
[25:21] Speaker 8: done here. They should clarify whether the bank manager was
[25:25] Speaker 8: really involved or not, so was he taking money from
[25:28] Speaker 8: customers or not. And the messenger, although he denied these allegations,
[25:33] Speaker 8: he said that he is being made a scapegoat. But
[25:35] Speaker 8: the officials have not clearly stated whether this particular aspect
[25:39] Speaker 8: of the case is also part of the investigation, so
[25:43] Speaker 8: very unclear thing. So I think finally they have only
[25:46] Speaker 8: said that the departmental inquiry will determine whether any further
[25:50] Speaker 8: disciplinary action needs to be taken against the officials involved.
[25:55] Speaker 1: Shubam says that what stands out is that the family
[25:58] Speaker 1: wasn't asking.
[25:59] Speaker 2: For new benefits or additional assistance.
[26:02] Speaker 1: They were simply trying to withdraw money that already belonged
[26:05] Speaker 1: to them. And this highlights the challenges faced by families
[26:09] Speaker 1: in rural areas, including poverty, disability, limited administrative awareness, and
[26:15] Speaker 1: dependence on government pensions. These factors often overlap, making even
[26:20] Speaker 1: routine banking procedures difficult to navigate.
[26:24] Speaker 8: So I think this is where this story becomes much
[26:28] Speaker 8: bigger than one family in this case and across rural
[26:32] Speaker 8: India or Jharkhan, many elderly people are THESS and daily
[26:36] Speaker 8: wage workers depend on welfare schemes, but they often struggle
[26:40] Speaker 8: with digital procedures like ADHAR authentication, biometric failures, EQYC, document
[26:47] Speaker 8: verification and now the SIA and everything that I'm seeing
[26:50] Speaker 8: so poor elderly and physically challenged person or illiterate even
[26:58] Speaker 8: a simple banking form can become a major obstacle if
[27:01] Speaker 8: there is no assistance, no support.
[27:04] Speaker 6: From the system.
[27:06] Speaker 8: And what struck me while reporting this story is that
[27:09] Speaker 8: even after the family lost Straton fool money hasn't had
[27:13] Speaker 8: time to grieve, so she's still running from one place
[27:17] Speaker 8: to another, one office to another, not just to access
[27:19] Speaker 8: the money, but also to get the death certificate. And
[27:24] Speaker 8: now she was also complaining that she also has to
[27:27] Speaker 8: go out for the SIA process and everything. So that
[27:30] Speaker 8: really shows how paperwork can continue even after a personal tragedy.
[27:36] Speaker 8: So paperwork is difficult for some people, and the system
[27:40] Speaker 8: should understand and give support to these families, to these
[27:44] Speaker 8: people full money.
[27:46] Speaker 1: For her part, say, is none of what the bank
[27:48] Speaker 1: states now changes what her family lived through for months.
[27:53] Speaker 1: She's now the only one holding the household together.
[27:57] Speaker 6: Fool money is mentally extorts.
[28:00] Speaker 8: While she was speaking to the Indian Express, she was
[28:03] Speaker 8: continuously renting about this system, the banking system, the bureau
[28:08] Speaker 8: crazy and everything. She was continuously telling that this happens
[28:12] Speaker 8: because we are poor, because she can obviously see that
[28:15] Speaker 8: there are a lot of people from different communities who
[28:18] Speaker 8: are coming to the bank. So here she was saying
[28:22] Speaker 8: that we are poor, we are from rural places. That's
[28:25] Speaker 8: why bank do like this to us. And this is
[28:28] Speaker 8: not the first time she is facing For the last
[28:31] Speaker 8: four months, she has been continuously going to the bank
[28:34] Speaker 8: she was coming back and she was taking Rattan her
[28:37] Speaker 8: father in law to bank to show the condition of him.
[28:40] Speaker 8: And even then the bank is not taking any action
[28:45] Speaker 8: on this, and they are continuously asking her to go back,
[28:49] Speaker 8: and she was disrespected and everything. So there are a
[28:53] Speaker 8: lot of things she have faced, and I think that
[28:56] Speaker 8: is a thing we need to understand that someone who
[29:00] Speaker 8: is physically challenged, so he or she has to rely
[29:04] Speaker 8: on the family members. So fool Money is the only
[29:08] Speaker 8: one person from her family who is doing all the jobs.
