# Why Maharashtra allowed homeopaths to prescribe modern medicine

An episode of [3 Things](https://invisiblenetwork.ai/podcast/1406730235), 24 Aug 2026, 32 min.

Audio: https://dts.podtrac.com/redirect.mp3/api.spreaker.com/download/episode/74604371/3_things_2026_august_24_v2.mp3

Earlier this month, Maharashtra allowed practitioners of homeopathy who have completed a specific bridge course to register with the Maharashtra Medical Council — a body traditionally meant for doctors practising modern medicine. The move has sparked protests from doctors, including strikes by the Indian Medical Association that disrupted outpatient services and elective surgeries. Why has Maharashtra introduced this change? Why are doctors so concerned about it? And what does scientific evidence actually tell us about homeopathy? In this episode, we speak to The Indian Express’ health reporter Anonna Dutt, who has been closely following the developments, to understand the controversy and what it could mean for healthcare in Maharashtra. You can watch the video edition of the show here. Produced, writen, and hosted by Shashank Bhargava Edited and mixed by Suresh Pawar

## Transcript

[0:00] Speaker 1: Dear listeners, before we start today's show, there's something that
[0:04] Speaker 1: we wanted you to know. A few weeks ago, we
[0:07] Speaker 1: started something that many of you had been asking about
[0:10] Speaker 1: for some time. We launched a weekly video edition of
[0:13] Speaker 1: the show on The Indian Express's YouTube channel. It's called
[0:17] Speaker 1: Three Things Deep Dive. As the name suggests, instead of
[0:21] Speaker 1: looking at three stories, we take an in depth look
[0:25] Speaker 1: at a single topic and examine it from three different angles.
[0:29] Speaker 1: And today we are bringing you the latest episode of
[0:32] Speaker 1: that show. If you'd like to watch it, you can
[0:35] Speaker 1: find a link in today's show notes. And if there's
[0:38] Speaker 1: a topic you'd like us to cover for it, or
[0:41] Speaker 1: if you have any feedback, let us know in the
[0:44] Speaker 1: comment section there. We'd love to hear from you. Now
[0:47] Speaker 1: here's the episode in its entirety. Hi, I'm Chishang Barder
[0:56] Speaker 1: and you listen to Three Things the Indian Express News show.
[1:04] Speaker 1: So earlier this month, something unprecedented happened in Mahrashtra, a
[1:08] Speaker 1: move that has both angered and worried doctors across the country.
[1:13] Speaker 1: The state allowed practitioners of homeopathy to register with the
[1:18] Speaker 1: Maharastra Medical Council, a body that up until now was
[1:22] Speaker 1: exclusively meant for doctors practicing modern medicine, actual MBBUS doctors. Now,
[1:29] Speaker 1: this is not meant for everyone. Not all practitioners of
[1:35] Speaker 1: homeopathy can register with the council, but only those who
[1:38] Speaker 1: have done a specific bridge course can now register with
[1:42] Speaker 1: this council. It is a move that has triggered protests
[1:45] Speaker 1: and strikes by the Indian Medical Association, which also led
[1:49] Speaker 1: to disruption in elective surgeries and outpatient services earlier this month.
[1:54] Speaker 1: Hello everyone, I'm Sahan Bhargav and you're watching the weekly
[1:57] Speaker 1: video edition of Three Things, the Indian Expresses flagship news podcast,
[2:02] Speaker 1: a show where we take a deep dive into a
[2:04] Speaker 1: topic and look at it from three different angles. And
[2:07] Speaker 1: today we're talking about why has Marastra done this, the
[2:11] Speaker 1: concerns it has raised, and what does science and research
[2:15] Speaker 1: actually tells us about homeopathy. And to talk about all this,
[2:18] Speaker 1: I have with me and The Indian Expresses Anon Adat,
[2:21] Speaker 1: who writes on health for the paper and who has
[2:23] Speaker 1: been closely monitoring this situation. Anona, welcome to the show.
[2:28] Speaker 2: Thank you for having me.
[2:29] Speaker 1: Anona, tell us what does it mean to be registered
[2:33] Speaker 1: under this council? What does it mean when you're registered
[2:36] Speaker 1: under the Mahrastra Medical Council.
[2:39] Speaker 3: So basically, when we say that someone is a doctor,
[2:43] Speaker 3: they cannot practice medicine unlessen until they are registered with
[2:47] Speaker 3: one of these state medical registers. And now, of course
[2:51] Speaker 3: the National Medical Commission has also sort of made a
[2:55] Speaker 3: national list based on these registers. But unless and until
[2:58] Speaker 3: one person has their name on a register, they cannot
[3:02] Speaker 3: legally practice modern medicine. And when there are some cases
[3:06] Speaker 3: where there's negligence or some sort of mistake on part
[3:10] Speaker 3: of a medical practitioner, then names are often struck from
[3:14] Speaker 3: this register as punishment for a certain duration. So during
[3:18] Speaker 3: that period they are not supposed to practice medicine, which
[3:21] Speaker 3: means anybody who is registered with this council can practice
[3:27] Speaker 3: modern medicine.
[3:28] Speaker 2: I mean, that's the license to practice modern medicine.
[3:31] Speaker 1: And now the state has allowed homeopathic practitioners to register
[3:36] Speaker 1: under this council to practice modern medicine if they've completed
[3:40] Speaker 1: this specific bridge course. Talk about what this course is.
[3:44] Speaker 3: So this one year bridge course that has been started
[3:47] Speaker 3: in Maharashtra, it started a while back. It's called CCMP,
[3:50] Speaker 3: which stands for Certificate Course in Modern Pharmacology. So essentially
[3:56] Speaker 3: it teaches the homeopaths about modern medicines, so you know
[4:01] Speaker 3: what are the ailments, what are the medicines that you
[4:03] Speaker 3: have to give for these ailments under modern medical therapies.
[4:06] Speaker 2: So if you talk about the courses.
[4:09] Speaker 3: In homeopathy or even any of the other you know
[4:12] Speaker 3: Indian medical systems. First of all, these students now have
[4:15] Speaker 3: to undergo a training which is similar to what you
[4:19] Speaker 3: would see for modern medicine. So everybody has to appear
[4:23] Speaker 3: for NEAT, which is the National level selection test.
[4:26] Speaker 1: So even if you want to practice homeopathy, you have
[4:28] Speaker 1: to give NEAT now.
[4:29] Speaker 3: Yes, so like ANYMBS doctor or even people who study
[4:35] Speaker 3: dental specialties or if you want to do auDA Yunani, whatever,
[4:39] Speaker 3: you have to undergo the National level NEAT test. And
[4:43] Speaker 3: with those courses you can actually register in one of
[4:46] Speaker 3: the colleges offering these courses. And when it comes to
[4:49] Speaker 3: the specific courses also there is similarity in the sense
[4:53] Speaker 3: that all these courses now are for a five point
[4:55] Speaker 3: five year duration, of which four point five years is
[4:58] Speaker 3: spent on the education and then one year of mandatory internship,
[5:03] Speaker 3: which is similar across board for whether you're studying modern medicine,
[5:07] Speaker 3: whether you're doing homeopathy, or you know, Irveda, and even
[5:11] Speaker 3: the initial subjects are pretty much similar. So anything about
[5:15] Speaker 3: the human body. So if you are studying say anatomy, physiology, pathology,
[5:21] Speaker 3: all of these subjects are same across board. So even
[5:24] Speaker 3: the homeopaths and people practicing Auveda, they would study these
[5:29] Speaker 3: subjects which relate to the human body. The different starts
[5:33] Speaker 3: when you talk about the treatment aspect of it.
[5:36] Speaker 1: So the you know, sort of the foundational courses or
[5:39] Speaker 1: the knowledge about the body that's the same across but
[5:42] Speaker 1: it's only how you treatailments that's different.
[5:45] Speaker 3: Yes, So of course the body, the systems, that's all
[5:49] Speaker 3: the same. What you do not learn with Auveda or
[5:52] Speaker 3: homeopathy is the kind of diagnostics that you have for
[5:56] Speaker 3: modern medicine, and of course the medical treatment aspect of it,
[6:00] Speaker 3: where you know, in modern medicine you would only talk
[6:02] Speaker 3: about the science based, evidence based therapies and in homeopathy
[6:07] Speaker 3: you would have the you know, law of similarities, and
[6:10] Speaker 3: in Ayurveda you would learn about punch karma and things
[6:14] Speaker 3: like that. So it's only the treatment and the diagnostic
[6:17] Speaker 3: aspect that differs in these courses. And of course then
[6:20] Speaker 3: in the internship, of course, the modern medicine practitioners would
[6:24] Speaker 3: work in the you know, different specialties in modern medicine,
[6:28] Speaker 3: whereas the people who are doing iuveda will go to
[6:31] Speaker 3: live away the hospitals, people doing homeopathy will go to
[6:34] Speaker 3: homeopathic centers, and.
[6:35] Speaker 1: So talk about you know, how was this move made possible?
[6:40] Speaker 1: What has allowed homeopathic practitioners to now register with this
[6:45] Speaker 1: state council.
[6:46] Speaker 3: So this is a very long story, of course, it
[6:49] Speaker 3: has just happened in twenty twenty six. The first person
[6:51] Speaker 3: was registered like a month back or so. It started
[6:55] Speaker 3: with you know, I think in the seventies or the eighties,
[6:58] Speaker 3: the IURBDA practitioner were allowed to study about some basic medicines,
[7:03] Speaker 3: so say the commonly used medicines like fever treatment and
[7:08] Speaker 3: diarrhea and you know, pain medication, some things that you
[7:11] Speaker 3: know everyday occurrences, you would. So the iorhic practitioners did
[7:16] Speaker 3: study a little bit about the modern medicine and that
[7:20] Speaker 3: sort of gave them the freedom to practice some modern
[7:24] Speaker 3: medicine in some states. So it's not allowed for all
[7:27] Speaker 3: the states or openly allowed, but some states do allow
[7:30] Speaker 3: them to practice this, especially in rural areas where there
[7:34] Speaker 3: was and there is a shortage of doctors, so they
[7:37] Speaker 3: would typically be in the you know, rural health centers
[7:41] Speaker 3: and give these basic treatments.