[29:11] Speaker 8: Her husband is visually impaired, her mother in law she
[29:16] Speaker 8: can't always accompany with her, okay, and father in law was.
[29:21] Speaker 6: Not in that condition.
[29:23] Speaker 8: So it is extremely mentally disturbing for a person from
[29:27] Speaker 8: the remote area who is illiterate and could not understand
[29:31] Speaker 8: the system, the mechanism of the system.
[29:34] Speaker 1: So yeah, And in the end, we talk about Parliament's
[29:43] Speaker 1: monsoon session which kicks off today and it's already shaping
[29:47] Speaker 1: up to be a turbulent one, with the opposition walking
[29:50] Speaker 1: out of an all party meeting even before the session began.
[29:54] Speaker 1: The walkout on Sunday happened after the government invited the
[29:57] Speaker 1: rebel faction of the Trinomul Congress, which has since merged
[30:01] Speaker 1: with a little known outfit called the Nationalist Citizens Party
[30:05] Speaker 1: of India to the pre session All party meeting. Meanwhile,
[30:09] Speaker 1: the DMK and ARP, both of which have been staying
[30:12] Speaker 1: away from India Block meetings of late, were among the
[30:15] Speaker 1: parties that walked out and yet the opposition is entering
[30:19] Speaker 1: this session with a clear agenda. Key issues they planned
[30:22] Speaker 1: to raise include the NEAT and other exam paper leaks
[30:26] Speaker 1: at the Vasnomwangchuk's hunger strike at Jantarmatar and his proposed
[30:31] Speaker 1: march to Parliament today alleged theft of donations at the
[30:34] Speaker 1: Ram Temple and Ayodhya ethanol blending in fuel and foreign policy.
[30:39] Speaker 1: On the Ram Temple issue, Rahul Gandhi and Congress President
[30:43] Speaker 1: malikar Jun Kharge wrote a joint letter to the Prime
[30:46] Speaker 1: Minister on Saturday demanding an independent investigation into the trust's finances. Now,
[30:52] Speaker 1: the political reckoning in Parliament has shifted considerably since the
[30:57] Speaker 1: last session in April. At least thirty seven MPs from
[31:00] Speaker 1: four opposition parties have moved to the BJP led NDA
[31:04] Speaker 1: in the intervening period, which strengthens the government's numbers, particularly
[31:08] Speaker 1: as it looks to reintroduce the legislative package on implementing
[31:12] Speaker 1: the Women's Reservation Act, which failed the look Subha test
[31:16] Speaker 1: in April. However, the government itself appears cautious. It has
[31:20] Speaker 1: shelf for now a bill that would remove ministers arrested
[31:23] Speaker 1: for serious offenses, and canceled a committee meeting on a
[31:28] Speaker 1: higher education regulation bill that has drawn opposition even from
[31:31] Speaker 1: within the NDA. On the delimitation bill, the government is
[31:35] Speaker 1: in a weight and watch more, with the DMK and
[31:38] Speaker 1: NCPSP both signaling conditional support depending on whether the final
[31:43] Speaker 1: text guarantees a fifty percent seate increase for all states.
[31:50] Speaker 2: You were listening to Three Things by the Indian Express.
[31:53] Speaker 1: Today's show was edited and mixed by Surreyesh Pavar and
[31:56] Speaker 1: produced by Shishang Barghov and me Ichasharma.
[31:59] Speaker 2: If you like the.
[32:00] Speaker 1: Show, do subscribe to us wherever you get your podcast.
[32:03] Speaker 1: You can also recommend it to someone you think may
[32:05] Speaker 1: like it, with a friend or in your family.
[32:08] Speaker 2: This is the best way for people to get to
[32:09] Speaker 2: know about us.
[32:10] Speaker 1: You can also tweet us at Express podcast or write
[32:13] Speaker 1: to us at podcast at Indianexpress dot com.

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