[7:43] Speaker 1: So for example, if you have a flu or if
[7:45] Speaker 1: you get diarrhea, you can go to a doctor like
[7:47] Speaker 1: that and they would be allowed to prescribe, say something
[7:50] Speaker 1: like paracetamol.
[7:51] Speaker 3: Yes, yes, but what happened This was not true for homeopaths, okay,
[7:56] Speaker 3: So there was a push from now homeopathy colleges to
[8:00] Speaker 3: allow this sort of courses because so that sort of
[8:04] Speaker 3: allows them to practice a little bit of the different
[8:07] Speaker 3: pathy and that's sometimes profitable. So there was a push
[8:10] Speaker 3: from the colleges offering homeopathy courses because they saw that
[8:15] Speaker 3: you know, more students were going into Ayrveda because of
[8:18] Speaker 3: this little bit of study of modern medicine.
[8:22] Speaker 1: And better career opportunities.
[8:24] Speaker 2: Yes, better career opportunity.
[8:25] Speaker 1: So the colleges wanted it. Did the Homeopathy Council want this?
[8:30] Speaker 2: Not at all.
[8:31] Speaker 3: So they have been consistently even now against this practice
[8:35] Speaker 3: because they do not want their practice to be mixed
[8:38] Speaker 3: with another practice. So they say that if you're practicing homeopathy,
[8:42] Speaker 3: you should only be practicing homeopathy and not anything else.
[8:45] Speaker 2: There shouldn't be a mixture.
[8:47] Speaker 1: Because technically homeopathy is at odds with modern medicine, right like,
[8:53] Speaker 1: fundamentally the core principles are against modern medicine in some ways,
[8:58] Speaker 1: in many ways.
[8:58] Speaker 2: In many ways.
[8:59] Speaker 1: Yes, okay, So the colleges wanted it, the council's the
[9:04] Speaker 1: homeopathy council didn't, So why did the government decide to
[9:07] Speaker 1: do it?
[9:08] Speaker 3: So this was like a midway compromise sort of. There
[9:12] Speaker 3: were a lot of colleges from Maharashtra especially who wanted it,
[9:15] Speaker 3: but the National Council said no. And the background has
[9:18] Speaker 3: been given to me by somebody who has been working
[9:20] Speaker 3: with you know, the Maharashtra Education Department for years, even
[9:24] Speaker 3: during this period when this push was happening. And of
[9:28] Speaker 3: course they then went to the Homeopathic Council in the
[9:31] Speaker 3: state and that council also refused, saying that any changes
[9:34] Speaker 3: in the course has to come from the National Council.
[9:37] Speaker 3: Then they went to the government, the then government, and
[9:41] Speaker 3: there were back and forth several times.
[9:44] Speaker 2: This decision was stopped.
[9:45] Speaker 3: But in twenty fourteen finally there was an amendment to
[9:49] Speaker 3: the Maharasha Medical Council Act which was passed and which
[9:53] Speaker 3: allowed practitioners of homeopathy who have undergone this one year
[9:57] Speaker 3: bridge course to register with the the Maharashtra Medical Council.
[10:01] Speaker 3: But I would like to add here that it is
[10:03] Speaker 3: a separate register. It's not the same register as the
[10:07] Speaker 3: ones where practitioners of modern medicine are registered.
[10:10] Speaker 2: It's a separate register but maintained by the Maharasha Medical Council.
[10:15] Speaker 1: And here we're talking about Maharasha. But what is the
[10:17] Speaker 1: mandate nationally?
[10:18] Speaker 3: So nationally, as I mentioned, all the practitioners have to
[10:22] Speaker 3: register with their respective councils. And usually if you see
[10:26] Speaker 3: nobody is registered with two councils, you're not supposed to.
[10:29] Speaker 3: But in this case that's an anomaly because they are
[10:32] Speaker 3: getting registered with the Homeopathy Council as well as the
[10:35] Speaker 3: Maharashtra Medical Council and then they can practice, like I said,
[10:39] Speaker 3: a little bit of allopathies, so a little bit of
[10:42] Speaker 3: modern medicine. So that is where the protest from the
[10:46] Speaker 3: doctors came in, because once they are registered, nobody is
[10:49] Speaker 3: going to.
[10:50] Speaker 2: Check that are they in this register or that register.
[10:53] Speaker 3: They can say that we are registered with the Maharasha
[10:56] Speaker 3: Medical Council and we are doctors, and you know, then
[10:59] Speaker 3: they might be practicing for years. And the problem here
[11:02] Speaker 3: is that the patients going to them might not know
[11:04] Speaker 3: that they are not really trained in modern medicine. They
[11:07] Speaker 3: are trained in another party.
[11:09] Speaker 1: But what is the government's rationale? Why do this? I mean,
[11:12] Speaker 1: at least the rationale can't be that. Oh, look, the
[11:15] Speaker 1: homeopathy colleges wanted it.
[11:17] Speaker 3: No, So if you look at the amendment but that
[11:20] Speaker 3: was passed by the Assembly, the statement of purpose in
[11:23] Speaker 3: that mentions that there is a shortage of doctors in
[11:26] Speaker 3: rural Marastra especially, and allowing the homeopaths to practice modern
[11:31] Speaker 3: medicine will actually help with bridging this gap in rural Marashtra.
[11:36] Speaker 3: So that was the rational given officially by the government
[11:39] Speaker 3: to approve this sort of registration.
[11:42] Speaker 1: And you el you mentioned you know that years ago,
[11:45] Speaker 1: for example certain i R ware, the doctors were allowed
[11:49] Speaker 1: to prescribe you know, limited number of medicines. Is that
[11:52] Speaker 1: the case here as well? Will these people will homeopathic
[11:56] Speaker 1: practitioners who are or who will be registered under the
[12:00] Speaker 1: State Medical Council? Will they only be allowed to prescribe
[12:04] Speaker 1: certain medicines or all medicines?
[12:07] Speaker 3: So, as far as I know, there is no restriction
[12:10] Speaker 3: as to what they can of course, you know, if
[12:12] Speaker 3: you go looking into these specialty medicines, like for example,
[12:16] Speaker 3: if someone's a urologist or cardiologists, those medicines, of course
[12:21] Speaker 3: they cannot. But for most of the basic medicines that
[12:24] Speaker 3: an MBBS doctor can prescribe, I think yes they would
[12:27] Speaker 3: be able to prescribe those.
[12:29] Speaker 1: And let us talk a bit about homeopathy. You know,
[12:32] Speaker 1: for those who are not familiar with its history, talk
[12:35] Speaker 1: about where does it come from and what are its
[12:38] Speaker 1: core principles.
[12:39] Speaker 3: So this was founded by a German doctor called doctor
[12:44] Speaker 3: Samuel Hahnheimann. I'm not very confident about the pronunciation of
[12:48] Speaker 3: the name, but homeopathy basically has two core principles. One
[12:54] Speaker 3: is that like treats like, so whatever causes a disease
[12:59] Speaker 3: is what would treat it is their philosophy.
[13:02] Speaker 1: And if it produces the symptom of the disease, then
[13:05] Speaker 1: it can cure the disease. And I think it comes
[13:08] Speaker 1: from this Heinemann, the founder of homeopathy, doing research on malaria.
[13:13] Speaker 1: I think Q nine, the thing that cures malaria, that
[13:17] Speaker 1: supposedly did the same thing. If you had it, it
[13:20] Speaker 1: would produce certain symptoms of malaria.
[13:23] Speaker 3: And also if you look at say modern day vaccines.
[13:27] Speaker 3: That is sort of the god principle, right, you give
[13:30] Speaker 3: a small dose of a virus to sort of train
[13:35] Speaker 3: your body to fight it off. So there is I
[13:38] Speaker 3: guess some truth to it, but that's what the belief
[13:41] Speaker 3: for all diseases that like treats like. And the second
[13:45] Speaker 3: is the principle of dilution, which where they take the
[13:48] Speaker 3: active ingredient and dilute it like I don't know, thousands
[13:52] Speaker 3: of times, and that's the medicine that is given to
[13:55] Speaker 3: the patients.
[13:56] Speaker 1: And to the point that it doesn't have the even
[13:59] Speaker 1: the mollycus of the originals.
[14:01] Speaker 3: Yes, so it's very diluted because some of the time
[14:04] Speaker 3: it does use some heavy metals, and even then it's
[14:07] Speaker 3: so diluted that it doesn't really harm the system as well.
[14:11] Speaker 3: So these are the two core principles of how homeopathy works.
[14:16] Speaker 1: And a lot of people think that it's natural and
[14:20] Speaker 1: plant based, but that's not true, right.
[14:22] Speaker 2: Not with homeopathy. Are you read that? You can still
[14:24] Speaker 2: say that, but not with homeopathy.
[14:26] Speaker 1: Right. Do we know when did it start becoming prevalent
[14:29] Speaker 1: in India?
[14:30] Speaker 3: So I think it came to India in the eighteen
[14:32] Speaker 3: hundreds when one of doctor Samuel's students came to India
[14:37] Speaker 3: and treated king or a prince in Punjab. That's where
[14:42] Speaker 3: the first instance of homeopathy coming to India is known.
[14:46] Speaker 3: And then of course it spread from their people opening
[14:50] Speaker 3: up homeopathy clinics elsewhere.
[14:51] Speaker 2: In the country.
[14:52] Speaker 1: And have there been any scientific studies done on the
[14:57] Speaker 1: methods that are used in homeopathy? Do we have any
[15:00] Speaker 1: research that tells us how effective these techniques are?
[15:03] Speaker 3: Yes, so there have been studies that people have done
[15:06] Speaker 3: globally on homeopathy, and there are some studies which show,
[15:11] Speaker 3: you know, some impact on the disease. But mostly if
[15:14] Speaker 3: you look at all these studies as an aggregate, as
[15:17] Speaker 3: a systemic review, largely nobody has found any therapeutic benefit
[15:23] Speaker 3: of homeopathy. So most of the studies, when you know,
[15:27] Speaker 3: we do an analysis of it, it shows that homeopathy
[15:30] Speaker 3: doesn't really work, you know.
[15:32] Speaker 1: But a lot of people who take homeopathic medicines, a
[15:36] Speaker 1: lot of them have these stories, right that, Look, I
[15:40] Speaker 1: had this problem and it wasn't going away with any
[15:42] Speaker 1: sort of modern medicine, and then I started taking this
[15:45] Speaker 1: particular homeopathic medicine and it went away. A lot of
[15:49] Speaker 1: people have the story, what we choked that up?
[15:51] Speaker 3: To So first of all, anecdotes are not the points
[15:55] Speaker 3: of course, of course, so when we look at it objectively,
[15:58] Speaker 3: homeopathy hasn't shown to be effective in the treatment of
[16:02] Speaker 3: any ailment. But when people narrate their stories, largely homeopathy
[16:08] Speaker 3: works because of placebo effect. Placebo effect is when you
[16:12] Speaker 3: get something which does not have any therapeutic value, but
[16:15] Speaker 3: because your brain believes it has therapeutic value, you tend
[16:19] Speaker 3: to get better. And this is an established principle. In fact,
[16:23] Speaker 3: whenever we do any study for modern medicines, usually you
[16:28] Speaker 3: would have one group receiving placebo drugs. So for example,
[16:32] Speaker 3: if you're doing a study of a pill, you will
[16:34] Speaker 3: make a similar pill but without the therapeutic ingredient.
[16:37] Speaker 1: It's crucial experiments, yes.
[16:39] Speaker 3: Just to see how much of it is just a
[16:41] Speaker 3: psychological impact and how much of it is actually the
[16:44] Speaker 3: impact of the medicine that we are studying. So modern
[16:47] Speaker 3: medicines are always compared with placebo and usually with homeopathy.
[16:53] Speaker 3: That is what has been seen that it is the
[16:55] Speaker 3: placebo effect that you know, sort of cures the page.
[17:00] Speaker 3: And it's especially for ailments like pain, hair loss, things
[17:04] Speaker 3: like that. People do tend to swear by it because
[17:08] Speaker 3: again their brain believes that.
[17:09] Speaker 1: So the effect of a placebo is psychological, right, you're
[17:14] Speaker 1: saying that effect is so strong that it has physical manifestations.
[17:19] Speaker 3: Yes, and again multiple studies have shown that placebo works.
[17:25] Speaker 2: So it could be two things.
[17:26] Speaker 3: One is, of course, a medical practitioner just listening to you,
[17:30] Speaker 3: just listening to your symptoms, taking everything that you say
[17:34] Speaker 3: seriously and then saying that, okay, you know, let's try this,
[17:37] Speaker 3: let's try that. And the second is the act of
[17:40] Speaker 3: taking the medicine, which again has been shown to actually
[17:43] Speaker 3: trick the brain into believing that it works. So there
[17:46] Speaker 3: have been almost ritualistic yes, and there have been studies
[17:51] Speaker 3: which have shown that, you know, if you compare say
[17:54] Speaker 3: one group receiving a therapeutic agent, one group receiving a
[17:57] Speaker 3: pain without the therapeutic agent, and one group receiving nothing,
[18:01] Speaker 3: and the second group actually performs better than the third one.
[18:04] Speaker 2: The one that receives nothing.
[18:06] Speaker 3: So it's just the act of taking that pill sort
[18:09] Speaker 3: of tells your brain that, oh, there is something in
[18:11] Speaker 3: your system which will cure you. And it does have
[18:15] Speaker 3: an impact, especially when it comes to how you perceive
[18:18] Speaker 3: pain for example, because that's again something that's happening in
[18:21] Speaker 3: your brain, you perceive the pain, so you tend to
[18:24] Speaker 3: perceive it less with these medicines.
[18:27] Speaker 1: Has modern medicine tried to take advantage of that, It
[18:31] Speaker 1: seems like it would be useful in some cases.
[18:34] Speaker 2: Yes, of course.
[18:35] Speaker 3: So even when, for example, if there is a cancer patient,
[18:39] Speaker 3: the doctors usually promote, you know, going for these additional
[18:43] Speaker 3: therapies that could be yoga, it could be ayur veda,
[18:46] Speaker 3: and all of that is because they believe that if
[18:49] Speaker 3: the patient believes they are getting better, they are much
[18:51] Speaker 3: more likely to actually get better. So usually doctors would
[18:55] Speaker 3: not discourage these additional you know, like you said, ritual
[19:00] Speaker 3: take treatments because they do tend to sort of produce
[19:04] Speaker 3: these positive effects in patients. The problem, Marcas, when patients
[19:09] Speaker 3: start taking those medicines instead of the treatments that.
[19:13] Speaker 1: They are present, when it becomes a replacement.
[19:15] Speaker 2: Yes, that's the problem.
[19:17] Speaker 1: And is that the only reason for concern the replacement?
[19:21] Speaker 3: So, I mean, first of all, the replacement is a
[19:24] Speaker 3: big concern, especially in India because anyway, it is difficult
[19:28] Speaker 3: for patients to access treatment, especially if you're living in
[19:33] Speaker 3: rural India, if you're living in hard to reach parts
[19:35] Speaker 3: of the country, it is difficult for them to go
[19:38] Speaker 3: to a district hospital and access the treatment or whatever.
[19:42] Speaker 2: Your a subcenter could also be kilometers away.
[19:45] Speaker 3: So in such a scenario, if people believe in an
[19:50] Speaker 3: alternate treatment and do not get tested. For example, if
[19:54] Speaker 3: someone has cancer and they believe that you know, a
[19:58] Speaker 3: UEA will cure them, and that has happen because doctors
[20:01] Speaker 3: do consistently see patients who come into the hospitals at
[20:04] Speaker 3: very late stages, when you know the cancer has already spread,
[20:08] Speaker 3: because they believed that you know, some local healer, some
[20:11] Speaker 3: faith healer would actually cure them.
[20:14] Speaker 2: So that is a problem. It should never be a replacement.
[20:17] Speaker 3: And secondly, there's also the ethical concern, right because there
[20:21] Speaker 3: is now evidence to show that homeopathy works. If you're
[20:24] Speaker 3: giving somebody a homeopathic pill and it is the placebo
[20:28] Speaker 3: that's working, how long can you like not tell them
[20:32] Speaker 3: that it's the placebo not working. Because patients, at the
[20:35] Speaker 3: end of the day, have a right to choose the
[20:37] Speaker 3: kind of treatment with an informed consent. So are we
[20:41] Speaker 3: taking an informed consent if you're just giving them the
[20:43] Speaker 3: pills which have not been shown to be effective.
[20:46] Speaker 2: So that's a concerption, and you.
[20:47] Speaker 1: Know, a lot of people, a lot of believers of homeopathy,
[20:51] Speaker 1: would say that it is scientific, right, And so perhaps
[20:55] Speaker 1: it's important for us to actually talk about what does
[20:59] Speaker 1: something being scientific means? What does it mean when we
[21:02] Speaker 1: say that something is scientific, right.
[21:06] Speaker 3: So when we talk about scientific methods, first of all,
[21:10] Speaker 3: it's different kinds of studies that can be done. One
[21:13] Speaker 3: would be say an observational study where you look at
[21:16] Speaker 3: a large population and you see that, Okay, so they
[21:20] Speaker 3: are having this medicine and I mean whatever. It could
[21:23] Speaker 3: be a homeopathic paier, it could be an iowadic medicine,
[21:26] Speaker 3: and this is the condition that's not happening in this
[21:29] Speaker 3: particular community. Now, even if you show that consistently, that
[21:34] Speaker 3: does not imply that that is the reason why it's
[21:36] Speaker 3: not happening. It could be that the people who are
[21:38] Speaker 3: taking this iouadic medicine are also people who are waking
[21:41] Speaker 3: up at four in the morning and rowing for their
[21:43] Speaker 3: morning walks, and which is why they are healthier than
[21:46] Speaker 3: the rest of the population. So, first of all, an
[21:49] Speaker 3: observational study is just a starting point. It will tell you, Okay,
[21:53] Speaker 3: maybe this is a relationship we need to investigate further,
[21:56] Speaker 3: but it will never be a proof that what we
[21:59] Speaker 3: see as the correlation is actually the cause of whatever
[22:04] Speaker 3: benefit or whatever problems that a person faces. For that,
[22:09] Speaker 3: we have something called the randomized control trials, which is
[22:13] Speaker 3: thought of as the.
[22:13] Speaker 2: Gold standard for modern medicine.
[22:17] Speaker 3: Where there are two groups of patients selected which and
[22:20] Speaker 3: they are similar groups, so they are similar in age,
[22:23] Speaker 3: in their practices, et cetera. One group is given the
[22:26] Speaker 3: therapeutic agent and one group is given up placebo, and
[22:29] Speaker 3: then you compare the results. So, like I mentioned, there
[22:33] Speaker 3: could be confounded in factors, like you know, somebody waking
[22:36] Speaker 3: up in the morning and going for a morning walk.
[22:38] Speaker 2: That would be similar across both groups.
[22:40] Speaker 3: So if five percent of the people in this group
[22:42] Speaker 3: get better and twenty five percent in the other group
[22:44] Speaker 3: get better, you know the additional twenty percent is actually
[22:47] Speaker 3: because of the therapeutic.
[22:49] Speaker 2: Agent that you have given.
[22:50] Speaker 3: So all the medicines are evaluated in this way against
[22:54] Speaker 3: a placebo, and only when they clear the trial that's
[22:58] Speaker 3: when they can be recommended for you as therapies.
[23:01] Speaker 2: And even then you have like a series of trials.
[23:04] Speaker 3: So the first would be animal trials where you see
[23:07] Speaker 3: whether you know something is toxic or not. Then you
[23:09] Speaker 3: would give it to a small group of humans to
[23:11] Speaker 3: see if there are any side effects, serious side effects.
[23:14] Speaker 3: Then you would progress to a phase two trial where
[23:16] Speaker 3: you give it to a slightly larger group where you
[23:18] Speaker 3: determine the kind of dosage that it would work with.
[23:21] Speaker 3: Then you do a phase three trial where it's a
[23:24] Speaker 3: bigger population.
[23:25] Speaker 1: It's a long process.
[23:26] Speaker 2: It's a long run process.
[23:27] Speaker 3: You would see medicines undergo trials for like ten fifteen years,
[23:33] Speaker 3: And that was one of the questions that was raised
[23:35] Speaker 3: during the pandemic about vaccines, like why is the trial shortened?
[23:39] Speaker 3: But that was an emergency period where people were dying,
[23:43] Speaker 3: so you know, cost versus benefit was done, and shorter
[23:47] Speaker 3: trials led to approvals for vaccines.
[23:50] Speaker 2: But in general, you would.
[23:52] Speaker 3: See agents going to trial for like years together before
[23:56] Speaker 3: they are approved for treatment.
[23:58] Speaker 1: And so randomized trials that have happened for homeopathic medicines,
[24:04] Speaker 1: they you say, have not shown any concrete evidence. No,
[24:08] Speaker 1: And have these trials happened for things like ir veda
[24:11] Speaker 1: and other sort of alternative medicinal practices.
[24:16] Speaker 3: For several things, yes, not every drug, possibly because when
[24:21] Speaker 3: we talk about say ayrveda, the council that regulates the
[24:25] Speaker 3: medicines for the practice actually approves the medicines based on texts.
[24:31] Speaker 2: In India, it is approved based.
[24:32] Speaker 3: On texts that are available for you know, like the
[24:35] Speaker 3: ancient texts that have been teaching Irveda.
[24:38] Speaker 2: So that is not exactly the scientific process.
[24:41] Speaker 3: But there have been trials, yes, to see whether something works,
[24:45] Speaker 3: and in some.
[24:46] Speaker 2: Cases actually you know, they do.
[24:48] Speaker 3: Like you mentioned the example of malaria, the treatment agent
[24:51] Speaker 3: quinine was actually you're not plant bark, so it is
[24:55] Speaker 3: coming from nature. Then there is also a treatment for
[24:59] Speaker 3: the heart, which again comes from a natural tree. So
[25:03] Speaker 3: there is you know, evidence to support that there are
[25:06] Speaker 3: certain products in nature that can help. For example, curcumen
[25:10] Speaker 3: is known to help with the colon cancers, so it
[25:13] Speaker 3: does help, but again it has to be established through
[25:16] Speaker 3: this whole scientific process that we talked about.
[25:18] Speaker 1: But when we talk about homeopathy, does it also have
[25:21] Speaker 1: a problem when it comes to regulation. How regulated are
[25:25] Speaker 1: these you know, homeopathic medicines that are being sold.
[25:29] Speaker 3: So again the approval just is based on texts and
[25:34] Speaker 3: therefore nobody needs to do the trials. There have been
[25:37] Speaker 3: some trials and they haven't shown significant effects.
[25:41] Speaker 1: But how do I as a consumer know or can
[25:44] Speaker 1: be sure that you know the thing that is being
[25:47] Speaker 1: sold to me actually has that thing or doesn't have
[25:49] Speaker 1: that thing.
[25:50] Speaker 3: So no, the regulations are not that strict. It's not
[25:53] Speaker 3: even that strict for modern medicine. Sadly, in India, what
[25:57] Speaker 3: we do do for modern medicine is that the state
[26:01] Speaker 3: regulators will actually every month pick up these random samples
[26:06] Speaker 3: of medicines and test them, and there is a national
[26:10] Speaker 3: list of medicines that have failed these tests, and the
[26:13] Speaker 3: companies are told to improve their quality given solutions as
[26:16] Speaker 3: to what they need to do. This sort of process
[26:18] Speaker 3: followed from modern medicine. We do not have something similar happening.
[26:22] Speaker 3: I mean, these inspectors can pick up homeopathy medicines as well, but.
[26:27] Speaker 2: Largely they check only the allopathic ones.
[26:30] Speaker 1: Right. Oh, and because you mentioned allopathy, I mean, this
[26:33] Speaker 1: term is very contentious because again it was coined by
[26:36] Speaker 1: the founder of homeopathy, and it also sort of creates
[26:39] Speaker 1: this false symmetry between modern medicine and homeopathy. It makes
[26:44] Speaker 1: it seem that both of them are you know, scientific
[26:46] Speaker 1: evidence based medicine systems, which you know we discussed is not,
[26:52] Speaker 1: which is not the case.
[26:53] Speaker 3: So most doctors would not call it allopathy, yes, because
[26:56] Speaker 3: allopathy is like there's homeopathy and everything else is allopathy,
[27:00] Speaker 3: which people do not believe. Because modern medicine is, like
[27:03] Speaker 3: I said, has to be evidence based.
[27:05] Speaker 2: Nothing is given in a guideline.
[27:07] Speaker 3: So every year, you know, you would see these guidelines
[27:10] Speaker 3: for treatment of heart disease or management of diabetes change,
[27:13] Speaker 3: and that's because you keep getting new therapies and you
[27:16] Speaker 3: keep getting newer diagnostic tests, and there is a team
[27:19] Speaker 3: that evaluates the scientific evidence that's out there and then
[27:23] Speaker 3: recommends the use of these diagnostics or therapies. So modern
[27:28] Speaker 3: medicine is always evidence based and that's why, yes, no
[27:33] Speaker 3: practitioner of modern medicine would call it allopathy.
[27:36] Speaker 1: Yeah. And talk about how this controversy is playing out
[27:39] Speaker 1: on the ground we mentioned earlier. You know that there
[27:41] Speaker 1: have been strikes in Maharasha. How have doctors reacted to those?
[27:46] Speaker 2: So doctors are very against it.
[27:47] Speaker 3: And there have been instances in the past as well
[27:50] Speaker 3: where there is some you know, allowances given to practitioners
[27:55] Speaker 3: of Indian medicines or homeopathy to do certain things, and
[27:59] Speaker 3: the modern medicin and practitioners have always been against because
[28:02] Speaker 3: they do not want a mixed spathy, is what they say.
[28:05] Speaker 3: And specifically in the case of Maharashtra, after the twenty
[28:09] Speaker 3: fourteen amendment was passed by the Assembly, the Indian Medical Association,
[28:14] Speaker 3: which is the largest body of doctors, they went to
[28:18] Speaker 3: court against it and that case is still going on.
[28:22] Speaker 1: Actually, so there's amendment that brought about this change that's
[28:26] Speaker 1: still being challenged in the court.
[28:27] Speaker 3: Yes, and one of the contentions that I did speak
[28:31] Speaker 3: to a few people from Ima, Maharashtra, and what they
[28:35] Speaker 3: say is the rational that the government gave, which is
[28:38] Speaker 3: a shortage of medical practitioners is no longer true because
[28:42] Speaker 3: one so, all these states have this bond system where
[28:46] Speaker 3: doctors who study in and that is slowly being done
[28:50] Speaker 3: away with, but it still exists where doctors who study
[28:53] Speaker 3: in government colleges are supposed to work in the rural
[28:57] Speaker 3: area for a fixed duration and every state has a
[29:00] Speaker 3: front mandate.
[29:01] Speaker 2: But in case they choose not to do that.
[29:03] Speaker 3: They have to pay the state a bond because the
[29:05] Speaker 3: state invested in their education.
[29:07] Speaker 1: On this condition.
[29:08] Speaker 3: Yes, so there is a condition to getting admission in
[29:11] Speaker 3: government colleges that once they pass out, they have to
[29:14] Speaker 3: work in rural areas for a bit this was recently
[29:18] Speaker 3: withdrawn in Maharashtra because there was no posts announced for
[29:22] Speaker 3: these doctors. So the IMA said that then clearly there
[29:25] Speaker 3: is no shortage because you're not announcing the posts and
[29:28] Speaker 3: you've done away with the bond. So then why would
[29:31] Speaker 3: you want homeopaths to also practice modern medicine. And secondly
[29:36] Speaker 3: what they said is there are about ten thousand homeopathy
[29:40] Speaker 3: practitioners in Maharashtra who have undergone this, yes, the one
[29:44] Speaker 3: your bridge course, and most of them actually come from
[29:48] Speaker 3: you know, places like Mumbai and other cities of Maharashtra.
[29:52] Speaker 1: So they're not going to practice.
[29:53] Speaker 3: In contention, like, why would they then go to you know,
[29:58] Speaker 3: the back of the beyond and actice medicine there? They wouldn't,
[30:02] Speaker 3: and so it defeats the whole rationale of this amendment.
[30:07] Speaker 1: And also if the quotes strike this amendment down, will
[30:11] Speaker 1: those people who have been registered under this council will
[30:14] Speaker 1: they be deregistered?
[30:16] Speaker 2: We don't know that.
[30:17] Speaker 3: So there was this example, and again this happened in Maharashtra,
[30:21] Speaker 3: I think in.
[30:21] Speaker 2: The seventies eight.
[30:22] Speaker 3: There was a course that Maharashtra started for a couple
[30:25] Speaker 3: of years which was called Rural Doctors or Barefoot doctors,
[30:31] Speaker 3: so they gave them a diploma in medicine instead of.
[30:34] Speaker 2: A degree, so it was a shorter duration course.
[30:37] Speaker 3: And these doctors again were supposed to treat patients in
[30:41] Speaker 3: rural Mahrashtra and they were registered with the Medical Council.
[30:46] Speaker 3: But only when there was a lot of pressure from
[30:49] Speaker 3: the National Council that okay, you know what, we will
[30:52] Speaker 3: not recognize your other courses. Yes you continue with this.
[30:55] Speaker 3: That Maharashtra discontinued it. But for a couple of years
[30:59] Speaker 3: there were people who asked from this course and they
[31:01] Speaker 3: were given registration and they continue to practice medicine and
[31:05] Speaker 3: Maharashtra still so we don't know whether the people who
[31:09] Speaker 3: get registered right now whether they would be deregistered or not.
[31:15] Speaker 1: You were listening to Three Things by the Indian Express.
[31:17] Speaker 1: Today's show was written and produced by Mishashan Bhargov and
[31:21] Speaker 1: was edited and mixed by Soreesh Pawar. If you like
[31:23] Speaker 1: the show, then do subscribe to us wherever you get
[31:25] Speaker 1: your podcasts. You can also recommend the show to someone
[31:28] Speaker 1: you think we'll like it, share it with a friend
[31:30] Speaker 1: or someone in your family. It's the best way for
[31:32] Speaker 1: people to get to know about us. You can tweet
[31:35] Speaker 1: us at Express Podcasts and write to us at Podcasts
[31:38] Speaker 1: at Indian express dot com

Shows are listed from Apple Podcasts' charts and directory, and Podcast Index where it is used. Every show and episode belongs to its publisher and plays from the publisher's own feed; this site hosts none of them.
